{"body":{"audit_root":"12dbb802403eab9e8e929a109c074b55a9c9374494d1fd55efb852ef9a520d23","base_ontology":{"concepts":[],"format":"r2r-audit-ontology/1","relations":[{"from":"record","id":"supports","to":"record"},{"from":"record","id":"contradicts","to":"record"},{"from":"record","id":"qualifies","to":"record"},{"from":"record","id":"supersedes","to":"record"},{"from":"record","id":"depends_on","to":"record"},{"from":"record","id":"same_as","to":"record"},{"from":"record","id":"duplicate_of","to":"record"},{"from":"record","id":"about","to":"concept"},{"from":"concept:Check","id":"validated_by","to":"concept:Revision"},{"from":"record","id":"in_report","to":"concept:Report"}],"stances":["reported","confirmed","refuted","qualified","superseded","open","unknown"],"types":["Report","Component","Revision","RevisionRef","Check","Gate","Stage","Rule","Limitation","Decision","Issue"]},"engine_container_hex":"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","engine_root":"61eb4cb329a5d3a8b3bd43fdd1103c0172b6f1d0d57280002faf36661d1eef0c","format":"r2r-audit-genesis/3","manifest_hash":"282f1fbc7856275d9b1e719aab69ebd51efcff7ac74ed16de4dc60396f93b946","operator_meta":null,"questions":[{"about":["The effect of ChatGPT on","Wang","Wang & Fan","Wang (2025)","Wang 2025","Wang J","Wang and Fan","Wang's","Wang, 2025","Wang’s","reference 36","retracted"],"id":"q1","text":"Which statements of the articles rest on the retracted meta-analysis Wang J and Fan W (2025), \"The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis\" (Humanit Soc Sci Commun 2025), which the meta-analysis's record file describes? The meta-analysis is reference 36 in Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012); an article may cite it by that number alone, also inside a range of numbers. Write one claim for each way an article uses the meta-analysis (a finding or effect size it reports from it, a comparison with its result, a statement it supports with it, a row of a table) and call the meta-analysis Wang and Fan 2025 in each claim. In the answer to this question every claim about an article rests on at least two quotes: the article's own passage that cites the meta-analysis, and the Title line of the meta-analysis's record (the quote that begins 'Title: The effect of ChatGPT'), which shows which work the citation names; when the passage cites the meta-analysis by number, add the article's reference-list entry of that number. A claim about an article that leaves out the Title line quote does not show that it is about this meta-analysis."},{"about":["conclu","pooled","meta-analys","significant"],"id":"q2","text":"What do the articles conclude: their main results, the outcomes they measured, and the studies or data each article rests on?"}],"rules_version":"r2r-audit-rules/3","run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","seal_format":"r2r-seal/2","settings_hash":"74816b917396df6f808921716abe36f149bc227daf66722f582ca332cb556042","source_documents":{"PMC13226197.txt":{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","kind":"opaque","raw_sha256":"ab4f2013f126545f0b946e7b96c7df5e0cffe8c7341c4841e96c2d5d4cf12d84"},"PMC13314867.txt":{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","kind":"opaque","raw_sha256":"083f6e5abe47970ff7705226382285eaca03983e6ddb8b585792fabfeb7b227c"},"PMC13388837.txt":{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","kind":"opaque","raw_sha256":"c14a42b1ad5672eed7e2010b677ee73f909bbfdc54db6c735fcc66d140ef0083"},"PMC13449012.txt":{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","kind":"opaque","raw_sha256":"220a11dcb3a93b02cb36e5e6a850bdc62ac4887b25fe3081e875b929b9add93b"},"PMC13647323.txt":{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","kind":"opaque","raw_sha256":"ef7b9c6755b5631cf2ad2cbc2f6082fb2a54934af23544282566c755143967b8"},"retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt":{"doc_id":"retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt","kind":"opaque","raw_sha256":"cd148c2af35a730f41ba7fee3324ee349ae94245918f79ff2afc6a3c7233510b"}},"source_mode":"opaque","state_root_format":"r2r-state-root/2"},"hash":"ae03175bb9da9dcaaeb290e7408780557274813f090a1cacfcd4352b8f0d5fe2","header":{"body_hash":"b4564a2848b8cdc7d474651602d674020b1c06af50a64ba2ee72cde2b0d6d45f","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":0,"wal_op":"genesis"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"70bb54d94154470db4d88da4c7080bbf3c62e65db7129795275be1e872b7684b","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent_timeout_ms":300000,"build_backlog":16,"build_scope":"none","circle_readers":["reader-1","reader-2","reader-3"],"circles":true,"dynamic_roles":true,"format":"r2r-audit-mcp-coverage/1","graph_quality":{"stale_suspect":true,"summary_companions":true,"temporal_summary":true},"section_bytes":6000,"section_rule":2,"wave_sections":3},"from":0,"key":"audit:mcp:coverage","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"61eb4cb329a5d3a8b3bd43fdd1103c0172b6f1d0d57280002faf36661d1eef0c","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"c08c84ded980bb8fba3c775de979aadb123e300e86d551edfd35aabadf669e9d","submission_id":"audit-mcp-coverage-config"},"hash":"7e82629f33e1f7a26ebd34d099bb9ed523af0d36f60f7fce89e9c8adb93b7f68","header":{"body_hash":"5364167227f0be63a41ee752d1ca555ac068a7cf04a178effb75d5a480142f14","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ae03175bb9da9dcaaeb290e7408780557274813f090a1cacfcd4352b8f0d5fe2","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":1,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"43a92e3b0387e0624bb386e625b9b3f850d127225b44c9e4271e2cf09ac27963","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":1,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":0},"started_unix_ms":1795101734735,"wave":{"doc:PMC13226197.txt#0":"reader-1","doc:PMC13226197.txt#1":"reader-2","doc:PMC13226197.txt#2":"reader-3"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"61eb4cb329a5d3a8b3bd43fdd1103c0172b6f1d0d57280002faf36661d1eef0c","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"840945bebf6d8295f8f45bd2e9372f6835086681c968f8a40c8bbe816a6525da","submission_id":"circle:757c325d646fd20eabb498ef295f81af6bf6a322a3941aa025c311d0f28d94c5"},"hash":"8ec0ab8a0573b09962248128b19e171f0a013d5612d6771a891b2633ddd22d0f","header":{"body_hash":"750cb98c8c1a359bd72de1e7a29c888b2c0ac740cb0491d44af99bc26451693a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"7e82629f33e1f7a26ebd34d099bb9ed523af0d36f60f7fce89e9c8adb93b7f68","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":2,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"3f5a46a92ef91b37c84cd9a15782e5849112f50d01d92c516ca12ba740034908","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"43a92e3b0387e0624bb386e625b9b3f850d127225b44c9e4271e2cf09ac27963","engine_root":"61eb4cb329a5d3a8b3bd43fdd1103c0172b6f1d0d57280002faf36661d1eef0c","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"b0344ee273a825704a980e221fd9df8d4ac462de1e4c6e38597c0223879cdfd9","log_size":3,"projections":{"dependencies":"65ec2af34b368787092fa5d7b6e498b243c7b7eaedf11eb45f3033fd5ba49133","status":"88f19ee44d285b626e63507ebd361e8ce71ccc967e93d303dad85d908ac5a875"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"8ec0ab8a0573b09962248128b19e171f0a013d5612d6771a891b2633ddd22d0f"}},"engine_root":"61eb4cb329a5d3a8b3bd43fdd1103c0172b6f1d0d57280002faf36661d1eef0c","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"43a92e3b0387e0624bb386e625b9b3f850d127225b44c9e4271e2cf09ac27963","engine_root":"61eb4cb329a5d3a8b3bd43fdd1103c0172b6f1d0d57280002faf36661d1eef0c","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"b0344ee273a825704a980e221fd9df8d4ac462de1e4c6e38597c0223879cdfd9","log_size":3,"projections":{"dependencies":"65ec2af34b368787092fa5d7b6e498b243c7b7eaedf11eb45f3033fd5ba49133","status":"88f19ee44d285b626e63507ebd361e8ce71ccc967e93d303dad85d908ac5a875"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"8ec0ab8a0573b09962248128b19e171f0a013d5612d6771a891b2633ddd22d0f"},"seal_hash":"1fbd3a53f984a30b9f918b0017b69d9fe27d32bff30fdf295b868b2f2606b03d"}},"request_hash":"dfc6af97c137c40b3f34fd0311371fc18c6496c63189f256053ab866e34508af","submission_id":"seal-3"},"hash":"886c23be7d14e17f622dbd1739f237e1817942ef3bb6532270b7e6784bea83ed","header":{"body_hash":"de94f6032ae43bda5cdfec9fc2a6fb47effd11a04f7c287f0789b7056692b1fb","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"8ec0ab8a0573b09962248128b19e171f0a013d5612d6771a891b2633ddd22d0f","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":3,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"07986029a999208f93572f1326441644e74640122ecad705820c140df1fafbdb","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"epoch":1,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795101734735},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"61eb4cb329a5d3a8b3bd43fdd1103c0172b6f1d0d57280002faf36661d1eef0c","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"67b8d24e2e69f5352a983b138d60c5058b3ff21eb869467ed3386b181d0a9e40","submission_id":"ring-members:116aae8a7b65c5e3a66b3d41a01ec14a89daed033b60182691980792e6d68cf8"},"hash":"5198443c97197e16dc7b72cf44a2037bb825fe3495b53359891c19feed130937","header":{"body_hash":"28ed250a28586daf0fe6f880125bb3f2b288c0bfa79c1225e8f8d8320e130b83","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"886c23be7d14e17f622dbd1739f237e1817942ef3bb6532270b7e6784bea83ed","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":4,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"b4900fa1cb024519cc930e6aa8adc4a18d5e09f789946cf62aabf13d38d8f96f","command":{"allowed_records":[],"directive":"T3-6b5256b03d436693","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"the conceptual model links AI-mediated tutoring experiences to observable metacognitive proxies and involvement behaviors, which, in turn, influence knowledge transfer outcomes.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t3_o1","terms":["conceptual model","AI-mediated tutoring","metacognitive proxies","engagement","knowledge transfer"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Our conceptualization of the application of educational AI in EdNet is exposure to system-mediated assistance events within a learner’s problem-solving sequence","kind":"observe","local_id":"t3_o2","terms":["EdNet dataset","educational AI exposure","system-mediated assistance"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"including requests and the receipt of hints, explanations, step-by-step instructions, or adaptive feedback.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t3_o3","terms":["assistance events","hints","explanations","adaptive feedback"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Section 4 presents the empirical findings, including effects on metacognition, engagement, and transfer, and provides rigorous analyses.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t3_o4","terms":["measured outcomes","metacognition","engagement","transfer"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Metacognition is operationalized as monitoring and control behaviors that can be inferred from event streams.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t3_o5","terms":["metacognition operationalization","monitoring behaviors","control behaviors","event streams"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"EdNet can be used especially well due to its ability to record the various types of actions other than correctness, and form behavioral proxies used to monitor and control behavior","kind":"observe","local_id":"t3_o6","terms":["EdNet dataset","behavioral proxies","monitoring and control"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Representative probability of verification behavior that follows an attempt, represented as the conditional probability of a verification action, given a successful response: Mitmon=Pr(Checkit=1∣Attemptit=1)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t3_o7","terms":["monitoring proxy","verification behavior"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Other monitoring proxies are the rate of error-correction, which is Pr(Correcti,t+1=1∣Wrongit=1,Feedbackit=1) .","kind":"observe","local_id":"t3_o8","terms":["monitoring proxy","error-correction rate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"For example, the probability of asking for help after an incorrect attempt is a control proxy, by using Equation (2):","kind":"observe","local_id":"t3_o9","terms":["control proxy","help seeking after error"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"or a revision proxy, which is determined as the probability of modifying the answer with the help of feedback.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t3_o10","terms":["control proxy","revision after feedback"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"In tutoring logs, we operationalize engagement in terms of quantifiable measures such as session length, attempt frequency, persistence after errors, and the interval between learning sessions on different days.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t3_o11","terms":["engagement operationalization","session length","attempt frequency","persistence after errors","inter-session interval"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t3_o2","t3_o3","t3_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t3_c1","object":"EdNet tutoring log dataset","predicate":"uses_data","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 rests on the EdNet tutoring interaction dataset to study exposure to system-mediated AI assistance events (hints, explanations, step-by-step instructions, adaptive feedback)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t3_o1","t3_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t3_c2","object":"metacognition proxies, engagement behaviors, and knowledge transfer","predicate":"measures_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 examines how AI-mediated tutoring exposure affects three outcome domains: metacognition proxies, learner engagement behaviors, and downstream knowledge transfer."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t3_o5","t3_o7","t3_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t3_c3","object":"metacognitive monitoring proxies (verification and error-correction rates)","predicate":"operationalizes_outcome","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 operationalizes metacognitive monitoring from event streams via verification probability after an attempt and post-feedback error-correction rate."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t3_o5","t3_o9","t3_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t3_c4","object":"metacognitive control proxies (help-seeking and answer revision)","predicate":"operationalizes_outcome","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 operationalizes metacognitive control via the probability of seeking help after an incorrect attempt and the probability of revising an answer using feedback."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t3_o11"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t3_c5","object":"engagement (session length, attempt frequency, persistence after errors, inter-session intervals)","predicate":"operationalizes_outcome","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 operationalizes learner engagement in tutoring logs via session length, attempt frequency, persistence after errors, and inter-day session intervals."},{"about":["PMC13226197"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t3_q1","needed":"Check Section 4, Section 5, and Section 6 of PMC13226197.txt","text":"What are the empirical findings and main conclusions of PMC13226197 regarding the causal effects of AI tutoring support on metacognition, engagement, and knowledge transfer?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",10549,16287]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"e918965aef699a0707e1598f5efffae33a97d55f5088f719dbb2659222434146","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["5ac142c5735ae6148ba81d892a41a9f80ee05d5896ac546c4d2a6faf264a5db4","f0f740795cc887511a07214ce3c5359916422b446ced07e8bcb3c6d32395b135","77ae3c07082380d0dbb15367fabea7cfd89b66507aa5a6519444fcbed1d095e4","c149bf4223df54ee2978e6eaac09069da84cda7185672552a31da4a6ac1a7114","bbe45c69e9f4113803392c4956ed03a50ae9dc4ad1b72416f13f08247b910a36","b0d430dbe83d93eebe1dcfeb364b3e3a992bbf2b1b17f3151cf55823a3127757","95d87df1d442a0abe33bfee482efd710629c2792a1b67eedac6893dd51b239a3","399a1d0949cf9b1560a317b325844f09970c00f250e33a12d323e96d71985c9b","9604aaca42e6ef32cb6d38778082ea94db0d9ba7a3777bbf50beed48ff581f42","83fe53c7fb958df00ee959f57e58805214b4b3ae43268e3663ea38919d29042e","58c6693f26c00d66b4ced014d0111b64032b0bc81c137b80f780cbffca963b9a","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8","d091768c3233da1bfb81e12b036198757a156b729b2730897712fc1e4a82140a"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"b43748acba5d7d822f72003fba1a0c013cd65b62105e3b3d8a308ba1277f6a8e","submission_id":"T3-6b5256b03d436693#1"},"hash":"1ab95c2ad7e5f3e5a7dd1ae52d67fcaa9bf1c6f1abefaf27bfc83cc14553dbbd","header":{"body_hash":"71be4c1487fa5241e13ce3bb9db7dcad6f2b7db6d84d8f8cc12cb3f0b7c13af4","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"5198443c97197e16dc7b72cf44a2037bb825fe3495b53359891c19feed130937","records_root":"c34463be3ed31c3997641caf2bbe74d5f82598b53edc28919f3c3cfc19607fe5","seq":5,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"237feddf36942c04cdfee04e9104bc682814bc8a3d43194c1d0273c052914e1f","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":1,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":1,"task_id":"T3-6b5256b03d436693"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13226197.txt#2","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"e918965aef699a0707e1598f5efffae33a97d55f5088f719dbb2659222434146","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"431d03836e79200217787a0cea84dc63cfab1f25506a0ddd8fde4bd8bb04181d","submission_id":"T3-6b5256b03d436693#done2"},"hash":"354aebd81ce291000b58a68089dcf93b760fb2fed5a1ec3d84c1615eb6c35877","header":{"body_hash":"fc201fa8c8fb775a550c36d38af28ec78a9a4f4d49b15a90b20a434a29f34e3d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"1ab95c2ad7e5f3e5a7dd1ae52d67fcaa9bf1c6f1abefaf27bfc83cc14553dbbd","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":6,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"2d81eefa9f818486172e80fc2d87421da3dee4a8c589589f509ac6efbe7c77c4","command":{"allowed_records":[],"directive":"T2-73db8ea3de1ed043","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"this paper examines the causal relationship between AI use and three outcomes central to learning science and directly related to the special issue topic: metacognition, engagement, and knowledge transfer.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t2_o1","terms":["PMC13226197","outcomes measured","metacognition","engagement","knowledge transfer","AI use"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"We do not view metacognition as a highly introspective characteristic but rather as a set of observable regulatory behaviors evident in digital traces, including help seeking, verification, revisiting, and strategic switching under uncertainty.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t2_o2","terms":["PMC13226197","metacognition","regulatory behaviors","help seeking","verification","revisiting","strategic switching"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"We conceptualize engagement as a dynamic behavioral process characterized by persistence, interspersal, patterns of returns, and in-session effort.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t2_o3","terms":["PMC13226197","engagement","persistence","interspersal","patterns of returns","in-session effort"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"We consider transfer to be the capacity to apply knowledge across items and contexts, which can be estimated by performance on new items within the same underlying skill and by successful transfer across skill changes.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t2_o4","terms":["PMC13226197","knowledge transfer","performance on new items","transfer across skill changes"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The EdNet is a very large hierarchical set of interactions between students and the system that is gathered in an AI tutoring environment","kind":"observe","local_id":"t2_o5","terms":["PMC13226197","EdNet dataset","AI tutoring environment","data source"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"We employ this by using within-learner fixed-effects models that leverage longitudinal changes in AI exposure between repeated learning episodes for the same student.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t2_o6","terms":["PMC13226197","within-learner fixed-effects models","longitudinal AI exposure","identification design"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"We test this assumption using pre-trend, falsification, and overlap tests.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t2_o7","terms":["PMC13226197","pre-trend tests","falsification tests","overlap tests","identification tests"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"First, it provides causal evidence on the influence of AI-assisted tutoring sessions on metacognition, engagement, and knowledge transfer","kind":"observe","local_id":"t2_o8","terms":["PMC13226197","causal evidence","AI-assisted tutoring","metacognition","engagement","knowledge transfer"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Second, it models these constructs using behaviorally rooted proxies derived from learning traces of large-scale data","kind":"observe","local_id":"t2_o9","terms":["PMC13226197","behaviorally rooted proxies","learning traces"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Third, it integrates these outcomes into a single causal framework that explains when AI use aids learning and when it poses a threat of substitution and overdependence.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t2_o10","terms":["PMC13226197","causal framework","aids learning","substitution","overdependence"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t2_o1","t2_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t2_c1","object":"metacognition, engagement, and knowledge transfer","predicate":"measures_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 examines the causal effect of AI use on three outcomes: metacognition, engagement, and knowledge transfer."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t2_o2","t2_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t2_c2","object":"help seeking, verification, revisiting, and strategic switching under uncertainty","predicate":"operationalizes_metacognition_as","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 operationalizes metacognition via digital trace proxies of observable regulatory behaviors: help seeking, verification, revisiting, and strategic switching under uncertainty."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t2_o3","t2_o4","t2_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t2_c3","object":"persistence, interspersal, return patterns, in-session effort; performance on new items and across skill changes","predicate":"operationalizes_engagement_and_transfer_as","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 operationalizes engagement as persistence, interspersal, patterns of returns, and in-session effort, and knowledge transfer as performance on new items within a skill and transfer across skill changes."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t2_o5","t2_o6","t2_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t2_c4","object":"EdNet dataset and within-learner fixed-effects models with pre-trend, falsification, and overlap tests","predicate":"rests_on_data_and_method","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 rests on longitudinal interaction log data from the EdNet dataset gathered in an AI tutoring environment, analyzed with within-learner fixed-effects models and pre-trend, falsification, and overlap tests."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t2_o8","t2_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t2_c5","object":"causal framework explaining when AI use aids learning versus poses threats of substitution and overdependence","predicate":"concludes_framework","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 integrates metacognition, engagement, and knowledge transfer into a causal framework explaining when AI-assisted tutoring aids learning versus when it poses threats of substitution and overdependence."},{"about":["PMC13226197"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t2_q1","needed":"Check the Results, Discussion, and Conclusion sections of PMC13226197.txt","text":"What are the specific quantitative results and directional findings of PMC13226197 for the causal effects of AI exposure on metacognition, engagement, and knowledge transfer in EdNet?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",4779,10549]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"9855db6b1dd6f2f69606dfb12f6a1a23db428fb42ee6d402ab57684145ddfd91","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["95d5f72cc8b7b27ed6d29c548fe2baa05f8940e7e0989b0f876ef4f9d6374596","2cb033637214eded92788447f97745c28cb50a10360d517931329603594e31ec","2f4d85d2238c2e5e28cb7c069fb367551268d7f2e2ecf0d32b9a9d746564a072","946292405e8921913010da8626d6de9d7039671601a283366141928d23c761b6","9b2a13d14c4763e02882b15b2539ee8b3566530489b672192975556ffc474969","92f9d72ddbe2fa78f0ac6d88ecb3595a429d92c38b328516170dbd37fc44ad27","9fde17453bd7c9d19c34f9d54f9e5c406818cd2fa28b97b197d0c8e8e4379114","3b0f21e3e163ef74be345449e0050cc14a6fb0b79ac2072986b7bc8c5ce46a97","54be3c1842c104f42661fafddad0e85ec71efb4c3be71c6f137f288e989ef094","9369828e4df5a65832a0ed6801f34c3b3eb85c69eafbc257b882e3cfbc079df1","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","cbe284f0adcab2e45fce682e8c0a0a4c8ecdaf43e95d8411d2b42e371bbcad70"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"2fcfee1c505ca15ca11d378eac6133d27f0c99294895ff1d3b66d433e642d243","submission_id":"T2-73db8ea3de1ed043#1"},"hash":"0270e9986c36e9da326a97953eb93462bc7e3623cd5ee137175c954899467f5f","header":{"body_hash":"53875d79e33d3bc2869de8476f20de420990d090adffa11f788dacf323ee855d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"354aebd81ce291000b58a68089dcf93b760fb2fed5a1ec3d84c1615eb6c35877","records_root":"5c84cdc9727c03240003a43186bf16227866e3503e5a486b8a245f2fb5d5385d","seq":7,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"e22c70cd383456fb938531597637fb2629786e518e483a681f61eae722ded3f0","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":1,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":1,"task_id":"T2-73db8ea3de1ed043"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13226197.txt#1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"9855db6b1dd6f2f69606dfb12f6a1a23db428fb42ee6d402ab57684145ddfd91","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"67110852539a5ec4f038cb7f581568a0cf8a83f29da8b6f5bcc24b764787c07f","submission_id":"T2-73db8ea3de1ed043#done2"},"hash":"09a04929309392ca04275297e7fb3a4a0d0b20ff0e8b0f493938fbba263f2338","header":{"body_hash":"11968411d0cdc8cf1518d994331dd79fe3eb374941785eaad2e0e526901d04ea","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"0270e9986c36e9da326a97953eb93462bc7e3623cd5ee137175c954899467f5f","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":8,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"912703ca3a10551dfee600639dbcfc2c9cc4383ae424432a60387256ae1d36b5","command":{"allowed_records":[],"directive":"T1-e56fc11f1dd4a234","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Source: Europe PMC PMC13226197, doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1811065. Licence: CC BY (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Copyright © 2026 Li.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t1_o1","terms":["Li 2026","PMC13226197"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Title: The causal effects of artificial intelligence use on metacognition, engagement, and knowledge transfer in educational contexts","kind":"observe","local_id":"t1_o2","terms":["Li 2026","metacognition","engagement","knowledge transfer"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Using EdNet log data, AI use was operationalized as exposure to tutoring-system assistance events during learning episodes.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t1_o3","terms":["Li 2026","EdNet log data","AI use"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Fixed effects models with temporal controls within learner and clustered inference were estimated.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t1_o4","terms":["Li 2026","fixed effects models"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Monitoring proxies and control proxies were used to assess metacognition, time on task, activity intensity, persistence after errors, return probability, and spacing.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t1_o5","terms":["Li 2026","metacognition","outcomes measured"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Engagement, near transfer, topic-shift transfer, and delayed performance were assessed.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t1_o6","terms":["Li 2026","engagement","knowledge transfer","outcomes measured"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"AI exposure increased monitoring behaviors (β = 0.028–0.047) and control behaviors (β = 0.036–0.061).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t1_o7","terms":["Li 2026","monitoring behaviors","control behaviors","results"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Longer time on task (β = 0.083), higher activity intensity (β = 0.057), higher persistence after errors (β = 0.064), and higher return probability on the next day (β = 0.031) increased engagement, while shorter interval between activities (β = −0.018) decreased it.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t1_o8","terms":["Li 2026","engagement","results"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The strongest transfer gains were for near transfer (β = 0.052), topic-shift transfer (β = 0.021), and delayed performance (7 days) (β = 0.017).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t1_o9","terms":["Li 2026","near transfer","topic-shift transfer","delayed performance","results"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"AI-supported tutoring appears to strengthen metacognitive regulation and engagement, while broader transfer remains conditional on scaffolds that promote verification, retrieval, and abstraction.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t1_o10","terms":["Li 2026","conclusion","metacognitive regulation","engagement","knowledge transfer"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Most studies employ self-report, cross-sectional correlational designs, or brief interventions, primarily reporting outcome scores but not tracing the learning process that produced them (Wang and Fan, 2025).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t1_o11","terms":["Li 2026","Wang and Fan 2025","study design limitations"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t1_o1","t1_o2","t1_o3","t1_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c1","object":"EdNet log data with within-learner fixed effects models of tutoring-system assistance events","predicate":"analyzes data and methods","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) analyzes EdNet log data using within-learner fixed effects models, operationalizing AI use as exposure to tutoring-system assistance events during learning episodes."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t1_o1","t1_o5","t1_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c2","object":"metacognition, engagement, near transfer, topic-shift transfer, and delayed performance","predicate":"measured outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) measured metacognition (monitoring and control proxies), time on task, activity intensity, persistence after errors, return probability, spacing, engagement, near transfer, topic-shift transfer, and delayed performance."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t1_o1","t1_o7","t1_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c3","object":"increased monitoring and control behaviors and positive transfer gains","predicate":"reports main results","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) found that AI exposure increased monitoring behaviors (β = 0.028–0.047) and control behaviors (β = 0.036–0.061), and yielded gains in near transfer (β = 0.052), topic-shift transfer (β = 0.021), and 7-day delayed performance (β = 0.017)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t1_o1","t1_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c4","object":"positive effects of time on task, intensity, persistence, and return probability on engagement","predicate":"reports engagement results","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) found that engagement increased with longer time on task (β = 0.083), higher activity intensity (β = 0.057), higher persistence after errors (β = 0.064), and higher next-day return probability (β = 0.031), but decreased with shorter intervals between activities (β = −0.018)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t1_o1","t1_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c5","object":"AI tutoring strengthens metacognitive regulation and engagement; broader transfer depends on scaffolds","predicate":"concludes","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) concludes that AI-supported tutoring strengthens metacognitive regulation and engagement, while broader transfer is conditional on scaffolds promoting verification, retrieval, and abstraction."},{"about":["Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t1_q1","needed":"Check the References section of PMC13226197.txt for Wang and Fan (2025) and the meta-analysis record file for the 'Title: The effect of ChatGPT...' quote.","text":"Does the citation (Wang and Fan, 2025) in Li 2026 (PMC13226197) refer to the retracted meta-analysis Wang J and Fan W (2025) on ChatGPT, as needed to complete the claim with the meta-analysis Title quote?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"2c72bf423c5e8b4cd6f8c8fc705bd17445df8d429647c4f2341177761df6a494","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["c0c1c7ef91e3e8bdeda6f7e4ad0b3da17c9095cfd5a1530856bb1fae92882105","37a0ab907e21c5e9f9a452becf50ca7ed2b8415867d1a211ef9b97b2b03b4acd","ca35948ccf7ad4a37da47aef61e9951a101bd1546379beb9d5fb93e532f9cf69","ed7fccbf60f28e9d01a9b08dcc06f06394a274d548d0d448fc8cf94db3b28cfc","0a534545d6a40179527c64579a8fba27c3c276cfdd9e3b03176cafa47373ca73","ae32089a699bd95b0f8e898d5b53dd8b9305ada68f75445abb03833b6aed1d68","71cdea1a3827d876fd74895c2ec490256a83df4d918ea4de4118f76e9cd8d7b5","cf3cf8e60542c764f6f5c7cd66998c1b634316ee7dee064140ccfb79c9ea4f8d","1602b2e8cd90c1fd75b68d7a12a5c4a3aa0ef1a0d18f1876fe9e87fe1e707208","6527860faa20b249f71d5acd7941cdded1d86c9324a2ec392e9d3613e2e9d588","3ade14c9e3845c97457491b90b2bfe689c771a8d6ff055dc4a315d828855ee6a","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":12}},"request_hash":"bba869c00661cf48121eff32af948cd10312a24050e5a5e1f1d0cbfdb7373f3b","submission_id":"T1-e56fc11f1dd4a234#1"},"hash":"10097a6ea75ca02fc5f0af7f5d7bf22095f34f11f66446539e3fcacdd3c1aeb5","header":{"body_hash":"eee7d5f944d49b6bbddb6b246d3968eb6fa0088d71b9858318248448273ccca8","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"09a04929309392ca04275297e7fb3a4a0d0b20ff0e8b0f493938fbba263f2338","records_root":"e6563ece0d69d30559637e9db34f1ae04b4be4cfa972a0a399035397a8e63228","seq":9,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"f205b7a3dcd8b3a75ffa65914391e1a005663198fdd78251c9eecf2cb160cfbb","command":{"allowed_records":[],"directive":"T1-e56fc11f1dd4a234","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t1_o1","t1_o7","t1_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c3","object":"increased monitoring and control behaviors and positive transfer gains","predicate":"reports main results","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) found that AI exposure increased monitoring behaviors (β = 0.028–0.047) and control behaviors (β = 0.036–0.061), and yielded gains in near transfer (β = 0.052), topic-shift transfer (β = 0.021), and 7-day delayed performance (β = 0.017)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t1_o1","t1_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c4","object":"positive effects of time on task, intensity, persistence, and return probability on engagement","predicate":"reports engagement results","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) found that engagement increased with longer time on task (β = 0.083), higher activity intensity (β = 0.057), higher persistence after errors (β = 0.064), and higher next-day return probability (β = 0.031), but decreased with shorter intervals between activities (β = −0.018)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t1_o1","t1_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c5","object":"AI tutoring strengthens metacognitive regulation and engagement; broader transfer depends on scaffolds","predicate":"concludes","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) concludes that AI-supported tutoring strengthens metacognitive regulation and engagement, while broader transfer is conditional on scaffolds promoting verification, retrieval, and abstraction."},{"about":["Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t1_q1","needed":"Check the References section of PMC13226197.txt for Wang and Fan (2025) and the meta-analysis record file for the 'Title: The effect of ChatGPT...' quote.","text":"Does the citation (Wang and Fan, 2025) in Li 2026 (PMC13226197) refer to the retracted meta-analysis Wang J and Fan W (2025) on ChatGPT, as needed to complete the claim with the meta-analysis Title quote?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"2c72bf423c5e8b4cd6f8c8fc705bd17445df8d429647c4f2341177761df6a494","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":[],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":0}},"request_hash":"90f60ea7435a52b2271a09b0d830cb98326d0011d79b8c8efa0d7d833f939eaa","submission_id":"T1-e56fc11f1dd4a234#1.1"},"hash":"d90edb559149efd2305d26ebb3eb2e7691e2682f630223749f1ecb1f30f3eebe","header":{"body_hash":"71afc311918fc1289600097a1376c1295400ebfbc210c01e710e91bc5b47f000","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"10097a6ea75ca02fc5f0af7f5d7bf22095f34f11f66446539e3fcacdd3c1aeb5","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":10,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"18049322555d5a88de0f7fd448acb6eef7f50f3e3a59b1ead77fbbc73d385b83","command":{"allowed_records":[],"directive":"T1-e56fc11f1dd4a234","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t1_o1","t1_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c4","object":"positive effects of time on task, intensity, persistence, and return probability on engagement","predicate":"reports engagement results","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) found that engagement increased with longer time on task (β = 0.083), higher activity intensity (β = 0.057), higher persistence after errors (β = 0.064), and higher next-day return probability (β = 0.031), but decreased with shorter intervals between activities (β = −0.018)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t1_o1","t1_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c5","object":"AI tutoring strengthens metacognitive regulation and engagement; broader transfer depends on scaffolds","predicate":"concludes","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) concludes that AI-supported tutoring strengthens metacognitive regulation and engagement, while broader transfer is conditional on scaffolds promoting verification, retrieval, and abstraction."},{"about":["Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t1_q1","needed":"Check the References section of PMC13226197.txt for Wang and Fan (2025) and the meta-analysis record file for the 'Title: The effect of ChatGPT...' quote.","text":"Does the citation (Wang and Fan, 2025) in Li 2026 (PMC13226197) refer to the retracted meta-analysis Wang J and Fan W (2025) on ChatGPT, as needed to complete the claim with the meta-analysis Title quote?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"2c72bf423c5e8b4cd6f8c8fc705bd17445df8d429647c4f2341177761df6a494","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":[],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":0}},"request_hash":"54279e56f811f4abc2d3357577e3ea923a626116b6562699d95b2604c6305ece","submission_id":"T1-e56fc11f1dd4a234#1.2"},"hash":"4387c1acc4070cf23e5d1f3968d186e06b663069ec37b9c2ebb50d09c839e0b7","header":{"body_hash":"ba621c76074bc4034548d9ca28243ccfa4d25645eaa54ef387ceb2faf93aeacd","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"d90edb559149efd2305d26ebb3eb2e7691e2682f630223749f1ecb1f30f3eebe","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":11,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"1b6b7d82509873db70507d84c13d2a2519b7104184d5f4495be299a499bef3be","command":{"allowed_records":[],"directive":"T1-e56fc11f1dd4a234","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t1_o1","t1_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c5","object":"AI tutoring strengthens metacognitive regulation and engagement; broader transfer depends on scaffolds","predicate":"concludes","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) concludes that AI-supported tutoring strengthens metacognitive regulation and engagement, while broader transfer is conditional on scaffolds promoting verification, retrieval, and abstraction."},{"about":["Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t1_q1","needed":"Check the References section of PMC13226197.txt for Wang and Fan (2025) and the meta-analysis record file for the 'Title: The effect of ChatGPT...' quote.","text":"Does the citation (Wang and Fan, 2025) in Li 2026 (PMC13226197) refer to the retracted meta-analysis Wang J and Fan W (2025) on ChatGPT, as needed to complete the claim with the meta-analysis Title quote?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"2c72bf423c5e8b4cd6f8c8fc705bd17445df8d429647c4f2341177761df6a494","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","5fa49cc78ed8f3740dce59aeadf08e36862e208a23e35cd80fd32c18ca075e4b"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"08d13d621b73f2027e2b0a7c23b5baa5e495bd59d75bc61fb8a35853fb275ec5","submission_id":"T1-e56fc11f1dd4a234#1.3"},"hash":"f3572db292d6b2e3fcdf703c14143e53e79f3e6db1be6dd4ef74edd1de9fec77","header":{"body_hash":"1a2fa7b0cacf5eed237912e666ce7d8662a455ea75b2c740f2a97a6ab1002999","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"4387c1acc4070cf23e5d1f3968d186e06b663069ec37b9c2ebb50d09c839e0b7","records_root":"5bc6c39a3b5bc4c7e5739c3c0019c16aa25da718e59c396fbe157eafaf552d5d","seq":12,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"134e8391df6cb2f750a812f920ead343f9bad8ba53fa48f13fc613756ab8d5a8","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@c0c1c7ef91e3e8bd","@37a0ab907e21c5e9","@ca35948ccf7ad4a3","@ed7fccbf60f28e9d","@0a534545d6a40179","@ae32089a699bd95b","@71cdea1a3827d876","@cf3cf8e60542c764","@1602b2e8cd90c1fd","@6527860faa20b249","@3ade14c9e3845c97","@670322c4448332e3","@cd031dfcdbbc8943","@5fa49cc78ed8f374"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":12,"local_id":"t1_c2"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":13,"local_id":"t1_c3"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":14,"local_id":"t1_c4"}],"task_id":"T1-e56fc11f1dd4a234","work_key":"doc:PMC13226197.txt#0"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T1-e56fc11f1dd4a234:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"2c72bf423c5e8b4cd6f8c8fc705bd17445df8d429647c4f2341177761df6a494","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"472606b6177311adf7db349f43e5aaff3a06369cd28442081510f8d593f42114","submission_id":"T1-e56fc11f1dd4a234#repair1"},"hash":"aba0020a67de4869380a14efd283a7e17de332bcf0f577f032ce66a2652d0e30","header":{"body_hash":"c3f49614bfac05dcb19f8120dc8a2099ce63e65f29719eb0dda585251268373a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"f3572db292d6b2e3fcdf703c14143e53e79f3e6db1be6dd4ef74edd1de9fec77","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":13,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"072d5f2153b03bea63f7c88a548a2225fae4fb90d6fe53a2c46fa4a379ef5fd5","command":{"allowed_records":[],"directive":"T1-e56fc11f1dd4a234","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t1_o1","t1_o5","t1_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c2","object":"metacognition, engagement, near transfer, topic-shift transfer, and delayed performance","predicate":"measured outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) measured metacognition (monitoring and control proxies), time on task, activity intensity, error persistence, return probability, spacing, engagement, near/topic-shift transfer, and delayed performance."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t1_o1","t1_o7","t1_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c3","object":"increased monitoring and control behaviors and positive transfer gains","predicate":"reports main results","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) found AI exposure increased monitoring (β = 0.028–0.047) and control (β = 0.036–0.061) behaviors, with gains in near transfer (β = 0.052), topic-shift transfer (β = 0.021), and 7-day delayed performance (β = 0.017)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t1_o1","t1_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c4","object":"positive effects of time on task, intensity, persistence, and return probability on engagement","predicate":"reports engagement results","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) found engagement rose with time on task (β = 0.083), activity intensity (β = 0.057), persistence after errors (β = 0.064), and next-day return probability (β = 0.031), and fell with shorter intervals (β = −0.018)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"2c72bf423c5e8b4cd6f8c8fc705bd17445df8d429647c4f2341177761df6a494","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["cce47384777587249904e059743a08e293e9109adeec796d7d987016b473c6cb","28e6ce47f66b452bb63161de1d856fd31b1f2eb463a234944b49d92a49403b18","24fbbf7a3880f939ddd6ba3c8c3adc75b0aec3268bfd4594ea8ccb6a5fdfd0fc"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"4d5913703b9ae015b266b3f8b8599f277ada2f6851fa3c3ef95e76ae064bddab","submission_id":"T1-e56fc11f1dd4a234#2"},"hash":"968236429ffaba0af26150532a68a34f565ea6f356aff6170a5be3d91beaa5b8","header":{"body_hash":"a2cc5e15a4310173a45a7ca0a3530201c81442bedf55c10b003d13bc95de09ca","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"aba0020a67de4869380a14efd283a7e17de332bcf0f577f032ce66a2652d0e30","records_root":"3c2460de54770e65fcfb6e20a8ad2e8c3f3bedcf29c4018f7dd6c4c4d2bb84ed","seq":14,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"2384f4ffb78c28cc2767b90aca01fe8686d35117f3814a07ba1c5f335265646c","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":false,"agent":"reader-1","circle":1,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":17,"refusals":1,"stored":17,"sync_step":1,"task_id":"T1-e56fc11f1dd4a234"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13226197.txt#0","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"2c72bf423c5e8b4cd6f8c8fc705bd17445df8d429647c4f2341177761df6a494","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"2fe7b24c39aa13769664bdc762171c9b66332dcc8849760c9ccbd0fd1cd1011a","submission_id":"T1-e56fc11f1dd4a234#done3"},"hash":"4e9e83d441b3974fc20ed2e2023f9da98adce9942921d7303147a3205b33fe95","header":{"body_hash":"294a0ee959f3c4c135dbca714dd9d3b29d51890f215ea6d85f4d12d4216396a5","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"968236429ffaba0af26150532a68a34f565ea6f356aff6170a5be3d91beaa5b8","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":15,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"15f1c82dcfa2a3260112dbdf6df81a7af1304ac4dfcc60307a9bbc45e832e2d7","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TR4-af7618a13b7c3f05","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Source: Europe PMC PMC13226197, doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1811065. Licence: CC BY (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Copyright © 2026 Li.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t4_o1","terms":["article citation","PMC13226197","Li 2026"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"AI exposure increased monitoring behaviors (β = 0.028–0.047) and control behaviors (β = 0.036–0.061).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t4_o2","terms":["results","metacognition","monitoring behaviors","control behaviors","effect sizes"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Longer time on task (β = 0.083), higher activity intensity (β = 0.057), higher persistence after errors (β = 0.064), and higher return probability on the next day (β = 0.031) increased engagement","kind":"observe","local_id":"t4_o3","terms":["results","engagement increases","time on task","activity intensity","persistence","return probability"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"higher return probability on the next day (β = 0.031) increased engagement, while shorter interval between activities (β = −0.018) decreased it.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t4_o4","terms":["results","engagement","interval between activities","spacing"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The strongest transfer gains were for near transfer (β = 0.052), topic-shift transfer (β = 0.021), and delayed performance (7 days) (β = 0.017).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t4_o5","terms":["results","knowledge transfer","near transfer","topic-shift transfer","delayed performance"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Most studies employ self-report, cross-sectional correlational designs, or brief interventions, primarily reporting outcome scores but not tracing the learning process that produced them (Wang and Fan, 2025).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t4_o6","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025","prior study limitations","correlational designs","outcome scores"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t4_o1","t4_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t4_c1","object":"monitoring behaviors (β = 0.028–0.047) and control behaviors (β = 0.036–0.061)","predicate":"concludes_effect_on_metacognition","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) reports in its abstract results that AI exposure increased metacognitive monitoring behaviors (β = 0.028–0.047) and control behaviors (β = 0.036–0.061)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t4_o1","t4_o3","t4_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t4_c2","object":"time on task β=0.083, intensity β=0.057, persistence β=0.064, return β=0.031, interval β=-0.018","predicate":"concludes_effect_on_engagement","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) reports that AI exposure increased time on task (β = 0.083), activity intensity (β = 0.057), persistence after errors (β = 0.064), and next-day return probability (β = 0.031), while decreasing activity intervals (β = −0.018)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t4_o1","t4_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t4_c3","object":"near transfer (β = 0.052), topic-shift transfer (β = 0.021), 7-day delayed performance (β = 0.017)","predicate":"concludes_effect_on_transfer","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) reports that transfer gains from AI exposure were strongest for near transfer (β = 0.052), followed by topic-shift transfer (β = 0.021) and 7-day delayed performance (β = 0.017)."},{"about":["PMC13226197","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t4_q1","needed":"Check the Title line in Wang and Fan 2025's record file and the reference list entry in PMC13226197.txt to link with t4_o6.","text":"Confirm with the Title line quote of Wang and Fan 2025's record file and PMC13226197's reference list that (Wang and Fan, 2025) cited in PMC13226197 for prior studies reporting outcome scores without tracing processes is Wang and Fan 2025."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"10b54bb440878e365971b57a0e1fa42c140785dc467a0fce35f352d17a967b4f","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["da367720408cd0d6132edc6a0622a4f7c11b4390551d8cbf0ccaa34ed157a1b2","5ba8bfa631be25263e40c29c35863ebddeef775e74df34f097ba78353e8efed6","d38d51b340d3e726b17fccef562bd07a8f442391957079b9b851057cbd99f06d","781d942ca92d77c7dbf094fa375a1750f498ad0612a9ce79fad725447f4fc5b2","08171dc1108c23e5474f5a0ba2be523e985d77dbd0bf2d3fd3dc754fba57773b","4752148c8ba6f1fc99813be889aa6fd5fbd3ba3bc39256d7e84f6f8b794a1d66","926d69cdd0ce87e828672bd7c01fc418c5d0556451698b5cf81e0b51c808886f"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":7}},"request_hash":"4015e40060d18844c134e2498b51b472d19260f7533428ea494d69537d93b99c","submission_id":"TR4-af7618a13b7c3f05#1"},"hash":"d433a8a2d435e87c84a7ec05632ec2a37456dfb4143851ce23d429b7b8fb4f33","header":{"body_hash":"4163a96bd38372356c16583f14b5846aa62eb91a6ceafc08b2ffc2b83db880d1","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"4e9e83d441b3974fc20ed2e2023f9da98adce9942921d7303147a3205b33fe95","records_root":"efc8ea85b782f554cd4b46cea58fb8deda2a73e01c7bfabafb5e57a2929cc03d","seq":16,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"a2ab91aec721c6b8b8f2ed676c1b24fdbd4d5c400b62d319ea2191c53aefa189","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TR4-af7618a13b7c3f05","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t4_o1","t4_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t4_c3","object":"near transfer (β = 0.052), topic-shift transfer (β = 0.021), 7-day delayed performance (β = 0.017)","predicate":"concludes_effect_on_transfer","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) reports that transfer gains from AI exposure were strongest for near transfer (β = 0.052), followed by topic-shift transfer (β = 0.021) and 7-day delayed performance (β = 0.017)."},{"about":["PMC13226197","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t4_q1","needed":"Check the Title line in Wang and Fan 2025's record file and the reference list entry in PMC13226197.txt to link with t4_o6.","text":"Confirm with the Title line quote of Wang and Fan 2025's record file and PMC13226197's reference list that (Wang and Fan, 2025) cited in PMC13226197 for prior studies reporting outcome scores without tracing processes is Wang and Fan 2025."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"10b54bb440878e365971b57a0e1fa42c140785dc467a0fce35f352d17a967b4f","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["863535897f2aef3e494b5af69653e45a7e5840c38d7be8207af5fba7f9949202","2658a37e7e96dff6a7cb1d2fc611ada6617874f2c479b887dee02be5d8e1fba0"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"b22a1b6060ee5c6c118d708d4e4c99dea5d6faaee1c53c4f876253a5c642687f","submission_id":"TR4-af7618a13b7c3f05#1.1"},"hash":"0b9ea9004807b5b5ad71e792eb2c131ce7d04e3d9b71e45082af36602838a2a3","header":{"body_hash":"9736c9924f21d5c03f958477a4f63435aea965ad3b29972a24a218a81b4427aa","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"d433a8a2d435e87c84a7ec05632ec2a37456dfb4143851ce23d429b7b8fb4f33","records_root":"1107e99f6499cc4099c36d6487c01debbe3b11934ff41d1f1a55e5c0fe569a3e","seq":17,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"92843777ad473ca3053a61325dccb8da3ed86e036e979ed16f797bbc94416a19","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@da367720408cd0d6","@5ba8bfa631be2526","@d38d51b340d3e726","@781d942ca92d77c7","@08171dc1108c23e5","@4752148c8ba6f1fc","@926d69cdd0ce87e8","@863535897f2aef3e","@2658a37e7e96dff6"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"REQUEST","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":7,"local_id":"t4_c2"}],"task_id":"TR4-af7618a13b7c3f05","work_key":"reread:PMC13226197.txt#0"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:TR4-af7618a13b7c3f05:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"10b54bb440878e365971b57a0e1fa42c140785dc467a0fce35f352d17a967b4f","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"26902ffaa2d22df6f6fc3c8a4ce2ff79ba7231cfe88f91b566cd0f2a5a189a8a","submission_id":"TR4-af7618a13b7c3f05#repair1"},"hash":"7379996a86b5ffb17de68539e60a7567c031bb173afafece70b0c6e7b616ffe2","header":{"body_hash":"81e474fd53bbfe5cfea4cd27005fab276cd764574622859b106a8d152a1504c9","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"0b9ea9004807b5b5ad71e792eb2c131ce7d04e3d9b71e45082af36602838a2a3","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":18,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"19c78b5d9614058ae175f56584f6b3a158980d28d87b4c68fbba76ecab9bd507","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TR4-af7618a13b7c3f05","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t4_o1","t4_o3","t4_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t4_c2","object":"time on task β=0.083, intensity β=0.057, persistence β=0.064, return β=0.031, interval β=-0.018","predicate":"concludes_effect_on_engagement","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) reports AI exposure increased time on task (β = 0.083), activity intensity (β = 0.057), error persistence (β = 0.064), and next-day return probability (β = 0.031), while reducing activity intervals (β = −0.018)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"10b54bb440878e365971b57a0e1fa42c140785dc467a0fce35f352d17a967b4f","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["e7342a7f85458c6318ebb75f8b2f0340c1c6e0e0dafc8e79eff3442ba73b35da"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"f8b5b70cd6a9702efaaa69f282f92788b7b5300b70a0e80c423bfa45fef7cb32","submission_id":"TR4-af7618a13b7c3f05#2"},"hash":"3b9df8aac578ab8c11a28da4d0c28a7cb130370c1c50c2a8212cd9f97435c3c0","header":{"body_hash":"7efb830a611b621dab3f0e614484d2a9a9e1a53aaac7f2736bbca06032355a90","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"7379996a86b5ffb17de68539e60a7567c031bb173afafece70b0c6e7b616ffe2","records_root":"57a72be000c00cae1b3e2fb7d157071767a96039ff43ad36b5ed795ae420a1fe","seq":19,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"7c0273fb8f8c021ef21750d8fc88265353aaa30358a1ea3167de3fe3552079c4","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":1,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":5,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:PMC13226197.txt#0"},"sync_step":1,"task_id":"TR4-af7618a13b7c3f05"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:PMC13226197.txt#0","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"10b54bb440878e365971b57a0e1fa42c140785dc467a0fce35f352d17a967b4f","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"033dc118234dc3472e4299573f36d4478489044c4db8d65888c22e1b4811f16c","submission_id":"TR4-af7618a13b7c3f05#done3"},"hash":"4f5b2617fde6ca9514194d27a61fd7abae35067043cb69c1fb307e5b8bb9a18a","header":{"body_hash":"6942cfc8df2c7fe3c04c30fe9432c109d353b832a8e53211a01ebd81e536a49a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3b9df8aac578ab8c11a28da4d0c28a7cb130370c1c50c2a8212cd9f97435c3c0","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":20,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"db4727147ecd12275cd6ed4b13dc339f7d869452c22efd58bdbec90b4b8ca8d7","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":1,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":60},"started_unix_ms":1795101831780,"wave":{"doc:PMC13226197.txt#0":"reader-1","doc:PMC13226197.txt#1":"reader-2","doc:PMC13226197.txt#2":"reader-3"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"10b54bb440878e365971b57a0e1fa42c140785dc467a0fce35f352d17a967b4f","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"2ca16d157fd73b8372d0e7e8a4895111da28a1972c7eab567709f395a8f43e68","submission_id":"circle:8792aaeec09de01b8dc3848d3a27cc6c2130a503527bf2bd69ecf035302ab9ba"},"hash":"59c1032df2ea14cf504b04fd8378927d98605cf01cc31db90d8b0bcbfa5292d3","header":{"body_hash":"ff45e1894be9c5aa77922a2b0da8c2a3b61abe62eaa5428ff0efb78ca8c28662","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"4f5b2617fde6ca9514194d27a61fd7abae35067043cb69c1fb307e5b8bb9a18a","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":21,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"aa95d643a9a6a8703e7da273ca000bece37ec7a2cb7e9051f08328a091fcaae2","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"db4727147ecd12275cd6ed4b13dc339f7d869452c22efd58bdbec90b4b8ca8d7","engine_root":"10b54bb440878e365971b57a0e1fa42c140785dc467a0fce35f352d17a967b4f","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"92cf053997c17ba0bc87cf4862d7fb8722999ac2e62870f373edb3df46b0513e","log_size":22,"projections":{"dependencies":"e18f5d308818949726e7260d87d87df27210a89ef8976316a40772ffae0895ac","status":"da391d0d0631dffd55272342f685acf6492e662a5f33f58a902b0559cfbbb4a5"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"59c1032df2ea14cf504b04fd8378927d98605cf01cc31db90d8b0bcbfa5292d3"}},"engine_root":"10b54bb440878e365971b57a0e1fa42c140785dc467a0fce35f352d17a967b4f","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"db4727147ecd12275cd6ed4b13dc339f7d869452c22efd58bdbec90b4b8ca8d7","engine_root":"10b54bb440878e365971b57a0e1fa42c140785dc467a0fce35f352d17a967b4f","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"92cf053997c17ba0bc87cf4862d7fb8722999ac2e62870f373edb3df46b0513e","log_size":22,"projections":{"dependencies":"e18f5d308818949726e7260d87d87df27210a89ef8976316a40772ffae0895ac","status":"da391d0d0631dffd55272342f685acf6492e662a5f33f58a902b0559cfbbb4a5"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"59c1032df2ea14cf504b04fd8378927d98605cf01cc31db90d8b0bcbfa5292d3"},"seal_hash":"f2013585f463c32780fec30489f22bb0a07aefbf60fb725dc438cf629b06df62"}},"request_hash":"8450199f1994d1402f4a315862c5f7f8b3226266bac5d1348987bfd19f76788b","submission_id":"seal-22"},"hash":"5b5ffc803b7c125b984a303d17807da8c93c8d0291bd1660111654950ec9099d","header":{"body_hash":"b58ca2d29cff3bb62519c6e2b23d08578081e005474be912d4d6b2edc292e53d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"59c1032df2ea14cf504b04fd8378927d98605cf01cc31db90d8b0bcbfa5292d3","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":22,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"55770937eb5ddfd64098dce69f32ffb832e7b2c3cd1d49b37b1526ffba879d34","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"epoch":2,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795101831780},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"10b54bb440878e365971b57a0e1fa42c140785dc467a0fce35f352d17a967b4f","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"83f65e0eb9f2aa4086ced9b482445a322156ae9147d7cbef9e08f63906c7acfe","submission_id":"ring-members:c7fe7261a7e00353f6bd3b33ab044fed44b28e074fcbf10c1a01ab9ef9ef1fba"},"hash":"540526b53fe98dc450fd4541563a062f117b3adfe8fe4e29f9449459bab0528b","header":{"body_hash":"56ea7d74448f4d1dee6d4c99a9f17b621851c184b99552ad8ec0158230ccc359","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"5b5ffc803b7c125b984a303d17807da8c93c8d0291bd1660111654950ec9099d","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":23,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"ff374f2fa9d6d891a56a57dd301a3ac7f80376e5ce8693cc89ffc9e16efe8b72","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":2,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":60},"started_unix_ms":1795101831795,"wave":{"doc:PMC13226197.txt#3":"reader-2","doc:PMC13226197.txt#4":"reader-3","doc:PMC13226197.txt#5":"reader-1"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"10b54bb440878e365971b57a0e1fa42c140785dc467a0fce35f352d17a967b4f","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"551409043954324630f08fffd98116e6fe867a956fb699403d7a435a9fe4baf5","submission_id":"circle:c016a45c08f9fa37b7e25bf5e2aad16ede311d35a7c74770f5e6f2b9bc5dc79b"},"hash":"9bb2d442ac89cfdb5baf7e82584a45df2fb58861c0f56c607339a23b733d28e7","header":{"body_hash":"d85b20f79ad83574d9708cf71cd15f4b232f58f64beab88b0307f929bdd70d2d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"540526b53fe98dc450fd4541563a062f117b3adfe8fe4e29f9449459bab0528b","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":24,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"2de78e14b07698914b856f4ac3cb4dc019dfc32cd5d0cbef21c15e864c955d91","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"ff374f2fa9d6d891a56a57dd301a3ac7f80376e5ce8693cc89ffc9e16efe8b72","engine_root":"10b54bb440878e365971b57a0e1fa42c140785dc467a0fce35f352d17a967b4f","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"4277749842aecaabe97a4b3a7c1f5b201d6f0df395633eddfacd40206ff99bc7","log_size":25,"projections":{"dependencies":"e18f5d308818949726e7260d87d87df27210a89ef8976316a40772ffae0895ac","status":"da391d0d0631dffd55272342f685acf6492e662a5f33f58a902b0559cfbbb4a5"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"9bb2d442ac89cfdb5baf7e82584a45df2fb58861c0f56c607339a23b733d28e7"}},"engine_root":"10b54bb440878e365971b57a0e1fa42c140785dc467a0fce35f352d17a967b4f","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"ff374f2fa9d6d891a56a57dd301a3ac7f80376e5ce8693cc89ffc9e16efe8b72","engine_root":"10b54bb440878e365971b57a0e1fa42c140785dc467a0fce35f352d17a967b4f","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"4277749842aecaabe97a4b3a7c1f5b201d6f0df395633eddfacd40206ff99bc7","log_size":25,"projections":{"dependencies":"e18f5d308818949726e7260d87d87df27210a89ef8976316a40772ffae0895ac","status":"da391d0d0631dffd55272342f685acf6492e662a5f33f58a902b0559cfbbb4a5"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"9bb2d442ac89cfdb5baf7e82584a45df2fb58861c0f56c607339a23b733d28e7"},"seal_hash":"3cfa0c6cefb6e2daa3a7a07df2b1145e37f2b15acbaa3c2b95400c7b3337f13e"}},"request_hash":"f33437c301f5d8ce10bac481e652cdd780fe37b7289653e832a016522e87081c","submission_id":"seal-25"},"hash":"2fe7eed0843ebb31caa11a762c385b8aa4d84294144ffc39cf463d03cd9662cd","header":{"body_hash":"8573286a39a416b8dd425a4a400def7d204fe8b5f64e6a750bcef275170b03fd","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"9bb2d442ac89cfdb5baf7e82584a45df2fb58861c0f56c607339a23b733d28e7","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":25,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"938759951b5785cfd95d23eb26ea54cd693d4d87479a911c8610b377b9274dfe","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"epoch":3,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795101831795},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"10b54bb440878e365971b57a0e1fa42c140785dc467a0fce35f352d17a967b4f","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"34f1f59f264613ef760851814b63ecfbe0ec91b8ef3de6e912fecac6ae21cd7e","submission_id":"ring-members:8251e30990e7a9b8d678af68b9f8f1a43f71996d04d89430fff88e52a06f4f42"},"hash":"5f1920ca20b3a92e5f9cb76879b93243d9bf98fca70b646b0d98a89adfb1688f","header":{"body_hash":"4e92c5abee1712c00e19c95fad0a1b5eec5dcdd8f8ba9b182b211b6a7ece6912","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"2fe7eed0843ebb31caa11a762c385b8aa4d84294144ffc39cf463d03cd9662cd","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":26,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"fe1687b303664552c6cc6aee83bffeac3b3a90430ab4a5f1b08cfac9a1724f9b","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"T5-731ee89f6c475bfe","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"We thus consider metacognition, engagement, and transfer as outcome families; however, they are related yet distinct, and the proposed pathway is theoretically driven but not formally defined.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t5_o2","terms":["outcome families","theoretically driven pathway"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"A near transfer outcome can be defined as correctness on the first encounter with a novel item within the same skill after an exposure window by using Equation (4):","kind":"observe","local_id":"t5_o3","terms":["near transfer operationalization","novel item within same skill"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"EdNet can be able to use reasonable proxies based on (i) switches to new skill sets or topic groups, (ii) stunted generalization following dormancy, and (iii) resilience in performance during shifts in surface features","kind":"observe","local_id":"t5_o4","terms":["far transfer proxies","skill switches","dormancy","surface feature shifts"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"A far transfer proxy can thus be determined as accurately transferred to a new set of skill clusters C(·) , by using Equation (5):","kind":"observe","local_id":"t5_o5","terms":["far transfer operationalization","skill clusters"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"H1: AI-supported tutoring increases adaptive metacognitive regulation, reflected in more timely help seeking, revision, and strategy switching. H2: AI support increases behavioral engagement, reflected in greater persistence and activity.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t5_o6","terms":["hypotheses H1 and H2","metacognitive regulation","behavioral engagement"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"H3: AI support improves near transfer more consistently than far transfer. H4: Effects vary by prior mastery and task difficulty","kind":"observe","local_id":"t5_o7","terms":["hypotheses H3 and H4","near vs far transfer","prior mastery","task difficulty"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"In this paper, we assume that the core unit of analysis is a time-sequenced sequence of learner events within sessions, and that outcomes are constructed at the interaction, session, and short-horizon follow-up levels, based on the construct.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t5_o8","terms":["unit of analysis","outcome construction levels","EdNet"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The direction and significance of the engagement effects were found to be robust to this choice by sensitivity analyses with λ∈{0.5,,1,,2} .","kind":"observe","local_id":"t5_o9","terms":["composite engagement intensity","sensitivity analysis","tuning constant lambda"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t5_o3","t5_o4","t5_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t5_c2","object":"near transfer (first-encounter correctness on novel item in same skill) and far transfer (new skill clusters, post-dormancy generalization, surface shifts)","predicate":"operationalizes_outcome","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 operationalizes near transfer as correctness on a learner's first encounter with a novel item within the same latent skill after an exposure window, and far transfer via accuracy in new skill clusters, post-dormancy, or across surface shifts."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t5_o6","t5_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t5_c3","object":"H1 (adaptive metacognition), H2 (behavioral engagement), H3 (near > far transfer consistency), H4 (moderation by prior mastery and task difficulty)","predicate":"tests_hypotheses","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 tests four hypotheses: AI tutoring increases adaptive metacognitive regulation (H1) and behavioral engagement (H2), improves near transfer more consistently than far transfer (H3), and shows effects varying by prior mastery and task difficulty (H4)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t5_o8","t5_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t5_c4","object":"within-session event sequences at interaction, session, and short-horizon levels; engagement effects robust to tuning constant λ ∈ {0.5, 1, 2}","predicate":"uses_method_and_finds","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 uses time-sequenced learner events within EdNet sessions as its core unit of analysis, constructing outcomes at interaction, session, and short-horizon follow-up levels, with engagement effect direction and significance robust to λ in {0.5, 1, 2}."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",16287,21531]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"22d4e5bd64697dd05369cafbb495e5bff1e8ed196556d70ec8ffe622c3f082ad","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["19a60919570f613a1a45de71af6bdf5db806d868cb05b93c51d3a0c6c252e46d","6b801ae65b4b5215e906d1d9b17ecad180a08eef7d5cd9af21ad59427ec4f227","7cb5ec8b81a9c3bf6a89bcded45db972d10e157c94ff3774ea5232d4868aca67","0e7bff61069dacfca1b1d7322f384882f3fa8a0d74611d5c69de4ed497ebe2a0","569d0bd48d648d0b37b004de644e0a48842875e3e3f3d0d683564f804311f49e","836e95492a73369f421ae6ab0b5a672c5057a59771da89a5dfda7651209b0dfd","541084ae8b6f09159e05ae79b557ba0221e174acc9784026a396439b814d4de8","5e78a366067587a25f00c7c24d5d42bfde8db797a3477dcb7d71e906b43c5a5e"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":8}},"request_hash":"fd2b5610a5e772c018d873b18965694999a86c4b02b8026ac18ec7408fa137d6","submission_id":"T5-731ee89f6c475bfe#1"},"hash":"856c5e495d0ffd2f84d7048a6fe0a89300ec0231f9014fe9827f4a6e64956d71","header":{"body_hash":"288a15400ab9e7b406c96a822987fbf44fb797489ac6605c7fccc1bb28655037","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"5f1920ca20b3a92e5f9cb76879b93243d9bf98fca70b646b0d98a89adfb1688f","records_root":"1e0ce9c2d8fce066ce783e0dc5db0da7fb1add509ff5646f546a30429d58326a","seq":27,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"6cc6bddac91c0d0c234787801b148f2c08cc656b80e8c638cb3965be445c3398","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"T5-731ee89f6c475bfe","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t5_o6","t5_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t5_c3","object":"H1 (adaptive metacognition), H2 (behavioral engagement), H3 (near > far transfer consistency), H4 (moderation by prior mastery and task difficulty)","predicate":"tests_hypotheses","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 tests four hypotheses: AI tutoring increases adaptive metacognitive regulation (H1) and behavioral engagement (H2), improves near transfer more consistently than far transfer (H3), and shows effects varying by prior mastery and task difficulty (H4)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t5_o8","t5_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t5_c4","object":"within-session event sequences at interaction, session, and short-horizon levels; engagement effects robust to tuning constant λ ∈ {0.5, 1, 2}","predicate":"uses_method_and_finds","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 uses time-sequenced learner events within EdNet sessions as its core unit of analysis, constructing outcomes at interaction, session, and short-horizon follow-up levels, with engagement effect direction and significance robust to λ in {0.5, 1, 2}."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",16287,21531]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"22d4e5bd64697dd05369cafbb495e5bff1e8ed196556d70ec8ffe622c3f082ad","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":[],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":0}},"request_hash":"d8b49571f47fdc754a129e2852b0ea22f3ce0b3dd0eba6c39c903a9f52770e42","submission_id":"T5-731ee89f6c475bfe#1.1"},"hash":"dd4c6c18838b93f4680ada075781554ab3f210b96f95ab287e78f720d9b9822b","header":{"body_hash":"013427f6b34334e7b70ef59e9ee0fa499a60d9c8da6d4965f60d70fd61d99adb","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"856c5e495d0ffd2f84d7048a6fe0a89300ec0231f9014fe9827f4a6e64956d71","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":28,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"afd1432dbe7c849ffa5461deab4bc45b995882ea0d88785929a1ecba69b51cac","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"T5-731ee89f6c475bfe","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t5_o8","t5_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t5_c4","object":"within-session event sequences at interaction, session, and short-horizon levels; engagement effects robust to tuning constant λ ∈ {0.5, 1, 2}","predicate":"uses_method_and_finds","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 uses time-sequenced learner events within EdNet sessions as its core unit of analysis, constructing outcomes at interaction, session, and short-horizon follow-up levels, with engagement effect direction and significance robust to λ in {0.5, 1, 2}."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",16287,21531]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"22d4e5bd64697dd05369cafbb495e5bff1e8ed196556d70ec8ffe622c3f082ad","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":[],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":0}},"request_hash":"e48a382d9dfeeb8926300780dff1cbfa089b0807775a30c030c1f727cabf2081","submission_id":"T5-731ee89f6c475bfe#1.2"},"hash":"28811f2bca6ccb599aece73e64bfec9ba23be87906b3fd1562063cbfc6014237","header":{"body_hash":"f83a0a654dd9445fc976102bd174e4e104c1572897c964dd6832f89b4265698a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"dd4c6c18838b93f4680ada075781554ab3f210b96f95ab287e78f720d9b9822b","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":29,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"27d715994e1f336f603203cd17d3dc8a43e418919518aba1ac5fc03e3eeb9c44","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@19a60919570f613a","@6b801ae65b4b5215","@7cb5ec8b81a9c3bf","@0e7bff61069dacfc","@569d0bd48d648d0b","@836e95492a73369f","@541084ae8b6f0915","@5e78a366067587a2"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[{"index":9,"local_id":"t5_c1","rests_on":"t5_o1"}],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"QUOTE_NOT_FOUND_IN_BYTES","expected_by_kernel":{"rule":"byte_quote"},"field":"exact_quote","message":"quote has no byte-exact occurrence","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":0,"local_id":"t5_o1"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":10,"local_id":"t5_c2"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":11,"local_id":"t5_c3"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":12,"local_id":"t5_c4"}],"task_id":"T5-731ee89f6c475bfe","work_key":"doc:PMC13226197.txt#3"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T5-731ee89f6c475bfe:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"22d4e5bd64697dd05369cafbb495e5bff1e8ed196556d70ec8ffe622c3f082ad","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"ecd179c9ce8f9f1d500a6788308b95a32ee3d26adfc33f0a0684f4f470691f29","submission_id":"T5-731ee89f6c475bfe#repair1"},"hash":"3e6c9adc193c630a53134547fed1943ac5579f1a8485c582efd0db633f9f7102","header":{"body_hash":"71b23b785813fa9811447a14962b1e9cfef1d3d99c63ed2491d173e45c3b5adf","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"28811f2bca6ccb599aece73e64bfec9ba23be87906b3fd1562063cbfc6014237","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":30,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"bb8bdf6a76e89b5b625f832f0fca6a92246cc601f2cfece700435fa4737683ff","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"T7-88e4762de469c959","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Transfer across topic shifts is determined by assessing performance during topic changes or when new skill sets require applying the corresponding knowledge under altered surface conditions.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t7_o1","terms":["transfer across topic shifts","knowledge transfer","altered surface conditions"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Delayed performance is also used as a second proxy for durable generalization, measuring the effectiveness of learners’ performance after a significant delay in inactivity","kind":"observe","local_id":"t7_o2","terms":["delayed performance","durable generalization","knowledge transfer"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"items in EdNet are sampled from shared pools and have a learner-invariant difficulty parameter calibrated using item-response theory. All transfer models have item difficulty as a continuous covariate","kind":"observe","local_id":"t7_o3","terms":["EdNet","item difficulty","item-response theory","transfer models"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Overall, the AI support coefficient for near transfer does not change following such an adjustment (β = 0.046, 95% CI [0.035, 0.057]), indicating that the transfer effects cannot be explained by increased repetition","kind":"observe","local_id":"t7_o4","terms":["near transfer","AI support coefficient","practice volume adjustment"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The analysis was based on secondary log data of the EdNet dataset. To start with, the raw event files were acquired on Kaggle and imported into the analysis environment.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t7_o5","terms":["EdNet dataset","Kaggle","secondary log data"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The timing of exposure prior to each outcome window was set so that AI support always occurred before the outcomes of metacognition, engagement, and transfer were measured.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t7_o6","terms":["exposure timing","AI support","outcome window"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Metacognitive proxies were calculated based on checking, error correction, help-seeking, revisiting, and strategy switching.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t7_o7","terms":["metacognitive proxies","checking","error correction","help-seeking","revisiting","strategy switching"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The outcomes of knowledge transfer were defined as the identification of new items within already practiced skills, transitions between topics or skills, and delayed performance following periods of inactivity.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t7_o8","terms":["knowledge transfer outcomes","new items","topic transitions","delayed performance"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The secondary effects comprise the heterogeneous effects of learner and task characteristics (e.g., prior mastery, baseline activity level, and item difficulty) and a dose–response curve","kind":"observe","local_id":"t7_o9","terms":["secondary effects","heterogeneous effects","dose-response curve"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t7_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t7_c1","object":"near transfer AI support coefficient β = 0.046 (95% CI [0.035, 0.057]) robust to cumulative attempts","predicate":"finds_result","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds a positive AI support effect on near transfer (β = 0.046, 95% CI [0.035, 0.057]) that remains unchanged after controlling for cumulative practice attempts, ruling out sheer practice repetition."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t7_o1","t7_o2","t7_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t7_c2","object":"knowledge transfer (near transfer on novel items, topic/skill transitions, delayed performance after inactivity)","predicate":"operationalizes_outcome","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 operationalizes knowledge transfer via three proxies: first-attempt performance on novel items within a practiced skill (near transfer), performance across topic or skill shifts, and delayed performance after inactivity."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t7_o3","t7_o5","t7_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t7_c3","object":"Kaggle EdNet logs in learner-session/item panels with IRT item-difficulty controls and prior exposure timing","predicate":"uses_data_and_methods","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 controls for IRT-calibrated item difficulty in all transfer models and acquires secondary EdNet event logs from Kaggle, structuring them into learner-session and learner-item panels with AI exposure preceding outcome windows."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t7_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t7_c4","object":"heterogeneous effects (prior mastery, baseline activity, item difficulty) and exposure dose-response curve","predicate":"measures_secondary_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In addition to mean treatment effects on metacognition, engagement, and transfer, PMC13226197 estimates secondary heterogeneous effects by prior mastery, baseline activity, and item difficulty, as well as a dose-response curve."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",26872,32757]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"47b361841c24d00fd57d20857727a5bd72997d957794480707ee8442e72b29e8","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["a8df37fb13db5044cd4d893ff45827c544cb284e437f94809437d4d1d74a141b","45f20def6861824e083a1a342716838a7e1d268fc2382741f7f5b5dee0fe8070","4b70d2e538226d0b7b63af0dd474b5d376cdd796f92a6f267d04e07e30f6d5af","7441f659886b2ceba9b0e65b2edf62a5c2b56b8fbcc1ccde61bc4cf26111deaf","3c51b44b8b8080714b000a8a62498f9e542521f900badf270074e395d3151918","831241dc0bda403664a237dfca53e17b3e73cd0513f79435330d82cd0c676ef7","d3d4e1d3ccf78a945d6d9480b22af485afeff4ceed8d7d12c87868f7b782d0f8","a886153044d80e9b04324f54336412c5785bd7f643d5876e240ce03541a9106a","0f4550b81c87a0ce9252ef8a7f83f6fdd5a44f82c12a0a11fffdd93b17daead0","5cc4825359af09317d551bd9c954b7d913624ee271771d3a906ed281675fcd0d","0f6052ca7e51b9016f79aa0dd716f937cbae0fa6a481b8c4360cf7a5a357ee5d","7b7403845c63b296863b9f9b8c6ec0170c637352f8d5ed378bd78334d105e492","6d048c34a9ecd21f4bac2dda87786263c8ae5ddbf24a646850a757bc6cbbd61c"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"df47777bde539a42582b654fe53eb5767212dd083a5e28bfbeb20c4c726387db","submission_id":"T7-88e4762de469c959#1"},"hash":"8f402fb6c74a77d7a921852e1bb00d8da35bddbe2c1c4af75a23e8fff7ef30f6","header":{"body_hash":"253d404e3dea345729ec9087788ef75b6b312ec358860c2a7cba7f575b873219","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3e6c9adc193c630a53134547fed1943ac5579f1a8485c582efd0db633f9f7102","records_root":"8b37647da39f062ab314857ef4b8bfde4933082e24fea77386337907fa406cad","seq":31,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"423f4beb3845e295cde80a91627ec1913a7e0fcd4e471c7ea605f69a38c99112","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":2,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":3,"task_id":"T7-88e4762de469c959"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13226197.txt#5","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"47b361841c24d00fd57d20857727a5bd72997d957794480707ee8442e72b29e8","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"284eea079dfb7559f5233ec25c972463d6227ef379cb173158eab31ccdc36ffe","submission_id":"T7-88e4762de469c959#done2"},"hash":"3f8277da468304495efb505f0f519bf520e1f0956eb8fe3179ead810ef85ca76","header":{"body_hash":"9d2cb38f9297e25446f751f8da0b6a0c1655aa0384f35302ac479c600c5654bd","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"8f402fb6c74a77d7a921852e1bb00d8da35bddbe2c1c4af75a23e8fff7ef30f6","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":32,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"60b2a65dc5382632a80aa48354b8421982b1950b95174aaf6a750ac1ca28d09f","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"T6-f27d3f6a3ed72faa","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"EdNet is collected in an AI-assisted tutoring system, yet it does not capture the use of generative AI in a chat-based large language model context.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t6_o1","terms":["EdNet data scope","generative AI limitation","LLM context exclusion"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"In this regard, we define AI use as tutoring-system assistance events, which are algorithm-based support events embedded in the learning process.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t6_o2","terms":["AI use operational definition","algorithm-based tutoring support"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Past performance and recent error record were considered observable proxies of past performance and current learning condition;","kind":"observe","local_id":"t6_o3","terms":["confounding controls","past performance","recent error record"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The item difficulty and skill context were added to explain the task’s complexity and the deviation in instructional needs across learning episodes.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t6_o4","terms":["confounding controls","item difficulty","skill context"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"session-level activity baseline and associated measures of behavioral intensity were added.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t6_o5","terms":["confounding controls","session-level activity baseline","behavioral intensity"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Taken together, these controls were intended to prevent significant backdoor routes related to learner state, task difficulty, and continued practice conditions","kind":"observe","local_id":"t6_o6","terms":["causal adjustment","backdoor routes","confounding controls"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"we define a range of exposure definitions with varying stringency, from assistance exposure to intensive exposure, and we test these alternative definitions in robustness checks.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t6_o7","terms":["exposure definitions","varying stringency","robustness checks"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"prediction-like behaviors and checking patterns, including rapid post-attempt verification, error detection followed by correction, and systematic post-feedback checking.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t6_o8","terms":["metacognitive monitoring proxies","checking patterns","verification"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Control proxies encompass effort allocation and strategy regulation. These are help-seeking decisions, switching strategies within a problem or between problems, review or revisit decisions, and adjustments of persistence following errors.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t6_o9","terms":["metacognitive control proxies","strategy regulation","persistence adjustments"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Lastly, we characterize train and test splits at the learner level to prevent temporal leakage and to ensure that evaluation is consistent with real-world generalization.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t6_o10","terms":["analytic cohort construction","learner-level train-test split","temporal leakage prevention"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t6_o1","t6_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t6_c1","object":"EdNet captures algorithm-based tutoring assistance rather than chat-based LLM generative AI","predicate":"qualifies_data_scope","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 qualifies its EdNet data scope by noting it captures algorithm-based tutoring assistance events rather than generative AI in a chat-based LLM context."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t6_o3","t6_o4","t6_o5","t6_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t6_c2","object":"past performance, recent errors, item difficulty, skill context, and session activity baseline","predicate":"controls_for_confounders","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 adjusts for time-varying covariates (past performance, recent errors, item difficulty, skill context, and session activity baseline) to block confounding backdoor paths."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t6_o7","t6_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t6_c3","object":"robustness checks across exposure stringency levels and learner-level train/test splits","predicate":"uses_analytic_design","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 tests alternative time-localized AI exposure definitions ranging from assistance exposure to intensive exposure in robustness checks, and splits train/test data at the learner level."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t6_o8","t6_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t6_c4","object":"monitoring (verification, error correction, checking) and control (help-seeking, switching, revisiting, persistence adjustments)","predicate":"operationalizes_metacognition_as","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 operationalizes metacognitive monitoring via rapid post-attempt verification, error detection/correction, and post-feedback checking, and control via help-seeking, strategy switching, revisiting, and post-error persistence."},{"about":["PMC13226197","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t6_q1","needed":"Check remaining sections and reference list of PMC13226197.txt for citations to Wang and Fan (2025).","text":"Does PMC13226197 cite the retracted meta-analysis Wang and Fan (2025) in other sections or its reference list?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",21531,26872]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"915ee444869ab04f444690a2f7d6f68bfd3a540f1c9322d325a93ef965325782","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["80e3010961093788f61a8f7cb2227655017dad8e70700d56b7211cb3cfc0e21f","86c2df0ff3a6d963abc15f13a549c440b699dcc300a4c03fb1d2990f719a8080","fca72b00cc2b15d834651209f34d8091cc85adeffef4c1166f60fc7795f495a0","a929fbeb38ee0720bc1dce9d68b55b6f369e959e2960e094b87bd120203e7474","7f77c5f520faae414ad8b14b025b2275385a5c128c3f5ea162200d8ba3638091","ef92f93bb17a361f6e2aef2eded441362dd8aa894916eb2fa7ed6ac793860c48","4b3d32b996a4b7d92f90b56017e0b5d22f9bf269f495024af19e1bf654ad9859","138aaf182bc4ada288e41af57f5936b6fe220da21dfd710560b9871dd88d5fae","c870e87043160825386922dba73445a036cedc7bc6e46a4b7c8ac0900b1e1b75","22dbeb83fed694a1fb3f6ea90be777568d575e08a9454d24f0a5a78f8d516932","cdc299cd076ce0e993ca4be9796ebf136db2891efeaf38cc426e5157553d6e4b","4b7e78e56636d691cf451f4591d590a7d5a2165bd8993cd5c2046729879e4b63","5e27c8c1f42ca9b5dafcae07ef04f18d37727e8f448e4c4277d3188698763f80","d3cfd564a90c7bdde660642628a91b0699cd24d3244cda971d34e38adfdb840f","414c655c6375016b8c5174b96265f37499b0110aad37b5be559b860fbdc4abe4"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"16c5c6ea1cd486ac20358a24fe901df57b13eaef91069e51ccdd31d74f3075fb","submission_id":"T6-f27d3f6a3ed72faa#1"},"hash":"4788c3f72a69bd86211e11985cb509f09541f1a9e0cd697eeaf3ad95d4e18fb6","header":{"body_hash":"296af49361c2d0bfd7c736e04189650a9baf96b1be849609c65fdfcb627d6037","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3f8277da468304495efb505f0f519bf520e1f0956eb8fe3179ead810ef85ca76","records_root":"0ff4c9595c18135f342b8758dabd913feb0177043f5c0f676f0e94837b7300a3","seq":33,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"bdadc644dabffba5e849c52df6bd6e8046dfa7440353e0a128c96a4cf208ee49","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":2,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":3,"task_id":"T6-f27d3f6a3ed72faa"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13226197.txt#4","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"915ee444869ab04f444690a2f7d6f68bfd3a540f1c9322d325a93ef965325782","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"294b44ee02d70b62c41326416f173be1da5ef0351cda5e681beba06cd2674822","submission_id":"T6-f27d3f6a3ed72faa#done2"},"hash":"13b048064fd512d9d384e9d6b85a36b8bd88c76cfe226bc235c19524f0332b60","header":{"body_hash":"9eccb740fa76398513a115fb0db1af17303f785c975eba25a71832e5425dace3","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"4788c3f72a69bd86211e11985cb509f09541f1a9e0cd697eeaf3ad95d4e18fb6","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":34,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"4773bfab3421fddf6cae3cf31a4e026794a5e9af080f58442acf34d56b056b0d","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"T5-731ee89f6c475bfe","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Even though Figure 2 introduces metacognition and engagement as mechanisms that connect AI exposure to transfer, the current study does not provide an estimate of a formal causal mediation model.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t5_o1","terms":["lack of formal causal mediation model","metacognition and engagement as mechanisms"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t5_o1","t5_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t5_c1","object":"treats metacognition, engagement, and transfer as distinct outcome families without estimating a formal causal mediation model","predicate":"qualifies_methodology","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 does not estimate a formal causal mediation model linking AI exposure to transfer via metacognition and engagement, instead treating them as distinct outcome families with a theoretically driven pathway."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t5_o3","t5_o4","t5_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t5_c2","object":"near transfer (first-encounter correctness on novel item in same skill) and far transfer (new skill clusters, post-dormancy generalization, surface shifts)","predicate":"operationalizes_outcome","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 operationalizes near transfer as correctness on first encounter with a novel item in the same latent skill, and far transfer via accuracy in new skill clusters, post-dormancy generalization, or surface feature shifts."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t5_o6","t5_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t5_c3","object":"H1 (adaptive metacognition), H2 (behavioral engagement), H3 (near > far transfer consistency), H4 (moderation by prior mastery and task difficulty)","predicate":"tests_hypotheses","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 tests four hypotheses: AI tutoring increases adaptive metacognitive regulation (H1) and behavioral engagement (H2), improves near over far transfer consistency (H3), and varies by prior mastery and task difficulty (H4)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t5_o8","t5_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t5_c4","object":"within-session event sequences at interaction, session, and short-horizon levels; engagement effects robust to tuning constant λ ∈ {0.5, 1, 2}","predicate":"uses_method_and_finds","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 uses time-sequenced learner events within EdNet sessions as its core unit of analysis, constructing outcomes at interaction, session, and short-horizon levels, with engagement effects robust to λ in {0.5, 1, 2}."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",16287,21531]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"9033989ea5b60c644cf6e45dfc96da2cddefda786778cb9024b046bd15d58cc5","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["97982ec5a86f9dc94158fb66c8081461819b61b21d6826405c404d64aea8f4d6","4633249af9fd9e3681cb3189bf68846566d4b9ebe11c39f0d01a818b7e39f8be","a1e2a84b0c298dac18f886a18de913ac1b00452b2a5b9acf682b045aa6ae087b","2140cb97ded74d7fb0bf40a1434a5bcff0c92d861885f01b8db02074680f3866","2aabfcb53b507df537d08e587f2b3759de3e32c502ac1d1b13b8c8f9693151df"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"981ba784a6f1111cb362fd5dc95b3b7272f7c07ce073e8f3a811c398b53b1458","submission_id":"T5-731ee89f6c475bfe#2"},"hash":"206b716bf85d9bbfb3eb3810cee0fba4ba58280c14bcf3b892a61c60f62e530c","header":{"body_hash":"57d35aac8b4b33954ddd7d0660feb39f32129dffe8bcb6efd32d2c9673616526","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"13b048064fd512d9d384e9d6b85a36b8bd88c76cfe226bc235c19524f0332b60","records_root":"c8f3f41b848a4e002e919451c9fba03c2a8c937411adf09612291908fea6f2d3","seq":35,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"f5f40de37b2f50514050e8db8e79e147519f83c10e8719c992deaa502a8ef9f9","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":false,"agent":"reader-2","circle":2,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":13,"refusals":1,"stored":13,"sync_step":3,"task_id":"T5-731ee89f6c475bfe"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13226197.txt#3","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"9033989ea5b60c644cf6e45dfc96da2cddefda786778cb9024b046bd15d58cc5","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"4a74222c797403d0aaaa6379a43ca8e7f56a3e8869c5d19979817e85be04485f","submission_id":"T5-731ee89f6c475bfe#done3"},"hash":"4f7db3f01dcbe17d0aec4a646cc29dd9acf1088f67f22ec2552d38cf90e0ae13","header":{"body_hash":"23df23d9d6e52bd858968a1fc3485e71c83039b359f21aa8494266045f0a01ea","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"206b716bf85d9bbfb3eb3810cee0fba4ba58280c14bcf3b892a61c60f62e530c","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":36,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"aee5b51ba62f5da68122628a14a7203271e2d2c327331cb2e94f243478396ef1","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TR8-0cb4c90b7149418a","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The direction and significance of the engagement effects were found to be robust to this choice by sensitivity analyses with λ∈{0.5,,1,,2} .","kind":"observe","local_id":"t8_o1","terms":["composite engagement intensity","sensitivity analysis","tuning constant lambda"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"We thus consider metacognition, engagement, and transfer as outcome families; however, they are related yet distinct, and the proposed pathway is theoretically driven but not formally defined.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t8_o3","terms":["outcome families","metacognition","engagement","transfer"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"A near transfer outcome can be defined as correctness on the first encounter with a novel item within the same skill after an exposure window by using Equation (4):","kind":"observe","local_id":"t8_o4","terms":["near transfer","operationalization","first encounter with novel item"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"EdNet can be able to use reasonable proxies based on (i) switches to new skill sets or topic groups, (ii) stunted generalization following dormancy, and (iii) resilience in performance during shifts in surface features","kind":"observe","local_id":"t8_o5","terms":["far transfer proxies","skill switches","dormancy","surface features"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"A far transfer proxy can thus be determined as accurately transferred to a new set of skill clusters C(·) , by using Equation (5):","kind":"observe","local_id":"t8_o6","terms":["far transfer proxy","skill clusters"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"H1: AI-supported tutoring increases adaptive metacognitive regulation, reflected in more timely help seeking, revision, and strategy switching. H2: AI support increases behavioral engagement, reflected in greater persistence and activity.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t8_o7","terms":["hypotheses H1 and H2","metacognitive regulation","behavioral engagement"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"H3: AI support improves near transfer more consistently than far transfer. H4: Effects vary by prior mastery and task difficulty","kind":"observe","local_id":"t8_o8","terms":["hypotheses H3 and H4","near vs far transfer","prior mastery","task difficulty"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"In this paper, we assume that the core unit of analysis is a time-sequenced sequence of learner events within sessions, and that outcomes are constructed at the interaction, session, and short-horizon follow-up levels","kind":"observe","local_id":"t8_o9","terms":["unit of analysis","session event sequence","outcome levels"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t8_o1"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t8_c1","object":"engagement effects robust to composite intensity tuning constant λ in {0.5, 1, 2}","predicate":"finds_robustness_of_outcome","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds that the direction and significance of engagement effects are robust across sensitivity analyses varying the effort-weighting tuning constant λ in {0.5, 1, 2}."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t8_o4","t8_o5","t8_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t8_c3","object":"near transfer (first-encounter correctness in same skill) and far transfer (new skill clusters, dormancy, surface shifts)","predicate":"operationalizes_outcome","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 operationalizes near transfer as correctness on the first encounter with a novel item in the same latent skill after an exposure window, and far transfer via switches to new skill clusters, post-dormancy, and surface shifts."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t8_o7","t8_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t8_c4","object":"H1 (metacognition), H2 (engagement), H3 (near > far transfer), H4 (heterogeneity by mastery and difficulty)","predicate":"tests_hypotheses","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 tests four hypotheses: AI tutoring increases adaptive metacognitive regulation (H1) and behavioral engagement (H2), improves near transfer more consistently than far transfer (H3), and varies by prior mastery and difficulty (H4)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t8_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t8_c5","object":"within-session learner event sequences with outcomes at interaction, session, and short-horizon follow-up levels","predicate":"defines_unit_of_analysis","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 uses time-sequenced learner events within sessions from EdNet (Kwang, 2020) as its core unit of analysis, constructing outcomes at interaction, session, and short-horizon follow-up levels."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",16287,21531]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"29bdec08da424caa346111ef6eb2b514fbda237443ef6438c584fcb80e931241","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["b4351e609f78ca4578ead4ad4d33a838997d981469beba2d7836ea05081d419c","012cf34cf2ebd93fd966519ce4c7d85d1df0bf9d5ee21b7b1c861e3fca132ea8","56276df22d170ddbb8380cb2361b73b07b75596648055cbd73c24188d4aa97c3","d3edf3c95a96d6cda06d9d5e925e0c06f6d059e7d362f6d168ce56958edec3b0","4e3628f4ecba2cf8d2d85258b639902f0994faacd0f3d2f6bfc730bff9a39dce","dd3d2fb8e4b8758530984f0a43a8d132b9f7babc6b94eef4d6f7ab4f7c867f7f","86d8013d8ea2f067d0a359b9704c73b3fe2a3f07a580a1775d40d7c7a915b252","60a25afb0da8110108e8e0f1684160fdc69c00bf2f76d65d9c9d0964b7ef574d","b3bb373c91bec75f5cbcf5d6cd7db29a460fde8ed3aa4f965a33779438112709","ebbbfe1fd3729cbbae11daea735e3282f09d567412bf9690b89a378e8d81ab04"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":10}},"request_hash":"41175f09ebe8102ac23d2d82084635e2db1f4424950f267f22955f96ba0cd8df","submission_id":"TR8-0cb4c90b7149418a#1"},"hash":"951d60a97b4b5f513c1b13d3abc6f6a35e44f7d6fe6db3b1eed8a0492df998e8","header":{"body_hash":"43f7f98baf8b42a0cd34a771211b4c4d27306866f39015cdd74ca43076787591","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"4f7db3f01dcbe17d0aec4a646cc29dd9acf1088f67f22ec2552d38cf90e0ae13","records_root":"ba4b64646b213a2d899a6eb144c2fc1c48d9c1bfd6f41b0a8818529e68edb7d2","seq":37,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"1789c1ea312bc4e70706d7e2a41a5289e7ad63c8098a65aea585bb7bc36db581","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TR8-0cb4c90b7149418a","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t8_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t8_c5","object":"within-session learner event sequences with outcomes at interaction, session, and short-horizon follow-up levels","predicate":"defines_unit_of_analysis","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 uses time-sequenced learner events within sessions from EdNet (Kwang, 2020) as its core unit of analysis, constructing outcomes at interaction, session, and short-horizon follow-up levels."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",16287,21531]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"29bdec08da424caa346111ef6eb2b514fbda237443ef6438c584fcb80e931241","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"1ee04596cebb147e900f3296dc9c0695da0f909cfedf41febe8f97ec7316a967","submission_id":"TR8-0cb4c90b7149418a#1.1"},"hash":"74288718f91f3fa9293fc5ffab24533db9d495cf400713f1f3262a6c665e6d3a","header":{"body_hash":"e62857eeaec9a9c81b92ae99d0f28f0125545d319937ec3b61567edd2b0e87a4","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"951d60a97b4b5f513c1b13d3abc6f6a35e44f7d6fe6db3b1eed8a0492df998e8","records_root":"8be3acd830011ce20ad335eb74ff5e5c645ad8112d681d12e8b580b06d7512a5","seq":38,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"962c8195d6b8baf3f3629db48d40118491e4e04201feeda14f78a0f84a976e9e","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@b4351e609f78ca45","@012cf34cf2ebd93f","@56276df22d170ddb","@d3edf3c95a96d6cd","@4e3628f4ecba2cf8","@dd3d2fb8e4b87585","@86d8013d8ea2f067","@60a25afb0da81101","@b3bb373c91bec75f","@ebbbfe1fd3729cbb","@f65551577830214f"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[{"index":10,"local_id":"t8_c2","rests_on":"t8_o2"}],"kind":"REQUEST","refused":[{"error":{"code":"QUOTE_NOT_FOUND_IN_BYTES","expected_by_kernel":{"rule":"byte_quote"},"field":"exact_quote","message":"quote has no byte-exact occurrence","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":1,"local_id":"t8_o2"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":12,"local_id":"t8_c4"}],"task_id":"TR8-0cb4c90b7149418a","work_key":"reread:PMC13226197.txt#3"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:TR8-0cb4c90b7149418a:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"29bdec08da424caa346111ef6eb2b514fbda237443ef6438c584fcb80e931241","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"2b2c933f5dbcd298ecc60e6c871bcbab3b16e51e4cc2a3bcb05bec8d428c3dec","submission_id":"TR8-0cb4c90b7149418a#repair1"},"hash":"879f97ab8b889e29f734118d897e0069958e8034efddc876b58937644d206bde","header":{"body_hash":"944748487deeaf5cd7f09514ba76122b707e5bc5af6b50e0d918b603c71d7d6a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"74288718f91f3fa9293fc5ffab24533db9d495cf400713f1f3262a6c665e6d3a","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":39,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"ce6f928c5794300f45921366d0aa735de55db260f59ac72b85ff58e2f815e4b1","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TR8-0cb4c90b7149418a","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Even though Figure 2 introduces metacognition and engagement as mechanisms that connect AI exposure to transfer, the current study does not provide an estimate of a formal causal mediation model.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t8_o2","terms":["causal mediation model","metacognition","engagement","transfer"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t8_o2","t8_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t8_c2","object":"does not estimate formal causal mediation; treats metacognition, engagement, and transfer as distinct outcome families","predicate":"qualifies_method","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 treats metacognition, engagement, and transfer as distinct outcome families rather than estimating a formal causal mediation model, because post-treatment processes dynamically co-evolve over short intervals."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t8_o7","t8_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t8_c4","object":"H1 (metacognition), H2 (engagement), H3 (near > far transfer), H4 (heterogeneity by mastery and difficulty)","predicate":"tests_hypotheses","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 tests four hypotheses: AI tutoring increases metacognitive regulation (H1) and behavioral engagement (H2), improves near transfer more consistently than far transfer (H3), and varies by prior mastery and task difficulty (H4)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",16287,21531]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"29bdec08da424caa346111ef6eb2b514fbda237443ef6438c584fcb80e931241","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["c32eaec769bc493beb52e61fd67c5affe61cd72387da489fff3262dd22f67bbe","1d43f0a7d4593517bd038b2b85dcb0b4f5512564abbaeb2d495977940dd62a93","8a5cafcc939094b133b0bf48166b930b93996a41183c63fc6cfe4f9b474a6d93"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"ec62b779a2f78d86f51a627130acfbfdffa18a7519d6fb9ab667f33d1a334d8a","submission_id":"TR8-0cb4c90b7149418a#2"},"hash":"44d680004154f625e81a4d257efe68da48b892857a5707098acd90695e20c556","header":{"body_hash":"800760e0952a23529f378261407060043e418d0bea3002c46a34f48826198e1c","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"879f97ab8b889e29f734118d897e0069958e8034efddc876b58937644d206bde","records_root":"ebe6f406a7454ea024e0be52beef5bc70c741685b3e0ebc9e330ab02a75e266a","seq":40,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"432dd4f5130c28048f01a7d2e1749342a2a3e9a07a2ef20652e5a36707a41d76","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":2,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":5,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:PMC13226197.txt#3"},"sync_step":3,"task_id":"TR8-0cb4c90b7149418a"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:PMC13226197.txt#3","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"29bdec08da424caa346111ef6eb2b514fbda237443ef6438c584fcb80e931241","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"3f518c4ab8e363f14b77b97a7ae8e68e19744efaf1ce04e7a9cea7ec30dd672c","submission_id":"TR8-0cb4c90b7149418a#done3"},"hash":"a8311e8154f0f3aeb4e029a52ea036b73695c0fab76fcfbbe8c8ffd1c040df7f","header":{"body_hash":"37866a5001ad45f30a6854c95a1ea1b5a95d61cf37b4969fc13bfb1513017876","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"44d680004154f625e81a4d257efe68da48b892857a5707098acd90695e20c556","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":41,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"7185f471fad893bcdaee77935446e54b0da9eb80f225359ddecf783e0a072d78","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":2,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":115},"started_unix_ms":1795101906526,"wave":{"doc:PMC13226197.txt#3":"reader-2","doc:PMC13226197.txt#4":"reader-3","doc:PMC13226197.txt#5":"reader-1"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"29bdec08da424caa346111ef6eb2b514fbda237443ef6438c584fcb80e931241","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"d299e97fd9f0e8ca7e92dc833c41e1f2a6c5543165cf98ccee9e1b13f19486c1","submission_id":"circle:12f6b14e9e9a5c2448963b2dc4e6ca20c85a63453e15c8703d1ba35be42a4a54"},"hash":"204518cefce8d93a4a3ee378ce0d493bd0dd16d94dcd0c99c76a6b561cbb5d61","header":{"body_hash":"e717cbe00e1ab0996a3c1c60b22fe28d8e5f95282acfb21fda07319bfc971b99","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"a8311e8154f0f3aeb4e029a52ea036b73695c0fab76fcfbbe8c8ffd1c040df7f","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":42,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"15fe59a4e03885a427a0b1e2bb58dfaf54290450d8ee59144af3c3b1e9c1d51b","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"7185f471fad893bcdaee77935446e54b0da9eb80f225359ddecf783e0a072d78","engine_root":"29bdec08da424caa346111ef6eb2b514fbda237443ef6438c584fcb80e931241","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"be682ed2e8adf3dc29127e2b4ad403fe1f537070ab73b249ce8ba07ccb38e675","log_size":43,"projections":{"dependencies":"eaad86d2e136e8ef5971c0335d157b2fa9de8076fd8471f91d64576f6db5a6a1","status":"b6afa8f5eb2534a228e329efb72bccbf41a8849dc3c98b30f784227f9a609f82"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"204518cefce8d93a4a3ee378ce0d493bd0dd16d94dcd0c99c76a6b561cbb5d61"}},"engine_root":"29bdec08da424caa346111ef6eb2b514fbda237443ef6438c584fcb80e931241","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"7185f471fad893bcdaee77935446e54b0da9eb80f225359ddecf783e0a072d78","engine_root":"29bdec08da424caa346111ef6eb2b514fbda237443ef6438c584fcb80e931241","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"be682ed2e8adf3dc29127e2b4ad403fe1f537070ab73b249ce8ba07ccb38e675","log_size":43,"projections":{"dependencies":"eaad86d2e136e8ef5971c0335d157b2fa9de8076fd8471f91d64576f6db5a6a1","status":"b6afa8f5eb2534a228e329efb72bccbf41a8849dc3c98b30f784227f9a609f82"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"204518cefce8d93a4a3ee378ce0d493bd0dd16d94dcd0c99c76a6b561cbb5d61"},"seal_hash":"72b5b774698907ce88b1eb69ce7697cb068359b1667e04b4bc08eadf8b51ff3d"}},"request_hash":"c527724f26d9b738fbc86e88e26ba596ecafcfad2d04d9c3ed0ff8bc3620bdfe","submission_id":"seal-43"},"hash":"d40e7305b40e8766b8ab1372e897c1629593f4581ca38ae2d43beab0686aec68","header":{"body_hash":"c58160bf2b7b101664a81ccfb014b10b99375854222594b01dbe789cbb3c74c3","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"204518cefce8d93a4a3ee378ce0d493bd0dd16d94dcd0c99c76a6b561cbb5d61","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":43,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"382edf2ee8ebe9fcc3dce06fa4a954067b0861580bf53a3fa5db52d9149fe048","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"epoch":4,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795101906526},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"29bdec08da424caa346111ef6eb2b514fbda237443ef6438c584fcb80e931241","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"32cb3966b2dba9e6804f117a611fff23b77b52e8382ef97a2e6abcf4dcec311d","submission_id":"ring-members:919f1ab496c13ce1f72d62b259d158bfe8bd0a67a19a8bbc5a3c13dee603f754"},"hash":"8544fbe45a0b2dd34f5bfc920e09d57d0f3b1e63e5a13641e9977f898a22c905","header":{"body_hash":"b7defa130df5010c71f1f2dc658500969bacb3720680dfbce1af395a54511bd5","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"d40e7305b40e8766b8ab1372e897c1629593f4581ca38ae2d43beab0686aec68","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":44,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"c6e01781a5a89b5ca4f698444f5eb38bb836aa079a52e6f843ef47c6614f5630","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":3,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":115},"started_unix_ms":1795101906541,"wave":{"doc:PMC13226197.txt#6":"reader-3","doc:PMC13226197.txt#7":"reader-1","doc:PMC13226197.txt#8":"reader-2"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"29bdec08da424caa346111ef6eb2b514fbda237443ef6438c584fcb80e931241","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"0ef85ff019467584c42777de5bad92ca9a11dc373f35c4246b44f172b9fef11b","submission_id":"circle:ca868cf9caa4196110bca646bd6aa59c477c29bab693c2caaa6bb554f7e54d4c"},"hash":"690d012fc1c4927bf9c7a5fc8d443db5eee73909fa129e392ea2a5784f89b8a5","header":{"body_hash":"ae9fd9421e4f0cde628d73035fc317e67525a94e9d6d89d85cb731334913603d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"8544fbe45a0b2dd34f5bfc920e09d57d0f3b1e63e5a13641e9977f898a22c905","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":45,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"5081df6b85f5d53650eae198b3d744732b73368c7edd311ab6e7bba4cbc3aa8e","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"c6e01781a5a89b5ca4f698444f5eb38bb836aa079a52e6f843ef47c6614f5630","engine_root":"29bdec08da424caa346111ef6eb2b514fbda237443ef6438c584fcb80e931241","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"419a801d87e611647a818762da5cd3b5d9766eb419e1730d7415491b2b628563","log_size":46,"projections":{"dependencies":"eaad86d2e136e8ef5971c0335d157b2fa9de8076fd8471f91d64576f6db5a6a1","status":"b6afa8f5eb2534a228e329efb72bccbf41a8849dc3c98b30f784227f9a609f82"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"690d012fc1c4927bf9c7a5fc8d443db5eee73909fa129e392ea2a5784f89b8a5"}},"engine_root":"29bdec08da424caa346111ef6eb2b514fbda237443ef6438c584fcb80e931241","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"c6e01781a5a89b5ca4f698444f5eb38bb836aa079a52e6f843ef47c6614f5630","engine_root":"29bdec08da424caa346111ef6eb2b514fbda237443ef6438c584fcb80e931241","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"419a801d87e611647a818762da5cd3b5d9766eb419e1730d7415491b2b628563","log_size":46,"projections":{"dependencies":"eaad86d2e136e8ef5971c0335d157b2fa9de8076fd8471f91d64576f6db5a6a1","status":"b6afa8f5eb2534a228e329efb72bccbf41a8849dc3c98b30f784227f9a609f82"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"690d012fc1c4927bf9c7a5fc8d443db5eee73909fa129e392ea2a5784f89b8a5"},"seal_hash":"da3ce50b040e02705247affb1f777f307bce50e4b1f51b7dc51c3becb3c2d21c"}},"request_hash":"a9d7d32d297bc6208472df363c9221501817a0ebd6407d0b3fcd157585e8ac09","submission_id":"seal-46"},"hash":"7ee5e99a4dc1bf689dde56146a089fb9d298e4eb2827570c375e895811da2e83","header":{"body_hash":"30a7e7cf54f8b2111d91a12fe3d9dd0e08d8eee21e67d0f35a91c9c7f3ea6586","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"690d012fc1c4927bf9c7a5fc8d443db5eee73909fa129e392ea2a5784f89b8a5","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":46,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"ddbe86cdf1d788a88c1cd871ca99bf6c3adcbcfddc983c5710092558f085a36d","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"epoch":5,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795101906541},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"29bdec08da424caa346111ef6eb2b514fbda237443ef6438c584fcb80e931241","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"cb13225f0efedfb6c909ada968b63fdebb101692f610525b4abbd3e7f4776085","submission_id":"ring-members:3dff5ccc041086b27b1f9b2d2035597260de330d0e39701a98fee421c223d1d2"},"hash":"ac468f0ca9df57c2951f8b2f9f95cb574ff8c0bb2e5020c6fc9d853035986f36","header":{"body_hash":"0562b5c80653fdf6b4a5362ff9322f954158ff75e1d0f01e7275fadddbf7750c","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"7ee5e99a4dc1bf689dde56146a089fb9d298e4eb2827570c375e895811da2e83","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":47,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"63f1024cf7e080a3b8a47671447bcdc3c703ce069178de3760c1be057aa494ee","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"T12-9d3c84772a715a8a","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"A set of robustness checks is performed to assess the stability of findings. These include alternative exposure windows and proxy measures of AI support, metacognition, and engagement.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t12_o1","terms":["robustness checks","alternative exposure windows","proxy measures"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Table 2 recorded cohort size, coverage of observations, number of events, session structure, concentration of activities, and prevalence of AI support at the learner, session, and event levels.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t12_o2","terms":["Table 2","cohort profile","AI support prevalence"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Cohort size | Learners | Learner | 52,418\n\nSessions | Session | 1,184,906\n\nEvents | Event | 38,762,114","kind":"observe","local_id":"t12_o3","terms":["cohort size","52,418 learners","1,184,906 sessions","38,762,114 events"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Content coverage | Unique items | Item | 12,947\n\nUnique skills | Skill | 189\n\nObservation window | Start date to end date | Dataset | 2018-01-01 to 2019-12-31","kind":"observe","local_id":"t12_o4","terms":["content coverage","12,947 items","189 skills","observation window 2018-2019"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Exposure prevalence | Any AI support exposure | Learner | 64.1%\n\nExposed sessions / all sessions | Session | 18.7%\n\nExposed events / all events | Event | 6.9%","kind":"observe","local_id":"t12_o5","terms":["AI support exposure prevalence","64.1% learners","18.7% sessions","6.9% events"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Baseline episode differences | Session duration, median (exposed vs. unexposed) | Session | 18.6 vs. 13.4 min\n\nEvents per session, median (exposed vs. unexposed) | Session | 34 vs. 24","kind":"observe","local_id":"t12_o6","terms":["baseline episode differences","exposed vs unexposed session duration and events"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Error rate, mean (exposed vs. unexposed) | Event | 0.41 vs. 0.28\n\nReturn within 24 h, rate (exposed vs. unexposed) | Learner day | 0.36 vs. 0.29","kind":"observe","local_id":"t12_o7","terms":["baseline error rate","24h return rate","exposed vs unexposed"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Table 2 also compares baseline features of exposed and unexposed episodes and illustrates that exposure is more likely to occur during more demanding learning moments","kind":"observe","local_id":"t12_o8","terms":["AI exposure during demanding learning moments","baseline differences"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Table 3 presents findings of monitoring and control outcomes. Proxies monitoring reveals systematic growth after exposure, which occurs more frequently in checking and error-correcting behaviors","kind":"observe","local_id":"t12_o9","terms":["Table 3","metacognitive monitoring growth","checking and error-correcting"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"There is also greater growth in control proxies, as there are more opportunities to help seek, revisit previous items, and revisit switching strategies, indicating greater regulation of reliance.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t12_o10","terms":["metacognitive control growth","help seeking","revisiting","switching strategies"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Outcome family | Outcome (proxy) | Unit | Coef. (β) | 95% CI | Std. effect | N (obs) | Learners | Controls","kind":"observe","local_id":"t12_o11","terms":["Table 3 header","fixed effects model columns"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Monitoring | Checking after the attempt | Session | 0.047 | [0.039, 0.055] | 0.21 | 1,184,906 | 52,418 | Learner FE, week FE, item difficulty","kind":"observe","local_id":"t12_o12","terms":["checking after attempt effect","beta 0.047","std effect 0.21"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Monitoring | Error correction (wrong → correct) | Session | 0.032 | [0.025, 0.039] | 0.17 | 1,184,906 | 52,418 | Same","kind":"observe","local_id":"t12_o13","terms":["error correction effect","beta 0.032","std effect 0.17"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Monitoring | Recheck after feedback | Session | 0.028 | [0.021, 0.036] | 0.14 | 1,184,906 | 52,418 | Same","kind":"observe","local_id":"t12_o14","terms":["recheck after feedback effect","beta 0.028","std effect 0.14"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t12_o2","t12_o3","t12_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t12_c1","object":"52,418 learners, 1,184,906 sessions, 38,762,114 events across 12,947 items and 189 skills (2018-2019)","predicate":"uses_cohort_data","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 analyzes an anonymized secondary log cohort of 52,418 learners, 1,184,906 sessions, and 38,762,114 events across 12,947 unique items and 189 skills from 2018-01-01 to 2019-12-31."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t12_o5","t12_o6","t12_o7","t12_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t12_c2","object":"AI exposure in 64.1% learners, 18.7% sessions, 6.9% events; higher baseline error rate (0.41 vs 0.28) and duration (18.6 vs 13.4 min)","predicate":"reports_exposure_prevalence_and_baseline","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In PMC13226197, AI support exposure occurs in 64.1% of learners, 18.7% of sessions, and 6.9% of events, and occurs during more demanding episodes (mean error rate 0.41 vs. 0.28; median duration 18.6 vs. 13.4 min)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t12_o9","t12_o11","t12_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t12_c3","object":"Checking after the attempt: β = 0.047, 95% CI [0.039, 0.055], std. effect = 0.21","predicate":"concludes_effect_on_monitoring","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds via fixed-effects estimation (controlling for learner FE, week FE, and item difficulty) that AI tutoring exposure increases checking after an attempt (β = 0.047, 95% CI [0.039, 0.055], std. effect = 0.21)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t12_o9","t12_o11","t12_o13"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t12_c4","object":"Error correction (wrong to correct): β = 0.032, 95% CI [0.025, 0.039], std. effect = 0.17","predicate":"concludes_effect_on_monitoring","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds via fixed-effects estimation that AI tutoring exposure increases error correction (wrong to correct) (β = 0.032, 95% CI [0.025, 0.039], std. effect = 0.17)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t12_o9","t12_o11","t12_o14"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t12_c5","object":"Recheck after feedback: β = 0.028, 95% CI [0.021, 0.036], std. effect = 0.14","predicate":"concludes_effect_on_monitoring","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds via fixed-effects estimation that AI tutoring exposure increases rechecking after feedback (β = 0.028, 95% CI [0.021, 0.036], std. effect = 0.14)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t12_o9","t12_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t12_c6","object":"growth in help seeking, revisiting previous items, and revisiting switching strategies","predicate":"concludes_effect_on_control","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 reports growth in metacognitive control proxies after AI tutoring exposure, including help seeking, revisiting previous items, and revisiting switching strategies."},{"about":["PMC13226197"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t12_q1","needed":"Read the continuation of Table 3 and subsequent results sections in PMC13226197.txt after byte 44417.","text":"What are the exact fixed-effects regression estimates (β, 95% CI, standardized effect) for the metacognitive control proxies in Table 3 and for engagement and knowledge transfer outcomes in subsequent tables?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",38519,44417]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"73dc12e92f3e0fa61104a3493458b9e329a98634092cbc6b3ef96d662c99f853","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["30af026353e90ced786bb40dbad92e1f5d092f59d743d574fd96f5b63596c7ef","899e24ab006673ddef0f42e8bb0fc8a4b2389108bf3ceb79e1f308ef317540c5","a6883e44d6c5ddb00fcaabae58a13032d61be4315fcad37f4f90456377bbd4c1","1e9fdcd363cdf4c938152882e13fdef4e2f0630315d513ccb58e0ee146cbca87","7cdf092fbf27e31a05b9626e7cc09501fa6416143942b15619efb8cdc028ff78","aeeb7aa15bdddd66843e0f37ffdad5209d9e1907dee01d9de26dfaf0d69671c4","6b51e32c8522272a2f64797593d53e0aa13c282d34b13b722587ad6cec63fd54","58750329305e23891e64192ce5736f3fa47cde912c038e0eaca2dc0157a3175c","65f6d9d23a35e6eac6b13cc78f10a47f04ccb80aba5f1029ca7ecdbe0f8c6785","700ae7f028c1a74549e6b94b0dc6a5aca38934c2a46acde03c54c71391c54b22","ffd89af109e0eef154365e6b5df997fbd5241388f5c82bfc883f93c697dd9926","bf055b5f673c3f3b1da9a1d6baa56d4640d40a0bf9ac9ebc77a6b6c1e8b4aaf5","39c73d811917f07d3b637b2fcea4a57cb37b59627643d91c4be155c6e485f653","022983dbf293f383575ad337f5d90b42f48a2e807897d776a8de992500d28e39","f1789f24357eeaa896c0a976cd1e577fa3d437b5f13ef922a97f32c46b9d5186","3afef35d1b7b3853c8b552122b747b50b806eceb801f8e0b6fd0d15a39bb725e","a4b64a6badde1d2f8ad4f1dfa9acdc69cb99a1d503f489a71951529c47c12db9","e68c0b845eaa5db361a4e7a58f7dfc26b316870b0c5a5da9b2e34d00f0661204","3ba20fa867ddd9340087b3273c88895392eae955c92d152187bad9314731d153","5ddf848626d9510b690bd43251f7b9f6e394b2d3a3bba423d20b3203edc95062","1ba47624024fb722b86e25f3680069cc5730e9eab79ee99e8978bcc0da8f626d"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"6800a3922cd0c06660e831499e1db9b089a5b5d0db580020d4882385c5db7c9e","submission_id":"T12-9d3c84772a715a8a#1"},"hash":"4df3e2421a09c9e563322e7f743d95d0bb9694609db3688c507fcd924359378e","header":{"body_hash":"9317c0df33428242fe12bcf5f6b93a2857cb2faeab38248629c7b3d7e476de3a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ac468f0ca9df57c2951f8b2f9f95cb574ff8c0bb2e5020c6fc9d853035986f36","records_root":"893ecfe556e0b3e9318fa489d6e56eb1b1ae9bb2d904ca8a567d31d23fd9bac5","seq":48,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"46d1d3a1c0e505b76893a92254c5a97bc948a9bb5435aa378f7ad798222e0931","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":3,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":5,"task_id":"T12-9d3c84772a715a8a"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13226197.txt#7","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"73dc12e92f3e0fa61104a3493458b9e329a98634092cbc6b3ef96d662c99f853","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"809b42e9f7d189f1e00872057bfdbc5e7a7d4258ee638f4467ed000984af3fe6","submission_id":"T12-9d3c84772a715a8a#done2"},"hash":"541b7283d703d4a88b6bfbeab2b998efe3fc580564ba9578c688d41ab7ff6d07","header":{"body_hash":"b83343824fdadc39f94bd732a14ff71afcabf08451f5a14d256282ffd3231d04","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"4df3e2421a09c9e563322e7f743d95d0bb9694609db3688c507fcd924359378e","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":49,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"d377ca151eae9a17502359eab5a72e532ab1dcdd5559b84f78e795aed73da5d5","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"T9-8b84b7bee6c589d7","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Ref. | Identification/study design | Metacognition | Engagement | Near transfer | Far transfer | Data type | Context","kind":"observe","local_id":"t9_o1","terms":["literature summary table header","outcome coverage columns"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Wang and Fan (2025) | Meta-analysis of prior studies | High | Moderate | — | — | Mixed | Self-regulated learning with GenAI","kind":"observe","local_id":"t9_o2","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025 table row","meta-analysis of prior studies","High metacognition","Moderate engagement","Self-regulated learning with GenAI"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The interaction and session levels are where proxies of metacognition are modeled, based on the definitions of the proxies used; the engagement measures are modeled at the session and day levels;","kind":"observe","local_id":"t9_o3","terms":["metacognition modeled at interaction and session levels","engagement modeled at session and day levels"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"and the results of transfers are modeled at the item level within skills and between skill-transition levels.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t9_o4","terms":["transfer modeled at item level within skills and between skill transitions"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Estimations for all models are performed using ordinary least squares with cluster-robust standard errors clustered at the learner level.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t9_o5","terms":["ordinary least squares","cluster-robust standard errors","learner-level clustering"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Because the study tests several outcomes across three construct families, we control the family-wise risk of false discoveries through multiple-testing adjustments","kind":"observe","local_id":"t9_o6","terms":["family-wise false discovery control","multiple-testing adjustments"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"where Yi,t+Δ outcome, measured at lag Δ after the exposure window; αi is a learner fixed effect that incorporates all non-time-related individual attributes;","kind":"observe","local_id":"t9_o7","terms":["lagged outcome","learner fixed effect"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"γw(t) is a week fixed effect that incorporates secular time effects shared by all learners; Ait∈{0,1} is a binary indicator of AI support exposure during the episode;","kind":"observe","local_id":"t9_o8","terms":["week fixed effect","binary AI support exposure indicator"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Xit is a vector of time-varying controls, such as item difficulty, prior error rate in the session, and session-level activity baseline; and εit is an idiosyncratic error term.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t9_o9","terms":["time-varying controls","item difficulty","prior error rate","session-level activity baseline"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t9_o1","t9_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t9_c1","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (Meta-analysis of prior studies; Metacognition: High; Engagement: Moderate; Near/Far transfer: —; Data: Mixed; Context: Self-regulated learning with GenAI)","predicate":"tabulates_citation_of","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In a comparison table row, PMC13226197 lists Wang and Fan 2025 as a meta-analysis of prior studies with mixed data in self-regulated learning with GenAI, rating metacognition High, engagement Moderate, and near/far transfer unaddressed."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t9_o3","t9_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t9_c2","object":"metacognition at interaction/session levels, engagement at session/day levels, transfer at item/skill-transition levels","predicate":"models_outcomes_at_levels","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 models metacognition proxies at the interaction and session levels, engagement measures at the session and day levels, and knowledge transfer at the item level within skills and across skill transitions."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t9_o5","t9_o6","t9_o7","t9_o8","t9_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t9_c3","object":"OLS with learner-clustered standard errors, multiple-testing adjustments, learner/week fixed effects, and time-varying controls","predicate":"uses_statistical_estimation","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 estimates all outcome models via ordinary least squares with learner-clustered robust standard errors, multiple-testing adjustments, learner and week fixed effects, and time-varying session controls."},{"about":["PMC13226197","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t9_q1","needed":"The Title line quote from the Wang and Fan 2025 record file and the corresponding reference entry in PMC13226197.txt.","text":"Link the Wang and Fan (2025) table row in PMC13226197 to the Title line quote ('Title: The effect of ChatGPT...') from the Wang and Fan 2025 meta-analysis record file and verify the reference list entry in PMC13226197."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",32757,38519]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"b9ffdfd81bf91db690fa2822288a2c695110301c5a82ae076abae1d09a6a7606","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["e8912985e6037b252a7a37444123107c88302dfcbe0a041d990bf49ea8f7de75","04588ef5a34c56f45b9b03fffb833e4377f0c87c5d6a96285ccaafbb43c64c4b","4fae7ef4b2e094b942d16db90ccd657deaa13f76ae9e88ce82edb4af4f452f37","aeabbfaee50b913fc44c0b4dff0f1e79c1ebe3174603037973cb857f9b78d525","bc43b63b23137689ab32db3d882821cfbc362e26cb5c82c68132336be4fad399","13cc6d0d35d6bb7c95df73080bb4bb89042450ddc17d97ba58941d2cc3453e58","6cedcd0c01a5517c1dccec9d30f31f169540d831fce597defcec7eba8fb9a54e","ec2b9d5d3e4494efb0a93ee9610467bcc13b6ef90394dc8c027974ab22367c4c","60b490bb551407cbdaed723db3b881299a2a136ef6d073a56a4e5b2d5010de3d","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","ef50e4413ffe99989a3a164d9fc9a3d23d7e8c5c176d20ed5667e1722bf1333c","02fdc172f2fd8fa816ca2552202109b93564d4485732ce73e1541a50a02c2bf5","c693ed71ab58dc99d5a52ff02f3247b86396ab747e6ab87ef77514fb6a1b630e"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"4bd0b14d7722f3838041dd4772b80bc4031e84dd8a480649db0862e88653b3d2","submission_id":"T9-8b84b7bee6c589d7#1"},"hash":"3b939c3ed6efc4c8c6f661f4bb21b4f56ef86d49c9717ebdd17b74a2d3b9b97c","header":{"body_hash":"749999b57fcd94f567a2ca9253f440fed80261c426caff8d3eaf1af8a4f47812","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"541b7283d703d4a88b6bfbeab2b998efe3fc580564ba9578c688d41ab7ff6d07","records_root":"43c3142a025645d6237644b912f5a467b0ca37c49478d635754623901bcf7b6e","seq":50,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"18b4c15fc9deb5bd28576b4e1837946ae4e567537d99a27358ed681660d5ffdb","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":3,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":5,"task_id":"T9-8b84b7bee6c589d7"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13226197.txt#6","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"b9ffdfd81bf91db690fa2822288a2c695110301c5a82ae076abae1d09a6a7606","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"89eaaa769ab12887e303e22de18b5582205b5b8d3a8cd0c577f3db97ec66bcc4","submission_id":"T9-8b84b7bee6c589d7#done2"},"hash":"bfda28f999050a09d415c417ec1b8a4b0afc8dde985190f5f0e8e1f65536c0ee","header":{"body_hash":"ae8b092c2e531119c307a954aa6d6c6f556f4f5ff065e7b2b6a0cb640685c21c","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3b939c3ed6efc4c8c6f661f4bb21b4f56ef86d49c9717ebdd17b74a2d3b9b97c","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":51,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"77fe796201e96bdc7a04533a0b457acbe789f7704df0ffa17234b00258fb69c0","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"T11-ec35a7ee53721035","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Control | Help-seeking probability | Interaction | 0.061 | [0.052, 0.070] | 0.29 | 38,762,114 | 52,418 | Same + error history","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o1","terms":["metacognitive control","help-seeking probability","effect size","sample size"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Control | Revisiting prior item | Session | 0.044 | [0.036, 0.052] | 0.20 | 1,184,906 | 52,418 | Same","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o2","terms":["metacognitive control","revisiting prior item","effect size"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Control | Strategy switching | Session | 0.036 | [0.028, 0.044] | 0.18 | 1,184,906 | 52,418 | Same","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o3","terms":["metacognitive control","strategy switching","effect size"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The event sequence rates in Figure 4c indicate that post-exposure checking and revision frequencies are higher, whereas in Figure 4d the effect size increases with exposure intensity.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o4","terms":["metacognition","checking and revision","exposure intensity"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Table 4 indicates that AI support exposure is associated with more time on task, higher activity intensity, greater persistence following errors, and higher short-term return behavior.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o5","terms":["behavioral engagement","AI support exposure","main results"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"These are the most pronounced effects that occur immediately after exposure episodes and diminish with longer horizons, as expected for short-horizon engagement responses.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o6","terms":["engagement horizon","diminishing effects"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Outcome | Unit | Coef. (β) | 95% CI | Std. effect | Adjusted p | N (obs) | Learners | Controls","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o7","terms":["engagement table header"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Time on task (log minutes) | Session | 0.083 | [0.072, 0.094] | 0.25 | <0.001 | 1,184,906 | 52,418 | Learner FE, week FE","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o8","terms":["time on task","engagement effect size"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Activity intensity | Session | 0.057 | [0.046, 0.068] | 0.22 | <0.001 | 1,184,906 | 52,418 | Same","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o9","terms":["activity intensity","engagement effect size"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Persistence after error | Interaction | 0.064 | [0.053, 0.075] | 0.27 | <0.001 | 38,762,114 | 52,418 | Same + error history","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o10","terms":["persistence after error","engagement effect size"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Return probability (next day) | Learner day | 0.031 | [0.024, 0.038] | 0.13 | <0.001 | 4,821,300 | 52,418 | Same + day FE","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o11","terms":["return probability","engagement effect size"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Spacing (shorter gap) | Learner week | −0.018 | [−0.026, −0.010] | −0.09 | 0.002 | 812,940 | 52,418 | Same","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o12","terms":["inter-session spacing","engagement effect size"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The transfer effects during topic shifts and delayed performance are also smaller but nevertheless positive and statistically significant relative to zero.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o13","terms":["knowledge transfer","topic shift","delayed performance"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The trends indicate that AI support can more reliably increase near transfer than far transfer.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o14","terms":["near transfer vs far transfer","AI support"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Transfer outcome | Definition | Unit | Coef. (β) | 95% CI | Std. effect | N (obs) | Learners","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o15","terms":["transfer table header"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Near transfer | New item, same skill | Interaction | 0.052 | [0.041, 0.063] | 0.24 | 9,842,117 | 51,006","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o16","terms":["near transfer","effect size"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Topic shift transfer | New skill cluster | Interaction | 0.021 | [0.011, 0.031] | 0.10 | 6,314,882 | 48,772","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o17","terms":["topic shift transfer","effect size"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Delayed performance | Gap ≥ 7 days | Interaction | 0.017 | [0.007, 0.027] | 0.08 | 3,102,944 | 44,985","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o18","terms":["delayed performance","7-day gap","effect size"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Near transfer (robust) | Strict novelty | Interaction | 0.046 | [0.035, 0.057] | 0.21 | 7,416,309 | 49,220","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o19","terms":["robust near transfer","strict novelty","effect size"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Delayed performance (robust) | Gap ≥ 14 days | Interaction | 0.012 | [0.003, 0.021] | 0.06 | 1,884,116 | 42,107","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o20","terms":["robust delayed performance","14-day gap","effect size"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Figure 6a demonstrates that near-transfer effects are higher in competence with higher-difficulty skills.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o21","terms":["near transfer heterogeneity","skill difficulty"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Figure 6b indicates attenuated effects when the topic shifts are larger, and Figure 6c denotes a downward trend in the effects as the inactivity gap increases.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t11_o22","terms":["transfer attenuation","topic shift size","inactivity gap"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t11_o1","t11_o2","t11_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t11_c1","object":"help-seeking (std. 0.29), item revisiting (std. 0.20), and strategy switching (std. 0.18) across 52,418 learners","predicate":"reports_metacognitive_control_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds positive effects on metacognitive control across 52,418 learners: help-seeking (β=0.061, std. effect=0.29, N=38,762,114), item revisiting (β=0.044, std. effect=0.20), and strategy switching (β=0.036, std. effect=0.18)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t11_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t11_c2","object":"higher post-exposure checking/revision frequencies and larger effect sizes at higher exposure intensity","predicate":"concludes_dose_response","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 reports higher post-exposure checking and revision frequencies, with metacognitive effect sizes increasing with AI support exposure intensity."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t11_o5","t11_o7","t11_o8","t11_o9","t11_o10","t11_o11","t11_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t11_c3","object":"positive effects on time on task, activity intensity, error persistence, and next-day return; shorter inter-session gaps","predicate":"reports_engagement_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds AI support exposure increases time on task (β=0.083, std. 0.25), activity intensity (β=0.057, std. 0.22), persistence after error (β=0.064, std. 0.27), and next-day return (β=0.031, std. 0.13), while reducing gap spacing (β=-0.018)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t11_o5","t11_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t11_c4","object":"engagement effects peak immediately after exposure and diminish over longer horizons","predicate":"qualifies_engagement_findings","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 qualifies its behavioral engagement findings by noting that effects are most pronounced immediately after AI exposure episodes and diminish over longer time horizons."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t11_o13","t11_o14","t11_o15","t11_o16","t11_o17","t11_o18","t11_o19","t11_o20"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t11_c5","object":"stronger effects on near transfer (std. 0.21-0.24) than topic-shift (std. 0.10) or delayed transfer (std. 0.06-0.08)","predicate":"reports_transfer_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 concludes that AI support increases near transfer (β=0.052, std. 0.24; robust strict-novelty β=0.046, std. 0.21) more reliably than topic-shift transfer (β=0.021, std. 0.10) or delayed performance (≥7d β=0.017; ≥14d β=0.012)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t11_o21","t11_o22"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t11_c6","object":"higher near transfer in harder skills; attenuated transfer across larger topic shifts and longer inactivity gaps","predicate":"qualifies_transfer_heterogeneity","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds heterogeneity in knowledge transfer: near-transfer effects are larger for higher-difficulty skills, whereas transfer effects attenuate with larger topic shifts and longer inactivity gaps."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",44417,49050]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"c51013c277c9257f46a0636d0779c3fb7d03774b3577ab785dfdfbbabc6b6509","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["d9942b6ec2202dcad6a2ebd1be1445788aea03f11507dc6fced330d4c7c0f72f","a4ca2e8e0026bb63c81b8231bcce318d93707b7e24d41b9600c05ab78a04c7df","8766717d2c8b973cf531ac8f91de0628995cb588ddcc2c24d858cc26a9a0ec14","027b6c6b98ea140fd90dbe47965c1c5e3607acf9b88b9b8ca71e199cadc880f0","61b159c942403a2cef22c9b202eaf7bfcabf68865d990572c42589ddbe8e4721","946dd1f881fec4639908fa126c0c59684529dd171839d6695584438ff4a4b2ef","f21a9cf8f6b06c408f9a0f3223f9b452079ff600d2d3f908bd6558e0b4808d94","d5b9e0fddf50f3bb2ab292537442751261b1f39be26bdd5b3a7dc11e2e8f2f28","6065e0387ad559d973545f9c16eee3d63cac7e8ec9f05fb7a4d305c2d0969b80","827ef4c740d2a34dc463aef806968dffb23cbf18cabf3af4c2d2900566a84b79","0c9764254487863e0147eff0942074b608d38da3d393c67ee2ade0b1e1b9ac94","0b5c6a6ce91ae28e1a76d289154073dafb020d998ffd815085f9185f78a69045","31f90ab6168890b5e6b072698a467dbd2f52b32ca81de58b1da2bda63c80dd14","768d56f8e3e7bdb601817047676a443fdb8ddc3207dbc7795f8bd6e3f7404a55","c01ec4f084d8134618f4f893aad4cb09479a7e74eb4b48a1fe4a3a5b543aabe3","e11822a9ef039dbfb0eeeb52bc8c7b331ac45faefb5db6b27323415d70f69ded","4e0ea1f174a7665f71af23bab607e0255b615e8672971621528f2f96c32e97ad","eec9864b3c66e088195b0c15d4fc97fb1590b4cc344e9c076c72a2dca35be6f4","1f36623a27bdd86bcf576097e61c6b94bddfea72749227bcc5a324dfd428aa2d","423885eff16cac703aac02b7c0dcf6ef480abcace42567600bc8fa335bfb876a","c06ecb7e9f70d2bfdfb49935458f5c8cbce4a215a195dfe0f686b63da0fb5ca0","2e810491cba1d524955280a993570b5fbcb38f64c76d33c93e3f5f0af72a5465","85ac4e4d8b14045fb8f899743fbd784f28bbfff84a1cb60a7eb1a9304705daef","abe8df605d6ddcbd2ae2915269869072be6711598b0b316bb8bb34f5765bccc1"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":24}},"request_hash":"70fc78ba7878ee296526d481c3da07a34b9a07968396d82ba5a3f1efdb55ebe5","submission_id":"T11-ec35a7ee53721035#1"},"hash":"6fad9de135d02d93cf2e6b27ae6b7e9ced2a7dd5fd8de5db1f2a1962bc7997be","header":{"body_hash":"774aa56c2eb494eed3dfd1dd4a4bfee953c97fe5f2bf13d0a7296fa8b111868d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"bfda28f999050a09d415c417ec1b8a4b0afc8dde985190f5f0e8e1f65536c0ee","records_root":"27bf63c890a50ee1486e6ccd6870d13ecfc05bbb8fb9f212466aa40d478b8ad7","seq":52,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"c1085e68d30cd3abbd983b894f2bef4b7c24cefb3a890022d2e2bc21a43a0025","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"T11-ec35a7ee53721035","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t11_o5","t11_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t11_c4","object":"engagement effects peak immediately after exposure and diminish over longer horizons","predicate":"qualifies_engagement_findings","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 qualifies its behavioral engagement findings by noting that effects are most pronounced immediately after AI exposure episodes and diminish over longer time horizons."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t11_o13","t11_o14","t11_o15","t11_o16","t11_o17","t11_o18","t11_o19","t11_o20"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t11_c5","object":"stronger effects on near transfer (std. 0.21-0.24) than topic-shift (std. 0.10) or delayed transfer (std. 0.06-0.08)","predicate":"reports_transfer_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 concludes that AI support increases near transfer (β=0.052, std. 0.24; robust strict-novelty β=0.046, std. 0.21) more reliably than topic-shift transfer (β=0.021, std. 0.10) or delayed performance (≥7d β=0.017; ≥14d β=0.012)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t11_o21","t11_o22"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t11_c6","object":"higher near transfer in harder skills; attenuated transfer across larger topic shifts and longer inactivity gaps","predicate":"qualifies_transfer_heterogeneity","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds heterogeneity in knowledge transfer: near-transfer effects are larger for higher-difficulty skills, whereas transfer effects attenuate with larger topic shifts and longer inactivity gaps."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",44417,49050]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"c51013c277c9257f46a0636d0779c3fb7d03774b3577ab785dfdfbbabc6b6509","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["4bc97089853cf7bf16147c6fb789e5441ad21c87aa5b5309f74de79df00062d7","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","70d227d4917051bfe68acafe001667f1f7c2cb14c5a1659fd30f705734cf5df6"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"b99d9d63799ee33d6fdfaa5d2c162b4fc20aa9134a9a8a875a52fda55c505db0","submission_id":"T11-ec35a7ee53721035#1.1"},"hash":"3fc7f7301f66a1569e1bccf8dc94e9581f393f4f3933324f6e1eba9aafeaae6b","header":{"body_hash":"1ca9d9bebe0f0206c2ecfa01c0048b7e2726ad85520b6086c6a3af4e599ae781","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"6fad9de135d02d93cf2e6b27ae6b7e9ced2a7dd5fd8de5db1f2a1962bc7997be","records_root":"6885ee82d11b907c2390c2fd35330fcefe1975f5bd06d24141bd7ae2db2fe6d5","seq":53,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"2313b2c656a4a60957660270be6e86aaa83fef37f6fc6ef35804278a0324bee1","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@d9942b6ec2202dca","@a4ca2e8e0026bb63","@8766717d2c8b973c","@027b6c6b98ea140f","@61b159c942403a2c","@946dd1f881fec463","@f21a9cf8f6b06c40","@d5b9e0fddf50f3bb","@6065e0387ad559d9","@827ef4c740d2a34d","@0c9764254487863e","@0b5c6a6ce91ae28e","@31f90ab6168890b5","@768d56f8e3e7bdb6","@c01ec4f084d81346","@e11822a9ef039dbf","@4e0ea1f174a7665f","@eec9864b3c66e088","@1f36623a27bdd86b","@423885eff16cac70","@c06ecb7e9f70d2bf","@2e810491cba1d524","@85ac4e4d8b14045f","@abe8df605d6ddcbd","@4bc97089853cf7bf","@e3af97ee9279b79e","@70d227d4917051bf"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":24,"local_id":"t11_c3"}],"task_id":"T11-ec35a7ee53721035","work_key":"doc:PMC13226197.txt#8"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T11-ec35a7ee53721035:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"c51013c277c9257f46a0636d0779c3fb7d03774b3577ab785dfdfbbabc6b6509","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"47df5f47bf30e10ffa9eea683ca037353cd4ccc3054e4701f4b7c12b76621dd0","submission_id":"T11-ec35a7ee53721035#repair1"},"hash":"e0953f4def90b65f59dd3b137accb830ced6f560af9cd90c43776847cdf18c9c","header":{"body_hash":"c1ccd2cee306e049178cf02667fd09699c31496349a882df2047f759705e3119","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3fc7f7301f66a1569e1bccf8dc94e9581f393f4f3933324f6e1eba9aafeaae6b","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":54,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"5f70aa886675b0df1d538ef0fe95a1ea560186b8de97a8ad9aa615ba76c3fb35","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"T11-ec35a7ee53721035","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t11_o5","t11_o7","t11_o8","t11_o9","t11_o10","t11_o11","t11_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t11_c3","object":"positive effects on time on task, activity intensity, error persistence, and next-day return; shorter inter-session gaps","predicate":"reports_engagement_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds AI exposure increases time on task (β=0.083, std. 0.25), activity intensity (β=0.057, std. 0.22), error persistence (β=0.064, std. 0.27), and next-day return (β=0.031, std. 0.13), while reducing gap spacing (β=-0.018)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",44417,49050]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"c51013c277c9257f46a0636d0779c3fb7d03774b3577ab785dfdfbbabc6b6509","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["54a32b30c86854ede205b158c3c29ccdcaca5b7e4257a77a6bc9ebb27417bb56"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"234a4ab41d71d83c135f4534abd454c6f1263f9e071e500ceee3477d509f9b06","submission_id":"T11-ec35a7ee53721035#2"},"hash":"4c09eafa2ac1596e793f86dac0ebe2dd2ab7c73c998394b8122a4a8d04dcc2d5","header":{"body_hash":"e32055d3f320950bfb24bcc893ed3e620ad457538ea6e2c71f9be3a381c36042","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"e0953f4def90b65f59dd3b137accb830ced6f560af9cd90c43776847cdf18c9c","records_root":"4345036fc9599b7b317bfc59a5073525f80c7218ae6be75be9dd18564a889222","seq":55,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"5403c083404230c12aa6fa637def1fcfdf33b72177064ff10e57681592ba0600","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":false,"agent":"reader-2","circle":3,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":28,"refusals":1,"stored":28,"sync_step":5,"task_id":"T11-ec35a7ee53721035"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13226197.txt#8","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"c51013c277c9257f46a0636d0779c3fb7d03774b3577ab785dfdfbbabc6b6509","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"dfdf293381a83e631342151b28f748fce227e7fa7b08ff18e068e30b5a4fdedd","submission_id":"T11-ec35a7ee53721035#done3"},"hash":"de57acf10d6912842dea9da75cb4df5af5e55c7d98f3409b9105d5ab058e7926","header":{"body_hash":"304a58355c72917ea179d1b4a5366db393844db4bbdffbafe1ea6f5d4f84ddbd","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"4c09eafa2ac1596e793f86dac0ebe2dd2ab7c73c998394b8122a4a8d04dcc2d5","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":56,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"33bb329aa2b61a197134de7de47a2a58b0093829b906ad4a9e42835da0e4ec64","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":3,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":177},"started_unix_ms":1795101966102,"wave":{"doc:PMC13226197.txt#6":"reader-3","doc:PMC13226197.txt#7":"reader-1","doc:PMC13226197.txt#8":"reader-2"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"c51013c277c9257f46a0636d0779c3fb7d03774b3577ab785dfdfbbabc6b6509","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"6a7c630e8ea2a03ac8eebd827ac3a90b302eb58a9bb7d9953a7adaaa837136ef","submission_id":"circle:a0c63d7cb72be692e49548a266cea683753e8e1de47a3e43373365d737bff2c0"},"hash":"3a32f82d984f03baf9ab981b562bd692e6d9ebe56d6f0d13066b7c5cf22eceed","header":{"body_hash":"7c1c1645802f6454588729914273586185a60245651031b4598ff018a87083ec","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"de57acf10d6912842dea9da75cb4df5af5e55c7d98f3409b9105d5ab058e7926","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":57,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"114649f9e88e446819cf7eabc233cc6318652bab987045e4a795bde619acae57","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"33bb329aa2b61a197134de7de47a2a58b0093829b906ad4a9e42835da0e4ec64","engine_root":"c51013c277c9257f46a0636d0779c3fb7d03774b3577ab785dfdfbbabc6b6509","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"417af8fc74ed867b486926210c720783b5ef86fc298644e17cbe75ce8dd77947","log_size":58,"projections":{"dependencies":"62e3dddebeb68dbff66ccccfeedd79c1135467e14f135c77a7114605f3de5fa5","status":"6f46d4311284f361362388c5e022afcaad42ce8ea13eb2c9a9636818c732b1c8"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"3a32f82d984f03baf9ab981b562bd692e6d9ebe56d6f0d13066b7c5cf22eceed"}},"engine_root":"c51013c277c9257f46a0636d0779c3fb7d03774b3577ab785dfdfbbabc6b6509","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"33bb329aa2b61a197134de7de47a2a58b0093829b906ad4a9e42835da0e4ec64","engine_root":"c51013c277c9257f46a0636d0779c3fb7d03774b3577ab785dfdfbbabc6b6509","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"417af8fc74ed867b486926210c720783b5ef86fc298644e17cbe75ce8dd77947","log_size":58,"projections":{"dependencies":"62e3dddebeb68dbff66ccccfeedd79c1135467e14f135c77a7114605f3de5fa5","status":"6f46d4311284f361362388c5e022afcaad42ce8ea13eb2c9a9636818c732b1c8"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"3a32f82d984f03baf9ab981b562bd692e6d9ebe56d6f0d13066b7c5cf22eceed"},"seal_hash":"d81c7a5f0c53ad26a0e59d281eeb0670750a025c9b1a95c28cc75c696da6ac55"}},"request_hash":"a937903b1c79bc0a88fb1c92aee743b01e0ac7ce59d90fe6499d67a3a5bebdc1","submission_id":"seal-58"},"hash":"65749ba74b1b09bf51c0c8884d78410f3dbbb3d538307caf88b05cce8efb2b6b","header":{"body_hash":"f4a6d198e7b05276e8f34c6287d31109d2843a7c1e81f6437903db7ea37c3bfb","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3a32f82d984f03baf9ab981b562bd692e6d9ebe56d6f0d13066b7c5cf22eceed","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":58,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"f23d41af320dabe6ffd3bd61081ab3459c4dd58d2f905cf8ef9c124ed7807217","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"epoch":6,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795101966102},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"c51013c277c9257f46a0636d0779c3fb7d03774b3577ab785dfdfbbabc6b6509","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"a52019f4eb6e92c6370ee1543a2f6bf2af5d009a956c0fb74ed659cf962d840f","submission_id":"ring-members:e655e5d792d4451d3b4c0ca9ebb6993836da533c58b32237cf9ff0c40e7302ca"},"hash":"a189528eb9ebd379768a756b27a039fe900fa756c1c8133c03205ed352ce57d8","header":{"body_hash":"2a60349f4b6f0e5e0845c8eebd71dae2e9ad67517c39162fbd09bef23520b326","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"65749ba74b1b09bf51c0c8884d78410f3dbbb3d538307caf88b05cce8efb2b6b","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":59,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"04f5c25e8898d8e35bfb2b5749829c52e57f2e1a62992daeb5246023d242dc71","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":4,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":177},"started_unix_ms":1795101966122,"wave":{"doc:PMC13226197.txt#10":"reader-2","doc:PMC13226197.txt#11":"reader-3","doc:PMC13226197.txt#9":"reader-1"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"c51013c277c9257f46a0636d0779c3fb7d03774b3577ab785dfdfbbabc6b6509","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"6b446779a5db9a940bc2fd36c50c9480cf85831ecf148994641e44e9544f30df","submission_id":"circle:545d598bdc781c11e417592ec28127df425b27ba490864c4af6dc8e051c45012"},"hash":"58e89c3eca0a2f3b5c7c136a9d5ae598f8c72eca28581e2d6a79e3765d3744ed","header":{"body_hash":"244db1636f603163a1f09cc03e9448cefd2f9bb976a7c10293a8f78f4852566b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"a189528eb9ebd379768a756b27a039fe900fa756c1c8133c03205ed352ce57d8","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":60,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"f314e900c27a9cf3afd237142f2445cc345b49e4406ee40ee94729489f310f8d","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"04f5c25e8898d8e35bfb2b5749829c52e57f2e1a62992daeb5246023d242dc71","engine_root":"c51013c277c9257f46a0636d0779c3fb7d03774b3577ab785dfdfbbabc6b6509","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"d9b153940ea11985f7fbf07048cae26b28de17e4e1d949f91beec3edbd1c0d45","log_size":61,"projections":{"dependencies":"62e3dddebeb68dbff66ccccfeedd79c1135467e14f135c77a7114605f3de5fa5","status":"6f46d4311284f361362388c5e022afcaad42ce8ea13eb2c9a9636818c732b1c8"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"58e89c3eca0a2f3b5c7c136a9d5ae598f8c72eca28581e2d6a79e3765d3744ed"}},"engine_root":"c51013c277c9257f46a0636d0779c3fb7d03774b3577ab785dfdfbbabc6b6509","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"04f5c25e8898d8e35bfb2b5749829c52e57f2e1a62992daeb5246023d242dc71","engine_root":"c51013c277c9257f46a0636d0779c3fb7d03774b3577ab785dfdfbbabc6b6509","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"d9b153940ea11985f7fbf07048cae26b28de17e4e1d949f91beec3edbd1c0d45","log_size":61,"projections":{"dependencies":"62e3dddebeb68dbff66ccccfeedd79c1135467e14f135c77a7114605f3de5fa5","status":"6f46d4311284f361362388c5e022afcaad42ce8ea13eb2c9a9636818c732b1c8"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"58e89c3eca0a2f3b5c7c136a9d5ae598f8c72eca28581e2d6a79e3765d3744ed"},"seal_hash":"ce820799adb7c4634e1f3b93c0027fde4c644d86080df69bd1705903935124a3"}},"request_hash":"a48132a763ef0ea353ab02b902a6f66b4e785432ed32a4b01cad42b6bb72fd75","submission_id":"seal-61"},"hash":"52fa01ca90514246f8397e1fa88752dd02e528f3f2b2438c79fcbfd7558405a2","header":{"body_hash":"01285cdb69716aa00392b1dc98cdcb2f5fe7df0783fcca0fd6ccf59bc0f44116","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"58e89c3eca0a2f3b5c7c136a9d5ae598f8c72eca28581e2d6a79e3765d3744ed","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":61,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"b8f2e27fc391754235e349e5e71f3b917660e99360524b833c051317abaf3359","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"epoch":7,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795101966122},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"c51013c277c9257f46a0636d0779c3fb7d03774b3577ab785dfdfbbabc6b6509","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"a40eabca7d55fa306a9851276f4131f7b543f532f60418f6ba0c00eb8db5e1a5","submission_id":"ring-members:9226e991024a7c0c23de003c1531078b046ed51e89ccf0867afb5b5d010764af"},"hash":"48ff2ee59049049a17a2552f78acac4e98837f1b23ad2d7bd45156a797f7baf7","header":{"body_hash":"f1b60d859c70202186d930e78d25e32376571cf827213fd4a73d2a66862550de","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"52fa01ca90514246f8397e1fa88752dd02e528f3f2b2438c79fcbfd7558405a2","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":62,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"e0384669eeee61dde0525f44aafe235336b12ed6d05bc7c57f929506307b94b6","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"T15-5e1d2591c54b572e","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Wang J., Fan W. (2025). The effect of ChatGPT on students’ learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t15_o1","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025 reference entry in PMC13226197"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Hum. Soc. Sci. Communic. 12, 1–21. doi: 10.1057/s41599-025-04787-y","kind":"observe","local_id":"t15_o2","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025 journal and DOI in PMC13226197 reference list"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Choi Y., Lee Y., Shin D., Cho J., Park S., Lee S., et al. (2020). “EdNet: a large-scale hierarchical dataset in education,” in Artificial Intelligence in Education","kind":"observe","local_id":"t15_o3","terms":["Choi et al. 2020 EdNet dataset paper reference"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Kwang. (2020). EdNet-KT1 Dataset. Available online at: https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/gmhost/ednetkt1 (Acessed May 5, 2026).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t15_o4","terms":["Kwang 2020 EdNet-KT1 dataset reference"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t15_o3","t15_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t15_c1","object":"EdNet-KT1 Dataset (Kwang 2020) and EdNet paper (Choi et al. 2020)","predicate":"cites_dataset","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 lists the EdNet-KT1 dataset (Kwang 2020) and the EdNet dataset paper (Choi et al. 2020) in its reference list as the data sources underlying its analysis."},{"about":["PMC13226197","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t15_q1","needed":"Check in-text citations to Wang & Fan (2025) in body sections of PMC13226197.txt and link with the Title line quote from the meta-analysis record file.","text":"Which statements in the body of PMC13226197 cite Wang J., Fan W. (2025), and how does that citation relate to the meta-analysis's record file Title line?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",60972,66169]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"a7578bda8e42ac8ae5cbfc0c4207c5bd1c257fb056f8af00269e4ebeadc7b889","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["4f8da53456a9f895a37e687c51bb54590f43dd75143b06cfb31136f4eb169c1f","c8a5c0af3571392f5616a8aff9e49ae45dc34351bee6fc92cf951c504c5a3dfb","6b1dc1772369965fb189de452f7c316444f572544a38f4a0f00c387ed2b938ae","447ee3fa8fcffbc704b28fbccba5c8c6739738877f740daea6bf85460ef1f6c2","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","1f91007433d4c197ca6dc1a46d00e0e5b3463e31aedc940c922cb3e83e36c972"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"8e69ef1ea4eb4dc1c684cb84def738a46bac8d45feb386f50ba2663770d0964d","submission_id":"T15-5e1d2591c54b572e#1"},"hash":"a0055d97e7d6b7f2d0ea0e00dd8be32f947a129925210fff3ebb4c947ea6c38a","header":{"body_hash":"0d724beebe34f1092f96316bc3a0400bffb1f88af970cd6dcd505baebc0c01dd","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"48ff2ee59049049a17a2552f78acac4e98837f1b23ad2d7bd45156a797f7baf7","records_root":"01ad680b1e82595ef9ddbacbaac6fed7ce9b81e34066d26adc056636b9ebcc17","seq":63,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"af661bc63117f37a1f7468eeba8b13364a05ee2e1cebaaa248837925e2d182ca","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":4,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":7,"task_id":"T15-5e1d2591c54b572e"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13226197.txt#11","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a7578bda8e42ac8ae5cbfc0c4207c5bd1c257fb056f8af00269e4ebeadc7b889","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"3168e00dea05f1adee46e052e4be9691773f790337075d4d7b53161772529edd","submission_id":"T15-5e1d2591c54b572e#done2"},"hash":"048bb80e4c61bc76b682f416d934910f9cdf682b0f17018ce8199309fbab7e85","header":{"body_hash":"030e0a25b453bc19ecf54a70ad58860ba41fd634606609311b032698e43eaa22","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"a0055d97e7d6b7f2d0ea0e00dd8be32f947a129925210fff3ebb4c947ea6c38a","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":64,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"68a2bc65bb184c9c13273ecfdc8c4c4923e1c3333a94ec497804dc0fbe70c30a","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"T13-1b98c24edd50d975","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The presented positive engagement effects are consistent with those of Wang and Fan (2025), who, in their meta-analysis, noted moderate engagement effects of use on students’ perceived learning","kind":"observe","local_id":"t13_o1","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025 citation","positive engagement effects","students' perceived learning"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"First, we identify within-learner variation in persistence and time on task using causal identification and rule out the possibility that more engaged learners merely used AI support more frequently.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t13_o2","terms":["within-learner variation","persistence and time on task","causal identification"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"the negative coefficient of spacing (β=−0.018) implies a subtlety that has not been previously studied, which is that AI exposure is correlated with smaller inter-session breaks","kind":"observe","local_id":"t13_o3","terms":["spacing negative coefficient","inter-session breaks","behavioral engagement"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"H3—Knowledge Transfer: The near-transfer effect (β=0.052) is stronger than topic-shift transfer ( β=0.021 ) and delayed performance ( β=0.017 )","kind":"observe","local_id":"t13_o4","terms":["near-transfer effect","topic-shift transfer","delayed performance","effect sizes"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"There is an increase in metacognitive proxies across the monitoring and control dimensions, including enhanced checking and error correction, greater help-seeking, revisiting, and strategy switching","kind":"observe","local_id":"t13_o5","terms":["metacognitive proxies increase","monitoring and control","H1 finding"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"There is also an increase in engagement, in the form of an extended time on task, a more vigorous activity, persistence following errors, and a higher return behavior once shorter (Table 4; Figure 5).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t13_o6","terms":["engagement increase","time on task","persistence following errors","return behavior"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The patterns of heterogeneity have greater effects in greater difficulty bands and reduced effects with increased topic distance and inactivity gaps (Table 5; Figure 6).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t13_o7","terms":["heterogeneity of transfer effects","difficulty bands","topic distance","inactivity gaps"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"metacognition proxies should be understood as indicators of regulatory activity rather than as direct measures of metacognitive accuracy or calibrated self-knowledge (Table 3; Figure 4).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t13_o8","terms":["metacognition proxies qualification","regulatory activity vs metacognitive accuracy"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t13_o5","t13_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t13_c1","object":"increased monitoring and control proxies reflecting regulatory activity rather than calibrated accuracy","predicate":"finds_metacognitive_result","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds that AI-based tutoring increases monitoring and control metacognitive proxies (checking, error correction, help-seeking, revisiting, strategy switching), which reflect regulatory activity rather than calibrated accuracy."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t13_o2","t13_o3","t13_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t13_c2","object":"increased time on task, persistence, return behavior, and smaller inter-session breaks (β = -0.018)","predicate":"finds_engagement_result","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds that AI-based tutoring increases behavioral engagement (extended time on task, vigorous activity, persistence after errors, higher return behavior) with smaller inter-session breaks (spacing β = -0.018)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t13_o4","t13_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t13_c3","object":"stronger near-transfer (β=0.052) than topic-shift (β=0.021) or delayed performance (β=0.017), moderated by difficulty, distance, and inactivity","predicate":"finds_transfer_result","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds stronger AI tutoring gains in near-transfer within skill (β = 0.052) than in topic-shift transfer (β = 0.021) or delayed performance (β = 0.017), with larger effects at higher difficulty and smaller with topic distance or inactivity."},{"about":["PMC13226197","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t13_q1","needed":"Check the reference list of PMC13226197.txt for the Wang and Fan (2025) entry and obtain the Title line quote from the Wang and Fan (2025) meta-analysis record file.","text":"Does the Wang and Fan (2025) meta-analysis cited in PMC13226197 for moderate engagement effects on perceived learning match the retracted Wang J and Fan W (2025) meta-analysis record ('Title: The effect of ChatGPT...')?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",49050,55050]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"ab8c585f38abf6f296e6795689930615b2724396f0dd643f456a95f212065df6","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["2d1181b33e71b97ee3d2670fdee713745cac5f9a89c73d04b78e4473e7e45bbf","6f77d807bb61a038a56e652c02c2cface1ab17bdd29d76df5cd0e350e4be25ff","489ab998d075089c141ee7f98ac4231fce6e9c1e9b9f179678607cfb58f71ccb","c8b2a6e670e96cedf9f3e04de727e87fe7e85717631b9dafb65fffc5589fe843","c48f350ac63503a96c8f0bd8e847a6c29f3d4c3364598106121e24e74058a6b7","fd6f60a0f6cf0e888d740c480cb2c3f862f65080c1097dcb306bd34bdf478ada","f6db9358999d3f3cfa187ef8cff48a0c9f03df0b609780ef1ac4896d650c7904","23ed3a451d80debe0e2e8cdb64802105f789de0ca9e8d6e10d75d658a4bfa303","3cf2d36d8e6e76f00a143961c6f4d14251dfc7065c2427d9b86c29b4cbfd4def","b32c3f367f34785cc2957601c7a17bf941db495460a38dd8a131a1b030ca5d86"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":10}},"request_hash":"d1b5461f89ab8bf05ef0cfb8d7b5673391c0368c1903f140e5a3971502e2c172","submission_id":"T13-1b98c24edd50d975#1"},"hash":"c472914108eed1f3211554a45b8b19f8781696cd38f63546df2ed4f6c2b21736","header":{"body_hash":"b5d06fd4c5986982e62d4637eec8f6db8a31828344d3b484cc788ed6fcfc92a5","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"048bb80e4c61bc76b682f416d934910f9cdf682b0f17018ce8199309fbab7e85","records_root":"fb631901f1e0fdd8727538e489754118f5db171ae828468018c587ab13ec6cc0","seq":65,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"bd1bcf5f5472d653e6114304b1b01b4abf85d4546de701a5664b3342ec519af7","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"T13-1b98c24edd50d975","kind":"submit","lines":[{"about":["PMC13226197","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t13_q1","needed":"Check the reference list of PMC13226197.txt for the Wang and Fan (2025) entry and obtain the Title line quote from the Wang and Fan (2025) meta-analysis record file.","text":"Does the Wang and Fan (2025) meta-analysis cited in PMC13226197 for moderate engagement effects on perceived learning match the retracted Wang J and Fan W (2025) meta-analysis record ('Title: The effect of ChatGPT...')?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",49050,55050]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"ab8c585f38abf6f296e6795689930615b2724396f0dd643f456a95f212065df6","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["9b3c026f5c32e8c2fb449b2212eea1358f43691398a7fcf3c6e4b2ed4d47fa38"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"1e204a0e4d7c5edd4a4a3793c362c429f736cd7651022d40f4485060c84ac42b","submission_id":"T13-1b98c24edd50d975#1.1"},"hash":"9a98356c471c36740918f2e6dbae41cc73d54b54b7b7cbe062058b3e9096efcd","header":{"body_hash":"fe7239e501135c64c8fa5f68516347a7b7681f9b73472e746680b0e0b17db285","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"c472914108eed1f3211554a45b8b19f8781696cd38f63546df2ed4f6c2b21736","records_root":"4fd683e7b1701f8d6e1267b45df8766aaa4548e2d234fe196ab34bf238579350","seq":66,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"44c0fa8b62d41bbce22af220d508c8fb88bb7a953709f5fff5c0e95d5f72246a","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@2d1181b33e71b97e","@6f77d807bb61a038","@489ab998d075089c","@c8b2a6e670e96ced","@c48f350ac63503a9","@fd6f60a0f6cf0e88","@f6db9358999d3f3c","@23ed3a451d80debe","@3cf2d36d8e6e76f0","@b32c3f367f34785c","@9b3c026f5c32e8c2"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":10,"local_id":"t13_c3"}],"task_id":"T13-1b98c24edd50d975","work_key":"doc:PMC13226197.txt#9"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T13-1b98c24edd50d975:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"ab8c585f38abf6f296e6795689930615b2724396f0dd643f456a95f212065df6","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"f425e5d75e553f074ce361ae77d38e486fc87437df48695320739a907de6f330","submission_id":"T13-1b98c24edd50d975#repair1"},"hash":"3c5ad6348f18224cd2e298a10e45193904158b28b32692da088e4d85d4915698","header":{"body_hash":"347a57b44dadbd2e10f170d22aa6344451b8db1f2a1e708c4c84e2b46ccfbc6d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"9a98356c471c36740918f2e6dbae41cc73d54b54b7b7cbe062058b3e9096efcd","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":67,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"aac5d23c7ce77e84d6b92a0aa17ad2389c5ab41aeceabcfaa8269c93393d3caa","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"T14-aabbc650381a9cfd","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"This paper demonstrates that AI-assisted tutoring exposure is associated with statistically significant changes in learning processes","kind":"observe","local_id":"t14_o1","terms":["AI-assisted tutoring exposure","statistically significant changes","learning processes"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"including higher monitoring- and control-related proxies, greater behavioral engagement, and the most pronounced changes in near transfer","kind":"observe","local_id":"t14_o2","terms":["monitoring and control proxies","behavioral engagement","near transfer"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"but less pronounced effects on topic shift and delayed performance outcomes.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t14_o3","terms":["topic shift","delayed performance outcomes","far transfer"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"AI support can reinforce regulation and persistence, but broader transfer requires designs that inhibit substitution and encourage generative processing.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t14_o4","terms":["regulation and persistence","broader transfer","substitution","generative processing"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"the use of AI is quantified by platform-assistance events, which are proxies for algorithm-mediated support; this approach reduces construct validity and cross-tool generalizability.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t14_o5","terms":["platform-assistance events","construct validity","cross-tool generalizability"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"metacognition is not directly measured by monitoring accuracy or calibration; instead, it is estimated from behavioral proxies","kind":"observe","local_id":"t14_o6","terms":["metacognition","monitoring accuracy","calibration","behavioral proxies"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"the findings should be interpreted as changes in regulatory functioning rather than changes in metacognitive accuracy (Table 3; Figure 4).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t14_o7","terms":["regulatory functioning","metacognitive accuracy"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"even with fixed effects, unobserved time-varying confounding may remain; this is especially evident when both sudden difficulty shocks and motivational changes simultaneously affect help-seeking","kind":"observe","local_id":"t14_o8","terms":["fixed effects","unobserved time-varying confounding","difficulty shocks","motivational changes"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"transfer measures are log-based proxies; whereas near transfer in skill is well supported, far transfer is an approximation and requires definitions of skills and topic clusters","kind":"observe","local_id":"t14_o9","terms":["transfer measures","log-based proxies","near transfer","far transfer approximation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"EdNet reflects a particular tutoring context; therefore, the effect sizes and mechanisms may differ in classroom settings, collaborative learning, or high-stakes testing.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t14_o10","terms":["EdNet context","external validity","classroom settings","high-stakes testing"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"We do not formally test mediation in this study, although our conceptual framework suggests that AI exposure may mediate the effects of AI on metacognition and engagement.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t14_o11","terms":["mediation analysis","conceptual framework","metacognition and engagement"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The mechanistic pathway would therefore be considered hypothetically possible and congruent with the pattern of results, but not formally established.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t14_o12","terms":["mechanistic pathway","not formally established"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t14_o1","t14_o2","t14_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t14_c1","object":"increased monitoring/control proxies, behavioral engagement, and near transfer; weaker effects on topic shift and delayed performance","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 concludes that AI-assisted tutoring exposure increases monitoring and control proxies, behavioral engagement, and near transfer, with weaker effects on topic shift and delayed performance."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t14_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t14_c2","object":"broader transfer requires designs inhibiting substitution and encouraging generative processing","predicate":"concludes_transfer_condition","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 concludes that while AI support reinforces regulation and persistence, achieving broader transfer requires instructional designs that inhibit substitution and promote generative processing."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t14_o5","t14_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t14_c3","object":"platform-assistance event proxies and single EdNet tutoring context limit construct validity and generalizability","predicate":"qualifies_validity_and_generalizability","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 qualifies its findings by noting that quantifying AI use via platform-assistance event proxies limits construct validity and cross-tool generalizability, and EdNet results may not generalize to other settings."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t14_o6","t14_o7","t14_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t14_c4","object":"metacognition proxies reflect regulatory functioning rather than calibration accuracy; log-based far transfer is an approximation","predicate":"qualifies_outcome_measures","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 qualifies its outcome measures because behavioral proxies estimate regulatory functioning rather than direct metacognitive accuracy or calibration, and log-based far transfer is only an approximation."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t14_o8","t14_o11","t14_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t14_c5","object":"potential unobserved time-varying confounding remains and the mediation pathway is not formally tested","predicate":"qualifies_causal_and_mediation_claims","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 qualifies its causal identification and mechanism claims: unobserved time-varying confounding (such as difficulty shocks or motivation shifts) may remain despite fixed effects, and mediation is not formally tested."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",55050,60972]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"fdd73ed001134619cefbf482e1e539d9566bec1cb1285e29238769e95583d007","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["a2ee4491efd72115de74bdbf8198159362b088a009a4265f0a0ef29970840c6a","d653fe64675372e669d4ead70dd8cc55bff31f90d17fbdb08f076976de35dda4","670f41af1c31551536a059db195d88bdb9eec3b86a5cc974d07b227d658b9b79","c915d2f831c43698c312ee2d655f7e22779781b1a6474e4201eb6ea4ad12d8c8","6843210033d7761389fed4a39a7a2f1cbe42e6a3908ad9ac12ed20a2a6a52f7c","e5566ca05a8fe508b9a85b626b7f15f7c6cec32153f834b4946a66561fd11b44","59523e97d14bb6c1b1bc7e124cbac718ec23838bbd44dd2578e3a38e5bea35f4","3343c366c756803fce5eb5a020a57c66f77922bc7927b23e9c6a46441f61faff","47c167be320faeca4327edf8e7a063dcc3beb3e81bf8d669f7be2b3bdcf8e30e","77f15d2ae3c76ec48caddcf6efed4615f402b6112e3214ce1e14299e99a3d869","656550c99091f0f1ae71c8e36894a561f3a601f44ec8dae561da177cc8a36f8a","81a6b55aa2123ed3e63fb9979a6bffe9464c3d6472bb274adede24ea89ad852d","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","e0724e44d2a6077195985beaa0c656d7938f8cb6a8ab5d1f4e56d036376415ac","0fb253f1d51a24b4c9d3f44598b79874cdd12a2d3cae189b00eec3ac50abd804","f2355b477c1967a9500580e1e09129a66216834453dd492e8a70ffe0e7d7ddb7"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"a1508f641d52c51581059b8660d71b6feafb4f183def9b793a0d372a04b20bef","submission_id":"T14-aabbc650381a9cfd#1"},"hash":"e5ed827325a20140227f122157c744772dfd4e2f342146c0000d4622006199c9","header":{"body_hash":"6805604b449bdbdc70394d91c68b58021d47caee732203f82d1fd7f326a1acc8","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3c5ad6348f18224cd2e298a10e45193904158b28b32692da088e4d85d4915698","records_root":"53c98e6b4570aa9c6ec0cac3e65b13a565cbc2385e42547c740ccd98ce27ceb4","seq":68,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"f2731a8dc7d5295b296b908e592f8a8881c25674daa7965712fd7fbc13550928","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":4,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":7,"task_id":"T14-aabbc650381a9cfd"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13226197.txt#10","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"fdd73ed001134619cefbf482e1e539d9566bec1cb1285e29238769e95583d007","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"3c82c5368103822cb4a1a1596da0c0292a2de8fdf4af3b834f5320877e4f2f4a","submission_id":"T14-aabbc650381a9cfd#done2"},"hash":"3ae68dd5b5f46fa41c6e4ee7da9525ef9ad19b86f82ab977673abf6d84d883b4","header":{"body_hash":"638a3b356e4e7108bea02e92c1fea3b964c85c82515eae813016cb9c8cd01148","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"e5ed827325a20140227f122157c744772dfd4e2f342146c0000d4622006199c9","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":69,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"f5483d81042dccdd56a78110930c967b699cda71f9d8ff416e17007c7cfbe69f","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"T13-1b98c24edd50d975","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t13_o4","t13_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t13_c3","object":"stronger near-transfer (β=0.052) than topic-shift (β=0.021) or delayed performance (β=0.017), moderated by difficulty, distance, and inactivity","predicate":"finds_transfer_result","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds stronger near-transfer gains (β=0.052) than topic-shift transfer (β=0.021) or delayed performance (β=0.017), with greater effects at higher difficulty and reduced effects with topic distance and inactivity."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",49050,55050]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"fdd73ed001134619cefbf482e1e539d9566bec1cb1285e29238769e95583d007","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["46d9fa7c0f8d5d96aa27d02da4fc823e110c8f893b427ea6108d114a2b0ddf5c"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"935d8e023dc0de1657e4fcaba7d243eec90ac7e51df9af3d89f24cbc2e6c3a9d","submission_id":"T13-1b98c24edd50d975#2"},"hash":"9ea0fbbde630cc98308493daef199a4b7e9b5cf63b783a49df504c1755392d59","header":{"body_hash":"8ed276a9b017b89195c103c450499bdf8fec52c866cf160386c938da731811c7","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3ae68dd5b5f46fa41c6e4ee7da9525ef9ad19b86f82ab977673abf6d84d883b4","records_root":"2f6af64d78c92f9f4e3201555cf21ecd6f4cdeb24037f27e1536e894afb307f9","seq":70,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"ccff56ff0b4574fbdf20a197b144d8cc0a23ce35133719c45844fa86f0953ee2","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":false,"agent":"reader-1","circle":4,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":12,"refusals":1,"stored":12,"sync_step":7,"task_id":"T13-1b98c24edd50d975"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13226197.txt#9","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"fdd73ed001134619cefbf482e1e539d9566bec1cb1285e29238769e95583d007","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"81ac92049016b3cd51827ee5459d807fe08af02f02ac766f826112baf5dec166","submission_id":"T13-1b98c24edd50d975#done3"},"hash":"f62ef8be6a5db8e2047a4eadda04c2bb5dc7554d38f94e5f83b3a89e400776ab","header":{"body_hash":"c0c98f67042dfc5669d85626ec56154d01a20cf62b4b6fd0cc3f52ea2e8f454e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"9ea0fbbde630cc98308493daef199a4b7e9b5cf63b783a49df504c1755392d59","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":71,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"c2f1bd07b912207258c19d63c3d7d9d5a2397e58cee404d1d756d2ae62d548b9","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":4,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":212},"started_unix_ms":1795102005031,"wave":{"doc:PMC13226197.txt#10":"reader-2","doc:PMC13226197.txt#11":"reader-3","doc:PMC13226197.txt#9":"reader-1"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"fdd73ed001134619cefbf482e1e539d9566bec1cb1285e29238769e95583d007","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"87e3d0a53049f06ebfd9dc99e552b7fed95bbc4dc595a92532e30dc6339fa45f","submission_id":"circle:2f120fd89893fca2ab44101a9eadf3e95166f1f96007dce84132fad1e6096795"},"hash":"70748b13fc31d2ddd0ec41fe3ce19b7742982836494b96ec006ebdfd73be3bfb","header":{"body_hash":"8f729ee9e43192326880f75adb1dfd0eda00a8e4ee294d8d33b75b2d0209802f","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"f62ef8be6a5db8e2047a4eadda04c2bb5dc7554d38f94e5f83b3a89e400776ab","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":72,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"8f1c5a59ec9ea9bed4603877ba094aac45765bd0b202548b2061057c963ac1e9","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"c2f1bd07b912207258c19d63c3d7d9d5a2397e58cee404d1d756d2ae62d548b9","engine_root":"fdd73ed001134619cefbf482e1e539d9566bec1cb1285e29238769e95583d007","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"fc34206f7ac6effb0d1aca1603b0a2e4c0c797a33364b127d58cde6231327fd3","log_size":73,"projections":{"dependencies":"0c18cfe7978f74965c5eca327d046a07f131476b1057e794894304287cae9bb8","status":"bd4c43c973f70c637dc348d5508a3c539b2e3eb111189cc55b1ff15b677582c1"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"70748b13fc31d2ddd0ec41fe3ce19b7742982836494b96ec006ebdfd73be3bfb"}},"engine_root":"fdd73ed001134619cefbf482e1e539d9566bec1cb1285e29238769e95583d007","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"c2f1bd07b912207258c19d63c3d7d9d5a2397e58cee404d1d756d2ae62d548b9","engine_root":"fdd73ed001134619cefbf482e1e539d9566bec1cb1285e29238769e95583d007","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"fc34206f7ac6effb0d1aca1603b0a2e4c0c797a33364b127d58cde6231327fd3","log_size":73,"projections":{"dependencies":"0c18cfe7978f74965c5eca327d046a07f131476b1057e794894304287cae9bb8","status":"bd4c43c973f70c637dc348d5508a3c539b2e3eb111189cc55b1ff15b677582c1"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"70748b13fc31d2ddd0ec41fe3ce19b7742982836494b96ec006ebdfd73be3bfb"},"seal_hash":"66f976ed9b59ad11a59451d51d1bc71dd525c9536986e2a7f23c1dc2dd85dd5f"}},"request_hash":"68da72ee105068e525778241b6a23c05a246e9f57f71befb542f0aa16c02c650","submission_id":"seal-73"},"hash":"72a1f3f425e1d5756b3f10b97a9a55762d38e7419d4573044ae2f04f0c08c148","header":{"body_hash":"44630b712c5fb1ffc6e750624b989a1c15ded2499defb15c571f2a854c6e58ca","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"70748b13fc31d2ddd0ec41fe3ce19b7742982836494b96ec006ebdfd73be3bfb","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":73,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"182af97c9f9af740e100c905ae5b63469093286947c22f5101bcdb76963c186d","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"epoch":8,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102005031},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"fdd73ed001134619cefbf482e1e539d9566bec1cb1285e29238769e95583d007","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"5cc9baf408ac41ed6d8d71cfe57819a91e13cb57f22eff13ef6d872ada017d5b","submission_id":"ring-members:9eee31ecbcb00ee35c5cf833e75d12d54aca0ecdac624f4710f83c5abc4697bd"},"hash":"80d349e818e3a2b5dae245a1ce93433478637bb555fc9ed354c9916796778ef8","header":{"body_hash":"911ed978f9e1b197f0e487327c816d3bb010aa5c57acacb85b445f8b817e17cb","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"72a1f3f425e1d5756b3f10b97a9a55762d38e7419d4573044ae2f04f0c08c148","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":74,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"40af4f246475d0df35ff73afeac809d3c214fb17ec9e55ff332f5b472b0ed8dc","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":5,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":212},"started_unix_ms":1795102005054,"wave":{"doc:PMC13314867.txt#0":"reader-2","doc:PMC13314867.txt#1":"reader-3","doc:PMC13314867.txt#2":"reader-1"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"fdd73ed001134619cefbf482e1e539d9566bec1cb1285e29238769e95583d007","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"49cd8f7ba58f41fbe35e305ecb081f36fba27d070b32f43d1b4e79fe067a0dc7","submission_id":"circle:860619459bae79b47986a96da5986e851c3c7e237f4eece1e1ca4a1d2806ea06"},"hash":"ee2a3e9e91ef0a084375b66c9a10c99b255cf6cc8b36ab537db7b5758862ca08","header":{"body_hash":"0574363b1f7ad596be9b700819b7b389209486a139f67b9caf46072e2dc068d0","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"80d349e818e3a2b5dae245a1ce93433478637bb555fc9ed354c9916796778ef8","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":75,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"abd20f21f1d43fbbfb69c510ec1a9795a4d333da18b503ff32839af303335783","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"40af4f246475d0df35ff73afeac809d3c214fb17ec9e55ff332f5b472b0ed8dc","engine_root":"fdd73ed001134619cefbf482e1e539d9566bec1cb1285e29238769e95583d007","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"2062424f6211a9fc0e8612adb0d97cbab2c33095322e16255f14edec0c91318a","log_size":76,"projections":{"dependencies":"0c18cfe7978f74965c5eca327d046a07f131476b1057e794894304287cae9bb8","status":"bd4c43c973f70c637dc348d5508a3c539b2e3eb111189cc55b1ff15b677582c1"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"ee2a3e9e91ef0a084375b66c9a10c99b255cf6cc8b36ab537db7b5758862ca08"}},"engine_root":"fdd73ed001134619cefbf482e1e539d9566bec1cb1285e29238769e95583d007","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"40af4f246475d0df35ff73afeac809d3c214fb17ec9e55ff332f5b472b0ed8dc","engine_root":"fdd73ed001134619cefbf482e1e539d9566bec1cb1285e29238769e95583d007","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"2062424f6211a9fc0e8612adb0d97cbab2c33095322e16255f14edec0c91318a","log_size":76,"projections":{"dependencies":"0c18cfe7978f74965c5eca327d046a07f131476b1057e794894304287cae9bb8","status":"bd4c43c973f70c637dc348d5508a3c539b2e3eb111189cc55b1ff15b677582c1"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"ee2a3e9e91ef0a084375b66c9a10c99b255cf6cc8b36ab537db7b5758862ca08"},"seal_hash":"0099c44af2bcba0275b3f179f2057433fd9365af319e3123857e45887badb846"}},"request_hash":"bd2e357f9ddc0101c01b0cd168fd150e6cb6d88139765450cbc3023ba4f01867","submission_id":"seal-76"},"hash":"547fccfcac985fea929a7c89f09c83a9ffb0d2428b1dfd779797dc97c42b6fe2","header":{"body_hash":"c673f49c7fd92379b707340191382194e5173ddd8bbbb1a043894119a5865f7f","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ee2a3e9e91ef0a084375b66c9a10c99b255cf6cc8b36ab537db7b5758862ca08","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":76,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"113521748100afa1547f3a1209a0766c1c441278dc28286f22be54bdd4667c82","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"epoch":9,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102005054},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"fdd73ed001134619cefbf482e1e539d9566bec1cb1285e29238769e95583d007","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"30e559680524b7d5abf6507110b25aff850db0a79197eaf72e5a3108bda64709","submission_id":"ring-members:714e65bcbbba1c6fe525c945e102e2b26ce26de13a9d3d358475323b2994f249"},"hash":"efbe88e208ae71902d90b65b5af3c8f0393c2d898a96253829773cd44e34f24d","header":{"body_hash":"3c503bdde3e830b2e8708bd5871dbb5e71b433adde211aa2054b80efaad0fa72","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"547fccfcac985fea929a7c89f09c83a9ffb0d2428b1dfd779797dc97c42b6fe2","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":77,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"0d27d267ebf0edd8de7e96eb68e68f65e2a03f024311b9c0562bc56724094de7","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T18-a2b2ca602cb7c1cd","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Students enrolled in undergraduate, master's, or doctoral programs at higher education institutions participated in the study. All participants had prior experience using ChatGPT","kind":"observe","local_id":"t18_o1","terms":["PMC13314867 participants","higher education students with ChatGPT experience"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"This measure ensured that the collected responses reflected perceptions grounded in real experiences with the tool (COVID-19 Social Science Lab, 2024a).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t18_o2","terms":["PMC13314867 data source","COVID-19 Social Science Lab 2024a questionnaire"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"For this Latin American study, data were collected from six countries: Ecuador (n = 1,235), Mexico (n = 566), Chile (n = 439), Brazil (n = 176), Colombia (n = 107), and Guatemala (n = 56).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t18_o3","terms":["PMC13314867 sample size and countries","Latin American higher education sample"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t18_o1","t18_o2","t18_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t18_c1","object":"questionnaire of 2,579 higher education students with ChatGPT experience across Ecuador (1,235), Mexico (566), Chile (439), Brazil (176), Colombia (107), and Guatemala (56) (COVID-19 Social Science Lab, 2024a)","predicate":"rests_on_data","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 rests on questionnaire data from 2,579 higher education students (undergraduate, master's, doctoral) with prior ChatGPT experience across six Latin American countries (COVID-19 Social Science Lab, 2024a)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",5475,11447]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"0b3e7b9cfb9689f16a0c0b4c2946a3339ac89e8164a3901002b9734af9e08743","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["bdacd1382145bd8562ba2e22523e27999c0b6318122a2e4453838329820e5992","366092ad49a08274a0bcba57645fe079874993eba6e6ce7f4b2abfc250a6b769","35ed2ac37e7cc295e4330fc7f5f786d833de6c54359d7de47e9fae1df9f775b8","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"cbd32c0e7fdbb02887b8b05075db1195c9c4a44b7b37eb5df835d271310e715c","submission_id":"T18-a2b2ca602cb7c1cd#1"},"hash":"c5a0e5ca95b460de2a753de4b7453602dc8bc5bb2ef41ac19e9c1611c6e01bea","header":{"body_hash":"c5dfeb932707d1b4de83c6dcac60c0c816241a8204e5e1082af1669e14b446f0","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"efbe88e208ae71902d90b65b5af3c8f0393c2d898a96253829773cd44e34f24d","records_root":"c6a0d5ad85e077b8aa19cc840b3c95f2b3e311321b108ba46854d0fb32bdf648","seq":78,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"af5d1e648fb1970d874e90421a4eb1d1c314259d24b8fc923b675ab348f3c788","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":5,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":9,"task_id":"T18-a2b2ca602cb7c1cd"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13314867.txt#1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"0b3e7b9cfb9689f16a0c0b4c2946a3339ac89e8164a3901002b9734af9e08743","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"c5d588ab4dddac07a19a415bed513b659fbce18dcf43860c2db71ac3ec382143","submission_id":"T18-a2b2ca602cb7c1cd#done2"},"hash":"3147d0947c10429d4f32e2bbb4aec3793b28f048f5fcf97cf83f99317d23dec8","header":{"body_hash":"01741f027802009dd5355c3385df36b8d9a18809a6f694f69302dc661ad5aff3","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"c5a0e5ca95b460de2a753de4b7453602dc8bc5bb2ef41ac19e9c1611c6e01bea","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":79,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"9a7bf240e9cd5e08af155434d00b84b3c2ce6038d8a0b6ce7408eb568aa11383","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T16-30598e21e29c92d6","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Source: Europe PMC PMC13314867, doi:10.3389/frma.2026.1816902.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t16_o1","terms":["PMC13314867","George-Reyes et al. 2026"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Copyright © 2026 George-Reyes, Romero, Merida-Cordova and Yeguas-Bolivar.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t16_o2","terms":["George-Reyes et al. 2026","authors"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Title: ChatGPT and higher education in Latin America: measuring perceived academic skills","kind":"observe","local_id":"t16_o3","terms":["PMC13314867 title","perceived academic skills"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"This study aimed to validate the Student Perception of ChatGPT instrument.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t16_o4","terms":["study aim","Student Perception of ChatGPT instrument"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"A non-experimental quantitative design with an instrumental and comparative approach was applied to a sample of 2,579 students with prior experience using ChatGPT","kind":"observe","local_id":"t16_o5","terms":["study design","sample of 2,579 students"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"students with prior experience using ChatGPT, from Ecuador, Mexico, Chile, Brazil, Colombia, and Guatemala.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t16_o6","terms":["sample countries","Latin America"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The questionnaire included 18 items organized into two key dimensions, communicative skills and analytical skills, measured on a five-point Likert scale.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t16_o7","terms":["measured outcomes","18-item questionnaire","communicative and analytical skills"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Internal consistency analyses (α = 0.943; ω = 0.944), as well as exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses, were conducted.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t16_o8","terms":["reliability metrics","EFA and CFA"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The results confirmed high reliability and a coherent two-factor structure, with consistent groupings among items related to academic writing, digital communication, critical thinking, and problem-solving.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t16_o9","terms":["main results","two-factor structure","high reliability"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"These findings provide empirical evidence of the instrument's validity to measure students' perceptions of ChatGPT's contribution to the development of such skills.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t16_o10","terms":["validity conclusion","Student Perception of ChatGPT"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"In addition, it has been suggested that this tool can improve academic performance (Essien et al., 2024) and the development of critical thinking skills (Jalil et al., 2023; Wang and Fan, 2025).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t16_o11","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025 citation","critical thinking skills"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t16_o1","t16_o2","t16_o11","@04588ef5a34c56f4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t16_c1","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (ChatGPT improves development of critical thinking skills)","predicate":"cites_for_claim","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) cites Wang and Fan 2025 (along with Jalil et al., 2023) to support the statement that ChatGPT has been suggested to improve the development of critical thinking skills."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t16_o1","t16_o2","t16_o5","t16_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t16_c2","object":"survey sample of 2,579 university students from Ecuador, Mexico, Chile, Brazil, Colombia, and Guatemala","predicate":"rests_on_data","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) rests on a non-experimental quantitative survey of 2,579 university students with prior ChatGPT experience from Ecuador, Mexico, Chile, Brazil, Colombia, and Guatemala."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t16_o1","t16_o4","t16_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t16_c3","object":"perceived communicative skills and analytical skills via 18-item five-point Likert questionnaire","predicate":"measures_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) measures perceived communicative skills and analytical skills using the 18-item Student Perception of ChatGPT questionnaire on a five-point Likert scale."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t16_o1","t16_o4","t16_o8","t16_o9","t16_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t16_c4","object":"high reliability (α=0.943, ω=0.944), two-factor structure, and validity of Student Perception of ChatGPT instrument","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) concludes that the Student Perception of ChatGPT instrument shows high internal consistency (α=0.943; ω=0.944), a coherent two-factor structure, and empirical validity."},{"about":["PMC13314867.txt","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t16_q1","needed":"Check the References section in later byte ranges of PMC13314867.txt for the full bibliographic entry of Wang and Fan (2025).","text":"Does the reference list of PMC13314867 confirm that 'Wang and Fan, 2025' refers to the retracted meta-analysis 'The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking'?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",0,5475]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"6330d7cf3f96b493b7f0251c9522887e3199033b9feb09f33d6fcf9ba2864415","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["1bbc6687f9d17196e9f1a40e85d9a6474a6d5f6c5587b928a03de18af41b226b","493109aa40be1afa09c9f5c40613d4eba21938a6a2b5f43747024f8edfe2ab05","1c992942f5fd3ab2971f11393cc3a70878df4de88f0bc8a79328f46ddad7a95b","33fedaebad3c5f73a4491b35776c6bc7db3590afc82189cf2ab5ae59ebf6abe4","b13774c4beaae75e0fa59c2da8b5841f969feafe29336440658c000a802c8664","11922380241d7afb6e354197943c3b876d1330097e24cbf29f4f2b4c20afb26a","207d9544dbe93293b404b8e79a0d9ef16498371f067bfa0809e9a85177462f79","6ef1edc987764a4ca9b21757ac4e1e81e8eed6d83964650613702b35e9c41b22","d5459c4cabe99ee33196c154c271ec16afc132f99b5a137dcf88d85b13f8304f","f34d0296c44c4041ef7b3891c9d0ccc696df36ba65d5e96903c7abe4333a708b","36a7360f76c796d49d30c3f6b1e6df7d9ca1dcad3955c95a4d2c0312bfbb461b"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"record was not issued in this context or allowed document scope","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":11}},"request_hash":"3264ee7c14fbfefe11f70f11133ed4a83334dbe33a0e66b147b02aae74e436d1","submission_id":"T16-30598e21e29c92d6#1"},"hash":"a152d3cd36144fffe3a87bc7dab80efe375b1c44c6d3d6746a66af812bd35db0","header":{"body_hash":"4b1b7b6c1a61003564af585fe7ace4072a5d04515c3a4b448f57ca2acb927a7a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3147d0947c10429d4f32e2bbb4aec3793b28f048f5fcf97cf83f99317d23dec8","records_root":"cd297c9dcfcd48f24f12a430ce6bcc328001fddbc96191b4cab107741470a428","seq":80,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"c5742bbba267689cdf42850cf5e2dc1ca244ac0680248faac7d0e6a172e4b45b","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T16-30598e21e29c92d6","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t16_o1","t16_o2","t16_o5","t16_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t16_c2","object":"survey sample of 2,579 university students from Ecuador, Mexico, Chile, Brazil, Colombia, and Guatemala","predicate":"rests_on_data","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) rests on a non-experimental quantitative survey of 2,579 university students with prior ChatGPT experience from Ecuador, Mexico, Chile, Brazil, Colombia, and Guatemala."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t16_o1","t16_o4","t16_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t16_c3","object":"perceived communicative skills and analytical skills via 18-item five-point Likert questionnaire","predicate":"measures_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) measures perceived communicative skills and analytical skills using the 18-item Student Perception of ChatGPT questionnaire on a five-point Likert scale."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t16_o1","t16_o4","t16_o8","t16_o9","t16_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t16_c4","object":"high reliability (α=0.943, ω=0.944), two-factor structure, and validity of Student Perception of ChatGPT instrument","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) concludes that the Student Perception of ChatGPT instrument shows high internal consistency (α=0.943; ω=0.944), a coherent two-factor structure, and empirical validity."},{"about":["PMC13314867.txt","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t16_q1","needed":"Check the References section in later byte ranges of PMC13314867.txt for the full bibliographic entry of Wang and Fan (2025).","text":"Does the reference list of PMC13314867 confirm that 'Wang and Fan, 2025' refers to the retracted meta-analysis 'The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking'?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",0,5475]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"6330d7cf3f96b493b7f0251c9522887e3199033b9feb09f33d6fcf9ba2864415","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","236708c9e09154e0f0c614a2db7e88b795b19b60b1784b34f9b148c63c1e789c"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"623e21d987e51af7d6327d4a493909bb3a4c57cd3928a60259be5fa0c12aa304","submission_id":"T16-30598e21e29c92d6#1.1"},"hash":"af9bb1f29905f984f127a13c426e1b2ec33177026f33115ca30bc4af8f793d10","header":{"body_hash":"0a1054ebe0d26e15db5e751eee5e91426248af0ef046b2797c912e546b978210","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"a152d3cd36144fffe3a87bc7dab80efe375b1c44c6d3d6746a66af812bd35db0","records_root":"7d174808d7772440fdd44bf914005853f08685749dde7d725615289ce89987d2","seq":81,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"041968ad2dffa3e48eac7615d5e457f79647c7b21773e02e75881ed59acb4532","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@1bbc6687f9d17196","@493109aa40be1afa","@1c992942f5fd3ab2","@33fedaebad3c5f73","@b13774c4beaae75e","@11922380241d7afb","@207d9544dbe93293","@6ef1edc987764a4c","@d5459c4cabe99ee3","@f34d0296c44c4041","@36a7360f76c796d4","@8458c2d89e0d12fa","@e7dfdf8e92bd43da","@54a8754c5a6c8ac7","@236708c9e09154e0"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"record was not issued in this context or allowed document scope","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":11,"local_id":"t16_c1"}],"task_id":"T16-30598e21e29c92d6","work_key":"doc:PMC13314867.txt#0"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T16-30598e21e29c92d6:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"6330d7cf3f96b493b7f0251c9522887e3199033b9feb09f33d6fcf9ba2864415","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"5c04c512c17c2f149457887a9316d5472c1b563c11e8f1ebf1aafa8ef1867d05","submission_id":"T16-30598e21e29c92d6#repair1"},"hash":"0ed2c2c80a1be80e3852786fdab1fe51eef081bdcc8634017c3bfd3aa675baad","header":{"body_hash":"1ac492527af08d070b716cca6bfeb324740dcc3408291fab01e4cbca5281b7e5","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"af9bb1f29905f984f127a13c426e1b2ec33177026f33115ca30bc4af8f793d10","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":82,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"0613196b20d7cfc17ad0a43800ee5e385b18da8ad79a31856a5379383355f973","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T17-93078277f4faab74","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The instrument used was the Student Perception of ChatGPT questionnaire, developed within the framework of the international project Global ChatGPT Student Survey, coordinated by the University of Ljubljana (Ravšelj et al., 2024).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t17_o1","terms":["Student Perception of ChatGPT questionnaire","Global ChatGPT Student Survey","Ravšelj et al., 2024"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The dimensions corresponding to sections Q28 and Q29 were selected, which explore perceptions of the impact of ChatGPT on the development of communicative, analytical, and problem solving skills.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t17_o2","terms":["sections Q28 and Q29","communicative, analytical, and problem solving skills"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Both dimensions included a set of nine items each, measured using a five point Likert type scale ranging from 1 = strongly disagree to 5 = strongly agree.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t17_o3","terms":["18 items","five point Likert type scale"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The instrument was subjected to a translation process into Spanish and a linguistic adaptation aimed at ensuring semantic clarity and conceptual equivalence of the items across the six participating countries.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t17_o4","terms":["Spanish translation","six participating countries"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Therefore, what is being validated is the internal consistency and factorial structure of this partial adaptation within a Latin American context.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t17_o5","terms":["validation scope","internal consistency","factorial structure","Latin American context"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"A reliability analysis was conducted, showing high levels of internal consistency (Cronbach's α = 0.943; McDonald's ω = 0.944).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t17_o6","terms":["reliability analysis","Cronbach's alpha","McDonald's omega"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"As shown in Table 3, in all cases the coefficients remain above 0.939, indicating that no item compromises the homogeneity of the scale and that its exclusion would not significantly increase the overall reliability of the instrument.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t17_o7","terms":["item removal reliability","scale homogeneity"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Likewise, the groupings largely respect the predefined theoretical dimensions, clearly differentiating between communication skills (blue cluster) and analytical and problem solving skills (red cluster).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t17_o8","terms":["hierarchical cluster analysis","communication skills cluster","analytical and problem solving skills cluster"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Bartlett's test of sphericity yielded a value of χ2 = 30,921, with 153 degrees of freedom and a significance level of p < 0.001, indicating that there are significant correlations among the questionnaire items.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t17_o9","terms":["Bartlett's test of sphericity","principal components analysis"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"As shown in Table 4, after applying a varimax rotation, a differentiation between the communication and analysis dimensions becomes evident.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t17_o10","terms":["varimax rotation","communication and analysis dimensions"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Items related to communicative skills (Q28a–Q28i) show high loadings on the first component, particularly those linked to academic and professional writing (Q28a and Q28b, above 0.76)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t17_o11","terms":["communicative skills loadings","first component","academic and professional writing"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t17_o1","t17_o2","t17_o3","t17_o4","t17_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t17_c1","object":"Spanish adaptation of Q28 and Q29 (18 items, 5-point Likert) from Student Perception of ChatGPT questionnaire (Ravšelj et al., 2024) across six Latin American countries","predicate":"uses_instrument","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 uses a Spanish adaptation of sections Q28 and Q29 (9 items each, 5-point Likert scale) from the Student Perception of ChatGPT questionnaire (Global ChatGPT Student Survey; Ravšelj et al., 2024) across six countries."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t17_o2","t17_o5","t17_o11"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t17_c2","object":"perceived impact of ChatGPT on communicative skills (Q28) and analytical/problem-solving skills (Q29), evaluating internal consistency and factorial structure","predicate":"measures_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 measures students' perceived impact of ChatGPT on communicative skills (Q28a-Q28i) and analytical and problem-solving skills (Q29a-Q29i), validating internal consistency and factorial structure in Latin America."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t17_o6","t17_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t17_c3","object":"Cronbach's α = 0.943, McDonald's ω = 0.944, and all item-removed coefficients > 0.939","predicate":"reports_reliability","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 reports high internal consistency for the 18-item adapted scale (Cronbach's α = 0.943; McDonald's ω = 0.944), with all item-deleted reliability coefficients remaining above 0.939."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t17_o8","t17_o9","t17_o10","t17_o11"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t17_c4","object":"empirical differentiation between communicative skills (Q28a-i, Q28a/b loadings > 0.76 on component 1) and analytical/problem-solving skills across cluster and PCA analyses","predicate":"concludes_factor_structure","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 finds via hierarchical cluster analysis and varimax-rotated PCA (Bartlett's χ2 = 30,921, df = 153, p < 0.001) that items separate into communicative (Q28a-i; Q28a/b loadings > 0.76) and analytical/problem-solving dimensions."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",11447,17444]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"ae0e0abcea5556338cd01d5d3f784f56f68f05c2a84b22e12ddc12570f7b842d","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["47731564fae0d9a0d619cc759223ece8a0e38667aa5626931119722a9d77c6b1","5b5b6b12218c1f83036f45c7f5086d4aeb48ff2ef40514b7248be9a3371d2535","5d1501da50481ff9299bf7a53b3bedb9ec363966459aded2ab3bb3140cbdcf35","4177ad9da1b7c18955a086bc19692f35c1fedf3b8f0a8ce71b5aa35de2d27029","f48a197becde3cf612bff25c3a4f9e423b60f02c8d7c82f407b4b1cb5bb76d93","93be540e7edb27167a112c1f2cdf6f8de8fbdc4b0027e49a41db5251dd8d6a29","ed0def08684ec7e0d3de11934740aac67a8498475b1aa6b0cad49428719a96fe","8c12b002514f4d6cb6f06033fe6855534a7f5dba96dfed022d5d0a986273954b","b6111c5c1a067f6e3de6440660b793eda0904ddbe66b144cff84a6e624e48d5c","25b58c33f3a08575efc53530dae74182afe3f567557a714cbe4fbf29521591dc","649643003e1e27347985af33ab517e205ccdcf37f7ba638d2d343a87b07680f8","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","00636ae681773aa2de1a3f1b7b3ba5b3caf54a805b60b3de9b571bf529e8e81a","099cebfd1758d63a8957557f3c228e2e7dd1e62a7b5adca8719ba563cc67bb76","beb271a2eb79c7b00fad16641e9fc400eea7fd2dbc197413ba1e12174f451018"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"69af81fcd8a0fc8b108f43c6424d9ec1035e614990bce8502106ef73341681f7","submission_id":"T17-93078277f4faab74#1"},"hash":"4c82f6eb6085e7720de61a63ae54df2ea23b9aae50d15b22a402e5bd8a1970b1","header":{"body_hash":"23f97b68623a08f77b02b3e5f5b714e127f8f952fc5a1c8252da08da1cd894c3","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"0ed2c2c80a1be80e3852786fdab1fe51eef081bdcc8634017c3bfd3aa675baad","records_root":"25549d130fe274533989f3de6a76590c7b3d002dac1da8cdf2877462d2229a6d","seq":83,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"4bcf7062e4de18b167021c95cae425bc734410dbf1cf0e1c59d18969ff41fb16","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":5,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":9,"task_id":"T17-93078277f4faab74"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13314867.txt#2","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"ae0e0abcea5556338cd01d5d3f784f56f68f05c2a84b22e12ddc12570f7b842d","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"7a4971103d86db24b60f8cb4b7595a4d421b039bb9d40cbdb95aeb053c2db2f5","submission_id":"T17-93078277f4faab74#done2"},"hash":"6ef58e9d32703ce98412f6d8caf6b47e4841cfffa239f547ebc50e9a84a49dfa","header":{"body_hash":"4783b77714a0c5542cb3f1d912d439b7aa7f59edf94e454da53ee84b333f8c2e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"4c82f6eb6085e7720de61a63ae54df2ea23b9aae50d15b22a402e5bd8a1970b1","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":84,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"23a2269b1c20599452a6a3dfac71c21dc2234af9a167f1f29319d4bc17757842","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T16-30598e21e29c92d6","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t16_o1","t16_o2","t16_o11"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t16_c1","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (ChatGPT improves development of critical thinking skills)","predicate":"cites_for_claim","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) cites Wang and Fan 2025 (along with Jalil et al., 2023) to support the statement that ChatGPT has been suggested to improve the development of critical thinking skills."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",0,5475]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"ae0e0abcea5556338cd01d5d3f784f56f68f05c2a84b22e12ddc12570f7b842d","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"452dd4fe982b26de2200c1ea564ddaa23f026f7fafb529cd3b89437b5b6111ab","submission_id":"T16-30598e21e29c92d6#2"},"hash":"92086658393012064f6f7f63214add33507bfd551aa4506d416a8dec5b740727","header":{"body_hash":"ea60003beebcbcaad53a1e2c9926ecc93c16bfe734938b1c9008346a36347994","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"6ef58e9d32703ce98412f6d8caf6b47e4841cfffa239f547ebc50e9a84a49dfa","records_root":"a98c8147b048a3296fc89974f4bf1e6ffcae97a4572b3087d9cacd42ff20e7a0","seq":85,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"953c0bf99fd223016adf66eb7216d6e2bfb3226eb309cb56561302aef07cba77","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":false,"agent":"reader-2","circle":5,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":16,"refusals":1,"stored":16,"sync_step":9,"task_id":"T16-30598e21e29c92d6"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13314867.txt#0","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"ae0e0abcea5556338cd01d5d3f784f56f68f05c2a84b22e12ddc12570f7b842d","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"435e4bca15147df0f3e78faddeec6eb346197f678792dca8c216491e9d6c7e5c","submission_id":"T16-30598e21e29c92d6#done3"},"hash":"05f55bcaba949f5fc75b1c24b95d65f15d3b69bf81d4c828bfb3f0573c39e997","header":{"body_hash":"aabc3ef97839d2f837ff98823da06788cc656a75c4954449cd5cfe9d81f8be24","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"92086658393012064f6f7f63214add33507bfd551aa4506d416a8dec5b740727","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":86,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"29e2354b641725c02388fb6c9bf5d59a36ca145779b17ba9b3fb134c470822c5","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR19-51d961343f9ef9dd","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Copyright © 2026 George-Reyes, Romero, Merida-Cordova and Yeguas-Bolivar.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t19_o1","terms":["article authorship and publication year of PMC13314867"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"In addition, it has been suggested that this tool can improve academic performance (Essien et al., 2024) and the development of critical thinking skills (Jalil et al., 2023; Wang and Fan, 2025).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t19_o2","terms":["citation of Wang and Fan 2025 for ChatGPT improving critical thinking skills"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Internal consistency analyses (α = 0.943; ω = 0.944), as well as exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses, were conducted.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t19_o3","terms":["exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses alongside internal consistency"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The results confirmed high reliability and a coherent two-factor structure, with consistent groupings among items related to academic writing, digital communication, critical thinking, and problem-solving.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t19_o4","terms":["item groupings in the two-factor structure: academic writing, digital communication, critical thinking, problem-solving"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"It is recommended to conduct longitudinal, mixed-method, and performance-based studies to more precisely examine its actual effect on university learning.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t19_o5","terms":["recommendation for longitudinal, mixed-method, and performance-based studies on actual learning effects"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t19_o1","t19_o2","@04588ef5a34c56f4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t19_c1","object":"suggestion that ChatGPT can improve the development of critical thinking skills","predicate":"cites_Wang_and_Fan_2025_for","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) cites Wang and Fan 2025 (with Jalil et al., 2023) to support the claim that it has been suggested ChatGPT can improve the development of critical thinking skills."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t19_o1","t19_o3","t19_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t19_c2","object":"consistent item groupings for academic writing, digital communication, critical thinking, and problem-solving via EFA and CFA","predicate":"finds_factor_groupings","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"Using exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses, George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) finds consistent item groupings for academic writing, digital communication, critical thinking, and problem-solving."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t19_o1","t19_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t19_c3","object":"longitudinal, mixed-method, and performance-based studies to measure actual effects on university learning","predicate":"recommends_future_research","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) qualifies its perception-based findings by recommending longitudinal, mixed-method, and performance-based studies to assess ChatGPT's actual effect on university learning."},{"about":["George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t19_q1","needed":"Check the References section of PMC13314867.txt for the full bibliographic entry of Wang and Fan (2025).","text":"Does the reference list of PMC13314867.txt confirm that 'Wang and Fan, 2025' is the retracted meta-analysis 'The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking' (Humanit Soc Sci Commun 2025)?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",0,5475]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"f9272bc0c3545a456704941e83ef583d450563655518aada9eefa8f4bf43c9ed","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["2fb29e43a710ad935fa150c296059c5b270a26504044d7da4f9b473137bcdc70","33dbc45b04e1c60120da627c1d54cfc7daa06280791594c1ffaf092a77c2a9b0","93b12833a64e583c0b5f0b0f0e3c74d6d40bf2cd13fc5835ddb2e76ff3b69f35","814c2fc0a52016056946e3ef34f36a8c1b4db47a00bb3b3cefd8f1341df1259f","bf4a98c085bdee1e09389b6100be7348b0166cff7e29abb9acec523fad81b9bd"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"record was not issued in this context or allowed document scope","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":5}},"request_hash":"4e100bee9fdbe725da00d0a6f25d2b9cedc9403f3466f209e81bde3dac9bc8f7","submission_id":"TR19-51d961343f9ef9dd#1"},"hash":"48269ade9cc00034d0644bb61966780ad5da1be2553d0310afe2080b26797566","header":{"body_hash":"bcaf5f7b483bb8ab25a8049d89bb28d10c4c13f2f2ecf7937a27e267decf8888","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"05f55bcaba949f5fc75b1c24b95d65f15d3b69bf81d4c828bfb3f0573c39e997","records_root":"c61dd3f7a48b3902e8fe4fa63bd05913cedd1453e4f48a415409d2b0566d6f54","seq":87,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"2d306bee1c9880843519edd78425978ab1c3d33b201f9b07208990ee17a673a4","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR19-51d961343f9ef9dd","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t19_o1","t19_o3","t19_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t19_c2","object":"consistent item groupings for academic writing, digital communication, critical thinking, and problem-solving via EFA and CFA","predicate":"finds_factor_groupings","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"Using exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses, George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) finds consistent item groupings for academic writing, digital communication, critical thinking, and problem-solving."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t19_o1","t19_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t19_c3","object":"longitudinal, mixed-method, and performance-based studies to measure actual effects on university learning","predicate":"recommends_future_research","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) qualifies its perception-based findings by recommending longitudinal, mixed-method, and performance-based studies to assess ChatGPT's actual effect on university learning."},{"about":["George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t19_q1","needed":"Check the References section of PMC13314867.txt for the full bibliographic entry of Wang and Fan (2025).","text":"Does the reference list of PMC13314867.txt confirm that 'Wang and Fan, 2025' is the retracted meta-analysis 'The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking' (Humanit Soc Sci Commun 2025)?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",0,5475]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"f9272bc0c3545a456704941e83ef583d450563655518aada9eefa8f4bf43c9ed","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["6177d64ca0d9235d7db60450700c6338b488bc8d5483bf843b84b094d4254ca5","4fc091bf9a9f6801e11120fd8e63cca1722bad42e294aa1c25fa403c29fba91b"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":2}},"request_hash":"2f3b7fb4c0c05ad2ae3a9dfc25d3e1eb9a811ab6b04087cde756f3ddcb20de7c","submission_id":"TR19-51d961343f9ef9dd#1.1"},"hash":"a66cee6e40358d57e09feeb3724bb972dfe53f9b71e3f40da0fa16f476d04e1d","header":{"body_hash":"5832e636e7b0cba91be0f1481373c0cbaa0170ca208aeefcac6067ef9de8ff26","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"48269ade9cc00034d0644bb61966780ad5da1be2553d0310afe2080b26797566","records_root":"354a7b3c6c0689eb47b365c5cc252fc07d79a897e1f812bf84575c26dd0a3dd8","seq":88,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"3c8916d4fd246caf39a7b8575ace0c8f102bcda6d3b04e1a265f5d3b6187d0f8","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@2fb29e43a710ad93","@33dbc45b04e1c601","@93b12833a64e583c","@814c2fc0a5201605","@bf4a98c085bdee1e","@6177d64ca0d9235d","@4fc091bf9a9f6801"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"REQUEST","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"record was not issued in this context or allowed document scope","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":5,"local_id":"t19_c1"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":8,"local_id":"t19_q1"}],"task_id":"TR19-51d961343f9ef9dd","work_key":"reread:PMC13314867.txt#0"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:TR19-51d961343f9ef9dd:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"f9272bc0c3545a456704941e83ef583d450563655518aada9eefa8f4bf43c9ed","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"d7c6f0dd124a17ad8cb4dcf47051b90f4aca429044b5f46f8da482673475db72","submission_id":"TR19-51d961343f9ef9dd#repair1"},"hash":"952ea38cb6ecaf08a4676599f2b4fb4b4a315ec0c23aec90f762b593acb125bb","header":{"body_hash":"800b5400bd8094c6b01313000ae0ba447ce11ca22ebfc79f2e3a9347502555eb","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"a66cee6e40358d57e09feeb3724bb972dfe53f9b71e3f40da0fa16f476d04e1d","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":89,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"d0f8181a3a0434b870faa5cd9857629609319fc23c3a59b582c14b3354294d90","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR19-51d961343f9ef9dd","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t19_o1","t19_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t19_c1","object":"suggestion that ChatGPT can improve the development of critical thinking skills","predicate":"cites_Wang_and_Fan_2025_for","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) cites Wang and Fan 2025 (with Jalil et al., 2023) to support the claim that it has been suggested ChatGPT can improve the development of critical thinking skills."},{"about":["George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t19_q1","needed":"Check the References section of PMC13314867.txt for the full bibliographic entry of Wang and Fan (2025) and match it to the Title line of Wang and Fan 2025.","text":"Does the reference list of PMC13314867.txt confirm that 'Wang and Fan, 2025' is the retracted meta-analysis on ChatGPT, learning performance, perception, and higher-order thinking (Humanit Soc Sci Commun 2025)?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",0,5475]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"f9272bc0c3545a456704941e83ef583d450563655518aada9eefa8f4bf43c9ed","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","3fff5bc4899b793b3afe8da77cdb546c27ce418828487436ec592aab5d154f2d"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"e3ca00455e5617cc848d3d4e3ec5ebb7eecb13dd50e20e9664f889a3dc748daf","submission_id":"TR19-51d961343f9ef9dd#2"},"hash":"dd45b8d13ed38293b3b7aab4b6123272110fe4ae2957efe0cf94a1ce0c710468","header":{"body_hash":"0c36e56dcce332a8c2aa3357043f250862742306cceb1d133df8f9d5339323b2","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"952ea38cb6ecaf08a4676599f2b4fb4b4a315ec0c23aec90f762b593acb125bb","records_root":"8687699f571f191da5a59ec6267c792814e336c585a256e4000593b9793b19cf","seq":90,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"04f0b60803dc79d66dc4ffebe724d8bf31dbdc0463436c627c324c6c75a4c579","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":5,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":5,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:PMC13314867.txt#0"},"sync_step":9,"task_id":"TR19-51d961343f9ef9dd"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:PMC13314867.txt#0","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"f9272bc0c3545a456704941e83ef583d450563655518aada9eefa8f4bf43c9ed","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"4318f9710e0987d3ef1a7ed829a7b9d4d92c7f8489c72051fc63499125741cfe","submission_id":"TR19-51d961343f9ef9dd#done3"},"hash":"06deb3f42a0f8f31810b5c51478e35df9368bb58f7fa5710557c27aa550f9fd0","header":{"body_hash":"23a0b9af34a3743ceb43ab7a9cd010b6859c9be99a25d862387db404dbfa27cc","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"dd45b8d13ed38293b3b7aab4b6123272110fe4ae2957efe0cf94a1ce0c710468","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":91,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"d2e7467b88c98f78e173cd88483879c3984e628bdedc3a084c32b1d44aadf432","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":5,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":256},"started_unix_ms":1795102104436,"wave":{"doc:PMC13314867.txt#0":"reader-2","doc:PMC13314867.txt#1":"reader-3","doc:PMC13314867.txt#2":"reader-1"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"f9272bc0c3545a456704941e83ef583d450563655518aada9eefa8f4bf43c9ed","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"97518f6211e2165c4227350f014a04e8377f3fc85c34306da852b0c3627655e2","submission_id":"circle:e83cb1571058a59fa6435455e522b9dc5bbc0d7e9e47bdba20caa512481e2290"},"hash":"b127e84246c356af9e8c7bcaaf4b58bd57cf5b7190d504b71e74996e62abfd77","header":{"body_hash":"f13c8101c00165ed7f790a9aa56c833ea29488d61c2acb505fab30d22e715281","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"06deb3f42a0f8f31810b5c51478e35df9368bb58f7fa5710557c27aa550f9fd0","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":92,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"193a4cb44ec30e97b2994699c1e8d03f42da49f7879e652c1f60ea15bb294be1","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"d2e7467b88c98f78e173cd88483879c3984e628bdedc3a084c32b1d44aadf432","engine_root":"f9272bc0c3545a456704941e83ef583d450563655518aada9eefa8f4bf43c9ed","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"764dc997a5b90d63b905ec706b2c8ba910ad315a96bb903cab67bc2a60b9086e","log_size":93,"projections":{"dependencies":"b37b9dc4f5e89fc9db771e76fc8b0735e30a4b72dfbf70041ee88d4b88689d66","status":"eeb91244314b9957027602836b8cfd3825b4e6f6cb3aa4872be0df156648f6ee"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"b127e84246c356af9e8c7bcaaf4b58bd57cf5b7190d504b71e74996e62abfd77"}},"engine_root":"f9272bc0c3545a456704941e83ef583d450563655518aada9eefa8f4bf43c9ed","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"d2e7467b88c98f78e173cd88483879c3984e628bdedc3a084c32b1d44aadf432","engine_root":"f9272bc0c3545a456704941e83ef583d450563655518aada9eefa8f4bf43c9ed","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"764dc997a5b90d63b905ec706b2c8ba910ad315a96bb903cab67bc2a60b9086e","log_size":93,"projections":{"dependencies":"b37b9dc4f5e89fc9db771e76fc8b0735e30a4b72dfbf70041ee88d4b88689d66","status":"eeb91244314b9957027602836b8cfd3825b4e6f6cb3aa4872be0df156648f6ee"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"b127e84246c356af9e8c7bcaaf4b58bd57cf5b7190d504b71e74996e62abfd77"},"seal_hash":"77d5006b11a982116a6e5cab59d354130066f892fa90282e02082a2915ffba34"}},"request_hash":"caf43b5b3ce8699b9e03f462013f0a726c7c48607024ac9bea3060958f95f2ed","submission_id":"seal-93"},"hash":"c3c647889c8dc1d27508e6dca2f65fdaa88506dce813ece532d82c87a877f4e0","header":{"body_hash":"fe806ee25f9facd5449808d6914e737c89d9fb57416af7d797282ccbbb8e2fe5","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"b127e84246c356af9e8c7bcaaf4b58bd57cf5b7190d504b71e74996e62abfd77","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":93,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"98a944d5c7f4901a6e0a136d5491c0d33424850f9162ba0000bd25852307bb3f","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"epoch":10,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102104436},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"f9272bc0c3545a456704941e83ef583d450563655518aada9eefa8f4bf43c9ed","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"f05d2e6c294f71a47154a2f9cdab62cfe7398756aac274b7d758bcc58098f488","submission_id":"ring-members:e5a92e2fee3b8211574f28ce55cee1f5151bddbd576ef86b7f401fce9c3a0224"},"hash":"ba7d866974c0219f908e5763bb6679d22113dfdc0faaee82491f7dd835c98206","header":{"body_hash":"324ded0a9ba42c47ff76a4742c74ca693cb4dc688e2454fbe44c1f1cb9ccc2f2","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"c3c647889c8dc1d27508e6dca2f65fdaa88506dce813ece532d82c87a877f4e0","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":94,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"8dcee2cf7888f40b8f012d9925ec1efef8612a09b0228834d5a4b7d45f44b3fd","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":6,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":256},"started_unix_ms":1795102104460,"wave":{"doc:PMC13314867.txt#3":"reader-3","doc:PMC13314867.txt#4":"reader-1","doc:PMC13314867.txt#5":"reader-2"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"f9272bc0c3545a456704941e83ef583d450563655518aada9eefa8f4bf43c9ed","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"762e35294bb84a0293b3e88d699d398fb96d2e0a2a300fc9fd5b432c2e2e27de","submission_id":"circle:56785dbfa27b7101c725bd8225a6b35689c2bedd79080579a732729cd58a69b5"},"hash":"b02ea168ee8a73b76470f614a9cfadeae36f89b8e42c32fa767cc044e1e9091d","header":{"body_hash":"bef5ffc2dcac58f9d01063c23d57a49e34071ffe762e17e950768fda613c1842","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ba7d866974c0219f908e5763bb6679d22113dfdc0faaee82491f7dd835c98206","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":95,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"c1f71478f0f67cf3810e79362d4a7c1328fff49240b68891bc67830e0a2c7a60","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"8dcee2cf7888f40b8f012d9925ec1efef8612a09b0228834d5a4b7d45f44b3fd","engine_root":"f9272bc0c3545a456704941e83ef583d450563655518aada9eefa8f4bf43c9ed","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"c0067d7fe42782296a5691d8388992eff94a1b8b1e7eb1b9e8c38f75ca7eebed","log_size":96,"projections":{"dependencies":"b37b9dc4f5e89fc9db771e76fc8b0735e30a4b72dfbf70041ee88d4b88689d66","status":"eeb91244314b9957027602836b8cfd3825b4e6f6cb3aa4872be0df156648f6ee"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"b02ea168ee8a73b76470f614a9cfadeae36f89b8e42c32fa767cc044e1e9091d"}},"engine_root":"f9272bc0c3545a456704941e83ef583d450563655518aada9eefa8f4bf43c9ed","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"8dcee2cf7888f40b8f012d9925ec1efef8612a09b0228834d5a4b7d45f44b3fd","engine_root":"f9272bc0c3545a456704941e83ef583d450563655518aada9eefa8f4bf43c9ed","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"c0067d7fe42782296a5691d8388992eff94a1b8b1e7eb1b9e8c38f75ca7eebed","log_size":96,"projections":{"dependencies":"b37b9dc4f5e89fc9db771e76fc8b0735e30a4b72dfbf70041ee88d4b88689d66","status":"eeb91244314b9957027602836b8cfd3825b4e6f6cb3aa4872be0df156648f6ee"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"b02ea168ee8a73b76470f614a9cfadeae36f89b8e42c32fa767cc044e1e9091d"},"seal_hash":"7fbddd730e65a81476b8566c0f699868430344982827542ccb66309e94121b77"}},"request_hash":"b1e7b3c49202867e84c4006ed1f27f0826d036a8702f33a8b7bb23bb941517eb","submission_id":"seal-96"},"hash":"e41ccd8c7343809fa640957545c4035fc343742123b56c576ef5948220c0767d","header":{"body_hash":"7f4af33717ffb5cdb809b6aa437258857ada70eac05f268a52268079409267a6","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"b02ea168ee8a73b76470f614a9cfadeae36f89b8e42c32fa767cc044e1e9091d","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":96,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"a9c937adde9e829d8db7c9baad181ecd08c7ef1edf7061d5f3ee976d4d097434","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"epoch":11,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102104460},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"f9272bc0c3545a456704941e83ef583d450563655518aada9eefa8f4bf43c9ed","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"95b7a3550f1e3fb6eddcecb75fff4590ec0cbdff7f412de923113168f9c211c9","submission_id":"ring-members:8d59ea15e0ad95dded30b948174e691bcb3594870a834fc3cde5a863b83f691c"},"hash":"cfa7fb9321d0281cbd32c5ce2e731810d82ad2dca8c0ea2e8e2afdb205666911","header":{"body_hash":"a8ad307cb9006a907e51fa4ac9f203caad10cf31bf30601cf001e19fca8fe12f","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"e41ccd8c7343809fa640957545c4035fc343742123b56c576ef5948220c0767d","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":97,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"9e2085d313f3e067c6be0562ee8bdc0a73d7bed027cf5fe14180a3414582aff6","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T20-8731f7b7dd97c11b","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"providing a validated instrument that makes it possible to analyze the pedagogical use of artificial intelligence systems such as ChatGPT from the students' perspective.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t20_o1","terms":["validated instrument","ChatGPT","students' perspective"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"However, these contributions must be interpreted within the limits of perceptual data, since the findings do not demonstrate that ChatGPT directly improves communicative or analytical skills.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t20_o2","terms":["perceptual data limitation","communicative skills","analytical skills"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"First, the sample consisted only of students with prior experience using ChatGPT, which excludes the views of non-users or occasional users who may hold different perceptions.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t20_o3","terms":["sample limitation","prior experience using ChatGPT"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Second, the concentration of participants in three countries (Ecuador, Mexico, and Chile) may limit the generalizability of the findings across the broader Latin American region.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t20_o4","terms":["generalizability limitation","Ecuador, Mexico, and Chile"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"the cross-sectional design does not allow causal inferences or conclusions about the actual educational effects of ChatGPT on student learning or performance.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t20_o5","terms":["cross-sectional design","no causal inferences","actual educational effects"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"if the same sample of 2,579 respondents was used for both the exploratory factor analysis and the confirmatory factor analysis, this should be recognized as a methodological limitation","kind":"observe","local_id":"t20_o6","terms":["2,579 respondents","EFA and CFA single sample limitation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"COVID-19 Social Science Lab (2024a). ChatGPT Student Survey. Available online at: https://www.covidsoclab.org/chatgpt-student-survey/ (Accessed January 3, 2026).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t20_o7","terms":["COVID-19 Social Science Lab 2024a","ChatGPT Student Survey reference"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t20_o1","t20_o2","t20_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t20_c1","object":"perceptual findings and cross-sectional design do not demonstrate direct skill improvement or causal effects on learning/performance","predicate":"qualifies_conclusions","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 concludes that its validated instrument and cross-country perceptual findings do not demonstrate that ChatGPT directly improves communicative or analytical skills or allows causal inferences on learning or performance."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t20_o3","t20_o4","t20_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t20_c2","object":"exclusion of non-users, concentration in Ecuador/Mexico/Chile, and potential model-fit overestimation from running EFA and CFA on the same 2,579 respondents","predicate":"reports_limitations","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 notes that its sample of 2,579 respondents excluded non-users, concentrated in Ecuador, Mexico, and Chile, and using the single dataset for both EFA and CFA may overestimate model fit."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t20_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t20_c3","object":"COVID-19 Social Science Lab (2024a) ChatGPT Student Survey","predicate":"cites_dataset","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 cites the COVID-19 Social Science Lab (2024a) ChatGPT Student Survey in its reference list."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",28966,34950]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"f95f070c3c439c7fce8b3f044d6ed4f997215728f44a43850fa3143e2715d858","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["b319f7b38290998a06835d6b4cb8e9f9abba55947f8c1329fa45abae0fbfb9e5","86b606c8c70adbfbc1db885323470191d9d2e09d92bb9c170300f3c15e8e8301","5888c1033a23102e92b7dd23f4bc3d308aa28f743603a37e5f714873da12cde2","17e3f4f4babc2861be8b7e5266bc1251cd591d36609d663d0ed834413efd7c2e","9d807115d2b186abcb5172a8fca9f20c91a5652dee8bf4720f69de48ea7d6a64","35ed46e8f2973248f5500e3c55f1dded62532fcdef5ff9674ac412eadaade920","64a0865c448995ae7964609428a75397f4b7bcfd0421032ee891704dbc3272f1","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","827276118d64cdbc1b18906cc98cc8158b87b10d2d9ed8359d3273631f1a165e","d074545e1e954165633f28a981557a4578da0ec523af174892d6b2c8ed3be05b"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"d705c073f85fcce712523c3b7454c5136d8d7e79329a756a70ed95cf2102c4d3","submission_id":"T20-8731f7b7dd97c11b#1"},"hash":"535e453a1ee158ffde47177e21fc0d81ed32aa592a1bcf9768625b9c9a62d296","header":{"body_hash":"69629829dd25b0ce02ea7e42baad9fc63f842bb53ce7287fc5464ffb3a618f3b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"cfa7fb9321d0281cbd32c5ce2e731810d82ad2dca8c0ea2e8e2afdb205666911","records_root":"8674a3241c6cf0f295a9e9ee2c1183a67e9199e73a24150357294f0b158109c6","seq":98,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"0e174b248389f590f9142af06c80ad2a89e59f500d7e7a2ce98d85850c2bf89e","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":6,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":11,"task_id":"T20-8731f7b7dd97c11b"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13314867.txt#5","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"f95f070c3c439c7fce8b3f044d6ed4f997215728f44a43850fa3143e2715d858","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"428f78e6b4f0148ecdfa8b9ccd4677ad439b83f6b740df23c9023f7fde76d30e","submission_id":"T20-8731f7b7dd97c11b#done2"},"hash":"8f6bd12607521f61a8f6a06049e46efb078e5f2aaf150e55080ad005bc46270e","header":{"body_hash":"9896f140320d9e35316094b0f5602ee0a73b97086a24509f90474bd539407b7b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"535e453a1ee158ffde47177e21fc0d81ed32aa592a1bcf9768625b9c9a62d296","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":99,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"6877326c655fe2347471e2cb24fe67da8d1cc8f4b8db940c86cf008372137294","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T22-5b37583865610ba1","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"In contrast, items associated with analytical and problem solving skills (Q29b–Q29e) cluster with high loadings on the second component, with values ranging from 0.73 to 0.91.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t22_o1","terms":["PCA second component","analytical and problem solving skills","Q29b-Q29e"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"However, some items such as Q28f present moderate and shared loadings, suggesting intersections between both dimensions and a possible transversal influence of ChatGPT on hybrid competencies","kind":"observe","local_id":"t22_o2","terms":["Q28f shared loadings","hybrid competencies","dimension intersection"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The exploratory factor analysis presented in Table 5 confirms the statistical adequacy of the model by showing a significant chi square test (χ2 = 4,365.694; df = 118; p < 0.001).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t22_o3","terms":["EFA chi square test","Table 5","model statistical adequacy"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The rotation performed allows the identification of two differentiated factors: the first concentrates the highest loadings on items related to analytical and problem solving skills (Q29b–Q29e","kind":"observe","local_id":"t22_o4","terms":["EFA rotation","two differentiated factors","analytical and problem solving skills"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"while the second consistently groups items related to written and digital communication (Q28a–Q28g), with loadings ranging from 0.54 to 0.87.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t22_o5","terms":["EFA second factor","written and digital communication","Q28a-Q28g"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The magnitude and distribution of these factor loadings demonstrate that the instrument measures in a differentiated manner two key competencies: communicative and analytical.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t22_o6","terms":["structural validity","communicative and analytical competencies"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"In addition, the uniqueness reported in several items (with values between 0.29 and 0.50) supports the robustness of the model, showing that a large proportion of the variance of the items is explained","kind":"observe","local_id":"t22_o7","terms":["item uniqueness","variance explained","model robustness"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"In the factor loading plot shown in Figure 2, items Q28a and Q28b, which assess improvement in academic and professional writing, display high loadings on the first factor","kind":"observe","local_id":"t22_o8","terms":["Q28a and Q28b","academic and professional writing"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Likewise, items Q28g, Q28h, and Q28i, linked to digital communication skills, are concentrated in a common direction, empirically validating their grouping under the second factor.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t22_o9","terms":["Q28g, Q28h, Q28i","digital communication skills"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"On the other hand, items Q29b, Q29c, Q29d, and Q29e are more strongly oriented toward the axis of the first factor, suggesting a solid factorial structure around critical thinking, problem solving, and quantitative skills.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t22_o10","terms":["Q29b-Q29e","critical thinking, problem solving, and quantitative skills"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"A confirmatory factor analysis was conducted. The baseline model, which assumes total independence among the items, presented a value of χ2 = 79,740.444 with 153 degrees of freedom, indicating poor fit.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t22_o11","terms":["CFA baseline model","chi square 79740.444","df 153"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"In contrast, the factorial model, which incorporates the expected latent structure of the instrument, substantially reduced the statistic to χ2 = 9,725.779 with 134 degrees of freedom and a significance level of p < 0.001.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t22_o12","terms":["CFA factorial model","chi square 9725.779","df 134"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Table 6 presents robust and statistically significant estimates for the 18 items grouped into two factors. All loading values exceed the recommended minimum threshold of 0.70, with values ranging from 0.829 to 1.191","kind":"observe","local_id":"t22_o13","terms":["CFA Table 6","18 items in two factors","loadings 0.829 to 1.191"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t22_o11","t22_o12","t22_o13"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t22_c2","object":"two-factor CFA fit (χ2=9,725.779, df=134, p<0.001 vs. baseline χ2=79,740.444, df=153) with 18 item estimates from 0.829 to 1.191","predicate":"reports_cfa_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"In PMC13314867, CFA supports the two-factor structure across the 18 items, reducing χ2 from 79,740.444 (df=153) in the baseline model to 9,725.779 (df=134, p<0.001), with all item factor estimates ranging from 0.829 to 1.191 (p<0.001)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t22_o1","t22_o2","t22_o8","t22_o9","t22_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t22_c3","object":"moderate shared loadings on items such as Q28f indicate intersections between communicative and analytical dimensions (hybrid competencies)","predicate":"qualifies_factor_structure","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 notes that while communicative (writing Q28a–Q28b; digital communication Q28g–Q28i) and analytical/quantitative items (Q29b–Q29e) separate clearly, shared loadings on items like Q28f suggest intersecting hybrid competencies."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",17444,23436]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"4d0a7cc689549ab6762c4bab8b1a855191b622c27dc2a65ec5465b03b8d85c48","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["b8f9b5b3ecc2e50104619820a077e9b1c2a6f64815a27f3ac9213fb9dfec1c4a","225106e92527618cfa7606e2c97e8891e23439eac8b8a112c764e1ab42751e99","3dd10752fd5051f4fed5a926ccad10c6fb99fc63618a013c872981df5df1814d","d63eb41a760dc52a5a9324f0edb8cd81c75c6ed78142290553952b7a7410f214","c0c6fa3eb98f673d1053efaf46c1d7574f3c5498eaf421e494d12c27fa77db6b","a15f4c3d5d2367acbb0281d54f0b245ffe4dd072eb4cba1ddc780fc1d920f8a6","b9a43e16b5db2cb4571d60df498390846118ef1cb70e672c6bea4adef32854a4","4ecd231afff1be8779553a6b42e33809aadb65415a5623a8a09c35b973802dd6","c8734d261ace53008157d61ad28d27a883dd8af6e769d0cbefff9eba6ee8936f","9185d8e5df0e0209da1f458e61909c1132f793bd3ed2913dcbad37087d60752d","83ea55e2cdc8fa0c752020f7191d9e5aea7b1b61de7e7ecad6f27458f21c2f0a","c8e3f255c060ad77bb7a3ad5322fbc71d23843a4209605fb248c1223f8f13eca","b24c2d613e9ba2076c4eaefb37afc995fbee36e687161365b4f13246a71408f1","f7a7d13375d7593cadd49c6bc13a2bca09b8a557339f6a4044642d7ef9ba2d3e","4d13d72da28bc83f16bdfa51ac0d55066556c5bbff3f60ce05017d3537c42164"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"f5ec6ca85f699d2610cf72f5bdfd607101701ceb20b607df8412a83ee07994a6","submission_id":"T22-5b37583865610ba1#1"},"hash":"737b6e4646dab51fce5083925d2cff14374f523488cd04681194f6c526caedd5","header":{"body_hash":"7475fe4f474276e171e0580d6792fb89a50485551a799506f928e991e3599b3e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"8f6bd12607521f61a8f6a06049e46efb078e5f2aaf150e55080ad005bc46270e","records_root":"5bf06883faa4fd328f6ffe81a1b4808bd240e74503f8b4a39d240366fefee0b7","seq":100,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"29ead5d4ac771600468e0512b541bc63e5efa05649ef0be3e9e2a14849ec9255","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@b8f9b5b3ecc2e501","@225106e92527618c","@3dd10752fd5051f4","@d63eb41a760dc52a","@c0c6fa3eb98f673d","@a15f4c3d5d2367ac","@b9a43e16b5db2cb4","@4ecd231afff1be87","@c8734d261ace5300","@9185d8e5df0e0209","@83ea55e2cdc8fa0c","@c8e3f255c060ad77","@b24c2d613e9ba207","@f7a7d13375d7593c","@4d13d72da28bc83f"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"NO_EVIDENCE","expected_by_kernel":{"missing_identifiers":["0.73"]},"field":"based_on","message":"a claim names only identifiers its quotes hold: add a quote of this section that holds each one listed, or leave it out of the claim","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":13,"local_id":"t22_c1"}],"task_id":"T22-5b37583865610ba1","work_key":"doc:PMC13314867.txt#3"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T22-5b37583865610ba1:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"4d0a7cc689549ab6762c4bab8b1a855191b622c27dc2a65ec5465b03b8d85c48","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"d49b63b50c8b4be3097fb05f8ed3967a305be2721846c83afb88c1c7cd9c756d","submission_id":"T22-5b37583865610ba1#repair1"},"hash":"149e59528b9575ae758d8a18380cb50e2dc69d75f4b847cc1e1dbfa546e9ba72","header":{"body_hash":"608f288ea233edf871ebde2e8fd34d04b81ce56a56e6edde160e82c673b42190","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"737b6e4646dab51fce5083925d2cff14374f523488cd04681194f6c526caedd5","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":101,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"37a4b3c21c2e6f370c391bd43672e47518741b5aa5cdd0d3cd541ccb8c8ae1a4","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T21-e573e86f767c8722","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"In line with Crompton and Burke (2023) and Wang and Fan (2025), these results support the importance of psychometrically sound instruments for examining educational phenomena related to artificial intelligence.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t21_o1","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025 citation","psychometrically sound instruments","artificial intelligence in education"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The high values of Cronbach's alpha (α = 0.943) and McDonald's omega (ω = 0.944), which remain stable even when individual items are removed, suggest that the scale reliably captures a homogeneous construct.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t21_o2","terms":["Cronbach's alpha 0.943","McDonald's omega 0.944","internal consistency"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The structural model represented in Figure 3 confirms a moderate correlation between the factors (r = 0.49).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t21_o3","terms":["structural model","factor correlation r = 0.49"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The standardized factor loadings of the items range from 0.86 to 1.00 for Fc1 and from 1.00 to 1.19 for Fc2, indicating a strong association between the items and their respective factors.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t21_o4","terms":["standardized factor loadings","Fc1 0.86 to 1.00","Fc2 1.00 to 1.19"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Likewise, the variance of the factors (0.80 for Fc1 and 0.52 for Fc2) suggests that a substantial proportion of the variance of the items is explained by the latent constructs.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t21_o5","terms":["factor variance","Fc1 0.80","Fc2 0.52"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Importantly, these findings should be interpreted as evidence of the instrument's capacity to consistently measure students' perceptions regarding ChatGPT's contribution to skill development, rather than as direct evidence of actual improvements in communicative or analytical competencies.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t21_o6","terms":["perception measure qualification","not direct evidence of actual skill improvement"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The principal components analysis revealed two coherent groupings corresponding to perceived communicative and analytical skills.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t21_o7","terms":["principal components analysis","perceived communicative and analytical skills"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The distinction between communicative and analytical dimensions, along with their moderate correlation (r = 0.49), suggests that students perceive these skill areas as related but conceptually independent.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t21_o8","terms":["communicative and analytical dimensions","moderate correlation r = 0.49","conceptually independent"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"However, the interpretation of these results must remain within the scope of perception-based data, avoiding causal claims about the actual educational effectiveness of ChatGPT.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t21_o9","terms":["perception-based data scope","avoiding causal claims"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The present study provides empirical evidence regarding the structural validity and high reliability of an instrument designed to assess university students' perceptions of ChatGPT's contribution to the development of communicative and analytical skills in Latin America.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t21_o10","terms":["structural validity","high reliability","university students in Latin America"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses revealed a coherent, differentiated, and theoretically grounded two-factor structure, while the internal consistency coefficients (α = 0.943; ω = 0.944) confirmed the psychometric stability of the questionnaire.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t21_o11","terms":["EFA and CFA","two-factor structure","psychometric stability"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"These findings support the use of the instrument as a reliable tool for examining how students perceive the role of generative artificial intelligence in relation to key academic skill domains, rather than as a measure of actual skill acquisition or direct educational effects.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t21_o12","terms":["reliable tool for student perceptions","not a measure of actual skill acquisition"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t21_o1","t21_o2","@04588ef5a34c56f4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t21_c1","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (importance of psychometrically sound instruments for examining AI-related educational phenomena)","predicate":"supports_statement_with","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 cites Wang and Fan 2025 alongside Crompton and Burke (2023) to support the importance of psychometrically sound instruments for examining AI-related educational phenomena after reporting α=0.943 and ω=0.944."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t21_o1","t21_o2","@e8912985e6037b25"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t21_c2","object":"Wang and Fan 2025","predicate":"cites_meta_analysis","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"In its Discussion, PMC13314867 cites Wang and Fan 2025 to support that high internal consistency (α=0.943, ω=0.944) underscores the importance of psychometrically sound instruments for studying AI in education."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t21_o3","t21_o4","t21_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t21_c3","object":"factor correlation r=0.49; loadings 0.86-1.00 (Fc1) and 1.00-1.19 (Fc2); factor variances 0.80 (Fc1) and 0.52 (Fc2)","predicate":"reports_structural_model_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 reports that the structural model confirms a moderate factor correlation (r=0.49), standardized loadings of 0.86-1.00 for Fc1 and 1.00-1.19 for Fc2, and factor variances of 0.80 for Fc1 and 0.52 for Fc2."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t21_o7","t21_o8","t21_o10","t21_o11"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t21_c4","object":"structural validity, high reliability (α=0.943, ω=0.944), and two-factor (communicative and analytical) structure with r=0.49","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 concludes from PCA, EFA, CFA, and internal consistency (α=0.943; ω=0.944) that its questionnaire has structural validity and reliability as a two-factor measure of perceived communicative and analytical skills in Latin America."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t21_o6","t21_o9","t21_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t21_c5","object":"findings measure perceived contribution to communicative and analytical skills, not actual skill acquisition or causal educational effectiveness","predicate":"qualifies_conclusion","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 qualifies its conclusions by stating the instrument measures students' perceptions of ChatGPT's role in communicative and analytical skills rather than actual skill acquisition, measurable gains, or causal educational effects."},{"about":["PMC13314867","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t21_q1","needed":"Check the References section of PMC13314867.txt for the Wang and Fan (2025) entry and match it to the Title line of the meta-analysis record.","text":"Does the reference list of PMC13314867 confirm that 'Wang and Fan (2025)' refers to the retracted meta-analysis 'The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis'?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",23436,28966]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"191052810fda6086d8a8da1a8c5834f00d4780b83a220f9cfbeba1181ea850d5","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["35f55c061bdf705ea3d77e178182abeb6f3ca3b87da08350c384848651b48b40","34d4fb6f8ed13a7c0fe2cdbf3774538b15dfa58cbe04981cbddd4a56e6da0565","d122081cea9c88b121667bef6b130ac13ec2cc6276793a2fd385d0664328d927","9b8b976b6ddb7c635351a34be1b5c0f7173dfcae60f41b16b8e481ce0810ae6b","95b153035be514ba8836b988c585979154af013a17daf2de5fa26ad595f5f6e0","a370f962cbeeb263a7d46489b934ceb70cb7c1575c525defb19eede11de0d2c5","54c2520117d397eddd8d9ac35a3b6a94379533788aa9d203a5afcf71c3656e9b","795d578b1a001a00e899a5c976fab8bd06e246e0e0525ab36f04d792e40ef7ed","2f53e5eb943013cd525dbd6a5ff1d8bae04896f0f07cdcaa6404c3d862872c8f","1d0e6954a21f610903727e4e8b986078b0a738669d0ca0ff56cc1c86ea722721","bd8f2470831e2078e3e64c8b80d75e55019328a342d427fe6f79212da3c9de69","6f730d119ee0af0e67265f3d6328b9108997251f0549a3bdd419ff13ad591ee6"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"record was not issued in this context or allowed document scope","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":12}},"request_hash":"69bfc600461dc87a3120e8982761e917e19c9aad5b8a5c43d1e5f3472c8d026a","submission_id":"T21-e573e86f767c8722#1"},"hash":"b3e5c49075ec55c64fbc8bbb2d25e8cf56d17b6a68147a7c90057d78e2965b44","header":{"body_hash":"909b6e10fcb8c97ebb0e6b7be6081ad9c7c67a425aca3137bb71aad4295a7f87","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"149e59528b9575ae758d8a18380cb50e2dc69d75f4b847cc1e1dbfa546e9ba72","records_root":"b83b6ced8a220b501b55c3eb6542c345694e2c59cf0f94e15e30365eea9519af","seq":102,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"146b519f9572959bcec1e64ee0a87120b0c6ca0048eb69ecb501358eb5cb6494","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T21-e573e86f767c8722","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t21_o1","t21_o2","@e8912985e6037b25"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t21_c2","object":"Wang and Fan 2025","predicate":"cites_meta_analysis","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"In its Discussion, PMC13314867 cites Wang and Fan 2025 to support that high internal consistency (α=0.943, ω=0.944) underscores the importance of psychometrically sound instruments for studying AI in education."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t21_o3","t21_o4","t21_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t21_c3","object":"factor correlation r=0.49; loadings 0.86-1.00 (Fc1) and 1.00-1.19 (Fc2); factor variances 0.80 (Fc1) and 0.52 (Fc2)","predicate":"reports_structural_model_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 reports that the structural model confirms a moderate factor correlation (r=0.49), standardized loadings of 0.86-1.00 for Fc1 and 1.00-1.19 for Fc2, and factor variances of 0.80 for Fc1 and 0.52 for Fc2."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t21_o7","t21_o8","t21_o10","t21_o11"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t21_c4","object":"structural validity, high reliability (α=0.943, ω=0.944), and two-factor (communicative and analytical) structure with r=0.49","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 concludes from PCA, EFA, CFA, and internal consistency (α=0.943; ω=0.944) that its questionnaire has structural validity and reliability as a two-factor measure of perceived communicative and analytical skills in Latin America."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t21_o6","t21_o9","t21_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t21_c5","object":"findings measure perceived contribution to communicative and analytical skills, not actual skill acquisition or causal educational effectiveness","predicate":"qualifies_conclusion","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 qualifies its conclusions by stating the instrument measures students' perceptions of ChatGPT's role in communicative and analytical skills rather than actual skill acquisition, measurable gains, or causal educational effects."},{"about":["PMC13314867","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t21_q1","needed":"Check the References section of PMC13314867.txt for the Wang and Fan (2025) entry and match it to the Title line of the meta-analysis record.","text":"Does the reference list of PMC13314867 confirm that 'Wang and Fan (2025)' refers to the retracted meta-analysis 'The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis'?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",23436,28966]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"191052810fda6086d8a8da1a8c5834f00d4780b83a220f9cfbeba1181ea850d5","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":[],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"record was not issued in this context or allowed document scope","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":0}},"request_hash":"92dc1fc14428b1d372bfeeaa049ba7d9c49406f50e2db5a5271e0ec1a4ab11ce","submission_id":"T21-e573e86f767c8722#1.1"},"hash":"d19a71af4f7d7ddb22b7934e8029e61f51e941dce9f5e940d00ed31c383ff4c1","header":{"body_hash":"8816c4b7d2e7717f3ad28033409089995e6e2a951f81b2906864bf5ae87afc86","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"b3e5c49075ec55c64fbc8bbb2d25e8cf56d17b6a68147a7c90057d78e2965b44","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":103,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"230c7148d94d4cc6de5563cbae455d958ccc4f39e950abd7bc0e3340da0c0601","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T21-e573e86f767c8722","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t21_o3","t21_o4","t21_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t21_c3","object":"factor correlation r=0.49; loadings 0.86-1.00 (Fc1) and 1.00-1.19 (Fc2); factor variances 0.80 (Fc1) and 0.52 (Fc2)","predicate":"reports_structural_model_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 reports that the structural model confirms a moderate factor correlation (r=0.49), standardized loadings of 0.86-1.00 for Fc1 and 1.00-1.19 for Fc2, and factor variances of 0.80 for Fc1 and 0.52 for Fc2."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t21_o7","t21_o8","t21_o10","t21_o11"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t21_c4","object":"structural validity, high reliability (α=0.943, ω=0.944), and two-factor (communicative and analytical) structure with r=0.49","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 concludes from PCA, EFA, CFA, and internal consistency (α=0.943; ω=0.944) that its questionnaire has structural validity and reliability as a two-factor measure of perceived communicative and analytical skills in Latin America."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t21_o6","t21_o9","t21_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t21_c5","object":"findings measure perceived contribution to communicative and analytical skills, not actual skill acquisition or causal educational effectiveness","predicate":"qualifies_conclusion","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 qualifies its conclusions by stating the instrument measures students' perceptions of ChatGPT's role in communicative and analytical skills rather than actual skill acquisition, measurable gains, or causal educational effects."},{"about":["PMC13314867","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t21_q1","needed":"Check the References section of PMC13314867.txt for the Wang and Fan (2025) entry and match it to the Title line of the meta-analysis record.","text":"Does the reference list of PMC13314867 confirm that 'Wang and Fan (2025)' refers to the retracted meta-analysis 'The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis'?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",23436,28966]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"191052810fda6086d8a8da1a8c5834f00d4780b83a220f9cfbeba1181ea850d5","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["f2aa54bbba67e3813ea7cd7ea64a3e9ec48ce0002365dc57b9c2aff2b635e219","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","919379b48cec048c79fcf2e746f053d6ba9b7c8b74ac983ea6fa8df54afc109f"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":3}},"request_hash":"2776b558069b889d57dc986fb39301507d84ec84618b0373edfb6d113cafa055","submission_id":"T21-e573e86f767c8722#1.2"},"hash":"54426b01f4209692ad1569d5f65790b73a367149a7fb35a676012bc78164bfb2","header":{"body_hash":"099eebef58ccb6e6c053b372876fbbe6efb02e6b7dbe188ea4573f3db3ca5ca7","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"d19a71af4f7d7ddb22b7934e8029e61f51e941dce9f5e940d00ed31c383ff4c1","records_root":"6b57897d99d87ba70de214175889c9b8dd250213014565c1dc928374949851ef","seq":104,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"138f6e586f89350bfa503611d8c24c3c77510b6a82388bd7139c12a93571ea8e","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@35f55c061bdf705e","@34d4fb6f8ed13a7c","@d122081cea9c88b1","@9b8b976b6ddb7c63","@95b153035be514ba","@a370f962cbeeb263","@54c2520117d397ed","@795d578b1a001a00","@2f53e5eb943013cd","@1d0e6954a21f6109","@bd8f2470831e2078","@6f730d119ee0af0e","@f2aa54bbba67e381","@8db5d947ff639e76","@919379b48cec048c"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"record was not issued in this context or allowed document scope","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":12,"local_id":"t21_c1"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"record was not issued in this context or allowed document scope","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":13,"local_id":"t21_c2"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":17,"local_id":"t21_q1"}],"task_id":"T21-e573e86f767c8722","work_key":"doc:PMC13314867.txt#4"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T21-e573e86f767c8722:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"191052810fda6086d8a8da1a8c5834f00d4780b83a220f9cfbeba1181ea850d5","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"013bbaeb79e69b691903fc0b61c836b4eac7482705a5d00d422404cf3e36315b","submission_id":"T21-e573e86f767c8722#repair1"},"hash":"b5a84171ecdcaca240057340caf015ab0582fd0fd5cffb519a4bc1c28fb5e5b4","header":{"body_hash":"647b02735bf5cffe26350dadfc9db9b3d572b932ce1c435d075aabb19dcbcfdf","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"54426b01f4209692ad1569d5f65790b73a367149a7fb35a676012bc78164bfb2","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":105,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"d1594cea16aca3275d79676a5ce6760b36950eb30c7093c0b5da1727603b5c25","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T22-5b37583865610ba1","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t22_o3","t22_o4","t22_o5","t22_o6","t22_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t22_c1","object":"two factors (χ2=4,365.694, df=118, p<0.001): analytical/problem-solving (Q29b–Q29e) and written/digital communication (Q28a–Q28g), with item uniqueness 0.29–0.50","predicate":"reports_efa_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"In PMC13314867, EFA (χ2=4,365.694, df=118, p<0.001) identifies two factors differentiating analytical/problem-solving skills (Q29b–Q29e) and written/digital communication (Q28a–Q28g, loadings 0.54–0.87)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",17444,23436]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"191052810fda6086d8a8da1a8c5834f00d4780b83a220f9cfbeba1181ea850d5","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["9884ec5f6cfd4209a58f13aba718d240476eda27b02f5bf2306fd976e059d1d3"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"c749e2bb5c034ae62895b64477970d70c179daf92ffb46cb07a5c8bb5ea5bd2d","submission_id":"T22-5b37583865610ba1#2"},"hash":"b84304e839016d62c9ecc4b84a08a5c3f27ac4133e07dee56592acfa912fa07c","header":{"body_hash":"1cad18685aaea8d6932ed03e45981ddfa64e574de68e8af5421d8aa16bfbbdb4","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"b5a84171ecdcaca240057340caf015ab0582fd0fd5cffb519a4bc1c28fb5e5b4","records_root":"83da96cfdb4d6d43b0f191c2088cb55739658d45c447b9a8acd48d65a96c841e","seq":106,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"2b57be2959be26a24583f86f8341aaa4f0fe18db476306797d49e3ff2e08ed85","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":false,"agent":"reader-3","circle":6,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":16,"refusals":1,"stored":16,"sync_step":11,"task_id":"T22-5b37583865610ba1"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13314867.txt#3","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"191052810fda6086d8a8da1a8c5834f00d4780b83a220f9cfbeba1181ea850d5","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"f22fad175b8e7813ddeba5d8adb5fa3ffa859f1fdee2ac18c19db83871c79eba","submission_id":"T22-5b37583865610ba1#done3"},"hash":"50c9d9a95f897f4b6983b7d8712f3b1bffed69eac7d3b89d167cfac2eb0cdd14","header":{"body_hash":"c7f7190564d736c67625c273195e22a9c6d9a5217be0115e9ccc4f2e9e16e3c3","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"b84304e839016d62c9ecc4b84a08a5c3f27ac4133e07dee56592acfa912fa07c","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":107,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"dc6ff60bfd6ab1d614aaab6b829c0be0840839bddc67768816208e6a1d7fab48","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T21-e573e86f767c8722","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t21_o1","t21_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t21_c1","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (importance of psychometrically sound instruments for examining AI-related educational phenomena)","predicate":"supports_statement_with","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 cites Wang and Fan 2025 alongside Crompton and Burke (2023) to support the importance of psychometrically sound instruments for examining AI-related educational phenomena after reporting α=0.943 and ω=0.944."},{"about":["PMC13314867","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t21_q1","needed":"Check the References section of PMC13314867.txt for the Wang and Fan (2025) entry and match it to the Title line of the meta-analysis record.","text":"Does the reference list of PMC13314867 confirm that 'Wang and Fan (2025)' refers to the retracted meta-analysis by Wang J and Fan W (2025) on the effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, perception, and higher-order thinking?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",23436,28966]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"191052810fda6086d8a8da1a8c5834f00d4780b83a220f9cfbeba1181ea850d5","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["181c36a3bc29675f5a0bbc1baf3b0b42d0997104f355ddab1a101dee30085cda","feb61873ac96c753deb657dbf747c000cbf3bcaa85ca4c6ddbe9e9df68788fd9"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"287646df4cd4a9feff63fc8cf0aed7fc28c7d6cb3abfef8b398c0e575b7d587c","submission_id":"T21-e573e86f767c8722#2"},"hash":"619945e4d685557c7e23cecdf03e33fce7ef63bb7b726c74425a2ab4a2d27c26","header":{"body_hash":"b98fbb3ebb01d86f8e7032954bc091fa35d65319037e3b1e0e6345b6b83421cf","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"50c9d9a95f897f4b6983b7d8712f3b1bffed69eac7d3b89d167cfac2eb0cdd14","records_root":"babbe80508a1932864308e9e16b70cf2658dc7159e687eb8e2ca4ca966f6ccd7","seq":108,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"0527fdbc5cffa91f24acaaf4635d4dd5b2e2ca658ca83e1b6ce98352e746a53d","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":false,"agent":"reader-1","circle":6,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":18,"refusals":1,"stored":17,"sync_step":11,"task_id":"T21-e573e86f767c8722"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13314867.txt#4","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"191052810fda6086d8a8da1a8c5834f00d4780b83a220f9cfbeba1181ea850d5","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"6d2f5c570597c9b39f46cfe0c9ba8470d1458c14f243f82a763f44c94d5096da","submission_id":"T21-e573e86f767c8722#done3"},"hash":"6386b477503c41f7d465d889fe261e1aaabe7c0f9bd93a9209d434d857de2c87","header":{"body_hash":"4b656d5fed45caad1030baa7553093caf16c8102bde8731dc560624cf3983020","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"619945e4d685557c7e23cecdf03e33fce7ef63bb7b726c74425a2ab4a2d27c26","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":109,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"5600c43d44efd377adc2aa8c68099b705a36338ad76551276bd7d7802d930754","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR23-e228fb5d2b2fdac1","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"items associated with analytical and problem solving skills (Q29b–Q29e) cluster with high loadings on the second component, with values ranging from 0.73 to 0.91.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t23_o1","terms":["PCA component 2 loadings","analytical and problem solving skills","Q29b-Q29e"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"some items such as Q28f present moderate and shared loadings, suggesting intersections between both dimensions and a possible transversal influence of ChatGPT on hybrid competencies","kind":"observe","local_id":"t23_o2","terms":["Q28f shared loadings","hybrid competencies","communicative and analytical intersection"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The exploratory factor analysis presented in Table 5 confirms the statistical adequacy of the model by showing a significant chi square test (χ2 = 4,365.694; df = 118; p < 0.001).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t23_o3","terms":["exploratory factor analysis","Table 5","model statistical adequacy","chi-square test"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"the first concentrates the highest loadings on items related to analytical and problem solving skills (Q29b–Q29e, with loadings above 0.73)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t23_o4","terms":["EFA first factor","analytical and problem solving skills","Q29b-Q29e loadings"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"the second consistently groups items related to written and digital communication (Q28a–Q28g), with loadings ranging from 0.54 to 0.87.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t23_o5","terms":["EFA second factor","written and digital communication","Q28a-Q28g loadings"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The magnitude and distribution of these factor loadings demonstrate that the instrument measures in a differentiated manner two key competencies: communicative and analytical.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t23_o6","terms":["differentiated measurement","communicative and analytical competencies","structural validity"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"the uniqueness reported in several items (with values between 0.29 and 0.50) supports the robustness of the model, showing that a large proportion of the variance of the items is explained","kind":"observe","local_id":"t23_o7","terms":["item uniqueness 0.29 to 0.50","model robustness","variance explained"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"items Q28a and Q28b, which assess improvement in academic and professional writing, display high loadings on the first factor","kind":"observe","local_id":"t23_o8","terms":["Q28a and Q28b","academic and professional writing","measured outcomes"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"items Q28g, Q28h, and Q28i, linked to digital communication skills, are concentrated in a common direction, empirically validating their grouping under the second factor.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t23_o9","terms":["Q28g, Q28h, Q28i","digital communication skills","measured outcomes"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"items Q29b, Q29c, Q29d, and Q29e are more strongly oriented toward the axis of the first factor, suggesting a solid factorial structure around critical thinking, problem solving, and quantitative skills.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t23_o10","terms":["Q29b-Q29e","critical thinking, problem solving, and quantitative skills","measured outcomes"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The baseline model, which assumes total independence among the items, presented a value of χ2 = 79,740.444 with 153 degrees of freedom, indicating poor fit.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t23_o11","terms":["CFA baseline model","chi-square 79740.444","df 153"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"the factorial model, which incorporates the expected latent structure of the instrument, substantially reduced the statistic to χ2 = 9,725.779 with 134 degrees of freedom and a significance level of p < 0.001.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t23_o12","terms":["CFA factorial model","chi-square 9725.779","df 134","structural validity"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Table 6 presents robust and statistically significant estimates for the 18 items grouped into two factors. All loading values exceed the recommended minimum threshold of 0.70, with values ranging from 0.829 to 1.191","kind":"observe","local_id":"t23_o13","terms":["CFA Table 6 estimates","18 items","loadings 0.829 to 1.191"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t23_o3","t23_o4","t23_o5","t23_o6","t23_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t23_c2","object":"significant EFA fit (χ2=4,365.694, df=118, p<0.001) with two factors (loadings >0.73 for Q29b-Q29e; 0.54-0.87 for Q28a-Q28g) and item uniqueness 0.29-0.50","predicate":"concludes_efa_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 reports that exploratory factor analysis confirms model adequacy (χ2=4,365.694, df=118, p<0.001), differentiating analytical/problem-solving skills (Q29b-Q29e, >0.73) and communication (Q28a-Q28g, 0.54-0.87)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t23_o8","t23_o9","t23_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t23_c3","object":"academic/professional writing (Q28a-Q28b), digital communication (Q28g-Q28i), and critical thinking, problem solving, and quantitative skills (Q29b-Q29e)","predicate":"measures_subdimensions","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"Within its communicative and analytical constructs, PMC13314867 specifically assesses academic and professional writing (Q28a-Q28b), digital communication skills (Q28g-Q28i), and critical thinking, problem solving, and quantitative skills (Q29b-Q29e)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t23_o11","t23_o12","t23_o13"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t23_c4","object":"two-factor CFA fit (χ2=9,725.779, df=134, p<0.001 vs baseline χ2=79,740.444, df=153) and 18 item estimates ranging from 0.829 to 1.191 (p<0.001)","predicate":"concludes_cfa_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 confirms structural validity via confirmatory factor analysis, where the two-factor model markedly improves fit (χ2=9,725.779, df=134, p<0.001) over the baseline model (χ2=79,740.444, df=153), with all 18 item loadings from 0.829 to 1.191."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",17444,23436]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"4811c07686db13bb9c025a1ac1b96a0f6a88b2da0e50fff0a9750cce72438ce1","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["eedbadb1f43e94f0a9531adf32b2303ed48d6dd672d91fe8355fa654b5251ef6","6413a067ef9ba737af817e766b5632b3ba5adbfffb0b10f5b95a987a9f9080dd","7a6fb9541b43fab52d210eaa73a51b52a1a942a3a2073bae1ad7f014b753b4d8","876464adb279d62264a6bad0ec19bdcbdeb7a4f29ab0170db8a8dd32c6da93d6","c77e037744af41a322bb0007afb425299448da934c801574cf2fa5a7b73ded1a","4a768c4dc683c8fbe8f2767d7c5da15f23e925ff7de339bf470e60538d7bd8ab","f8c7dddac5532e2597b3a86ec18246870de973f2591794a175dced4814898e90","5f2ca9447aece753db5400e1a41a2d75d84e846c169b34ea3fb54661c38d0450","1afae2012ec1e4192d70d9d33f0d4687f28d8931f2c476a579d72fe95db397ba","25758a15259b495b8e94f34ede024330ea8f0f01230a9e963ab819569c4e9ea7","08a0f7812f39b520053db4378f195e8ff25b5c35c462c2900b63dd0f79e5801a","4abe67acf67ea5dba879afa708b81c97d930bd5095a9cab048600077b489fc2f","cb6231312b40d6303f478ae118f1783eeea849a19c6e0235298b3d0a0d087b78","5d4ff23b061016beec399ae514f71c3af64c9bcc4f49da4a3034b1bfeffa430b"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":14}},"request_hash":"dc9a8ad0de2668f8e5a3522f2666a300dba98841a336d59d8c9a74cec746ee15","submission_id":"TR23-e228fb5d2b2fdac1#1"},"hash":"2546032d7c416917da5ef7802f6140630886cc3e2760560d7675d0b71d0e2c56","header":{"body_hash":"70e29522008e09e8a86c15a50bf7c50249563d4529d143bd37faa49452310ea4","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"6386b477503c41f7d465d889fe261e1aaabe7c0f9bd93a9209d434d857de2c87","records_root":"758f1f48b09ac3cfc9bd9bd838fda905915027d26341874a713637a91c4bd0af","seq":110,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"a6e0fe08aa39fa824772734add85040a72fee84e23ceab80e172528bc2387403","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR23-e228fb5d2b2fdac1","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t23_o11","t23_o12","t23_o13"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t23_c4","object":"two-factor CFA fit (χ2=9,725.779, df=134, p<0.001 vs baseline χ2=79,740.444, df=153) and 18 item estimates ranging from 0.829 to 1.191 (p<0.001)","predicate":"concludes_cfa_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 confirms structural validity via confirmatory factor analysis, where the two-factor model markedly improves fit (χ2=9,725.779, df=134, p<0.001) over the baseline model (χ2=79,740.444, df=153), with all 18 item loadings from 0.829 to 1.191."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",17444,23436]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"4811c07686db13bb9c025a1ac1b96a0f6a88b2da0e50fff0a9750cce72438ce1","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":[],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":0}},"request_hash":"a3df1675f9d8d3d7953547999ea560028c837a6d5190957237a51fa85cb58ad1","submission_id":"TR23-e228fb5d2b2fdac1#1.1"},"hash":"ae04d5f1476a85679500bfb09c0fb8af3b238f03e022a40779835a707e0ca5c2","header":{"body_hash":"3e15115747549e54adbfc73eee19b938fbf6ddc0c0fab0255b55df2106e35faa","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"2546032d7c416917da5ef7802f6140630886cc3e2760560d7675d0b71d0e2c56","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":111,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"266ebcf50f9090647049a463557229b11ec93c1ea3cc3d1914210e3038c7708b","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@eedbadb1f43e94f0","@6413a067ef9ba737","@7a6fb9541b43fab5","@876464adb279d622","@c77e037744af41a3","@4a768c4dc683c8fb","@f8c7dddac5532e25","@5f2ca9447aece753","@1afae2012ec1e419","@25758a15259b495b","@08a0f7812f39b520","@4abe67acf67ea5db","@cb6231312b40d630","@5d4ff23b061016be"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"REQUEST","refused":[{"error":{"code":"NO_EVIDENCE","expected_by_kernel":{"missing_identifiers":["0.613","0.394"]},"field":"based_on","message":"a claim names only identifiers its quotes hold: add a quote of this section that holds each one listed, or leave it out of the claim","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":13,"local_id":"t23_c1"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":15,"local_id":"t23_c3"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":16,"local_id":"t23_c4"}],"task_id":"TR23-e228fb5d2b2fdac1","work_key":"reread:PMC13314867.txt#3"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:TR23-e228fb5d2b2fdac1:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"4811c07686db13bb9c025a1ac1b96a0f6a88b2da0e50fff0a9750cce72438ce1","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"1576ed925e8565d4dde68d30413e750a719856033d5c829f0ad0b10e3f983f33","submission_id":"TR23-e228fb5d2b2fdac1#repair1"},"hash":"376d585b19b4a64fc61a57450a18487036c16544629b26cfab2b3be813880133","header":{"body_hash":"92d0a242132ed8af446df3a72a2f8a1fa19cb6f20df95b48c6fd2e8014a61feb","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ae04d5f1476a85679500bfb09c0fb8af3b238f03e022a40779835a707e0ca5c2","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":112,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"dbd689c4293a067bb3348b3b994c48cea3d598589348d4b4ce6feea7865dd358","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR23-e228fb5d2b2fdac1","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t23_o1","t23_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t23_c1","object":"high component 2 loadings for Q29b-Q29e (0.73-0.91) and shared loadings on Q28f indicating hybrid competencies","predicate":"concludes_pca_structure","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"In PMC13314867, PCA shows analytical/problem-solving items (Q29b-Q29e) load strongly on component 2 (0.73-0.91), while shared loadings on items like Q28f suggest hybrid communicative-analytical competencies."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t23_o8","t23_o9","t23_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t23_c3","object":"academic/professional writing (Q28a-Q28b), digital communication (Q28g-Q28i), and critical thinking, problem solving, and quantitative skills (Q29b-Q29e)","predicate":"measures_subdimensions","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 assesses academic and professional writing (Q28a, Q28b), digital communication skills (Q28g, Q28h, Q28i), and critical thinking, problem solving, and quantitative skills (Q29b, Q29c, Q29d, Q29e)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t23_o11","t23_o12","t23_o13"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t23_c4","object":"two-factor CFA fit (χ2=9,725.779, df=134, p<0.001 vs baseline χ2=79,740.444, df=153) and 18 item estimates ranging from 0.829 to 1.191 (p<0.001)","predicate":"concludes_cfa_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"In PMC13314867, confirmatory factor analysis shows the two-factor model (χ2=9,725.779, df=134, p<0.001) improves fit over the baseline model (χ2=79,740.444, df=153), with all 18 item loadings between 0.829 and 1.191."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",17444,23436]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"4811c07686db13bb9c025a1ac1b96a0f6a88b2da0e50fff0a9750cce72438ce1","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["05d56e8737c6174ad5b67dc2a2ab1bf2cc310c6ddde552012b03e4400aa15075","e247527fdc418a068e318e78390bbab32f79471999b1329c13f49a767dda446d","aacef8efa2e6a417f1b52fe6178c01a92926217d226bf4474d50104813e148b6"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"2c3a565c1db728d4df083659e8822ff319d83470d241627b1cde4046415af8ef","submission_id":"TR23-e228fb5d2b2fdac1#2"},"hash":"770a2f4b7ebe63bdeab46fbd3ca9285e82f11f3e70ec61412fc946a96cb703a7","header":{"body_hash":"ec11045e37997b02eab75716f48d8c56f4b757519c386ca1d29c733390689452","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"376d585b19b4a64fc61a57450a18487036c16544629b26cfab2b3be813880133","records_root":"0282d2efb4be2582c695d84cad1f58de75dba66b06747e2aa91504f8fc6be3c4","seq":113,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"de2f7b94f1c0d57f5be2052c9484fad83713da6caf9208ba78f7fcb357c2be96","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":6,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":5,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:PMC13314867.txt#3"},"sync_step":11,"task_id":"TR23-e228fb5d2b2fdac1"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:PMC13314867.txt#3","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"4811c07686db13bb9c025a1ac1b96a0f6a88b2da0e50fff0a9750cce72438ce1","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"3920a7d56adef22fb2a0290c2e28a97b771575d58436833e44dd6d8d8114fbdd","submission_id":"TR23-e228fb5d2b2fdac1#done3"},"hash":"0ff22efa45ee7e2370de395f8332bda47396723b080665f07fc87b668f010272","header":{"body_hash":"f382c4f67365981d84b3b03fdc31fb548e30413943ba91a214deba47adedc2bc","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"770a2f4b7ebe63bdeab46fbd3ca9285e82f11f3e70ec61412fc946a96cb703a7","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":114,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"f05e2eb9c69b3ecc3651f1c37e32d5de2081da1bbb73c4b588dc1494656378b6","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":6,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":316},"started_unix_ms":1795102219527,"wave":{"doc:PMC13314867.txt#3":"reader-3","doc:PMC13314867.txt#4":"reader-1","doc:PMC13314867.txt#5":"reader-2"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"4811c07686db13bb9c025a1ac1b96a0f6a88b2da0e50fff0a9750cce72438ce1","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"dcef8417966c67612d3ed48b8d02f682d14319f4fe69d24f17148f050647659d","submission_id":"circle:39f90a6cbe0aa60d4a1211888775f09a06d25587b00b35a66f1db192863a4876"},"hash":"a343ef0761f2848303cf02d95197ae01eadd9ad61eb12068b6118ab97a8b6ee6","header":{"body_hash":"a65495572e0ae5c37674346c9f67b19349144baefb52407050aa79342833b169","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"0ff22efa45ee7e2370de395f8332bda47396723b080665f07fc87b668f010272","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":115,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"b67f9e4bfec0382b31112678e3b9f3a8f8c1103ea816ae6db938e130bdc82abf","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"f05e2eb9c69b3ecc3651f1c37e32d5de2081da1bbb73c4b588dc1494656378b6","engine_root":"4811c07686db13bb9c025a1ac1b96a0f6a88b2da0e50fff0a9750cce72438ce1","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"a11bf28fa4de6a99166634a831b0fabfd50f8843a50726f8b7c1422db6685e9f","log_size":116,"projections":{"dependencies":"5f548d1fcc24e8a102a83fe4452e9cadee2faba2425d5068549673578ef2b2d6","status":"d912f565709244ebe11bf68633bfe7144c116e50b883b30f37ec7c079718d1e9"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"a343ef0761f2848303cf02d95197ae01eadd9ad61eb12068b6118ab97a8b6ee6"}},"engine_root":"4811c07686db13bb9c025a1ac1b96a0f6a88b2da0e50fff0a9750cce72438ce1","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"f05e2eb9c69b3ecc3651f1c37e32d5de2081da1bbb73c4b588dc1494656378b6","engine_root":"4811c07686db13bb9c025a1ac1b96a0f6a88b2da0e50fff0a9750cce72438ce1","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"a11bf28fa4de6a99166634a831b0fabfd50f8843a50726f8b7c1422db6685e9f","log_size":116,"projections":{"dependencies":"5f548d1fcc24e8a102a83fe4452e9cadee2faba2425d5068549673578ef2b2d6","status":"d912f565709244ebe11bf68633bfe7144c116e50b883b30f37ec7c079718d1e9"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"a343ef0761f2848303cf02d95197ae01eadd9ad61eb12068b6118ab97a8b6ee6"},"seal_hash":"26d703bedb5cc5c69e3b01f65f60cabf5aa1f56107c3d35f1b87b0fb7dc81cbf"}},"request_hash":"96f0f3190d79798e133462a154b43ef398dfc044b3f61b951c5872af287f4fb7","submission_id":"seal-116"},"hash":"b415e5654a2bc8e5f4f8df253b9d16961ba4169e1e122f9cbffdd065e4c61056","header":{"body_hash":"714f058579d1e09424a6787f37ae388383012940407038539d9790899e1d91b8","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"a343ef0761f2848303cf02d95197ae01eadd9ad61eb12068b6118ab97a8b6ee6","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":116,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"53008d83d70c7aa66f59c151a5070175255844a66d4b4f930f62549d45543c56","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"epoch":12,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102219527},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"4811c07686db13bb9c025a1ac1b96a0f6a88b2da0e50fff0a9750cce72438ce1","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"bfef71f1d7975644ea573b19087e4a6307cbb5ef5ab42d0a4ffb5eedecd4afd8","submission_id":"ring-members:bf74b7d0a61ac0cd436572b09781b99fb2f860875e730375ca3d3d9683559fe6"},"hash":"f23cdb8fff4741b6b88c182079b9185706814e16231f2432b1c24969aa18abbb","header":{"body_hash":"7be097528543fafe903154fb5d8adc8fffb1012111159de89ad2f48b1bda79de","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"b415e5654a2bc8e5f4f8df253b9d16961ba4169e1e122f9cbffdd065e4c61056","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":117,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"df39a08f8aec96acc533084262e302da9215074899f77755a5f8065ca9865852","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":7,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":316},"started_unix_ms":1795102219550,"wave":{"doc:PMC13314867.txt#6":"reader-1","doc:PMC13314867.txt#7":"reader-2","doc:PMC13388837.txt#0":"reader-3"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"4811c07686db13bb9c025a1ac1b96a0f6a88b2da0e50fff0a9750cce72438ce1","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"12c799ddf9ca3a1d872a097293afe620fa55f3bde8d969cd77f8f60a89019dfe","submission_id":"circle:6ad135091a293e6989098483bad557df50282ae0c4e108bf9f4dfc566819cabf"},"hash":"7fcf19fc887b0f2883b39c3bfe574e7a26977800621e82c6b501047838ac35d5","header":{"body_hash":"0e218ed0a594072904e0fc36a7c4dc1310060a8cc9ab39c4f2abea956b0a9779","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"f23cdb8fff4741b6b88c182079b9185706814e16231f2432b1c24969aa18abbb","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":118,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"fd8c4e275fb898c8db32440a4ef16e07915df33a7bc77a0acb8644ca86c98eaa","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"df39a08f8aec96acc533084262e302da9215074899f77755a5f8065ca9865852","engine_root":"4811c07686db13bb9c025a1ac1b96a0f6a88b2da0e50fff0a9750cce72438ce1","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"00a244bd6e1da623c12cced3747be251b9ca84b41b9d828408a90e73d5109bfd","log_size":119,"projections":{"dependencies":"5f548d1fcc24e8a102a83fe4452e9cadee2faba2425d5068549673578ef2b2d6","status":"d912f565709244ebe11bf68633bfe7144c116e50b883b30f37ec7c079718d1e9"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"7fcf19fc887b0f2883b39c3bfe574e7a26977800621e82c6b501047838ac35d5"}},"engine_root":"4811c07686db13bb9c025a1ac1b96a0f6a88b2da0e50fff0a9750cce72438ce1","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"df39a08f8aec96acc533084262e302da9215074899f77755a5f8065ca9865852","engine_root":"4811c07686db13bb9c025a1ac1b96a0f6a88b2da0e50fff0a9750cce72438ce1","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"00a244bd6e1da623c12cced3747be251b9ca84b41b9d828408a90e73d5109bfd","log_size":119,"projections":{"dependencies":"5f548d1fcc24e8a102a83fe4452e9cadee2faba2425d5068549673578ef2b2d6","status":"d912f565709244ebe11bf68633bfe7144c116e50b883b30f37ec7c079718d1e9"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"7fcf19fc887b0f2883b39c3bfe574e7a26977800621e82c6b501047838ac35d5"},"seal_hash":"6d62be79ac57777d12db31c090ba75ce9c8956d5bf691890500ed882aee07f4a"}},"request_hash":"3c75f1d86414ee0a9b193fd46e226fa669f1301e7d13a4eb443945cc908447b4","submission_id":"seal-119"},"hash":"f7f4dc5c29c6b92ce882984eeaf2625ca6eee304e69d58be0dbf7a98d821649e","header":{"body_hash":"ca6c6bc4045970578cc7d5da96c89cdd8b5a88efa9408c80c74686d576693d65","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"7fcf19fc887b0f2883b39c3bfe574e7a26977800621e82c6b501047838ac35d5","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":119,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"6dc42bebde5cf0c326e838b5654b481f1db9ef2e955b1dce0d569cbb6c41f28a","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"epoch":13,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102219550},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"4811c07686db13bb9c025a1ac1b96a0f6a88b2da0e50fff0a9750cce72438ce1","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"e0a1ba131e5483749918abb8dbc9e13efd4a1a43283a0c0193ee8b60e39e9127","submission_id":"ring-members:9a3e29def71bff5dcf4e41152024957b4bd3381a07f0202b762d9e43dc155d46"},"hash":"4d81b63c04824f27d2ebc7a94c04e5db157efb54ae571c3accab4fb1a0b35411","header":{"body_hash":"a8e246e58f64c9781d183689feaf8dfe623425c5f7ebc89eb006fefa44b31dc1","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"f7f4dc5c29c6b92ce882984eeaf2625ca6eee304e69d58be0dbf7a98d821649e","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":120,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"ac47db43de32cc8a3259d817c7fc744547072abbdae4c74c3f9c165a417ab746","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T24-63a5296721480666","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"RavšeljD. AristovnikA. KerŽičD. TomaŽevičN. UmekL. BrezovarN. . (2024). Higher Education Students' Early Perceptions of ChatGPT: Global Survey Data. Mendeley Data.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t24_o1","terms":["Ravšelj et al. 2024","Global Survey Data","Mendeley Data","reference list"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t24_o1"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t24_c1","object":"Ravšelj et al. (2024) Higher Education Students' Early Perceptions of ChatGPT: Global Survey Data (Mendeley Data)","predicate":"cites_dataset","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 lists Ravšelj et al. (2024), 'Higher Education Students' Early Perceptions of ChatGPT: Global Survey Data' (Mendeley Data), in its reference list as the source of the survey instrument and data."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",34950,40747]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"00892ce74df1c150ede85c5ca387037d0dc5d709a2ea1f2633278dac4d7b64ac","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["15fa6cf8f5d4d61bc9ea239c2b7b6946038c1a0b60b02dc78d28fd272741c156","1a415dd21883140db1a4b7fa5d7164a4f20c8ef7857d63cc2592a667c14db64f"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"e3984bb20e84897568ee50d99d4f323422202877eaad87119b66b65514a25aa0","submission_id":"T24-63a5296721480666#1"},"hash":"153037f5d5f08342ba30e8b9e64898d29fec76fc63c03b39f367d29319c7c96c","header":{"body_hash":"d0d0e9c2dd1e8bf1e5cbe76b615bc421c31c94edc38484b0e9673f61dcbba548","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"4d81b63c04824f27d2ebc7a94c04e5db157efb54ae571c3accab4fb1a0b35411","records_root":"950954fb79195e2400305fcba107bdacb9def3e40a56f73d1bd08e0d4f49af60","seq":121,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"96a12bfc68b9d3a49367573026cb88a80150d0e44ab850cced61927837a38c72","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":7,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":13,"task_id":"T24-63a5296721480666"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13314867.txt#6","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"00892ce74df1c150ede85c5ca387037d0dc5d709a2ea1f2633278dac4d7b64ac","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"f2fead4117d9f1049bebf951cafdb188fde78653f6b9485d8f18f3443c5848dd","submission_id":"T24-63a5296721480666#done2"},"hash":"300ed33f37dade1eb0f54555c0daf12862b358d1782d9b2820ad3501d309f971","header":{"body_hash":"6197c71fad54ad3dd22ca664b708c8358bed24c15995934544df48d8f442f204","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"153037f5d5f08342ba30e8b9e64898d29fec76fc63c03b39f367d29319c7c96c","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":122,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"dd8f1153507a9268fc643878f4abbea03169583d3683be63cf74063c932a4c5b","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T25-e84471f74f17e0b0","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"WangJ. FanW. (2025). The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis. Humanit. Soc. Sci. Commun. 12:621.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t25_o1","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025","reference list entry","PMC13314867"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t25_o1"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t25_c1","object":"Wang and Fan 2025","predicate":"lists_reference","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 lists Wang and Fan 2025 (\"The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis\", Humanit. Soc. Sci. Commun. 12:621) in its reference list."},{"about":["PMC13314867","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t25_q1","needed":"Check in-text citations to Wang and Fan (2025) in earlier sections of PMC13314867.txt and link with the Title line quote from the meta-analysis record file.","text":"Which body statements in PMC13314867 cite Wang and Fan 2025, and how can they be paired with the Title line of the meta-analysis record file?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",40747,41962]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"5da73ffcae9f5c7eb5aebf35c3145e667ef74a713e114d4560a97f8fa9bc29d7","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["9f8a18dcb79900654a9b027395dcc293d30d9d5b32832751f587cf74ee49138f","bfe4a7243c1f4d5cacfe8a729399d72f7422670356cf1b0dfc2f74f1d05df3dc","d21b9c09a79483d91a4d3f26f169168a7d7e1e70b8bc47df2853ff42728db4cd"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"0ee59d63a98260b04acc0f371a79e8b4fb0391167608a80426bce7900e141a9e","submission_id":"T25-e84471f74f17e0b0#1"},"hash":"3df44a0689129a61dc1a4f0be94a848e892122a4a83ab6d91349651b3309cb37","header":{"body_hash":"009a26638070c83df81bae21180f3399049ca45bd723b293dab11e0ca5db5ca7","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"300ed33f37dade1eb0f54555c0daf12862b358d1782d9b2820ad3501d309f971","records_root":"c5fe01d9f4873c1272e90369734f50bcd345a060e30d67918ae80931ef0cb992","seq":123,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"99e0e593930667b6ffce1f80c7d539e8d7d4cd8fe79b1f4425967519262965f0","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":7,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":13,"task_id":"T25-e84471f74f17e0b0"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13314867.txt#7","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"5da73ffcae9f5c7eb5aebf35c3145e667ef74a713e114d4560a97f8fa9bc29d7","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"c53daa2a1a40f527165aac0a44f4cb82a6efb36bcb01368a3483fc5442759092","submission_id":"T25-e84471f74f17e0b0#done2"},"hash":"0b567068e95ff740edaca1343623816e6487a80a102daefec78247d079e80337","header":{"body_hash":"7ead178478b211707181b84376f129dedd1937d3fb86018b3d3026210a46b845","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3df44a0689129a61dc1a4f0be94a848e892122a4a83ab6d91349651b3309cb37","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":124,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"f5e7badd79c8a44ef3b999dd4edac508773b3f2a085f8cc5a63a24d8eecfa970","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T26-7f0e89709bf11088","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Source: Europe PMC PMC13388837, doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1885211. Licence: CC BY (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Copyright © 2026 Li.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t26_o1","terms":["Li 2026","PMC13388837"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"This cross-sectional mixed-methods study examines the relationships between college students’ perceptions of intelligent learning environments and their multimodal L2 willingness to communicate (WTC)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t26_o2","terms":["cross-sectional mixed-methods study","perceptions of intelligent learning environments","multimodal L2 willingness to communicate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"while analyzing L2 self-efficacy as a potential mediator and foreign language anxiety (FLA) as a moderator.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t26_o3","terms":["L2 self-efficacy mediator","foreign language anxiety moderator"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Survey and qualitative data were collected from 960 college students.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t26_o4","terms":["survey and qualitative data","960 college students"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Quantitative analyses were conducted to examine the associations between perceptions of intelligent environments, L2 self-efficacy, FLA, and WTC across both receptive (listening, reading) and productive (speaking, writing) modalities.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t26_o5","terms":["measured outcomes","receptive and productive modalities"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The survey data indicated a significant positive association between the perception of intelligent environments and overall WTC.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t26_o6","terms":["positive association","perception of intelligent environments","overall WTC"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Although baseline WTC for productive skills was lower than for receptive tasks, favorable perceptions of AI showed comparable positive associations with communication willingness across both modalities.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t26_o7","terms":["comparable positive associations","receptive and productive modalities"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"L2 self-efficacy served as an indirect link, accounting for 56.19% of the total association.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t26_o8","terms":["L2 self-efficacy indirect link","56.19% of total association"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Exploratory analyses indicated that high self-efficacy exhibited a potential buffering tendency against the negative correlation between FLA and WTC, though this interaction did not reach statistical significance (p = 0.068).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t26_o9","terms":["FLA and WTC interaction","non-significant moderation p=0.068"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Multi-group analyses demonstrated that these positive associations were consistent across different language proficiency levels. Qualitatively, AI platforms were characterized as perceived “psychological safety buffers” with lower social-evaluative risks.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t26_o10","terms":["multi-group consistency","psychological safety buffers"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"These cross-sectional insights suggest that favorable perceptions of intelligent environments are positively related to L2 communication willingness.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t26_o11","terms":["main conclusion","favorable perceptions positively related to L2 WTC"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Rather than serving merely as auxiliary aids for vocabulary retrieval or grammar correction, these algorithms now act as intelligent agents. Equipped with natural language capabilities, they frequently participate in learners’ cognitive processing and emotional regulation processes (Slamet, 2024; Wang and Fan, 2025; Yu et al., 2024).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t26_o12","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025 citation","intelligent agents","cognitive processing and emotional regulation"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t26_o1","t26_o2","t26_o3","t26_o4","t26_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t26_c1","object":"survey and qualitative data from 960 college students on perceptions of intelligent environments, L2 self-efficacy, FLA, and receptive/productive WTC","predicate":"measures_outcomes_and_data","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13388837)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13388837) rests on cross-sectional mixed-methods survey and qualitative data from 960 college students, measuring perceptions of intelligent environments, L2 self-efficacy, FLA, and receptive/productive WTC."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t26_o1","t26_o6","t26_o7","t26_o8","t26_o10","t26_o11"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t26_c2","object":"positive association between intelligent environment perceptions and L2 WTC across modalities and proficiency levels, with L2 self-efficacy accounting for 56.19% of total association","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13388837)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13388837) concludes that favorable perceptions of intelligent environments are positively associated with overall, receptive, and productive L2 WTC across proficiency levels, with L2 self-efficacy mediating 56.19%."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t26_o1","t26_o9","t26_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t26_c3","object":"buffering interaction of self-efficacy against FLA on WTC did not reach statistical significance (p = 0.068); qualitatively AI platforms were perceived as psychological safety buffers","predicate":"qualifies_results","stance":"qualified","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13388837)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13388837) reports that high L2 self-efficacy showed a potential buffering tendency against the negative correlation between FLA and WTC that was not statistically significant (p = 0.068), while AI acted as safety buffers."},{"about":["Li 2026 (PMC13388837)","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t26_q1","needed":"Check the reference list of PMC13388837.txt for Wang and Fan (2025) and pair t26_o12 with the Title line quote of the meta-analysis's record file.","text":"Does the Wang and Fan (2025) citation in PMC13388837 refer to the retracted meta-analysis 'The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis'?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",0,5407]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"af96146eab2f37013929678e471de89c08daf09bf9ce6285390ade2138e41c3a","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["b613aa3cdb2c80da02db9880d03ba3f6f28b08092c965e0f7a48edfd333c4808","f4eb87a95a8dbe765f8677cc6f2b2a0639da4bae647e32c518f39106ec817f13","f830dc3280b1a2d0b248a7e68b6b481b3c36c47e541c8c51d155215915fc7a71","cd0bd51233ca7a6add7c97376d265637092011a1e27650be9ac6b0c537102218","57e49ee47d9b6300a9fc1019856f0c163cfef3aeb1dd6ee9affb2814e137818d","4076514025cbf6d81d5cf1efe1db0c6617c1ed42c55a3c7260813e82677c14e5","ce710c268fc0953cffbbdde0f363d0604bf11cbff0bfc10d4a05805db5bbd328","7157439c05c936b85b7fee6e832363cc83b3965753cac8256b1d487342c51ff2","8275e6ad0bf10d2430cc7b89262a4bca3cdf6efa885f40f628400d9dcc512b76","1442a45e909b8b540473da43a7ebd792468cd762da3af7d02146ec7a86004486","26078c727bf727ce17cf72012cbe4fd4eac20f47ac264185cee7015c3021f3e5","43203e6892d30d6cb5c2460507b73c0e1fddfe82c8bb3a77a1fbe23f045a4abf","a8cd9991215748ee5cc9fa85613e7554b68e2c08be18e8e04afdd4eee66afe5c","d76d4295435f00384500b58976004e0ca2bd324b42b12548be8e056ad4bd2a7d","ef069e07ea5452baa01d851837c9d4756ee134632b283ebc57473a61da89b072","558513dec474cadb38f66558db40814d7bb778dfb7f9cf01f62440a5088fa415"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"8e60162d6c665dc539585c5e6d4a35b9bd0a44549fa1d0afc9468966fb08a7a3","submission_id":"T26-7f0e89709bf11088#1"},"hash":"f81dadd34967ea65bd16a4382142707dfd199c4ca49be1bd2ddd3047cb537d2b","header":{"body_hash":"fda2442c13060f79dedfebe7bc4e668d080e330ecf58778e436162433dddf987","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"0b567068e95ff740edaca1343623816e6487a80a102daefec78247d079e80337","records_root":"180cdd7ea2e483280027806febdd0d388e4c989caac46c12ae5440ff79b5c9d4","seq":125,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"e59c1986d0215d2feeb1e0f8e5c8dad2957d5ca3124fd6c24abadea10a930a6f","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":7,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":13,"task_id":"T26-7f0e89709bf11088"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13388837.txt#0","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"af96146eab2f37013929678e471de89c08daf09bf9ce6285390ade2138e41c3a","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"2c270247ad63256539fba4ad4a138bd06a1a263e38f368a3b9253e0a16fcf181","submission_id":"T26-7f0e89709bf11088#done2"},"hash":"b5450873c6b9d5966e8d136fb4d1b9b696811b1b5ac04769535ce3c94f978880","header":{"body_hash":"bd76b8e2a37736e9f77866ed02354d94b3e0f0bb5a0322371fcc98b3c8380fc8","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"f81dadd34967ea65bd16a4382142707dfd199c4ca49be1bd2ddd3047cb537d2b","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":126,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"685a668582ad9d4593617612ca4df59fecb5527abdad896a24422a1c57acc46d","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":7,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":337},"started_unix_ms":1795102247995,"wave":{"doc:PMC13314867.txt#6":"reader-1","doc:PMC13314867.txt#7":"reader-2","doc:PMC13388837.txt#0":"reader-3"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"af96146eab2f37013929678e471de89c08daf09bf9ce6285390ade2138e41c3a","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"51de2e0ea54bf67d64e3d7b786415b1341de0776b3aac64a1d9afc43fe13553e","submission_id":"circle:fbc53eeaf62f1b5ac48ec2fb8b61ca5936dd2087ded5717d4201d09d0904b2a2"},"hash":"2859fc8d3fbfb2bde02d796acc940ca014bca6caa53aec3b24eb266d6a0f50bb","header":{"body_hash":"b32b807745de30e452e58dffc78c6474008b286a841bc01e9fa4b77eed4132b3","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"b5450873c6b9d5966e8d136fb4d1b9b696811b1b5ac04769535ce3c94f978880","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":127,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"dc9bf8980f690a274086413de21d3b679daf8f5d523ce4edfe0a71662dff6698","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"685a668582ad9d4593617612ca4df59fecb5527abdad896a24422a1c57acc46d","engine_root":"af96146eab2f37013929678e471de89c08daf09bf9ce6285390ade2138e41c3a","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"13aa2ff569258353dfdf8e2c6235d061879ded07f7d6c9c7eb059f9f31d7ef3b","log_size":128,"projections":{"dependencies":"95a38ef346269b87b13b978530036d2d27d92e8cd9a99b78197d1e5c8294e2c2","status":"40820ebb4621e68e0332f7122efbc87abb2fabb04de9c4f4aec5624ab7bd6ade"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"2859fc8d3fbfb2bde02d796acc940ca014bca6caa53aec3b24eb266d6a0f50bb"}},"engine_root":"af96146eab2f37013929678e471de89c08daf09bf9ce6285390ade2138e41c3a","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"685a668582ad9d4593617612ca4df59fecb5527abdad896a24422a1c57acc46d","engine_root":"af96146eab2f37013929678e471de89c08daf09bf9ce6285390ade2138e41c3a","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"13aa2ff569258353dfdf8e2c6235d061879ded07f7d6c9c7eb059f9f31d7ef3b","log_size":128,"projections":{"dependencies":"95a38ef346269b87b13b978530036d2d27d92e8cd9a99b78197d1e5c8294e2c2","status":"40820ebb4621e68e0332f7122efbc87abb2fabb04de9c4f4aec5624ab7bd6ade"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"2859fc8d3fbfb2bde02d796acc940ca014bca6caa53aec3b24eb266d6a0f50bb"},"seal_hash":"78840c428695ccba11c35efbf7f16eaa721f0b649962e3f8255c60dfaa1214e6"}},"request_hash":"999e5203619ef34e790a170d33b75db66f21050f1adb34bba61fcf7b4115e486","submission_id":"seal-128"},"hash":"6dad5da0b66bcc451a6513a3f871b3f0646b0d17294d963fe18699b0d6542965","header":{"body_hash":"fded514e1c990b7d2fd50adf052a9fc95a361b6eea05a3087ffd69021abfea6b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"2859fc8d3fbfb2bde02d796acc940ca014bca6caa53aec3b24eb266d6a0f50bb","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":128,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"4c261e6024dca5b01e77beefd77fa025ca4e7c043eeb33eeab6830d5abfae55f","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"epoch":14,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102247995},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"af96146eab2f37013929678e471de89c08daf09bf9ce6285390ade2138e41c3a","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"d172d3768e5d8c6429813e3a64ab1461f8055da8e75b377b61cc154837eefd1a","submission_id":"ring-members:c8a22b6bc692d46277cdacc90e277aaed7f464bffa251a560a48bde431a6aef8"},"hash":"9c30c4821dff9884c740408669a22dd3ce12366454ccdb1677eb56655ebe1023","header":{"body_hash":"2848a51557972acb196081dd8abf8b0f909f5461d86a7d7426b395ec29bbc83d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"6dad5da0b66bcc451a6513a3f871b3f0646b0d17294d963fe18699b0d6542965","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":129,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"b81f8c7cba0becb4391b418cc4d5666a520107f8472085641db54a9753157dd3","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":8,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":337},"started_unix_ms":1795102248022,"wave":{"doc:PMC13388837.txt#1":"reader-2","doc:PMC13388837.txt#2":"reader-3","doc:PMC13388837.txt#3":"reader-1"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"af96146eab2f37013929678e471de89c08daf09bf9ce6285390ade2138e41c3a","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"29bce9d7d6c61a33f1760adcd64a330295ec7f0a1e179dcc15b273f90a0be98d","submission_id":"circle:8711a54108fbf6f850cbe60ab4581ad0b803ddc4890d5b886df13be9f31951e6"},"hash":"6232a6a7139ae113e2380824acb4046590125de9f7ace812d9fc0313455a60f6","header":{"body_hash":"ca66e9cb9a582509223ae6164e7a9f434790165f0c023625b95d70e3c0df6f03","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"9c30c4821dff9884c740408669a22dd3ce12366454ccdb1677eb56655ebe1023","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":130,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"f0e538a9fae1c4fdd100f6592af51c559ec60d3dfa46e179d2008950d97d6326","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"b81f8c7cba0becb4391b418cc4d5666a520107f8472085641db54a9753157dd3","engine_root":"af96146eab2f37013929678e471de89c08daf09bf9ce6285390ade2138e41c3a","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"f5b92e5802c5e4c26642e7c59262d9a7f16f46e7474e15f702213ae07d00ba65","log_size":131,"projections":{"dependencies":"95a38ef346269b87b13b978530036d2d27d92e8cd9a99b78197d1e5c8294e2c2","status":"40820ebb4621e68e0332f7122efbc87abb2fabb04de9c4f4aec5624ab7bd6ade"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"6232a6a7139ae113e2380824acb4046590125de9f7ace812d9fc0313455a60f6"}},"engine_root":"af96146eab2f37013929678e471de89c08daf09bf9ce6285390ade2138e41c3a","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"b81f8c7cba0becb4391b418cc4d5666a520107f8472085641db54a9753157dd3","engine_root":"af96146eab2f37013929678e471de89c08daf09bf9ce6285390ade2138e41c3a","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"f5b92e5802c5e4c26642e7c59262d9a7f16f46e7474e15f702213ae07d00ba65","log_size":131,"projections":{"dependencies":"95a38ef346269b87b13b978530036d2d27d92e8cd9a99b78197d1e5c8294e2c2","status":"40820ebb4621e68e0332f7122efbc87abb2fabb04de9c4f4aec5624ab7bd6ade"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"6232a6a7139ae113e2380824acb4046590125de9f7ace812d9fc0313455a60f6"},"seal_hash":"f35a7718c992b43b900b2fefe201d9b9cfc52212a4690c9500fcd1693fc307db"}},"request_hash":"8b4641fbf5690b91d9ead9c253e720aa74c0cc79a8f84717bc37584dfd1fed90","submission_id":"seal-131"},"hash":"969df01e7f832bf9ac4872a8aea3aa894b7201755ca99afe8672f993fe830054","header":{"body_hash":"1dfdf10ef49ea64672cdd45fb2f02fb425df79d1a4b65417f4b9e0d8b17976d2","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"6232a6a7139ae113e2380824acb4046590125de9f7ace812d9fc0313455a60f6","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":131,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"d41ae5ef45a05e9e3796bda1d7db87caf87c2a671dca5ba279d24ba90ffb5ae3","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"epoch":15,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102248022},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"af96146eab2f37013929678e471de89c08daf09bf9ce6285390ade2138e41c3a","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"20a892900f811055ad1aedc646e7d11ca7f98ea916940e0c4b92dae2a1916e72","submission_id":"ring-members:14197822670650197cf46e16fc9c6505bf6768351ce6ddd8c069c5c245b192cc"},"hash":"40c60471e99c58bc1dee5013c72f00b9b79489691434cf4eb0f1e75e2c1c180a","header":{"body_hash":"7656a2d5565b6ae727be2fa14b9360b6567a7bd28e768a6ab8dcb5951bda2635","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"969df01e7f832bf9ac4872a8aea3aa894b7201755ca99afe8672f993fe830054","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":132,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"a939956feb3cad9154b08484ecb16e5608e204720ce79899b46db923fd3ed6d5","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T29-b2f8e484242c386c","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"this study aims to examine the following progressive research questions through a cross-sectional survey and qualitative feature analysis targeting the college student population","kind":"observe","local_id":"t29_o1","terms":["cross-sectional survey","qualitative feature analysis","college student population","study design"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Question 1: Is there a significant positive correlation between college students’ perceptual experience of intelligent English learning environments and their multimodal (listening, speaking, reading, and writing) willingness to communicate?","kind":"observe","local_id":"t29_o2","terms":["perceptual experience of intelligent English learning environments","multimodal willingness to communicate","listening, speaking, reading, and writing"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Question 3: Does domain-specific L2 self-efficacy play a significant mediating role in the associative path between environmental perception and willingness to communicate?","kind":"observe","local_id":"t29_o3","terms":["domain-specific L2 self-efficacy","mediating role","environmental perception","willingness to communicate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Question 4: In an intelligent environment, does foreign language learning anxiety act as a negative moderating variable, restricting the associative strength between self-efficacy and willingness to communicate?","kind":"observe","local_id":"t29_o4","terms":["foreign language learning anxiety","negative moderating variable","self-efficacy","willingness to communicate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Question 5: Does the aforementioned multi-dimensional psychological mediation model possess cross-group stability among subsamples categorized by different baseline English levels?","kind":"observe","local_id":"t29_o5","terms":["multi-dimensional psychological mediation model","cross-group stability","baseline English levels"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t29_o1"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t29_c1","object":"cross-sectional survey and qualitative feature analysis of a college student population","predicate":"uses_study_design_and_sample","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 rests on a cross-sectional survey and qualitative feature analysis targeting college students to examine associative patterns of communicative psychology in intelligent English learning environments."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t29_o2","t29_o3","t29_o4","t29_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t29_c2","object":"intelligent environment perception, multimodal L2 WTC (listening, speaking, reading, writing), L2 self-efficacy, foreign language anxiety, baseline English levels","predicate":"examines_outcomes_and_variables","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 measures college students' perceptual experience of intelligent English learning environments, multimodal L2 willingness to communicate (listening, speaking, reading, writing), L2 self-efficacy, and foreign language anxiety."},{"about":["PMC13388837"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t29_q1","needed":"Check the Results, Discussion, and Conclusion sections of PMC13388837.txt","text":"What are the empirical results and main conclusions of PMC13388837 for Research Questions 1-5 on intelligent environment perception, multimodal L2 WTC, L2 self-efficacy mediation, and foreign language anxiety moderation?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",5407,10918]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"1368db0cb2aed2b068cacf158f9978beeb8756fd6c2daadd437cb74620c30157","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["3fe47aeff779e2b2db46a58c928365ca73e331eb081372ae8b9c55a3d3852f16","f999bd21067dcf15466a9d53dba1a724c2f02c4065f58c4adc1c5f7e434d7466","3f1bce000471ea4be84d36a8c26fa6ce70b925d8440fb30bf56cced7ec8ae5f6","0a18f06fbbdcbb5cbab484a3e1afe07603bcbec9e2073c901678806cb5d0861b","92b2cb88b636a8f9e370c3a4c69940f2b37c9c105a770590a5c2a24c4200d251","290dfc9524b2b97398df608395af74f673aada35620c3da1d4fd366caf9ac5c9","83393296d0bb763b34ef00ad70c22c7aba459ce284ae9cb6c5d526ee970b7d53","46785a67d453bf07340b82806d5aa1aa8be24a1ad89f60312330f7ecf2cdb146"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"3e58c2d9f70792cb157a34b49960164ec6480981444f9eb3213feaeb4e2d0b2a","submission_id":"T29-b2f8e484242c386c#1"},"hash":"c2e5f17b5b3cbcd649e7ec3e7c79727b9e89c8d7841280609e9fce4d634215ff","header":{"body_hash":"1cacf8d84d89dccc89bc65c010e1a9cce262ea56107e0c70c7530dc952a20631","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"40c60471e99c58bc1dee5013c72f00b9b79489691434cf4eb0f1e75e2c1c180a","records_root":"2acd2f3373e6e746d36082e760823438fe809e55af2116b3e5dbf847584505e4","seq":133,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"9156b7d08b689db4450fcc4670c3179b4c6171aa136fb520c071d694a814f541","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":8,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":15,"task_id":"T29-b2f8e484242c386c"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13388837.txt#1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"1368db0cb2aed2b068cacf158f9978beeb8756fd6c2daadd437cb74620c30157","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"90b0fcf058ae92ca5a9458fb226f759e15d958d767da3d04d295c8f14c0d50ee","submission_id":"T29-b2f8e484242c386c#done2"},"hash":"dad47d5e6097a568e6591bdf06944cc3ce39f7f6a5b872515e3ad6d1ffbb380f","header":{"body_hash":"97745e319e7360308c42a888d697dbbcb97196e85056f027129d2e16032aa0d3","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"c2e5f17b5b3cbcd649e7ec3e7c79727b9e89c8d7841280609e9fce4d634215ff","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":134,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"fdf88032dce8e60d65b5408c496cb37caf26119453144ba9dca4a5031168d957","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T28-d003ebad3dc53e23","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Recognizing the highly mediated nature of AI contexts, it becomes necessary to segment traditional WTC measurements by modality.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t28_o1","terms":["WTC modality segmentation","AI contexts"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"creating distinct psychological boundary lines between “receptive willingness” (listening and reading) and “productive willingness” (speaking and writing)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t28_o2","terms":["receptive willingness","productive willingness","listening and reading","speaking and writing"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"What remains to be tested in cross-sectional models is whether this technological linkage undergoes a true internalization process","kind":"observe","local_id":"t28_o3","terms":["L2 self-efficacy internalization","cross-sectional models"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Consequently, evaluating the moderating role of FLA in contemporary contexts requires examining whether heightened self-efficacy can effectively navigate the traditional fears","kind":"observe","local_id":"t28_o4","terms":["foreign language learning anxiety","FLA moderation","L2 self-efficacy"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Integrating these theoretical dimensions into a comprehensive structural model, this study outlines several hypotheses regarding main associations, structural heterogeneity, indirect links","kind":"observe","local_id":"t28_o5","terms":["structural model","research hypotheses"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"H1 (main association): AI intelligent environment perception shows a significant positive correlation with college students’ multidimensional L2 willingness to communicate.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t28_o6","terms":["H1","AI intelligent environment perception","multidimensional L2 WTC","college students"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"H2a: L2 communicative willingness presents a baseline asymmetrical distribution, where receptive WTC (listening/reading) is significantly higher than productive WTC (speaking/writing).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t28_o7","terms":["H2a","receptive WTC","productive WTC","asymmetrical distribution"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t28_o1","t28_o2","t28_o3","t28_o4","t28_o5","t28_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t28_c1","object":"AI intelligent environment perception, multidimensional L2 WTC (receptive and productive), L2 self-efficacy, and Foreign Language Anxiety (FLA) in college students","predicate":"examines_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 frames a structural model of college students' L2 willingness to communicate (segmented into receptive listening/reading and productive speaking/writing), AI environment perception, L2 self-efficacy, and FLA."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t28_o6","t28_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t28_c2","object":"H1: positive correlation between AI environment perception and L2 WTC; H2a: baseline receptive WTC (listening/reading) higher than productive WTC (speaking/writing)","predicate":"hypothesizes","stance":"open","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 hypothesizes (H1) that AI intelligent environment perception correlates positively with college students' multidimensional L2 willingness to communicate, and (H2a) that receptive WTC exceeds productive WTC."},{"about":["PMC13388837","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t28_q1","needed":"Check subsequent sections (hypotheses continuation, methods, results, discussion, and references) of PMC13388837.txt","text":"What are the remaining hypotheses (e.g., H2b, H3, H4), empirical dataset/sample, and main results of PMC13388837, and does it cite Wang and Fan 2025?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",10918,16820]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"702c1930dd7220a62242500f75efb310d422849bd29ec226d3b5ec527736f6d1","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["c9ea7c273e3d9ceb3e58e3b255c39425c611d8b802a5acab03680dc89bcfd4b5","f11ed666387c771e0be45889b4e9f311c61ff44a6bcacd1278784210211a1b99","4deb3fe0eb77febb1addb904deaf96841bbc3c9782864a47e6df1897b6a472fe","a941f9ce34467a2991412ae341603c383fb676593c3fe0f1ae41b12015f298a4","93ab1a62f7082761a57f2da3762190b55bce7efcbe097296ef7fe2f21fb42b39","b7d63db0f7665c364f87430d715e48eb6b66b97bf7125ad10d4e80b8e985c5d4","5b46657304b4c9d8d3c3729eab6488e44adc92a401e3b230d8b5e5665a2c0981","ccf224838daf27b808aed618057702104630e3ba0a8e82c7751a984ec180502d","75b66684790552ec977b962824d8a4e85a41d2effc50226f9b697f7b901472c7","56eb3823ae741b55ab87673b64703341fcd51c4f23c7ee9e42cd23a7538683e7"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"1ca955309322d6acdd90f7fc6822662cb5a1c6f363a55bfd55768d3b540ee9ad","submission_id":"T28-d003ebad3dc53e23#1"},"hash":"bb83139386bbd6e38ec6a3f6e23d10ab5e0b0336cf888dab8b0e8222798a792f","header":{"body_hash":"cf6c0a3ec508b5f3ba85932bf6c1ee054988357bebf92c2c21202170e537feb6","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"dad47d5e6097a568e6591bdf06944cc3ce39f7f6a5b872515e3ad6d1ffbb380f","records_root":"b9b160f8272a56bab070423d577d6b6f3e4b0f325015414d3a4ef3fffe97e540","seq":135,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"add628e431fa6060a685682f4bd691ece8c4ae8c081991eacb13b1557f084483","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":8,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":15,"task_id":"T28-d003ebad3dc53e23"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13388837.txt#2","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"702c1930dd7220a62242500f75efb310d422849bd29ec226d3b5ec527736f6d1","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"ad0b96563745c01bf8de3ddae941c15f5d666b1b2387278f88827f36b831dae2","submission_id":"T28-d003ebad3dc53e23#done2"},"hash":"5b4644be0a282bcf1b2a12aa01010b80357e6aa034d84f7c7aae185dd0792334","header":{"body_hash":"426fd6b89a30c63f2999e55d9cc5a89f905db39a9586af9b2d22fd9d369bee03","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"bb83139386bbd6e38ec6a3f6e23d10ab5e0b0336cf888dab8b0e8222798a792f","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":136,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"0523c9179f4eb09e68a5080fea62345fa83951dc9ab805e072a32e3cbbf0312b","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T27-aca16fba92068a03","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"This study adopted a cross-sectional mixed-methods design combining a quantitative survey with qualitative thematic analysis.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t27_o1","terms":["research design","cross-sectional mixed-methods","quantitative survey","qualitative thematic analysis"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The quantitative component was used to examine the structural associations among AI perception, self-efficacy, foreign language anxiety, and multimodal L2 WTC","kind":"observe","local_id":"t27_o2","terms":["measured outcomes","AI perception","self-efficacy","foreign language anxiety","multimodal L2 WTC"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Data collection was concentrated between January and March 2026, primarily implemented through Wenjuanxing, a widely used online survey platform in China.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t27_o3","terms":["data collection","Wenjuanxing","January to March 2026","China"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The survey collected an initial 1,030 questionnaires.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t27_o4","terms":["initial sample size","1,030 questionnaires"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"960 high-quality valid samples were finally retained (effective recovery rate 93.2%).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t27_o5","terms":["retained valid sample size","N = 960","effective recovery rate 93.2%"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"All items are scored on a 5-point Likert scale.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t27_o6","terms":["measurement scale","5-point Likert scale"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Prior to the large-scale administration, a pilot test was conducted with 45 undergraduate EFL students to evaluate instructional clarity, readability, and cultural appropriateness.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t27_o7","terms":["pilot test","45 undergraduate EFL students"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"referencing Davis’s (1989) Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) and Mac Callum and Jeffrey’s (2013) exploration of digital skill adoption behavior","kind":"observe","local_id":"t27_o8","terms":["AI intelligent perception scale sources","Davis 1989 TAM","Mac Callum and Jeffrey 2013"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"we compiled the “AI Intelligent Tool Usage Experience and Perception Scale” containing 5 items.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t27_o9","terms":["AI Intelligent Tool Usage Experience and Perception Scale","5 items"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t27_o1","t27_o2","t27_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t27_c1","object":"AI perception, L2 self-efficacy, foreign language anxiety, and multimodal L2 WTC via cross-sectional mixed-methods (5-point Likert survey and thematic analysis)","predicate":"measures_outcomes_with_design","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 uses a cross-sectional mixed-methods design (quantitative survey and qualitative thematic analysis) measuring AI perception, L2 self-efficacy, foreign language anxiety, and multimodal L2 WTC on 5-point Likert scales."},{"as_of":20260300,"based_on":["t27_o3","t27_o4","t27_o5","t27_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t27_c2","object":"960 valid questionnaires (from 1,030 initial) collected via Wenjuanxing in China (Jan-Mar 2026) and a 45-student EFL pilot test","predicate":"rests_on_data","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 rests on survey data from 960 valid questionnaires (out of 1,030 collected; 93.2% recovery rate) gathered via Wenjuanxing in China between January and March 2026, following a pilot test with 45 undergraduate EFL students."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t27_o8","t27_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t27_c3","object":"5-item AI Intelligent Tool Usage Experience and Perception Scale based on Davis (1989) and Mac Callum and Jeffrey (2013)","predicate":"measures_AI_perception_with","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"To measure AI intelligent perception, PMC13388837 compiled the 5-item AI Intelligent Tool Usage Experience and Perception Scale referencing Davis (1989) TAM and Mac Callum and Jeffrey (2013)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",16820,22812]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"e07bd3fd12a6187071a378290d2cb766c6db25e6fc38e75c85bfefe9a251253e","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["fe0b0a44c9d9a7dbbe25c4c6f3cb231448312591aecddffe7c7c94c5a4b4bcd3","37f23a9691104698af7d2f305c768674436463d2bc71129a4b17122d056cfc22","03141aa5579b32d644417331af1458c62fad4a2f412a0cfaac949703a46d5952","9799078b20f2d936f05068eb857080fdff8cb18cb638ed014eea0b3ca161d67c","69ac18dba8034e1de84c0093efb1ab3ca5a7f1caf7aaf4d4b5b4440b9e964e28","14d377e35de2331dcde7bf33be6758ceac2a5ce1bbb66a5f74fe8230c025c2c2","c69bd457047cd365b1abe55fae758850e06a9530c3d5a6dd7b0546c2b4b65463","40ed8bfd2b1664cb55d48335f1d1b5cc9e08bde83cc5ecc22b6f58de2a356407","b19ff2061f3d94f3a69d03836883b3accb094adc20ed6fe0a81b82dce59f6cc0","b14bccfd0be9976f677cd4166f832c1817812bf16c93ba7a262100725b9465c6"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"type":["integer","null"],"x-calendar":"YYYYMMDD"},"field":"as_of","message":"as_of must be null or an integer encoding a valid Gregorian date YYYYMMDD","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":10}},"request_hash":"ce1364177b207bb0733ba6f67edd729ce31c61d5b177e0c07c6adb723e1747d3","submission_id":"T27-aca16fba92068a03#1"},"hash":"96af66edba2300dd84849c5816415aee731dbb52863bf65bd1f6b720e4c6bfe9","header":{"body_hash":"a22939482e6da4386015f043494fba9212d4d379b12edad288e3b3f33c0afb40","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"5b4644be0a282bcf1b2a12aa01010b80357e6aa034d84f7c7aae185dd0792334","records_root":"ee3188a13af1a3ad37588d37f108aff82acedd0ad1bda70cf9f12fc4a140c1bb","seq":137,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"fbc2055be86f6cce0e9ae1f3332ca077b0119569522ddfe5765f15330ff971cc","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T27-aca16fba92068a03","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t27_o8","t27_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t27_c3","object":"5-item AI Intelligent Tool Usage Experience and Perception Scale based on Davis (1989) and Mac Callum and Jeffrey (2013)","predicate":"measures_AI_perception_with","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"To measure AI intelligent perception, PMC13388837 compiled the 5-item AI Intelligent Tool Usage Experience and Perception Scale referencing Davis (1989) TAM and Mac Callum and Jeffrey (2013)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",16820,22812]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"e07bd3fd12a6187071a378290d2cb766c6db25e6fc38e75c85bfefe9a251253e","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["539d55b6a37b055f1ac9c6d28018d06ec959b0aef54077988cd2e341775920ce"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"efa62b634d5e32ed5e651e717ad6363e44826d66795ae8c4083690d19b93a4e0","submission_id":"T27-aca16fba92068a03#1.1"},"hash":"bf3135251045d4de35f5399b51adcd6f35f98500e79869449dd4ed00fc6798b1","header":{"body_hash":"0738e9b0dad85db72a2cee888a2cd73bf39913be8dce49e9697023566f6666de","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"96af66edba2300dd84849c5816415aee731dbb52863bf65bd1f6b720e4c6bfe9","records_root":"b85873bbb45b3c9a0ef4b85485a9cf73547f4a75193fda97e46667fd93a42ba0","seq":138,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"9c6d96716dbd91e60a970ebf91b2fcad741497abb8b0191a483b76e544268906","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@fe0b0a44c9d9a7db","@37f23a9691104698","@03141aa5579b32d6","@9799078b20f2d936","@69ac18dba8034e1d","@14d377e35de2331d","@c69bd457047cd365","@40ed8bfd2b1664cb","@b19ff2061f3d94f3","@b14bccfd0be9976f","@539d55b6a37b055f"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"type":["integer","null"],"x-calendar":"YYYYMMDD"},"field":"as_of","message":"as_of must be null or an integer encoding a valid Gregorian date YYYYMMDD","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":10,"local_id":"t27_c2"}],"task_id":"T27-aca16fba92068a03","work_key":"doc:PMC13388837.txt#3"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T27-aca16fba92068a03:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"e07bd3fd12a6187071a378290d2cb766c6db25e6fc38e75c85bfefe9a251253e","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"390aaa74c2e00ffd3a933bf4601cf00f9175df807250806806c91b1a0352cb6c","submission_id":"T27-aca16fba92068a03#repair1"},"hash":"add38365010a29c864dd02cbf44660561b94a9b87d396380b78111612be38bf8","header":{"body_hash":"121e8f720d227a092053072498bef79669af4999012d35649ef3190de1720cd5","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"bf3135251045d4de35f5399b51adcd6f35f98500e79869449dd4ed00fc6798b1","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":139,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"af26e9ab2bfaab06b312bcc892480c131b8abb3957e95bb640c7ccefb776e07f","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T27-aca16fba92068a03","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t27_o3","t27_o4","t27_o5","t27_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t27_c2","object":"960 valid questionnaires (from 1,030 initial) collected via Wenjuanxing in China (Jan-Mar 2026) and a 45-student EFL pilot test","predicate":"rests_on_data","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 rests on survey data from 960 valid questionnaires (out of 1,030 collected; 93.2% recovery rate) gathered via Wenjuanxing in China between January and March 2026, following a pilot test with 45 undergraduate EFL students."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",16820,22812]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"e07bd3fd12a6187071a378290d2cb766c6db25e6fc38e75c85bfefe9a251253e","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["6e4f3f9f907de7f4c31dc5b687de29570bb515a98fa359ec97765bde02705059"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"3bc88926a9276f68387f8a34f344ece0d59406e5e4598da22ad70842105a3faf","submission_id":"T27-aca16fba92068a03#2"},"hash":"366fddfd52a6405bb496085e1a916d1faab0bf44c4947fbfa2b536e9fe8b951d","header":{"body_hash":"7cee5a20cc2f3264fc44fa54d89e84c5133172d1fad0ecb5baee3deec75f0684","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"add38365010a29c864dd02cbf44660561b94a9b87d396380b78111612be38bf8","records_root":"975d30775ae52388e4d68d53e25e4415114072ce48ac306febd4fe719eb3f886","seq":140,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"c9fc6231fcba0b6127da0e1d75e759234d5c298bd47aa6e63551b1063fce1d09","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":false,"agent":"reader-1","circle":8,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":12,"refusals":1,"stored":12,"sync_step":15,"task_id":"T27-aca16fba92068a03"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13388837.txt#3","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"e07bd3fd12a6187071a378290d2cb766c6db25e6fc38e75c85bfefe9a251253e","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"39b13eac7d37e98fb226c49a40022759e20f22de970fa8f393adcdbbecb43f73","submission_id":"T27-aca16fba92068a03#done3"},"hash":"37e494625d74a5a9fd42e85302b90f1feca47355c013bead7fca364ee7f2853d","header":{"body_hash":"1d5e61dab5c79e25db209a44098298e3f27fbfd41d10e01795745690bc87d48e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"366fddfd52a6405bb496085e1a916d1faab0bf44c4947fbfa2b536e9fe8b951d","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":141,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"364546ede4153384078ce94350cb72f4de48f0a3ee93e6d570d380e55a5c0b65","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR30-6eb95e0a14bc8351","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"This study adopted a cross-sectional mixed-methods design combining a quantitative survey with qualitative thematic analysis.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t30_o1","terms":["research design","mixed-methods","PMC13388837"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The quantitative component was used to examine the structural associations among AI perception, self-efficacy, foreign language anxiety, and multimodal L2 WTC","kind":"observe","local_id":"t30_o2","terms":["outcomes measured","constructs","multimodal L2 WTC"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Data collection was concentrated between January and March 2026, primarily implemented through Wenjuanxing, a widely used online survey platform in China.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t30_o3","terms":["data collection","Wenjuanxing","China"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The survey collected an initial 1,030 questionnaires.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t30_o4","terms":["initial sample size"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"960 high-quality valid samples were finally retained (effective recovery rate 93.2%).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t30_o5","terms":["valid sample size","N=960"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Prior to the large-scale administration, a pilot test was conducted with 45 undergraduate EFL students to evaluate instructional clarity, readability, and cultural appropriateness.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t30_o6","terms":["pilot test","undergraduate EFL students"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"referencing Davis’s (1989) Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) and Mac Callum and Jeffrey’s (2013) exploration of digital skill adoption behavior, we compiled the “AI Intelligent Tool Usage Experience and Perception Scale” containing 5 items.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t30_o7","terms":["AI intelligent perception scale","measurement tool"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"This scale focuses on learners’ intuitive experiences in dimensions such as “alleviating cognitive burden,” “immediacy of feedback,” “pleasure of efficiency,” and “technological path dependence.”","kind":"observe","local_id":"t30_o8","terms":["AI perception dimensions","5-point Likert scale"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t30_o1","t30_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t30_c1","object":"cross-sectional mixed-methods survey and thematic analysis of AI perception, L2 self-efficacy, foreign language anxiety, and multimodal L2 WTC","predicate":"uses_design_and_constructs","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 uses a cross-sectional mixed-methods design (quantitative survey + qualitative thematic analysis) to examine associations among AI perception, L2 self-efficacy, foreign language anxiety, and multimodal L2 WTC."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t30_o3","t30_o4","t30_o5","t30_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t30_c2","object":"960 valid questionnaires (of 1,030) collected Jan-Mar 2026 via Wenjuanxing in China after a 45-student EFL pilot","predicate":"rests_on_data","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 rests on 960 valid questionnaires (from 1,030 collected, 93.2% recovery) gathered via Wenjuanxing in China between January and March 2026, following a pilot test with 45 undergraduate EFL students."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t30_o7","t30_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t30_c3","object":"5-item AI Intelligent Tool Usage Experience and Perception Scale (based on Davis 1989; Mac Callum and Jeffrey 2013)","predicate":"measures_outcome_with","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 measures AI intelligent perception with a 5-item, 5-point Likert scale adapted from Davis (1989) and Mac Callum and Jeffrey (2013), covering cognitive burden, feedback immediacy, efficiency pleasure, and path dependence."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",16820,22812]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"3917ce3c3880dad490709afd8ee425ea7c62b0217fe1efcf89acd63b7df4668d","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["a43f299418e392edcf72190cce9679c3fecd47018ed0dc77865a9d53c22d24f3","5faa04a738c6317620d4a34bf866fda624da669f3b5d218f59549df2517aa0f9","eff29992e32d06cc8841cedd1ceaaf75d23d8c9dcb2d376a5ba24b457376f752","0d37ffffdb582f6f20038e3d8837c98f379be1b820e0de57c9ff1a68ec2f766e","2239332e9736723e9077ca90be8b2023088dfc7048709f0872084c9d8c518f37","ae653704bfcdcc2d23599979a4d92b29dc736290aecaf95540e25809a2025a75","8ce9b3b3dce1f9ba685a50fe258c8404cf413a3a3f1fab55dd60762d62445491","f6a8f366e0dd8f05ca6f100e152d1438174aa944eb83192a833aaedfdd762a28","54ec74c66b437a258847d6267dfdc9ef9b98a7214585f68d921a208bf5e2a413","48f6a240d1b804b98b8bbcd90ae332cf20a35a70ee942aa479efd66896a7ad6c","2e1429dc32a4ee29c7254d116221f10e18bb87d547ea5e46f2edfed605957212"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"668a745c89b5f52dc14f6a43383ca91b6657fb14e4b5b2c7736a7b0d1ae76312","submission_id":"TR30-6eb95e0a14bc8351#1"},"hash":"7db9e7da55149bc21afc3a2491335ac7ceb9ffc42ce089bcdbbd96b7277900a1","header":{"body_hash":"0f5086e55d85eec0cc3b69512afdf6d86f8b014832458decfe3193aa9dbfbcee","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"37e494625d74a5a9fd42e85302b90f1feca47355c013bead7fca364ee7f2853d","records_root":"b99aeaf9503a84e96afd3130f534e968735e4d1cb53ba5c0c993d344be6f624f","seq":142,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"a51c63847f192c17df1b64b05724142224a3570ebdb1232882239b8647865165","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":8,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":5,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:PMC13388837.txt#3"},"sync_step":15,"task_id":"TR30-6eb95e0a14bc8351"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:PMC13388837.txt#3","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3917ce3c3880dad490709afd8ee425ea7c62b0217fe1efcf89acd63b7df4668d","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"d47f623a2d21d5889b04bcfb94e18f1d1d98aee3dd6f648e46838ee64ca5a3bb","submission_id":"TR30-6eb95e0a14bc8351#done2"},"hash":"6333eda7c4ea19f01b5a319fddb57b552b20ece944e84e9cce15406ae50bb16c","header":{"body_hash":"713444ad224d07de65a5ae80a7f19ef3f81c5eaae50301005f9ea82cb9de6dc8","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"7db9e7da55149bc21afc3a2491335ac7ceb9ffc42ce089bcdbbd96b7277900a1","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":143,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"7d0316f5798a3b06b81ac7ef2e21bafc671a3339a95e9ebcd5487b19dbcd2847","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":8,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":378},"started_unix_ms":1795102309106,"wave":{"doc:PMC13388837.txt#1":"reader-2","doc:PMC13388837.txt#2":"reader-3","doc:PMC13388837.txt#3":"reader-1"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3917ce3c3880dad490709afd8ee425ea7c62b0217fe1efcf89acd63b7df4668d","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"1ede2df7fe0af4cf812482b8a87fcaf9774a85eb598f730db4842accbdf1f592","submission_id":"circle:044c674c0ec4d64a55648748f7d9a729724bbc411c1dfccf392894aaff777ec6"},"hash":"254b772832110bfbe0afc7abce719f9a219a20cd36244cf4abd4cb6f033c66e8","header":{"body_hash":"c59fd25dd1789915632975762948664cf97d818e95fd4ebaec310f6021410bf8","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"6333eda7c4ea19f01b5a319fddb57b552b20ece944e84e9cce15406ae50bb16c","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":144,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"138b5d7e90ee32dc19a165ce51987615b135da1d83ed6181b78eb2a912ea8a37","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"7d0316f5798a3b06b81ac7ef2e21bafc671a3339a95e9ebcd5487b19dbcd2847","engine_root":"3917ce3c3880dad490709afd8ee425ea7c62b0217fe1efcf89acd63b7df4668d","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"9f3ed74c948f9ebe4949add6e48743fb65fb5c32d78736ab6c55ab76cd0506f7","log_size":145,"projections":{"dependencies":"db08e85f57509846dd8cdc6a276d22f2c09f4a2ad76668f8cfe8c49b1f21e253","status":"01d4b902669e604278aba9237bf2f46b9bc6281ad52ab13a0c26aebfbe39b7e5"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"254b772832110bfbe0afc7abce719f9a219a20cd36244cf4abd4cb6f033c66e8"}},"engine_root":"3917ce3c3880dad490709afd8ee425ea7c62b0217fe1efcf89acd63b7df4668d","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"7d0316f5798a3b06b81ac7ef2e21bafc671a3339a95e9ebcd5487b19dbcd2847","engine_root":"3917ce3c3880dad490709afd8ee425ea7c62b0217fe1efcf89acd63b7df4668d","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"9f3ed74c948f9ebe4949add6e48743fb65fb5c32d78736ab6c55ab76cd0506f7","log_size":145,"projections":{"dependencies":"db08e85f57509846dd8cdc6a276d22f2c09f4a2ad76668f8cfe8c49b1f21e253","status":"01d4b902669e604278aba9237bf2f46b9bc6281ad52ab13a0c26aebfbe39b7e5"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"254b772832110bfbe0afc7abce719f9a219a20cd36244cf4abd4cb6f033c66e8"},"seal_hash":"aef56f968afb76e615f80e108ad7c49d4afb1c51835109ee9a363e4e2686d86e"}},"request_hash":"5153846121294b8be1fc80029d54bb247994895fb847b1e9d2b8d5ef8d04e084","submission_id":"seal-145"},"hash":"bbccb316e337a34d36c632352f3847310a17b0f8256fdd776df0ca97048cb0a1","header":{"body_hash":"f6f711fbe2e5f4cc18f1c1d02a26a3ba87ad7951c8a81259f1291c379e58dad9","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"254b772832110bfbe0afc7abce719f9a219a20cd36244cf4abd4cb6f033c66e8","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":145,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"1e169a60337ae41220443e78e2ad96f3d3f3e7d84b96db52c275cb2a2d294121","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"epoch":16,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102309106},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3917ce3c3880dad490709afd8ee425ea7c62b0217fe1efcf89acd63b7df4668d","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"33ada3906043e6b3c72c1a19ffd5299f25fc9cfa6e9e46fa9d8a33554344048b","submission_id":"ring-members:c1b00e3faccc485811e4a78027cdbd581e32cc89f4e0e096774d29cd52232037"},"hash":"0e3e0d7370ee9ebeb3f3289190a7f27e7fdc69a8ece2e0478e5dccc5f0434003","header":{"body_hash":"b2e6ba3288f4bd716097b403db84a5fe449d140c938987623abeae273c5bf734","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"bbccb316e337a34d36c632352f3847310a17b0f8256fdd776df0ca97048cb0a1","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":146,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"29aceca7d0c2e502398e8327e131941b0f954a7b979392358533931abfc51ac5","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":9,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":378},"started_unix_ms":1795102309137,"wave":{"doc:PMC13388837.txt#4":"reader-3","doc:PMC13388837.txt#5":"reader-1","doc:PMC13388837.txt#6":"reader-2"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3917ce3c3880dad490709afd8ee425ea7c62b0217fe1efcf89acd63b7df4668d","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"4796737f9857d21899801cbc439779328e78dddd9fe725c58da2e38d471f88dc","submission_id":"circle:26ac44987f344892160114b78e6765f2ce3f6f851f0eb3372747be6b626e2c52"},"hash":"8ddb6989168ca1f9f00f4ded1ab66bb468f7c90fc84f2810b9b8af0dea9c2a1b","header":{"body_hash":"1a6053681a2af654ee5e5340abc461f72bf5a89e4b449fe9905429e2446e4afe","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"0e3e0d7370ee9ebeb3f3289190a7f27e7fdc69a8ece2e0478e5dccc5f0434003","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":147,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"37b86bd718993ef7aa69979913db91f44497154b16e6e7bc51edde8742cc1744","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"29aceca7d0c2e502398e8327e131941b0f954a7b979392358533931abfc51ac5","engine_root":"3917ce3c3880dad490709afd8ee425ea7c62b0217fe1efcf89acd63b7df4668d","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"18a5ba83b6079c60bfadf54e24b6f73cfd2aa5c678add337672793af6be813a9","log_size":148,"projections":{"dependencies":"db08e85f57509846dd8cdc6a276d22f2c09f4a2ad76668f8cfe8c49b1f21e253","status":"01d4b902669e604278aba9237bf2f46b9bc6281ad52ab13a0c26aebfbe39b7e5"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"8ddb6989168ca1f9f00f4ded1ab66bb468f7c90fc84f2810b9b8af0dea9c2a1b"}},"engine_root":"3917ce3c3880dad490709afd8ee425ea7c62b0217fe1efcf89acd63b7df4668d","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"29aceca7d0c2e502398e8327e131941b0f954a7b979392358533931abfc51ac5","engine_root":"3917ce3c3880dad490709afd8ee425ea7c62b0217fe1efcf89acd63b7df4668d","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"18a5ba83b6079c60bfadf54e24b6f73cfd2aa5c678add337672793af6be813a9","log_size":148,"projections":{"dependencies":"db08e85f57509846dd8cdc6a276d22f2c09f4a2ad76668f8cfe8c49b1f21e253","status":"01d4b902669e604278aba9237bf2f46b9bc6281ad52ab13a0c26aebfbe39b7e5"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"8ddb6989168ca1f9f00f4ded1ab66bb468f7c90fc84f2810b9b8af0dea9c2a1b"},"seal_hash":"32ef8760325a2530247ee8bd2d8b2cec36977df35e9149cdeec8f63efd1ed657"}},"request_hash":"ce4563011a5dba922d689b53f5364268d14302c76e11f2e6d63614985b6d543f","submission_id":"seal-148"},"hash":"c2ea73a509ffa9a648f47fd86d98cee4e2906da82e6566906144ce0ae540e12c","header":{"body_hash":"ab18db4533a06357f86eb61e2d3eeaddc944d06d936b55f7cf6aa57e9dc84a6c","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"8ddb6989168ca1f9f00f4ded1ab66bb468f7c90fc84f2810b9b8af0dea9c2a1b","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":148,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"8a56a537cb5ae3b828a91ed9cb9ba675caa0642752910572251779be8e0364f0","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"epoch":17,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102309137},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3917ce3c3880dad490709afd8ee425ea7c62b0217fe1efcf89acd63b7df4668d","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"f4299db8b499d6e26f6d9a7060a286be7dfc0f9bd1cb7a136689f327c18f2b1e","submission_id":"ring-members:c2486495f48255c1257a67fc4af6af4c31a601eb74b56caa4705405687fc3d3d"},"hash":"d31dd0294ad004b6a4e5c30849b5b6df375baf21288a600e2dda15e3959d1d29","header":{"body_hash":"457a93cb58b8f3f0cc668bf79a857b85572bf5bb9146b76ccf999b1d402f3a05","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"c2ea73a509ffa9a648f47fd86d98cee4e2906da82e6566906144ce0ae540e12c","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":149,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"3e8d38b7f98658d1e4f7c13ddb540fd3e103d4c707f4584e6b42fe3367c56012","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T32-a6901519ee68c858","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"we adopted the domain-specific efficacy scale framework developed by Wang et al. (2014). This section contains 4 core measurement items","kind":"observe","local_id":"t32_o1","terms":["self-efficacy measurement","outcomes measured"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"covering competence belief measurements in the four basic skills of listening, speaking, reading, and writing.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t32_o2","terms":["self-efficacy four skills","outcomes measured"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Foreign language anxiety perception scale (FLA)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t32_o3","terms":["foreign language anxiety scale","outcomes measured"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"this section focuses via 4 measurement items on “peer pressure,” “impromptu response panic,” “fear of negative evaluation,” and “assessment anxiety.”","kind":"observe","local_id":"t32_o4","terms":["FLA items","outcomes measured"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"As the key dependent variable of this study, the measurement of WTC referred to concepts from MacIntyre et al. (1998) and Peng and Woodrow (2010).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t32_o5","terms":["L2 WTC dependent variable","outcomes measured"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"we disassembled WTC into two dimensions: “receptive willingness (listening and reading)” and “productive willingness (speaking and writing),” totaling 8 measurement items.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t32_o6","terms":["WTC dimensions and items","outcomes measured"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"this study appended an optional qualitative question (Part 3) at the end of the survey.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t32_o7","terms":["qualitative survey component","data source"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The prompt specifically asked: “When using generative AI tools (such as ChatGPT or translation applications) for English learning, what specific benefits, cognitive shifts, or psychological anxieties","kind":"observe","local_id":"t32_o8","terms":["qualitative prompt on GenAI","outcomes measured"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"valid qualitative responses were obtained from 712 participants (excluding blank or meaningless inputs), with text lengths ranging from 15 to 120 words (averaging approximately 45 words).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t32_o9","terms":["qualitative sample size","data source"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"the two coders initially reviewed 100 random responses to establish a unified codebook, achieving high inter-rater reliability (Cohen’s Kappa = 0.86).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t32_o10","terms":["thematic coding reliability","qualitative methods"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t32_o1","t32_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t32_c1","object":"domain-specific self-efficacy across listening, speaking, reading, and writing (4 items adapted from Wang et al. 2014)","predicate":"measures_outcome","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 measures domain-specific self-efficacy across listening, speaking, reading, and writing using a 4-item scale adapted from Wang et al. (2014)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t32_o3","t32_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t32_c2","object":"foreign language anxiety perception (FLA; 4 items: peer pressure, impromptu response panic, fear of negative evaluation, assessment anxiety)","predicate":"measures_outcome","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 measures foreign language anxiety perception (FLA) via 4 items covering peer pressure, impromptu response panic, fear of negative evaluation, and assessment anxiety."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t32_o5","t32_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t32_c3","object":"multimodal L2 willingness to communicate (WTC; 8 items across receptive and productive dimensions)","predicate":"measures_dependent_variable","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 measures multimodal L2 willingness to communicate (WTC) as its key dependent variable via 8 items split into receptive (listening, reading) and productive (speaking, writing) willingness."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t32_o7","t32_o8","t32_o9","t32_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t32_c4","object":"712 qualitative responses on generative AI in English learning, coded via thematic analysis (Cohen's Kappa = 0.86)","predicate":"uses_qualitative_data","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 rests in part on 712 valid voluntary qualitative survey responses (15-120 words, mean ~45) on benefits, cognitive shifts, or anxieties when using GenAI tools for English learning, coded with Cohen's Kappa = 0.86."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",22812,26553]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"86fba40d0f1ec79def7a87c9f4ee57fc6a811edd2178464c51c5c08af41ee5ea","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["68728c3225bac52dc5b734cab892540be7bc202629dcca7e7c2fee6405943ef5","34a14a2d9d4a7a9e0e6a76cde5ae6bc7e570dbc44bccef9e0f1987ba269550e1","23eb945abed4dd523ceaaeb18eccfe7234b9c3b99f74eba2ffab6e2650137513","885b0cef9608e67e04ab27269fd53a2f692fbf768155738e3c94d8e2f643fe43","fa42d6a0bc1b7b13b1bb9a55ce46f0918bebbcaf7a57689a7111018a8866848b","912a1b578e4dcbfac9a4545b0542557eb59d4d8e0ac77866823fce47ab425fc5","abf958cabc5eed75b205b1d46b0d74227d2fabe93bc0ee84cb2904f4422fef44","87da36a2b1e7c8339947d77565c26c6caf9a5a3d801c4b669c2d069845694734","d15e307dbb633901090400b15af9568574216ad74f4309040342d7b93f0f82f7","53cc4e3cea734e136240ae7547785609dd69a6e27254a7bd3500384cf3198e52","273ae79a00ff65a3dfbf30a17732a330331b5443fcb966097d819b84fe8fc05a","b26035b95047fc3260ec364700deef46277e3428902b9538774c7ff1a5e79da4","4f98a3e612fb3ab719c61c3811d528810534b80d55d181b3b3c55fcf638fdb46","773fc992a7b2509b5c0e636efc12f96d44343a9e10b6a7735734576c24000420"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"28861926a34de0878a834e3385f67d1e24bad904f740db430ce35c699ddc5c1d","submission_id":"T32-a6901519ee68c858#1"},"hash":"a37dc77e5d0fc5276268701b52047c91f8d8cf67a8f02e505b6de4d78f97626b","header":{"body_hash":"9faa4f5d5a7c97d3bb7d228a1655d2a6b88d3b995c7a69993fe43f0ea69a945e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"d31dd0294ad004b6a4e5c30849b5b6df375baf21288a600e2dda15e3959d1d29","records_root":"e82394a13c96335f0dc8d4e2368c3db3f727e8f3a213935ebe94e7dad9492df4","seq":150,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"beba32a40aa102df059b9c6fa1e0756bfe37773cf1d0a20407dd6e6c0bce631e","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":9,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":17,"task_id":"T32-a6901519ee68c858"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13388837.txt#4","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"86fba40d0f1ec79def7a87c9f4ee57fc6a811edd2178464c51c5c08af41ee5ea","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"875e4e1209366a08399f38a28912211ce1e9e44f9db3f6e8eae56289c1158bb8","submission_id":"T32-a6901519ee68c858#done2"},"hash":"31b103b80cf0a25ea38aa83a052c44f8359db820797569f6deff1439b377a96d","header":{"body_hash":"2a99fe008b3a4ae9fb1fd40098def3c58d7d09c9844d5cbd57c5863760ead62e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"a37dc77e5d0fc5276268701b52047c91f8d8cf67a8f02e505b6de4d78f97626b","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":151,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"8441dceee946f9e18fcae81d8354c79c6bc26e4c4ee988d798f234d9c4e213dc","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T31-87ffc46e31106bcb","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"AI intelligent perception (M = 3.57) demonstrates significant positive correlations with students’ receptive and productive WTC (r = 0.220 and 0.224, p < 0.01)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t31_o1","terms":["AI intelligent perception","receptive WTC","productive WTC","correlation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"L2 self-efficacy shares robust positive links with these dual communication modalities (r = 0.414 and 0.375) while foreign language anxiety displays expected negative correlations (r = −0.200 and −0.285).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t31_o2","terms":["L2 self-efficacy","foreign language anxiety","receptive WTC","productive WTC","correlation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Results showed that the square root of the AVE for each construct (listed on the diagonal) was significantly greater than the correlation coefficients between that construct and other latent variables.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t31_o3","terms":["Fornell-Larcker criterion","discriminant validity","AVE"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Data from the paired-samples t-test demonstrated that learners’ baseline willingness for receptive WTC (M = 3.66, SD = 0.71) was significantly higher than that for productive WTC (M = 3.10, SD = 0.72)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t31_o4","terms":["paired-samples t-test","receptive WTC","productive WTC","baseline willingness"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"with the difference reaching a statistically significant level, t(959) = 24.06, p < 0.001, Cohen’s d = 0.79.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t31_o5","terms":["t-test statistics","sample size df 959","Cohen's d"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Specifically, the standardized path coefficient from AI perception to receptive WTC was β = 0.220, 95% CI [0.156, 0.288]; to productive WTC, it was β = 0.224, 95% CI [0.163, 0.295].","kind":"observe","local_id":"t31_o6","terms":["path coefficients","AI perception","receptive WTC","productive WTC"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The two sets of confidence intervals highly overlapped, and the path coefficient difference was extremely small, Δβ = 0.004, not reaching statistical significance.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t31_o7","terms":["path coefficient difference","non-significance","H2b test"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"In summary, the validation results failed to support Hypothesis H2b (the differential path strength hypothesis). While the data substantiated the theoretical premise of Hypothesis H2a","kind":"observe","local_id":"t31_o8","terms":["Hypothesis H2b unsupported","Hypothesis H2a supported"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Consequently, the assertion that “AI assistance holds a stronger predictive power for receptive willingness” is not empirically supported, nor can we definitively claim statistical equivalence without an a priori equivalence bounds test (e.g., TOST).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t31_o9","terms":["qualification","statistical equivalence","TOST"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"To test the mechanism between perception and willingness, a Structural Equation Model (SEM) was established and a Bootstrap sampling was used to test the mediation effect.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t31_o10","terms":["Structural Equation Model","Bootstrap sampling","mediation effect"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"As shown in Table 4, after controlling for statistical variables, AI perception was significantly and positively correlated with self-efficacy (β = 0.346, p < 0.001).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t31_o11","terms":["AI perception","self-efficacy","SEM path coefficient"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Mediation effect bootstrap test report (5,000 samples).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t31_o12","terms":["bootstrap 5,000 samples","mediation test"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t31_o1","t31_o2","t31_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t31_c1","object":"AI perception (r=0.220, 0.224), L2 self-efficacy (r=0.414, 0.375), and FL anxiety (r=-0.200, -0.285) with receptive/productive WTC; Fornell-Larcker discriminant validity","predicate":"reports_correlations_and_validity","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 reports positive correlations of AI perception (r=0.220, 0.224; p<0.01) and L2 self-efficacy (r=0.414, 0.375) with receptive and productive WTC, negative correlations with FL anxiety (r=-0.200, -0.285), and Fornell-Larcker validity."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t31_o4","t31_o5","t31_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t31_c2","object":"receptive WTC (M=3.66, SD=0.71) exceeds productive WTC (M=3.10, SD=0.72), t(959)=24.06, p<0.001, d=0.79 (supporting H2a)","predicate":"concludes_baseline_WTC_difference","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"Using a paired-samples t-test (df=959, indicating N=960 learners), PMC13388837 finds baseline receptive WTC (M=3.66, SD=0.71) is significantly higher than productive WTC (M=3.10, SD=0.72), t(959)=24.06, p<0.001, d=0.79 (supporting H2a)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t31_o6","t31_o7","t31_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t31_c3","object":"Hypothesis H2b unsupported; path coefficients from AI perception to receptive WTC (β=0.220) and productive WTC (β=0.224) do not significantly differ (Δβ=0.004)","predicate":"rejects_differential_prediction_hypothesis","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 rejects Hypothesis H2b, finding that AI perception's predictive strength for receptive WTC (β=0.220, 95% CI [0.156, 0.288]) and productive WTC (β=0.224, 95% CI [0.163, 0.295]) shows no significant difference (Δβ=0.004)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t31_o7","t31_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t31_c4","object":"statistical equivalence of AI perception predictive power across WTC modalities cannot be definitively claimed without an a priori equivalence bounds test (e.g., TOST)","predicate":"qualifies_null_path_difference","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 qualifies its finding of non-significant path differences (Δβ=0.004) by stating that statistical equivalence between AI perception's effects on receptive and productive WTC cannot be definitively claimed without an equivalence test (TOST)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t31_o10","t31_o11","t31_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t31_c5","object":"AI perception positively predicts self-efficacy (β=0.346, p<0.001) in SEM with 5,000-sample bootstrap","predicate":"reports_SEM_association","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"Using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) with 5,000-sample bootstrap mediation testing, PMC13388837 finds that AI perception is significantly and positively associated with self-efficacy (β=0.346, p<0.001) after controlling for covariates."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",32309,38260]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"478db707f09cef5b9baca50a09fb78cb8bb64c9a31d0e30fb536baac0b003e80","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["9bac28d24e66ee005c77c3b82f84f6f7d0e32c7a9aac2356d869b985e8104610","c1f1842ac7edd40216eeb0e549bee92652bb0ebfa92d9d927769a7649a4aa262","d1b724bfdd244b173a6d978ce563ea1828127923b74360c8da55baa45f871dc9","d7c3914cb187b8216ccdb93c8e43c2d4b9c9f1997abe329f81ac6912cae99664","b9c6b8db508e8d981c8b3e8ccffd07a24bbd7c6d253e072bdb9f0f234f37d97a","00ac1ecd92f489b4f0a1ed4ec1ba9365d1740a1cdfd5a571155715191fe69723","fc85a0d917744d753c773c00875cd145b6d5d1133ccd772f501f8b1edcad9fc6","6f700e126e0d100914477cb435407dfd299d4be95b7cf0379f3d8d3b8c6f2d8d","cd73879c4791ce98d21ba741d6eb3a1c0275ec0635ada992b3748e9f441cacc7","54680f8a0f335a2e92acf2ee6f81a217a3572430746e89e38fddf3860c005686","51e7c38c15474878667edf926c96fe09ae5a224a1d38a1e53273987668e4050b","42a05caad3ac0a71d1cc0c21d877bb739f116e617c8752e49b127bb26de43de0"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":12}},"request_hash":"d04853f2d969f18b30ade8fd78c4320eef0cdb586542df1944f55e1de7b69802","submission_id":"T31-87ffc46e31106bcb#1"},"hash":"1b5e7ede339675c6a1947e265f02e872db1d256160f7ecacc7e3f6928ff7e145","header":{"body_hash":"d8febc1f6371247683b072110cf932080c86e224ec44c5fb72b642061e8d44b3","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"31b103b80cf0a25ea38aa83a052c44f8359db820797569f6deff1439b377a96d","records_root":"b3689d80334d4cca8807024bb3f5a373bfcb71ac1bc033f370db2241679d03ff","seq":152,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"c1201f52bb47dc525ed674279e2ec1f711f70274029bfd6d3bf418e8e1a8cf2f","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T31-87ffc46e31106bcb","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t31_o4","t31_o5","t31_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t31_c2","object":"receptive WTC (M=3.66, SD=0.71) exceeds productive WTC (M=3.10, SD=0.72), t(959)=24.06, p<0.001, d=0.79 (supporting H2a)","predicate":"concludes_baseline_WTC_difference","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"Using a paired-samples t-test (df=959, indicating N=960 learners), PMC13388837 finds baseline receptive WTC (M=3.66, SD=0.71) is significantly higher than productive WTC (M=3.10, SD=0.72), t(959)=24.06, p<0.001, d=0.79 (supporting H2a)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t31_o6","t31_o7","t31_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t31_c3","object":"Hypothesis H2b unsupported; path coefficients from AI perception to receptive WTC (β=0.220) and productive WTC (β=0.224) do not significantly differ (Δβ=0.004)","predicate":"rejects_differential_prediction_hypothesis","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 rejects Hypothesis H2b, finding that AI perception's predictive strength for receptive WTC (β=0.220, 95% CI [0.156, 0.288]) and productive WTC (β=0.224, 95% CI [0.163, 0.295]) shows no significant difference (Δβ=0.004)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t31_o7","t31_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t31_c4","object":"statistical equivalence of AI perception predictive power across WTC modalities cannot be definitively claimed without an a priori equivalence bounds test (e.g., TOST)","predicate":"qualifies_null_path_difference","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 qualifies its finding of non-significant path differences (Δβ=0.004) by stating that statistical equivalence between AI perception's effects on receptive and productive WTC cannot be definitively claimed without an equivalence test (TOST)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t31_o10","t31_o11","t31_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t31_c5","object":"AI perception positively predicts self-efficacy (β=0.346, p<0.001) in SEM with 5,000-sample bootstrap","predicate":"reports_SEM_association","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"Using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) with 5,000-sample bootstrap mediation testing, PMC13388837 finds that AI perception is significantly and positively associated with self-efficacy (β=0.346, p<0.001) after controlling for covariates."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",32309,38260]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"478db707f09cef5b9baca50a09fb78cb8bb64c9a31d0e30fb536baac0b003e80","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["21e0b6501f65af2bf23798a61a82f101c87d341d22ae989e7bec3cf1c235d523","876146ef6be3c37fa2acb55078eaf1394f7e7d67526bec40dd11285b0d54fe6e"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":2}},"request_hash":"4243258835987ee2be580ab000dd8b217a6c0de2aebe8def71faed6352d91a0f","submission_id":"T31-87ffc46e31106bcb#1.1"},"hash":"a826dbbd042ec352dba16385233aa7c7d3daa9d360d993eebdaad32946f9084d","header":{"body_hash":"bd62462d48cb4da0da433c9c97c4e102c2e4dcb107988b6eaf3ecea0538d7b03","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"1b5e7ede339675c6a1947e265f02e872db1d256160f7ecacc7e3f6928ff7e145","records_root":"38385646402bb82227bc8e03312bc843e7e522cfb5b838680f1903814fd58a86","seq":153,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"1febaff955e300818e841f91bc9923b41926fc0d91c710fe451f08bb720480e9","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T31-87ffc46e31106bcb","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t31_o10","t31_o11","t31_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t31_c5","object":"AI perception positively predicts self-efficacy (β=0.346, p<0.001) in SEM with 5,000-sample bootstrap","predicate":"reports_SEM_association","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"Using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) with 5,000-sample bootstrap mediation testing, PMC13388837 finds that AI perception is significantly and positively associated with self-efficacy (β=0.346, p<0.001) after controlling for covariates."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",32309,38260]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"478db707f09cef5b9baca50a09fb78cb8bb64c9a31d0e30fb536baac0b003e80","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["77227a3be7f73e785c8334065c045c25bbe960eca4f08ab00da7adb780465383"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"6317055d45ef0ee1d0f3e171db5cbd4d565206f114737891aae35430c7026cf2","submission_id":"T31-87ffc46e31106bcb#1.2"},"hash":"d581c19dfde6a0024506d2bd72aa4266d0e789073d4a419299e753efe3672d6b","header":{"body_hash":"c8ea41d9a97648e7f5ea37cbd7c0d410e2a96c2c9bce2529a3307782b7f727cf","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"a826dbbd042ec352dba16385233aa7c7d3daa9d360d993eebdaad32946f9084d","records_root":"55700468c511bd9693b2e558c7b9020a2a210ea16dfae02b694183ee915056de","seq":154,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"0c8e9033f2c28bae9cdfb9e6254507bb3cfddedd0159bd79220e0ed7c279d072","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@9bac28d24e66ee00","@c1f1842ac7edd402","@d1b724bfdd244b17","@d7c3914cb187b821","@b9c6b8db508e8d98","@00ac1ecd92f489b4","@fc85a0d917744d75","@6f700e126e0d1009","@cd73879c4791ce98","@54680f8a0f335a2e","@51e7c38c15474878","@42a05caad3ac0a71","@21e0b6501f65af2b","@876146ef6be3c37f","@77227a3be7f73e78"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":12,"local_id":"t31_c1"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":15,"local_id":"t31_c4"}],"task_id":"T31-87ffc46e31106bcb","work_key":"doc:PMC13388837.txt#6"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T31-87ffc46e31106bcb:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"478db707f09cef5b9baca50a09fb78cb8bb64c9a31d0e30fb536baac0b003e80","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"4d1139e62e0a10607892d807456393febada79cb8dacc2fc96785703a87d0b9c","submission_id":"T31-87ffc46e31106bcb#repair1"},"hash":"f7bf918547f070d9c60a31b8e30e319fc1a5a8ea78bfdcfa261a4999f9c12d9a","header":{"body_hash":"33f17ff73c461a843aec2fd2f5770380c7ac3baaa5b1dcc361f84a846c861ceb","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"d581c19dfde6a0024506d2bd72aa4266d0e789073d4a419299e753efe3672d6b","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":155,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"3102c3242f6f2d91e0421b2d8cd199be35bb024151fe03e4758ab2fb18dc5fab","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T33-dc4ca07a21df61d7","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"This study employs a mixed analysis strategy primarily quantitative with qualitative support.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t33_o1","terms":["mixed analysis strategy","study design"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"AMOS 24.0 software was used to construct a Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) to examine the complex correlations among psychological latent variables.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t33_o2","terms":["AMOS 24.0","SEM","psychological latent variables"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"two independent researchers used NVivo qualitative analysis software to conduct semantic segmentation, high-frequency word condensation, and thematic categorization coding on the 712 valid open-ended responses","kind":"observe","local_id":"t33_o3","terms":["NVivo","712 valid open-ended responses","qualitative data"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The first unrotated factor explained 24.05% of the total variance, which was below the commonly used 40% reference threshold (Podsakoff et al., 2003), suggesting that no dominant single-factor structure was detected in the self-reported data.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t33_o4","terms":["Harman's Single-Factor Test","24.05% variance","common method bias"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"However, given the low sensitivity of this diagnostic approach, this result should not be interpreted as sufficient evidence to rule out CMB. Therefore, subsequent interpretations of correlation and path coefficients should remain cautious.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t33_o5","terms":["common method bias qualification","low sensitivity"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The Cronbach’s α coefficients of all latent variables ranged between 0.702 and 0.780, and the Composite Reliability (CR) values were all greater than 0.8 (0.817–0.850), showing good internal consistency.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t33_o6","terms":["Cronbach's alpha","Composite Reliability","internal consistency"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"the Average Variance Extracted (AVE) values for all latent variables ranged from 0.528 to 0.573, entirely exceeding the 0.5 threshold suggested by Fornell and Larcker (1981), indicating good convergent validity of the measurement model.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t33_o7","terms":["AVE","convergent validity"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"the structural model exhibited good goodness of fit: χ2 = 338.55, df = 183, χ2/df = 1.850, CFI = 0.968, TLI = 0.962, RMSEA = 0.030, GFI = 0.958, SRMR = 0.043.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t33_o8","terms":["CFA goodness of fit","structural model fit indices"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Measurement construct | No. of items | Standardized CFA factor loadings | Cronbach’s α | Composite reliability (CR) | Average variance extracted (AVE)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t33_o9","terms":["Table 2 header","measurement constructs"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"AI intelligent perception (AI) | 5 | 0.673–0.767 | 0.780 | 0.850 | 0.531","kind":"observe","local_id":"t33_o10","terms":["AI intelligent perception","reliability and validity"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Self-efficacy (SE) | 4 | 0.710–0.754 | 0.726 | 0.830 | 0.549","kind":"observe","local_id":"t33_o11","terms":["Self-efficacy","reliability and validity"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Foreign language anxiety (FLA) | 4 | 0.698–0.761 | 0.702 | 0.817 | 0.528","kind":"observe","local_id":"t33_o12","terms":["Foreign language anxiety","reliability and validity"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Receptive WTC (WTC-R) | 4 | 0.737–0.782 | 0.751 | 0.843 | 0.573","kind":"observe","local_id":"t33_o13","terms":["Receptive WTC","reliability and validity"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Productive WTC (WTC-P) | 4 | 0.721–0.762 | 0.733 | 0.833 | 0.555","kind":"observe","local_id":"t33_o14","terms":["Productive WTC","reliability and validity"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t33_o1","t33_o2","t33_o3","t33_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t33_c1","object":"mixed analysis: SEM on self-reported data and NVivo thematic coding of 712 valid open-ended responses","predicate":"uses_data_and_methods","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 uses a mixed analysis strategy combining Structural Equation Modeling (SEM in AMOS 24.0) on self-reported quantitative data with NVivo qualitative coding of 712 valid open-ended responses."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t33_o9","t33_o10","t33_o11","t33_o12","t33_o13","t33_o14"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t33_c2","object":"AI intelligent perception (AI), Self-efficacy (SE), Foreign language anxiety (FLA), Receptive WTC (WTC-R), and Productive WTC (WTC-P)","predicate":"measures_constructs","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 measures five latent constructs (21 items total): AI intelligent perception (5 items), Self-efficacy (4 items), Foreign language anxiety (4 items), Receptive WTC (4 items), and Productive WTC (4 items)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t33_o6","t33_o7","t33_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t33_c3","object":"good reliability (α 0.702-0.780, CR 0.817-0.850), convergent validity (AVE 0.528-0.573), and CFA fit (χ2/df=1.850, CFI=0.968, RMSEA=0.030)","predicate":"concludes_measurement_validity","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 reports good internal consistency (Cronbach's α=0.702–0.780; CR=0.817–0.850), convergent validity (AVE=0.528–0.573), and CFA model fit (χ2/df=1.850, CFI=0.968, TLI=0.962, RMSEA=0.030, GFI=0.958, SRMR=0.043)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t33_o4","t33_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t33_c4","object":"first unrotated factor explained 24.05% variance (<40%), but low diagnostic sensitivity does not rule out common method bias","predicate":"qualifies_common_method_bias_test","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"In PMC13388837, Harman's Single-Factor Test showed the first factor explained 24.05% of variance (<40%), detecting no dominant single factor, though the authors qualify that low test sensitivity cannot rule out common method bias."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",26553,32309]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"6c4f60678c3105a4e7d6c1e81d22089e3d396921784b7a89b047000d74c4fc6c","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["37294671206c048c370b7cad69875620d03c6ea39c8a5409d1e7132c4677424b","38f94b613382e51fe84f33c13d451089e896992bceac3ebcd5adfa77fcb8ce23","6189944e042b56bc4661b45df1fe2e11c84792f228af6cd8013db0ca0460aad6","b7baaca00d775c71855a6a22a56dfc6728a43982a17b555f3217c69d04a1921d","cb23b69411c36995e0b695edef31b61dfed3c68dacde5dabd8d01fd7b736582e","6cf40b2d2796b3fa13f02f405a2b9a11d82f11f5f54a64b10f20589dd0989cea","e654eaee77a53167e989b2855cd1542b719de7040b5e815b844b5c143ae6baa0","c8daec1b2023e24c51829b77d4226756aa48e26adaef1014f0e80f9d16331807","626ff5ea98d185f5f28d1997fc4a13a46f56a9b3a9c4d1b670c80eac00c9abb6","1749c9fcba80a1dec6bc1961eb7c3a956a4e6946bbd02186f01528cf9add25d9","5e2c4712c0fa15ac8085b81b95cde6d7600b573ce82518ff9a76f01eaf1ffa9b","6682d1a1fb4949b5506822ac6cb0afd64fe61cac94d8d5fbaaacae20a8d327cc","6f878a81cb37d6140116f306facf655fb811fd3af0c1fc3d48dcd81d94c2b43c","aae847cd3fd11b5239baaa4d4aeffb067b383750b8ed4685891f2432c6e12625","cc98e85b86834e3c09664caf21fca46709aff20359a0005d106c74fd463393eb","f48c7280dfbfa98eb1a21f251803cd3d118a6e598485d9fb63b082882a83da10","c37cecbee0a0d221902161b77e6bc134440623472682a77333282fe0928acebc","179537a589fa64b3b18418453690ce48ce89f6923c8009ed76e2e228d94a04d2"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"41ae8b9954439cc2a57837370367d873c105a2976949152f2a670e9a7ec5a9d1","submission_id":"T33-dc4ca07a21df61d7#1"},"hash":"19cd779be5a9dd3c213e392f5cd48feff990b0f77896cb6bd4b5dd40a1c2c9ba","header":{"body_hash":"9a166fd4270cfd5c54c9be2c472ca741ba7b0cf519424ab68544d5967169c953","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"f7bf918547f070d9c60a31b8e30e319fc1a5a8ea78bfdcfa261a4999f9c12d9a","records_root":"f3b958f0405d8637bd010937a09face08ff1e349f46e37298028f16866771468","seq":156,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"61ab47c39b1ebc93442f4eab427b245523b156819449d3f60543b1e83496812a","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":9,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":17,"task_id":"T33-dc4ca07a21df61d7"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13388837.txt#5","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"6c4f60678c3105a4e7d6c1e81d22089e3d396921784b7a89b047000d74c4fc6c","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"6a910a8cee3c1d5856563f81acc76b941ab7323cd080d65bc6230b0a48e901e6","submission_id":"T33-dc4ca07a21df61d7#done2"},"hash":"d487972062b6dc1f79fe13ef32130b04224e7c6c7dcfd9e2de56a1b0ea7ff23f","header":{"body_hash":"65a1ceb576a68c2836d6263bb1428301b62bf42b52edfc3b6e8386a402855f48","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"19cd779be5a9dd3c213e392f5cd48feff990b0f77896cb6bd4b5dd40a1c2c9ba","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":157,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"5e639da36fb2e74a47e9bdd1fa7e4ea600591130c02467c5dd8cda2ce2d07d0e","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T31-87ffc46e31106bcb","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t31_o1","t31_o2","t31_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t31_c1","object":"AI perception (r=0.220, 0.224), L2 self-efficacy (r=0.414, 0.375), and FL anxiety (r=-0.200, -0.285) with receptive/productive WTC; Fornell-Larcker discriminant validity","predicate":"reports_correlations_and_validity","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 reports positive correlations of AI perception (r=0.220, 0.224; p<0.01) and L2 self-efficacy (r=0.414, 0.375) with receptive/productive WTC, negative links with FL anxiety (r=-0.200, -0.285), and Fornell-Larcker validity."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t31_o7","t31_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t31_c4","object":"statistical equivalence of AI perception predictive power across WTC modalities cannot be definitively claimed without an a priori equivalence bounds test (e.g., TOST)","predicate":"qualifies_null_path_difference","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 qualifies its null path difference (Δβ=0.004), stating that statistical equivalence between AI perception's effects on receptive and productive WTC cannot be claimed without an equivalence test (e.g., TOST)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",32309,38260]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"6c4f60678c3105a4e7d6c1e81d22089e3d396921784b7a89b047000d74c4fc6c","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["2a4eb93d011bdadfe5166f0f73f31d7a25a9041474e96befb34fa46fa29d1a96","c7ae0257df92051259b3467aea872d243da851ceab543119b29954bf88f6c7e3"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"953eb23c8d03960ef79021ac2126816684baa9d41d9f24a6241e458b6fb684d2","submission_id":"T31-87ffc46e31106bcb#2"},"hash":"1da3c532873a0ba470d90e416104416b0ca64ce0103b5e8a1cce7d9234d370b1","header":{"body_hash":"35ef15dcc349c141393699b9927dec8bf5339839778bcfc14fd93a18eea95786","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"d487972062b6dc1f79fe13ef32130b04224e7c6c7dcfd9e2de56a1b0ea7ff23f","records_root":"56dd0e8a35c13346d22f6c5da98bfa934a9d1dc68e3ef40ffe6c8061588e406b","seq":158,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"d5750ad1069c44586f766e9791821b1c053c014f8097eb786ce300980df6689c","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":false,"agent":"reader-2","circle":9,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":17,"refusals":1,"stored":17,"sync_step":17,"task_id":"T31-87ffc46e31106bcb"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13388837.txt#6","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"6c4f60678c3105a4e7d6c1e81d22089e3d396921784b7a89b047000d74c4fc6c","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"95ee08f576a9e81f137b17cb5f64c5207f3319c3e92d6ce3c9b7971ba4ba4ed4","submission_id":"T31-87ffc46e31106bcb#done3"},"hash":"7143a89d1c37c73f72f7954cf2e3124f87a61a018c9fb1c9fc4e32ec07de348e","header":{"body_hash":"c7ec3bde9d75ab865023bf33791d03756666b2e9bca22339006e2ce87163c6d7","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"1da3c532873a0ba470d90e416104416b0ca64ce0103b5e8a1cce7d9234d370b1","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":159,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"28b269293efef4bc77700fbe9ada38de169fd5e71be210500bdb2d206ad580f0","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR34-816fb953d129ef38","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Specifically, AI intelligent perception (M = 3.57) demonstrates significant positive correlations with students’ receptive and productive WTC (r = 0.220 and 0.224, p < 0.01)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o1","terms":["AI intelligent perception","receptive WTC","productive WTC","correlation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"providing initial statistical support for the primary association proposed in Hypothesis H1.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o2","terms":["Hypothesis H1","initial statistical support"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"L2 self-efficacy shares robust positive links with these dual communication modalities (r = 0.414 and 0.375) while foreign language anxiety displays expected negative correlations (r = −0.200 and −0.285).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o3","terms":["L2 self-efficacy","foreign language anxiety","receptive and productive WTC correlations"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Results showed that the square root of the AVE for each construct (listed on the diagonal) was significantly greater than the correlation coefficients between that construct and other latent variables.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o4","terms":["Fornell-Larcker criterion","discriminant validity","AVE"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"1. AI perception | 3.57 | 0.70 | 0.729 |  |  |  |","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o5","terms":["AI perception mean SD and square root of AVE"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"2. Self-efficacy | 3.38 | 0.70 | 0.346** | 0.741 |  |  |","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o6","terms":["Self-efficacy mean SD correlation and square root of AVE"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"3. FL anxiety | 3.02 | 0.70 | −0.155** | −0.224** | 0.727 |  |","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o7","terms":["FL anxiety mean SD correlations and square root of AVE"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"4. Receptive WTC | 3.66 | 0.71 | 0.220** | 0.414** | −0.200** | 0.757 |","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o8","terms":["Receptive WTC mean SD correlations and square root of AVE"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"5. Productive WTC | 3.10 | 0.72 | 0.224** | 0.375** | −0.285** | 0.482** | 0.745","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o9","terms":["Productive WTC mean SD correlations and square root of AVE"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"learners’ baseline willingness for receptive WTC (M = 3.66, SD = 0.71) was significantly higher than that for productive WTC (M = 3.10, SD = 0.72)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o10","terms":["paired-samples t-test","baseline receptive vs productive WTC"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"with the difference reaching a statistically significant level, t(959) = 24.06, p < 0.001, Cohen’s d = 0.79.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o11","terms":["t-test statistic","df 959","Cohen's d"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Specifically, the standardized path coefficient from AI perception to receptive WTC was β = 0.220, 95% CI [0.156, 0.288]; to productive WTC, it was β = 0.224, 95% CI [0.163, 0.295].","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o12","terms":["standardized path coefficients","AI perception to receptive and productive WTC"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The two sets of confidence intervals highly overlapped, and the path coefficient difference was extremely small, Δβ = 0.004, not reaching statistical significance.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o13","terms":["path coefficient difference","non-significant difference"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"In summary, the validation results failed to support Hypothesis H2b (the differential path strength hypothesis).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o14","terms":["Hypothesis H2b not supported"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"While the data substantiated the theoretical premise of Hypothesis H2a (that productive WTC exhibits a lower baseline mean), the positive predictive strengths of AI perception on the two communicative dimensions did not differ significantly.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o15","terms":["Hypothesis H2a supported","predictive strengths did not differ significantly"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Consequently, the assertion that “AI assistance holds a stronger predictive power for receptive willingness” is not empirically supported, nor can we definitively claim statistical equivalence without an a priori equivalence bounds test (e.g., TOST).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o16","terms":["qualification on statistical equivalence","TOST"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"To test the mechanism between perception and willingness, a Structural Equation Model (SEM) was established and a Bootstrap sampling was used to test the mediation effect.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o17","terms":["Structural Equation Model","Bootstrap sampling","mediation effect"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"As shown in Table 4, after controlling for statistical variables, AI perception was significantly and positively correlated with self-efficacy (β = 0.346, p < 0.001).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o18","terms":["AI perception to self-efficacy path","Table 4"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Mediation effect bootstrap test report (5,000 samples).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t34_o19","terms":["5,000 bootstrap samples"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t34_o1","t34_o2","t34_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t34_c1","object":"AI perception positively correlates with receptive WTC (r=0.220) and productive WTC (r=0.224, p<0.01), supporting H1","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 reports significant positive correlations between AI intelligent perception (M=3.57, SD=0.70) and students' receptive WTC (r=0.220, p<0.01) and productive WTC (r=0.224, p<0.01), supporting Hypothesis H1."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t34_o4","t34_o5","t34_o6","t34_o7","t34_o8","t34_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t34_c2","object":"AI perception, Self-efficacy, FL anxiety, Receptive WTC, and Productive WTC with confirmed Fornell-Larcker discriminant validity","predicate":"measures_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 measures five constructs meeting Fornell-Larcker discriminant validity: AI perception (M=3.57, √AVE=0.729), Self-efficacy (M=3.38, √AVE=0.741), FL anxiety (M=3.02, √AVE=0.727), Receptive WTC (M=3.66), and Productive WTC (M=3.10)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t34_o10","t34_o11","t34_o15"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t34_c4","object":"baseline receptive WTC exceeds productive WTC (t(959)=24.06, p<0.001, d=0.79), supporting H2a in a sample of 960 learners","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"Supporting Hypothesis H2a, a paired-samples t-test in PMC13388837 shows baseline receptive WTC (M=3.66, SD=0.71) is significantly higher than productive WTC (M=3.10, SD=0.72), t(959)=24.06, p<0.001, Cohen's d=0.79 (N=960)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t34_o12","t34_o13","t34_o14","t34_o15","t34_o16"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t34_c5","object":"H2b unsupported as AI perception predicts receptive (β=0.220) and productive WTC (β=0.224) similarly (Δβ=0.004, n.s.), without TOST equivalence proof","predicate":"qualifies_conclusions","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 refutes Hypothesis H2b: AI perception's predictive path to receptive WTC (β=0.220, 95% CI [0.156, 0.288]) and productive WTC (β=0.224, 95% CI [0.163, 0.295]) does not significantly differ (Δβ=0.004), though equivalence lacks a TOST test."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t34_o17","t34_o18","t34_o19"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t34_c6","object":"in SEM with 5,000 bootstrap samples, AI perception positively predicts self-efficacy (β=0.346, p<0.001)","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"Using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) with 5,000-sample bootstrap mediation testing, PMC13388837 finds AI perception is significantly and positively associated with self-efficacy after controls (β=0.346, p<0.001)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",32309,38260]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"243a9abaeb28ff327c5b4cedbf7ed06069ba50d22ceecdfd0714e0662150d2ef","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["339fe33af70438e309eedebc9c5cbc64743464ff0ee9b34f06518065b9c753fb","0311d6c80244bf3d49da88fc47cd995e9180f3aa43bfe70d26234c7f0d0d06ac","585043913ed9477f129790eda502cab6413486d24757e9594072aa0b766d5c7a","5e18550faf62cfa27835c1aad08499c8bfff5fcf8e0715f7c5e715c983420b98","9859c7902ef863cf21dcde841aec319bc43264ba78bcdf4e7d79718baebb4ea3","73e908cdc8c6c8e0ebd88079e2b8ade254f9c32015ed2e5f8e30ed1caafed2e1","e1a6374efa87d59b56457189ea1c6a43f2968976fa61aaa34769272f464bef42","75b3178f13e182fdf7ebeeba7b605e132e77143fed68c4c312615c9e743eca45","59e68cb09b12b9da7095cb2e4feef3969c4ce70f39d40881727c27d796e1d634","c7abc03fd01e6b0848ca2b930079d25527381cc5d19b90c5a8cdb07d0d68006d","66ab11f4b7dfea37500c7b041c867e9247ee6251dd03fb4422e9d6a515f1e77d","7d9117ac71e1c59d32cdf6923d40ddfa0829ba543423c71aceddfe90163f99c2","c9a88bd3b345f517aa47446a0a9a8bae099f41f3b9a1f777e22cc719132c6b2b","84de4517841a6a47ffd2a9893c95cb37278d7fb35414aa3e0f481f8c9c34b0b2","385babc4b2fdf6c21483cdfd6f0be36919f4f0ff4f8e9291e6bb879ad0b8eb40","711eb248229436f84acb300cebbe64c4e1ae70cd3c3975c4a32f95f03e4d21cb","f5edefa21e5d974d230a902c043dfc9df7e40e726c8ed7c5d007d896c38e91b2","85efcd87946ed21dd9cf88f6d8ac9693af7c52096627972e582ceec2ee40869f","4541dd863525f79cf27ee69987f805ac4499c79314ca688c59beff44c3a1284b","de76ced14702cdd2b5b6a8668243ffe439718091abb4182964cf7b954879358f"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":20}},"request_hash":"7ef9baaec5a840a37c7bcbd1c709fc85280ecebb288accd99d8d0151f57d59a1","submission_id":"TR34-816fb953d129ef38#1"},"hash":"90e59ae5dc7b6d6c083ef107192bc5d3d71ea056b40b87f35e9a61a8adff4bef","header":{"body_hash":"5bee5794c89595b9716c6820eef79bb6dbf7f48c5db80c770d5eb17a0d2c7f1e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"7143a89d1c37c73f72f7954cf2e3124f87a61a018c9fb1c9fc4e32ec07de348e","records_root":"0df1e356dd30092d3b393584bab2d8dda69b1d8944e7fe81b65ff8501a476535","seq":160,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"930a3c65e375b8fb8a07d4372c754d14790eaf02af6741898e0ffaa9ad8eb43e","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR34-816fb953d129ef38","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t34_o10","t34_o11","t34_o15"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t34_c4","object":"baseline receptive WTC exceeds productive WTC (t(959)=24.06, p<0.001, d=0.79), supporting H2a in a sample of 960 learners","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"Supporting Hypothesis H2a, a paired-samples t-test in PMC13388837 shows baseline receptive WTC (M=3.66, SD=0.71) is significantly higher than productive WTC (M=3.10, SD=0.72), t(959)=24.06, p<0.001, Cohen's d=0.79 (N=960)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t34_o12","t34_o13","t34_o14","t34_o15","t34_o16"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t34_c5","object":"H2b unsupported as AI perception predicts receptive (β=0.220) and productive WTC (β=0.224) similarly (Δβ=0.004, n.s.), without TOST equivalence proof","predicate":"qualifies_conclusions","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 refutes Hypothesis H2b: AI perception's predictive path to receptive WTC (β=0.220, 95% CI [0.156, 0.288]) and productive WTC (β=0.224, 95% CI [0.163, 0.295]) does not significantly differ (Δβ=0.004), though equivalence lacks a TOST test."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t34_o17","t34_o18","t34_o19"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t34_c6","object":"in SEM with 5,000 bootstrap samples, AI perception positively predicts self-efficacy (β=0.346, p<0.001)","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"Using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) with 5,000-sample bootstrap mediation testing, PMC13388837 finds AI perception is significantly and positively associated with self-efficacy after controls (β=0.346, p<0.001)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",32309,38260]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"243a9abaeb28ff327c5b4cedbf7ed06069ba50d22ceecdfd0714e0662150d2ef","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["1b3d1de993deef130125a82603c2714b1f40a24c7549e08eff124c2b13f682b4"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":1}},"request_hash":"a65d32b83037c971dfb8ac7946c8479e5702ba0c76a45766fe6e2fe921510b3b","submission_id":"TR34-816fb953d129ef38#1.1"},"hash":"45f7955d6df80cbdf73d2a8adc384d4cc9ab15a0c159983241457c3bdb5aa53d","header":{"body_hash":"37f9f0bae050605b2634b2b53db4b1fc69f4b6bfd2dce034f585b0bb26583791","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"90e59ae5dc7b6d6c083ef107192bc5d3d71ea056b40b87f35e9a61a8adff4bef","records_root":"07b51399349b2702608c70b34d5137db75256179ca5a738f5a8f94ae09d0c052","seq":161,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"ca64f5aa6909dca238ae745f0c02d340aa60a05d9d94e016a7930f7c7489f175","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR34-816fb953d129ef38","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t34_o17","t34_o18","t34_o19"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t34_c6","object":"in SEM with 5,000 bootstrap samples, AI perception positively predicts self-efficacy (β=0.346, p<0.001)","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"Using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) with 5,000-sample bootstrap mediation testing, PMC13388837 finds AI perception is significantly and positively associated with self-efficacy after controls (β=0.346, p<0.001)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",32309,38260]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"243a9abaeb28ff327c5b4cedbf7ed06069ba50d22ceecdfd0714e0662150d2ef","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["b2230853fb02b422fd9298671d532d2e1cfb548c03ee597abd2ca53e60bee77e"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"c2cc55142b283ba7f5bea10cde59d270ab7fe2eb533d5d9a8b9777b7de28f82c","submission_id":"TR34-816fb953d129ef38#1.2"},"hash":"26899d9c1a6bb24e0ed2834ae59f63b8c5bf46b9ea59c4d143e8e645b04ba7ac","header":{"body_hash":"3d66d6e3b4c76f6b6d69cb605425c66a5951acdb329af937726d363defe75e55","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"45f7955d6df80cbdf73d2a8adc384d4cc9ab15a0c159983241457c3bdb5aa53d","records_root":"2998ab865fe2bc2e217edf0320fbdc80b605d787fa4ed419833eebe2bfc25781","seq":162,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"6d745d97bbad513d8eedea144f2669e26dd280acb4f1ce6360df510c7cbea888","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@339fe33af70438e3","@0311d6c80244bf3d","@585043913ed9477f","@5e18550faf62cfa2","@9859c7902ef863cf","@73e908cdc8c6c8e0","@e1a6374efa87d59b","@75b3178f13e182fd","@59e68cb09b12b9da","@c7abc03fd01e6b08","@66ab11f4b7dfea37","@7d9117ac71e1c59d","@c9a88bd3b345f517","@84de4517841a6a47","@385babc4b2fdf6c2","@711eb248229436f8","@f5edefa21e5d974d","@85efcd87946ed21d","@4541dd863525f79c","@de76ced14702cdd2","@1b3d1de993deef13","@b2230853fb02b422"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"REQUEST","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":20,"local_id":"t34_c2"},{"error":{"code":"NO_EVIDENCE","expected_by_kernel":{"missing_identifiers":["0.01"]},"field":"based_on","message":"a claim names only identifiers its quotes hold: add a quote of this section that holds each one listed, or leave it out of the claim","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":21,"local_id":"t34_c3"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":23,"local_id":"t34_c5"}],"task_id":"TR34-816fb953d129ef38","work_key":"reread:PMC13388837.txt#6"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:TR34-816fb953d129ef38:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"243a9abaeb28ff327c5b4cedbf7ed06069ba50d22ceecdfd0714e0662150d2ef","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"dacc17eb5d78506338635193fd1aabbc6e0811fa216724d1455910107b77193f","submission_id":"TR34-816fb953d129ef38#repair1"},"hash":"066b998a0929b69d33f272da4afb1fdf8c68f61b830a8397dd6dc1bdfc3fb711","header":{"body_hash":"4869796fba7630efb5af4c6c1b8cbfc21abe5302d586436cb13990e6b18c969c","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"26899d9c1a6bb24e0ed2834ae59f63b8c5bf46b9ea59c4d143e8e645b04ba7ac","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":163,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"593bcfd64cec92cccae44e98549351b2d61d5d2d9877ca8d6c8d1f7cd256c252","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR34-816fb953d129ef38","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t34_o4","t34_o5","t34_o6","t34_o7","t34_o8","t34_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t34_c2","object":"AI perception, Self-efficacy, FL anxiety, Receptive WTC, and Productive WTC with confirmed Fornell-Larcker discriminant validity","predicate":"measures_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 measures five constructs meeting Fornell-Larcker discriminant validity: AI perception (M=3.57, √AVE=0.729), Self-efficacy (M=3.38, √AVE=0.741), FL anxiety (M=3.02, √AVE=0.727), Receptive WTC (M=3.66), Productive WTC (M=3.10)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t34_o3","t34_o8","t34_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t34_c3","object":"L2 self-efficacy positively (r=0.414, 0.375) and FL anxiety negatively (r=-0.200, -0.285) correlate with receptive and productive WTC","predicate":"reports_correlations","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 finds that L2 self-efficacy positively correlates with receptive and productive WTC (r=0.414, r=0.375), whereas foreign language anxiety negatively correlates with both (r=-0.200, r=-0.285)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t34_o12","t34_o13","t34_o14","t34_o15","t34_o16"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t34_c5","object":"H2b unsupported as AI perception predicts receptive (β=0.220) and productive WTC (β=0.224) similarly (Δβ=0.004, n.s.), without TOST equivalence proof","predicate":"qualifies_conclusions","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 refutes Hypothesis H2b: AI perception paths to receptive WTC (β=0.220, 95% CI [0.156, 0.288]) and productive WTC (β=0.224, 95% CI [0.163, 0.295]) do not significantly differ (Δβ=0.004), though equivalence lacks a TOST test."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",32309,38260]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"243a9abaeb28ff327c5b4cedbf7ed06069ba50d22ceecdfd0714e0662150d2ef","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["6424dfc589de47605d122684141268a9ce52d41516bcc07f6d761040bffb2b2a","ae8044af7dc7e53278767047b69c0d72faedbb7fd3df79b7501b6e1d4317e94b","df65fc7d949a9efee7a2545896f9b52462a346fd77cb3d4fbfc8cbf575825bfe"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"12f06baf7b7514735809134c4bda190d389383fe249eb25da8cd5b82fcd23233","submission_id":"TR34-816fb953d129ef38#2"},"hash":"79e97784d0a4b82168027108fd3dad79c667464d063078b5e3f5fee96ca7a6bc","header":{"body_hash":"5e479b6e1f88b77109b6c7c0c3b7fe6424abac1e29ed6a503a2a7368d48a7ef6","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"066b998a0929b69d33f272da4afb1fdf8c68f61b830a8397dd6dc1bdfc3fb711","records_root":"fec00417956325e83bcdba215607267ba6b3d8ba3defe487c718d05a7a57b661","seq":164,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"1118977301893df165607c13c147e90350e9230698a86fe15d019465f7b1e25d","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":9,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":5,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:PMC13388837.txt#6"},"sync_step":17,"task_id":"TR34-816fb953d129ef38"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:PMC13388837.txt#6","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"243a9abaeb28ff327c5b4cedbf7ed06069ba50d22ceecdfd0714e0662150d2ef","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"8cdbbd56dbb2f616d4e6783b82213765ce30fde4d6ad5cfdaa01a03512973410","submission_id":"TR34-816fb953d129ef38#done3"},"hash":"d49efcb47f1a1957c70b76bd3e2817f81a10e984ef0a731fc841286f709dd297","header":{"body_hash":"725e9eaa0bbfbe9fed8f7a32ec492875f09b7035ed454be13600049effec239a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"79e97784d0a4b82168027108fd3dad79c667464d063078b5e3f5fee96ca7a6bc","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":165,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"6f9e4d3ce0c52381c19659db38252d4f0a1e8dfbe8053c3d264927119429d941","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":9,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":452},"started_unix_ms":1795102422386,"wave":{"doc:PMC13388837.txt#4":"reader-3","doc:PMC13388837.txt#5":"reader-1","doc:PMC13388837.txt#6":"reader-2"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"243a9abaeb28ff327c5b4cedbf7ed06069ba50d22ceecdfd0714e0662150d2ef","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"ccb2b6b520872a17ffa05b4646cefe3085d0a541fd6b26b8f65b0739c96a7a1a","submission_id":"circle:775c1c11151b66ea86ca4407439388864166dcfc1b8dd2d74666ddcaf86ffb4e"},"hash":"8c70f70b617f7ec7d1f0e5130d6e4ead65789ff32f41260717deb68c098bb629","header":{"body_hash":"5d5339d9c1a5dae9e5f44a238c897d008742034dddc73181d0a4527fc4606408","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"d49efcb47f1a1957c70b76bd3e2817f81a10e984ef0a731fc841286f709dd297","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":166,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"4048680aa07b6a615cb302194e74ebb012c816bb9474f989a0a71f9976ff15bf","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"6f9e4d3ce0c52381c19659db38252d4f0a1e8dfbe8053c3d264927119429d941","engine_root":"243a9abaeb28ff327c5b4cedbf7ed06069ba50d22ceecdfd0714e0662150d2ef","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"52417ba0871eeec143bb45870d090d8294631f44bb4c50b4102e31ee9023d975","log_size":167,"projections":{"dependencies":"89fa0dbdf094f1a8c776e57cb060cf262e283d8c54e926c40a9fb84e4769943a","status":"bf088cf31bbfa26bafde5a83e7046cbe1f65298c0113d9cf930557e33bdd51ed"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"8c70f70b617f7ec7d1f0e5130d6e4ead65789ff32f41260717deb68c098bb629"}},"engine_root":"243a9abaeb28ff327c5b4cedbf7ed06069ba50d22ceecdfd0714e0662150d2ef","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"6f9e4d3ce0c52381c19659db38252d4f0a1e8dfbe8053c3d264927119429d941","engine_root":"243a9abaeb28ff327c5b4cedbf7ed06069ba50d22ceecdfd0714e0662150d2ef","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"52417ba0871eeec143bb45870d090d8294631f44bb4c50b4102e31ee9023d975","log_size":167,"projections":{"dependencies":"89fa0dbdf094f1a8c776e57cb060cf262e283d8c54e926c40a9fb84e4769943a","status":"bf088cf31bbfa26bafde5a83e7046cbe1f65298c0113d9cf930557e33bdd51ed"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"8c70f70b617f7ec7d1f0e5130d6e4ead65789ff32f41260717deb68c098bb629"},"seal_hash":"9a41ff8aea7537d83f2142f6a29871b902533e2df9a54ba19cb9696cab2d32ea"}},"request_hash":"5fdd69784ab6b999b3bd2542fa5f32b809de4c8529b162add90fed27adf84f1c","submission_id":"seal-167"},"hash":"4ec4b8f8d2cb15e826c98e16c9dd57996082842a5e663ea77da8addbdd5367ad","header":{"body_hash":"bd07f42889ecb7040ecf1997250c63836fb9417e62ff2af46bf7bd0c8b247940","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"8c70f70b617f7ec7d1f0e5130d6e4ead65789ff32f41260717deb68c098bb629","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":167,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"a2a2c7326b15c47b0a7cb3a9d9a8a42671345f8999c336e4cac990332a6a641a","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"epoch":18,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102422386},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"243a9abaeb28ff327c5b4cedbf7ed06069ba50d22ceecdfd0714e0662150d2ef","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"ff38e7e7d4e00c824b0571bb226a881b014c1cb9fc31e97bc2f5f329cece9eea","submission_id":"ring-members:95719c22151c29c1b7fcbe04bb0b6e973dbc9a6989bbdbe83a2e0ac6bd2f8260"},"hash":"2e216d0da8cb104642361bcd399a053db6e0dc4d019d88cb6a1d26a7abe5bdde","header":{"body_hash":"0c035155e3ff15f24196eb5ffb59ca957cbeca1a674a6ebbf6351c65e9f3a424","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"4ec4b8f8d2cb15e826c98e16c9dd57996082842a5e663ea77da8addbdd5367ad","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":168,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"6be217b788f2c36294bceaa939c087ea647834814ae1282ad95a8e2525455a2c","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":10,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":452},"started_unix_ms":1795102422424,"wave":{"doc:PMC13388837.txt#7":"reader-1","doc:PMC13388837.txt#8":"reader-2","doc:PMC13388837.txt#9":"reader-3"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"243a9abaeb28ff327c5b4cedbf7ed06069ba50d22ceecdfd0714e0662150d2ef","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"7e1bb25825830d5b60ad6f852c5cc3250bb4328501816d41d084c23e41fc77f6","submission_id":"circle:4d58288e85d112f6553500a73bb7e9c736c1b34315e253787d1efa883e3ee646"},"hash":"6234dab1f8fe3a8808e1a6105e50fd4c1c1f2e1522492089b4f36636e0f9bcf5","header":{"body_hash":"b9b2aafcdf812acb5487a419ed0228462c34b11c62151fd208c21cb8078b2ded","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"2e216d0da8cb104642361bcd399a053db6e0dc4d019d88cb6a1d26a7abe5bdde","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":169,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"539cbad8a638921b7bdcf3ce65d4c3b9e5241196043d01ebdd9d63a461fc72cc","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"6be217b788f2c36294bceaa939c087ea647834814ae1282ad95a8e2525455a2c","engine_root":"243a9abaeb28ff327c5b4cedbf7ed06069ba50d22ceecdfd0714e0662150d2ef","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"75f6a0b82b544b446f3f0dcce138f871b32e1e126030ae8b58677ccb84a115f4","log_size":170,"projections":{"dependencies":"89fa0dbdf094f1a8c776e57cb060cf262e283d8c54e926c40a9fb84e4769943a","status":"bf088cf31bbfa26bafde5a83e7046cbe1f65298c0113d9cf930557e33bdd51ed"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"6234dab1f8fe3a8808e1a6105e50fd4c1c1f2e1522492089b4f36636e0f9bcf5"}},"engine_root":"243a9abaeb28ff327c5b4cedbf7ed06069ba50d22ceecdfd0714e0662150d2ef","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"6be217b788f2c36294bceaa939c087ea647834814ae1282ad95a8e2525455a2c","engine_root":"243a9abaeb28ff327c5b4cedbf7ed06069ba50d22ceecdfd0714e0662150d2ef","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"75f6a0b82b544b446f3f0dcce138f871b32e1e126030ae8b58677ccb84a115f4","log_size":170,"projections":{"dependencies":"89fa0dbdf094f1a8c776e57cb060cf262e283d8c54e926c40a9fb84e4769943a","status":"bf088cf31bbfa26bafde5a83e7046cbe1f65298c0113d9cf930557e33bdd51ed"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"6234dab1f8fe3a8808e1a6105e50fd4c1c1f2e1522492089b4f36636e0f9bcf5"},"seal_hash":"93c025966a42e8e4e6d6374f97e2493c0a21bf5bed41f1dd4ac99c9724e654a7"}},"request_hash":"e95a2166fb8bb7e5b77bef27ba11ce0c2315247a87dd5611f19c1dfb27abe62d","submission_id":"seal-170"},"hash":"6535fb01402d4aa357970c97be057b4674daf34fd10b3bcda1eeea4e81c1d11b","header":{"body_hash":"b290ca7dca7626f15495156ea44309a630fb61cfa78e06735712de54c216d1b2","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"6234dab1f8fe3a8808e1a6105e50fd4c1c1f2e1522492089b4f36636e0f9bcf5","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":170,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"7afa4ec89ac4231898ae4acf44f0b49f0b71a03d5e2f30add2c826e1941f8e23","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"epoch":19,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102422424},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"243a9abaeb28ff327c5b4cedbf7ed06069ba50d22ceecdfd0714e0662150d2ef","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"03bfd73d04eb994492ad6c1e16b1b390e66c7e65ec5de8207523b2da94695d13","submission_id":"ring-members:04553ae2abe30b7ad7f31d4835a1c11ff4e7607b162b2c31c44608fcfcef4772"},"hash":"c6da4c24a88fd17637f8991fcadd94319bdd62275f056a8ead9cfcfe168184c2","header":{"body_hash":"baee9ecb5820a53ae14446fa9714eaca54a6c80934088c142f5d68affeadccd0","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"6535fb01402d4aa357970c97be057b4674daf34fd10b3bcda1eeea4e81c1d11b","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":171,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"761ce7723cbc3d1f8d96d7c115e19313e6a80441f9872415a2e682f5a8227a1c","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T35-8d835b76f8819132","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Descriptive data corroborated Hypothesis H2a, confirming that learners exhibit a significantly lower baseline WTC for productive tasks compared to receptive tasks","kind":"observe","local_id":"t35_o1","terms":["Hypothesis H2a","baseline WTC","productive tasks","receptive tasks"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"However, the path analysis results did not support Hypothesis H2b, as there was no statistically significant difference in the predictive strength of AI perception on receptive willingness (β = 0.220) versus productive willingness (β = 0.224).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t35_o2","terms":["Hypothesis H2b","path analysis","AI perception","receptive willingness","productive willingness"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The quantitative analysis indicated that self-efficacy accounts for 56.19% of the indirect association between AI perception and willingness to communicate.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t35_o3","terms":["L2 self-efficacy","mediation","AI perception","willingness to communicate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Looking at the main associations, the latent SEM results show that FLA was significantly and negatively associated with multimodal WTC.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t35_o4","terms":["Foreign Language Anxiety","latent SEM","multimodal WTC","negative association"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The interaction term between SE and FLA was positive and marginally significant, suggesting a potential buffering tendency.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t35_o5","terms":["self-efficacy","Foreign Language Anxiety","interaction term","moderation","buffering"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Specifically, although high-anxiety learners generally showed lower levels of WTC, the positive association between self-efficacy and WTC appeared to be relatively stronger under higher anxiety conditions.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t35_o6","terms":["high-anxiety learners","self-efficacy","WTC","compensatory association"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t35_o1"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t35_c1","object":"lower baseline WTC for productive tasks than receptive tasks (H2a confirmed)","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 confirms Hypothesis H2a that learners show significantly lower baseline willingness to communicate (WTC) for productive tasks than for receptive tasks."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t35_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t35_c2","object":"no significant difference in AI perception predicting receptive WTC (β=0.220) vs productive WTC (β=0.224); H2b unsupported","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes from path analysis that Hypothesis H2b is not supported: AI perception shows no significant difference in predicting receptive WTC (β = 0.220) versus productive WTC (β = 0.224)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t35_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t35_c3","object":"self-efficacy accounts for 56.19% of indirect association between AI perception and WTC","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes that L2 self-efficacy mediates the relationship between AI perception and willingness to communicate, accounting for 56.19% of the indirect association."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t35_o4","t35_o5","t35_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t35_c4","object":"negative main association of FLA with multimodal WTC; positive marginally significant SE × FLA interaction buffering anxiety","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes from latent SEM results that Foreign Language Anxiety (FLA) is significantly and negatively associated with multimodal WTC, while the SE × FLA interaction is positive and marginally significant."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",49877,55079]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"1c68eeda893d0e88b534e8218092a8026760e02f717033b5af3718e428f6739a","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["693009159cad41bac3760e1eedfaf1c4602bf5a757755349d2356bd642394af9","128403d81ff50d66b5201c4f72584bcca315b7ae26421ab6c22884bb8329f62c","174fc835deb43ec6e0696d7a58432fdabeaacfb9a0e1bb16e0476029ff363786","570022cd8d70fd07cb4142266a12ddeece0cb6e6925b269c8a6fb734c08e0f1f","83711bfc30582e8835611ca2eaf337c54703d2ad93a5a2fb040b4d446fcf73ad","6466b546ed390dfa8e87ec9ec8147338a2f0e215043a8b1e5df009d62875098e","fbf4b40d44780f21e18051c898462ed58f46b6f7ddc36f5b26760e75e0e9077b","26bd38da5cebeb53c44544f6e2b896cf369d0af14affebaf26c01b27cfae31a4","02cc0aa7838411b00f87605a9f70b0c847e36d580b018d8d71eb0476a36c0c51","9cd1095a6f2708e2fdbaf8d087e696421d244310346f3651b963bf6adc618e44"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"c9453aac87aff71fd1d2100540cb8c91be6fa6bd24b85e2648498b9b8041bf75","submission_id":"T35-8d835b76f8819132#1"},"hash":"1b4bc30870775e13301d1898fe988b1cc847bc47a7c271bde4ecac192e541215","header":{"body_hash":"25f433c78936b68856195fe5bdbe04f95b38dda85ce77a4d5bc5407c5bfdb8d5","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"c6da4c24a88fd17637f8991fcadd94319bdd62275f056a8ead9cfcfe168184c2","records_root":"3dcb00b1b3d8b93eaba4d942ccef1a00befd525c4abf330916bab7a1f45eca95","seq":172,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"2377c777ce3f5b0fb9735c87976c8f3db9c0c7794a86831667f31cb319989035","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":10,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":19,"task_id":"T35-8d835b76f8819132"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13388837.txt#9","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"1c68eeda893d0e88b534e8218092a8026760e02f717033b5af3718e428f6739a","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"940b0665436836040e09b67ccc539481159a40b10dcd27f254ea37e7f67c6853","submission_id":"T35-8d835b76f8819132#done2"},"hash":"24c70cd23e5acfc0db178c3fc83c312f154a0647e17d700774550ab012e6ee22","header":{"body_hash":"93336d44d749ce83bfbf0a5212bba9efec2405ead349a814ef1b5dd429aae233","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"1b4bc30870775e13301d1898fe988b1cc847bc47a7c271bde4ecac192e541215","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":173,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"40fcb028cd5a601f0c119e46e24cc2b56c45624db4f5dfeb48021ea184679541","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T36-2ed8f49cacd04354","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Total effect (AI → WTC) | 0.226 | 0.031 | 0.198 | 0.320 | ***","kind":"observe","local_id":"t36_o1","terms":["total effect of AI perception on multimodal L2 WTC"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Direct effect (AI → WTC) | 0.099 | 0.028 | 0.077 | 0.187 | ***","kind":"observe","local_id":"t36_o2","terms":["direct effect of AI perception on multimodal L2 WTC"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Indirect effect (AI → SE → WTC) | 0.127 | 0.015 | 0.099 | 0.157 | ***","kind":"observe","local_id":"t36_o3","terms":["indirect effect of AI perception on multimodal L2 WTC via self-efficacy"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Bootstrap sampling was run 5,000 times; CI not containing 0 indicates a significant effect, ***p < 0.001. The overall model predictive power R2 = 0.231.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t36_o4","terms":["bootstrap sampling and R2 for mediation model"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"This result supports Hypothesis H3: Self-efficacy plays a significant mediating role between AI perception and multimodal L2 WTC, with the indirect effect accounting for 56.19% of the total effect.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t36_o5","terms":["H3 support and self-efficacy mediation share"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"SE → Multimodal WTC | 0.496 | 0.051 | 9.760 | <0.001","kind":"observe","local_id":"t36_o6","terms":["main effect of self-efficacy on multimodal WTC in SEM"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"FLA → Multimodal WTC | −0.191 | 0.042 | −4.493 | <0.001","kind":"observe","local_id":"t36_o7","terms":["main effect of foreign language anxiety on multimodal WTC in SEM"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Interaction (SE × FLA) → Multimodal WTC | 0.129 | 0.071 | 1.823 | 0.068","kind":"observe","local_id":"t36_o8","terms":["latent interaction effect of self-efficacy and foreign language anxiety on multimodal WTC"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"N = 960. The estimators are unstandardized due to the mathematical scaling variations in the product-indicator approach.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t36_o9","terms":["sample size N=960 and unstandardized estimators in Table 5"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Importantly, the latent interaction term (SE × FLA) exhibited a positive coefficient on WTC (B = 0.129, p = 0.068, 95% CI [−0.010, 0.268]).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t36_o10","terms":["latent interaction coefficient and confidence interval"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Consequently, because this moderation effect does not reach conventional significance levels (p < 0.05), it should be interpreted with caution.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t36_o11","terms":["caution in interpreting marginal moderation effect"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"We present this pattern primarily as an exploratory finding that points to a potential emotional buffering tendency within technology-mediated contexts, a dynamic that warrants further empirical replication.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t36_o12","terms":["exploratory status of emotional buffering finding"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"In conclusion, Hypothesis H4 is partially supported. The results reveal that rather than simply exerting a rigidly negative moderation, foreign language learning anxiety acts as an emotional stressor whose negative impact can be marginally yet effectively buffered by strong self-efficacy.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t36_o13","terms":["partial support for H4 and self-efficacy buffering anxiety"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t36_o1","t36_o2","t36_o3","t36_o4","t36_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t36_c1","object":"self-efficacy mediates 56.19% of AI perception -> multimodal L2 WTC (total 0.226, direct 0.099, indirect 0.127, R2=0.231)","predicate":"concludes_mediation_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes ( supporting H3, R2=0.231, 5,000 bootstraps) that self-efficacy mediates 56.19% of AI perception's effect on multimodal L2 WTC (total=0.226, direct=0.099, indirect=0.127, all p<0.001)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t36_o6","t36_o7","t36_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t36_c2","object":"SE (B=0.496, p<0.001) and FLA (B=-0.191, p<0.001) significantly predict multimodal L2 WTC (N=960)","predicate":"concludes_main_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"Using product-indicator SEM on N=960 survey respondents, PMC13388837 finds significant main effects on multimodal L2 WTC for self-efficacy (B=0.496, p<0.001) and foreign language anxiety (B=-0.191, p<0.001)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t36_o8","t36_o10","t36_o11","t36_o12","t36_o13"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t36_c3","object":"SE × FLA interaction on multimodal WTC is marginal (B=0.129, p=0.068); H4 partially supported and exploratory","predicate":"qualifies_moderation_conclusion","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes that H4 is partially supported: the SE × FLA latent interaction on multimodal L2 WTC is positive but only marginally significant (B=0.129, p=0.068, 95% CI [-0.010, 0.268]), presenting emotional buffering as exploratory."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",38260,44238]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"0c5fcacfdd99e0896b16cebdb4edca5e56fd149f66a8e3541838d8196cebbad2","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["812a262b787b514482461b041d26e57a7137ff84cfa0c489890a3c230199a393","e4f74a08ba56f55a3ab34a11db18321e00af53eb60ea96903197f365e47832b1","e6967d5801568e1b6505693e66b2c5544358228e2d1759145679bcfbb0ac3c98","4d68edb500aa3989651a324456c834b4a96e60903cd6810bed83267e5a1e6d0a","2934634a8e9cbea68f5c89616376949d8d5919aee19c70e5cafe2d31b820df8e","8ff600a0bfed41ea9650c4f7e8e7aa79002e17f4bd3c2b399944992483473cef","427997c7e46de3592b81dd6c83d6ca5da55e8b297b34c193bd80d5a1f2413c1f","0978da82e20ecc16b280eb9df16002aed635e7ace403dac4a8f498fe54355287","53b13ec0e748ad076b5346c247b49d0bd0b28e32a538a81ddfe226f59709381e","9503229f4e567bafe0dea77ce7fd7f82910d80b05342077a2cd560e0bb82b706","154726c1b7b33d84dcd3d489789ee2d53a4900992d61d2acc066320d38177c82","12b5c82fea2f35a84cb2a8e363065b666267cf71c4965bb0c414da82d18968f4","8018c389d6f4067b6202642e8447bc1b9bae946e6ffca01ace7a7c23575a0fa3","61264f67996be41406b7964c950a01f828e49938e1c3552f0a1e8ec240089a7e","3af8c11e250fc5e8cd0cb7d0217508ddc17bbbb4f2715cdc7459e05743832f4b"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":15}},"request_hash":"cc893d4514ea1e10b0484eb834b888e873a2f10c9802ce7dfd63e508a53fa2c2","submission_id":"T36-2ed8f49cacd04354#1"},"hash":"9e1fe20b4fa038bef1d4bf9bfb83992af93dc4e540d5ab1b781e51875bbd92df","header":{"body_hash":"e88785434bcd32fcc2db614344370a991a4c0e653309a444982d070ece2b83e6","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"24c70cd23e5acfc0db178c3fc83c312f154a0647e17d700774550ab012e6ee22","records_root":"aa328811f18e95dbd065eae642aa692c9e1db3d0bbfc02a1c36f29df83930017","seq":174,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"a14d05f04c92fd6c7697fda0723d23ae652e612ca88820059355d8c9bdf24224","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@812a262b787b5144","@e4f74a08ba56f55a","@e6967d5801568e1b","@4d68edb500aa3989","@2934634a8e9cbea6","@8ff600a0bfed41ea","@427997c7e46de359","@0978da82e20ecc16","@53b13ec0e748ad07","@9503229f4e567baf","@154726c1b7b33d84","@12b5c82fea2f35a8","@8018c389d6f4067b","@61264f67996be414","@3af8c11e250fc5e8"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":15,"local_id":"t36_c3"}],"task_id":"T36-2ed8f49cacd04354","work_key":"doc:PMC13388837.txt#7"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T36-2ed8f49cacd04354:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"0c5fcacfdd99e0896b16cebdb4edca5e56fd149f66a8e3541838d8196cebbad2","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"48fe3c84bfbdab7109cfa2a3069c14ce1ec42148a71d6645c79c5e61ad34e1f7","submission_id":"T36-2ed8f49cacd04354#repair1"},"hash":"33da5613f1876876bd2d8bc9df3f0226719ca7c0c6a2479753f54563c69b95cb","header":{"body_hash":"0534e583236161c135d2ef8fe78837f13b76188c061af5f47d15fe64acfb068b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"9e1fe20b4fa038bef1d4bf9bfb83992af93dc4e540d5ab1b781e51875bbd92df","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":175,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"2f02755d49397736d715b60213b4e0e30937f650509e4b2263e27c135611072b","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T37-b28d0e658ab64376","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Furthermore, to examine the potential group heterogeneity across English proficiency levels (H5), this study conducted a structured multi-group SEM analysis.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t37_o1","terms":["multi-group SEM analysis","English proficiency levels","H5"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The configural model, which allowed factor loadings to be freely estimated across groups, yielded an excellent fit (χ2/df <2.50, CFI = 0.998, RMSEA = 0.021).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t37_o2","terms":["configural invariance","model fit"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The subsequent metric invariance model, where factor loadings were constrained to be equal across the four English level groups, also demonstrated high stability (ΔCFI < 0.001).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t37_o3","terms":["metric invariance","four English level groups"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"As presented in Table 7, the positive path association from AI perception to self-efficacy remained statistically significant across all proficiency groups, with Critical Ratios (z-values) well exceeding the threshold of 1.96 (p < 0.01).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t37_o4","terms":["AI perception to self-efficacy","statistically significant across proficiency groups"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"English level group | Sample size (N) | Path estimate (B) | S.E. | C.R. (z-value) | p value\n\nGroup 1: beginner (below CET-4) | 144 | 0.312 | 0.090 | 3.467 | 0.001\n\nGroup 2: CET-4 level | 413 | 0.479 | 0.078 | 6.141 | <0.001","kind":"observe","local_id":"t37_o5","terms":["English level groups 1 and 2","sample size","path estimate B"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Group 3: CET-6 level | 303 | 0.326 | 0.066 | 4.939 | <0.001\n\nGroup 4: high cert. level | 100 | 0.326 | 0.106 | 3.075 | 0.002","kind":"observe","local_id":"t37_o6","terms":["English level groups 3 and 4","sample size","path estimate B"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Because specific structural path constraint tests (i.e., chi-square difference tests for constrained vs. unconstrained models) were not performed, we refrain from claiming magnitude differences across proficiency levels.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t37_o7","terms":["no structural path constraint tests","refrain from claiming magnitude differences"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"In this sense, H5 received preliminary empirical support regarding the model’s generalizability rather than comparative differentiation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t37_o8","terms":["H5 preliminary empirical support","model generalizability"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"To provide textual triangulation for the quantitative data, this study employed a thematic analysis method to encode and summarize the open-ended data as shown in Table 8.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t37_o9","terms":["thematic analysis","open-ended data","textual triangulation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Among these, “Emotional safety (low pressure),” mentioned 165 times, offered a possible qualitative interpretation for the exploratory buffering tendency observed in the quantitative model","kind":"observe","local_id":"t37_o10","terms":["Emotional safety","165 mentions","exploratory buffering"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Theme | Frequency | Representative quote\n\nFunctional support and efficiency | 241 | “AI helped tremendously in academic English reading, summarizing literature structures for me, greatly easing reading pressure.”","kind":"observe","local_id":"t37_o12","terms":["Functional support and efficiency","frequency 241"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The current data indicate that intelligent environment perception shares a significant positive association with multimodal L2 WTC (Deng et al., 2024).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t37_o13","terms":["intelligent environment perception","multimodal L2 WTC","positive association"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t37_o4","t37_o5","t37_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t37_c2","object":"significant positive AI perception -> self-efficacy path across all four English proficiency levels (B=0.312 to 0.479, p<0.01)","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 finds a positive path from AI perception to self-efficacy across all four English proficiency groups: beginner (B=0.312, p=0.001), CET-4 (B=0.479, p<0.001), CET-6 (B=0.326, p<0.001), and high cert. (B=0.326, p=0.002)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t37_o7","t37_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t37_c3","object":"H5 supported only for cross-group generalizability, not comparative magnitude differences across proficiency levels","predicate":"qualifies_conclusions","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 refrains from claiming magnitude differences in the AI perception to self-efficacy path across proficiency levels because structural path constraint tests were not performed, supporting H5 only for generalizability."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t37_o13"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t37_c5","object":"significant positive association between intelligent environment perception and multimodal L2 WTC","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes that intelligent environment perception has a significant positive association with multimodal L2 willingness to communicate (WTC)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",44238,49877]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"938a3bc6f2c3232d9841f619eb7dc93560e4b03e7d5fc93542f39729b365f01e","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["f7696b2914757fb5eaf6836daf5d060f97e178c60369b9bdceb5651fec59effa","c51c8f10feb97095a3869049d2c4d7e34ee0837c4d3dc9b83bc5b3b8c81bcaf3","911ab998e0f437aa615f2f41f8bfbc9019289b2881178aeddbfb64ccb180cf70","bd573e42f607a1285118229b05075d5c4a6134afe6d75292718363720ccbeb4e","2f9f9f5cd0a1c15784894dc9c810a9e9ebb7eae2129cf9852e6e578f886bac7c","d3362fc51de773b4423aa20b9e918bd00741f396e5651f73dbcdaf0f7451383b","cb0ba4f0f319ac5d95e2c52a4bc18e0cece0a2757d3d22663b13b0b2e75f1b24","b37cf52aec7a1426170460deb6f9f5632b190280f15b4b3cc1e3385de7551634","582ecd96dea8ebc3f54c7c0a15088872943ceb725f5bcf84f0f2cba25295ab46","ccfe995861124c10f672de5e1588718fadad14e7fbf44af385de68bdf558a6b5","dd2d1584325b3e73f0a83effdd61c94ca6f782b987e5dbd212200b872f468fda","22af7bca35f4805c2ae564f920e3698b8b9bff279c2d3ac99eaa608793759a80","a8e7c8c9a031a2f20ef8de19689c6e79583227e9233bf36288d647a29c43ad6a","4a4558b1060bcd8e16023826d758abde947a21b8509e2e51a8ec935dd722efe5","27c0935afdc41793ac3e8fd7aa9939191ea0e6d5d35b3b292877a483ba99e68b"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"6dde442739f2afb9a230a2d4837a8d5374615550db3928218a2cf8efc95ee931","submission_id":"T37-b28d0e658ab64376#1"},"hash":"a3714a82eca85f092337aa1fd8ec7f8f932f8be48efd65de352bab550a8d2601","header":{"body_hash":"7dff19d3326bcf0ac3263fbdd93849e07e3199e1b4a923e59b6be21ef93b5557","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"33da5613f1876876bd2d8bc9df3f0226719ca7c0c6a2479753f54563c69b95cb","records_root":"7dbadb16e1947eac3e29dde9f5ca831a1e858dcd991f435a4fe2c3e5b135eaba","seq":176,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"862502d02642c1ca5726e51583486c1d1a2e1c5d9d3c4d8add40ba1f5473144d","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@f7696b2914757fb5","@c51c8f10feb97095","@911ab998e0f437aa","@bd573e42f607a128","@2f9f9f5cd0a1c157","@d3362fc51de773b4","@cb0ba4f0f319ac5d","@b37cf52aec7a1426","@582ecd96dea8ebc3","@ccfe995861124c10","@dd2d1584325b3e73","@22af7bca35f4805c","@a8e7c8c9a031a2f2","@4a4558b1060bcd8e","@27c0935afdc41793"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[{"index":16,"local_id":"t37_c4","rests_on":"t37_o11"}],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"negation_before":"“Because there’s no need to worry about real human social judgments, dialoguing with AI vastly lowers the cost of trial and error.”","rule":"negation_before"},"field":"exact_quote","message":"a quote keeps the clause it belongs to: quote from the start of the sentence when it negates what follows, and to the end of the clause when the quote ends on a word like 'from' or 'with'","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":10,"local_id":"t37_o11"},{"error":{"code":"NO_EVIDENCE","expected_by_kernel":{"missing_identifiers":["1.77"]},"field":"based_on","message":"a claim names only identifiers its quotes hold: add a quote of this section that holds each one listed, or leave it out of the claim","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":13,"local_id":"t37_c1"}],"task_id":"T37-b28d0e658ab64376","work_key":"doc:PMC13388837.txt#8"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T37-b28d0e658ab64376:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"938a3bc6f2c3232d9841f619eb7dc93560e4b03e7d5fc93542f39729b365f01e","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"782a61566653c7995c7f191afe3cdd85a013a2d22f0dcebdc82717d4d7859546","submission_id":"T37-b28d0e658ab64376#repair1"},"hash":"1b99f3efbf85812ef0d1ab6cf7104c586473b768ea82ec488bcf240fbc0032b5","header":{"body_hash":"f4b6832254ad8bd843337f62495d4f6cd17fc4dd077c84bbf1358276b61b393a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"a3714a82eca85f092337aa1fd8ec7f8f932f8be48efd65de352bab550a8d2601","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":177,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"3a236eb4feb76dfaea043c3ffc390f1d4ed94dbd08d6b8cab5a4a6b448f78ac2","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T36-2ed8f49cacd04354","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t36_o8","t36_o10","t36_o11","t36_o12","t36_o13"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t36_c3","object":"SE × FLA interaction on multimodal WTC is marginal (B=0.129, p=0.068); H4 partially supported and exploratory","predicate":"qualifies_moderation_conclusion","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 finds H4 is partially supported: the SE × FLA latent interaction on multimodal L2 WTC is positive but marginally significant (B=0.129, p=0.068, 95% CI [-0.010, 0.268]), presenting emotional buffering as exploratory."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",38260,44238]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"938a3bc6f2c3232d9841f619eb7dc93560e4b03e7d5fc93542f39729b365f01e","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["d88620dded2eb05d8ac9e4f26fba68da1a1260b5b6594846f133171f69f5a087"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"3d79ad15df2ea33adc6445f26b053a8e3e62c60ccf62b80039f9f852c2f3d33a","submission_id":"T36-2ed8f49cacd04354#2"},"hash":"197ab26de7c3eba3bef35aad57b345bc9b135062ac673301da1ed9108acda0a7","header":{"body_hash":"fcb3483d84c19212599085d492ef86217cd062212feee6687dee91b471b46590","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"1b99f3efbf85812ef0d1ab6cf7104c586473b768ea82ec488bcf240fbc0032b5","records_root":"fa7c60beedc89c13d629923423066c5a9b4e16c0ebeb76e763d313b4fc9aed6e","seq":178,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"517578ea134a682d7b4f50f41c67e5355e6ec470d14fe4433964094c4f329667","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":false,"agent":"reader-1","circle":10,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":16,"refusals":1,"stored":16,"sync_step":19,"task_id":"T36-2ed8f49cacd04354"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13388837.txt#7","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"938a3bc6f2c3232d9841f619eb7dc93560e4b03e7d5fc93542f39729b365f01e","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"06ece9e997c7b79577ebda8c8ca21ef5a036d3fd4a7dd273e6c582e9d409960d","submission_id":"T36-2ed8f49cacd04354#done3"},"hash":"a86bab62f8a1c6c3a5c814b6ea21e13a4b6644bee176163d372b47e16d227de5","header":{"body_hash":"43363f69cdb8e9a4b2832657a6da96f30465693f725ea267a49999020b109ee9","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"197ab26de7c3eba3bef35aad57b345bc9b135062ac673301da1ed9108acda0a7","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":179,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"35bd2490740d6a19ef27800dd2e052f1895c2623c96f60d799d8f106993089ea","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T37-b28d0e658ab64376","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Cognitive/dependency risks | 180 | “It sure is fast to one-click translate complex sentences, but I feel myself increasingly dependent on it. I’m actually more confused when it comes to independent thinking.”\n\nLack of real interaction | 81 | “Lacks the contextual pressure of real scenarios.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t37_o11","terms":["Cognitive/dependency risks","180","Lack of real interaction","81"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t37_o1","t37_o2","t37_o3","t37_o5","t37_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t37_c1","object":"configural and metric invariance across four English proficiency groups (N=144, 413, 303, 100)","predicate":"establishes_measurement_invariance","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 establishes configural (χ2/df<2.50, CFI=0.998, RMSEA=0.021) and metric invariance (ΔCFI<0.001) across four English proficiency groups (N=144, 413, 303, 100) via multi-group SEM."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t37_o9","t37_o10","t37_o11","t37_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t37_c4","object":"open-ended feedback themes: functional support (241), cognitive/dependency risks (180), emotional safety (165), lack of real interaction (81)","predicate":"reports_qualitative_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"From thematic analysis of open-ended feedback, PMC13388837 reports frequencies for functional support and efficiency (241), cognitive/dependency risks (180), emotional safety/low pressure (165), and lack of real interaction (81)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",44238,49877]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"3bd26a97ea53e0c36ae78b7620fb991ce5777b4c2588d7dfa97394889da65f97","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["6cde6fee0a21bc7fb7745e3054109a9d222197f36ca7a1ca9b7f2f59666034bb","bb5e802b419da4998ed8f2220b4db6b9fb33af40d9cedacdb13096645f77d3a3","c643e30c07143a393da32ea7f0c5bff667107a212a31c3f36f49c0dba3eba616"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"51455d9437b08a4e49d520233dafbb2712cd324f73f3fea30b2271cf6413f29f","submission_id":"T37-b28d0e658ab64376#2"},"hash":"06b598e4aaa9291101eb0cd0263235dd75a8d700dff3b534e2a59345847565b8","header":{"body_hash":"6e558e4b65719f4078bb6fc62a24af9c4cc39b1a54a23363b80fbf458892c491","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"a86bab62f8a1c6c3a5c814b6ea21e13a4b6644bee176163d372b47e16d227de5","records_root":"f738fd0f333007525ce00112e0f10effd7ecd558bab721ea5c4f8eb43e6da337","seq":180,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"dd983f8d136de85d472204d51bc191e70ee3759a1c814fa07e3d600ae40d2cd4","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":false,"agent":"reader-2","circle":10,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":18,"refusals":1,"stored":18,"sync_step":19,"task_id":"T37-b28d0e658ab64376"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13388837.txt#8","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3bd26a97ea53e0c36ae78b7620fb991ce5777b4c2588d7dfa97394889da65f97","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"c3f3cd0f0d7e41302d4a37fc4beff6955b83fb322f9c0b2ee4cfddb8c085af14","submission_id":"T37-b28d0e658ab64376#done3"},"hash":"bd2c88aca364a851cbfb28639bf5426bfc1bf2a51dbeb3a84650972025d99fec","header":{"body_hash":"3257f2e5869234ac829275f87bbd9ea751028fb246c078161951ece52def584d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"06b598e4aaa9291101eb0cd0263235dd75a8d700dff3b534e2a59345847565b8","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":181,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"61bf8d4dbf98c146547ce7308c87a18da04dd9c5eafc99fad7a8734dfb1fb48a","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":10,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":496},"started_unix_ms":1795102465472,"wave":{"doc:PMC13388837.txt#7":"reader-1","doc:PMC13388837.txt#8":"reader-2","doc:PMC13388837.txt#9":"reader-3"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3bd26a97ea53e0c36ae78b7620fb991ce5777b4c2588d7dfa97394889da65f97","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"277b5e10fb2ae993befe079e69411c6b2e4a940bf76e1cf0dde8080fe01afe60","submission_id":"circle:5cbf4340eead73a35f06258f1fb3fd2bc86550da870214439c0519fc99b295b5"},"hash":"f783c78895e2d342f0dbbdf32089681ff3841f30ab5fc73b6584556076b67aa2","header":{"body_hash":"0a0dada7cf753eb607d018c4395d46cad7c6f31543cd690df6378e60ad07934b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"bd2c88aca364a851cbfb28639bf5426bfc1bf2a51dbeb3a84650972025d99fec","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":182,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"9acaf056ef0f31bee7ad2f5b53b9b5f26ff1246b5b78ea0aa6a5056248674c73","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"61bf8d4dbf98c146547ce7308c87a18da04dd9c5eafc99fad7a8734dfb1fb48a","engine_root":"3bd26a97ea53e0c36ae78b7620fb991ce5777b4c2588d7dfa97394889da65f97","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"9397e88ef66d80f1a5b5ef0c1bcb755843279ff38842132e385d80284b87778d","log_size":183,"projections":{"dependencies":"9f7c2be9decea75bd66e4b3cc8c665c013c9bff151503e875c47b126a02e2f3e","status":"25bf3dceeadc7aea21e2e01d98b2f5ba61bf7edb62862f55b2d83f318d818382"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"f783c78895e2d342f0dbbdf32089681ff3841f30ab5fc73b6584556076b67aa2"}},"engine_root":"3bd26a97ea53e0c36ae78b7620fb991ce5777b4c2588d7dfa97394889da65f97","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"61bf8d4dbf98c146547ce7308c87a18da04dd9c5eafc99fad7a8734dfb1fb48a","engine_root":"3bd26a97ea53e0c36ae78b7620fb991ce5777b4c2588d7dfa97394889da65f97","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"9397e88ef66d80f1a5b5ef0c1bcb755843279ff38842132e385d80284b87778d","log_size":183,"projections":{"dependencies":"9f7c2be9decea75bd66e4b3cc8c665c013c9bff151503e875c47b126a02e2f3e","status":"25bf3dceeadc7aea21e2e01d98b2f5ba61bf7edb62862f55b2d83f318d818382"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"f783c78895e2d342f0dbbdf32089681ff3841f30ab5fc73b6584556076b67aa2"},"seal_hash":"391df12caf69e4e14c279eae2c23edb1bbfa7b757d300a93dee9025b76d0a0e9"}},"request_hash":"316c61d150d90d125bba9cc2787bd48c0564f76556bca6931d8b3751bf4d110f","submission_id":"seal-183"},"hash":"408c102ce4c2cfb7f2fae21302a85d54a16b547241593cb7501a66a628f35708","header":{"body_hash":"b9398dfc87940880cd9d949b9c9a82ce6714831ad156c118fb4904f6bdeb6358","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"f783c78895e2d342f0dbbdf32089681ff3841f30ab5fc73b6584556076b67aa2","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":183,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"f81b205af7c4781eab82bff99ce1fee216c204654f2e419741ea94993b83f9b4","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"epoch":20,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102465472},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3bd26a97ea53e0c36ae78b7620fb991ce5777b4c2588d7dfa97394889da65f97","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"44fdce08a47f7463a4e9df9ee9cbf58f8c4d1a8d702c5d0b9c6e5b5430ef7c53","submission_id":"ring-members:00cf28d9ca70f13a72731b0fb3685003fdb18fecf92c6d884f616cc729002c07"},"hash":"908e52e9aec1ef921eca9d9a1664de5f0b99cf8eeb8d3cc5af65a02623c57d6c","header":{"body_hash":"116cc6336b67d7f2d0cfbf0b0af6c05e08e2899dbe749cd8adb2e0abe4cf47b8","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"408c102ce4c2cfb7f2fae21302a85d54a16b547241593cb7501a66a628f35708","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":184,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"00a3a4c1c1d3647d8d4274d40087409c3b309300f8cfdeb8e5453454902267ce","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":11,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":496},"started_unix_ms":1795102465520,"wave":{"doc:PMC13388837.txt#10":"reader-2","doc:PMC13388837.txt#11":"reader-3","doc:PMC13388837.txt#12":"reader-1"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3bd26a97ea53e0c36ae78b7620fb991ce5777b4c2588d7dfa97394889da65f97","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"8edf8f30361a687c9ada5fb93b7754f84a0cfd5a8a58ebf5775a5fca15b500dd","submission_id":"circle:8677797b32a953cfe35a937d450fe36e38bd54d421c3d7fc720a09b42a790a08"},"hash":"24a2d40b757ca1a79b859cf248cfe86be730ac3721c344ceb95663921f658631","header":{"body_hash":"ac3e88853cd2a4d70fa868ccca0e163ee5ce1aad150f90f3795f68de6b113bd5","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"908e52e9aec1ef921eca9d9a1664de5f0b99cf8eeb8d3cc5af65a02623c57d6c","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":185,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"8971d999397821bd8ad34e4b694bcf502151a4ee79634c0536a10f73ef996031","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"00a3a4c1c1d3647d8d4274d40087409c3b309300f8cfdeb8e5453454902267ce","engine_root":"3bd26a97ea53e0c36ae78b7620fb991ce5777b4c2588d7dfa97394889da65f97","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"91e2eed5758f1ae492035dbdf81ce13b6b07d50f93b796fce995ff95346d594f","log_size":186,"projections":{"dependencies":"9f7c2be9decea75bd66e4b3cc8c665c013c9bff151503e875c47b126a02e2f3e","status":"25bf3dceeadc7aea21e2e01d98b2f5ba61bf7edb62862f55b2d83f318d818382"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"24a2d40b757ca1a79b859cf248cfe86be730ac3721c344ceb95663921f658631"}},"engine_root":"3bd26a97ea53e0c36ae78b7620fb991ce5777b4c2588d7dfa97394889da65f97","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"00a3a4c1c1d3647d8d4274d40087409c3b309300f8cfdeb8e5453454902267ce","engine_root":"3bd26a97ea53e0c36ae78b7620fb991ce5777b4c2588d7dfa97394889da65f97","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"91e2eed5758f1ae492035dbdf81ce13b6b07d50f93b796fce995ff95346d594f","log_size":186,"projections":{"dependencies":"9f7c2be9decea75bd66e4b3cc8c665c013c9bff151503e875c47b126a02e2f3e","status":"25bf3dceeadc7aea21e2e01d98b2f5ba61bf7edb62862f55b2d83f318d818382"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"24a2d40b757ca1a79b859cf248cfe86be730ac3721c344ceb95663921f658631"},"seal_hash":"75af31781104cb292d1fa70f1d19fdd767de387b7b6aa3da1f83818eb1f2aab2"}},"request_hash":"8157b7a5c7897cc78dd5ac586479463bf19bff758a0cf53340c923c4577f7e29","submission_id":"seal-186"},"hash":"43d241b6c69879ef97adbc3e9789b8b8690429670b60b054ed16945f1d31a060","header":{"body_hash":"c639f6ec9552ec839b5f66bcb680474a8a1da29d2d621dc93c83b20b0a64663b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"24a2d40b757ca1a79b859cf248cfe86be730ac3721c344ceb95663921f658631","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":186,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"d421fff4a85bf953fabd6fc8f4e950d26f52c16f2bc121526b97bf8c9dfba6d5","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"epoch":21,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102465520},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3bd26a97ea53e0c36ae78b7620fb991ce5777b4c2588d7dfa97394889da65f97","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"16f35d9418913ae0e5abf2650e5d1563ef9ed98b252402243c6802dc82296bd0","submission_id":"ring-members:517f2ef051df5fd3774f0d034310d448b801fa6bb60bbdb1ad35f83db3b53bef"},"hash":"52055934c86cabb0bb2591d9222d0a09d6f674c20e3f78133c8bb7cab8da0413","header":{"body_hash":"2f9cc4f642d7a3eb2b5096ceb846facfa7ceb315e442095193a89c7aa36e79e5","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"43d241b6c69879ef97adbc3e9789b8b8690429670b60b054ed16945f1d31a060","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":187,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"a9fa3d4957775126104479f174be500497bdd044b73617b2093eee610f4536e1","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":11,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":21,"task_id":"T38-9c3bb26b11d10e17"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13388837.txt#12","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3bd26a97ea53e0c36ae78b7620fb991ce5777b4c2588d7dfa97394889da65f97","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"1749db03f84f78ca6ef5a9efe0e7ef9d5cf5ed9bcf0a344de6ab5e215e97c4b6","submission_id":"T38-9c3bb26b11d10e17#done2"},"hash":"bbd4575f7ebb0eea52ced698e88f4026f3dfc0cab64fe344eec6e798026b65b3","header":{"body_hash":"e10929a8313e5ae1d00e9fa7ccc50f99bef07d34346b96f62b64eeeb6ec2cf9e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"52055934c86cabb0bb2591d9222d0a09d6f674c20e3f78133c8bb7cab8da0413","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":188,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"b6fb7b4f477987a90e30d26b75f298142570f90ff73473f7a5e7f1d9283a0066","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T40-573eb67407b51d09","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"the cross-sectional research design mainly discloses the correlational relationship among variables, possessing limited causative inferential power for psychological evolutions.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t40_o1","terms":["cross-sectional design","correlational relationship","limited causative inferential power"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"although the proposed model identified meaningful associations among AI perception, self-efficacy, anxiety, and multimodal WTC, its overall predictive power for WTC remained moderate (R2 = 0.231).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t40_o2","terms":["AI perception","self-efficacy","anxiety","multimodal WTC","R2 = 0.231"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"the marginally significant latent interaction between self-efficacy and foreign language anxiety should be interpreted as an exploratory associational tendency rather than causal evidence","kind":"observe","local_id":"t40_o3","terms":["latent interaction","self-efficacy","foreign language anxiety","exploratory associational tendency"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"From a behavioral perspective, the qualitative materials presented the risk of “cognitive laziness under machine dependency,”","kind":"observe","local_id":"t40_o4","terms":["qualitative materials","cognitive laziness under machine dependency"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"as this study was conducted within a single university in Northwest China, the generalizability of the results may be subject to specific institutional and cultural nuances","kind":"observe","local_id":"t40_o5","terms":["single university in Northwest China","generalizability limitation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"I am deeply grateful to the School of Foreign Languages, Lanzhou City University, for their research support throughout this project.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t40_o6","terms":["School of Foreign Languages","Lanzhou City University"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"I also extend my sincere thanks to the 960 college students who participated in this study—for carving out time from their packed academic schedules to complete the survey","kind":"observe","local_id":"t40_o7","terms":["960 college students","survey participants"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t40_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t40_c1","object":"meaningful associations among AI perception, self-efficacy, anxiety, and multimodal WTC; moderate predictive power for WTC (R2 = 0.231)","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 reports that its proposed model identified meaningful associations among AI perception, self-efficacy, anxiety, and multimodal WTC, with moderate overall predictive power for WTC (R2 = 0.231)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t40_o1","t40_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t40_c2","object":"cross-sectional design yields correlational rather than causal evidence; self-efficacy x foreign language anxiety interaction is exploratory","predicate":"qualifies_conclusions","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 qualifies its mediation findings by noting that its cross-sectional design mainly discloses correlational relationships with limited causal inferential power, and that the self-efficacy by anxiety interaction is exploratory."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t40_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t40_c3","object":"risk of cognitive laziness under machine dependency","predicate":"reports_qualitative_finding","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 reports that its qualitative materials identified a behavioral risk of cognitive laziness under machine dependency among learners."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t40_o1","t40_o4","t40_o5","t40_o6","t40_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t40_c4","object":"cross-sectional survey and qualitative materials from 960 college students at Lanzhou City University in Northwest China","predicate":"uses_sample_and_data","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 rests on a cross-sectional survey (and qualitative materials) of 960 college students at a single university in Northwest China (Lanzhou City University), which limits generalizability."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",60528,66471]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"0a0f496170b488263b8214164479a751a77610f0c2521f4e1a9ea3e7dc4f2d84","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["d21bfe7f5779dd301f16c8980c3d768a813f75cd7eba753fb9c861753036be5a","91acb663990b8370b46994e374fa012b78948848d56b273ff7ace6971b8923b0","fca31b962a7554df2cfe480024e1c9fcd9c026980d4815758d4c7688889ed639","7a52f66a3b1f7e4a23ff98e362e265ec270c29461698bf5a2f235714b3e901ca","d0dbd5d4f725c203f24f0454f609c348d638a5c148f84cd5f81dd79dee196a77","1dde4db124e6c8e5457bda9f005e44e0c43b70635101ae8a97efedef5bdbd46c","9556ed9858f16aa29fb36eb229370e9a9b07c0c38a4a183b151e58e55f979b4e","b620ce5a565c472078911364c598e1f99cdb654ae1888dc50c0adf09833aa696","eb024cb2fcece7356783d1a87cc71b225004316cae272f7acd98fec69fca8911","1ae0214f34e89f125c5e42c3b5fb8153a74d1e9b2a3cf561e9056557bb988ac2","c076aa8ea7f6860a27860430a16290ed2e214dd8cf233b42dffc0ad0057871c2"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"f8aabf203df51bdce23c14f1d7a7e05141fb8db8c41af320cd81ba9582f1492f","submission_id":"T40-573eb67407b51d09#1"},"hash":"7c8c4a59ae61339a9822681144d371117339aca3736deeb5ca3e84c4a836f471","header":{"body_hash":"769cdc02d36665f9f6d48ae809171eb051126483986dfd855b115dc653e5256c","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"bbd4575f7ebb0eea52ced698e88f4026f3dfc0cab64fe344eec6e798026b65b3","records_root":"e0b1fedd4a6d3d0ccd7a0a5af81d400af960ae526ef6a4eb3c0dd67e710e30d0","seq":189,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"d745498b2113b7e6674398b735c9cd261d296b0a79f91b2c872cb49ef9220fee","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":11,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":21,"task_id":"T40-573eb67407b51d09"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13388837.txt#11","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"0a0f496170b488263b8214164479a751a77610f0c2521f4e1a9ea3e7dc4f2d84","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"48a69e921363e3db9e80beca59dcc80aedbf26b5f6ff4267114c46e119db9f90","submission_id":"T40-573eb67407b51d09#done2"},"hash":"0ef10a42a35584950f6d124b709a80b190be7ac85445df2ade96d1be1df07ded","header":{"body_hash":"4fd21a0284c4b6606a23a3e78fadfd15f1633255d8b27e06da9a033022a40904","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"7c8c4a59ae61339a9822681144d371117339aca3736deeb5ca3e84c4a836f471","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":190,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"01bccc27ed85218e9abe484b502c8889de14b642e2e9283d581482bf0116ef3a","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T39-cc2e690709fc3174","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Through a cross-sectional mixed-methods study involving 960 college students, this research elucidated the structural relationships surrounding L2 willingness to communicate (WTC) within intelligent learning environments.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t39_o1","terms":["study design","sample size","960 college students","L2 willingness to communicate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Survey data indicate that learners’ perception of AI not only positively correlates with their overall WTC and exerts comparable predictive strength across both receptive (listening/reading) and productive (speaking/writing) modalities.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t39_o2","terms":["AI perception","overall WTC","receptive and productive modalities"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Within this structural path, L2 self-efficacy served as an important indirect link.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t39_o3","terms":["L2 self-efficacy","indirect link","mediation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The latent moderation analysis further revealed that foreign language anxiety was significantly and negatively associated with multimodal WTC.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t39_o4","terms":["foreign language anxiety","multimodal WTC","latent moderation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Importantly, the interaction between self-efficacy and anxiety presented a marginally significant buffering tendency (p = 0.068), functioning as an exploratory pattern requiring future validation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t39_o5","terms":["self-efficacy and anxiety interaction","buffering tendency","p = 0.068","exploratory pattern"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The path coefficients between AI perception and self-efficacy remained consistently positive and statistically significant across all proficiency levels—from beginners to advanced credential holders.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t39_o6","terms":["AI perception to self-efficacy path","proficiency levels","cross-group stability"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Because rigorous chi-square difference constraints were not applied, we avoid claiming comparative magnitude differences among these clusters.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t39_o7","terms":["chi-square difference constraints","no comparative magnitude differences claimed"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Supporting these structural patterns, qualitative feedback corroborated the quantitative data, highlighting AI’s role as a “psychological safety buffer” while also delineating the practical boundaries between virtual AI assistance and authentic interpersonal communication.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t39_o8","terms":["qualitative feedback","psychological safety buffer","boundaries of AI assistance"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Regarding the psychometric modeling and data sources, the current study relied entirely on self-reported survey data.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t39_o9","terms":["self-reported survey data","data source limitation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Second, in the CFA model, some item residuals were correlated based on Modification Indices. While theoretically justified within the same latent constructs (Byrne, 2016), this hints that certain scale items possess semantic overlap.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t39_o10","terms":["CFA model","correlated item residuals","Modification Indices","semantic overlap"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o1","t39_o2","t39_o3","t39_o4","t39_o8","t39_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c1","object":"cross-sectional mixed-methods study of 960 college students (self-reported survey data and qualitative feedback) measuring AI perception, L2 self-efficacy, foreign language anxiety, and multimodal L2 WTC","predicate":"uses_data_and_measures","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 rests on a cross-sectional mixed-methods study of 960 college students relying entirely on self-reported survey data along with qualitative feedback, measuring AI perception, L2 self-efficacy, foreign language anxiety, and L2 WTC."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o1","t39_o2","t39_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c2","object":"AI perception positively correlates with overall L2 WTC across receptive and productive modalities, linked indirectly via L2 self-efficacy","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes that learners' AI perception positively correlates with overall L2 WTC with comparable predictive strength across receptive (listening/reading) and productive (speaking/writing) modalities, with L2 self-efficacy as an indirect link."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o4","t39_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c3","object":"negative association of foreign language anxiety with multimodal WTC; marginally significant (p = 0.068) exploratory buffering interaction of self-efficacy and anxiety","predicate":"concludes_moderation_results","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 finds that foreign language anxiety is significantly negatively associated with multimodal WTC, while the self-efficacy × anxiety interaction shows only a marginally significant buffering tendency (p=0.068) requiring validation."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o6","t39_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c4","object":"consistent positive AI perception to self-efficacy path across proficiency levels, without claiming magnitude differences due to unapplied chi-square difference constraints","predicate":"qualifies_subgroup_comparison","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 finds positive, significant paths from AI perception to self-efficacy across all English proficiency levels, but avoids claiming comparative magnitude differences between groups because chi-square difference constraints were not applied."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c5","object":"qualitative feedback corroborates quantitative patterns, showing AI acts as a psychological safety buffer with practical boundaries vs. authentic interpersonal communication","predicate":"concludes_qualitative_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 reports that qualitative feedback corroborated quantitative findings by identifying AI as a 'psychological safety buffer' while noting boundaries between virtual AI assistance and authentic interpersonal communication."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o9","t39_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c6","object":"reliance on self-reported survey data and post-hoc correlated item residuals in CFA based on Modification Indices indicating semantic overlap","predicate":"qualifies_methodology","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 qualifies its psychometric modeling by noting full reliance on self-reported survey data and post-hoc correlation of some CFA item residuals via Modification Indices, which hints at semantic overlap among scale items."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",55079,60528]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"d8e09f267196b81073b9c0e0544c1aa3d24af34c98ad2db486a4618e5fe7b808","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["c51fd15f7c5d6dc7380e63e5360055974e07041745a1e8dbe0d1270482fc01f9","e3b88d40e51c4c4b8b3c8dcb995ba7df48f2dd90148554d8b701753f1450940f","17e8a24e232f2e23cf2043bf407a725b6ab8034b8fe227b34ac0de1521012fd4","7042f0fb96e01503f6b6f17bd001cc7ddfdad7e40c6abd79240f0be0f994580a","8acd2579ff5f6a5339cd9de267add5700df555a33f608965f195a678bbcfe298","6fc61ff97278746c8f37a8777085f5a8036f8d010d57de534f1ef0dd92862ea3","9c82eac4f625754020167d4b6e7bb44bf9a8b3440cbd0dd54ac2d92e9be31c6e","2353935292a597e19c7e8561cf31d95773397e04a96af96eff9bac7d93d74e19","f1e9688cfe5d83fe7f05197488070f98b7c96265f3b8bb85736cb83695344fb9","71e3aa99bb2f8e125b1921cc0aa783cb6342c9b33553074adb51e1140ccd99a7"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":10}},"request_hash":"fa23b13e6c6d9f867157670168ff4c748938c238aae9ed6e84c264bbcef2adc9","submission_id":"T39-cc2e690709fc3174#1"},"hash":"cb1a83cab4af610019b05509f38a19621975c1e85b61f7a46c7b721d7041e25b","header":{"body_hash":"5f3eb683e6407962a41a61e44ae7744fc4ae01cdf2b7e6f1c16f842b593eb3df","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"0ef10a42a35584950f6d124b709a80b190be7ac85445df2ade96d1be1df07ded","records_root":"1bcd649012bcc8f514539ed0b4ab44b8319cbcec0b6a4911b3a964cdda06056b","seq":191,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"58d104cb712fa26dd7982aa4f0cd62a01a63f0ee76fd21b778ac8d9ddeb0ba22","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T39-cc2e690709fc3174","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o1","t39_o2","t39_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c2","object":"AI perception positively correlates with overall L2 WTC across receptive and productive modalities, linked indirectly via L2 self-efficacy","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes that learners' AI perception positively correlates with overall L2 WTC with comparable predictive strength across receptive (listening/reading) and productive (speaking/writing) modalities, with L2 self-efficacy as an indirect link."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o4","t39_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c3","object":"negative association of foreign language anxiety with multimodal WTC; marginally significant (p = 0.068) exploratory buffering interaction of self-efficacy and anxiety","predicate":"concludes_moderation_results","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 finds that foreign language anxiety is significantly negatively associated with multimodal WTC, while the self-efficacy × anxiety interaction shows only a marginally significant buffering tendency (p=0.068) requiring validation."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o6","t39_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c4","object":"consistent positive AI perception to self-efficacy path across proficiency levels, without claiming magnitude differences due to unapplied chi-square difference constraints","predicate":"qualifies_subgroup_comparison","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 finds positive, significant paths from AI perception to self-efficacy across all English proficiency levels, but avoids claiming comparative magnitude differences between groups because chi-square difference constraints were not applied."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c5","object":"qualitative feedback corroborates quantitative patterns, showing AI acts as a psychological safety buffer with practical boundaries vs. authentic interpersonal communication","predicate":"concludes_qualitative_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 reports that qualitative feedback corroborated quantitative findings by identifying AI as a 'psychological safety buffer' while noting boundaries between virtual AI assistance and authentic interpersonal communication."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o9","t39_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c6","object":"reliance on self-reported survey data and post-hoc correlated item residuals in CFA based on Modification Indices indicating semantic overlap","predicate":"qualifies_methodology","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 qualifies its psychometric modeling by noting full reliance on self-reported survey data and post-hoc correlation of some CFA item residuals via Modification Indices, which hints at semantic overlap among scale items."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",55079,60528]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"d8e09f267196b81073b9c0e0544c1aa3d24af34c98ad2db486a4618e5fe7b808","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":[],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":0}},"request_hash":"3e90c9f187feb5e2b74af6d39a7951a37bcb13ea4a3dffa5e17f38f5d5aca47f","submission_id":"T39-cc2e690709fc3174#1.1"},"hash":"2c6a33d272bef4177aab03c317c034ed58b7ba4cbbd16150d6256e84c9b9ee87","header":{"body_hash":"88d1846188b9a189df96ffb0dee54a05477959d5f223209d497bd35c26c944d9","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"cb1a83cab4af610019b05509f38a19621975c1e85b61f7a46c7b721d7041e25b","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":192,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"675725d6ff69aedf052a5a060f2eff78f58ec6ceacdc4c5ec59b5e64a8f93381","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T39-cc2e690709fc3174","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o4","t39_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c3","object":"negative association of foreign language anxiety with multimodal WTC; marginally significant (p = 0.068) exploratory buffering interaction of self-efficacy and anxiety","predicate":"concludes_moderation_results","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 finds that foreign language anxiety is significantly negatively associated with multimodal WTC, while the self-efficacy × anxiety interaction shows only a marginally significant buffering tendency (p=0.068) requiring validation."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o6","t39_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c4","object":"consistent positive AI perception to self-efficacy path across proficiency levels, without claiming magnitude differences due to unapplied chi-square difference constraints","predicate":"qualifies_subgroup_comparison","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 finds positive, significant paths from AI perception to self-efficacy across all English proficiency levels, but avoids claiming comparative magnitude differences between groups because chi-square difference constraints were not applied."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c5","object":"qualitative feedback corroborates quantitative patterns, showing AI acts as a psychological safety buffer with practical boundaries vs. authentic interpersonal communication","predicate":"concludes_qualitative_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 reports that qualitative feedback corroborated quantitative findings by identifying AI as a 'psychological safety buffer' while noting boundaries between virtual AI assistance and authentic interpersonal communication."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o9","t39_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c6","object":"reliance on self-reported survey data and post-hoc correlated item residuals in CFA based on Modification Indices indicating semantic overlap","predicate":"qualifies_methodology","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 qualifies its psychometric modeling by noting full reliance on self-reported survey data and post-hoc correlation of some CFA item residuals via Modification Indices, which hints at semantic overlap among scale items."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",55079,60528]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"d8e09f267196b81073b9c0e0544c1aa3d24af34c98ad2db486a4618e5fe7b808","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["aff44d1624d04d62b780fd370c959731245572075ce220cad72476d07639c2b6"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":1}},"request_hash":"6c1ee458956957a93a54531c0fd987f168bd94837368dd8f2248be5bacbb1693","submission_id":"T39-cc2e690709fc3174#1.2"},"hash":"80b5574295fad1fd2a88a49dc238af1cbd4ccde78ff17dea6865c71a7993eeb7","header":{"body_hash":"ee85adbcf262b090230c8045943426170048ef3577c3929c90d47c148df10f5a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"2c6a33d272bef4177aab03c317c034ed58b7ba4cbbd16150d6256e84c9b9ee87","records_root":"f104e100dbd223f8cb51b1ab0bfc1a79e58f4f4c65c2fa3e06f32e4d987014fb","seq":193,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"6433a39003ab2bb0d7ecaadafd9c8b979768113e0d1736c04add207c1fcbc056","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T39-cc2e690709fc3174","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c5","object":"qualitative feedback corroborates quantitative patterns, showing AI acts as a psychological safety buffer with practical boundaries vs. authentic interpersonal communication","predicate":"concludes_qualitative_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 reports that qualitative feedback corroborated quantitative findings by identifying AI as a 'psychological safety buffer' while noting boundaries between virtual AI assistance and authentic interpersonal communication."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o9","t39_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c6","object":"reliance on self-reported survey data and post-hoc correlated item residuals in CFA based on Modification Indices indicating semantic overlap","predicate":"qualifies_methodology","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 qualifies its psychometric modeling by noting full reliance on self-reported survey data and post-hoc correlation of some CFA item residuals via Modification Indices, which hints at semantic overlap among scale items."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",55079,60528]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"d8e09f267196b81073b9c0e0544c1aa3d24af34c98ad2db486a4618e5fe7b808","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["2c1ad457579097810edb411dee944f37fdcf5e9d124e8518b09757780cd0bfc7","244cb1036805f40aa2959686851d49bc3257c4a1c47dfab331e0fd4053d40592"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"f2117df605d054bbe0ea0a78f6bf58860e9400bfa0d4f8f4a3559db57cb04852","submission_id":"T39-cc2e690709fc3174#1.3"},"hash":"5617261319933556fb6b9d126256b079add0a9f40b482fccbd2a4b68a722ba16","header":{"body_hash":"da3eb0ff730003f360ceedfbf1246ed061250366b962779fd88c892e17b6bf78","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"80b5574295fad1fd2a88a49dc238af1cbd4ccde78ff17dea6865c71a7993eeb7","records_root":"21de28d9b5782f943e9a1e5aceafd985e354805a4b11292cf3818991abe057d7","seq":194,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"eed8377db8862c24b6ba7457039c1abc67a2847c8415787b956021b098230ae9","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@c51fd15f7c5d6dc7","@e3b88d40e51c4c4b","@17e8a24e232f2e23","@7042f0fb96e01503","@8acd2579ff5f6a53","@6fc61ff97278746c","@9c82eac4f6257540","@2353935292a597e1","@f1e9688cfe5d83fe","@71e3aa99bb2f8e12","@aff44d1624d04d62","@2c1ad45757909781","@244cb1036805f40a"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":10,"local_id":"t39_c1"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":11,"local_id":"t39_c2"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":13,"local_id":"t39_c4"}],"task_id":"T39-cc2e690709fc3174","work_key":"doc:PMC13388837.txt#10"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T39-cc2e690709fc3174:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"d8e09f267196b81073b9c0e0544c1aa3d24af34c98ad2db486a4618e5fe7b808","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"43b84494f8ded1fae266b49912ce85684b002eda7f4e21034a59ea1280acb5b2","submission_id":"T39-cc2e690709fc3174#repair1"},"hash":"120e7a16e373d2f141f8d54ac09a75d9b8be662596e4769290421f411ff84efc","header":{"body_hash":"2186abd7b72d87d79c8b0289528f2eb6e3d37860c74f3aa7928766f635b6d886","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"5617261319933556fb6b9d126256b079add0a9f40b482fccbd2a4b68a722ba16","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":195,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"a176c93bcd688ad609ce25948204e7df4db434ad1d077917ab3213ad36ebb4f0","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T39-cc2e690709fc3174","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o1","t39_o2","t39_o3","t39_o4","t39_o8","t39_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c1","object":"cross-sectional mixed-methods study of 960 college students (self-reported survey data and qualitative feedback) measuring AI perception, L2 self-efficacy, foreign language anxiety, and multimodal L2 WTC","predicate":"uses_data_and_measures","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 rests on a cross-sectional mixed-methods study of 960 college students using self-reported survey data and qualitative feedback to measure AI perception, L2 self-efficacy, foreign language anxiety, and multimodal L2 WTC."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o1","t39_o2","t39_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c2","object":"AI perception positively correlates with overall L2 WTC across receptive and productive modalities, linked indirectly via L2 self-efficacy","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes that learners' AI perception positively correlates with overall L2 WTC with comparable predictive strength across receptive and productive modalities, with L2 self-efficacy serving as an important indirect link."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t39_o6","t39_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t39_c4","object":"consistent positive AI perception to self-efficacy path across proficiency levels, without claiming magnitude differences due to unapplied chi-square difference constraints","predicate":"qualifies_subgroup_comparison","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 finds consistently positive, significant paths from AI perception to self-efficacy across all English proficiency levels, avoiding comparative magnitude claims because chi-square difference constraints were not applied."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",55079,60528]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"d8e09f267196b81073b9c0e0544c1aa3d24af34c98ad2db486a4618e5fe7b808","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["9ee36b2f9a99d247eae71874e62e94634479618ed0c845868b65ccf9a17dffa3","fa514e7ba5ba43885ba218e09154a767429e24ce8f696633348d8ba5a0160758","5ff1f7b7cb46e020a66f09bbcd8907e03b8f6254f9ee9e8c19eacd26ff87793a"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"9bac7fc283d5d19d8dced822d948242eb728d4dd839866b1e7173685c98efbb4","submission_id":"T39-cc2e690709fc3174#2"},"hash":"bf0748b50a03317b757bc30d30e7d30dc9a1fa2e45779ba38d5efde92222fec6","header":{"body_hash":"4682f31db582a2ca3103aa1801a2f7babf1c11adade9003b7cd27a1bacb822b5","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"120e7a16e373d2f141f8d54ac09a75d9b8be662596e4769290421f411ff84efc","records_root":"029d7f82ecadc15eb36a8da7463f80d626620661a5e5a1b0d74f8bc36c5a5230","seq":196,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"4c2ce66b0ed2e1e78e6443504b1e65c35de8cc4338cb2979bd19e9911d3d0a66","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":false,"agent":"reader-2","circle":11,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":16,"refusals":1,"stored":16,"sync_step":21,"task_id":"T39-cc2e690709fc3174"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13388837.txt#10","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"d8e09f267196b81073b9c0e0544c1aa3d24af34c98ad2db486a4618e5fe7b808","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"4af34fe9e9390ead11464eefdb3eb45c6f75e2c6f29bcbc016f6d2f63bafa111","submission_id":"T39-cc2e690709fc3174#done3"},"hash":"4bd0cffa6500d700b1088c6c0ec15701d0f0daeb7af2b6ea0f78a247d12032ef","header":{"body_hash":"3c3b0c7f10087fe380425bef368337df6d0aeda8ee7861896c434023e8ff7205","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"bf0748b50a03317b757bc30d30e7d30dc9a1fa2e45779ba38d5efde92222fec6","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":197,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"c01c5de21e336e2a40dab791c90f318208902ea0af00f601cc7d1efa2d9e3880","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":11,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":523},"started_unix_ms":1795102511085,"wave":{"doc:PMC13388837.txt#10":"reader-2","doc:PMC13388837.txt#11":"reader-3","doc:PMC13388837.txt#12":"reader-1"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"d8e09f267196b81073b9c0e0544c1aa3d24af34c98ad2db486a4618e5fe7b808","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"86b9b69ba20910e00690550f10f2f55d95b384a5dcc80993ba29b7c75fbb776b","submission_id":"circle:0fa0eb58c57a056f50eb0cef90f6877aa6540f476c44615967d89e54619b0e75"},"hash":"648725409f589190da5d3c89e056ba21840e0b26335d23d9bd5a7ee93ed23f4e","header":{"body_hash":"90db146a95af33a009d8a787a7dfec8d2de8c207b1232fd7896d0f24384ce7a1","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"4bd0cffa6500d700b1088c6c0ec15701d0f0daeb7af2b6ea0f78a247d12032ef","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":198,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"a93e77579c29ad51769be7d19ee90b40e7c1be9971e17dd3dcbf5800b111a364","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"c01c5de21e336e2a40dab791c90f318208902ea0af00f601cc7d1efa2d9e3880","engine_root":"d8e09f267196b81073b9c0e0544c1aa3d24af34c98ad2db486a4618e5fe7b808","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"49456433eae89ace71c79e89a3b3428ebc4da9c2946341032a15123fdfc7d02b","log_size":199,"projections":{"dependencies":"b80163d5f374187afd665e309fad501b21d3a934b8112e57b319bf756b78c4e8","status":"7db4503fc47fe0ce080ff7ac7e0dfe44ec2cd00c62f490b8394eb8f71b9ddf10"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"648725409f589190da5d3c89e056ba21840e0b26335d23d9bd5a7ee93ed23f4e"}},"engine_root":"d8e09f267196b81073b9c0e0544c1aa3d24af34c98ad2db486a4618e5fe7b808","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"c01c5de21e336e2a40dab791c90f318208902ea0af00f601cc7d1efa2d9e3880","engine_root":"d8e09f267196b81073b9c0e0544c1aa3d24af34c98ad2db486a4618e5fe7b808","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"49456433eae89ace71c79e89a3b3428ebc4da9c2946341032a15123fdfc7d02b","log_size":199,"projections":{"dependencies":"b80163d5f374187afd665e309fad501b21d3a934b8112e57b319bf756b78c4e8","status":"7db4503fc47fe0ce080ff7ac7e0dfe44ec2cd00c62f490b8394eb8f71b9ddf10"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"648725409f589190da5d3c89e056ba21840e0b26335d23d9bd5a7ee93ed23f4e"},"seal_hash":"9539c78573a94be9618b3b3814489eb12739ba98da44e17ee5688f1e620ffcdb"}},"request_hash":"a5a24d5170b436f336a1c465ad667a814922ddb9a8ff20bc62d5aa21dcca5b61","submission_id":"seal-199"},"hash":"5ddef81d9607da977143b966c691d0877fb8c3ee4ca97806f06728ad8197cb4a","header":{"body_hash":"e203ea27e286670c13ed8dd06b8bbd66d6a1297c03d5f543175fbca0c1525d13","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"648725409f589190da5d3c89e056ba21840e0b26335d23d9bd5a7ee93ed23f4e","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":199,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"a007536d6e243244718ac3e4b61d0d7680c35bf4ed26772641d9fa34069bd0d5","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"epoch":22,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102511085},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"d8e09f267196b81073b9c0e0544c1aa3d24af34c98ad2db486a4618e5fe7b808","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"0ee527957d7448b752913847446b35833ff6aa12f763dbde4002936b1b9d511b","submission_id":"ring-members:744e2b4815b01997227704959854759f446f5d05dddde3256aa6ab77961c8455"},"hash":"bbd22587a52d3b4cdf570eb63700c1fe862e03d91e99ca06a79ff8a7a876507a","header":{"body_hash":"09349242c12d3853c075b775c5ac1f95e96047af090ddf76bf46844b0a7ccdc8","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"5ddef81d9607da977143b966c691d0877fb8c3ee4ca97806f06728ad8197cb4a","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":200,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"50149161786860cb1bbe6979ac65af94c7bf2f1b439a0dc664f2542810c0f58d","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":12,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":523},"started_unix_ms":1795102511118,"wave":{"doc:PMC13388837.txt#13":"reader-3","doc:PMC13449012.txt#0":"reader-1","doc:PMC13449012.txt#1":"reader-2"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"d8e09f267196b81073b9c0e0544c1aa3d24af34c98ad2db486a4618e5fe7b808","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"1bb646e71cb3373dca110f5711d903e22fe62b3560a6666a2a225ee70ee47ae3","submission_id":"circle:998840346ef0abde44a4f4f4789d54c7cbfd793a540bf43f409253429ab83538"},"hash":"c0702fa544e48b74fbdd35b64b1beb32d584fddfd0d7eb68b7a85aba8444b89e","header":{"body_hash":"e231d8c386aeef0b7e75d4879a4dafab96a23baa4b6a3ef641c15caf8417df88","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"bbd22587a52d3b4cdf570eb63700c1fe862e03d91e99ca06a79ff8a7a876507a","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":201,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"5b94925b211ee34b68dd9d567afea38c8b9f8e5d3a7b096a0e9cc5923ed1a385","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"50149161786860cb1bbe6979ac65af94c7bf2f1b439a0dc664f2542810c0f58d","engine_root":"d8e09f267196b81073b9c0e0544c1aa3d24af34c98ad2db486a4618e5fe7b808","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"8ee1f157458f42f59e9bfc555fde75f80367ec44051907408923ba7647a4b8a8","log_size":202,"projections":{"dependencies":"b80163d5f374187afd665e309fad501b21d3a934b8112e57b319bf756b78c4e8","status":"7db4503fc47fe0ce080ff7ac7e0dfe44ec2cd00c62f490b8394eb8f71b9ddf10"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"c0702fa544e48b74fbdd35b64b1beb32d584fddfd0d7eb68b7a85aba8444b89e"}},"engine_root":"d8e09f267196b81073b9c0e0544c1aa3d24af34c98ad2db486a4618e5fe7b808","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"50149161786860cb1bbe6979ac65af94c7bf2f1b439a0dc664f2542810c0f58d","engine_root":"d8e09f267196b81073b9c0e0544c1aa3d24af34c98ad2db486a4618e5fe7b808","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"8ee1f157458f42f59e9bfc555fde75f80367ec44051907408923ba7647a4b8a8","log_size":202,"projections":{"dependencies":"b80163d5f374187afd665e309fad501b21d3a934b8112e57b319bf756b78c4e8","status":"7db4503fc47fe0ce080ff7ac7e0dfe44ec2cd00c62f490b8394eb8f71b9ddf10"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"c0702fa544e48b74fbdd35b64b1beb32d584fddfd0d7eb68b7a85aba8444b89e"},"seal_hash":"cf390a19de37910047230e230fb3923f952410accdc91383a97f48af50e551e6"}},"request_hash":"1b06b7d29be8495caacf33014839f94c49e1fb7b072ac7c74a80953005f73d37","submission_id":"seal-202"},"hash":"7bba5a8aab9a489fbca86e9639c398d635e87403b1d7293ba3491fd987c96bc7","header":{"body_hash":"7ac7b132ed1aa0e2a1b7e3c62d7ace37ce3e302ea7be152c5a7ca094d083661b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"c0702fa544e48b74fbdd35b64b1beb32d584fddfd0d7eb68b7a85aba8444b89e","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":202,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"cae236f95d166dc0aac272f786ebfae3da9b075f5c75f00d9eeaa5da2ef38e94","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"epoch":23,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102511118},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"d8e09f267196b81073b9c0e0544c1aa3d24af34c98ad2db486a4618e5fe7b808","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"f630c07bdf63d4ec864ea7827eb94067473f74f07033d8fe07b007e7dcc84018","submission_id":"ring-members:0d5934416d252b1f487df023f4237a2f9a03fcefe8f17621943dafe8285ab70a"},"hash":"9a56afd2d8cb300148d8c901eea85b3d49473d9c2f0d608f7e815d9dcab92f7f","header":{"body_hash":"66c977bb702e7be4544461af3881aa9fc2573ac1b104d536f72fb13a49628f67","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"7bba5a8aab9a489fbca86e9639c398d635e87403b1d7293ba3491fd987c96bc7","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":203,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"937adca668bc5bbec1bc79b4adc36c4346818d9a0ac0b84383d5fd925f085984","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T43-06759465b2f5ae26","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Wang J., Fan W. (2025). The effect of ChatGPT on students’ learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis. Hum. Soc. Sci. Commun. 12, 1–21.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t43_o1","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025 reference list entry","PMC13388837 references"]},{"about":["PMC13388837.txt","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t43_q1","needed":"Check in-text citations of Wang and Fan (2025) in the body of PMC13388837.txt and link with the Title line quote from the meta-analysis record file.","text":"Which statements in the body of PMC13388837 cite Wang and Fan (2025), and what findings or claims do they support with it?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",72408,76700]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"1f7a5f535328a92c0e21e62616ea0f378a578a5343cdefc6f7170193605cd57b","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["99d25fe9ca68f73dca7badcc49012473fea76963d5ddd5144e95bec147c33db0","7cc6df519f15ea9c78e5f55efc2b93ae5450d4bbcdf1d1b6889c6febd1256ad6"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"e8e2680f218350b8a8d64159c49848ce5b6e107fb304ed72c35ac46f1819d349","submission_id":"T43-06759465b2f5ae26#1"},"hash":"bc53f6f083fd60671a9fd8804023fd765fea6248c4d80cd280883f7847f9897d","header":{"body_hash":"314339ec7dd7ef76e7b1e1e2bb0480d2db5ebb5a30be45469965957679a6f463","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"9a56afd2d8cb300148d8c901eea85b3d49473d9c2f0d608f7e815d9dcab92f7f","records_root":"7f24c92dd8c77a3fe6cfc3f4ef8a2a5dd128d6a3868a1abfbd7864a7ed2a4d64","seq":204,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"e714ed25ed8049d4f40169a639c9e037821b6849ceb1470d433c0e5a56af323e","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":12,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":23,"task_id":"T43-06759465b2f5ae26"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13388837.txt#13","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"1f7a5f535328a92c0e21e62616ea0f378a578a5343cdefc6f7170193605cd57b","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"30f49bcc2f58f798470aa655512407f1fffa983ef9cfc9cb7b784fe38fdc226a","submission_id":"T43-06759465b2f5ae26#done2"},"hash":"1efdc6f5aaa20a45eace84c40a18ce58d824c8a9049524c916a94da8f762852b","header":{"body_hash":"afdbc804d023ae03c201154541cde0a0ad672757a0f4a2d1014f9707b523e42c","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"bc53f6f083fd60671a9fd8804023fd765fea6248c4d80cd280883f7847f9897d","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":205,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"b5869c11a77c6c985028061c2318a7b4cb9b328fe442f1253d7e8af2de0ee2ef","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T42-81ecfe50c71524d9","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Therefore, this study aimed to evaluate the accuracy of responses generated by the ChatGPT AI language model, specifically utilizing its GPT-3.5 and 4.1 mini versions.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t42_o1","terms":["ChatGPT","GPT-3.5","GPT-4.1 mini","response accuracy"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"By evaluating the correctness, consistency and reliability of these responses, this research aims to provide insights into the potential and limitations of using ChatGPT","kind":"observe","local_id":"t42_o2","terms":["correctness","consistency","reliability","measured outcomes"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"this study not only evaluates the factual accuracy of AI-generated answers but also highlights the importance of keyword usage in structured assessments","kind":"observe","local_id":"t42_o3","terms":["factual accuracy","keyword usage","structured assessments"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"To initiate the process, a comprehensive list of bacterial species and relevant questions was developed in collaboration with a board of clinical microbiologists.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t42_o4","terms":["clinical microbiologists","bacterial species","question development"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The selected bacterial species were chosen based on their national importance in seasonal epidemics of Sri Lanka, as reported by the national health ministry [25, 26]","kind":"observe","local_id":"t42_o5","terms":["Sri Lanka seasonal epidemics","national health ministry","species selection"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Accordingly, for each of the 15 selected bacterial species, 3 sets of 18 questions (1 per proficiency level) were applied, resulting in a total of 810 (18 questions×15 species×3 proficiency levels) individual prompts per ChatGPT model (see File S1).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t42_o6","terms":["15 bacterial species","18 question types","3 proficiency levels","810 prompts per model"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t42_o1","t42_o2","t42_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t42_c1","object":"correctness, consistency, reliability, factual accuracy, and keyword usage of GPT-3.5 and 4.1 mini responses","predicate":"measures_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) evaluates responses generated by ChatGPT models GPT-3.5 and 4.1 mini across correctness, consistency, reliability, factual accuracy, and keyword usage in structured microbiology assessments."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t42_o4","t42_o5","t42_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t42_c2","object":"810 prompts per model (18 question types x 3 proficiency levels x 15 bacterial species relevant to Sri Lanka epidemics and curricula)","predicate":"uses_study_data","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) rests on a dataset of 810 prompts per ChatGPT model (18 standardized question types across low, moderate, and high proficiency levels for 15 bacterial species developed with clinical microbiologists)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13449012.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13449012.txt",5100,10372]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"3ecc883e5224c31d586c57035ea4473a84c012fb79f77e189bd980b89d1e2733","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["f731675a340a549027d112c3a2b5e2f3bcd032403b6abacced3bb9ca08a3d06e","9fbbf73761da3eb8afe948cc879214d3bce0730f225467990b2e76c9e3df8d58","7e4e4731d6fcf5c7517a3bade0b0654be98a2bb8f3f663e7d5191a046cb853f8","e01161766596f85e0b44d7dd8d11eb1fd19fc3c92e79265f735e4f3d80d4c4f7","70b7a3d1e1d12502608394c51abdf3599cf130c0dba63af17cc40057bdb01223","e0b2c00ddf8cdd7d91bdcc69890ea41449955719280bb442d4d1602082699cc9","3caa704bb854a6b6c1dbe03f157310e70b5ba1f29b58dfb89ba387b644aef6ab","3bb73ba1c7e1899b59daf073ce3ff68b97b336b2fb048a326c15bde91060e289"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"e9c9dbae81264f25e76ca735566aaf82e7ce4db6633ec4ee1d38ab8ed4744151","submission_id":"T42-81ecfe50c71524d9#1"},"hash":"527b0c9d41868f4ee2be10f8c56676d7e34f24b0cdb03c7b41704a82f992f6bb","header":{"body_hash":"66dea4ed0b8376b2aac18c853fd0d45635cb9ac124eb642e20560f47dc1f38dc","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"1efdc6f5aaa20a45eace84c40a18ce58d824c8a9049524c916a94da8f762852b","records_root":"4f2ebacd6fb8f04a46c7756c6e60551907f615ce7b091179ccd20b468a195ba0","seq":206,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"b7a2f228aef9675a062274e338f322e617378f68790ff99328e2198eb312e153","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":12,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":23,"task_id":"T42-81ecfe50c71524d9"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13449012.txt#1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3ecc883e5224c31d586c57035ea4473a84c012fb79f77e189bd980b89d1e2733","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"0ebf9bbdaddf2c45b7e8b998cd4a4ddb1ade6d59bbfa1d31a33957034ff67d5c","submission_id":"T42-81ecfe50c71524d9#done2"},"hash":"5d488bc2dc3a140d8ac9f95b9bd57c84c1a25a0f96ef53f2b45a3d1cd2cb91c7","header":{"body_hash":"dccc18b6c9338e6b56bb7c00a20c0e433779ce18f22d0abbeb113420593e1cc7","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"527b0c9d41868f4ee2be10f8c56676d7e34f24b0cdb03c7b41704a82f992f6bb","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":207,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"2e3d01a977b043579f0343f76b92a60fb2b18b7d6f4f1ef98c0c6dd48ebf7388","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T41-76c4a7b1c2a90337","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Source: Europe PMC PMC13449012, doi:10.1099/acmi.0.001137.v5. Licence: CC BY (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Copyright © 2026 The Authors","kind":"observe","local_id":"t41_o1","terms":["PMC13449012 source and 2026 publication metadata"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Title: Assessment of the efficacy of ChatGPT responses to bacterial species-specific questions in microbiology","kind":"observe","local_id":"t41_o2","terms":["article title of PMC13449012"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Objectives. This study focused on evaluating the accuracy of ChatGPT’s responses to general questions on bacterial species and assessing whether the responses included key microbiological terms","kind":"observe","local_id":"t41_o3","terms":["study objectives and measured outcomes"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Questions were designed to reflect interactions at three language proficiency levels, including low, moderate and high.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t41_o4","terms":["three language proficiency levels design"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"A clinical microbiologist finalized a list of 15 bacterial species, each with 18 specific questions of both local and international relevance.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t41_o5","terms":["15 bacterial species with 18 questions each"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"These questions were then prompted to ChatGPT 3.5 and 4.1 mini models, simulating real user interactions.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t41_o6","terms":["ChatGPT 3.5 and 4.1 mini models evaluated"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Responses were evaluated using a microbiology reference guide and categorized as accurate, mixed/incomplete or inaccurate.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t41_o7","terms":["outcome categorization using microbiology reference guide"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Results revealed average scores of 1.5%, 58.1% and 40.4% and 0.5%, 43.2% and 56.3% for inaccurate, mixed/incomplete and accurate answers for 3.5 and 4.1 mini models, respectively.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t41_o8","terms":["main accuracy results for ChatGPT 3.5 and 4.1 mini"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"While high proficiency demonstrated a higher percentage of accurate responses, all other results were either mixed/incomplete or inaccurate.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t41_o9","terms":["high proficiency vs other levels accuracy finding"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Conclusion. Findings suggest that precise questions yielded more accurate responses, while imprecise questions often led to partially correct responses.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t41_o10","terms":["conclusion on question precision and response accuracy"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Notably, ChatGPT 4.1 mini gave clearer and more reliable answers than ChatGPT 3.5.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t41_o11","terms":["conclusion comparing ChatGPT 4.1 mini and 3.5"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"By applying a keyword-based scoring framework rooted in a clinical microbiology reference guide, it reveals how artificial intelligence (AI)-generated answers vary with question specificity","kind":"observe","local_id":"t41_o12","terms":["keyword-based scoring framework in clinical microbiology reference guide"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t41_o1","t41_o2","t41_o4","t41_o5","t41_o6","t41_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t41_c1","object":"15 bacterial species x 18 questions at 3 language proficiency levels prompted to ChatGPT 3.5 and 4.1 mini, scored via a microbiology reference guide","predicate":"rests_on_data_and_design","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13449012","text":"PMC13449012 evaluates ChatGPT 3.5 and 4.1 mini on 18 questions across 15 bacterial species at low, moderate, and high language proficiency levels, scoring answers against a microbiology reference guide."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t41_o1","t41_o3","t41_o7","t41_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t41_c2","object":"response accuracy and key microbiological term inclusion (categorized as accurate, mixed/incomplete, or inaccurate)","predicate":"measures_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13449012","text":"PMC13449012 measures response accuracy and inclusion of key microbiological terms expected in academic/exam settings, categorizing outputs as accurate, mixed/incomplete, or inaccurate."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t41_o1","t41_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t41_c3","object":"ChatGPT 3.5: 1.5% inaccurate, 58.1% mixed/incomplete, 40.4% accurate; ChatGPT 4.1 mini: 0.5% inaccurate, 43.2% mixed/incomplete, 56.3% accurate","predicate":"reports_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13449012","text":"PMC13449012 reports average scores of 1.5% inaccurate, 58.1% mixed/incomplete, and 40.4% accurate for ChatGPT 3.5, versus 0.5% inaccurate, 43.2% mixed/incomplete, and 56.3% accurate for ChatGPT 4.1 mini."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t41_o1","t41_o9","t41_o10","t41_o11"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t41_c4","object":"question precision drives response accuracy; ChatGPT 4.1 mini gives clearer and more reliable answers than ChatGPT 3.5","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13449012","text":"PMC13449012 concludes that precise (high-proficiency) questions yield more accurate responses while imprecise questions often yield mixed/incomplete or inaccurate ones, and ChatGPT 4.1 mini is more reliable than 3.5."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13449012.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13449012.txt",0,5100]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"182dd2a143d9f46c1124918d15e3c4645db0ccb98707e3f093fa3bc4b0d80acc","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["e124f0cfe13c60194e8e51a6815a0d230b226a078fa1c649e8524dfe3389def9","3ab387f8058014025d5d9f4215be1041b7ac7eda7b0121d4f7f50239928caccd","f81dd610436c550dbf8346dca69d6a30ccee8fc4016f63ff79156ed478388116","35350116ecd7743d588f3955a747438ab1d36629558063b882d8f221316093fd","bd04b4d92dad5bf3c682f492aaba3e97777fcc6353614205896f15edc98ff55e","42d0d581cd222e7a17ba78b4f59601c6e63320cf18440084fc5e0fb038efabbe","2757e5e205092872e18d664207ea0bf85e40100f144720e917f5c8573002c407","8bd52cdf8ed158eb41d7bb41af23cafd8d7b752419e1f724cc6980a68ada5c01","4b15401deb94a3656a337ef4b4bcd3422d4d8dff6513b7d3ee2c272809bdb8a6","fedfbf4403eccbc6aba5721bcd788cafa76c7602aae35097d226082100bf1c6f","40316a85dfb10877b9b47aeb66a0e6549427d940f4b72b626704a165a999c1fb","46d7f807604a461933fbc4c6b73750257a3f5fb9092abc843d7cdf04768dadf2","b8ec5b8a00a41702311157b3853d4d765de42091361f64dc0949210800400cc2","757f6603e1315e578fbf6ecf3a69ed96dd0488f0ff2c19f6d4cbe7a507dd2d44","520cbdd383357f51288d0903fa93ed1f71f110d73247353ccc8dd356a4f58fcd","15fa8c6698cd2c96de3d427b8991e0b419fc9105b10b79949556c4a7a17dca2d"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"28faaebeb8f4b6cdc291e9d69c4edd2217c7aa449afce68b17d9376d721a2ad3","submission_id":"T41-76c4a7b1c2a90337#1"},"hash":"04fc2a5f21ae977916b1acc6e9bca3902ac6905fb795675719c339ad2fb37867","header":{"body_hash":"859f3653deb7c7157184aecc05b27832b7cb9e81843a9ab494a43d7b947e3e74","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"5d488bc2dc3a140d8ac9f95b9bd57c84c1a25a0f96ef53f2b45a3d1cd2cb91c7","records_root":"a01e1ae61988a469b4d19c6344b254b321be32b48eece7a9fb9f1fefd7007b15","seq":208,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"d420c53573e666d8930dea8a1c06b82c1bbca8c678ad24b33b3689f214d509bd","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":12,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":23,"task_id":"T41-76c4a7b1c2a90337"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13449012.txt#0","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"182dd2a143d9f46c1124918d15e3c4645db0ccb98707e3f093fa3bc4b0d80acc","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"a21efdaa05207f78a793ebfc21c5a795d0514a63e35eda5f9cae41a8c58ec6c6","submission_id":"T41-76c4a7b1c2a90337#done2"},"hash":"dc17533554824ac1c2ec0b06cd6fb3d849cb7b11deeaa23e282bdd34cc60ee9b","header":{"body_hash":"12fd2ba352cf32a3f253d0937afb1a61a0b3b5f367b3001defee1567fdffc63c","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"04fc2a5f21ae977916b1acc6e9bca3902ac6905fb795675719c339ad2fb37867","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":209,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"b0ed3de2bc437be4891890608a91a98c0748c2aa18768b4127eec858804d8f7a","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":12,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":549},"started_unix_ms":1795102548778,"wave":{"doc:PMC13388837.txt#13":"reader-3","doc:PMC13449012.txt#0":"reader-1","doc:PMC13449012.txt#1":"reader-2"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"182dd2a143d9f46c1124918d15e3c4645db0ccb98707e3f093fa3bc4b0d80acc","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"ad6453a0938ddebcf0e4f6492b09a444886b292d369bc3533212a2c90d277bfb","submission_id":"circle:291afd77772afd60c71356cf02515087e47cf202fea12238020f97b92b05f610"},"hash":"e9532eb6f25d80aeee7a21e8a0ab9615554634d3bec8f910d20976df5d354afe","header":{"body_hash":"df81fc5186444b2509dafaf57f3a5c5198b386c713522d8f569ed16a6318ea0f","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"dc17533554824ac1c2ec0b06cd6fb3d849cb7b11deeaa23e282bdd34cc60ee9b","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":210,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"6ce14fc7b7c5651ee3107d67ff2aa1d5267a6501f8ac62046f21ceef11fcb480","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"b0ed3de2bc437be4891890608a91a98c0748c2aa18768b4127eec858804d8f7a","engine_root":"182dd2a143d9f46c1124918d15e3c4645db0ccb98707e3f093fa3bc4b0d80acc","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"012537c35de7d53f5d36ca9293c62583478e06ef896f1cf795f686d65648870b","log_size":211,"projections":{"dependencies":"9c09966cf6545f4fcc48292e52dd8f365a04ef84e3a5f9016ae85551a40ab050","status":"67913a8d6d401cb50d13f9eae5d460403a1ff012817f14bdaf2c4eb367095529"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"e9532eb6f25d80aeee7a21e8a0ab9615554634d3bec8f910d20976df5d354afe"}},"engine_root":"182dd2a143d9f46c1124918d15e3c4645db0ccb98707e3f093fa3bc4b0d80acc","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"b0ed3de2bc437be4891890608a91a98c0748c2aa18768b4127eec858804d8f7a","engine_root":"182dd2a143d9f46c1124918d15e3c4645db0ccb98707e3f093fa3bc4b0d80acc","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"012537c35de7d53f5d36ca9293c62583478e06ef896f1cf795f686d65648870b","log_size":211,"projections":{"dependencies":"9c09966cf6545f4fcc48292e52dd8f365a04ef84e3a5f9016ae85551a40ab050","status":"67913a8d6d401cb50d13f9eae5d460403a1ff012817f14bdaf2c4eb367095529"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"e9532eb6f25d80aeee7a21e8a0ab9615554634d3bec8f910d20976df5d354afe"},"seal_hash":"d198b7323510f77884eb98829e399b6db8322f5af556443c64441bba9749a416"}},"request_hash":"f050eb0074a3d25cdac657c720a124b9ad2137d3ae79838810c411453f90d851","submission_id":"seal-211"},"hash":"3af936b5bef3243819d07d8639263ff7d10ab5b4c2cc48109bc2750d8de831a7","header":{"body_hash":"4114bb48700350486c52f6c673e9021dc34988e46aedb274d7716194bf0a3da5","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"e9532eb6f25d80aeee7a21e8a0ab9615554634d3bec8f910d20976df5d354afe","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":211,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"4dab76a9d46329da121642f046e2570f14fd6067da99f9f7ef7b2d97d9f853cd","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"epoch":24,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102548778},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"182dd2a143d9f46c1124918d15e3c4645db0ccb98707e3f093fa3bc4b0d80acc","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"01077be948caad594f59ff185b10a3bd84b2529903838218e0985a84c5f32d97","submission_id":"ring-members:9a3a842f20ee7dfb6f99dc2d71789d70f949472d528e35d85c6a6f5bab0e3645"},"hash":"d130c39614bea40f6b1505871ee3f0d2bf509103535368e9f9b37e474a9376ad","header":{"body_hash":"0c8a2009fc24e4ce014de6def739a1ae31c22c2cada294b04cf4c579825c9096","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3af936b5bef3243819d07d8639263ff7d10ab5b4c2cc48109bc2750d8de831a7","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":212,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"301bf4b1c5100134e52811d1aac8b1450c206eee449ab591af7b202205d473ed","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":13,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":549},"started_unix_ms":1795102548812,"wave":{"doc:PMC13449012.txt#2":"reader-1","doc:PMC13449012.txt#3":"reader-2","doc:PMC13449012.txt#4":"reader-3"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"182dd2a143d9f46c1124918d15e3c4645db0ccb98707e3f093fa3bc4b0d80acc","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"faf267b9edb2ce1044209b3901d8144c45898e79cb272e0995ede016c8c2b3b5","submission_id":"circle:c1b966809592a5ed8f628580a132b969af5981cb1b49fa0485514fa2af0d87bb"},"hash":"a54a631c1616505a82a5a6c55f0596f3fb64b8499d8e8b75cdee801e80e22a41","header":{"body_hash":"69cee38ca5e29dd6e7d620820d1d1126e66803195b732434b9a35700f257c76f","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"d130c39614bea40f6b1505871ee3f0d2bf509103535368e9f9b37e474a9376ad","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":213,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"9e19b4316de14b9f0d1ac85503cd1507a8ff4fee73b85c416336da4705d82d6a","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"301bf4b1c5100134e52811d1aac8b1450c206eee449ab591af7b202205d473ed","engine_root":"182dd2a143d9f46c1124918d15e3c4645db0ccb98707e3f093fa3bc4b0d80acc","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"71509e37a02901f5060207167a0e56c47f189b38c4abe3e56ff64a9c28fba0db","log_size":214,"projections":{"dependencies":"9c09966cf6545f4fcc48292e52dd8f365a04ef84e3a5f9016ae85551a40ab050","status":"67913a8d6d401cb50d13f9eae5d460403a1ff012817f14bdaf2c4eb367095529"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"a54a631c1616505a82a5a6c55f0596f3fb64b8499d8e8b75cdee801e80e22a41"}},"engine_root":"182dd2a143d9f46c1124918d15e3c4645db0ccb98707e3f093fa3bc4b0d80acc","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"301bf4b1c5100134e52811d1aac8b1450c206eee449ab591af7b202205d473ed","engine_root":"182dd2a143d9f46c1124918d15e3c4645db0ccb98707e3f093fa3bc4b0d80acc","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"71509e37a02901f5060207167a0e56c47f189b38c4abe3e56ff64a9c28fba0db","log_size":214,"projections":{"dependencies":"9c09966cf6545f4fcc48292e52dd8f365a04ef84e3a5f9016ae85551a40ab050","status":"67913a8d6d401cb50d13f9eae5d460403a1ff012817f14bdaf2c4eb367095529"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"a54a631c1616505a82a5a6c55f0596f3fb64b8499d8e8b75cdee801e80e22a41"},"seal_hash":"51582b647e585a45eed75270ab0d6115236a7d1d1cdd9c4d6a784c89725e4d54"}},"request_hash":"bdd088a12c95922cbc42dafa8ead6891bd665f330fc34d6b4e08e3212420d32e","submission_id":"seal-214"},"hash":"426b2b734922f7a218c4a256eac167445e3a000a4d449b611bdf6e1c54646802","header":{"body_hash":"cfeb814720792bdc9b7ae4afa9f541487d4ae05a41364e3af802d50feba21c72","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"a54a631c1616505a82a5a6c55f0596f3fb64b8499d8e8b75cdee801e80e22a41","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":214,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"500624e29c4fe01702ba5e46accb346a3e67d6e5920ce2017bf7fb57d4ae14cd","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"epoch":25,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102548812},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"182dd2a143d9f46c1124918d15e3c4645db0ccb98707e3f093fa3bc4b0d80acc","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"31c011ee9d9025467d1525a7245b94f343a2f39fc64f0fce75d5a7368fa178d5","submission_id":"ring-members:188af163a0d1eb4d48d7a152f2e879bcf870c78047946a843e6c75971fe35a13"},"hash":"d7b6431eb21415b7183b064ee253ccecebbf39c9e4c82198f5ef2384f8ab81b2","header":{"body_hash":"de423f36e274ec4b8d71b142ea9b9b7b19566b755a71898ffcc41fa5adafcb13","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"426b2b734922f7a218c4a256eac167445e3a000a4d449b611bdf6e1c54646802","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":215,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"81a263cfe60d9471a38aff58e1f6a34aa749912f2ad04e3def4cfd09820a7f95","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T44-945c11646cbb9ca5","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Comparing the three prompts in ChatGPT version 3.5 and version 4.1, the Friedman test gives the P-value of 0.288 and 0.980 (Table 3), suggesting that there is no statistically significant difference between these three prompts at 5% level of significance for both versions.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t44_o1","terms":["Friedman test","prompt comparison","ChatGPT 3.5","ChatGPT 4.1","no statistically significant difference"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"According to the Kruskal–Wallis test for both models, low proficiency level obtained a low mean rank (284.08 for ChatGPT 3.5 and 319.38 for ChatGPT 4.1 mini), while the high proficiency level obtained a high mean rank (523.36 for ChatGPT 3.5 and 492.54 for ChatGPT 4.1 mini).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t44_o2","terms":["Kruskal-Wallis test","proficiency level","mean rank","ChatGPT 3.5","ChatGPT 4.1 mini"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The P-values show (P<0.001) highly statistically significant differences among the three proficiency levels for both models. Furthermore, these results indicate that user proficiency level has a substantial impact on the accuracy and quality of responses generated by both ChatGPT versions.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t44_o3","terms":["proficiency level differences","P<0.001","response accuracy","response quality"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"A statistical comparison of the average scores between the two versions (Table 3) revealed a highly significant difference, with ChatGPT 4.1 mini (Z=−10.2, P<0.001) demonstrating notably better performance than ChatGPT 3.5, highlighting a marked improvement in response accuracy and quality","kind":"observe","local_id":"t44_o4","terms":["ChatGPT 4.1 mini vs ChatGPT 3.5","average scores","Z=-10.2","P<0.001","performance comparison"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Score range | ChatGPT 3.5 (%) | ChatGPT 4.1 mini (%)\n\n0–1 | 1.98% | 1.11%\n\n1–2 | 7.16% | 4.07%\n\n2–3 | 21.11% | 12.10%\n\n3–4 | 21.98% | 17.90%\n\n4–5 | 47.78% | 64.81%","kind":"observe","local_id":"t44_o5","terms":["Table 4","average score distribution","ChatGPT 3.5","ChatGPT 4.1 mini"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The comparative analysis between ChatGPT version 3.5 and GPT-4.1 mini revealed that while both models performed well in answering bacterial species-specific microbiology questions, GPT-4.1 mini demonstrated more consistent and reliable performance across all proficiency levels.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t44_o6","terms":["bacterial species-specific microbiology questions","ChatGPT 3.5","GPT-4.1 mini","consistent performance"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Both models performed well overall, with average scores above 3.5 out of 5. However, GPT-4.1 mini exhibited lower variability in responses, indicating a more stable and predictable output quality.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t44_o7","terms":["average scores above 3.5 out of 5","response variability","output quality"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Therefore, the possibility that contextual memory effects influenced later responses within the same session should also be considered. Consequently, improvements observed across proficiency levels may partly reflect contextual carryover effects in addition to the intrinsic performance of the model.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t44_o8","terms":["contextual memory effects","session carryover","proficiency level improvement qualification"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t44_o1"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t44_c1","object":"no significant difference across three prompts for ChatGPT 3.5 (P=0.288) or 4.1 (P=0.980)","predicate":"concludes_prompt_comparison","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) finds no statistically significant difference across the three prompt types for either ChatGPT 3.5 (Friedman P=0.288) or ChatGPT 4.1 (P=0.980) at the 5% level."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t44_o2","t44_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t44_c2","object":"highly significant differences across three proficiency levels (P<0.001) for ChatGPT 3.5 and 4.1 mini","predicate":"concludes_proficiency_effect","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) concludes that user proficiency level significantly impacts response accuracy and quality (Kruskal-Wallis P<0.001), with mean ranks rising from low (3.5: 284.08; 4.1 mini: 319.38) to high (523.36; 492.54)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t44_o4","t44_o5","t44_o6","t44_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t44_c3","object":"ChatGPT 4.1 mini outperforms ChatGPT 3.5 (Z=-10.2, P<0.001; 64.81% vs 47.78% in 4-5 score range; both >3.5/5 overall)","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) concludes that ChatGPT 4.1 mini performs significantly better than ChatGPT 3.5 (Z=-10.2, P<0.001) on bacterial species-specific microbiology questions, achieving 64.81% vs 47.78% of average scores in the 4-5 range."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t44_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t44_c4","object":"proficiency-level performance gains may partly reflect within-session contextual carryover effects","predicate":"qualifies_conclusions","stance":"qualified","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) qualifies the observed performance improvements across proficiency levels by noting they may partly reflect within-session contextual memory carryover effects rather than solely intrinsic model performance."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13449012.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13449012.txt",22288,27474]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"5adb0ca7fac333c3b5929fbf6dcee9ed5099b2ee3048634d9e1548b34282dad8","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["639c93d8c7469d049575b3437dcf33f2c46432ab0f402c66c545e7bf32a50c9d","f34566341285af094bf3d17c09e5a71a4a48ab7c8b1b65d8d70d4e0bd3cdb5f3","1ffcd9c7a419a3025e0b3f8ef2ae26395251acea937a6201169f51ab89520065","3c8784a5b855170f811a0336315528e2f15fa843f2986b67a081a454dc35149a","212ebd7f32241a5dfd2ac608b816747a7ba0ead90220145f6f98d04b1676ab5f","c9d22d0eeea05ce10eaf5450010966db8c15ac0c315bb44bb165cc7f1c8b2651","e5a028efb2107b7fccf87ff9616fbcc360adbdd776db3dc537b86c08b0f3013d","12efabe28f30f157ec3786f2a2da0becf6215d87cb2805e98577e49604cb2c6b","cd501828dc0547c11e08e73409372f8a06db27df8b36e60b345f45aac548fb8a","0d4f47dd7cc213bfc377b037616c2bdd1fbf4b916a8edae15ca4980717738bcb"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":10}},"request_hash":"771fd584a73154f98824f07772d12361223d79892d70cf3bd1452655a4641531","submission_id":"T44-945c11646cbb9ca5#1"},"hash":"8755edb5d8bb5d4e71c7b71c757e2e2abb29880a7d019e022971dec32ee62444","header":{"body_hash":"70e9ed375c1928feb857f5cda0a61bc71fcb2ca2201781714caf1c4428c261c0","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"d7b6431eb21415b7183b064ee253ccecebbf39c9e4c82198f5ef2384f8ab81b2","records_root":"51a98c5ffa36c6608d46157856ae91041d14d0445c90ab92563096fb337b06d7","seq":216,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"aa762c8313509dd1c090cd544bd87cd5e4d9fdc2913c559a4a39be0911b01652","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T44-945c11646cbb9ca5","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t44_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t44_c4","object":"proficiency-level performance gains may partly reflect within-session contextual carryover effects","predicate":"qualifies_conclusions","stance":"qualified","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) qualifies the observed performance improvements across proficiency levels by noting they may partly reflect within-session contextual memory carryover effects rather than solely intrinsic model performance."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13449012.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13449012.txt",22288,27474]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"5adb0ca7fac333c3b5929fbf6dcee9ed5099b2ee3048634d9e1548b34282dad8","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["3348f2072123585da98e6b14d7912cb6dbe164b71b7bf4b46c0532c2af10a94e"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"a9fa86b4c060a4a028f27e1eea607c1b12f023a3f3f7e6d34513c9574426350e","submission_id":"T44-945c11646cbb9ca5#1.1"},"hash":"f21d74c21634fe730b97f33a679c3a7dbdc9358dab45d301b478041818149869","header":{"body_hash":"6fc4c1b7831ddcf3950855282f7fae6c178acd97397ec83555ea17ee79aa4b0b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"8755edb5d8bb5d4e71c7b71c757e2e2abb29880a7d019e022971dec32ee62444","records_root":"35148f49b9e47e1ae281dccc6f5d406d95b3284841b2a2025beb926151178aa4","seq":217,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"937fe68bddeffd0d010d24a1cdcffaefa42e6ac6941da1a19d45169a131fff03","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@639c93d8c7469d04","@f34566341285af09","@1ffcd9c7a419a302","@3c8784a5b855170f","@212ebd7f32241a5d","@c9d22d0eeea05ce1","@e5a028efb2107b7f","@12efabe28f30f157","@cd501828dc0547c1","@0d4f47dd7cc213bf","@3348f2072123585d"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":10,"local_id":"t44_c3"}],"task_id":"T44-945c11646cbb9ca5","work_key":"doc:PMC13449012.txt#4"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T44-945c11646cbb9ca5:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"5adb0ca7fac333c3b5929fbf6dcee9ed5099b2ee3048634d9e1548b34282dad8","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"7bcfa039cb2a980e7979a876164f1cfdf6c85256100777c06f4a3171301094a5","submission_id":"T44-945c11646cbb9ca5#repair1"},"hash":"53d503bf84d3da765382beaf386dd85d8d39fac6f9fa5eb01f6c68df2a22399f","header":{"body_hash":"af8fc3d37fbb96afa5ff728ee97cf73a7903c16f6e3a4db43abac44be6ae1273","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"f21d74c21634fe730b97f33a679c3a7dbdc9358dab45d301b478041818149869","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":218,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"61f64bd8162dc176ea046f9e831ab2560144e87363f9be4d32489d0570bcb2e1","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T45-813e16ff1d0fe197","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"This replication was performed for all 18 standardized questions across 15 bacterial species, resulting in a total of 810 responses analysed per ChatGPT version.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t45_o1","terms":["sample size","810 responses per ChatGPT version","18 questions across 15 bacterial species"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Therefore, GPT-3.5 and GPT-4.1 mini were selected as the most practical and consistent models for this study. Responses were collected in February 2024 for GPT-3.5 and in April 2025 for GPT-4.1 mini.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t45_o2","terms":["ChatGPT models evaluated","data collection dates","GPT-3.5","GPT-4.1 mini"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Correctness was evaluated using the 18th edition of the Medical Microbiology Guide [29], which served as the reference standard.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t45_o3","terms":["reference standard","Medical Microbiology Guide 18th edition","correctness evaluation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The qualitative assessment considered correctness, clarity and contextual relevance of responses.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t45_o4","terms":["qualitative outcomes measured","correctness","clarity","contextual relevance"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Quantitative analysis assessed response completeness using a keyword-based scoring system.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t45_o5","terms":["quantitative outcome measured","response completeness","keyword-based scoring system"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Hence, for each question, key microbiological terms were identified based on the Medical Microbiology Guide (Greenwood et al., 18th edition).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t45_o6","terms":["keyword source","Greenwood et al. 18th edition","Medical Microbiology Guide"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The raw score defined as the number of matched keywords was then converted into a 0–5-point scale (see supplementary files – Excel file).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t45_o7","terms":["0-5-point scale","matched keywords","scoring conversion"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Responses scoring 0 were considered inaccurate, those scoring between 1 and <5 were classified as mixed or partially complete, and responses scoring exactly 5 were classified as fully accurate.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t45_o8","terms":["accuracy classification thresholds","0-5 scale categories"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"A total of 810 responses were evaluated for each version of ChatGPT (3.5 and 4.1 mini) across 3 systematically designed prompts.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t45_o9","terms":["3 prompts","user proficiency levels","810 responses per model"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"ChatGPT 4.1 mini demonstrated superior performance across all prompts, with an overall mean score of 4.216 compared to 3.794 for ChatGPT 3.5.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t45_o10","terms":["main result","ChatGPT 4.1 mini vs 3.5 overall mean score"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The lower standard deviation for ChatGPT 4.1 mini (1.09) relative to ChatGPT 3.5 (1.28) suggests greater consistency in response quality.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t45_o11","terms":["response consistency","standard deviation comparison"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"| Parameter | ChatGPT 3.5 | ChatGPT 4.1 mini","kind":"observe","local_id":"t45_o12","terms":["Table 1 header","ChatGPT 3.5","ChatGPT 4.1 mini"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Overall average (mean±sd) | 3.79±1.23 | 4.22±1.09","kind":"observe","local_id":"t45_o13","terms":["Table 1 overall average","mean and standard deviation"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t45_o1","t45_o2","t45_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t45_c1","object":"810 responses per model (GPT-3.5 and GPT-4.1 mini) to 18 questions across 15 bacterial species at 3 proficiency levels","predicate":"collects_data_from","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) evaluates 810 responses per model from GPT-3.5 (collected Feb 2024) and GPT-4.1 mini (Apr 2025) across 18 questions on 15 bacterial species at 3 proficiency levels, triplicated by 3 users."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t45_o3","t45_o4","t45_o5","t45_o6","t45_o7","t45_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t45_c2","object":"response completeness (0-5 keyword score) and qualitative correctness, clarity, and contextual relevance using Medical Microbiology Guide (18th ed.)","predicate":"measures_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) measures response completeness quantitatively on a 0–5 keyword-matching scale and assesses correctness, clarity, and contextual relevance qualitatively against the Medical Microbiology Guide (Greenwood et al., 18th ed.)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t45_o10","t45_o11","t45_o12","t45_o13"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t45_c3","object":"ChatGPT 4.1 mini outperformed ChatGPT 3.5 across all prompts (mean 4.216 vs 3.794; SD 1.09 vs 1.28 / Table 1: 4.22±1.09 vs 3.79±1.23)","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) concludes that ChatGPT 4.1 mini outperformed ChatGPT 3.5 across all prompts in accuracy, completeness, and consistency, with a higher overall mean score (4.216 vs 3.794; Table 1: 4.22±1.09 vs 3.79±1.23) and lower SD."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13449012.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13449012.txt",10372,16328]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"990afd8a7b6e58a86c087553b00bd56fc5f9e6c1ab79d892c0413db78df70f35","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["5596676a8a46b339cf77b2486b06edbabd95dcf32d1df51513ee5566c68736ea","c5b02214d8cd39ee8e80628221d15ee3d8f498a3a447689676485e0863701ad2","189ee54ebee9b362faa425d13473ac0f050525e9eba0c6232309e7cdd0b20370","274899ad4823f41e761530c40d8efb278151f4af46c84c124d2c0ba13a4eaef6","873401bdb3b3122f2d56188b56a28f12096cec509ed4e22f47a263c8c3d49b05","f66eb8139e2fba686e519ecaf7d36559daaaf2663d78fe4e4e451ee222d70600","dfd5eddfad0e71c102db9efcda18f8ea39bee10c604087102f649bc2ffb9cad0","955cf60df01c85676fd2f91dd4854c65db792c8f317a10401d1d5c4e62a841a8","207e395f764f89f4bfd626924294293d7a4a9d1d4e94185aa6ef51ad521b9a91","bc0350f535c72e3753a6081622cd8ff160f83bd07a2067d68ba905d039420b5f","8eed9fbdfba0472d67af6722a4fac7ccaec11dab7fafb19301cb5a77d022b446","bc287469642e6e2d18e0bd6414f1a85b20c9991fbf9d0d6d7baacb23f360a835","d2c1665c1bf6367889fb46710faa10819a3fd449b698dbca1951798014d99d85","30c486961e073e51e6b5a897aca41b3a190549a1dc5b738aeff26cf68a28c481"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":14}},"request_hash":"4b632ac6ddd0bb14e55ce1de6810eab212664d0759f742c88d6f274570c07e61","submission_id":"T45-813e16ff1d0fe197#1"},"hash":"8c5117d4699f1802750ba2347dfb2094462da05a15d1629d681018372aceb871","header":{"body_hash":"a27b587650e22530c8ce0f7e55f3f6696bfe10d13af902e5f1673a281fae17b6","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"53d503bf84d3da765382beaf386dd85d8d39fac6f9fa5eb01f6c68df2a22399f","records_root":"433e31919b555cfd6bf929cce85d245b2e4faf1e75cd09a57af95e3f986ac923","seq":219,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"d8f9a72199b1abdbbf75145695b57ab57c7feb19c3a96ebff576fb0ba47d3835","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T45-813e16ff1d0fe197","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t45_o10","t45_o11","t45_o12","t45_o13"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t45_c3","object":"ChatGPT 4.1 mini outperformed ChatGPT 3.5 across all prompts (mean 4.216 vs 3.794; SD 1.09 vs 1.28 / Table 1: 4.22±1.09 vs 3.79±1.23)","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) concludes that ChatGPT 4.1 mini outperformed ChatGPT 3.5 across all prompts in accuracy, completeness, and consistency, with a higher overall mean score (4.216 vs 3.794; Table 1: 4.22±1.09 vs 3.79±1.23) and lower SD."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13449012.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13449012.txt",10372,16328]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"990afd8a7b6e58a86c087553b00bd56fc5f9e6c1ab79d892c0413db78df70f35","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":[],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":0}},"request_hash":"26394ce8c7aa279bda1e0870ce13b4a20fd5827b6f7d230b31f921ba72c6196b","submission_id":"T45-813e16ff1d0fe197#1.1"},"hash":"61d538d55e43f9fdfc498251998eef2270337f21f27280d7f105ef365ce9152e","header":{"body_hash":"312ec13c7027bb3ad024c7760e0727498290be9d03cac4f12df50878d500902b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"8c5117d4699f1802750ba2347dfb2094462da05a15d1629d681018372aceb871","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":220,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"1441c998007eaa0f4d8acb5176e18ab48ffb16639649153b4cd5ca2031532f3d","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@5596676a8a46b339","@c5b02214d8cd39ee","@189ee54ebee9b362","@274899ad4823f41e","@873401bdb3b3122f","@f66eb8139e2fba68","@dfd5eddfad0e71c1","@955cf60df01c8567","@207e395f764f89f4","@bc0350f535c72e37","@8eed9fbdfba0472d","@bc287469642e6e2d","@d2c1665c1bf63678","@30c486961e073e51"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":14,"local_id":"t45_c2"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":15,"local_id":"t45_c3"}],"task_id":"T45-813e16ff1d0fe197","work_key":"doc:PMC13449012.txt#2"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T45-813e16ff1d0fe197:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"990afd8a7b6e58a86c087553b00bd56fc5f9e6c1ab79d892c0413db78df70f35","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"d8e108089a7355af36247b5d7bfdcaf4c5568850873bfcd1ab18ba923207eedc","submission_id":"T45-813e16ff1d0fe197#repair1"},"hash":"53eb477129137c08d366689318e974395d09e6c78778372a274ebc24b84d70bc","header":{"body_hash":"45bc1ae3cc89d11764b6521f4da0cdd3cc192e7f2faa17f196f4f77f8450143e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"61d538d55e43f9fdfc498251998eef2270337f21f27280d7f105ef365ce9152e","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":221,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"df33f95179bff6004671f832f54578cf8b16e6599da2e9d0815b9a3f151e6725","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T44-945c11646cbb9ca5","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t44_o4","t44_o5","t44_o6","t44_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t44_c3","object":"ChatGPT 4.1 mini outperforms ChatGPT 3.5 (Z=-10.2, P<0.001; 64.81% vs 47.78% in 4-5 score range; both >3.5/5 overall)","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) concludes that ChatGPT 4.1 mini performs significantly better than ChatGPT 3.5 (Z=-10.2, P<0.001) on bacterial microbiology questions, with 64.81% vs 47.78% of average scores in the 4-5 range."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13449012.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13449012.txt",22288,27474]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"990afd8a7b6e58a86c087553b00bd56fc5f9e6c1ab79d892c0413db78df70f35","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["e58cb5715f3a2dd5580c95472017fcdd116d5f54417401a2c266719799198e58"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"c3bdd03b71316fe442b29fba93ec36a77206467dbbdc58c5f68468fa2d023c83","submission_id":"T44-945c11646cbb9ca5#2"},"hash":"786f8cfb719d835a2a92bc35d3e37418422de3b93d59727839c585338cf2de5e","header":{"body_hash":"be13bb5be85ac4d231b5c0be85531504b6b66d14b5f6c98c18ece7ae19eeb7fd","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"53eb477129137c08d366689318e974395d09e6c78778372a274ebc24b84d70bc","records_root":"70a5638a0ca21c668ff97e0edcdc4d3dd8b37731c851b55abd6e9d785d3b7ebe","seq":222,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"c27425fef7dac6ffd04b52ea07c45733d2e16dceecfa718c54499b0e34c632a1","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":false,"agent":"reader-3","circle":13,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":12,"refusals":1,"stored":12,"sync_step":25,"task_id":"T44-945c11646cbb9ca5"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13449012.txt#4","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"990afd8a7b6e58a86c087553b00bd56fc5f9e6c1ab79d892c0413db78df70f35","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"60a85217f987f88b439a62ba8750ced0d8ed1dda0c784b35eb7824e62cded778","submission_id":"T44-945c11646cbb9ca5#done3"},"hash":"8d140b65ce6f027d984601983b8a77db1dad302b140f8cf0f4c02327cfae1577","header":{"body_hash":"361b0da16e0c2deb6ec3d87d4718eb023e29d0425021c340b0b37a655275be72","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"786f8cfb719d835a2a92bc35d3e37418422de3b93d59727839c585338cf2de5e","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":223,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"a18966ff42155813d39ff6421f5c93ae7e9f127b6c15b3c3ef1378fa02374505","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T46-5343ac4cae1ebf1b","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Model performance across proficiency levels | Low proficiency (mean±sd) | 3.08±1.37 | 3.75±1.27","kind":"observe","local_id":"t46_o1","terms":["low proficiency mean and SD scores for ChatGPT 3.5 and ChatGPT 4.1 mini"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Moderate proficiency (mean±sd) | 3.83±1.04 | 4.24±1.01","kind":"observe","local_id":"t46_o2","terms":["moderate proficiency mean and SD scores for ChatGPT 3.5 and ChatGPT 4.1 mini"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"High proficiency (mean±sd) | 4.46±0.81 | 4.65±0.72","kind":"observe","local_id":"t46_o3","terms":["high proficiency mean and SD scores for ChatGPT 3.5 and ChatGPT 4.1 mini"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The results show that ChatGPT 4.1 mini consistently achieved higher mean scores with lower standard deviations compared to ChatGPT 3.5, indicating more accurate and consistent performance.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t46_o4","terms":["ChatGPT 4.1 mini outperformed ChatGPT 3.5 in mean accuracy and consistency"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"both models achieved the maximum score of 5.00 during the prompting by all three users (User 1, User 2 and User 3)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t46_o5","terms":["maximum score 5.00 across three users"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"yet also recorded a minimum score of 0.00, revealing that both versions occasionally generated completely inaccurate responses.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t46_o6","terms":["minimum score 0.00 for both models"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The median and mode values for ChatGPT 4.1 mini were uniformly 5.00 across all prompts, further supporting the interpretation that this version delivered more consistently high-scoring responses.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t46_o7","terms":["median and mode of 5.00 for ChatGPT 4.1 mini"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"All prompts for both ChatGPT 3.5 and ChatGPT 4.1 mini yielded P-values less than 0.001, confirming statistically significant deviations from normality in all cases (Table 3).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t46_o8","terms":["normality testing P < 0.001 for all prompts"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"| Statistic | ChatGPT 3.5 | ChatGPT 4.1 mini\n\nFriedman test (prompt variation) | Sample size (N) | 810 | 810\n\nChi-square (χ²) | 2.489 | 0.041\n\ndf | 2 | 2\n\nP-value | 0.288 | 0.980","kind":"observe","local_id":"t46_o9","terms":["Friedman test sample size N=810, chi-square, df, and P-values"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Kruskal–Wallis test (proficiency level differences) | Chi-square (χ²) | 151.519 | 90.097\n\nMean rank – low proficiency | 284.08 | 319.38\n\nMean rank – high proficiency | 523.36 | 492.54","kind":"observe","local_id":"t46_o10","terms":["Kruskal-Wallis chi-square and mean ranks across proficiency levels"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The Friedman test showed no statistically significant variation (P>0.05) across the three replicated user prompts, indicating consistent model performance regardless of the user or device.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t46_o11","terms":["no significant variation across three replicated user prompts"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"In contrast, the Kruskal–Wallis test revealed highly significant differences across proficiency levels for both models (P<0.001), with mean rank scores increasing from low to high proficiency.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t46_o12","terms":["Kruskal-Wallis P < 0.001 differences across proficiency levels"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"These results confirm that technical complexity and structured question design strongly influence the accuracy of ChatGPT-generated microbiology responses.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t46_o13","terms":["conclusion that technical complexity and structured design influence microbiology response accuracy"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t46_o1","t46_o2","t46_o3","t46_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t46_c1","object":"ChatGPT 4.1 mini vs ChatGPT 3.5 mean±SD: low 3.75±1.27 vs 3.08±1.37; moderate 4.24±1.01 vs 3.83±1.04; high 4.65±0.72 vs 4.46±0.81","predicate":"reports_proficiency_scores","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13449012","text":"PMC13449012 reports that ChatGPT 4.1 mini achieved higher mean accuracy scores and lower SDs than ChatGPT 3.5 across low (3.75±1.27 vs 3.08±1.37), moderate (4.24±1.01 vs 3.83±1.04), and high (4.65±0.72 vs 4.46±0.81) proficiency prompts."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t46_o5","t46_o6","t46_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t46_c2","object":"0.00 to 5.00 response accuracy score across Users 1–3; ChatGPT 4.1 mini median and mode uniformly 5.00","predicate":"measures_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13449012","text":"PMC13449012 reports that on a 0.00–5.00 accuracy scale across three users (Users 1–3), both models recorded scores from 0.00 to 5.00, while ChatGPT 4.1 mini had a uniform median and mode of 5.00 across all prompts."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t46_o9","t46_o11"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t46_c3","object":"no significant variation across 3 user prompts (N=810; ChatGPT 3.5 χ²=2.489, P=0.288; ChatGPT 4.1 mini χ²=0.041, P=0.980)","predicate":"concludes_user_consistency","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13449012","text":"PMC13449012 concludes from Friedman tests (N=810 per model) that neither ChatGPT 3.5 (χ²=2.489, df=2, P=0.288) nor ChatGPT 4.1 mini (χ²=0.041, df=2, P=0.980) showed significant variation across the three replicated user prompts."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t46_o8","t46_o10","t46_o12","t46_o13"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t46_c4","object":"significant accuracy gain from low to high prompt proficiency (P<0.001; χ²=151.519 for 3.5, χ²=90.097 for 4.1 mini)","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13449012","text":"PMC13449012 concludes from Kruskal–Wallis tests that accuracy differs significantly across proficiency levels for ChatGPT 3.5 (χ²=151.519, P<0.001; mean rank 284.08 to 523.36) and ChatGPT 4.1 mini (χ²=90.097, P<0.001; 319.38 to 492.54)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13449012.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13449012.txt",16328,22288]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"1d51403b09e411f21733b401e71420a7c983b5566b04a4ea9044de34a9df76c0","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["0c38a3431a3c492715096e0002336a5f0bffc881d51006125a0f1a516d5aedc4","7f21abcfe857d0aa7db440127e23f8d27596f24dad2f22c89ca7534ebb7ccaf5","1ba16f457c757eda8b3a72376858f5800af94160298060db3d1f3b923c407b61","be04952221ce09afafc685e40e8f7b6789d6f842024903b4353ae0b2aa2bd132","6d0c32d3c734fc10ceb52f9fc259e1882c1f7848e056478f7954a1eb43dc315a","5f1c35a08b2ac6fc579eb5217fa9cd0556fa967a2e29911cab6b893a18b3fdc0","b60466e1479c5c82255f6e7c76b89703341f2cacf6c7882edcfb2a502b74f768","eecebf3955e6a6f3d4247d2c3bf17b64934995c3386deae779ddcbf13ab62fb2","17640e518001d72e2b4a1588865094706279b6c4120e10a58145c3f23234f01c","86d3e30655b07eada4d90ebe241375ad003945a7b7b30fd0fdacb710cff5feff","dcb1050604203e09173d157863a64b0b133e62a25052924647606314823981a1","2244884a8871d2dd314bb49494af368eb1d160e46abecbfbf261024045c313c5","4a137cb7d345e0877c43e7c57a0f4f7277819b8d536d2598f091e7f874327a80","290422e6ce10e7b1eafebd50857f7083aa20edc3c1a92082d5fad78141f10ea7","0cb23350225e4d22870d570b42f530e77bdda34ebfb8dbcf4490d13e2144a8aa","245f0de7532acff390ed2843c086bf6004432126a5469d12522e5ab84165bf9d","5f39a0c541abab0d84dc8a7b62adc18db22d5d388b7aebabcd2a107ea39aa2a4"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"9e0293b0d9436b2ff8c2dfae16686d8640d7bc62b4076394f403aaaebba2b0f9","submission_id":"T46-5343ac4cae1ebf1b#1"},"hash":"200fcbdc9b347c9433155b58b7928a208cd29bde1413fa4af479a762fc51ca4e","header":{"body_hash":"7cdfbe844c5b231d5392f48c942549fe136a376b6c8bcd3c63f262f757e97e7e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"8d140b65ce6f027d984601983b8a77db1dad302b140f8cf0f4c02327cfae1577","records_root":"eeb2708aeb44c4bbbec0da53aaa1215758f18c8dee70924eb2d063ea5def85e3","seq":224,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"60dbc5aed168f63d917c91d2ae7df50c0821722349ad11e911f48a41c6b3c549","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":13,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":25,"task_id":"T46-5343ac4cae1ebf1b"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13449012.txt#3","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"1d51403b09e411f21733b401e71420a7c983b5566b04a4ea9044de34a9df76c0","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"6307d2875627907e7fdc5ae96283e42d7f7237003c65f9705292658ab1aaac64","submission_id":"T46-5343ac4cae1ebf1b#done2"},"hash":"9647aee6de81a46bf2bd7329ced1787efef376bebf42c4da2862398d87aeaa79","header":{"body_hash":"ff95db1c97ecb1f7e68867506a47f308aa4c24bebaebb58aeda7109e647cd77b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"200fcbdc9b347c9433155b58b7928a208cd29bde1413fa4af479a762fc51ca4e","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":225,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"26f33b6075c514161234602b5ff0fa387e64def35169f18c5551f8d48b0ffaea","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T45-813e16ff1d0fe197","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t45_o3","t45_o4","t45_o5","t45_o6","t45_o7","t45_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t45_c2","object":"response completeness (0-5 keyword score) and qualitative correctness, clarity, and contextual relevance using Medical Microbiology Guide (18th ed.)","predicate":"measures_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) measures response completeness quantitatively on a 0–5 keyword scale and assesses correctness, clarity, and contextual relevance qualitatively against the Medical Microbiology Guide (Greenwood et al., 18th ed.)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t45_o10","t45_o11","t45_o12","t45_o13"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t45_c3","object":"ChatGPT 4.1 mini outperformed ChatGPT 3.5 across all prompts (mean 4.216 vs 3.794; SD 1.09 vs 1.28 / Table 1: 4.22±1.09 vs 3.79±1.23)","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) concludes that ChatGPT 4.1 mini outperformed ChatGPT 3.5 across all prompts in accuracy, completeness, and consistency, with a higher overall mean score (4.216 vs 3.794; Table 1: 4.22±1.09 vs 3.79±1.23) and lower SD."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13449012.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13449012.txt",10372,16328]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"1d51403b09e411f21733b401e71420a7c983b5566b04a4ea9044de34a9df76c0","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["b408df101260846b3c033715fdd6502f72c5e2b82328179ce19ae78543e33ee5"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":1}},"request_hash":"f187518b22688d8e0c0758e426b5f6561c563ad4734b483d96c94703b6572ccc","submission_id":"T45-813e16ff1d0fe197#2"},"hash":"5c3a0815cc3b975d16d4e7214aac993eaeeeb6d9343332d0625eb11e41ecf578","header":{"body_hash":"e905b5a4d6ac8c3767416b28e5baf19f2ce00fe8f1408f48d670abadea1596a0","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"9647aee6de81a46bf2bd7329ced1787efef376bebf42c4da2862398d87aeaa79","records_root":"be1088a91f64942910a6236ef8f63fc19b55aa2202b46f4ceccd9a7baf6317bc","seq":226,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"1e5f41b117089e4fd8c11c907b499160975ede5e16f71d22815dd5ae9e76e812","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@b408df101260846b"],"attempt":2,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":1,"local_id":"t45_c3"}],"task_id":"T45-813e16ff1d0fe197","work_key":"doc:PMC13449012.txt#2"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T45-813e16ff1d0fe197:2","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"1d51403b09e411f21733b401e71420a7c983b5566b04a4ea9044de34a9df76c0","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"dba15cebb61131fcf15efac21b970ad89974ba7747b7c10556b7face72cc2573","submission_id":"T45-813e16ff1d0fe197#repair2"},"hash":"22b96d9a57a966ba45eb4b44a750dcebe17fd5a8bfb50ab22a6fb4539382fb79","header":{"body_hash":"187f0666ceecd68e03ee5a0acc579b510110c339d8e01e7d2a3e0864b4d193f0","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"5c3a0815cc3b975d16d4e7214aac993eaeeeb6d9343332d0625eb11e41ecf578","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":227,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"bfba4f958949a2c86904da029c131959c6d22070917ae627dce83794127284d9","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T45-813e16ff1d0fe197","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t45_o10","t45_o11","t45_o12","t45_o13"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t45_c3","object":"ChatGPT 4.1 mini outperformed ChatGPT 3.5 across all prompts (mean 4.216 vs 3.794; SD 1.09 vs 1.28 / Table 1: 4.22±1.09 vs 3.79±1.23)","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) concludes that ChatGPT 4.1 mini outperformed ChatGPT 3.5 across all prompts in accuracy, completeness, and consistency, with a higher overall mean score (4.216 vs 3.794; Table 1: 4.22±1.09 vs 3.79±1.23)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13449012.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13449012.txt",10372,16328]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"1d51403b09e411f21733b401e71420a7c983b5566b04a4ea9044de34a9df76c0","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["dfca6ea813dff69d4c1fd00d08c57a459f301100608067050f5abef38c911c5a"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"2f2dddfde03249a9a3346836cc46f3b704e92ed32c35b1d76388e4fa0fbbc025","submission_id":"T45-813e16ff1d0fe197#3"},"hash":"e02781e7d36ba22b0ab5b158771ea4e1d75e5301b44691f74e1b40d93879a7c7","header":{"body_hash":"88e7db3af0c7da89b0b49a50760f32f209d5dcd5bd500b817bb463233d7133bf","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"22b96d9a57a966ba45eb4b44a750dcebe17fd5a8bfb50ab22a6fb4539382fb79","records_root":"d07085b17bc1433b3ff3f63771496693da1da464b3b6dbd82d452fc32b0d447f","seq":228,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"9bd185e3c6520dfe7d1d0fda7056151011dfee07ee7e404cd5a7e1d05301c34f","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":false,"agent":"reader-1","circle":13,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":16,"refusals":2,"stored":16,"sync_step":25,"task_id":"T45-813e16ff1d0fe197"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13449012.txt#2","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"1d51403b09e411f21733b401e71420a7c983b5566b04a4ea9044de34a9df76c0","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"9f3ada8f3df390636672c61537da54341485d82386e9d7c24f3d816d2d1b145c","submission_id":"T45-813e16ff1d0fe197#done4"},"hash":"bff1daa9489a8f02de4572a86a630ec5766458167cd75ead7b4de25d6d25911b","header":{"body_hash":"077c06dcefdb49fab93d1b2ca12f4ded4260d2bd60af87dac40b992da29c7b22","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"e02781e7d36ba22b0ab5b158771ea4e1d75e5301b44691f74e1b40d93879a7c7","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":229,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"6222cb111880dc3228c86e281906b2f8024a21f336f8549d22a6d08d27aec9c0","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR47-53a1de7694d50187","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Comparing the three prompts in ChatGPT version 3.5 and version 4.1, the Friedman test gives the P-value of 0.288 and 0.980 (Table 3), suggesting that there is no statistically significant difference between these three prompts at 5% level of significance for both versions.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t47_o1","terms":["Friedman test","prompt comparison","ChatGPT 3.5","ChatGPT 4.1"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"According to the Kruskal–Wallis test for both models, low proficiency level obtained a low mean rank (284.08 for ChatGPT 3.5 and 319.38 for ChatGPT 4.1 mini), while the high proficiency level obtained a high mean rank (523.36 for ChatGPT 3.5 and 492.54 for ChatGPT 4.1 mini).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t47_o2","terms":["Kruskal-Wallis test","proficiency level","mean rank","ChatGPT 3.5","ChatGPT 4.1 mini"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The P-values show (P<0.001) highly statistically significant differences among the three proficiency levels for both models.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t47_o3","terms":["proficiency level","statistically significant differences","P<0.001"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Furthermore, these results indicate that user proficiency level has a substantial impact on the accuracy and quality of responses generated by both ChatGPT versions.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t47_o4","terms":["user proficiency level","response accuracy","response quality"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"A statistical comparison of the average scores between the two versions (Table 3) revealed a highly significant difference, with ChatGPT 4.1 mini (Z=−10.2, P<0.001) demonstrating notably better performance than ChatGPT 3.5","kind":"observe","local_id":"t47_o5","terms":["performance comparison","average scores","ChatGPT 4.1 mini","ChatGPT 3.5","Z=-10.2"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Score range | ChatGPT 3.5 (%) | ChatGPT 4.1 mini (%)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t47_o6","terms":["score distribution table header","ChatGPT 3.5","ChatGPT 4.1 mini"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"4–5 | 47.78% | 64.81%","kind":"observe","local_id":"t47_o7","terms":["score range 4-5","percentage distribution"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The comparative analysis between ChatGPT version 3.5 and GPT-4.1 mini revealed that while both models performed well in answering bacterial species-specific microbiology questions, GPT-4.1 mini demonstrated more consistent and reliable performance across all proficiency levels.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t47_o8","terms":["bacterial species-specific microbiology questions","GPT-4.1 mini","ChatGPT 3.5","consistency"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Both models performed well overall, with average scores above 3.5 out of 5. However, GPT-4.1 mini exhibited lower variability in responses, indicating a more stable and predictable output quality.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t47_o9","terms":["average scores above 3.5 out of 5","response variability","output quality"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"As proficiency increases, ChatGPT 4.1 mini exhibits a marked shift towards accurate responses, particularly at the high proficiency level, where accurate outputs clearly predominate and incomplete responses are substantially reduced.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t47_o10","terms":["high proficiency level","accurate responses","incomplete responses","ChatGPT 4.1 mini"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"In contrast, although ChatGPT 3.5 also shows improved accuracy with increasing proficiency, it retains a relatively higher proportion of incomplete responses across all levels, including the high proficiency category (Fig. 2 and Table 4).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t47_o11","terms":["ChatGPT 3.5","incomplete responses","proficiency levels"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Therefore, the possibility that contextual memory effects influenced later responses within the same session should also be considered. Consequently, improvements observed across proficiency levels may partly reflect contextual carryover effects in addition to the intrinsic performance of the model.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t47_o12","terms":["contextual memory effects","contextual carryover effects","proficiency level qualification"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t47_o1"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t47_c1","object":"no significant difference across three prompts for ChatGPT 3.5 (P=0.288) and 4.1 (P=0.980)","predicate":"concludes_prompt_comparison","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) finds no statistically significant difference across three prompts in ChatGPT 3.5 (Friedman P=0.288) or ChatGPT 4.1 (P=0.980) at the 5% significance level."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t47_o2","t47_o3","t47_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t47_c2","object":"user proficiency level significantly impacts response accuracy and quality (P<0.001) in both models","predicate":"concludes_proficiency_effect","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) finds highly significant differences across three question proficiency levels (Kruskal-Wallis P<0.001) for ChatGPT 3.5 (mean ranks 284.08 low to 523.36 high) and 4.1 mini (319.38 low to 492.54 high)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t47_o5","t47_o6","t47_o7","t47_o8","t47_o9","t47_o10","t47_o11"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t47_c3","object":"ChatGPT 4.1 mini outperforms ChatGPT 3.5 in average score (Z=-10.2, P<0.001), consistency, and completeness on microbiology questions","predicate":"concludes_model_comparison","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) concludes that while both models averaged above 3.5/5 on bacterial species-specific microbiology questions, ChatGPT 4.1 mini significantly outperformed ChatGPT 3.5 (Z=-10.2, P<0.001; 64.81% vs 47.78% in score range 4-5)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t47_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t47_c4","object":"improvements across proficiency levels may partly reflect within-session contextual memory carryover effects","predicate":"qualifies_proficiency_effect","stance":"qualified","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) qualifies its finding on proficiency levels by noting that observed improvements across proficiency levels may partly reflect within-session contextual carryover effects alongside intrinsic model performance."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13449012.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13449012.txt",22288,27474]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"3d0e0c5cf4bbb5415d04fe2ace4b71c55c7b26f00c1e67c0a493f03047dfd6b8","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["b66d3c7719896288b129db6393cfff8377c8332d0ada947e14245afd3180d9df","b14e037fc8d4a27756eacfab295d284333ee39c40f9b871ca9a0e87fa3f36e45","ab50716eaf98e80e955c51de5fb5292ac4e8e45f94dfece10fc847319161627f","3cb060c9bd3bd1cc602d656043a1eb9606060f8b54c5ebf692c063f740d29d13","4948cd790a7aca1d74356919df4f148aaa1247145ac0836195d5d9522aa5e0d9","bb09d21fd3c8e030a7cea551738e010c9e94972b97ff0523cfe8505c43055c40","0e2316188912e96684d1336cd3382467942a02571c7f844ae68b6c55d589bf95","ed44d390f70035ac5b370ff25ea77eeb4cb7184e76448bc2492edde3487eca68","931d5261296cc42ccaf345b176b5e4f3da9f553bfe292b6b5811481021cb1405","e58662351f5fbf1dfed4556012bb58ea26793710ff82758ebb15504a7c3556b5","ee994e3a7448d1df2760a1453842f128b03d7e1405275e1fd7dac70c88803c78","d22f0bc67d132403b2f1cb988356d5aa552f7e19a3ed9c42090a1312eac97a0e","b8b6faa88ab5d76879d445859e17d39755fa75e6dbb42381c86171b31bb67758","b1aafb63a7491e460e849689ea06d5eb3c285ab6f86a2f65deb313b35ac54396"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":14}},"request_hash":"6578cf95d50526e4658a003b65e8f2ea77596d1dbb4719f18ec716a3465638ab","submission_id":"TR47-53a1de7694d50187#1"},"hash":"7da4995afecbf24975250e9cf0bce21765261097f1d379cba7345f0527374293","header":{"body_hash":"7d60fd41204d463ef55eafa1030efca2d9258f9749b122833efdcb1d9de40f70","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"bff1daa9489a8f02de4572a86a630ec5766458167cd75ead7b4de25d6d25911b","records_root":"ae263452e9f09d68adb0a649a19bbb093d739703044814270e86326a411068cb","seq":230,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"b5da78cae88781349269188c1af72de38d2b6e574c252b33f9a72ccf275b4f2e","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR47-53a1de7694d50187","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t47_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t47_c4","object":"improvements across proficiency levels may partly reflect within-session contextual memory carryover effects","predicate":"qualifies_proficiency_effect","stance":"qualified","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) qualifies its finding on proficiency levels by noting that observed improvements across proficiency levels may partly reflect within-session contextual carryover effects alongside intrinsic model performance."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13449012.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13449012.txt",22288,27474]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"3d0e0c5cf4bbb5415d04fe2ace4b71c55c7b26f00c1e67c0a493f03047dfd6b8","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["8a3419bf5904558982e12fe51afd2d9fe4fa1849db246b664f9bb586657197b8"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"4e0fcab6d3495ff940d52d2a3d3df040d44fd016689ec02e622db70f8ea67302","submission_id":"TR47-53a1de7694d50187#1.1"},"hash":"e1ca9a7afb8b75bd10701ae3dde67575b775fa41aa077fee1b85c2794ca4917d","header":{"body_hash":"7537dc566cbb3ecb461331f0e3c4c5b3953b04330d9b557f39c79951158c314b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"7da4995afecbf24975250e9cf0bce21765261097f1d379cba7345f0527374293","records_root":"3346caac13c6825a358b6023bc3c54cfb9f9a128bc2b6f02ba6d84b63182f053","seq":231,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"70c3048a978da7ec632ca573600f4dec38b6663a98dfb68e0db9a9d6ebb4128f","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@b66d3c7719896288","@b14e037fc8d4a277","@ab50716eaf98e80e","@3cb060c9bd3bd1cc","@4948cd790a7aca1d","@bb09d21fd3c8e030","@0e2316188912e966","@ed44d390f70035ac","@931d5261296cc42c","@e58662351f5fbf1d","@ee994e3a7448d1df","@d22f0bc67d132403","@b8b6faa88ab5d768","@b1aafb63a7491e46","@8a3419bf59045589"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"REQUEST","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":14,"local_id":"t47_c3"}],"task_id":"TR47-53a1de7694d50187","work_key":"reread:PMC13449012.txt#4"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:TR47-53a1de7694d50187:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3d0e0c5cf4bbb5415d04fe2ace4b71c55c7b26f00c1e67c0a493f03047dfd6b8","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"345773f344086b21b9995caca75e531c31eacc831ac29df0decafe0b86ba9ede","submission_id":"TR47-53a1de7694d50187#repair1"},"hash":"fa1f6d3b3a8adbab0ce5db0d25c5ab5dfbe959085f202c33bfc511536f1615f4","header":{"body_hash":"bf5977b69287e0b4c4102df650f8eafe3dc03ce2973af2b25ec4c0ce75f719bd","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"e1ca9a7afb8b75bd10701ae3dde67575b775fa41aa077fee1b85c2794ca4917d","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":232,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"78ae2820f7990c8828dfe06e4513c5687dbd9d5cc2bb131071576a8a8341eb92","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR47-53a1de7694d50187","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t47_o5","t47_o6","t47_o7","t47_o8","t47_o9","t47_o10","t47_o11"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t47_c3","object":"ChatGPT 4.1 mini outperforms ChatGPT 3.5 in average score (Z=-10.2, P<0.001), consistency, and completeness on microbiology questions","predicate":"concludes_model_comparison","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) concludes that while both models averaged >3.5/5 on microbiology questions, ChatGPT 4.1 mini significantly outperformed ChatGPT 3.5 (Z=-10.2, P<0.001; 64.81% vs 47.78% in score range 4-5)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13449012.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13449012.txt",22288,27474]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"3d0e0c5cf4bbb5415d04fe2ace4b71c55c7b26f00c1e67c0a493f03047dfd6b8","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["ef29f2b02761b0e141ef15c460de36ddd815209c9ea400025b39dcf21d733da9"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"90c66e7de1abd0fefcce179aa317fa1870b346ef5f84a039240f84aa18b3ad9e","submission_id":"TR47-53a1de7694d50187#2"},"hash":"ff02e14869ed8a477e5da05548b14fff9fc9e3748be3424d7ee18cbd89d63f55","header":{"body_hash":"331cdb102feb8b33c450d56c02c5f7470a8b970ef977c621204493831d450927","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"fa1f6d3b3a8adbab0ce5db0d25c5ab5dfbe959085f202c33bfc511536f1615f4","records_root":"622148cb96848f77ccdc750c88ffc29131744f5030165a9c6cb861efb8f57150","seq":233,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"9d1fcb0e3e9d82c6b1b5a0449de80fe3b90daf667eecdf682271c20b3c6b323a","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":13,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":5,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:PMC13449012.txt#4"},"sync_step":25,"task_id":"TR47-53a1de7694d50187"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:PMC13449012.txt#4","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3d0e0c5cf4bbb5415d04fe2ace4b71c55c7b26f00c1e67c0a493f03047dfd6b8","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"dc8efe9f03fed94c46a0df2d9ba757faffbdf464c18e4a413d7c5c230f4f6961","submission_id":"TR47-53a1de7694d50187#done3"},"hash":"d926a05b95fb4da9b6cfff45475b320de06b309a8b37dcbd1bd159e82d04fa01","header":{"body_hash":"c6581ada8fb48239dc0a83b21867b582eaafeb1104b48058e283561dbbf3934d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ff02e14869ed8a477e5da05548b14fff9fc9e3748be3424d7ee18cbd89d63f55","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":234,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"d6f8753d9e63f82c4f9bf134039e8001901fa8498617fb09b151342ff0f05ea5","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR48-32f86e3a2a5aeff4","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"This replication was performed for all 18 standardized questions across 15 bacterial species, resulting in a total of 810 responses analysed per ChatGPT version.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t48_o1","terms":["PMC13449012 data collection sample size","810 responses across 18 questions and 15 bacterial species"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Responses were collected in February 2024 for GPT-3.5 and in April 2025 for GPT-4.1 mini.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t48_o2","terms":["PMC13449012 data collection dates","GPT-3.5 and GPT-4.1 mini"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The qualitative assessment considered correctness, clarity and contextual relevance of responses. Correctness was evaluated using the 18th edition of the Medical Microbiology Guide [29], which served as the reference standard.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t48_o3","terms":["PMC13449012 qualitative outcomes measured","Medical Microbiology Guide reference standard"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Quantitative analysis assessed response completeness using a keyword-based scoring system.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t48_o4","terms":["PMC13449012 quantitative outcome measured","response completeness keyword scoring"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Hence, for each question, key microbiological terms were identified based on the Medical Microbiology Guide (Greenwood et al., 18th edition).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t48_o5","terms":["PMC13449012 reference standard","Greenwood et al. 18th edition Medical Microbiology Guide"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The raw score defined as the number of matched keywords was then converted into a 0–5-point scale (see supplementary files – Excel file).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t48_o6","terms":["PMC13449012 scoring scale","0-5-point scale from matched keywords"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Responses scoring 0 were considered inaccurate, those scoring between 1 and <5 were classified as mixed or partially complete, and responses scoring exactly 5 were classified as fully accurate.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t48_o7","terms":["PMC13449012 response accuracy classification thresholds"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"A total of 810 responses were evaluated for each version of ChatGPT (3.5 and 4.1 mini) across 3 systematically designed prompts. These prompts were structured to reflect increasing levels of user proficiency, including low, moderate and high.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t48_o8","terms":["PMC13449012 study design","three user proficiency prompt levels"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"ChatGPT 4.1 mini demonstrated superior performance across all prompts, with an overall mean score of 4.216 compared to 3.794 for ChatGPT 3.5. This indicates that ChatGPT 4.1 mini generally provided more accurate and complete responses.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t48_o9","terms":["PMC13449012 main result","ChatGPT 4.1 mini vs ChatGPT 3.5 overall mean score"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The lower standard deviation for ChatGPT 4.1 mini (1.09) relative to ChatGPT 3.5 (1.28) suggests greater consistency in response quality.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t48_o10","terms":["PMC13449012 consistency result","standard deviation comparison"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"| Parameter | ChatGPT 3.5 | ChatGPT 4.1 mini","kind":"observe","local_id":"t48_o11","terms":["PMC13449012 Table 1 header"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Overall average (mean±sd) | 3.79±1.23 | 4.22±1.09","kind":"observe","local_id":"t48_o12","terms":["PMC13449012 Table 1 overall average across users"]},{"as_of":20250401,"based_on":["t48_o1","t48_o2","t48_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t48_c1","object":"810 responses per model (GPT-3.5 and GPT-4.1 mini) across 18 questions, 15 bacterial species, 3 proficiency levels, and 3 users","predicate":"rests_on_data","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) rests on primary experimental data comprising 810 responses per model (GPT-3.5 in Feb 2024; GPT-4.1 mini in Apr 2025) across 18 questions, 15 bacterial species, 3 proficiency prompt levels, and 3 users."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t48_o3","t48_o4","t48_o6","t48_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t48_c2","object":"quantitative response completeness (0-5 keyword score) and qualitative correctness, clarity, and contextual relevance","predicate":"measures_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) measured response completeness quantitatively via a 0-5 keyword-matching scale (0=inaccurate, 1 to <5=mixed, 5=fully accurate) and qualitatively assessed correctness, clarity, and contextual relevance."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t48_o3","t48_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t48_c3","object":"Medical Microbiology Guide (Greenwood et al., 18th edition) and clinical microbiologist validation","predicate":"uses_reference_standard","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) used the 18th edition of the Medical Microbiology Guide (Greenwood et al.) and clinical microbiologist validation as the reference standard for evaluating correctness and expected microbiological keywords."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t48_o9","t48_o10","t48_o11","t48_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t48_c4","object":"ChatGPT 4.1 mini achieved higher mean accuracy/completeness (4.216 vs 3.794) and lower SD (1.09 vs 1.28/1.23) than ChatGPT 3.5","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) concludes that ChatGPT 4.1 mini outperformed ChatGPT 3.5 across all prompts in accuracy, completeness, and consistency, achieving an overall mean score of 4.216 (4.22±1.09) vs 3.794 (3.79±1.23; prose SD 1.28)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13449012.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13449012.txt",10372,16328]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"471e2e8a34343879937a41d96d2a727ee1e5b66c609bf037344250c4545d72cf","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["772b9fd8d68b7daa3839596e2f25ccef39b01b89892c17c7ad3ce38a9807531b","74fc968cb4afc342c6992b96571890c5b04b19093ff4d48104b2217d5e56a999","c370a5ea7c9200f96f8858c7e7e6c86d593af4c08ba20946ef871ef31cebda93","90061914f4416bd5c974bbc9424e7af2c9bbaff179d10811956369b0d4e6a6a1","3c2fe65aecc9def275e191690b63a4a536e157e1046ea57e049583c9873458ef","40ca071c988e041ed3afec041b53e30cbc55d5ee5d772da418a7d9fa304e2b48","1570db34e9545a087a7c0b81e1aec2aa99244c0c4a1b1eedbccc71f9d7ea0212","36951f5139a9ee37fdc6934e86d13d37742c51d585f6c5f6214714806d73a044","e0c49cc45838fdf2866e303ad798b5590fc6b1511b3ee9b4fabd4ee97d9ff31a","c1d1032e545c9754beb395dff87dfdd3292d83a377de06c8359f4f8295f4846f","99da2a239ecd0fa24836150eb43b398fa33a76b764c6ca2052af1bd1958add94","f3a83c0cf21c24cb6b7bc03abad9af715ebe03bf0efd4673f68c01d87cbd87dd","a417da24478f065981885f88a8d81358f39a150f20223d9a8b19031cd0a4e043","9ffc1e262c156d16a6e7906e14a97e2d31142698c26e86ae0fda135249bd2393","29eb77f88a4f27de9e6a53f4fe8c3c163af01d24a27ef2d9ad9b32b128d01a31","7bc9e2f4b13c7447cca0b9b7e9b901a11428864abb49127c149f877bfca4e92a"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"16e3356924edaf5952eea70305123d45ffbffa4c3ae7dec2db60d49174252308","submission_id":"TR48-32f86e3a2a5aeff4#1"},"hash":"3a2ad7ec7e661d8efbe06b4dc168da95818daffd728a79a23389f8cba2bea5c0","header":{"body_hash":"c857644c2192fc24efba04172dc9ddfe87d35d241a9047d5f1d5d508d9270798","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"d926a05b95fb4da9b6cfff45475b320de06b309a8b37dcbd1bd159e82d04fa01","records_root":"0cd9fe7550a2462d69003617a527d7021ef07de7bf7559ad406550a60059d748","seq":235,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"bf1edcb6a7d4b2d10cd89b32e681dadb2ea5d5eb433dcad870cb375651226ecd","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":13,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":10,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:PMC13449012.txt#2"},"sync_step":25,"task_id":"TR48-32f86e3a2a5aeff4"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:PMC13449012.txt#2","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"471e2e8a34343879937a41d96d2a727ee1e5b66c609bf037344250c4545d72cf","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"4f51cdf4273f92e6d0befb3108f6a6f9cc6ac83f2b6ac69a697d9b517d23c112","submission_id":"TR48-32f86e3a2a5aeff4#done2"},"hash":"e698d7244a57655df5a0dc1c6fb9401c0a1c811d77c7d32483a48cf541acd23f","header":{"body_hash":"cc554f66b6dc1c8a9cc56ff9fd23f1290a05e1cef80d0835347e51261adecf88","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3a2ad7ec7e661d8efbe06b4dc168da95818daffd728a79a23389f8cba2bea5c0","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":236,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"6cccf75bcdc2b214c2edfa4628ba9de58d6a4ab9ce2c2dc7f709332f3cba18bc","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":13,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":626},"started_unix_ms":1795102634943,"wave":{"doc:PMC13449012.txt#2":"reader-1","doc:PMC13449012.txt#3":"reader-2","doc:PMC13449012.txt#4":"reader-3"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"471e2e8a34343879937a41d96d2a727ee1e5b66c609bf037344250c4545d72cf","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"729292bdc4f79e5a0ef8f12860549f0dc56ed69aff7d642df058cae7e04e79c1","submission_id":"circle:c1a7db5f55a4d25c3b58820048e717d765783e8e786d2413ce6ac1ef6c8a5fd4"},"hash":"8dc50f721243251edb6dcb537454450d837e729141f022653ab5cbaee4958647","header":{"body_hash":"39a803f928f8af20a0b2fd017b8ba3323a589927912d1a6041242c414e11ff32","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"e698d7244a57655df5a0dc1c6fb9401c0a1c811d77c7d32483a48cf541acd23f","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":237,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"d46e58f497b5786af8364a059458cabdec3e2541f75e8632f4ec8b57c403ee2a","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"6cccf75bcdc2b214c2edfa4628ba9de58d6a4ab9ce2c2dc7f709332f3cba18bc","engine_root":"471e2e8a34343879937a41d96d2a727ee1e5b66c609bf037344250c4545d72cf","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"cf2edd7503d3c2edc1683cad243f3aeed80753f1f9e671a185374df17e4ff9ae","log_size":238,"projections":{"dependencies":"9953853826fd1ec0a0b6afd1524639aa8fed8a7294ce4c527ce0f8a7c1ec0103","status":"2d6021d4e31a5205a45bfab628df8cedc245dcdc90034988eb15320b481ec8c9"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"8dc50f721243251edb6dcb537454450d837e729141f022653ab5cbaee4958647"}},"engine_root":"471e2e8a34343879937a41d96d2a727ee1e5b66c609bf037344250c4545d72cf","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"6cccf75bcdc2b214c2edfa4628ba9de58d6a4ab9ce2c2dc7f709332f3cba18bc","engine_root":"471e2e8a34343879937a41d96d2a727ee1e5b66c609bf037344250c4545d72cf","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"cf2edd7503d3c2edc1683cad243f3aeed80753f1f9e671a185374df17e4ff9ae","log_size":238,"projections":{"dependencies":"9953853826fd1ec0a0b6afd1524639aa8fed8a7294ce4c527ce0f8a7c1ec0103","status":"2d6021d4e31a5205a45bfab628df8cedc245dcdc90034988eb15320b481ec8c9"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"8dc50f721243251edb6dcb537454450d837e729141f022653ab5cbaee4958647"},"seal_hash":"29b4b308c7ffbde5d5d652b25fa6ed7d7a9a7e5a933b91368637c9fed2730c1a"}},"request_hash":"620a348a50a0a329dab3dd9dc4ae3c573cbfe70ff53ce06132218233dad593e9","submission_id":"seal-238"},"hash":"357a7aae115646af506d89df50faf0f4a05646d99e0e8e320e1634da2b4d7a26","header":{"body_hash":"81313ed9dc49db2952c7ec08cbf119efcae5158b5c9b49049c60d428e065687e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"8dc50f721243251edb6dcb537454450d837e729141f022653ab5cbaee4958647","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":238,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"3352a824368629da453d1143fba412fc09b711cf42cb5eee9ad9c511cb24815e","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"epoch":26,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25},{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":26}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102634943},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"471e2e8a34343879937a41d96d2a727ee1e5b66c609bf037344250c4545d72cf","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"f6576583888779e3201fdd61d4dd950c5aaada9afccbeaaa53bdb8ab468adf47","submission_id":"ring-members:6d6a7b908a33cd21981ef4bab10d24eeafcb7b665c39c7897a525a33dff5a9c6"},"hash":"6538ac7d081f31a8473df2d858fbf30a32fc865d67e080631e980face492a9e1","header":{"body_hash":"4fb846be57699f741da2078a049283fca2558381bdb3272a985ceeab2eb4b970","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"357a7aae115646af506d89df50faf0f4a05646d99e0e8e320e1634da2b4d7a26","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":239,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"672117dec73691c2db7d3a8cf32ebab1a372fa35fdf29654d6f6c95724ab2368","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":14,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":626},"started_unix_ms":1795102634980,"wave":{"doc:PMC13449012.txt#5":"reader-2","doc:PMC13449012.txt#6":"reader-3","doc:PMC13449012.txt#7":"reader-1"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"471e2e8a34343879937a41d96d2a727ee1e5b66c609bf037344250c4545d72cf","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"508c48cd9771abb1d22487e4d686a2a8a35db50e1f673ab31e18a3725d298073","submission_id":"circle:c0e754a4e83a39ecc1263be79ce583e0d3d93b8f4332ef3427fed15fe5a102e4"},"hash":"73ac5415b1aaa810e27a2e8a6835a50a64acfd715d99cdfc5922d9a075dfea12","header":{"body_hash":"6efea401d3253e1a31bbf2bae3d6913a690f3ede191f211a6a1c56551f17394e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"6538ac7d081f31a8473df2d858fbf30a32fc865d67e080631e980face492a9e1","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":240,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"840a6bae6e60aead14bfabc2a737069c06802e8f2147e081cb5ebbb0787f7632","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"672117dec73691c2db7d3a8cf32ebab1a372fa35fdf29654d6f6c95724ab2368","engine_root":"471e2e8a34343879937a41d96d2a727ee1e5b66c609bf037344250c4545d72cf","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"995f856688fdddcd5ba650fbfac1c4328b8b4cdb2ef6d0e58a146eea81251de4","log_size":241,"projections":{"dependencies":"9953853826fd1ec0a0b6afd1524639aa8fed8a7294ce4c527ce0f8a7c1ec0103","status":"2d6021d4e31a5205a45bfab628df8cedc245dcdc90034988eb15320b481ec8c9"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"73ac5415b1aaa810e27a2e8a6835a50a64acfd715d99cdfc5922d9a075dfea12"}},"engine_root":"471e2e8a34343879937a41d96d2a727ee1e5b66c609bf037344250c4545d72cf","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"672117dec73691c2db7d3a8cf32ebab1a372fa35fdf29654d6f6c95724ab2368","engine_root":"471e2e8a34343879937a41d96d2a727ee1e5b66c609bf037344250c4545d72cf","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"995f856688fdddcd5ba650fbfac1c4328b8b4cdb2ef6d0e58a146eea81251de4","log_size":241,"projections":{"dependencies":"9953853826fd1ec0a0b6afd1524639aa8fed8a7294ce4c527ce0f8a7c1ec0103","status":"2d6021d4e31a5205a45bfab628df8cedc245dcdc90034988eb15320b481ec8c9"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"73ac5415b1aaa810e27a2e8a6835a50a64acfd715d99cdfc5922d9a075dfea12"},"seal_hash":"9d3c3328b6468c0e3155c4421728037fd3c26b99eafe511d44bc6fc94894df27"}},"request_hash":"60db68d9d3e1a196100201c0b76b9b6c5dced4834c109e0fdf782cf4fa6a305f","submission_id":"seal-241"},"hash":"d6ac6d040a94cda55030246ecd6fecbdadce612ce29fe31c639d6ee77b59dc79","header":{"body_hash":"fc25de54702328636f3f8bf4eb91692c01cbb9fd6e67243868b0bb92695b0ef0","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"73ac5415b1aaa810e27a2e8a6835a50a64acfd715d99cdfc5922d9a075dfea12","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":241,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"0cbe0a74eda8ae7c4a9de7b37bf42aba6ed4b722af531f4ae06ae88d36a0e9e5","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[14,"READ",0],"epoch":27,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25},{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":26},{"binding":[14,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":27}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102634980},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"471e2e8a34343879937a41d96d2a727ee1e5b66c609bf037344250c4545d72cf","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"5138c7d1483aa3fe5df5554f812542cdf8523087a22bdc1adc3cd5eb115a289a","submission_id":"ring-members:2f862eaf29262fca29f2655723df5b5f25223ecd58b66a3a69c8f5581da0b02e"},"hash":"a25885ba55e8461b932f5d36ada2786c9286789711d67d31b2e3636ab20b31b2","header":{"body_hash":"f61562bc40da37ab09c0028a0a07c86656c3934da92df77e946500d041c11672","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"d6ac6d040a94cda55030246ecd6fecbdadce612ce29fe31c639d6ee77b59dc79","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":242,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"39a9aa7618d21c064cee431901388c0768b2f98d8b8c5c9f0d90de5be29d87a5","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T49-1db185bf528e9f31","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"36. WangJ FanW RETRACTED ARTICLE: the effect of ChatGPT on students’ learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis Humanit Soc Sci Commun 202512110.1057/s41599-025-04787-y","kind":"observe","local_id":"t49_o1","terms":["reference 36","Wang and Fan 2025","retracted meta-analysis","Manushi 2026 reference list"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"19. DasD KumarN LongjamLA SinhaR Deb RoyA et al Assessing the capability of ChatGPT in answering first- and second-order knowledge questions on microbiology as per competency-based medical education","kind":"observe","local_id":"t49_o2","terms":["reference 19","Das et al. 2023","microbiology questions","ChatGPT capability"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"21. SallamM Al-SalahatK Below average chatgpt performance in medical microbiology exam compared to university studentsFront Educ20238133341510.3389/FEDUC.2023.1333415/BIBTEX","kind":"observe","local_id":"t49_o3","terms":["reference 21","Sallam and Al-Salahat 2023","medical microbiology exam","ChatGPT performance"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"25. Ministry of Health, Sri Lanka Epidemiology Unitn.dhttps://www.epid.gov.lk/weekly-epidemiological-reportaccessed11-January-2025","kind":"observe","local_id":"t49_o4","terms":["reference 25","Ministry of Health Sri Lanka","Epidemiology Unit","weekly epidemiological report"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"26. DheerasekaraWKH MuthugalaMARV LiyanapathiranaV Epidemiology and diagnosis of viral and bacterial central nervous system infections in Sri Lanka: a narrative review Sri Lankan J Infec Dis 20231310.4038/sljid.v13i1.8488","kind":"observe","local_id":"t49_o5","terms":["reference 26","Dheerasekara et al. 2023","central nervous system infections in Sri Lanka"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"29. GreenwoodD SlackRCB BarerMR IrvingWL Medical Microbiology: A Guide to Microbial Infections: Pathogenesis, Immunity, Laboratory Diagnosis and ControlElsevier Health Sciences2012","kind":"observe","local_id":"t49_o6","terms":["reference 29","Greenwood et al. 2012","Medical Microbiology textbook"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"32. JinHK LeeHE KimEY Performance of ChatGPT-3.5 and GPT-4 in national licensing examinations for medicine, pharmacy, dentistry, and nursing: a systematic review and meta-analysisBMC Med Educ202424101310.1186/s12909-024-05944-839285377PMC11406751","kind":"observe","local_id":"t49_o7","terms":["reference 32","Jin et al. 2024","ChatGPT-3.5 and GPT-4","national licensing examinations"]},{"about":["PMC13449012.txt","Wang and Fan 2025","reference 36"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t49_q1","needed":"Check earlier sections of PMC13449012.txt for in-text citations to [36] (or ranges containing 36) and link them with t49_o1 and the Title line quote from Wang and Fan 2025's record file.","text":"Which body passages in Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012.txt) cite reference 36 (Wang and Fan 2025), and what statements or findings do they rest on it (together with the meta-analysis record's Title line)?"},{"about":["PMC13449012.txt","references 19-39"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t49_q2","needed":"Check the Methods, Results, and Discussion sections of PMC13449012.txt where references 17-39 are cited.","text":"How does Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012.txt) use microbiology, epidemiological, and medical exam references [19, 21, 25, 26, 29, 32] as data sources, benchmarks, or comparison studies for its conclusions?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13449012.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13449012.txt",38799,43375]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"ca020e7bfa68c47def4dc3f1a3225dca2709780b981b79b6227bab10bb48e6a4","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["9eb2fad6d4d69abc626fdcd445a0e909b0e038ff77e01d416678b6b377795273","5c028e7385f54490dd6207bf8dac7ae978815a0a78b5a2ad656d0aea8f2a1b1b","da6bee875cabd96131aa8a95b8bae1cea60eca9ebb4d34ed2e7235ac2487ea5e","dccff9a5738fcd8036bb10a610bd446efefb3eee1e1e6b4b793c51fb87af4aa3","2b8d178165b68b3a199e3fb08f2478d8251b254a8ba2be89684bca0db0dad33e","ca4e4dc72b9ae85770dc59af161e7baa015de82a5dade5262ffa922ecb1fc717","da29dfe9ba1c5afc5f07d57151d54b4290261e00ed85d4ba2e4019c2e50fd3e7","89b02f4059c6f8d956e2b0d421d07b74c54b6b2b8f252a39d225e779f775b138","351fc14b623838e6316eb4ebf8f9f4b14644a24a0170172ef7f36bb6ec9c29a2"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"ac776468f7ec53bc56649491664be73379328f61c04473f3747bb28e4ec7eca9","submission_id":"T49-1db185bf528e9f31#1"},"hash":"ec55f5b9a531140921fe6aa558c470b91238b774ae6f778d5a3129002dc953ea","header":{"body_hash":"3a3477cfb13c4cfad206543f1e71b9620ac33ccb37fee9494b99f4fbba95f421","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"a25885ba55e8461b932f5d36ada2786c9286789711d67d31b2e3636ab20b31b2","records_root":"c672e9de35d8efd6d4d835dc8df664af79d2b1acf0f0be78affaec387039a2f6","seq":243,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"3ad8ce156b968787478d5fce6398c42f01e99e68b49c1122631d27e362c2bb77","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":14,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":27,"task_id":"T49-1db185bf528e9f31"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13449012.txt#7","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"ca020e7bfa68c47def4dc3f1a3225dca2709780b981b79b6227bab10bb48e6a4","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"8c45e60157c37a776855e0c6bfebc38cbb52e3e77e924541d74ec190f7cceff0","submission_id":"T49-1db185bf528e9f31#done2"},"hash":"d94b9d10cde8d10861fa8f9b6e77a53d59a914f2fc776a7417f56bc3c29ae369","header":{"body_hash":"c6efa6ae4d8eb279c5bf6216b37b7247943d35632091fc8256d7a8a0cdc6c477","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ec55f5b9a531140921fe6aa558c470b91238b774ae6f778d5a3129002dc953ea","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":244,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"69b36a577fceadf94932e7446960a9d8b9f588b6600beed77375fb4a0ec3bb84","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T51-2a6f502c7defbdd0","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Furthermore, studies by [35, 36] demonstrated that AI-based learning assistants improved student engagement in medical sciences by providing interactive explanations and immediate feedback.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t51_o1","terms":["citation of reference 36","AI-based learning assistants","student engagement in medical sciences","interactive explanations and immediate feedback"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The results indicate that ChatGPT can serve as a valuable supplementary educational tool for microbiology students, particularly in reinforcing foundational concepts and enhancing engagement","kind":"observe","local_id":"t51_o2","terms":["main conclusion","ChatGPT as supplementary educational tool","microbiology students","reinforcing foundational concepts","enhancing engagement"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"However, given the inconsistencies identified in this study, ChatGPT should not be solely relied upon as an authoritative source.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t51_o3","terms":["qualification of conclusion","inconsistencies identified","ChatGPT not authoritative source"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Instead, it should be integrated with expert-reviewed materials to ensure accuracy and credibility.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t51_o4","terms":["recommendation","integration with expert-reviewed materials","accuracy and credibility"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"responses produced at higher proficiency levels may have been influenced, to some extent, by contextual information carried over from earlier interactions","kind":"observe","local_id":"t51_o5","terms":["study limitation","contextual carry-over across proficiency levels"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"While this study provides valuable insights into the efficacy of ChatGPT in responding to bacterial species-specific microbiology questions, further research is needed","kind":"observe","local_id":"t51_o6","terms":["study scope","efficacy of ChatGPT","bacterial species-specific microbiology questions"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t51_o2","t51_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t51_c1","object":"ChatGPT is a valuable supplementary tool for microbiology students on bacterial species-specific questions, reinforcing foundational concepts and engagement","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"PMC13449012 concludes that ChatGPT can serve as a valuable supplementary educational tool for microbiology students in reinforcing foundational concepts and enhancing engagement, after evaluating bacterial species-specific questions."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t51_o3","t51_o4","t51_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t51_c2","object":"inconsistencies and prompt carryover require integrating ChatGPT with expert-reviewed materials rather than relying on it as an authoritative source","predicate":"qualifies_conclusions","stance":"qualified","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"PMC13449012 qualifies its conclusion due to identified inconsistencies and potential contextual carryover across prompts, advising against sole reliance on ChatGPT without integration with expert-reviewed materials."},{"about":["Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t51_q1","needed":"The reference list section of PMC13449012.txt containing entry 36 (after reference 16) and the meta-analysis record file containing the 'Title: The effect of ChatGPT...' quote.","text":"Locate reference entry 36 in PMC13449012.txt and the Title line of the Wang and Fan 2025 record file to complete the q1 claim that PMC13449012 cites [35, 36] for AI learning assistants improving medical sciences student engagement."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13449012.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13449012.txt",33008,38799]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"52aa921c291ad6b4fa88ec381b99add017f49747d2982b249274be5758663867","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["f09998d4561da5f7ce03e380308fbfdc5363a1354600bec2d2538819929658d7","46b06f972173f6918041934ddf25153fdf200a4c3bfb5e84487eb30bed1a30bc","580d12adee6a59e58c6f96d44be609fa46abcec770add1463a8156c388254a0a","fedf09ab428216be9c1556deb60ccdc85ff636c4a12d83305b7b5b6a9ed7e8d9","70f6775183aad9b612b18d2a0fc0b19693f78f7d829a1b9ad2373c60cec797e8","b7d5f7564840f7707cda3783c7f3c935bf763486c10c74eaf8b7e1417257b6bf","3af18967e3c5160c7fb874b472d6cf5afca29f65af579151a4224f07b2e1b61e","571dc157d43d99feda730d73c2422a7d6b4e48bff396acfd2249532056e03ea2","48af98f8d9a6b6f00db80c8d3fcfcdc3e4d43e5b39f4f59c94705be24b155c16"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"d9c5135135d45e3340611317aed0d096c1c223bb20a16e0a83004883448610a2","submission_id":"T51-2a6f502c7defbdd0#1"},"hash":"e93f23cc610d6f42fb0f9d9cc02607085dc3d4b5082be3a5ef53f4732eb05d40","header":{"body_hash":"33eeceeb7ea7920d5d0c4d102da324416eec603cbca3c8c1439b4119185350d5","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"d94b9d10cde8d10861fa8f9b6e77a53d59a914f2fc776a7417f56bc3c29ae369","records_root":"482ade363d09c391797ee46bcec97920874ee0aea7d0d07988477deec551a6e4","seq":245,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"092493fbe81545ee15190b7a51833ed2669c72031c01e488c9937c779376dfa2","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":14,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":27,"task_id":"T51-2a6f502c7defbdd0"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13449012.txt#6","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"52aa921c291ad6b4fa88ec381b99add017f49747d2982b249274be5758663867","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"8e1daefe00abec24c08412b96fc6ba3e7d434aff5fc4f72f9af712bad37cbd1c","submission_id":"T51-2a6f502c7defbdd0#done2"},"hash":"49481d851758ca2676fc2c194d90f450e23f2aa6f9f7d185a181fc5e228b07cb","header":{"body_hash":"59b0b47f529494fc0e6a3a1e576127db4f7c7d9f55261dec08223906b9a2856d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"e93f23cc610d6f42fb0f9d9cc02607085dc3d4b5082be3a5ef53f4732eb05d40","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":246,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"477437092d40815b84213e19d42c5e95cd61dc1cd0cf613e1761f5b6a6db8c2d","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T50-a64728b8f78795ea","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Therefore, in the ChatGPT 3.5 model, nearly half of the responses (47.78%) fell within the 4–5 range, indicating a substantial proportion of accurate or near-accurate answers.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t50_o1","terms":["PMC13449012 ChatGPT 3.5 score distribution 4-5 range 47.78%"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Moderate performance was also notable, with 21.98 and 21.11% of responses in the 3–4 and 2–3 ranges, respectively. Lower scores were less frequent, with 7.16% in the 1–2 range and 1.98% in the 0–1 range","kind":"observe","local_id":"t50_o2","terms":["PMC13449012 ChatGPT 3.5 score distribution moderate and low score ranges"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"In contrast, ChatGPT 4.1 mini demonstrated a clear improvement in score distribution, with a markedly higher proportion of responses (64.81%) in the 4–5 range.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t50_o3","terms":["PMC13449012 ChatGPT 4.1 mini score distribution 4-5 range 64.81%"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The percentages in the 3–4 (17.50%) and 2–3 (12.10%) categories were lower than those observed for ChatGPT 3.5, while low-scoring responses were comparatively rare at 4.07% [1, 2] and 1.11% (0–1).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t50_o4","terms":["PMC13449012 ChatGPT 4.1 mini score distribution moderate and low score ranges"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Overall, while ChatGPT 3.5 demonstrated notable capabilities in responding to microbiology-related queries, the GPT-4.1 mini model consistently outperformed it in terms of accuracy, reliability and adaptability","kind":"observe","local_id":"t50_o5","terms":["PMC13449012 main conclusion comparing GPT-4.1 mini and ChatGPT 3.5 on microbiology queries"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The findings of this study highlight that ChatGPT provides generally accurate responses to bacterial species-specific microbiology questions, particularly at moderate and high proficiency levels.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t50_o6","terms":["PMC13449012 conclusion on ChatGPT accuracy on bacterial species-specific microbiology questions"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The mean scores across all responses were recorded as 4.46 for 3.5 and 4.65 for 4.1 mini models in the high proficiency group suggesting that the technical term quality is significant for the output","kind":"observe","local_id":"t50_o7","terms":["PMC13449012 mean scores in high proficiency group for ChatGPT 3.5 and 4.1 mini"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"and that prompt construction and technical specificity had a greater influence on response quality than session history effects (Fig. 3 and Table 1).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t50_o8","terms":["PMC13449012 conclusion on prompt construction and technical specificity versus session history"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"Despite ChatGPT’s strong performance in general microbiology knowledge, limitations were evident in handling complex or highly technical questions.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t50_o9","terms":["PMC13449012 qualification on limitations in complex or highly technical microbiology questions"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13449012.txt","exact_quote":"The presence of lower ratings, particularly at the low proficiency level, suggests that ChatGPT occasionally generates responses lacking precise contextual understanding or depth.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t50_o10","terms":["PMC13449012 qualification on lower ratings at low proficiency level and contextual depth"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t50_o1","t50_o2","t50_o3","t50_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t50_c1","object":"ChatGPT 3.5 (4-5: 47.78%, 3-4: 21.98%, 2-3: 21.11%, 1-2: 7.16%, 0-1: 1.98%) vs ChatGPT 4.1 mini (64.81%, 17.50%, 12.10%, 4.07%, 1.11%)","predicate":"reports_score_distributions","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) reports ChatGPT 3.5 score distributions of 47.78% in the 4–5 range, 21.98% in 3–4, 21.11% in 2–3, 7.16% in 1–2, and 1.98% in 0–1, versus 64.81%, 17.50%, 12.10%, 4.07%, and 1.11% for ChatGPT 4.1 mini."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t50_o5","t50_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t50_c2","object":"ChatGPT gives generally accurate answers to bacterial species-specific microbiology queries; GPT-4.1 mini outperforms ChatGPT 3.5","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) concludes that ChatGPT provides generally accurate answers to bacterial species-specific microbiology queries, with GPT-4.1 mini consistently outperforming ChatGPT 3.5 in accuracy, reliability, and adaptability."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t50_o7","t50_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t50_c3","object":"mean scores 4.46 (ChatGPT 3.5) and 4.65 (GPT-4.1 mini); prompt construction and technical specificity outweigh session history effects","predicate":"concludes_from_high_proficiency_scores","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) reports high-proficiency mean response scores of 4.46 for ChatGPT 3.5 and 4.65 for GPT-4.1 mini, concluding that prompt construction and technical specificity influence quality more than session history."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t50_o9","t50_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t50_c4","object":"limitations in complex/technical questions and occasional lack of precise contextual understanding or depth at low proficiency levels","predicate":"qualifies_conclusions","stance":"qualified","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) qualifies ChatGPT's microbiology performance by noting limitations on complex or highly technical questions and lower ratings at low proficiency levels where responses lack contextual depth."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13449012.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13449012.txt",27474,33008]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"644cba0775f50e57e53fbbb7c5f51a899b58e665e4c3da2522c12c64c6bb4f99","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["8cc7322f5cdb74002d3e771b8657934491e0cb2a8ac80faee6cfe121326ca662","a09a1565cd9b3141d77a433dd324f948c5d8076a61d173ad03dbd35b2addd9e8","14451685bad295ab2982be9ad6983a218892b94e0dadeda68fc36ec24a3d8f3d","12f1ad5d1ff162a22bbf3e845adaa2ee85c28e060ae4d2701c539fc9abad7fca","42238f1d36593adcbf5381db1723b0147c95181a87a93f0ea43bbe6495956414","ca249ab85f8eb45835a966d4ae0d111d66bab658fefafc4d757a9e9db75dc85b","300533787d8c4d57648d943fa3eb25df89099b2689c748aeeda2e5d7b03697ac","18a223023db0491df76f1371f8f5ba3e8006e89524ea922052155c67c49098d2","9f1653782dc75fdae2f6f09a2e8e0bb5deac11e0e4e5c6dd175fd5c60f7f3c67","aaacee56f97c42c0eb3e2211ce90fb73bdbee90832d1344aeb4e9cf2e70dd5f0","4633a61eaffcd099573fde885e66eb9fe1ee76d9926fce8ace2ee58f6830718e","8722c9ba807d0e75c102d483df53157f4c2db5469d644fd01791016e7d0c59c6","92260bbe31fc2b76fc17cef2c70790a03aa94766cac5382b7a6b28f801d0f00d","29a630059fe955679b27e954155320abb4006cbe50a334fb7c5d815ab066ecb6"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"c44eaf20ee7e1752db9a80e8ba7b0516566d421a2566abf82d41b6c38ec8ad82","submission_id":"T50-a64728b8f78795ea#1"},"hash":"043f73e87b95ea2beb489d82e7e652c18f2b8866cb1872b5d4968700ec4c3710","header":{"body_hash":"1f9c51bbabd11091e08aa53cf82a4dc621b1851334d35588d2a3f2e277b1d671","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"49481d851758ca2676fc2c194d90f450e23f2aa6f9f7d185a181fc5e228b07cb","records_root":"fe6f0ae6cc376db1f9403a1d9c99d36dffe9cb0c5f4c415e477aaedf10b9b233","seq":247,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"b5652bb9fbcb6764387e496abc2e66dded7a49f431a2788b8ad4fb1130ea8fd6","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":14,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":27,"task_id":"T50-a64728b8f78795ea"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13449012.txt#5","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"644cba0775f50e57e53fbbb7c5f51a899b58e665e4c3da2522c12c64c6bb4f99","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"2e4a57649753a2431faa4f15aa34efcacc630cc4c5e1d41a60c6d7df3029e951","submission_id":"T50-a64728b8f78795ea#done2"},"hash":"ad57d71767ef5ea95038cb92e13aa350fbf10d296bab09b20b339884967e9f0a","header":{"body_hash":"d9010d1efcd6d09ded5c9e5b74a6943398519de9a98545965a5b40c584a8f47a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"043f73e87b95ea2beb489d82e7e652c18f2b8866cb1872b5d4968700ec4c3710","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":248,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"2efcc83c6c636584c37da34b9d4c50fbe439e0a6ae9b2d0b1d6f203a64e182f9","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":14,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":658},"started_unix_ms":1795102663928,"wave":{"doc:PMC13449012.txt#5":"reader-2","doc:PMC13449012.txt#6":"reader-3","doc:PMC13449012.txt#7":"reader-1"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"644cba0775f50e57e53fbbb7c5f51a899b58e665e4c3da2522c12c64c6bb4f99","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"43f05766f33e782b82a0b3bf0f055c17abc3f301fdba73bbb9c487469259bdf5","submission_id":"circle:4bb5ad127ab2079ea7038ab9b1f061146b1b90dcdca0c5f6eac2b98e8e39ad20"},"hash":"4b8e0aa294ffc91ffd0f9a1378630bfec55e14997a98ab123a6c49725a87353a","header":{"body_hash":"e5f33065cf40aa867ca816859b9cce1c862a49a92958d7d2aee73518e82c8863","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ad57d71767ef5ea95038cb92e13aa350fbf10d296bab09b20b339884967e9f0a","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":249,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"bb034285bf5b2229642ff546b52f8a987276865460e5ef817889372fe304c11a","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"2efcc83c6c636584c37da34b9d4c50fbe439e0a6ae9b2d0b1d6f203a64e182f9","engine_root":"644cba0775f50e57e53fbbb7c5f51a899b58e665e4c3da2522c12c64c6bb4f99","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"a4d7fb8a4695bcc17231ba8ca61b3d758fb44ab31fb2129fc342b67a670f7efd","log_size":250,"projections":{"dependencies":"16ef46705046f82a128d6695c93af8c2410d11960dd26943bc330f48d9fd869b","status":"f7f6a04c2d881613e1bc058cb2d424f75cd972ddc936eb03dc0e5bd2edc99fda"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"4b8e0aa294ffc91ffd0f9a1378630bfec55e14997a98ab123a6c49725a87353a"}},"engine_root":"644cba0775f50e57e53fbbb7c5f51a899b58e665e4c3da2522c12c64c6bb4f99","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"2efcc83c6c636584c37da34b9d4c50fbe439e0a6ae9b2d0b1d6f203a64e182f9","engine_root":"644cba0775f50e57e53fbbb7c5f51a899b58e665e4c3da2522c12c64c6bb4f99","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"a4d7fb8a4695bcc17231ba8ca61b3d758fb44ab31fb2129fc342b67a670f7efd","log_size":250,"projections":{"dependencies":"16ef46705046f82a128d6695c93af8c2410d11960dd26943bc330f48d9fd869b","status":"f7f6a04c2d881613e1bc058cb2d424f75cd972ddc936eb03dc0e5bd2edc99fda"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"4b8e0aa294ffc91ffd0f9a1378630bfec55e14997a98ab123a6c49725a87353a"},"seal_hash":"bf81f7a5a654428fa310eb8534b30b8009a9917892f972c7ed90eb89a80cd58a"}},"request_hash":"e312e52f6913f9bfb1d3c7c9634a530037f04f616207ae378d611569446413f0","submission_id":"seal-250"},"hash":"f87e4ee540ab3dde935fa555e7b6b6b582e04adde312502c63471e8fe41e333c","header":{"body_hash":"a904a84465e78bf76d1b73d3bc06697e99a8720eef83ba753e1ee2521525fa8c","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"4b8e0aa294ffc91ffd0f9a1378630bfec55e14997a98ab123a6c49725a87353a","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":250,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"a35d69e6d5607ee6b1db400e9877108c3a7eb1beb1ac565d816bcfff4b743452","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[14,"BUILD",0],"epoch":28,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25},{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":26},{"binding":[14,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":27},{"binding":[14,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":28}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102663928},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"644cba0775f50e57e53fbbb7c5f51a899b58e665e4c3da2522c12c64c6bb4f99","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"3bf8661a9ec978bf5648e9ce7dca388b6bec13fe7739d5326beea0c5bfbfe950","submission_id":"ring-members:3998e19319ab840603cb5133f25e5c00b7938fe5dffeae435f4308ea9c1b2651"},"hash":"09ef94a9f48dfb82db4b78278a5c4c333ff660b9de2f1a805ef2623a8997d458","header":{"body_hash":"b61cc9fa25430bc2f005a216553e7190ddaf4a3ca39763c0b4430d977e08d4f0","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"f87e4ee540ab3dde935fa555e7b6b6b582e04adde312502c63471e8fe41e333c","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":251,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"af14a640bcd6cb9a5a8e264d727b399568654ab897f3d8eb0326d43e61cac3d5","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":15,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":658},"started_unix_ms":1795102663964,"wave":{"doc:PMC13647323.txt#0":"reader-3","doc:PMC13647323.txt#1":"reader-1","doc:PMC13647323.txt#2":"reader-2"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"644cba0775f50e57e53fbbb7c5f51a899b58e665e4c3da2522c12c64c6bb4f99","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"37e0cdee85c7be28538d73e353acdd7464400baf88acf9ed0e90a1a43b2eb3b4","submission_id":"circle:7fad78295e719124692663fca40d2316dab083f1e942ed1204aff73c81967a1e"},"hash":"b0684c9137071efdc351423d1ca1f718e117150a85a2f2ac3d4822edca0f3816","header":{"body_hash":"46fec935642572d0f6cc8a37a17d524fc476e8dd04483c21b4d98d9e80fd2f3b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"09ef94a9f48dfb82db4b78278a5c4c333ff660b9de2f1a805ef2623a8997d458","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":252,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"1e2f142604db1c8cbf94b8b072970f3ca7e45f36ffca2002ae80d7424b6bbd57","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"af14a640bcd6cb9a5a8e264d727b399568654ab897f3d8eb0326d43e61cac3d5","engine_root":"644cba0775f50e57e53fbbb7c5f51a899b58e665e4c3da2522c12c64c6bb4f99","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"d02487f48e5db084f82a75ee3fde78da4c1ae89295eabe0002d095b604ba76a6","log_size":253,"projections":{"dependencies":"16ef46705046f82a128d6695c93af8c2410d11960dd26943bc330f48d9fd869b","status":"f7f6a04c2d881613e1bc058cb2d424f75cd972ddc936eb03dc0e5bd2edc99fda"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"b0684c9137071efdc351423d1ca1f718e117150a85a2f2ac3d4822edca0f3816"}},"engine_root":"644cba0775f50e57e53fbbb7c5f51a899b58e665e4c3da2522c12c64c6bb4f99","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"af14a640bcd6cb9a5a8e264d727b399568654ab897f3d8eb0326d43e61cac3d5","engine_root":"644cba0775f50e57e53fbbb7c5f51a899b58e665e4c3da2522c12c64c6bb4f99","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"d02487f48e5db084f82a75ee3fde78da4c1ae89295eabe0002d095b604ba76a6","log_size":253,"projections":{"dependencies":"16ef46705046f82a128d6695c93af8c2410d11960dd26943bc330f48d9fd869b","status":"f7f6a04c2d881613e1bc058cb2d424f75cd972ddc936eb03dc0e5bd2edc99fda"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"b0684c9137071efdc351423d1ca1f718e117150a85a2f2ac3d4822edca0f3816"},"seal_hash":"092cfaf09c494d952ce25cb3c6ceabc28c0cb7866612c82b2ffdc5175b820c95"}},"request_hash":"1ac043d80447b0dd17f3eafc82f0c1ffc693662545e2b88b1d65bb27c48ec1aa","submission_id":"seal-253"},"hash":"1950661dba13e775b21f8fdbe06046ad4d428eeec3e435b80c21202f02e10cc8","header":{"body_hash":"d4ba80946183327e5c368723b6cb3c14df6f09d4f17823100b910dca438df052","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"b0684c9137071efdc351423d1ca1f718e117150a85a2f2ac3d4822edca0f3816","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":253,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"eb2a0057bd26b81a787b76d8705d5b57d2a0ac557a964b8ff04f39815709b9e1","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[15,"READ",0],"epoch":29,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25},{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":26},{"binding":[14,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":27},{"binding":[14,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":28},{"binding":[15,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":29}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102663964},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"644cba0775f50e57e53fbbb7c5f51a899b58e665e4c3da2522c12c64c6bb4f99","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"58fac137d7ee3ff6c14b4c6b6ebe5cbe283ffb800320b9c7f24d674d227ac225","submission_id":"ring-members:a835d5f18b4e4c05f72e983d25709bac07839802c080b0c00fc2a22c08543ed1"},"hash":"17c3d1c96065842b31030059bf825d17f58688848a8c580a0dd2e9b94760dfe0","header":{"body_hash":"23254e7eeb0a869cfe20201f253fed1f13bd4d68c9676cff3733a7a041695cad","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"1950661dba13e775b21f8fdbe06046ad4d428eeec3e435b80c21202f02e10cc8","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":254,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"7d71c4610b64bc7299c2088f69e4a8c8046e0228058614ee0b08c0b5e113f4fa","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T53-4421f720bbb903e9","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Therefore, whether intervention duration moderates the impact of GenAI on learning motivation remains unclear.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t53_o1","terms":["intervention duration","moderator","learning motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Given these disciplinary distinctions, the benefits of using GenAI may not be uniform across subjects; therefore, the present study includes subject domain as a moderator.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t53_o2","terms":["subject domain","moderator","learning motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Overall, the evidence remains mixed, warranting further tests of education stage as a moderator.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t53_o3","terms":["education stage","moderator","learning motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"GenAI effects may also differ across publication years.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t53_o4","terms":["publication year","moderator","GenAI effects"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t53_o1","t53_o2","t53_o3","t53_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t53_c1","object":"learning motivation moderators: subject domain, intervention duration, publication year, education stage","predicate":"examines_moderators","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 examines potential moderators of GenAI's effects on learning motivation, including subject domain, intervention duration, publication year, and education stage."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t53_o1","t53_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t53_c2","object":"whether intervention duration and education stage moderate GenAI effects on learning motivation","predicate":"identifies_open_moderator_questions","stance":"open","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 reports that prior evidence is unclear or mixed on whether intervention duration and education stage moderate GenAI's impact on learning motivation."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",11372,15821]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"e01eb30da874467b797c0d1ffbca98e9418082361d77ee742ff5bf76202aaac1","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["2b2c5d72c4b4ede455a0eecdc45c4ce5cf1d1d9d71cce511873cf0b7e2b3674a","7455a02821cc9da5d48044c9032763dec1a9dd0660f801f17594982b1bfecf83","a16d2cc102b59000de3128f514ad9a53e48710831cb49b0bc30e7f0dc490fb50","08afa1abd912f0400aa96065368bf8dc1de175b6589f29e882f030c9729a0ca0","4f25f856fc060e629621e3a734f44dbbac44c09b6a246c5d7e5173c88f18f6db","712ebdb36bfd152b8e53fb467e2754fa32f7d2eea2fecc6343e232d3424517a6"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"97c3d4f624f51998a63302337c987ea8a873d70edaee003ecbdeeb524f05fab6","submission_id":"T53-4421f720bbb903e9#1"},"hash":"fa9e530901f29fdc968a9f3b273ec1325d91f47e222302ea98aacb38777e7404","header":{"body_hash":"0c38d2bd65fe92feb51743d9e113267176f7cbde5e52327347458c7bf94e6f25","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"17c3d1c96065842b31030059bf825d17f58688848a8c580a0dd2e9b94760dfe0","records_root":"55d9bad36526d82fafb21878556e54483166b4858e91c19b8e30eb04ff9ef259","seq":255,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"7851022ab4b46dc0c34ce16e72489fbb6d95068b777e61192050d337c7060eff","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":15,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":29,"task_id":"T53-4421f720bbb903e9"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13647323.txt#2","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"e01eb30da874467b797c0d1ffbca98e9418082361d77ee742ff5bf76202aaac1","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"8e2aab2ab472b55c5531678b39e837c569340309378d3a87cc98a509513a5ea1","submission_id":"T53-4421f720bbb903e9#done2"},"hash":"4bcf844d4507ca676f38f7485a56b6be1c7ddfdbaf910aed0a0fb7c4fd49b817","header":{"body_hash":"0ad19103ded0849ff425cd0152202f8c0606a177cbcdb9c2accc52680d0fb839","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"fa9e530901f29fdc968a9f3b273ec1325d91f47e222302ea98aacb38777e7404","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":256,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"ebf7b112b20ab8d7e61b7e85a8f5985f05fd73c40fa4c3b334f0c6bcba1b3c94","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T54-c8b40d39fe40b848","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Source: Europe PMC PMC13647323, doi:None. Licence: CC BY (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Copyright © 2026 Fang, Li, Xiong and Lu.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t54_o1","terms":["Fang et al. 2026","PMC13647323","article metadata"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Title: Effects of generative artificial intelligence on students' learning motivation: evidence from a meta-analysis","kind":"observe","local_id":"t54_o2","terms":["article title","learning motivation","meta-analysis"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"A random-effects meta-analysis synthesized 56 effect sizes from 42 controlled experimental and quasi-experimental studies involving 6,059 participants.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t54_o3","terms":["56 effect sizes","42 studies","6,059 participants","random-effects meta-analysis"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Moderator analyses assessed variation by educational level, cultural context, subject domain, and device type.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t54_o4","terms":["moderator analyses","educational level","cultural context","subject domain","device type"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The random-effects model showed a positive average effect of GenAI on students' learning motivation (Hedges' g = 0.764).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t54_o5","terms":["Hedges' g = 0.764","learning motivation","main effect"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"However, heterogeneity was very high (I2 = 93.7%), indicating substantial variation across study contexts.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t54_o6","terms":["heterogeneity","I2 = 93.7%"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Exploratory moderator analyses suggested that effects were larger in higher education than in primary/secondary education, larger in collectivistic than individualistic contexts, larger in language learning than in other subjects, and larger when GenAI was used on mobile devices (MD) rather than computers.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t54_o7","terms":["moderator results","higher education","collectivistic","language learning","mobile devices"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The observed subgroup differences should be interpreted cautiously because these moderators represented study-level characteristics rather than experimentally manipulated conditions.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t54_o8","terms":["cautious interpretation","study-level characteristics"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"GenAI-supported learning is associated with higher learning motivation on average; however, the substantial heterogeneity suggests that its motivational benefits are not uniform across educational contexts.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t54_o9","terms":["main conclusion","learning motivation","substantial heterogeneity"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t54_o1","t54_o2","t54_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t54_c1","object":"56 effect sizes on learning motivation from 42 controlled experimental/quasi-experimental studies (6,059 participants)","predicate":"synthesizes_data","stance":"reported","subject":"Fang et al. 2026 (PMC13647323)","text":"Fang et al. 2026 (PMC13647323) rests on a random-effects meta-analysis synthesizing 56 effect sizes on students' learning motivation from 42 controlled experimental and quasi-experimental studies with 6,059 participants."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t54_o1","t54_o5","t54_o6","t54_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t54_c2","object":"positive average effect on learning motivation (Hedges' g = 0.764) with very high heterogeneity (I2 = 93.7%)","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"Fang et al. 2026 (PMC13647323)","text":"Fang et al. 2026 (PMC13647323) concludes that GenAI has a positive average effect on students' learning motivation (Hedges' g = 0.764), though heterogeneity across contexts is very high (I2 = 93.7%)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t54_o1","t54_o4","t54_o7","t54_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t54_c3","object":"larger effects in higher education, collectivistic contexts, language learning, and mobile devices (cautiously interpreted as study-level moderators)","predicate":"reports_moderator_results","stance":"qualified","subject":"Fang et al. 2026 (PMC13647323)","text":"Fang et al. 2026 (PMC13647323) finds larger motivational effects of GenAI in higher education, collectivistic contexts, language learning, and mobile devices, qualified as exploratory study-level subgroup differences."},{"about":["PMC13647323","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t54_q1","needed":"Read subsequent sections (Problem statement, Methods, Results, Discussion, References) of PMC13647323.txt","text":"Which primary studies are included in the 42 synthesized studies of PMC13647323, and does the rest of the article cite or rely on Wang and Fan 2025?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",0,5387]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"fe6bbce26d1f9ca11e1aa8d3bcc68e536ababa1a5983ecd6c2f70acc3d59c012","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["84f6b5d94ef84de06a8baf1985684980166710917b06e5b690f8bff036a84938","0cc5da2e9d0178e36f4bd22710c9333e2645b45338e4d08d879379edc167538c","ee419d37f7f3a91adde665fdb8900cb50159b6e6414209bab6fe74c337bc6d86","b8a6b830fb42bf15dcfab65ec5d670dca1d2a27ff81e283e3a0d8b751dbfe102","1add7afcc218f8c67ea5649b00d41c25e96afd8e67596f41cc6518b690a1f9ac","fd3c44ea3c11bdc16e30d0816424e8f6307c87cec35461f0dac4618aa6fc1753","a35077fcb2fed072f79dea6414932bd8d67ea34fa7ce216bba25390b1cc42d96","3f43326cc1facac75694b9470cbaa73008f93f0015bfe0f57764958942426a5f","9cec90a915f4cb77af91065d34b63157da307154b014b90027064666da4645bd","3708cc2df47a3e8c94329e4e446a32b9c0edd1e43b85df96519cc2f9748fb607","dfd29d54438fe5ec01424de96f328e02c5778b7a371b073e2180e8db5cbc9244","bf9cf5fd007b4f5dd0f9a8de0606bb2ca9ccc640e077d9fe0f9b90322e44345c","0a8b6799bab6edd0841911e4e9e8b1a3d11d09c7dfe0c80add1d2e89996eba34"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"0ab33b20505db23a27ed58147b978dc1db11ee3e63466f3b4422f04bd3d2a176","submission_id":"T54-c8b40d39fe40b848#1"},"hash":"c1be3e22ae5e612d891cccbcf91919cf500706b8394c6a5a016d91a0566fcd3a","header":{"body_hash":"f2161b65306a01360d422929a91aac3f452503101230ad2e2e43f9ad9c56eb35","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"4bcf844d4507ca676f38f7485a56b6be1c7ddfdbaf910aed0a0fb7c4fd49b817","records_root":"4da3f5f345d64c1b2df27a33f3fb40b9f740bcad194fa5f8f943b845b8f70580","seq":257,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"8f5358a19c969e8d0262df9b380e1ba1e366dae001869a87b01d6dd6ee072ec6","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":15,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":29,"task_id":"T54-c8b40d39fe40b848"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13647323.txt#0","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"fe6bbce26d1f9ca11e1aa8d3bcc68e536ababa1a5983ecd6c2f70acc3d59c012","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"02263838914c4777fe1421eef004418e4941856db46304d1d0be7e7821fff736","submission_id":"T54-c8b40d39fe40b848#done2"},"hash":"4be0bb3768cbff552d9326214f9352d54c8f9d5d62a5d452741e4986b4b14fa2","header":{"body_hash":"a4405c2b4fe944f83a503a5db0b9c4f9e575f232cf3d5042bf673c85d2649677","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"c1be3e22ae5e612d891cccbcf91919cf500706b8394c6a5a016d91a0566fcd3a","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":258,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"a2c8ea973d4d01db87d1d592cbdc42f952851b85819eaf9943fbf56bff9811fc","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T52-d8a652b062885997","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"A systematic quantitative synthesis is therefore needed to establish the overall relationship between GenAI and learning motivation","kind":"observe","local_id":"t52_o1","terms":["systematic quantitative synthesis","GenAI","learning motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"identify the factors that may explain differences in observed effects across studies, so as to give robust evidence for educators and policymakers","kind":"observe","local_id":"t52_o2","terms":["moderating factors","observed effects across studies"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"existing evidence suggests that benefits of GenAI appear to be more strongly related to intrinsic rather than extrinsic motivation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t52_o3","terms":["intrinsic motivation","extrinsic motivation","GenAI benefits"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t52_o1","t52_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t52_c1","object":"GenAI and student learning motivation (and moderating factors across studies)","predicate":"synthesizes_relationship_between","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 conducts a systematic quantitative synthesis to establish the overall relationship between GenAI and student learning motivation and to identify factors explaining variation in effects across studies."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t52_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t52_c2","object":"GenAI benefits relate more strongly to intrinsic motivation than extrinsic motivation","predicate":"reports_prior_literature_pattern","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"In its literature review, PMC13647323 reports that prior empirical evidence indicates GenAI benefits are more strongly associated with intrinsic motivation than extrinsic motivation."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",5387,11372]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"6621d95883d7db87a0b71ae55d05506d10b2ce50d88cac275dad3a0ee4791dbc","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["5e8b9985849ca2e4ec34b9df16c37571fb3ad6afeb24f8be7147ce673e4a0bbe","b8f9e01cee17cdf131e376b6c9ff4b4ad96948fc11538ddfec1100e97b16db38","385b6e71629af3105c9f970d95169d9c21c60a589b612111fc5bfff9b501a0ac","650b642738e564244ed70795ba510e2e419464b4bfb01b0af5eb2181db24acc2","97cf84253454426906cebd4b2de5a280b64248803308f81d80d8efb03eb8b7d2"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"42adbcf1f2e4071873296d9816a6fe231bdee0402702bf91b640a48421de9e64","submission_id":"T52-d8a652b062885997#1"},"hash":"54ba755bede8c2640bfd331fe5beedc6507888155674054afdeadd50618d8a59","header":{"body_hash":"3ea9085a39c91430f8f87924eacf5d68aa8f28f3d2c26835f8c26dd844a28dfb","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"4be0bb3768cbff552d9326214f9352d54c8f9d5d62a5d452741e4986b4b14fa2","records_root":"2885ec500d76c9ce72e6fcc0d760b432dd961c28910c6acf84d30f435372e2f4","seq":259,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"00f3c9f2229fcbcf42035d3e69c54d8d0cd5cb6b62d07c56ba635c5cf52f84d8","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":15,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":29,"task_id":"T52-d8a652b062885997"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13647323.txt#1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"6621d95883d7db87a0b71ae55d05506d10b2ce50d88cac275dad3a0ee4791dbc","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"1261744de827ea629b76682fe0f660bd5e784719aaf745576b3c1fef7356b4f9","submission_id":"T52-d8a652b062885997#done2"},"hash":"eb3553779dc06d1f1c4f65b4a4f8191e0f568ac417d9e9ba532b3740b90604de","header":{"body_hash":"8af8f57545cb8f501dd7bf1bb379e97137ccad0c2582cb1d32e3efb346d1ecf9","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"54ba755bede8c2640bfd331fe5beedc6507888155674054afdeadd50618d8a59","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":260,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"ea0cc6a2b0846c8a6d8f5008709f95d1dc90494dcfe0318ea8107cfc6063505b","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":15,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":682},"started_unix_ms":1795102688719,"wave":{"doc:PMC13647323.txt#0":"reader-3","doc:PMC13647323.txt#1":"reader-1","doc:PMC13647323.txt#2":"reader-2"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"6621d95883d7db87a0b71ae55d05506d10b2ce50d88cac275dad3a0ee4791dbc","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"88f63363a1f81085f5d6f8a058487601e803e88da58c0547eb3bc10b26bb0365","submission_id":"circle:15483b3976ee1db94366cb2fc9a41a1a92b08594bb561b776ae0628c44eabcab"},"hash":"2f3c3365d8859c458b6e89c71ca290c93f79d51f9278ac16a90ffbfc21f70fff","header":{"body_hash":"e6186175352a06d35e78173c423b580856d20fd7b20efd7131ed8d8b105c57d3","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"eb3553779dc06d1f1c4f65b4a4f8191e0f568ac417d9e9ba532b3740b90604de","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":261,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"1f9f33999ebc25eef0eca51f048bf91ffae662749f0f7912812360204fe6f9a6","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"ea0cc6a2b0846c8a6d8f5008709f95d1dc90494dcfe0318ea8107cfc6063505b","engine_root":"6621d95883d7db87a0b71ae55d05506d10b2ce50d88cac275dad3a0ee4791dbc","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"4ce0aba45b09cd7c1cf908793cf47b29e3b6f584f5f2f19fc5c185bf11808f4c","log_size":262,"projections":{"dependencies":"70ca4fb5a76befd54cf5e3a6bf5ef7b054f44f79fd893ae42e2c1d7fb7ad21b7","status":"9760dc758fdef0b005c216eba6cf7384aec999128a8c5f1e1f237d9b923fa8c8"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"2f3c3365d8859c458b6e89c71ca290c93f79d51f9278ac16a90ffbfc21f70fff"}},"engine_root":"6621d95883d7db87a0b71ae55d05506d10b2ce50d88cac275dad3a0ee4791dbc","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"ea0cc6a2b0846c8a6d8f5008709f95d1dc90494dcfe0318ea8107cfc6063505b","engine_root":"6621d95883d7db87a0b71ae55d05506d10b2ce50d88cac275dad3a0ee4791dbc","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"4ce0aba45b09cd7c1cf908793cf47b29e3b6f584f5f2f19fc5c185bf11808f4c","log_size":262,"projections":{"dependencies":"70ca4fb5a76befd54cf5e3a6bf5ef7b054f44f79fd893ae42e2c1d7fb7ad21b7","status":"9760dc758fdef0b005c216eba6cf7384aec999128a8c5f1e1f237d9b923fa8c8"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"2f3c3365d8859c458b6e89c71ca290c93f79d51f9278ac16a90ffbfc21f70fff"},"seal_hash":"668ba5830877299e48549ca37ea3439b2663e988dd0ab741d630cfdee5794461"}},"request_hash":"c0ec5a159299196a41d6a7ac69d607b9ed6f700c439a7303e6ef0305822364f7","submission_id":"seal-262"},"hash":"e172e7d9e2eddda0aa0c5f2a8f8ee0b255b552aa12e5e5eb7180f97a1e024ebb","header":{"body_hash":"0886f0bf34a38b967baccd35dfe890da6b754a7cc577d7b8a5c0f62139bd3d0a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"2f3c3365d8859c458b6e89c71ca290c93f79d51f9278ac16a90ffbfc21f70fff","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":262,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"f5c3160f825b595e5da40ac4ae70931f9c2c87bcc5ac8f529b96ee862c065f20","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[15,"BUILD",0],"epoch":30,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25},{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":26},{"binding":[14,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":27},{"binding":[14,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":28},{"binding":[15,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":29},{"binding":[15,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":30}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102688719},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"6621d95883d7db87a0b71ae55d05506d10b2ce50d88cac275dad3a0ee4791dbc","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"660e11eb7e76e8383e92d64de13b49b933b8a956d97df42f756c9f945795d354","submission_id":"ring-members:9985470ef6efa1eeed4ad6758af1eb55b2392339226e93e8698ae797925c8e35"},"hash":"49eab260cda7f63bf5cd6c4ef41820075aae83697d0ee882516670ab42fe19b8","header":{"body_hash":"65f4f58466d97dc598f4d79bf951106a7a573e5980958ae3feae41187c418181","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"e172e7d9e2eddda0aa0c5f2a8f8ee0b255b552aa12e5e5eb7180f97a1e024ebb","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":263,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"660187e73c3206f2ac2e13dd4d6a679d5d25f6d8916de5d3e0a75a4c650b30a0","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":16,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":682},"started_unix_ms":1795102688756,"wave":{"doc:PMC13647323.txt#3":"reader-1","doc:PMC13647323.txt#4":"reader-2","doc:PMC13647323.txt#5":"reader-3"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"6621d95883d7db87a0b71ae55d05506d10b2ce50d88cac275dad3a0ee4791dbc","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"0317dcae2e6dffc660020165f195c786a5349337525ea52fc72c57f0084a9959","submission_id":"circle:2878df6c9b0fc669c62e6306d1e1a1e27d5e8d24a99d7138fde08eb3ec2dbea1"},"hash":"16511405ba9b17bbf35f55a3829d3e46bfc17459f24ebac6902b22ee710a9f01","header":{"body_hash":"b5f696cfbe3b9c66711dc89acf8f36cc7c6d0792a18747f1dfeffba6031f3073","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"49eab260cda7f63bf5cd6c4ef41820075aae83697d0ee882516670ab42fe19b8","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":264,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"c29f08314bddf930c5e6b3f71b3f03a8e3b8cfd86e20fa7f40d2b760bdb7b1d3","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"660187e73c3206f2ac2e13dd4d6a679d5d25f6d8916de5d3e0a75a4c650b30a0","engine_root":"6621d95883d7db87a0b71ae55d05506d10b2ce50d88cac275dad3a0ee4791dbc","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"f3e55b55bfb2af657bfa6772b806edeefe94a4eedf8f1d12a00f59df36f99a20","log_size":265,"projections":{"dependencies":"70ca4fb5a76befd54cf5e3a6bf5ef7b054f44f79fd893ae42e2c1d7fb7ad21b7","status":"9760dc758fdef0b005c216eba6cf7384aec999128a8c5f1e1f237d9b923fa8c8"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"16511405ba9b17bbf35f55a3829d3e46bfc17459f24ebac6902b22ee710a9f01"}},"engine_root":"6621d95883d7db87a0b71ae55d05506d10b2ce50d88cac275dad3a0ee4791dbc","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"660187e73c3206f2ac2e13dd4d6a679d5d25f6d8916de5d3e0a75a4c650b30a0","engine_root":"6621d95883d7db87a0b71ae55d05506d10b2ce50d88cac275dad3a0ee4791dbc","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"f3e55b55bfb2af657bfa6772b806edeefe94a4eedf8f1d12a00f59df36f99a20","log_size":265,"projections":{"dependencies":"70ca4fb5a76befd54cf5e3a6bf5ef7b054f44f79fd893ae42e2c1d7fb7ad21b7","status":"9760dc758fdef0b005c216eba6cf7384aec999128a8c5f1e1f237d9b923fa8c8"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"16511405ba9b17bbf35f55a3829d3e46bfc17459f24ebac6902b22ee710a9f01"},"seal_hash":"f127ff29c987003e9d2ae94cf0fe90047a4c83c9d8e130e149923fbc6fa3592a"}},"request_hash":"a25c0ceff783364b009d71b2f9d1d88639606d04e0eb0021654f888070cada2e","submission_id":"seal-265"},"hash":"80c58c9bedecfafa96d8489d42494c2b211c375a1c96c81d8e79c46eef039ca6","header":{"body_hash":"ab579ae75739fc1bbf80a4729a91754ec0138da40c6525bb59746456c99283a4","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"16511405ba9b17bbf35f55a3829d3e46bfc17459f24ebac6902b22ee710a9f01","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":265,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"543fd4eb73c9399df54ec533cc1609a03a23144db3427365dfc8c8292a255ed6","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[16,"READ",0],"epoch":31,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25},{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":26},{"binding":[14,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":27},{"binding":[14,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":28},{"binding":[15,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":29},{"binding":[15,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":30},{"binding":[16,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":31}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102688756},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"6621d95883d7db87a0b71ae55d05506d10b2ce50d88cac275dad3a0ee4791dbc","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"0972cff7fd62ed05cf0ec9024813f98c1d7f620d893bb212620cd8966573bdd3","submission_id":"ring-members:89797ef3d35b3141f95789bfb7d0422b1ac146d76d724575894563ad95f91f00"},"hash":"8e8e016965cb2ebb1c14f65205c20167b6cd49909b3ff8fb80dace48cb84d2ba","header":{"body_hash":"371bd0bb167d1c3673185fd9d78cc979a73a112ace3528c15ee040b75ee2f920","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"80c58c9bedecfafa96d8489d42494c2b211c375a1c96c81d8e79c46eef039ca6","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":266,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"787daa0a3ecc89519e70c31d57e710a606198e174ea917dd619d3ddea9a71c51","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T55-133d3fd52d044244","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Outcome | Quantitatively assessed learning motivation, including learning motivation, academic motivation, motivation to learn, intrinsic motivation, extrinsic motivation","kind":"observe","local_id":"t55_o1","terms":["PMC13647323","outcomes measured","learning motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Study design | Controlled experimental or quasi-experimental studies that included both a GenAI-supported group and a non-GenAI comparison group","kind":"observe","local_id":"t55_o2","terms":["PMC13647323","included studies","study design"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Total BQAPS scores ranged from 18 to 23 (M = 20.38), indicating that the included studies ranged from medium-high to very high methodological quality","kind":"observe","local_id":"t55_o3","terms":["PMC13647323","study quality","BQAPS scores"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"extracted posttest means, standard deviations, and sample sizes for the experimental and control groups to compute effect sizes (Hedges' g).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t55_o4","terms":["PMC13647323","effect size metric","Hedges' g"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The final coded dataset comprised 56 effect sizes, as shown in Table 7 in Appendix A.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t55_o5","terms":["PMC13647323","dataset size","56 effect sizes"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Motivation type was coded only as intrinsic motivation or extrinsic motivation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t55_o6","terms":["PMC13647323","motivation type coding","intrinsic and extrinsic motivation"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t55_o1","t55_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t55_c1","object":"controlled experimental/quasi-experimental GenAI vs. non-GenAI studies measuring quantitative learning motivation","predicate":"analyzes_studies_and_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 is a meta-analysis of controlled experimental and quasi-experimental studies comparing GenAI-supported and non-GenAI comparison groups on quantitatively assessed learning motivation."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t55_o4","t55_o5","t55_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t55_c2","object":"56 Hedges' g effect sizes of learning motivation coded as intrinsic or extrinsic motivation","predicate":"measures_and_codes_data","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 computes Hedges' g effect sizes from posttest means, SDs, and sample sizes across a final coded dataset of 56 effect sizes, coding motivation type as intrinsic or extrinsic motivation."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t55_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t55_c3","object":"BQAPS scores 18 to 23 (M = 20.38), medium-high to very high methodological quality","predicate":"evaluates_primary_study_quality","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"In PMC13647323, the included primary studies achieved total BQAPS methodological quality scores ranging from 18 to 23 (M = 20.38 out of 24), indicating medium-high to very high quality."},{"about":["PMC13647323"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t55_q1","needed":"Check the Results, Discussion, Conclusion, References, and Appendix A (Tables 6 and 7) sections of PMC13647323.txt","text":"Which primary studies are included in the 56 effect sizes of PMC13647323 (Table 6 and Table 7 in Appendix A), and what are the main pooled effect size results and conclusions?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",27440,33015]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"50711046fcdd4f2cd07495e15303039f924a2d717ff29811845282fcccf71b1b","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["d17a3218c9172c9aada2f7abc7327410815497f0595dd3bca46c7cf632dec4ad","08a008c50aa08b2eddd5d87dcc111c0b4779ca0cb559910a63fa20ea7443adca","c28c8b3438565934e4c976b3b1b99e9388400c910998a6cdb3fa3e915f61fead","6e2347cdfffdf34fdc8e1f336ff8c10d03ec9a8e9fc3d53ba4dfffa7d8aeb147","0e4868d711d2c1443555b84560d491e66cb8eb1d5189fe588a4c72177bdeff27","e5f5f7d7739078f7f1ff2acbe7035b919e1ea10bfe85a060bf3c4cac7225ac39","79d12d31b034b083446cdb16c7b73a8b019846a2a86ccf15eca5465ceebd1b1f","fbeda17c3263b2fda38942cf02c7af311634035553a8e9b97ba6348294fca86a","397c788a7e9c7b97248825a4b6373df62c98db2325e227fe86db2c1114fcac2a","e94e081d7f94da9b786e189272d3d4e0c02c9903029828dcb707c1355a9d4a7d"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"2c2f461a15c584778d1f882a576246c662dd317b51951df3a76b83c20cf9bf7b","submission_id":"T55-133d3fd52d044244#1"},"hash":"519dbd591ac2e716aa071b2c97e4dbb59b44a0dc18ad922f162985bc620154bd","header":{"body_hash":"74ce2f0894016676289c13e03cbbfa9113b09260c0a0f8078e35ba177dfc9df6","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"8e8e016965cb2ebb1c14f65205c20167b6cd49909b3ff8fb80dace48cb84d2ba","records_root":"4f28e9dbf8367d1545c9847eb9765db4231f7f3898c9daf652e38099f3c87cd1","seq":267,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"e1091fbc4c21cee86431dde47c0f993d241a8a4ed900893043d89a2abcf1b11b","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":16,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":31,"task_id":"T55-133d3fd52d044244"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13647323.txt#5","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"50711046fcdd4f2cd07495e15303039f924a2d717ff29811845282fcccf71b1b","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"fec47d67fff2b7df7bb87fafa199510d6338cf718cc692980df69317274f887b","submission_id":"T55-133d3fd52d044244#done2"},"hash":"06e4f052195cbb093c1ea65e44178bec37add59b86cc2f57d886eb5251d77647","header":{"body_hash":"ebd3b0919f74a0d33714e3c25931442e92e6d0dc9d9426d3331fd6aa38126dd5","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"519dbd591ac2e716aa071b2c97e4dbb59b44a0dc18ad922f162985bc620154bd","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":268,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"df5fe85ec9b60d62fbb9483c0dffc6d135e73f092bc1ae96d54be8eacde8567a","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T56-5f836b5efc2fa78c","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"For example, ChatGPT has been associated with better academic outcomes, affective–motivational states, and dispositions toward higher-order thinking (Deng et al., 2025; Wang and Fan, 2025; Zhao et al., 2025; Nie et al., 2025; Mo et al., 2026).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t56_o1","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025 citation","ChatGPT academic outcomes","affective-motivational states","higher-order thinking"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Specifically, the present study conducts a meta-analysis to estimate the overall effect of GenAI on students' learning motivation and to examine whether this effect varies by GenAI characteristics, study characteristics, and demographic factors.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t56_o2","terms":["study design","meta-analysis","learning motivation","moderators"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"In this study, GenAI device type was coded as mobile devices (MD) vs. PCs.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t56_o3","terms":["GenAI device type moderator","mobile devices vs PCs"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Following a prior meta-analysis, GenAI function can be classified as assessment (evaluating student performance), personalized learning support (PLS) and intelligent tutoring systems (ITS) (Zhu et al., 2025).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t56_o4","terms":["GenAI function moderator classification","assessment","personalized learning support","intelligent tutoring systems"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The present study adopts the same scheme to test whether GenAI function moderates GenAI's effects on learning motivation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t56_o5","terms":["GenAI function moderator"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Following Hofstede's cultural dimensions, we classify contexts as collectivist vs. individualist (Khlif, 2016).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t56_o6","terms":["cultural background classification","collectivist vs individualist"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Therefore, we examine cultural background as a moderator.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t56_o7","terms":["cultural background moderator"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"H-1a. Students using GenAI have more intrinsic motivation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t56_o8","terms":["hypothesis H-1a","intrinsic motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"H-1b. Students using GenAI have more extrinsic motivation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t56_o9","terms":["hypothesis H-1b","extrinsic motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"H-1c. GenAI shows a larger effect on intrinsic motivation than extrinsic motivation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t56_o10","terms":["hypothesis H-1c","intrinsic vs extrinsic motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"H-2. The link between GenAI and learning motivation is stronger in later years.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t56_o11","terms":["hypothesis H-2","publication year moderator"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"H-3. The link between GenAI and learning motivation is stronger for male students than for female students.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t56_o12","terms":["hypothesis H-3","gender moderator"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t56_o1","@33dbc45b04e1c601"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t56_c1","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (ChatGPT associated with better academic outcomes, affective-motivational states, and dispositions toward higher-order thinking)","predicate":"cites_Wang_and_Fan_2025_for","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 cites Wang and Fan 2025 (with Deng et al., 2025; Zhao et al., 2025; Nie et al., 2025; Mo et al., 2026) to support that ChatGPT is associated with better academic outcomes, affective-motivational states, and higher-order thinking."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t56_o2","t56_o8","t56_o9","t56_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t56_c2","object":"meta-analysis of GenAI effect on students' learning motivation (intrinsic, extrinsic) moderated by GenAI, study, and demographic factors","predicate":"examines_outcomes_and_moderators","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 conducts a meta-analysis estimating the overall effect of GenAI on students' learning motivation (intrinsic and extrinsic) and moderation by GenAI characteristics, study characteristics, and demographic factors."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t56_o3","t56_o4","t56_o5","t56_o6","t56_o7","t56_o11","t56_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t56_c3","object":"cultural background (collectivist vs. individualist), device type (MD vs. PCs), GenAI function (assessment, PLS, ITS), year, and gender","predicate":"tests_moderators","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 tests cultural background (collectivist vs. individualist), GenAI device type (mobile devices vs. PCs), GenAI function (assessment, PLS, ITS), year, and gender as moderators of GenAI's effect on learning motivation."},{"about":["PMC13647323"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t56_q1","needed":"Read the Research method, Results, Discussion, and References sections of PMC13647323.txt to record the sample size, included studies, and meta-analytic findings for H-1a..H-3.","text":"What are the main empirical meta-analytic results, effect sizes, and included primary study dataset details of PMC13647323?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",15821,21668]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"97031b87e12f651bedeb0342ff7b415278e523a97aa54d7d4b43e2e0db2ab9f5","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["5ba36d0ed6ebadc82a39d48cc9945ad68213c939e57e21e4962589bfc1e4a3e0","02ac2d80dacc43a46f0d5764098f99152575f910628b421eb915f12bcc20e94c","9c18ba44e30c2b303f9e4536aa736b83cca544167359fd76a77bae4c66133e14","14481bdb74d88d8c0cac69cfa05381adc1aabfe9b2eb7331ea029e83dfe5b277","8d0dd7807ec13c572f6807096823ba3853a6e1d481d53526c3f3563d12b7207b","119fd003a2f0d64d2e103321c35f1c47e62f81d921a7964479f5b423f95407ec","789b2c492cb07d284c64f0532ade44de0affe5c45dd5cc530f84386d1eef4c98","3cf89c0564f05ab8068b33b238e583cc96f7e0ce1a8d75bcca2ea8d736402cb7","2d31d284beecc1d67e7b2df6203fe8a8b7544b7ed3496b230505e3666c40997b","79f36ed5e7d4b6d63b1c4ce861ffbfb6376e74c21f19b946cb9409b22b6ce38c","d5d3148bc57b9756cbb1da6c99d82bb0ebfe577bfb69e921b2de296e9680b23e","3e4123b0e2effda421994c37f09bafe726378c6f73bef3f59f2ec23a71fbd93c"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":12}},"request_hash":"7a596ff73dad2dc0cdfc0711731ca4ea39773a628b4ae08a2ec448b44e91e01f","submission_id":"T56-5f836b5efc2fa78c#1"},"hash":"2e67acedc95a46908690ed0ab3caaff9a51d6987dc19bbd3871ee1db1e4bda33","header":{"body_hash":"26fde4973fdf5eacd966099342a76b5830ad3d014ade0c67334e3b8018c5f973","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"06e4f052195cbb093c1ea65e44178bec37add59b86cc2f57d886eb5251d77647","records_root":"c649ab9d90bb0a5628bad827a561e48bbfcad0f9360ad7680a569622ded7a711","seq":269,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"a2d1138b642edad0e6088043d73d82be70ab9fcf13d17dd1ce6d61cdbfafb024","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T56-5f836b5efc2fa78c","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t56_o2","t56_o8","t56_o9","t56_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t56_c2","object":"meta-analysis of GenAI effect on students' learning motivation (intrinsic, extrinsic) moderated by GenAI, study, and demographic factors","predicate":"examines_outcomes_and_moderators","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 conducts a meta-analysis estimating the overall effect of GenAI on students' learning motivation (intrinsic and extrinsic) and moderation by GenAI characteristics, study characteristics, and demographic factors."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t56_o3","t56_o4","t56_o5","t56_o6","t56_o7","t56_o11","t56_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t56_c3","object":"cultural background (collectivist vs. individualist), device type (MD vs. PCs), GenAI function (assessment, PLS, ITS), year, and gender","predicate":"tests_moderators","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 tests cultural background (collectivist vs. individualist), GenAI device type (mobile devices vs. PCs), GenAI function (assessment, PLS, ITS), year, and gender as moderators of GenAI's effect on learning motivation."},{"about":["PMC13647323"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t56_q1","needed":"Read the Research method, Results, Discussion, and References sections of PMC13647323.txt to record the sample size, included studies, and meta-analytic findings for H-1a..H-3.","text":"What are the main empirical meta-analytic results, effect sizes, and included primary study dataset details of PMC13647323?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",15821,21668]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"97031b87e12f651bedeb0342ff7b415278e523a97aa54d7d4b43e2e0db2ab9f5","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["ed7d8256a59b85069106a3d445fdeb27d2f03ff94cddf445277cff4ffd8da5ec","a715c9f86ff1c65cc0a55bd7c5aacb6435b867f12171c51c9b4ba9b3c4c908f4","4bc6228cb980de6b87e871fd55cc7b849a6b6e0e326832155b4f335b41f2645c"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"beea8c6e367697c176f5773af41141b5f760c4a7afcbc6399a83e7c5d1f93dd4","submission_id":"T56-5f836b5efc2fa78c#1.1"},"hash":"c0b4a17238ff8e25648a8ca047603ba71e0dc9631aa6b81ad23fc7317bf46ce2","header":{"body_hash":"2fb0a0220c287de88eda1172ef6f6dfc77e0fb5d84a54f5813f88024264f035e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"2e67acedc95a46908690ed0ab3caaff9a51d6987dc19bbd3871ee1db1e4bda33","records_root":"3bd607b2fd981009a4c9315e176531e7916b91973e02bf52f562bd66fd58d523","seq":270,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"02755f69bb1c8d64bcd0a1d9f99f4451f04d9ff51b366c92529e8ad4d8611c7b","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@5ba36d0ed6ebadc8","@02ac2d80dacc43a4","@9c18ba44e30c2b30","@14481bdb74d88d8c","@8d0dd7807ec13c57","@119fd003a2f0d64d","@789b2c492cb07d28","@3cf89c0564f05ab8","@2d31d284beecc1d6","@79f36ed5e7d4b6d6","@d5d3148bc57b9756","@3e4123b0e2effda4","@ed7d8256a59b8506","@a715c9f86ff1c65c","@4bc6228cb980de6b"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":12,"local_id":"t56_c1"}],"task_id":"T56-5f836b5efc2fa78c","work_key":"doc:PMC13647323.txt#3"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T56-5f836b5efc2fa78c:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"97031b87e12f651bedeb0342ff7b415278e523a97aa54d7d4b43e2e0db2ab9f5","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"efe8daff7f0e2b006a07314fd97392ff35fa0b37b453e2c3264a58f57fde6bda","submission_id":"T56-5f836b5efc2fa78c#repair1"},"hash":"aed84f0a3d6dad00541301c3b3345b5ee89c972bf46a74ed4d7f8714492f5bc0","header":{"body_hash":"6307a4b928c7ac5184491b3be7b2998b4f857a1730fa914c129985ba7d88d450","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"c0b4a17238ff8e25648a8ca047603ba71e0dc9631aa6b81ad23fc7317bf46ce2","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":271,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"aafa2b965dbc561d500d307c3984e926db435d63d9aae73de4a5b380f2ba4cdc","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T57-bf15c11803d8bb77","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"to estimate the overall effect of GenAI on learning motivation, quantify between-study heterogeneity, and examine whether study characteristics, learner demographics, and GenAI-related features","kind":"observe","local_id":"t57_o1","terms":["study aims","learning motivation","between-study heterogeneity","moderators"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Accordingly, studies published between January 2023 and November 2025 were searched.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t57_o2","terms":["search date range","January 2023 to November 2025"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The search procedures followed the PRISMA 2020 reporting guideline (Page et al., 2021) and were conducted in major academic databases and platforms, including Web of Science, ERIC, ProQuest, EBSCO, and Scopus.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t57_o3","terms":["PRISMA 2020","databases searched","Web of Science","ERIC","ProQuest","EBSCO","Scopus"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The initial database search yielded 2,365 records. A second-round search using citation chasing (i.e., reviewing the reference lists and citing articles of the retrieved studies) identified an additional 74 records.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t57_o4","terms":["initial search count","2,365 records","citation chasing","74 records"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"After removing 541 duplicates, 1,898 records remained.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t57_o5","terms":["duplicates removed","1,898 records screened"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"These sources included peer-reviewed journal articles and published full conference papers.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t57_o6","terms":["source types","peer-reviewed journal articles","conference papers"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Population: Participants were students enrolled in formal educational settings, ranging from primary school to university.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t57_o7","terms":["population criteria","formal educational settings","primary school to university"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Intervention: The experimental condition involved learning or instruction supported by generative artificial intelligence, such as large language model-based chatbots, GenAI tutors, or systems","kind":"observe","local_id":"t57_o8","terms":["intervention criteria","GenAI-supported learning","chatbots","GenAI tutors"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Comparator: The comparison group studied the same or closely related content without GenAI support, including conventional instruction or non-GenAI-supported digital learning.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t57_o9","terms":["comparator criteria","without GenAI support"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Outcome: Learning motivation was assessed quantitatively using a scale, subscale, or composite score explicitly described by the original authors as learning motivation, academic motivation, motivation to learn, intrinsic motivation, extrinsic motivation, or a closely related motivational construct.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t57_o10","terms":["outcome measured","learning motivation","quantitative scale","intrinsic motivation","extrinsic motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Study design: Studies employed a controlled experimental or quasi-experimental design that included both a GenAI-supported group and a non-GenAI comparison group.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t57_o11","terms":["study design criteria","controlled experimental","quasi-experimental"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The study reported sufficient statistics to compute effect sizes, including sample size, mean(s), and standard deviation(s).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t57_o12","terms":["statistical data requirement","sample size","mean","standard deviation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Applying these criteria, 42 eligible studies (56 effect sizes) were ultimately included in the meta-analysis.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t57_o13","terms":["included studies","42 studies","56 effect sizes"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t57_o1"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t57_c1","object":"overall effect of GenAI on learning motivation, between-study heterogeneity, and moderator variables","predicate":"evaluates_aims","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 is a meta-analysis aiming to estimate the overall effect of GenAI on student learning motivation, quantify between-study heterogeneity, and examine study, learner, and GenAI moderator features."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t57_o2","t57_o3","t57_o4","t57_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t57_c2","object":"Web of Science, ERIC, ProQuest, EBSCO, Scopus (Jan 2023-Nov 2025; 2,365 records) and citation chasing (74 records), yielding 1,898 after deduplication","predicate":"searches_data_sources","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 rests on a PRISMA 2020 search of Web of Science, ERIC, ProQuest, EBSCO, and Scopus (Jan 2023-Nov 2025) plus citation chasing, screening 1,898 unique records from 2,439 identified."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t57_o6","t57_o7","t57_o8","t57_o9","t57_o11","t57_o12","t57_o13"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t57_c3","object":"42 controlled experimental/quasi-experimental studies (56 effect sizes) of primary-to-university students in peer-reviewed journals and conference papers","predicate":"rests_on_studies","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 includes 42 eligible controlled experimental or quasi-experimental studies (56 effect sizes) of primary-to-university students comparing GenAI-supported learning with non-GenAI instruction."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t57_o10","t57_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t57_c4","object":"quantitative learning motivation (learning, academic, intrinsic, or extrinsic motivation scales/subscales/composites)","predicate":"measures_outcome","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 measures quantitative learning motivation outcomes (scales, subscales, or composite scores for learning, academic, intrinsic, or extrinsic motivation) with sample sizes, means, and standard deviations."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",21668,27440]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"dac26ba2cd2c95a92fb25e59c4bea749de3d6d107d770917a9cbeeef7e1007f1","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["d5e75611e9f288db8f4c1affc54696367b287ea130ee7a049fe35ad6f9e79631","2820b5759c7879fef701f449b33c059aeb8271af7d410f9bfbe92e965f80ccc1","0fff6b2d0f1af8f307456f111a279f772afebea6cea0f4401d2ca53cfe723fc1","1ae03c7a2aca853b28e73e5993749e59dd830d787dd866e3adca0b5d0d2a3f96","115baff09d5ff76433761cd98e4b2a006edfc30ee09784ec302ca7c22fa7107a","ae7fcdb0a791e5dbd206acd70718e8e9b02a9065c976fb7805de5aeed981b798","330e485d1da601b452355bbd08fea709e173c37efff17a1580bbb5456efb4369","1f1c46cef854d52d0b75590a8fe757a0c7f17a4d50397293eb5572d89a229f00","f6ebc6f9096d3dce03a6b171fd5a941afbe4815700afbea0acc1ea6908b44cbc","5d2f7e4345917dd9328e3f12c5519fd290d2ae7dc702e68ef918828b777ea915","3042d0c4ef16d7ddabf1c659cb09ff4e465ceb96e7ad583b8eb117f6de9c7aea","3a8cbea1f64b59a41880d7bc1e9e4347e93d6a570cd6f494e19884ce528af4f7","8ba974c364d52e6b43d75f8026bcfff3d4a324e22485650de8b6b821e8f674ea","878418a76e821e827c674f63922cdca27c9032850dcb1f43ba5de9ad8b7ccbf7","ea2fbe54d0838d1947b350577e64c0afae8601374cfd9076499418fb74c3f857","dbf9ebffc05df49fb0980fed86c458261b8fb691cb3b91fbaad4d0c0f38d839d","8fe58963de0ab243aa99801569315f741c77c96a75968cdfefb571e5c48386df"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"62929b6f0c8e3d25783c205e1e320181928ad723f7f22f537d2373ba0894c7c0","submission_id":"T57-bf15c11803d8bb77#1"},"hash":"ff604cc2f456c8485cce11f9cf8780f4c20b1533b9882f0ac48aa5ed914275b2","header":{"body_hash":"d446c863722fd96430c01cbb7ec66e55ea57f225915caaa48d70b22233c2b00b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"aed84f0a3d6dad00541301c3b3345b5ee89c972bf46a74ed4d7f8714492f5bc0","records_root":"2ee6471c2f6423772a58a46d4c8566d9be0cf9f06651cc740fd878dec1f7264a","seq":272,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"b926d2b1d35c4dc117cad9aac5e769709691fb039ad83b0c27e28712abfce6d1","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":16,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":31,"task_id":"T57-bf15c11803d8bb77"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13647323.txt#4","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"dac26ba2cd2c95a92fb25e59c4bea749de3d6d107d770917a9cbeeef7e1007f1","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"42e09257401fde3b7ed3a4abeb662cdaf502460bdaf7a8615099ab5388838271","submission_id":"T57-bf15c11803d8bb77#done2"},"hash":"51e7cce1f1f39d196a6b498929a4bfbf7e5e87806bb671708795b501b686d755","header":{"body_hash":"d78ba6288ffddb062f525d200454acaebb8e90cd5d313fb80c326d0180dc11a1","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ff604cc2f456c8485cce11f9cf8780f4c20b1533b9882f0ac48aa5ed914275b2","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":273,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"7864d1ee5122846428a029a5e8aff029c450ddbdce551f2da1efad6b4ecfe8f5","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T56-5f836b5efc2fa78c","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t56_o1","@33dbc45b04e1c601"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t56_c1","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (ChatGPT associated with better academic outcomes, affective-motivational states, and dispositions toward higher-order thinking)","predicate":"cites_Wang_and_Fan_2025_for","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 cites Wang and Fan 2025 (with four other works) to support the statement that ChatGPT is associated with better academic outcomes, affective-motivational states, and dispositions toward higher-order thinking."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",15821,21668]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"dac26ba2cd2c95a92fb25e59c4bea749de3d6d107d770917a9cbeeef7e1007f1","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":[],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"record was not issued in this context or allowed document scope","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":0}},"request_hash":"341c409d268addfbb5563938428fe0fc84253a9ab00fcf5adc81d6880e6c50ec","submission_id":"T56-5f836b5efc2fa78c#2"},"hash":"e5b8c42eb3c872487a8771e480c2f54f9e8ba0d47d039f5fbe2de2264a31cdfb","header":{"body_hash":"4a1da1a769f44442609f19c704a5c93ccc0aab503a50ed161ffe5817876c3823","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"51e7cce1f1f39d196a6b498929a4bfbf7e5e87806bb671708795b501b686d755","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":274,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"1fb302b87373452ee06b694c7d3e78231eefaf9549b3f43b4019647a6c83ab71","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":[],"attempt":2,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"record was not issued in this context or allowed document scope","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":0,"local_id":"t56_c1"}],"task_id":"T56-5f836b5efc2fa78c","work_key":"doc:PMC13647323.txt#3"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T56-5f836b5efc2fa78c:2","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"dac26ba2cd2c95a92fb25e59c4bea749de3d6d107d770917a9cbeeef7e1007f1","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"96663bb6f8d6c1eff99f1370bd511359aaf6dfe62fe5292fa8cba8ead17a40c0","submission_id":"T56-5f836b5efc2fa78c#repair2"},"hash":"e720cae7b5fed908e35c5cfc736171f19ea784b7c73882eed4237f81eabbddca","header":{"body_hash":"765a9d3a65eb60a4c54c2ce62bb912021da518257f2ddfb4dc7456973312721d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"e5b8c42eb3c872487a8771e480c2f54f9e8ba0d47d039f5fbe2de2264a31cdfb","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":275,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"92c699b5b39bfac337f02ee3b3e232550f39eb4992c23a16c0011a41e779c784","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T56-5f836b5efc2fa78c","kind":"submit","lines":[{"about":["PMC13647323","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t56_q2","needed":"Check the References section of PMC13647323.txt for Wang and Fan (2025) and the Title line of the meta-analysis's record file","text":"Does the reference list entry for Wang and Fan (2025) in PMC13647323 refer to the retracted meta-analysis Wang J and Fan W (2025) matching the Title line of its record file?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",15821,21668]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"dac26ba2cd2c95a92fb25e59c4bea749de3d6d107d770917a9cbeeef7e1007f1","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["f1802200fef48ed62ebfc1c7325885441f09c4dbe1662c453983806d0e589e20"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"fb0f5d598fb97724f2e22255d3c27159650ee708964511fbbb9c6c9a805cd873","submission_id":"T56-5f836b5efc2fa78c#3"},"hash":"3ef87b08a386070613850c0e42cae92c7b375477e9fe104f46d207b25a215206","header":{"body_hash":"fa7588f7a857ef2e879fbb9b4e6d20b0bb0d6405c76a95484ac041d0b660d4c9","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"e720cae7b5fed908e35c5cfc736171f19ea784b7c73882eed4237f81eabbddca","records_root":"7fd9c8638081fd15e43f189d79186c027220473f19e2a0fe9d4c2367426678c4","seq":276,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"53d34899644e2480464cbf8fdcbc9b670ea794a5f1207d363751aae2cb804370","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":false,"agent":"reader-1","circle":16,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":16,"refusals":2,"stored":16,"sync_step":31,"task_id":"T56-5f836b5efc2fa78c"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13647323.txt#3","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"dac26ba2cd2c95a92fb25e59c4bea749de3d6d107d770917a9cbeeef7e1007f1","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"0eb6d71fd583f0f2b315be4ba39c18b1a5cf623a961e3adebde98fe29d87a24e","submission_id":"T56-5f836b5efc2fa78c#done4"},"hash":"82e991fcbb8a1ef4b4d14a14876d7f1bd0710239650e1b55d0fc135eb97dc4ac","header":{"body_hash":"e038eaf8b99ade7ad45e25e6724708fe581dc305e97af13926170b6f196ebf4f","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3ef87b08a386070613850c0e42cae92c7b375477e9fe104f46d207b25a215206","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":277,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"06810cfeb0ed0b59ab2bb26dfa9ffd0d57978c95154810edb38935e2c806c9fb","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR58-4159d77d8c961465","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"For example, ChatGPT has been associated with better academic outcomes, affective–motivational states, and dispositions toward higher-order thinking (Deng et al., 2025; Wang and Fan, 2025;","kind":"observe","local_id":"t58_o1","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025 citation","ChatGPT academic outcomes","affective-motivational states","higher-order thinking"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Specifically, the present study conducts a meta-analysis to estimate the overall effect of GenAI on students' learning motivation and to examine whether this effect varies by GenAI characteristics,","kind":"observe","local_id":"t58_o2","terms":["study design","meta-analysis","learning motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"estimate the overall effect of GenAI on students' learning motivation and to examine whether this effect varies by GenAI characteristics, study characteristics, and demographic factors.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t58_o3","terms":["outcomes measured","moderators","GenAI characteristics","demographic factors"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"H-1a. Students using GenAI have more intrinsic motivation.\n\nH-1b. Students using GenAI have more extrinsic motivation.\n\nH-1c. GenAI shows a larger effect on intrinsic motivation than extrinsic motivation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t58_o4","terms":["hypotheses","intrinsic motivation","extrinsic motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"H-2. The link between GenAI and learning motivation is stronger in later years.\n\nH-3. The link between GenAI and learning motivation is stronger for male students than for female students.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t58_o5","terms":["moderator hypotheses","publication year","student gender"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"In this study, GenAI device type was coded as mobile devices (MD) vs. PCs.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t58_o6","terms":["moderator coding","GenAI device type"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Following a prior meta-analysis, GenAI function can be classified as assessment (evaluating student performance), personalized learning support (PLS) and intelligent tutoring systems (ITS) (Zhu et al., 2025).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t58_o7","terms":["GenAI function classification","assessment","PLS","ITS"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The present study adopts the same scheme to test whether GenAI function moderates GenAI's effects on learning motivation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t58_o8","terms":["moderator test","GenAI function"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Following Hofstede's cultural dimensions, we classify contexts as collectivist vs. individualist (Khlif, 2016).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t58_o9","terms":["cultural background classification","collectivist vs individualist"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Therefore, we examine cultural background as a moderator.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t58_o10","terms":["cultural background moderator"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t58_o1","@1bbc6687f9d17196"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t58_c1","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (ChatGPT associated with better academic outcomes, affective-motivational states, and dispositions toward higher-order thinking)","predicate":"cites_Wang_and_Fan_2025_for","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 cites Wang and Fan 2025 (with Deng et al. 2025, Zhao et al. 2025, Nie et al. 2025, Mo et al. 2026) as meta-analytic evidence associating ChatGPT with better academic outcomes, affective-motivational states, and higher-order thinking."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t58_o2","t58_o3","t58_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t58_c2","object":"students' learning motivation (intrinsic, extrinsic) and moderation by GenAI, study, and demographic factors","predicate":"measures_outcomes_and_moderators","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 conducts a meta-analysis estimating the overall effect of GenAI on students' learning motivation (intrinsic and extrinsic) and testing moderation by GenAI characteristics, study characteristics, and demographic factors."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t58_o5","t58_o6","t58_o7","t58_o8","t58_o9","t58_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t58_c3","object":"device type (MD vs PCs), GenAI function (assessment, PLS, ITS), cultural background (collectivist vs individualist), year, and gender","predicate":"examines_moderators","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 tests moderation of GenAI's effect on learning motivation by device type (mobile devices vs. PCs), GenAI function (assessment, PLS, ITS), cultural background (collectivist vs. individualist), year, and gender."},{"about":["PMC13647323","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t58_q1","needed":"Check the Results, Discussion, and References sections of PMC13647323.txt","text":"Does the reference list of PMC13647323 confirm that 'Wang and Fan, 2025' refers to Wang J and Fan W (2025) in Humanit Soc Sci Commun, and what are the main results and included studies of PMC13647323?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",15821,21668]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"a28d2f48c0746d8260ca39cc07e669416922a4efc2ea028c61740287f53aeaae","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["54b23081e73fd5f2d0f81760fe4d80fd61f86f29b201c7d232e9ccb5a40e2c4a","9b34e1e5d6cd6682311e2376e18dc24736e001a01ad41fdc3b99133549100c99","7098f3a8d77d608b90d4acdd1022ef8491d5cb1ac3d1b9a2c2d6acb3323de089","fc5840251ef2a9de3eb986711162fe3e01af088d12572c42277e87a7cdd47dc0","5fddadf17e948ef581edcdc26010f4746a93554e06a700fc689e8837bf43cb03","ed01400e0952592d809b6404f2cecb8ef0687ff00fed19cb19bbdd421f7e9930","4b7966cdad829e7a193b3ce475e1028716aed89432a2e49eee2fded2b92eea9f","1d32ed18ae378809b2892e68cb19280c1cbb86b5c07b26500319aad53207f6eb","120c641c729b58be8150ff78ff7fa671ff8a77084cb18d16b6ac461904dd32ee","f572b3b4ab9c8af99a97197ec37fb0e3a97b7ede608543e263f5dca212d7b2e5"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":10}},"request_hash":"b62d42e43fab91e8d0a6c6e66156c5c1ade9aace3e09e76bd994ab911589c661","submission_id":"TR58-4159d77d8c961465#1"},"hash":"0402351b6642db0199c5c967b4ca88c05db1b3b8850d57053e3a305f22a96689","header":{"body_hash":"50a8657aa00424579e99731d965bb358a76c5f215d47f081481aac4c6a85584d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"82e991fcbb8a1ef4b4d14a14876d7f1bd0710239650e1b55d0fc135eb97dc4ac","records_root":"3c1e173aa55638d99dbc40f643496fe35e1ccc5dbe49a4e509cf4828de139be6","seq":278,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"acf35d95fc5f38778b500838969a2863cfb1077fd1fbe0d6e3c85881a7f0857b","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR58-4159d77d8c961465","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t58_o2","t58_o3","t58_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t58_c2","object":"students' learning motivation (intrinsic, extrinsic) and moderation by GenAI, study, and demographic factors","predicate":"measures_outcomes_and_moderators","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 conducts a meta-analysis estimating the overall effect of GenAI on students' learning motivation (intrinsic and extrinsic) and testing moderation by GenAI characteristics, study characteristics, and demographic factors."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t58_o5","t58_o6","t58_o7","t58_o8","t58_o9","t58_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t58_c3","object":"device type (MD vs PCs), GenAI function (assessment, PLS, ITS), cultural background (collectivist vs individualist), year, and gender","predicate":"examines_moderators","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 tests moderation of GenAI's effect on learning motivation by device type (mobile devices vs. PCs), GenAI function (assessment, PLS, ITS), cultural background (collectivist vs. individualist), year, and gender."},{"about":["PMC13647323","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t58_q1","needed":"Check the Results, Discussion, and References sections of PMC13647323.txt","text":"Does the reference list of PMC13647323 confirm that 'Wang and Fan, 2025' refers to Wang J and Fan W (2025) in Humanit Soc Sci Commun, and what are the main results and included studies of PMC13647323?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",15821,21668]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"a28d2f48c0746d8260ca39cc07e669416922a4efc2ea028c61740287f53aeaae","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["b138ed198daee4e07279426cb6b049aeafeb647c94c57bd6822c826d1bbe36ee","df423fae466916abc12ce24808f5dc92ddc18911f34678c654401b872356f974","241b446ac0b54559e4406935ac415d86230402b437f00f8fdc59daa92db94680"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"9c0ecfdabc427338cf767d1d6f5e073601f897e3071af810444cafd1a93c576e","submission_id":"TR58-4159d77d8c961465#1.1"},"hash":"f0e537ea20a6125e7ff1402c346b0bb41ec432ab41c5ad35a069bcaf0ff54f3b","header":{"body_hash":"018d2fe749521210cb73df889729550b0453fb8a01ea2c53d1afd4d24911c972","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"0402351b6642db0199c5c967b4ca88c05db1b3b8850d57053e3a305f22a96689","records_root":"80e673569acaf70d32e0e5f0b33a170ebf2340b459f08df289be990e2e76b432","seq":279,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"7e0676befcdef90b257d255f5f60bc3d1b079670af55647dbbdc7e08e47cc821","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@54b23081e73fd5f2","@9b34e1e5d6cd6682","@7098f3a8d77d608b","@fc5840251ef2a9de","@5fddadf17e948ef5","@ed01400e0952592d","@4b7966cdad829e7a","@1d32ed18ae378809","@120c641c729b58be","@f572b3b4ab9c8af9","@b138ed198daee4e0","@df423fae466916ab","@241b446ac0b54559"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"REQUEST","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":10,"local_id":"t58_c1"}],"task_id":"TR58-4159d77d8c961465","work_key":"reread:PMC13647323.txt#3"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:TR58-4159d77d8c961465:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a28d2f48c0746d8260ca39cc07e669416922a4efc2ea028c61740287f53aeaae","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"07888dacfba89c40b5b042c2b0abcb2e73717b6b28ab9489440b1d32e19659a7","submission_id":"TR58-4159d77d8c961465#repair1"},"hash":"d32ff1f4b69b06fdb4635ebba6f4ebd8633e8a9a2b6d154f2acd33538efc9915","header":{"body_hash":"0b843845b595847772796b4bf3b36a6149a22cfc89da2727ba3bd7ff6d68be0f","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"f0e537ea20a6125e7ff1402c346b0bb41ec432ab41c5ad35a069bcaf0ff54f3b","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":280,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"a26e5219a4d07b170a3b22d5bab175c3c27e32fa494c06b9fdd6d80dab2f8347","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR58-4159d77d8c961465","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t58_o1","@1bbc6687f9d17196"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t58_c1","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (ChatGPT associated with better academic outcomes, affective-motivational states, and dispositions toward higher-order thinking)","predicate":"cites_Wang_and_Fan_2025_for","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 cites Wang and Fan 2025 (with Deng et al. 2025, Zhao et al. 2025, Nie et al. 2025, Mo et al. 2026) as evidence associating ChatGPT with better academic outcomes, affective-motivational states, and higher-order thinking."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",15821,21668]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"a28d2f48c0746d8260ca39cc07e669416922a4efc2ea028c61740287f53aeaae","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":[],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"record was not issued in this context or allowed document scope","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":0}},"request_hash":"5a9d8f17c501242a353590a303f81a28e596373c5f57d64519b479d07a820a96","submission_id":"TR58-4159d77d8c961465#2"},"hash":"f12bc7459f1cd537f90cb39cf2b35d70fa5595a9a7292ef390195c21a15d8f33","header":{"body_hash":"0e2ccc404eef0875101cdaaa52c25fa26147bddba87ae00ba7d2d860923e802e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"d32ff1f4b69b06fdb4635ebba6f4ebd8633e8a9a2b6d154f2acd33538efc9915","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":281,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"dae820f69adfb730716ee5f82e82ca26c22466659d26a144948bbb34a400b0ce","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":[],"attempt":2,"excluded":[],"kind":"REQUEST","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"record was not issued in this context or allowed document scope","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":0,"local_id":"t58_c1"}],"task_id":"TR58-4159d77d8c961465","work_key":"reread:PMC13647323.txt#3"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:TR58-4159d77d8c961465:2","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a28d2f48c0746d8260ca39cc07e669416922a4efc2ea028c61740287f53aeaae","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"b40aceb2b4c4a81c82e9c20715ba8a06a68b9edb0a05781782c9c6e8fca06a25","submission_id":"TR58-4159d77d8c961465#repair2"},"hash":"c86a62e7bbe1ff92ed1439a256131e7a076cf0b850ac6f666bc43bff5943b4db","header":{"body_hash":"d2809767e0f0e7e6d0d51e3ef28e1973fd6d2a4acc197b05d7ecdbc9b2f90cca","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"f12bc7459f1cd537f90cb39cf2b35d70fa5595a9a7292ef390195c21a15d8f33","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":282,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"5d8613a31a0a345939c739cae1affd6689a2f68a36ed85bfc8ba539e89429412","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR58-4159d77d8c961465","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t58_o1"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t58_c1","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (ChatGPT associated with better academic outcomes, affective-motivational states, and dispositions toward higher-order thinking)","predicate":"cites_Wang_and_Fan_2025_for","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 cites Wang and Fan 2025 (with Deng et al. 2025, Zhao et al. 2025, Nie et al. 2025, Mo et al. 2026) as evidence associating ChatGPT with better academic outcomes, affective-motivational states, and higher-order thinking."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",15821,21668]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"a28d2f48c0746d8260ca39cc07e669416922a4efc2ea028c61740287f53aeaae","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["c8d0593020f89043b700bae65685d25a2604025c598397da438fee1f10e2b0ae"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"d26b40021b4232822b3f03679dbe10b353a087a649cf2646b2ea8c5aa27a5ef6","submission_id":"TR58-4159d77d8c961465#3"},"hash":"ea278be12c006077e5a3d6347d5f4307963ce56e316c5e862114ed4d6b30f102","header":{"body_hash":"b04c6ceb8304d61fa4409565375fef685370967d76337778ca98369aade08c7a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"c86a62e7bbe1ff92ed1439a256131e7a076cf0b850ac6f666bc43bff5943b4db","records_root":"bba36427780d2b3b48ce1d918c8690e3559bf5bebe4f5f43779b21b0446edf5f","seq":283,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"5dfbe39314baa38a188237e2a664aaf3e0687d0f93b776e084ca48f2c71ce47f","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":16,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":10,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:PMC13647323.txt#3"},"sync_step":31,"task_id":"TR58-4159d77d8c961465"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:PMC13647323.txt#3","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a28d2f48c0746d8260ca39cc07e669416922a4efc2ea028c61740287f53aeaae","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"a89910bb5912434e91932cecf30d4b02dcdd0260734159b567c928d348d53806","submission_id":"TR58-4159d77d8c961465#done4"},"hash":"da622eb7708055480acef27167f274fc3881f28b68d696ca105f5697eb5c7321","header":{"body_hash":"fcb5b1f839f5fbe42f59e5965f28d08590b3f78d6c5f330bd1fe9d8b8581d669","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ea278be12c006077e5a3d6347d5f4307963ce56e316c5e862114ed4d6b30f102","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":284,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"f6015956e27832b5000f8762f05e42ca6d599d1c165f3453ed0955be105630b2","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":16,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":739},"started_unix_ms":1795102805464,"wave":{"doc:PMC13647323.txt#3":"reader-1","doc:PMC13647323.txt#4":"reader-2","doc:PMC13647323.txt#5":"reader-3"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a28d2f48c0746d8260ca39cc07e669416922a4efc2ea028c61740287f53aeaae","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"b46f69ccd5b8164077ac57a0302ab3a950759eb05a43103a778cf2e46e44eaaf","submission_id":"circle:0090608065c6b1ae1c18493214f22ae006d99b961f3000d0f9df1bd2e42e5351"},"hash":"1dca89e6a42ae311477ef0b15d82d12492cfb10a389d80d7a9516eca507ae8a0","header":{"body_hash":"67c039b4fc3df2c2524952096b556a4c1779d7603ca898f5a010773b18d2f28d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"da622eb7708055480acef27167f274fc3881f28b68d696ca105f5697eb5c7321","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":285,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"0d52f023048a73f84f5290bc64c7165bf32cfea3f288ec2e50a6b265f2a0c7a2","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"f6015956e27832b5000f8762f05e42ca6d599d1c165f3453ed0955be105630b2","engine_root":"a28d2f48c0746d8260ca39cc07e669416922a4efc2ea028c61740287f53aeaae","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"0d6885b15d16f073d469ddfaf4ced2d4d32e5c9b4f70d699a4c99b6c35c2e606","log_size":286,"projections":{"dependencies":"ceff2ac1f085a02fadc8afef4e9414ef72e3d652bf42b8c6094a87cb276c2299","status":"7d82ad979eb02cbf7f6f1713593619b7db2253c969d0494c192dc2e3af878702"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"1dca89e6a42ae311477ef0b15d82d12492cfb10a389d80d7a9516eca507ae8a0"}},"engine_root":"a28d2f48c0746d8260ca39cc07e669416922a4efc2ea028c61740287f53aeaae","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"f6015956e27832b5000f8762f05e42ca6d599d1c165f3453ed0955be105630b2","engine_root":"a28d2f48c0746d8260ca39cc07e669416922a4efc2ea028c61740287f53aeaae","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"0d6885b15d16f073d469ddfaf4ced2d4d32e5c9b4f70d699a4c99b6c35c2e606","log_size":286,"projections":{"dependencies":"ceff2ac1f085a02fadc8afef4e9414ef72e3d652bf42b8c6094a87cb276c2299","status":"7d82ad979eb02cbf7f6f1713593619b7db2253c969d0494c192dc2e3af878702"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"1dca89e6a42ae311477ef0b15d82d12492cfb10a389d80d7a9516eca507ae8a0"},"seal_hash":"79ea07dc18593c1284de62e3a32760fde43f1c98fe8dee49d40feed154f46606"}},"request_hash":"83ae8a7f00fa7f5e66ac8c7d04b434b9df2eff14d62911b14abd76d3241682ab","submission_id":"seal-286"},"hash":"8f7b92a384ed097eccc2724f94a8a3967511f4096375a75e9d4cb969b2fed882","header":{"body_hash":"9747a05f8a798e8790fa743b5a61f00a7ea75fc43d73da9469010568f5e64e61","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"1dca89e6a42ae311477ef0b15d82d12492cfb10a389d80d7a9516eca507ae8a0","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":286,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"6ee650ec1402820d6135e8e96921cd64ba40e52ac8a84faafc00b390065aefa4","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[16,"BUILD",0],"epoch":32,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25},{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":26},{"binding":[14,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":27},{"binding":[14,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":28},{"binding":[15,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":29},{"binding":[15,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":30},{"binding":[16,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":31},{"binding":[16,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":32}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102805464},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a28d2f48c0746d8260ca39cc07e669416922a4efc2ea028c61740287f53aeaae","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"47000dd018f06adb2a66ac20626f25cbf181bc1bf4573d71bf506a2c50c01f71","submission_id":"ring-members:a647a68e346c026f862708a8981890004b38be619452898b1f9d477be5382b5f"},"hash":"123df007da635de7f6753c5d3d8fbdde77febe2ff6736e158b80bec7a52f3e3e","header":{"body_hash":"c92c7e7e6cdc583c761ca1fdff18dd9484c29658dfdb4f739b42b3468b8bcf3a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"8f7b92a384ed097eccc2724f94a8a3967511f4096375a75e9d4cb969b2fed882","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":287,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"500c0ba7ac0fedb91c91be82088dec1ad2423841d809d8bbb15b1991868eafb6","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":17,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":739},"started_unix_ms":1795102805488,"wave":{"doc:PMC13647323.txt#6":"reader-2","doc:PMC13647323.txt#7":"reader-3","doc:PMC13647323.txt#8":"reader-1"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a28d2f48c0746d8260ca39cc07e669416922a4efc2ea028c61740287f53aeaae","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"5fc6baec9f2c31995bbf7db1e66d29e8e568683b8639cf39a1acc95526a13046","submission_id":"circle:56bb3bdcba7e5072cbe275e79ec5b9ba7068a02717810ecfcb6727ca79682e5e"},"hash":"9cc2b65023636a397165ccea7953d36b8de69e94e5b7611bdb5c07dbf337564c","header":{"body_hash":"c4876e16bf761fcc324f3f785d4d5b8b2aa82cc3cd3e5461d14f70329d5b5697","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"123df007da635de7f6753c5d3d8fbdde77febe2ff6736e158b80bec7a52f3e3e","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":288,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"a572f5f7c4a1927f918b1408c574e1f7b44ac6ea6a165a8137faa4f5e4bd4156","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"500c0ba7ac0fedb91c91be82088dec1ad2423841d809d8bbb15b1991868eafb6","engine_root":"a28d2f48c0746d8260ca39cc07e669416922a4efc2ea028c61740287f53aeaae","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"ca93dd5b744805ef4d2a0e4dd5f334a412edcb45ca3f3e986569956e9e50f8db","log_size":289,"projections":{"dependencies":"ceff2ac1f085a02fadc8afef4e9414ef72e3d652bf42b8c6094a87cb276c2299","status":"7d82ad979eb02cbf7f6f1713593619b7db2253c969d0494c192dc2e3af878702"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"9cc2b65023636a397165ccea7953d36b8de69e94e5b7611bdb5c07dbf337564c"}},"engine_root":"a28d2f48c0746d8260ca39cc07e669416922a4efc2ea028c61740287f53aeaae","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"500c0ba7ac0fedb91c91be82088dec1ad2423841d809d8bbb15b1991868eafb6","engine_root":"a28d2f48c0746d8260ca39cc07e669416922a4efc2ea028c61740287f53aeaae","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"ca93dd5b744805ef4d2a0e4dd5f334a412edcb45ca3f3e986569956e9e50f8db","log_size":289,"projections":{"dependencies":"ceff2ac1f085a02fadc8afef4e9414ef72e3d652bf42b8c6094a87cb276c2299","status":"7d82ad979eb02cbf7f6f1713593619b7db2253c969d0494c192dc2e3af878702"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"9cc2b65023636a397165ccea7953d36b8de69e94e5b7611bdb5c07dbf337564c"},"seal_hash":"b7886ee10d3e8565598acb4f4cbaf9e2a59eec54a97c9db7b4e31fe54690ab51"}},"request_hash":"880ea847dee8614b5627a9839185b569e8011698fb9d66bc7d5bd4c40e5b15ba","submission_id":"seal-289"},"hash":"12450a6d754c0f928aacc8bc32b575c1e3cd07b0175f3545f3b8a1db04f08fd5","header":{"body_hash":"83cc226b2fd25fb18eb723fceb9a497f743a2ab6dea191ba60513343ee8abf68","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"9cc2b65023636a397165ccea7953d36b8de69e94e5b7611bdb5c07dbf337564c","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":289,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"af770cca4ee23f154008ce589bb2825c57836b0e3e5efcd5cdb5092292cb62d9","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[17,"READ",0],"epoch":33,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25},{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":26},{"binding":[14,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":27},{"binding":[14,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":28},{"binding":[15,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":29},{"binding":[15,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":30},{"binding":[16,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":31},{"binding":[16,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":32},{"binding":[17,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":33}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102805488},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a28d2f48c0746d8260ca39cc07e669416922a4efc2ea028c61740287f53aeaae","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"fb88aa487c663320b30acc505c5c75325b83db44da8bf2a7c41ae696a1c596b5","submission_id":"ring-members:ccac90b00de40dd765a65671065b7f1b1be38909a1707f673bfc7eb14c4d7348"},"hash":"ac5e414b0d113c8bcdd542f267ab2f37a221691f94db43d93ed923e273e554c3","header":{"body_hash":"2f8662756a7527ede41a625f4524413d0fb799ea44f3b4dfd518e413d6140b09","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"12450a6d754c0f928aacc8bc32b575c1e3cd07b0175f3545f3b8a1db04f08fd5","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":290,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"21f9497a072289850b5e134f2329afb36f2cc70e28e8033bac7fd4924fdedabc","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T61-c11d22f5f4dc6805","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"This meta-analysis examined 56 effect sizes in 42 studies of 6,059 participants from 2023 to 2025. Sample sizes ranged from 32 to 486.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t61_o1","terms":["studies and data examined","sample size","meta-analysis dataset"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Some primary studies reported general, positive, total, or combined motivation scores rather than separate intrinsic and extrinsic motivation scores.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t61_o2","terms":["measured outcomes","learning motivation","intrinsic and extrinsic motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"When a study reported both a total motivation score and separate intrinsic/extrinsic subscale scores, the total score was used for the overall motivation estimate, whereas the subscale-specific scores were used for the motivation-type subgroup analysis.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t61_o3","terms":["overall motivation estimate","intrinsic/extrinsic subscale scores","measured outcomes"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Therefore, post-test scores were used as the common metric to ensure comparability across studies. Hedges' g was adopted as the standardized mean difference statistic","kind":"observe","local_id":"t61_o4","terms":["post-test scores","Hedges' g","effect size metric"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The meta-analysis was conducted using CMA 3.0. For continuous variables (gender), meta-regression analysis was employed. For categorical variables, subgroup analysis was performed to identify and interpret the sources of heterogeneity.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t61_o5","terms":["CMA 3.0","meta-regression","subgroup analysis"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The variance decomposition showed that 15.70% of the variance was attributable to sampling variance at Level 1, 4.35% to within-study variance at Level 2, and 79.95% to between-study variance at Level 3. Thus, only a small proportion of the total variance was located at the within-study level.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t61_o6","terms":["three-level meta-analysis","variance decomposition","within-study vs between-study variance"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t61_o1"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t61_c1","object":"56 effect sizes in 42 primary studies of 6,059 participants (sample sizes 32–486) from 2023 to 2025","predicate":"rests_on_data","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 rests on a meta-analysis of 56 effect sizes across 42 primary studies involving 6,059 participants (sample sizes 32 to 486) published from 2023 to 2025."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t61_o2","t61_o3","t61_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t61_c2","object":"overall learning motivation and intrinsic/extrinsic motivation subscales using post-test Hedges' g","predicate":"measures_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 measures students' overall learning motivation as well as intrinsic and extrinsic motivation subscales, using post-test between-group Hedges' g as the effect-size metric."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t61_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t61_c3","object":"three-level variance decomposition: 79.95% between-study, 15.70% sampling, and 4.35% within-study variance","predicate":"reports_result","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"In a supplementary three-level meta-analysis, PMC13647323 finds that 79.95% of variance is between-study (Level 3), 15.70% is sampling variance (Level 1), and only 4.35% is within-study variance (Level 2)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t61_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t61_c4","object":"CMA 3.0 with meta-regression for continuous variables (gender) and subgroup analysis for categorical variables","predicate":"uses_methodology","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 conducts its primary meta-analysis in CMA 3.0 using meta-regression for continuous moderators (gender) and subgroup analysis for categorical moderators."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",33015,38833]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"0acae78bf0af16f3ccae1d1792dce22e085d4c11b5d0bd6a21d648b31ae96eeb","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["33b1ba9666262744926d1c8cd38e03d1b55c82ee0b16baf5c49972ea55b65c84","c3abed5701b3bc671ff7700e0882acc295622271f7e325487279c171322eb5cf","04ee339c29c199bd8d512a78668afa2a7e01517084a33dd6d2582fd72349b61a","be798668f8a45d3a40c2d8bebd85f0baaecbeaa6c6b07672d16bf34e91d03f69","090e5204183d6aba151db2a546adf333960e9c874402943d8b5c62de46c03caf","b4019c63a6c67f255e84a7fd728a82f74e9df127d7ac3632f688b10000984455","9228d9495d52af720c230dc6a6eb3644189bf923521ee0a3c0ac6c1009ad1583","abf47e33969c15780671cc4daf5b8f6bfe0392a3467ecd92df1adba653c6c31d","f3ef574e67528a1a852757901d0aff4d208ee782f3e4623e28ccc33ffe7252f9","0207e441872b32768f06b2b43475b8e272a79fe8f833013cb771c4f31e1ed4c9"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"aa51b68580db9cec7354f0fc0d6a8a04132af30a1e2544573fa2d770d4ffc0a6","submission_id":"T61-c11d22f5f4dc6805#1"},"hash":"564bf90d974206899f4aa4a1fc5b47394516c01b59400ffb0bd907ac7fd1de54","header":{"body_hash":"976289835ea22b2a0ba2ea923b240a5e625b1cb77610969ab2618f93153ac9cf","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ac5e414b0d113c8bcdd542f267ab2f37a221691f94db43d93ed923e273e554c3","records_root":"6df80672c0e1457f0e433ee48361e6b2b6130ede8a8687598d8500d4906ea2d7","seq":291,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"bc76b467d0e28ed021d9c213c9ab814596bf8f46bb099d86540284a30e8419ef","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":17,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":33,"task_id":"T61-c11d22f5f4dc6805"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13647323.txt#6","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"0acae78bf0af16f3ccae1d1792dce22e085d4c11b5d0bd6a21d648b31ae96eeb","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"59d38693630008790770617f31519d4caafbd235e8257054088333f4f5d1a7cf","submission_id":"T61-c11d22f5f4dc6805#done2"},"hash":"c99a7c9c574e51fb0f681211f7c741b10a58e397b9fe47301b175d6d51158efa","header":{"body_hash":"b57983d0c5a9eb945cc37e6c2ac2566e0f20dd74eb509d3dcd0b0b1aaabc76a1","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"564bf90d974206899f4aa4a1fc5b47394516c01b59400ffb0bd907ac7fd1de54","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":292,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"0714754f979ba0df208d7183f5b506d3ba3dec6f4772c7526c880fe269b56037","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T59-1ba8dabb47634880","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"This meta-analysis examined whether students who use GenAI exhibit greater learning motivation compared to those who do not.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t59_o1","terms":["learning motivation","GenAI","outcomes measured"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Additionally, this study analyzed the influence of nine moderator variables on the effectiveness of GenAI.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t59_o2","terms":["moderator variables","GenAI effectiveness"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"This meta-analysis demonstrated that, compared with conventional teaching conditions, GenAI produced a statistically significant improvement in students' overall learning motivation (g = 0.764)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t59_o3","terms":["overall learning motivation","g = 0.764","main result"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"with significant positive effects detected for both intrinsic motivation and extrinsic motivation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t59_o4","terms":["intrinsic motivation","extrinsic motivation","outcomes measured"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Nevertheless, the extremely high between-study heterogeneity (I2 = 93.7%) indicates that the magnitude of this effect varies dramatically across study contexts.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t59_o5","terms":["between-study heterogeneity","I2 = 93.7%"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Consequently, our findings do not support the conclusion that GenAI reliably increases motivation across all educational environments.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t59_o6","terms":["qualification","educational environments"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Observed between-subgroup differences were found across cultural contexts (QBET = 7.594, df = 1, p < 0.05).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t59_o7","terms":["cultural contexts","moderator analysis"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"This effect was larger in countries with predominantly collectivist cultures (g = 0.815, 95% CI = [0.585, 1.046]) than those with individualistic ones (g = 0.367, 95% CI = [0.147, 0.587]).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t59_o8","terms":["collectivist cultures","individualistic cultures","effect size"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Observed between-subgroup differences by education stage were found (QBET = 13.536, df = 2, p < 0.05).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t59_o9","terms":["education stage","moderator analysis"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The effect was stronger among university students (g = 0.886, 95% CI = [0.637, 1.136]), followed by secondary school students (g = 0.360, 95% CI = [0.157, 0.563]), and finally primary school students (g = 0.311, 95% CI = [0.077, 0.544]).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t59_o10","terms":["university students","secondary school","primary school"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Using GenAI on mobile devices (g = 0.782, 95% CI = [0.545, 1.018]) had a stronger effect on learning motivation than using it on computers (g = 0.303, 95% CI = [0.169, 0.438]).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t59_o11","terms":["device type","mobile devices","computers"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Observed between-subgroup differences across subject domains were found (QBET = 23.785, df = 4, p < 0.05), with language-related studies showing the largest pooled effect (g = 0.946, 95% CI = [0.630, 1.262])","kind":"observe","local_id":"t59_o12","terms":["subject domains","language"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"followed by mathematics (g = 0.711, 95% CI = [0.356, 1.066]) and pedagogy (g = 0.697, 95% CI = [0.261, 1.133]), then information (g = 0.291, 95% CI = [0.047, 0.535]), and lowest in science (g = 0.109, 95% CI = [−0.107, 0.325]).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t59_o13","terms":["mathematics","pedagogy","information","science"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Meta-regression showed no significant association between gender and GenAI's effect on learning motivation (QModel(1, k = 25) = 0.25, p > 0.05; see Table 4).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t59_o14","terms":["gender","proportion of female participants"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Between-subgroup differences were not significant across GenAI function (QBET = 0.011, df = 1, p > 0.05).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t59_o15","terms":["GenAI function"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Between-subgroup differences were not significant across intervention duration (QBET = 1.475, df = 2, p > 0.05) and type of motivation (QBET = 1.415, df = 1, p > 0.05).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t59_o16","terms":["intervention duration","type of motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Meta-regression showed no significant association between publication year and GenAI's effect on learning motivation (QBET = 3.519, df = 2, p > 0.05).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t59_o17","terms":["publication year"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t59_o1","t59_o2","t59_o3","t59_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t59_c1","object":"GenAI improves overall learning motivation (g=0.764), intrinsic and extrinsic motivation across 9 moderators","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 concludes that GenAI significantly improves overall student learning motivation compared with conventional teaching (g=0.764), with positive effects on both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation, while analyzing nine moderators."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t59_o3","t59_o5","t59_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t59_c2","object":"high heterogeneity (I2=93.7%) prevents concluding GenAI reliably increases motivation across all environments","predicate":"qualifies_conclusions","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 qualifies its main conclusion by noting that due to extremely high heterogeneity (I2=93.7%), its findings do not support concluding that GenAI reliably increases learning motivation across all educational environments."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t59_o12","t59_o13"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t59_c4","object":"language g=0.946, math g=0.711, pedagogy g=0.697, information g=0.291, science g=0.109 (QBET=23.785)","predicate":"reports_subject_domain_moderation","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 reports significant differences across subject domains (QBET=23.785, p<0.05): language (g=0.946, k=32), math (g=0.711, k=4), pedagogy (g=0.697, k=6), information (g=0.291, k=8), and science (g=0.109, k=3)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t59_o14","t59_o15","t59_o16","t59_o17"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t59_c5","object":"no significant moderation by gender, GenAI function, duration, motivation type, or publication year","predicate":"reports_null_moderators","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 finds no significant moderation of GenAI's effect on learning motivation by female proportion (p>0.05), GenAI function (QBET=0.011), intervention duration (QBET=1.475), motivation type (QBET=1.415), or publication year (QBET=3.519)."},{"about":["PMC13647323","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t59_q1","needed":"Check earlier sections (Introduction, Methods, Results) and References of PMC13647323.txt","text":"Does PMC13647323 cite Wang and Fan 2025, and what primary studies and databases does this meta-analysis rest on?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",44772,49534]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"44ab3d96550cdab821ef06a83d2f85ca6a32322490b015a541d07da5a209cec9","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["ef21fdead93280226b949ecae0558ecc2baef58b62f80bb1c36047c4b64fcce8","003aff7e992098516ef1522ac551da7a360e38d67dd0e8e148c919ac3ab1be3d","0e92f9d7bc27f9317a6a8b2ee95a384a7c0ed40e837863c40c4d3c76e833c2fa","6127d1b25d070cd63631e96e5b673b5ec952875b1bc5904a5b6d6fb50af27096","f30b5fa84835a4f2859a5c651ea8dd1373fb48e41f77184e26440ed9e1e2449e","c913f51b542376680ce9aad33114735f53ec0020a6ddb274ac14e257d6d4f9cf","fd837267fa46c57349f9b4245d144de5bc8b2ebb7ca9c00d03aec7de4707c1eb","6d9e675215d8cd177e8ea6261c1c2746e7f747884bae5d7e2807fe2940cf8695","fdcfec0e736f1353c45fb554d299800ccd491510cf96e055f8ec637b6245ebbd","87f59105cbf2799f498ccaf107764e7fc1bc4524c81f2bb662b9b6129360f6cb","88d13ebb99fca5ed10c20fe876b023804bf56fe992127914b3fb93b1d4fae731","075615ad0db7c4989b940e78566a63ed336851414c10b244a0ad3cee182f6b96","b97722ecb9933ae7ba77d934eea509a7d8cd95a157a559b6a5210c8e5a461052","784cc578cae636c07bd51669bdc7daa09baaeef5915b9da61d7c37b850015329","2f41614e872934928531568f5fecefaacbcb7293a1c77b1e037c40ce964b3bb7","2ab4b6270e14fd559c9e6d60926bed0932c5924e1ff7bb08b60735f27ec93731","bf45a1f0ef50475f6728977abe8235ed5132c9071f1d45c9431e4835414320ec","b1104607d6aa0edd5b741281676a5347c632c3dd3bdb126a7e8181c55539c3f2","6f37d45b454efa84ebcb531851501fc7a0245c17fc7f30671b1e2f0ff834a905","a65367a4c093017486d075a77ea4e1311798ea14fec1354f1339b72393cb737e"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":20}},"request_hash":"b673a0902b27da79c7ac47f58b29c68b93b201dc8be3dc8168b07909041dd9ea","submission_id":"T59-1ba8dabb47634880#1"},"hash":"9a30448a34c5e5a7cdb6df87990ac3a70376df8c4ad33054022cff95a9a3c8c5","header":{"body_hash":"8931e861e9ce4c5ab419f05d3ba631af2722e99a3d3e9f8ffd0a76122dba9b93","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"c99a7c9c574e51fb0f681211f7c741b10a58e397b9fe47301b175d6d51158efa","records_root":"8e2896328b161c19e1f9afeb770b182da6e3765a0376b2bf863b51d7600cbc22","seq":293,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"7f03f3c02e16238a1800e18ea28b25ca67251286a38bd60cd0c6bc410687fb4d","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T59-1ba8dabb47634880","kind":"submit","lines":[{"about":["PMC13647323","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t59_q1","needed":"Check earlier sections (Introduction, Methods, Results) and References of PMC13647323.txt","text":"Does PMC13647323 cite Wang and Fan 2025, and what primary studies and databases does this meta-analysis rest on?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",44772,49534]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"44ab3d96550cdab821ef06a83d2f85ca6a32322490b015a541d07da5a209cec9","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["36c5a3072b9bcb8705cadb511e199b09787f63a42c49024520b0311da0b0a638"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"3f0510b966a369f3f8d9fc9549426e9299b05dd00d0343ead7e9064a92cae56b","submission_id":"T59-1ba8dabb47634880#1.1"},"hash":"187ee7f9aadc633712bc3c269bed2cf9ad0d191a8331cd1beb09f6ad0aa1a43e","header":{"body_hash":"68b81ef0b196649acebfe3fc64ab985389d316ab8daba2d31fb093a73b6e9d4e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"9a30448a34c5e5a7cdb6df87990ac3a70376df8c4ad33054022cff95a9a3c8c5","records_root":"d4acf80df792a743fe30cb54e4612274d25c1930c5fe9948c782f7820eea12fd","seq":294,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"68bcadbbaab2eedee85f823da31a8582c0196788076c10c4e1b8dd10ad0ae24e","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@ef21fdead9328022","@003aff7e99209851","@0e92f9d7bc27f931","@6127d1b25d070cd6","@f30b5fa84835a4f2","@c913f51b54237668","@fd837267fa46c573","@6d9e675215d8cd17","@fdcfec0e736f1353","@87f59105cbf2799f","@88d13ebb99fca5ed","@075615ad0db7c498","@b97722ecb9933ae7","@784cc578cae636c0","@2f41614e87293492","@2ab4b6270e14fd55","@bf45a1f0ef50475f","@b1104607d6aa0edd","@6f37d45b454efa84","@a65367a4c0930174","@36c5a3072b9bcb87"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"NO_EVIDENCE","expected_by_kernel":{"missing_identifiers":["11.913"]},"field":"based_on","message":"a claim names only identifiers its quotes hold: add a quote of this section that holds each one listed, or leave it out of the claim","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":19,"local_id":"t59_c3"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":21,"local_id":"t59_c5"}],"task_id":"T59-1ba8dabb47634880","work_key":"doc:PMC13647323.txt#8"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T59-1ba8dabb47634880:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"44ab3d96550cdab821ef06a83d2f85ca6a32322490b015a541d07da5a209cec9","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"d6f44cf11136823f194b85fad2f0622b22973c69911d6eba8f205a428b502e86","submission_id":"T59-1ba8dabb47634880#repair1"},"hash":"a2edd6cd2d30a282d3c373e2686208601f424e57af615b9e44709a0e0cc7133d","header":{"body_hash":"6840997200b61bcb8044045137b89acdb5c1e93340327cef2da10102babf66d4","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"187ee7f9aadc633712bc3c269bed2cf9ad0d191a8331cd1beb09f6ad0aa1a43e","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":295,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"76362464a5131a60c616d7b757e205f6fd86eefd5f2905a2f9f28abbf12d42c1","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T59-1ba8dabb47634880","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t59_o7","t59_o8","t59_o9","t59_o10","t59_o11"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t59_c3","object":"significant differences by culture (QBET=7.594), education stage (QBET=13.536), and device type","predicate":"reports_moderator_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 reports moderator effects on motivation for culture (collectivist g=0.815 vs individualistic g=0.367), education stage (university g=0.886, secondary g=0.360, primary g=0.311), and device (mobile g=0.782 vs PC g=0.303)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t59_o14","t59_o15","t59_o16","t59_o17"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t59_c5","object":"no significant moderation by gender, GenAI function, duration, motivation type, or publication year","predicate":"reports_null_moderators","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 finds no significant moderation of GenAI's effect on motivation by gender (p>0.05), GenAI function (QBET=0.011), duration (QBET=1.475), motivation type (QBET=1.415), or publication year (QBET=3.519)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",44772,49534]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"44ab3d96550cdab821ef06a83d2f85ca6a32322490b015a541d07da5a209cec9","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["367260baed64e69fe776fba725de1b6df19d9fb6ba85c3b021dbebfac7cf952f","aa35d32c0cfa46997c70ccf3df47d38a14510df0f1ff740ff976748710a1c571"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"985f2417cfc88f51618cbb1bb77ed24d0f65520eed6004b95085e2cbdf57ece5","submission_id":"T59-1ba8dabb47634880#2"},"hash":"0cfa4a36b09ffc7e1b8dec94e191af9bc95fc0d60dabf25769b637c238518f5d","header":{"body_hash":"99b594340fd59a56c6ffba63d178b76dff15e12ad54234c663e6bb92b60b087e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"a2edd6cd2d30a282d3c373e2686208601f424e57af615b9e44709a0e0cc7133d","records_root":"8a7a3e3efae2e9f9ffe2f9844d8371c5512c95d34a5f30a79e7c02b13c1ee7d7","seq":296,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"81f4179a1eb0971c8d398438b99a5e49cc4814ad8b63ce7b49717a480acc867d","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":false,"agent":"reader-1","circle":17,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":23,"refusals":1,"stored":23,"sync_step":33,"task_id":"T59-1ba8dabb47634880"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13647323.txt#8","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"44ab3d96550cdab821ef06a83d2f85ca6a32322490b015a541d07da5a209cec9","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"7f5d1effd0a5eb97c53fd5442570c16bfd7aa1597bc271050380507ba956155c","submission_id":"T59-1ba8dabb47634880#done3"},"hash":"1df02f6cb26d80caeac8c22c3bb10432c8f0f6a58d3c647b0d70b7e18a502ce2","header":{"body_hash":"308d41e5700beafdbbf1e0f8207e3e094a7e82533b9b4f8a3719ec5c7d5fa5bc","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"0cfa4a36b09ffc7e1b8dec94e191af9bc95fc0d60dabf25769b637c238518f5d","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":297,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"3955194ce17ee721c34257c0e71469d884b66c53880d721c3d81b36d66ed666d","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T60-cd36e33c05d5bb85","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"As likelihood-ratio tests demonstrated that the full three-level model did not yield a statistically significant improvement relative to the corresponding reduced two-level models, the more parsimonious two-level meta-analytic model was adopted.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o1","terms":["two-level meta-analytic model adoption","likelihood-ratio tests"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The 56 effect sizes of GenAI on learning motivation showed heterogeneity: Qmotivation [55] = 866.132, p < 0.001, I2 = 93.7%, Tau2 = 0.515 (see Table 2).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o2","terms":["learning motivation outcome","heterogeneity","56 effect sizes"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"As Hedge's g = 0.764, 95% CI = [0.566, 0.962], 95% PI = [−0.689, 2.217]; z = 7.571, p < 0.001, students using GenAI showed more learning motivation than other students.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o3","terms":["overall effect size","Hedges's g","learning motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"However, due to the extremely high heterogeneity, the pooled effect should be interpreted as a positive average effect rather than evidence of a stable effect across all educational contexts.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o4","terms":["heterogeneity qualification","pooled effect interpretation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The residuals ranged from −1.3725 to 0.8925, all studentized residuals were below the outlier threshold of 2 (Viechtbauer, 2010), with most values clustered near zero, indicating no extreme deviations from the fitted model.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o5","terms":["sensitivity analysis","studentized residuals"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The resulting effect sizes varied between 0.695 and 0.840, remaining well within the 95% confidence interval of the primary analysis (0.566 to 0.962), and all remained statistically significant (p ≤ 0.001).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o6","terms":["leave-one-out sensitivity analysis","robustness"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Egger's regression intercept did not reach statistical significance at the conventional 0.05 level, although the result was close to the threshold, b = 2.727, t(54) = 1.945, p = 0.057 > 0.05.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o7","terms":["publication bias","Egger's regression intercept"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Therefore, the results provide no clear statistical evidence of publication bias.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o8","terms":["publication bias conclusion"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Funnel plot of the 56 effect sizes from 42 studies in the meta-analysis.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o9","terms":["56 effect sizes","42 studies","study count"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Given the very high heterogeneity and the possibility that study-level characteristics may be confounded, moderator analyses were treated as exploratory.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o10","terms":["exploratory moderator analysis","confounding qualification"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Moderator variables | QBET | k | g | SE | 95% CI for g | QW | I2","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o11","terms":["Table 3 header","categorical moderators"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t60_o1","t60_o2","t60_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t60_c1","object":"56 effect sizes from 42 studies on learning motivation using a two-level random-effects model","predicate":"bases_analysis_on","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 analyzes 56 effect sizes from 42 studies on students' learning motivation using a two-level random-effects meta-analytic model after likelihood-ratio tests did not support a three-level model."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t60_o2","t60_o3","t60_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t60_c2","object":"GenAI increases learning motivation (g=0.764, 95% CI [0.566, 0.962], 95% PI [-0.689, 2.217], I2=93.7%), interpreted as a positive average rather than uniform effect","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 concludes that GenAI significantly increases students' learning motivation (Hedges's g=0.764, 95% CI [0.566, 0.962], p<0.001), qualified as a positive average effect across contexts due to high heterogeneity (I2=93.7%)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t60_o5","t60_o6","t60_o7","t60_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t60_c3","object":"robust pooled effect (leave-one-out g=0.695-0.840) and no clear statistical evidence of publication bias (Egger's b=2.727, p=0.057)","predicate":"reports_robustness_and_bias","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 concludes that its pooled effect on learning motivation is robust (studentized residuals -1.3725 to 0.8925; leave-one-out g=0.695 to 0.840, p<=0.001) with no clear statistical evidence of publication bias (Egger's p=0.057)."},{"about":["PMC13647323"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t60_q1","needed":"Check the next section of PMC13647323.txt after byte 44772 for the rest of Table 3 and Table 4.","text":"What are the remaining categorical moderator rows (after 2023 publication year) in Table 3 and the continuous meta-regression results in Table 4 of PMC13647323?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",38833,44772]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"7dccff2e62a02be3e9766b6f230dc1ca6e8bdf0a2d4c634c7e5dd61e4b04022c","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["5fe7a8d1f8426c3f680d076eebc91f7171c21867e7ec943d5a4dcd15f294f9c5","8f4a23153d431aee7fe1b01d56fe56f3990d0da53a262deec7cad088767a0b48","1979a21b528282dd0b08a7445de4dae6ea2a9ef0c9abe5cf0c25c49bf5e0ed9e","a816596fb6fb874d0d1052f33de7390c5338e6c8599f11657048fd3371cbef9d","d412e65ef6cb8a31deab7a8ac8c58771f8f3abcacd41ad078f9c524731d3045b","690f2c50bafaee41a422c60253b68f9d9c0fc068c0e4541854b1165ecbbc5da6","67a3f05ce7c71ee19a12dea9d6acf7b57a2055f9ef1ed89f87ea007630ce48ae","ebf07b438c8070d6a1c79342738340446dc94f5e32a07b736f19fde2234f2c0d","639a9ddfc6ed65ed55a5e44555b0776c82f341fbca61b4044183f94a5e118ef7","210a9ce945343a639332a3be27bc401117b33f810fcc1be4fcbdd784590928d7","7d33537598bc5184b3280dcdc9c06f972a3353224d79fedac1b016c3234374ab","ef82a8b6c64ff4cff0238b242dfbc867594e00651f8961b62c354f94c7182a97","2698d9b5ff9dfc67e3160c23e1f040f7fd5a777f130392b34ed69b7037f064e7","429f8cc1876f64162b9a7595825a275b68fd1b2faed0845edb6cc139cbdd6bdb","bcaa0d216e028f4a481b5543b070307c585fb6fa4319b26aac5f525fd5513b01"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"a257bfe0ad54332ede9c6edb83d0974b054ab0181d198edd0656dc060fd9bec2","submission_id":"T60-cd36e33c05d5bb85#1"},"hash":"0f6797f893c1d8a4f24eba5dd8f3f6c16e1a5e4fbc5084392a5e5f4841a579ff","header":{"body_hash":"bedc841e946ec12b04d3df718e6fb6d7158aad29917999e400854ec7de1e3bee","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"1df02f6cb26d80caeac8c22c3bb10432c8f0f6a58d3c647b0d70b7e18a502ce2","records_root":"62f4cf6a4cb915c8f17b6f0fa65c692045b90eb40f8386bde9ebbc86b00e8755","seq":298,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"c6fe966d33be70dac94644d92470cf61f59f923bb380f2fdfdaeac5d0273997e","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@5fe7a8d1f8426c3f","@8f4a23153d431aee","@1979a21b528282dd","@a816596fb6fb874d","@d412e65ef6cb8a31","@690f2c50bafaee41","@67a3f05ce7c71ee1","@ebf07b438c8070d6","@639a9ddfc6ed65ed","@210a9ce945343a63","@7d33537598bc5184","@ef82a8b6c64ff4cf","@2698d9b5ff9dfc67","@429f8cc1876f6416","@bcaa0d216e028f4a"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[{"index":19,"local_id":"t60_c4","rests_on":"t60_o13"},{"index":20,"local_id":"t60_c5","rests_on":"t60_o14"},{"index":21,"local_id":"t60_c6","rests_on":"t60_o12"}],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"QUOTE_NOT_FOUND_IN_BYTES","expected_by_kernel":{"rule":"byte_quote"},"field":"exact_quote","message":"quote has no byte-exact occurrence","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":11,"local_id":"t60_o12"},{"error":{"code":"QUOTE_NOT_FOUND_IN_BYTES","expected_by_kernel":{"rule":"byte_quote"},"field":"exact_quote","message":"quote has no byte-exact occurrence","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":12,"local_id":"t60_o13"},{"error":{"code":"QUOTE_NOT_FOUND_IN_BYTES","expected_by_kernel":{"rule":"byte_quote"},"field":"exact_quote","message":"quote has no byte-exact occurrence","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":13,"local_id":"t60_o14"},{"error":{"code":"QUOTE_NOT_FOUND_IN_BYTES","expected_by_kernel":{"rule":"byte_quote"},"field":"exact_quote","message":"quote has no byte-exact occurrence","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":14,"local_id":"t60_o15"},{"error":{"code":"QUOTE_NOT_FOUND_IN_BYTES","expected_by_kernel":{"rule":"byte_quote"},"field":"exact_quote","message":"quote has no byte-exact occurrence","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":15,"local_id":"t60_o16"}],"task_id":"T60-cd36e33c05d5bb85","work_key":"doc:PMC13647323.txt#7"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T60-cd36e33c05d5bb85:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"7dccff2e62a02be3e9766b6f230dc1ca6e8bdf0a2d4c634c7e5dd61e4b04022c","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"9530d747901ca4573b0416eb6800c9ccb243453ed56b9d38e51a129554596721","submission_id":"T60-cd36e33c05d5bb85#repair1"},"hash":"0ddfca1a6cf2c8f1c140947301d9fa3b8d6ccbb8d2851f4164ff0f200331e771","header":{"body_hash":"2ca43a708b6aafab97dc88ae06473135afc681302932de2724ce149051ed7efa","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"0f6797f893c1d8a4f24eba5dd8f3f6c16e1a5e4fbc5084392a5e5f4841a579ff","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":299,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"9e63a0f479e1ee85251465a1347caaf5165a0dba704a33012d5e61c1d3b60834","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T60-cd36e33c05d5bb85","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Type of motivation | 1.415 (p = 0.234) |  |  |  |  |  |","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o12","terms":["type of motivation moderator","QBET test"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Extrinsic motivation |  | 8 | 0.382 | 0.122 | [0.143, 0.621] | 22.130** | 0.684","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o12a","terms":["extrinsic motivation subgroup"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Intrinsic motivation |  | 36 | 0.549 | 0.070 | [0.412, 0.686] | 154.936*** | 0.774","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o12b","terms":["intrinsic motivation subgroup"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Culture | 7.594** (p = 0.006) |  |  |  |  |  |","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o13","terms":["culture moderator","QBET test"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Collectivism |  | 49 | 0.815 | 0.118 | [0.585, 1.046] | 769.721*** | 0.938","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o13a","terms":["collectivism subgroup"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Individualism |  | 7 | 0.367 | 0.112 | [0.147, 0.587] | 27.919*** | 0.785","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o13b","terms":["individualism subgroup"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Education stage | 13.536** (p = 0.001) |  |  |  |  |  |","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o14","terms":["education stage moderator","QBET test"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Primary School |  | 4 | 0.311 | 0.119 | [0.077, 0.544] | 1.948 | 0.000","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o14a","terms":["primary school subgroup"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Secondary School |  | 9 | 0.360 | 0.104 | [0.157, 0.563] | 25.810** | 0.690","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o14b","terms":["secondary school subgroup"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"University |  | 43 | 0.886 | 0.127 | [0.637, 1.136] | 778.346*** | 0.946","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o14c","terms":["university subgroup"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"GenAI function | 0.011 (p = 0.916) |  |  |  |  |  |","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o15","terms":["GenAI function moderator","QBET test"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Intelligent tutoring systems |  | 30 | 0.759 | 0.114 | [0.536, 0.982] | 295.243*** | 0.902","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o15a","terms":["intelligent tutoring systems subgroup"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Personalized learning support |  | 25 | 0.782 | 0.191 | [0.407, 1.157] | 560.917*** | 0.957","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o15b","terms":["personalized learning support subgroup"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"GenAI device type | 11.913** (p = 0.001) |  |  |  |  |  |","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o16","terms":["GenAI device type moderator","QBET test"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Mobile device |  | 15 | 0.782 | 0.120 | [0.545, 1.018] | 68.070*** | 0.794","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o16a","terms":["mobile device subgroup"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Personal computer |  | 19 | 0.303 | 0.068 | [0.169, 0.438] | 47.014*** | 0.617","kind":"observe","local_id":"t60_o16b","terms":["personal computer subgroup"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t60_o10","t60_o11","t60_o13","t60_o13a","t60_o13b"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t60_c4","object":"culture significantly moderates learning motivation effect (QBET=7.594, p=0.006; collectivism k=49, g=0.815 vs individualism k=7, g=0.367); exploratory","predicate":"reports_moderator_effect","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"In exploratory subgroup analyses, PMC13647323 finds significant moderation of GenAI's effect on learning motivation by culture (QBET=7.594, p=0.006; collectivism g=0.815 vs individualism g=0.367)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t60_o10","t60_o11","t60_o14","t60_o14a","t60_o14b","t60_o14c","t60_o16","t60_o16a","t60_o16b"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t60_c5","object":"significant exploratory moderation by education stage (p=0.001; university g=0.886, secondary g=0.360, primary g=0.311) and device type (p=0.001; mobile g=0.782, PC g=0.303)","predicate":"reports_moderator_effect","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"In exploratory subgroup analyses, PMC13647323 finds significant moderation by education stage (QBET=13.536, p=0.001; university g=0.886, secondary g=0.360, primary g=0.311) and device type (QBET=11.913, p=0.001; mobile g=0.782, PC g=0.303)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t60_o10","t60_o11","t60_o12","t60_o12a","t60_o12b","t60_o15","t60_o15a","t60_o15b"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t60_c6","object":"non-significant moderation by motivation type (p=0.234) and GenAI function (p=0.916; ITS g=0.759 vs personalized support g=0.782)","predicate":"reports_null_moderator_effect","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"In exploratory subgroup analyses, PMC13647323 finds no significant moderation of learning motivation by motivation type (QBET=1.415, p=0.234; extrinsic g=0.382, intrinsic g=0.549) or GenAI function (QBET=0.011, p=0.916)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",38833,44772]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"a9a59010c74def0bb33478e5a8c610a2b1acd7695a1790ac13e7214534f037e2","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["ef5608cabffe37e469482dca710b2cb7dd6c0321d924b82441c0ffb9b282ebe5","5c779f3f51c96c62fe153ec5aacb9ded7820e7af5ba757f5cad3cd18099f3a32","14301ca92a1e71fc5044673ebafcf39626584ab63166efdf4e2d2eabe5c632c0","9c72aab8e0e0edffb14afaadf344671756e022e06d3687dc5d6fc3b5e0b97870","d05bf2bf8c68043aaa51f2cfb8fb0d2c5d1e786f27b9cc35979caf603b617b86","17833e367694ba59e5c96175df7d21bdf9a74faecf713df1a0a729a24419c4a3","f5c7301aebaa1be44666f74ed37989fde8720931a7de565f9d0120a3259d29ac","3b56e23f7c50665a7126e8be785b916e00049af21aa563408603f30a6c0d58f3","50c74f0b4f60295f32baaa64f9988d641ef58dd03f87892ad8c5943282b71911","a61078c1e734b8381b4acfeaefb1bbf1bce6333a95611250b585e0e5659797bd","2f9e80e1ce87c03c4ad91e992bcbf67e6c71bf6f1e7b9b23b00a2e45681cf1b1","bdc8129c6d2b339bf334be67bc326cc40c42db205cb9dc3fdeaeffb3abc3d536","f0dbe5481dd430ece792afd209b66bc3074d8e11338cfdb96fd9b5ccab6cf28e","b41a42b6460e65b669bc91421d5ae7cdf309c91bd75275fbfd30d1a1940250b8","6823cdfa48cb938c7220cea003e138a04199827eb741d91fba8667a8fa739871","b1d5dbd96f04c307cd0ec4742ff77e8a00ea0e5207c0f3a0e7e2883c6483d741","3c290e41ac100869059a40f77ff37d1ea351d278aaadf74c7e5c88df5044f2ce","7eec7107f2403aee082d3d06b0609352e6b0e3dac0e8bcfb627e6365fbc87b16","bbb248370e1b2a302010bb9244dd4a6c29d2ea859a6ee718be9f77d22976fa3c"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"008570d50fca43d256d066f3a83520a0e478c40d2a6751a6c7d2a0bc19b113a8","submission_id":"T60-cd36e33c05d5bb85#2"},"hash":"c815e99f498e7fed9c3e185ee4c239eb906e5f4eb1448ef73ff4fc543201366f","header":{"body_hash":"86f869ef50295295fe9403c1781e8869aebda337bc085d82e8cfe50eb5d92bc8","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"0ddfca1a6cf2c8f1c140947301d9fa3b8d6ccbb8d2851f4164ff0f200331e771","records_root":"b5316728ab35439a030b72d941bae07a6671ee174fb689d0775fc18ed629a777","seq":300,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"21a6117a0719e1e4eb58690b8d5375f4c313ebe6c0524bdf4d5243ccb97630b1","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":false,"agent":"reader-3","circle":17,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":23,"refusals":1,"stored":34,"sync_step":33,"task_id":"T60-cd36e33c05d5bb85"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13647323.txt#7","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a9a59010c74def0bb33478e5a8c610a2b1acd7695a1790ac13e7214534f037e2","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"ae13f9a73e316a3b04d977aadd7b2f1fac9c4e8802d54c801402f6546c74f7d6","submission_id":"T60-cd36e33c05d5bb85#done3"},"hash":"9d221971823fa5129ab76298b3f09b4c1cd9cb9bdabfd8e023df3e8aff4b521d","header":{"body_hash":"a713089738c5d7f4d7fbb395a26260ee4c21b1ee31285157471b3882721c3978","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"c815e99f498e7fed9c3e185ee4c239eb906e5f4eb1448ef73ff4fc543201366f","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":301,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"e99ac352175b071ef050524a5df66054032be57649748ce58303f67a4bdb1b1b","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR62-558c09b09a9f1416","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Observed between-subgroup differences were found across cultural contexts (QBET = 7.594, df = 1, p < 0.05).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o1","terms":["cultural context moderator","between-subgroup heterogeneity"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"This effect was larger in countries with predominantly collectivist cultures (g = 0.815, 95% CI = [0.585, 1.046]) than those with individualistic ones (g = 0.367, 95% CI = [0.147, 0.587]).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o2","terms":["collectivist vs individualistic culture","effect sizes on learning motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Meta-regression showed no significant association between gender and GenAI's effect on learning motivation (QModel(1, k = 25) = 0.25, p > 0.05; see Table 4).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o3","terms":["gender meta-regression","proportion of female participants"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Female | QModel(1, k = 25) = 0.25, p = 0.614\n\nβ0 | 0.434 | 0.276 | 1.570 | 0.116 | [−0.106, 0.975] | 105.640*** | 0.782\n\nβ1 | 0.266 | 0.527 | 0.500 | 0.614 | [−0.768, 1.300] |  |","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o4","terms":["gender meta-regression parameters","k=25","β1=0.266","I2=0.782"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Observed between-subgroup differences by education stage were found (QBET = 13.536, df = 2, p < 0.05).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o5","terms":["education stage moderator","between-subgroup heterogeneity"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The effect was stronger among university students (g = 0.886, 95% CI = [0.637, 1.136]), followed by secondary school students (g = 0.360, 95% CI = [0.157, 0.563]), and finally primary school students (g = 0.311, 95% CI = [0.077, 0.544]).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o6","terms":["education stage effect sizes","university","secondary","primary"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Between-subgroup differences were not significant across GenAI function (QBET = 0.011, df = 1, p > 0.05).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o7","terms":["GenAI function moderator"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Observed between-subgroup differences were found across GenAI device type (QBET = 11.913, df = 1, p < 0.05).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o8","terms":["GenAI device type moderator"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Using GenAI on mobile devices (g = 0.782, 95% CI = [0.545, 1.018]) had a stronger effect on learning motivation than using it on computers (g = 0.303, 95% CI = [0.169, 0.438]).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o9","terms":["mobile vs computer device effect sizes"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Observed between-subgroup differences across subject domains were found (QBET = 23.785, df = 4, p < 0.05), with language-related studies showing the largest pooled effect (g = 0.946, 95% CI = [0.630, 1.262])","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o10","terms":["subject domain moderator","language domain effect size"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"followed by mathematics (g = 0.711, 95% CI = [0.356, 1.066]) and pedagogy (g = 0.697, 95% CI = [0.261, 1.133]), then information (g = 0.291, 95% CI = [0.047, 0.535]), and lowest in science (g = 0.109, 95% CI = [−0.107, 0.325]).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o11","terms":["subject domain effect sizes","mathematics","pedagogy","information","science"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Subject domain | 23.785*** (p = 0.000) |  |  |  |  |  |\n\nInformation |  | 8 | 0.291 | 0.125 | [0.047, 0.535] | 19.490** | 0.641\n\nLanguage |  | 32 | 0.946 | 0.161 | [0.630, 1.262] | 738.283*** | 0.958","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o12","terms":["subject domain k values","Information k=8","Language k=32"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Math |  | 4 | 0.711 | 0.181 | [0.356, 1.066] | 8.422* | 0.644\n\nPedagogy |  | 6 | 0.697 | 0.222 | [0.261, 1.133] | 30.635*** | 0.837\n\nScience |  | 3 | 0.109 | 0.110 | [−0.107, 0.325] | 0.137 | 0.000","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o13","terms":["subject domain k values","Math k=4","Pedagogy k=6","Science k=3"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Between-subgroup differences were not significant across intervention duration (QBET = 1.475, df = 2, p > 0.05) and type of motivation (QBET = 1.415, df = 1, p > 0.05).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o14","terms":["intervention duration moderator","type of motivation moderator"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Intervention duration | 1.475 (p = 0.478) |  |  |  |  |  |\n\nLong |  | 13 | 0.456 | 0.095 | [0.270, 0.642] | 59.694*** | 0.799\n\nMedium |  | 17 | 0.643 | 0.122 | [0.404, 0.883] | 80.738*** | 0.802\n\nShort |  | 17 | 0.519 | 0.104 | [0.315, 0.722] | 64.178*** | 0.751","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o15","terms":["intervention duration subgroup statistics","Long k=13","Medium k=17","Short k=17"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Meta-regression showed no significant association between publication year and GenAI's effect on learning motivation (QBET = 3.519, df = 2, p > 0.05).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o16","terms":["publication year moderator"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"2024 |  | 19 | 0.552 | 0.099 | [0.358, 0.745] | 93.616*** | 0.808\n\n2025 |  | 28 | 0.929 | 0.176 | [0.585, 1.273] | 693.288*** | 0.961","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o17","terms":["2024 and 2025 subgroup statistics","2024 k=19","2025 k=28"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"This meta-analysis examined whether students who use GenAI exhibit greater learning motivation compared to those who do not. Due to the high heterogeneity among studies, a random effects model was adopted.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o18","terms":["meta-analysis scope","learning motivation","random effects model"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Additionally, this study analyzed the influence of nine moderator variables on the effectiveness of GenAI.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o19","terms":["nine moderator variables"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"This meta-analysis demonstrated that, compared with conventional teaching conditions, GenAI produced a statistically significant improvement in students' overall learning motivation (g = 0.764)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o20","terms":["overall learning motivation effect size g=0.764","conventional teaching comparison"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"with significant positive effects detected for both intrinsic motivation and extrinsic motivation. Taken together, the synthesized evidence indicates that GenAI yields a moderate-to-large average effect on student motivation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o21","terms":["intrinsic motivation","extrinsic motivation","moderate-to-large average effect"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Nevertheless, the extremely high between-study heterogeneity (I2 = 93.7%) indicates that the magnitude of this effect varies dramatically across study contexts.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o22","terms":["high between-study heterogeneity I2=93.7%","context variability"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Consequently, our findings do not support the conclusion that GenAI reliably increases motivation across all educational environments.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t62_o23","terms":["qualification of conclusion","not reliable across all environments"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t62_o18","t62_o19","t62_o20","t62_o21"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t62_c1","object":"GenAI improves overall learning motivation (g=0.764), intrinsic and extrinsic motivation vs conventional teaching","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 is a random-effects meta-analysis of 9 moderators concluding that GenAI significantly improves student learning motivation over conventional teaching (g=0.764), including intrinsic and extrinsic motivation."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t62_o20","t62_o22","t62_o23"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t62_c2","object":"I2=93.7% heterogeneity; findings do not support reliable motivation increase across all educational environments","predicate":"qualifies_conclusions","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 qualifies its main conclusion by noting that extremely high between-study heterogeneity (I2=93.7%) means the findings do not support that GenAI reliably increases motivation across all educational environments."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t62_o1","t62_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t62_c3","object":"QBET=7.594, df=1, p<0.05; collectivist g=0.815 [0.585, 1.046] vs individualistic g=0.367 [0.147, 0.587]","predicate":"reports_moderator_cultural_context","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 finds significant subgroup differences in GenAI's effect on learning motivation by cultural context (QBET=7.594, p<0.05; collectivist g=0.815 vs individualistic g=0.367)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t62_o5","t62_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t62_c4","object":"QBET=13.536, df=2, p<0.05; university g=0.886, secondary g=0.360, primary g=0.311","predicate":"reports_moderator_education_stage","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 finds significant subgroup differences by education stage (QBET=13.536, df=2, p<0.05): stronger in university (g=0.886) than secondary (g=0.360) and primary school (g=0.311)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t62_o8","t62_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t62_c5","object":"QBET=11.913, df=1, p<0.05; mobile devices g=0.782 [0.545, 1.018] vs computers g=0.303 [0.169, 0.438]","predicate":"reports_moderator_device_type","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 finds significant subgroup differences by GenAI device type (QBET=11.913, df=1, p<0.05), with mobile devices (g=0.782) showing a stronger effect on learning motivation than computers (g=0.303)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t62_o10","t62_o11","t62_o12","t62_o13"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t62_c6","object":"QBET=23.785, df=4, p<0.05; language g=0.946 (k=32), math g=0.711 (k=4), pedagogy g=0.697 (k=6), information g=0.291 (k=8), science g=0.109 (k=3)","predicate":"reports_moderator_subject_domain","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 finds significant differences across subject domains (QBET=23.785, df=4, p<0.05): language (k=32, g=0.946), math (k=4, g=0.711), pedagogy (k=6, g=0.697), information (k=8, g=0.291), science (k=3, g=0.109)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t62_o3","t62_o4","t62_o7","t62_o14","t62_o16","t62_o17"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t62_c7","object":"non-significant: gender (k=25, p=0.614), GenAI function (QBET=0.011), motivation type (QBET=1.415), publication year (QBET=3.519)","predicate":"reports_nonsignificant_moderators","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 finds no significant moderation of learning motivation by female proportion (k=25, QModel=0.25, p=0.614, β1=0.266), GenAI function (QBET=0.011), motivation type (QBET=1.415), or pub year (QBET=3.519; 2024 k=19, 2025 k=28)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t62_o14","t62_o15"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t62_c8","object":"QBET=1.475, df=2, p=0.478; Long (k=13, g=0.456), Medium (k=17, g=0.643), Short (k=17, g=0.519)","predicate":"reports_moderator_intervention_duration","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 finds no significant subgroup differences by intervention duration (QBET=1.475, df=2, p=0.478 across Long k=13 g=0.456, Medium k=17 g=0.643, and Short k=17 g=0.519)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",44772,49534]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"df25353d1038dab3311f099684bb83c1536bbd318927d2aa6e6bf26b839c0428","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["bb20f4ae1a30306c4df19834dba68cde1f4897ea96965679648a0100da2874af","1e36e486f8767a61778f3cfac449689ad8d3508fedd2fa3de83757f04edc77ca","a89ca207a08dcc0ebd33477c58c2f1ed87e206139f827c9202529466b3bdb014","df0f7f3918746880609e1aad35e1fcd939df4b69424c044ccfb89f604146e5c4","9270284e8426aa9fb9c101c81a35722cb78d7c929e7ccfb991ca358995ce9262","dedbb2d52c8bf23f5b28bad3ad0aacbcdf1614ac9fff730db8762377300f2890","dd4118928376cd7bdf5c7bd5f1efc9bc5e4c7a52c6d023bd9bb75351736aea5a","53b2f817281b81cab1db9bc50664d5030108969683d1196f857258fbec844226","d2c68257161ac5439e4d9de8bed24919cada4f29d55ea3b081e0d8be0d34f47f","6594b24aaaf694c164f667335c88178afbc3e7c37d9154e20870573b239cabf8","77ea8a6c16d681260d79402f816aa6dd2e546cc5d71902bf6baabe3347bdbcd9","5e6fb7500f50538a20a14e9e144d59727ae0322078eadfc1c9d677bdb5cac0ce","bf89948cae933675d4ac93bc2a8092b76249de8f78a6a997864a6ebdd963e632","95c8f3f4fe86064e701cfd907a0c66521850ad8a2961e18d9912c0e7bdaf0c86","3e2a95c5ede817c6b4ee1063092f621c28e2567f4bacb0357d15d6826f037dc2","b35f0b124453adb08f9c938a475b04d566dd3ebbf4a10fda4820018f35792f60","5905f19c24db55127a96ebd0dbfeb8e0d1199c6565742da9a35ebc11286ba492","b2869045dd17b3791677d34945c31df26e4d34f7dbe7db004c51baeb009d91d4","f02f531049b1bd56711cb48033a3446852f41139dc8b90981bf3401872f27480","3435164e4b9dcd33b2c815972eda3acf39f2702631b2a2dd5529d0e9dd9767e2","8f02479215d92490f89ca036c7efe36271de57e16bc2df8e15c0d5a85e2ee214","fe8494cc3a61aa37ee47016027e8bfcad7789c8c20bf73686fdc53458c2eb261","b46fb7f246df5355968139cbf9ca1f5a2e974c04d5a87189f1960c43c6ac791a","cddc463810bfb5044e21089c472f1c80fd3020bdb429e3381ce846221cf223d7","c7639d1bb3e371a0a506f7779889e4316b235fd7d03132cf454890e10f8bbfcd","e5da44672996f5963234e99e5c6590166a2f784f7fa07b851a707f09b7fabfb6","09c7caa83e04412df39c9c2b12368af324d2b8d23ea84f59385c68dc1f2e60fd","19514cac5865a2e8ba37f55a3ab9fe259e17fdcc39d693dacd4cf0a32d1e2413","14b0bb6f0077911ccfcabd3ce28b8f9ebfb5aa58e46a609a83844fab098ca385","17e9893466b6270a1c9bebb989228a68fa191c73eb912a394aa1daa8659b6cb1","d038194825c4cbe9ca3d2b1a80caf6305f80ba94dbafd9abcadc2cc3d0af7944"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"bf1258b3350b4ca37157c70b39d29e14b783e51937a99a7b93cd4cf6291db81c","submission_id":"TR62-558c09b09a9f1416#1"},"hash":"862547288b12cd06701940c3384e656dfb987470e67751a2a2b58da6e31027ee","header":{"body_hash":"897c565af6664d18495d6f24f2cac3228f6b78c838d56da6866e35411d2dd972","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"9d221971823fa5129ab76298b3f09b4c1cd9cb9bdabfd8e023df3e8aff4b521d","records_root":"1cb101a0bebb1e87672eec7fafc5048e9575a15eb6f0bcfa1290aa3667028df9","seq":302,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"1c23adff1d271982f5d457ed5b3431d32d31f2e7a15880d3fb22bcc691e36a84","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":17,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":5,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:PMC13647323.txt#8"},"sync_step":33,"task_id":"TR62-558c09b09a9f1416"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:PMC13647323.txt#8","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"df25353d1038dab3311f099684bb83c1536bbd318927d2aa6e6bf26b839c0428","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"6146a59682d6103c2d52037a1376c7f9ffa09122a10b26607ce8b4b79e900cc2","submission_id":"TR62-558c09b09a9f1416#done2"},"hash":"95574ef303df6b6b54d7b4ce6a24ca3d9a9d2dc2e7286dacb646805f38cbeb95","header":{"body_hash":"62aead4192a3421b8cad1d92fe372c532b232c18492cdd376493c99d49921d46","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"862547288b12cd06701940c3384e656dfb987470e67751a2a2b58da6e31027ee","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":303,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"7e43bae6474a86643488b7fd70b9ab43fd8bd4f36d362413e1e5badadefcef20","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":17,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":837},"started_unix_ms":1795102902121,"wave":{"doc:PMC13647323.txt#6":"reader-2","doc:PMC13647323.txt#7":"reader-3","doc:PMC13647323.txt#8":"reader-1"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"df25353d1038dab3311f099684bb83c1536bbd318927d2aa6e6bf26b839c0428","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"43bf09cfebde68eeeab2fa13272f6eb4902572a3c28ee4ed1cf2d92d746fef61","submission_id":"circle:2e28901ef0aad57382829bcdf57786913f4712f8e5d60ce90e16ee98db1a35dc"},"hash":"c50d4751e552d697f3c94383946b76e0ffb9f96127598441887e57a017e7d85c","header":{"body_hash":"118a7d1a19767d38c8abd47c87a0d5a310c0174e749f26be7533787904516cb1","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"95574ef303df6b6b54d7b4ce6a24ca3d9a9d2dc2e7286dacb646805f38cbeb95","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":304,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"ba07a9a2e6f0362727c431920495b5bd5807cddd5be7f870603717212a1e08d5","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"7e43bae6474a86643488b7fd70b9ab43fd8bd4f36d362413e1e5badadefcef20","engine_root":"df25353d1038dab3311f099684bb83c1536bbd318927d2aa6e6bf26b839c0428","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"efa1cf7c9d39a39e5ac1994cddd92cb1d28e9106b8d3e060374010a1f3434044","log_size":305,"projections":{"dependencies":"54157f1e5c426fb3e2f3b84c626cf8468e07f816c3c630a1a248a3df1c295ab6","status":"8f8ebf5c96ed24335fc2be37c0ecb9e4dc08868e45b559a9457f65ce4d142850"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"c50d4751e552d697f3c94383946b76e0ffb9f96127598441887e57a017e7d85c"}},"engine_root":"df25353d1038dab3311f099684bb83c1536bbd318927d2aa6e6bf26b839c0428","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"7e43bae6474a86643488b7fd70b9ab43fd8bd4f36d362413e1e5badadefcef20","engine_root":"df25353d1038dab3311f099684bb83c1536bbd318927d2aa6e6bf26b839c0428","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"efa1cf7c9d39a39e5ac1994cddd92cb1d28e9106b8d3e060374010a1f3434044","log_size":305,"projections":{"dependencies":"54157f1e5c426fb3e2f3b84c626cf8468e07f816c3c630a1a248a3df1c295ab6","status":"8f8ebf5c96ed24335fc2be37c0ecb9e4dc08868e45b559a9457f65ce4d142850"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"c50d4751e552d697f3c94383946b76e0ffb9f96127598441887e57a017e7d85c"},"seal_hash":"ff81de62c9561cc1cda601d894f1d155b0e3cecd142e152526d592b01738e5a0"}},"request_hash":"ddb3c9028764885218fe3ac1ba80f1d67497eb685493f87a7134cb4eca9c85ea","submission_id":"seal-305"},"hash":"9e1375458ab5ccd932942a367f82155fcef1a26a06ecb65bdf9886730ab5c55d","header":{"body_hash":"52b39538add15292570ef4c78e89feb233518e846c1daef694d219e6362cbca1","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"c50d4751e552d697f3c94383946b76e0ffb9f96127598441887e57a017e7d85c","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":305,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"f8f65e049f018ebe34daf5da8cd3f804dba659cd054827e0b73982f1a974bd87","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[17,"BUILD",0],"epoch":34,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25},{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":26},{"binding":[14,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":27},{"binding":[14,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":28},{"binding":[15,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":29},{"binding":[15,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":30},{"binding":[16,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":31},{"binding":[16,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":32},{"binding":[17,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":33},{"binding":[17,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":34}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102902121},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"df25353d1038dab3311f099684bb83c1536bbd318927d2aa6e6bf26b839c0428","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"baabd37bb8e80065b12c2f63b8f933de776bd602e1b538e4ac7eb9a76a63d982","submission_id":"ring-members:70df980751968f7df35e68738dbcd4dcbe9f3b4325e3205cc7c8be9223b1a947"},"hash":"a53ceb2d89150df0701d7f146a665e8b533685c98a67bac6bfc01e5ec26b090a","header":{"body_hash":"1f1fd5d3ef355ca8acc41b57c50db501e340d1857ce4a0da4e0ad0f30bfb969f","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"9e1375458ab5ccd932942a367f82155fcef1a26a06ecb65bdf9886730ab5c55d","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":306,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"dd9253a7d180eff6eb0dbef72805a3d43e5c933b5643e39aeb262b47b1bd9f74","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":18,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":837},"started_unix_ms":1795102902153,"wave":{"doc:PMC13647323.txt#10":"reader-1","doc:PMC13647323.txt#11":"reader-2","doc:PMC13647323.txt#9":"reader-3"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"df25353d1038dab3311f099684bb83c1536bbd318927d2aa6e6bf26b839c0428","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"58cbc9840053b59e94a004f4dc926b452a0b12c2793646e3505f564e89714de1","submission_id":"circle:c92d2a292092d11e6a4eea4440a6702423f2f8806e2d252be71800c9bde769a4"},"hash":"e8558d3dd675593d4736e78042b3548970c5abf9058a6c74446e87d8a749c430","header":{"body_hash":"b96a48d57a411b7073cd4b9b75bb06f134b4f9ec73af8cfc3369e85a6b53210b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"a53ceb2d89150df0701d7f146a665e8b533685c98a67bac6bfc01e5ec26b090a","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":307,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"08e1770855be114b2a5e5b711d4927c9c25d74eb5b0d3effa4ba8fcdc55fdbc5","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"dd9253a7d180eff6eb0dbef72805a3d43e5c933b5643e39aeb262b47b1bd9f74","engine_root":"df25353d1038dab3311f099684bb83c1536bbd318927d2aa6e6bf26b839c0428","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"094420a62ab2162cad667c027538168297bfddff0c3db0650ab04b5ebdb5bb33","log_size":308,"projections":{"dependencies":"54157f1e5c426fb3e2f3b84c626cf8468e07f816c3c630a1a248a3df1c295ab6","status":"8f8ebf5c96ed24335fc2be37c0ecb9e4dc08868e45b559a9457f65ce4d142850"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"e8558d3dd675593d4736e78042b3548970c5abf9058a6c74446e87d8a749c430"}},"engine_root":"df25353d1038dab3311f099684bb83c1536bbd318927d2aa6e6bf26b839c0428","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"dd9253a7d180eff6eb0dbef72805a3d43e5c933b5643e39aeb262b47b1bd9f74","engine_root":"df25353d1038dab3311f099684bb83c1536bbd318927d2aa6e6bf26b839c0428","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"094420a62ab2162cad667c027538168297bfddff0c3db0650ab04b5ebdb5bb33","log_size":308,"projections":{"dependencies":"54157f1e5c426fb3e2f3b84c626cf8468e07f816c3c630a1a248a3df1c295ab6","status":"8f8ebf5c96ed24335fc2be37c0ecb9e4dc08868e45b559a9457f65ce4d142850"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"e8558d3dd675593d4736e78042b3548970c5abf9058a6c74446e87d8a749c430"},"seal_hash":"41bab07633b73831547f2964b06d7c6bd225d706ae2e60cdf9c634872ed4c49b"}},"request_hash":"8cd847ab4b44aa740bb130836a41b689c32a617ee83d61482851e66e21d6c0fe","submission_id":"seal-308"},"hash":"873342df817b20581b3ef7215d912436ab9ab79521f5331326ee0f35593781d9","header":{"body_hash":"b9d531f737c7e5dc60432eecbfa9d0b549bea90d6752e6b1945a8ffcd8e6b4eb","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"e8558d3dd675593d4736e78042b3548970c5abf9058a6c74446e87d8a749c430","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":308,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"4c5df06aa96510bf2f406979fcd3d87f566e274b3d2bdc4f89b348d1c2a59de7","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[18,"READ",0],"epoch":35,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25},{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":26},{"binding":[14,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":27},{"binding":[14,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":28},{"binding":[15,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":29},{"binding":[15,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":30},{"binding":[16,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":31},{"binding":[16,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":32},{"binding":[17,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":33},{"binding":[17,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":34},{"binding":[18,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":35}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102902153},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"df25353d1038dab3311f099684bb83c1536bbd318927d2aa6e6bf26b839c0428","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"f89ebe2b0f6573834aadf17caada69c14b0cd7381738fd7648e20f6fcee7630c","submission_id":"ring-members:eab0f81941ee03a2bd44fc5a553a9521ca69dbeecac96aa9b7f0f330972cc565"},"hash":"e77b7f478ad08608b981b58f177445022ee92c224544a6915ce11639f44ef4bb","header":{"body_hash":"53ee01e100d2172df8e7ae984bda3bb3860d3e45e16a150f793833c8264a39a6","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"873342df817b20581b3ef7215d912436ab9ab79521f5331326ee0f35593781d9","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":309,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"6e747ab5b702640942d42ec091d9f5a092a0081468d63e215f1285e0b7298ced","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T63-58df06363792de6c","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"these patterns suggest that GenAI may be more likely to foster improvements in students' learning motivation relative to conventional instruction.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t63_o1","terms":["GenAI effect on learning motivation","conventional instruction comparison"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Although culture, education stage, subject domain, and device type were statistically associated with differences in average effect sizes, these variables were study-level characteristics rather than experimentally manipulated conditions.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t63_o2","terms":["moderator variables","culture","education stage","subject domain","device type","study-level characteristics"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"They may help explain why GenAI effects differed across studies, but they do not establish that culture, device type, subject domain, or education stage causally determined the motivational effects of GenAI.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t63_o3","terms":["causal qualification","moderator boundary conditions"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Motivation type was not a significant moderator. To test H-1a and H-1b, subgroup analyses were conducted for intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. GenAI showed positive effects on both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t63_o4","terms":["motivation type moderator","intrinsic motivation","extrinsic motivation","H-1a","H-1b"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"However, the between-group comparison between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation was not statistically significant. Therefore, H-1c was not supported.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t63_o5","terms":["intrinsic vs extrinsic motivation comparison","H-1c not supported"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Our exploratory findings suggest that cultural context may contribute to heterogeneity in GenAI's effects on learning motivation, with stronger effects in collectivist societies.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t63_o6","terms":["cultural context moderator","collectivist vs individualist societies","learning motivation heterogeneity"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t63_o1","t63_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t63_c1","object":"GenAI improves learning motivation relative to conventional instruction, with positive effects on both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 concludes that GenAI fosters improvements in students' learning motivation relative to conventional instruction, showing positive effects on both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation (supporting H-1a and H-1b)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t63_o4","t63_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t63_c2","object":"motivation type (intrinsic vs. extrinsic) is not a significant moderator (H-1c not supported)","predicate":"reports_moderator_finding","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 finds that motivation type is not a significant moderator of GenAI's effect on learning motivation: the between-group difference between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation was not statistically significant (H-1c not supported)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t63_o2","t63_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t63_c3","object":"culture (stronger in collectivist societies), education stage, subject domain, and device type significantly moderate GenAI motivational effects","predicate":"reports_moderator_finding","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 reports that culture, education stage, subject domain, and device type were statistically associated with differences in average effect sizes on learning motivation (with stronger effects in collectivist societies)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t63_o2","t63_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t63_c4","object":"moderator associations (culture, device type, subject domain, education stage) are study-level characteristics and do not establish causal determination","predicate":"qualifies_conclusions","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 qualifies its significant moderator findings (culture, education stage, subject domain, device type) as exploratory signals that do not establish causal determination because they were study-level characteristics."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",49534,55426]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"244f88b5515be0d8e887a6e5cc832d19f0f77b9e50fd2dbd81840806f623cc5d","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["2c3611eea993a63a2d722a264626d16fb22af433038a2bc04972665330884559","7f3d079a915e71c17e3d7bf242740f98098ca0896c666c7603d99672bebe6aa4","76821cb5a085c3eb290e5458b6a64ce0b2e7a4411c1f21131ad1a833293163ca","ba1870e1dcff65e6d4a3f6e8687c9155670924d33fffbfef55a23d89cf81d88a","759841178d0799947d969b00274d958fc9dc85655f21796c72baebe66efe981b","4c936293fb3f3ac14519b8bd766429cd7ba9dad579b36e9e6afc3c390d1a71d4","43f3a22a34f2f8e1fa7df5b752aeb868276b40dbf4d616273bbd007aa17a5624","64ecbc051e1935b99e1430139ecfab0f1e77667155f7c0610b02ed73393d47f0","c61b6511c99a6b579dc9df8e594e3a99dc0776de3c94708538702b334885eda8","88b66015acd30293342b05e2b32ca87ad0c7488ad02fc32e71e1afcc48049dd3"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"b4621db5f48212dca881b0c771a36f3d6bee1dc6952925f777d995ac9169ba8b","submission_id":"T63-58df06363792de6c#1"},"hash":"9a4d240c45a908c39fa0a1f5acb81260a58c740be9798ffb4e3c28945c501ad3","header":{"body_hash":"524d401f75bde7cb175cd774cbf03d9580f064ce031515a6d6bfd80b33f1b8ec","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"e77b7f478ad08608b981b58f177445022ee92c224544a6915ce11639f44ef4bb","records_root":"7cc1f6f4c7a1c35d6f65447351cb14522bec14c82735fce8139d53656cc33410","seq":310,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"aa771f46610a37057e2f21a0eda2d88a0e8fda38af4f67fa760b0bee13a2972b","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":18,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":35,"task_id":"T63-58df06363792de6c"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13647323.txt#9","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"244f88b5515be0d8e887a6e5cc832d19f0f77b9e50fd2dbd81840806f623cc5d","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"637b959413d565244b3a90baa1c6d8ac94c23c5b10529a4d982090af6e0cdaa8","submission_id":"T63-58df06363792de6c#done2"},"hash":"eaa42b469e786428450968ebc1976e94966e2f51c549153440fd35d35afc2b4b","header":{"body_hash":"d2010ad756b3e22912afd6eb67a6663d4b99782800fdd6480ae014159171b685","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"9a4d240c45a908c39fa0a1f5acb81260a58c740be9798ffb4e3c28945c501ad3","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":311,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"f571830202aae10709132c3c458d8c5c860f8f0c9e988f2cceab5d0705cd61c7","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T64-5967ab869687e000","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The exploratory subject-domain finding suggested that average effects were largest in language-related courses.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t64_o1","terms":["PMC13647323","subject domain moderator","language-related courses"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"In contrast, motivational benefits were smaller in information technology and science, aligning with prior meta-analytic conclusions (Ma and Zhong, 2025).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t64_o2","terms":["PMC13647323","subject domain moderator","information technology and science"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Owing to the uneven distribution of included studies across subject domains, several subgroups contained relatively small sample sizes.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t64_o3","terms":["PMC13647323","subject domain limitation","uneven sample distribution"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The observed differences in motivational effect sizes may be partially attributed to imbalanced sample distribution, rather than representing a robust, genuine moderating effect of subject domain.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t64_o4","terms":["PMC13647323","subject domain qualification","imbalanced sample distribution"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Intervention duration did not significantly moderate the effect. This suggests that the length of exposure alone may not determine whether GenAI supports students' motivation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t64_o5","terms":["PMC13647323","intervention duration moderator","learning motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Hypothesis 3 was not supported by the present meta-analytic findings. Gender did not significantly moderate the effect of GenAI on learning motivation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t64_o6","terms":["PMC13647323","gender moderator","Hypothesis 3","learning motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"This study suggests a positive effect of GenAI on learning motivation with observed between-subgroup differences were found across cultural contexts, education stage, GenAI device type and subject domains.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t64_o7","terms":["PMC13647323","overall effect","learning motivation","subgroup differences"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"However, these findings should be treated as exploratory because of the uneven sample-size distribution across some subgroups and the substantial heterogeneity.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t64_o8","terms":["PMC13647323","exploratory qualification","uneven sample-size distribution","substantial heterogeneity"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"At the same time, cultural context may influence GenAI's effectiveness, with exploratory findings suggesting potentially larger effects in countries where collectivist values predominate.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t64_o9","terms":["PMC13647323","cultural context moderator","collectivist values"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Although a random-effects model was used and moderator analyses were conducted to explore possible sources of variation, the large heterogeneity indicates that the pooled effect should be interpreted as an average estimate rather than as evidence of a uniform effect across educational contexts.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t64_o10","terms":["PMC13647323","random-effects model","moderator analyses","large heterogeneity","pooled effect limitation"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t64_o7","t64_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t64_c1","object":"positive effect of GenAI on learning motivation; exploratory subgroup differences by cultural context, education stage, device type, and subject domain","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 concludes a positive meta-analytic effect of GenAI on learning motivation, with exploratory subgroup differences across cultural contexts, education stage, GenAI device type, and subject domains."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t64_o5","t64_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t64_c2","object":"intervention duration and gender (Hypothesis 3) did not significantly moderate GenAI's effect on learning motivation","predicate":"reports_non_significant_moderators","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 finds that intervention duration and gender (Hypothesis 3) did not significantly moderate the effect of GenAI on students' learning motivation."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t64_o1","t64_o2","t64_o3","t64_o4","t64_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t64_c3","object":"largest motivational effects in language courses, smaller in IT and science, potentially larger in collectivist cultural contexts","predicate":"reports_subgroup_findings","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 reports exploratory findings that GenAI motivational effects were largest in language-related courses, smaller in IT and science, and potentially larger in countries with predominantly collectivist values."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t64_o3","t64_o4","t64_o8","t64_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t64_c4","object":"random-effects meta-analysis with substantial heterogeneity and uneven subgroup sample sizes; pooled effect is an average rather than uniform effect","predicate":"qualifies_conclusions","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 uses a random-effects meta-analytic model with moderator analyses and qualifies its pooled effect as an average estimate rather than a uniform effect due to substantial between-study heterogeneity and uneven subgroup sizes."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",60078,65923]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"4308806f35eac5a8fe20b0ce70a4a34cade145e9d6e067970e27848e74f4d661","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["1a7885d47664927b635bfdbfaf693472aa9fd39caebb2ffcc7135b3787b97434","d758433b27d1c5667bc10a060c2d010c106e9f5f5c92d0fff21d17367ea74202","ef88021b464ba16af4e872471d571ba3bc0cb66c14351b1331fc40ab50a55c80","4d0004c3a204b8cbfc09449ae9df6f389ef5ac9fc2861f5825a10ec0f8cb9352","280b694688b8958c4a1b2a695c1ef203c6308ab61c42dc6b6d13b01daa386d3b","4079539c527d09df7653537e2cc670877a8f4c7d83fb7bfd0f64ac20ed48404a","0aca95dd4a30139c889632ad74f9f517f9804e2d8be19b331e42e263707c415e","44209a95f3b2e66f88747a8f2a0b5b75f2568d719c2c3454778509f6aeebea34","3ef498cca7c4f562dc36d6bc1079eb5527b53db8068da9aaf3d33e2f0f1986a0","53bc348146ddd49f1907bc23b8f88616730f8deb58feb8d90be80f6fd7752383","72086e2640eb00ac2a5d88c5639b1dd43e49f07ff8926c66cb1b8935affc7fea","f2e739ce1321c95d2c8db3b39cbcdcfb3647cce8e723c9cd2366c6ff6942534f","e4bcfeae9cf798d9d28b1fcb470e41f57fffb72932b4e311044eb006630c7036","8ff82d45ee16f5d604bec95a91306fb1d429b36fd5379f78da4e9146eade4237"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"c29b0d13ba74b8eb9441729ec8d83ae2a46173cd8f459edd666d2057be7a907b","submission_id":"T64-5967ab869687e000#1"},"hash":"ba625ac5ccdcdcce4df1129a2874a55ccec4446b8eb37059f5922111794fcfc2","header":{"body_hash":"80cdc77ce6bbdd3967659f8a9bc7647b66f0b752097438de00214e619eaa1aaf","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"eaa42b469e786428450968ebc1976e94966e2f51c549153440fd35d35afc2b4b","records_root":"31621f66724e3e4f1f265f8523342be6ce1093f12754aa5c67fc66e5864779da","seq":312,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"a7f32bb89346c04e898d9d927453cf1229f4e62af896ae730203cdd1bf9fe2dc","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":18,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":35,"task_id":"T64-5967ab869687e000"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13647323.txt#11","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"4308806f35eac5a8fe20b0ce70a4a34cade145e9d6e067970e27848e74f4d661","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"2de93329303c1bd75d8d55e9cf4017ad9c301bb40e572e28b4a264a170c06fd9","submission_id":"T64-5967ab869687e000#done2"},"hash":"9b33afebdd405418a13b745d7fc9a8182ad17fc663451194e09d9baf07403b8c","header":{"body_hash":"71089985183b587c6dcc66e17224b3e985c7d1c5545471db15ffaa9dd4b3e3f1","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ba625ac5ccdcdcce4df1129a2874a55ccec4446b8eb37059f5922111794fcfc2","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":313,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"affe1f10f6c064bace51059a15bb24beb781f1b21ef232c043f012a1356de29c","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T65-9a59ac5a9a921463","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Our exploratory subgroup analysis suggests that student education level may moderate the effects of GenAI on learning motivation","kind":"observe","local_id":"t65_o1","terms":["student education level moderator","learning motivation","exploratory subgroup analysis"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"with university students appearing to show larger motivational gains than secondary school students, who in turn appeared to benefit more than primary school students.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t65_o2","terms":["university students","secondary school students","primary school students","motivational gains"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"GenAI function was not a significant moderator.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t65_o3","terms":["GenAI function","non-significant moderator"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The non-significant result may therefore reflect the broadness of the current functional categories rather than the absence of meaningful differences among GenAI applications.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t65_o4","terms":["functional categories qualification","GenAI function"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Exploratory analysis suggests that GenAI device type may be a potential moderator of GenAI's effects on learning motivation","kind":"observe","local_id":"t65_o5","terms":["GenAI device type","potential moderator","learning motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"these exploratory patterns tentatively point to relatively stronger usage intentions and intrinsic motivation compared with desktop-based use","kind":"observe","local_id":"t65_o6","terms":["mobile vs desktop","intrinsic motivation","usage intentions"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Hypothesis 2, which posited that the link between GenAI and learning motivation would be stronger in studies published in later years, was not supported by the meta-analytic results.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t65_o7","terms":["Hypothesis 2 not supported","publication year","learning motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Publication year was not a significant moderator. Although GenAI technologies have developed rapidly, the studies included in this meta-analysis were concentrated within a short time window from 2023 to 2025.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t65_o8","terms":["publication year non-significant","included studies 2023 to 2025"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Therefore, the absence of a significant publication-year effect should be interpreted cautiously rather than as evidence that technological development is irrelevant to GenAI's educational impact.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t65_o9","terms":["publication-year effect qualification","cautious interpretation"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t65_o1","t65_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t65_c1","object":"student education level may moderate GenAI effects on learning motivation (university > secondary > primary)","predicate":"concludes_moderator_finding","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 reports from exploratory subgroup analysis that student education level may moderate GenAI's effects on learning motivation, with university students showing larger gains than secondary and primary school students."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t65_o3","t65_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t65_c2","object":"GenAI function is not a significant moderator (qualified by broad overlapping categories)","predicate":"concludes_moderator_finding","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 finds that GenAI function was not a significant moderator, qualifying that this may reflect broad overlapping functional categories rather than no meaningful differences among applications."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t65_o5","t65_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t65_c3","object":"GenAI device type may moderate effects on learning motivation (tentatively stronger intrinsic motivation on mobile vs desktop)","predicate":"concludes_moderator_finding","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 reports from exploratory analysis that GenAI device type may potentially moderate effects on learning motivation, tentatively pointing to stronger intrinsic motivation on smartphones/tablets than desktop use."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t65_o7","t65_o8","t65_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t65_c4","object":"Hypothesis 2 not supported; publication year is not a significant moderator (qualified by 2023-2025 window)","predicate":"concludes_moderator_finding","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 concludes that Hypothesis 2 was not supported as publication year was not a significant moderator of the GenAI-learning motivation link, qualified by the compressed 2023-2025 window of included studies."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t65_o7","t65_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t65_c5","object":"meta-analysis of studies concentrated in publication years 2023 to 2025","predicate":"rests_on_studies","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"The studies included in the PMC13647323 meta-analysis on GenAI and learning motivation were concentrated within a publication time window from 2023 to 2025."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",55426,60078]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"bbb1d6025f3b1228d6d0b12bbfa95421f47ddfca582c571e904244166c959dd7","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["031296b96f9ace34ca63a1d3b7405a2c2ddaa256dd5c245bb83bba38788fda76","922d87f5b013f481be81fe7c231d2b6cdf126f909fa9d034cb715801cf1e6e1e","f5082e68ef201b2d588017de68f2a6b03c0912609e24d51cec6b2934c9140b92","823135730053d2ce563cd7fdcef43db8f7668ebdec8a440ab15a39f2834cb7e5","050870fbd2593c9dfdbdf5ae1d3e2fdcf8080095e471989a46fdb346dcc7084a","ebb516d3b601551a70ea205d10466c79baddd27f879b172ee19a933d861dcf10","628c30ba95cc29a176752b7719c65b00ea841ed8e4d566fb8c183872f394cc41","f8f0ab51138c364bed330e3cbce04274307493b15b6daa9c9ff9ee7c0110ae25","fdbc49385dd508a58c9412c0ba919babe933db17001b72434171d12309726cc5","35ddae50f78383e47fc06746892630ca19e1e78647b78265ce8ac4c2f10b8d6b","c4d387551cdac0d1dd23a5c59e92aae3c5b60d78af7271a9bc06cc0f87b3e824","b19450bb25be4c5d8e3b064b16d0e4d99ac8f1e542c72a8e785d8af538377a9f","17cd8889a92fd3727ed8dfbc8aba64a8bae606689c8f945c8b80c625e19e424b","8229f47e53e6e0f925fb33580829fa6d75fd2698dad03fbf26f159188e1f45d7"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"d3c1c19c4a19cb57c627427ce341fa7166ae79d159e453e42e7ee2c6fab65f41","submission_id":"T65-9a59ac5a9a921463#1"},"hash":"f18a38034fd3affd53d0114666f0ec28933e21e065da063145fc11c630fb6495","header":{"body_hash":"c5963b081531cf46cdfee4b24a40418f297bb392d1c4867dd1247e148dfdb87d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"9b33afebdd405418a13b745d7fc9a8182ad17fc663451194e09d9baf07403b8c","records_root":"890ee54769000b181d558be373ce10d4367307a65f287584e342a19897ae87a5","seq":314,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"8e7fa6a913dd742ad1e58eb5f730848d24af246a0805e0076df638cbd215d218","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":18,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":35,"task_id":"T65-9a59ac5a9a921463"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13647323.txt#10","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"bbb1d6025f3b1228d6d0b12bbfa95421f47ddfca582c571e904244166c959dd7","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"8114375382458025bbf3a70bc4946a39ab29735a0b0ea2e96d29cbe1e1f20703","submission_id":"T65-9a59ac5a9a921463#done2"},"hash":"aad00b380d85b4aa650a270fb420d76f743137d910d7f1dde7aec8b900a96081","header":{"body_hash":"616ad2d61e1f26266083415b98b97f1d1bb83657a26f1f11c21bf7bef8216202","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"f18a38034fd3affd53d0114666f0ec28933e21e065da063145fc11c630fb6495","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":315,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"bca3c30ca0893eb22d62556b5614444cc67916f385f8a6ce4e20dcaa382ab773","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":18,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":875},"started_unix_ms":1795102930447,"wave":{"doc:PMC13647323.txt#10":"reader-1","doc:PMC13647323.txt#11":"reader-2","doc:PMC13647323.txt#9":"reader-3"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"bbb1d6025f3b1228d6d0b12bbfa95421f47ddfca582c571e904244166c959dd7","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"2a7e60714663d6acf0811e71125d0571b9419fed3083a2d908c8832d2a58c0dd","submission_id":"circle:5a29b637d780663a9ff319830d3b5756bf62b1fa52d1229bca0074567e1c43b8"},"hash":"acde0d06ec0bb13cde06dd448f60a60357399ba5c3af18b58ab0058f6c60aa45","header":{"body_hash":"55eb00effbb662157c2dc4661749ce6ad24de423ab1998f8fa83c00b67eac1ad","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"aad00b380d85b4aa650a270fb420d76f743137d910d7f1dde7aec8b900a96081","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":316,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"61be205904af74994657b0abcbbcc98fed8e18d0ace99b76cd6aa854722fd79d","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"bca3c30ca0893eb22d62556b5614444cc67916f385f8a6ce4e20dcaa382ab773","engine_root":"bbb1d6025f3b1228d6d0b12bbfa95421f47ddfca582c571e904244166c959dd7","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"06d6dc026775373c63466fc2d6ce2365bb0c1ec96171e3a0aa0f6b7882c79e6c","log_size":317,"projections":{"dependencies":"3b7fcc22dec4b1c403893eb202e922c0cd07837dbfa71f4b5e359df21a6d59af","status":"2f93fd374c62a36ebc09bc913b184e4484f88a74cd80c7f1cfb7405a748d6790"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"acde0d06ec0bb13cde06dd448f60a60357399ba5c3af18b58ab0058f6c60aa45"}},"engine_root":"bbb1d6025f3b1228d6d0b12bbfa95421f47ddfca582c571e904244166c959dd7","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"bca3c30ca0893eb22d62556b5614444cc67916f385f8a6ce4e20dcaa382ab773","engine_root":"bbb1d6025f3b1228d6d0b12bbfa95421f47ddfca582c571e904244166c959dd7","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"06d6dc026775373c63466fc2d6ce2365bb0c1ec96171e3a0aa0f6b7882c79e6c","log_size":317,"projections":{"dependencies":"3b7fcc22dec4b1c403893eb202e922c0cd07837dbfa71f4b5e359df21a6d59af","status":"2f93fd374c62a36ebc09bc913b184e4484f88a74cd80c7f1cfb7405a748d6790"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"acde0d06ec0bb13cde06dd448f60a60357399ba5c3af18b58ab0058f6c60aa45"},"seal_hash":"14f2f0dc30e20ef338b2e8c556e1263f6c029a2d5626c2cadc0f877e164633fd"}},"request_hash":"4d6b6f2a4c66f6ff8d35ae3ecf4a0d84558ca4423d68c75a226f9c51a61054d7","submission_id":"seal-317"},"hash":"22990a390befe8ab5cc67f860ad280c9740a2bea0334ed04c372ff408c879c0c","header":{"body_hash":"f99a97e1897c60cb1d9916ae0acdcc9e0d11405161fe3370cc4d2efdd19e597d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"acde0d06ec0bb13cde06dd448f60a60357399ba5c3af18b58ab0058f6c60aa45","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":317,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"4771c5c95fdb53990cca3f19d22b56272ed60afb0bc96ae673333bfdc4530268","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[18,"BUILD",0],"epoch":36,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25},{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":26},{"binding":[14,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":27},{"binding":[14,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":28},{"binding":[15,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":29},{"binding":[15,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":30},{"binding":[16,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":31},{"binding":[16,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":32},{"binding":[17,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":33},{"binding":[17,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":34},{"binding":[18,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":35},{"binding":[18,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":36}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102930447},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"bbb1d6025f3b1228d6d0b12bbfa95421f47ddfca582c571e904244166c959dd7","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"fbfa640590d732554540ac041fc48f93bb01a086f9975b3ef0138c5341e2f519","submission_id":"ring-members:eae20cd6bc404fe0888e0860527cc504499b7f555b98b61fe55786551d2261e3"},"hash":"29135d31dbf689d0ad2e13b75d8d8de0fd554ff136ac4185b19d66138dbd4a14","header":{"body_hash":"3d10635b583cce846913142d87f77b46a63026cca9493ed39f78085a42a684f6","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"22990a390befe8ab5cc67f860ad280c9740a2bea0334ed04c372ff408c879c0c","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":318,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"4ebf04302d25cde56fa82a7f321761ceeaf0c15e6a71873377aa5f9d818a8c07","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":19,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":875},"started_unix_ms":1795102930476,"wave":{"doc:PMC13647323.txt#12":"reader-1","doc:PMC13647323.txt#13":"reader-2","doc:PMC13647323.txt#14":"reader-3"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"bbb1d6025f3b1228d6d0b12bbfa95421f47ddfca582c571e904244166c959dd7","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"2c470aefff3bbcb05bf1cb656e57f8ec6f1c45aa5c42483c0769292e913c7c93","submission_id":"circle:9caa3eeb08dd3a7be889608d889feddca318772762242b64e22c767fc34aa2f7"},"hash":"011e336ddd4e19979def7d28051e610135a0eb357f3f16eddf9ba14a900d3733","header":{"body_hash":"5f98d468025ee38a82669dfbe64840d35283196f83a6a89e2dd5f19e62deff47","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"29135d31dbf689d0ad2e13b75d8d8de0fd554ff136ac4185b19d66138dbd4a14","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":319,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"8de1f979c12ef9fab1d7059b4e4f0de66a50f6630041cc4d9254838952276d6f","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"4ebf04302d25cde56fa82a7f321761ceeaf0c15e6a71873377aa5f9d818a8c07","engine_root":"bbb1d6025f3b1228d6d0b12bbfa95421f47ddfca582c571e904244166c959dd7","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"4e29438d8178610f671c3afe19b4fe3383bdb98af2c3f1b1730a970848012fdd","log_size":320,"projections":{"dependencies":"3b7fcc22dec4b1c403893eb202e922c0cd07837dbfa71f4b5e359df21a6d59af","status":"2f93fd374c62a36ebc09bc913b184e4484f88a74cd80c7f1cfb7405a748d6790"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"011e336ddd4e19979def7d28051e610135a0eb357f3f16eddf9ba14a900d3733"}},"engine_root":"bbb1d6025f3b1228d6d0b12bbfa95421f47ddfca582c571e904244166c959dd7","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"4ebf04302d25cde56fa82a7f321761ceeaf0c15e6a71873377aa5f9d818a8c07","engine_root":"bbb1d6025f3b1228d6d0b12bbfa95421f47ddfca582c571e904244166c959dd7","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"4e29438d8178610f671c3afe19b4fe3383bdb98af2c3f1b1730a970848012fdd","log_size":320,"projections":{"dependencies":"3b7fcc22dec4b1c403893eb202e922c0cd07837dbfa71f4b5e359df21a6d59af","status":"2f93fd374c62a36ebc09bc913b184e4484f88a74cd80c7f1cfb7405a748d6790"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"011e336ddd4e19979def7d28051e610135a0eb357f3f16eddf9ba14a900d3733"},"seal_hash":"95ea681faf7cc11b5727a73db949e17c6199b10128c6ff987d617c041a47f481"}},"request_hash":"d6d5e55667816abc8ac200d03715181aa9b5f6b8241cb5b68d79e1456f14705a","submission_id":"seal-320"},"hash":"ece2149f8235b80939ebf49963ddc4eb4f8d7c36d6216baa938b5ddcb0f61da5","header":{"body_hash":"4a4717697ffbded3ece6a60d927ea28762acf33efbe30c5874fb8e05c268b01e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"011e336ddd4e19979def7d28051e610135a0eb357f3f16eddf9ba14a900d3733","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":320,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"05afc01d8869048a771d8a90e722700c9ff0b2066d4cd9bb5fabdef8fa8dd313","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[19,"READ",0],"epoch":37,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25},{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":26},{"binding":[14,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":27},{"binding":[14,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":28},{"binding":[15,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":29},{"binding":[15,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":30},{"binding":[16,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":31},{"binding":[16,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":32},{"binding":[17,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":33},{"binding":[17,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":34},{"binding":[18,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":35},{"binding":[18,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":36},{"binding":[19,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":37}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102930476},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"bbb1d6025f3b1228d6d0b12bbfa95421f47ddfca582c571e904244166c959dd7","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"de06f1074a64caedf47b0a647098aa3b81b0bc73efe6f0922034d0f40c584350","submission_id":"ring-members:c3bfe20ef1133d156182ad8282d38724b2a2aacdd10cfaba8cd98f0d5c145e38"},"hash":"431815fe832c21b32e5fc6ba23d1b42136389003b8fb8a21de7594304e9da035","header":{"body_hash":"fb30925cd1892ab417eb0abe308ea244dfc6ddd8806e9a4588e5c6bd538751c4","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ece2149f8235b80939ebf49963ddc4eb4f8d7c36d6216baa938b5ddcb0f61da5","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":321,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"d0deefdc9b95000c41e68b81c80e2223556bb2c3261fc638d3120d0a479f879e","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":19,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":37,"task_id":"T66-c479cd18662766a1"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13647323.txt#14","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"bbb1d6025f3b1228d6d0b12bbfa95421f47ddfca582c571e904244166c959dd7","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"43fb0b301d0d3e7d576733504a6b079714484afc10f719063560fcecc87a8069","submission_id":"T66-c479cd18662766a1#done2"},"hash":"9e0af0dc90ba1b6c61415cefcf8c421463209595562c78d7090f7b7bf9ae5160","header":{"body_hash":"f2c89a650a1f932b846fc269157ac553f0216c4614a3ce771333edd0c750363f","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"431815fe832c21b32e5fc6ba23d1b42136389003b8fb8a21de7594304e9da035","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":322,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"7e49b2d20031e5cc7b41e368baf603a1d856caf31f2e4ce191e5f1206b2b007d","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":19,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":37,"task_id":"T68-1ee77de5e0c885ed"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13647323.txt#13","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"bbb1d6025f3b1228d6d0b12bbfa95421f47ddfca582c571e904244166c959dd7","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"f1eb3ec9deef0f8eaf5b54d576ea8ba2994058a8c0ffad209a758b57cd82d075","submission_id":"T68-1ee77de5e0c885ed#done2"},"hash":"ee75fd7dac7fb9e3826e4a72dac2e5b6c134d46e90dbd0b71314cbdac3616631","header":{"body_hash":"50befca365975f6e56c311f2d419ebc02330bf2fa223b2e35e68cdcd982a3858","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"9e0af0dc90ba1b6c61415cefcf8c421463209595562c78d7090f7b7bf9ae5160","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":323,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"01024d1fd13e3acd3d53b43b6d46aaea163fdfdc9ce8f760228bb87dc6284b4a","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T67-d6b80e5f8316465f","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"This random-effects meta-analysis synthesized 56 effect sizes from 42 studies involving 6,059 participants to examine the association between GenAI-supported learning and students' learning motivation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t67_o1","terms":["meta-analysis dataset","56 effect sizes","42 studies","6,059 participants","learning motivation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Pooled results indicated that GenAI use was associated with higher learning motivation on average, yet the very high between-study heterogeneity suggests that the magnitude and consistency of this effect vary substantially","kind":"observe","local_id":"t67_o2","terms":["pooled results","GenAI use","learning motivation","between-study heterogeneity"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Specifically, the positive association between GenAI and learning motivation appeared larger for college students relative to secondary and elementary school students, greater in collectivistic cultures","kind":"observe","local_id":"t67_o3","terms":["subgroup differences","college students","collectivistic cultures"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"more prominent when GenAI was delivered via mobile devices rather than personal computers, and largest among studies in language disciplines.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t67_o4","terms":["subgroup differences","mobile devices","language disciplines"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"In contrast, no statistically significant moderation effects were detected for gender, publication year, intervention duration, GenAI function, or motivation type in the current analyses.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t67_o5","terms":["null moderation effects","gender","publication year","intervention duration","GenAI function","motivation type"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Given the very high overall heterogeneity, imbalanced study distribution across subgroups, and potential confounding at the study level, these subgroup findings should be interpreted as preliminary exploratory patterns","kind":"observe","local_id":"t67_o6","terms":["heterogeneity","imbalanced subgroup distribution","confounding","exploratory patterns"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Although all studies measured learning motivation quantitatively, they used different instruments and operational definitions. Some studies reported intrinsic or extrinsic motivation separately, whereas others reported general","kind":"observe","local_id":"t67_o7","terms":["quantitative motivation measurement","intrinsic motivation","extrinsic motivation","general motivation scores"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Fifth, this meta-analysis included only studies published in English.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t67_o8","terms":["English-only inclusion criterion","primary studies"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The included studies focused on students from primary school through university and did not include kindergarten-aged learners or students receiving special education services","kind":"observe","local_id":"t67_o9","terms":["sample coverage","primary school through university","exclusions"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Although a supplementary three-level meta-analysis suggested that within-study variance was small and did not materially alter the main findings, some dependency may remain","kind":"observe","local_id":"t67_o10","terms":["effect-size dependence","three-level meta-analysis","within-study variance"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Therefore, the pooled effect and moderator findings should be interpreted cautiously.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t67_o11","terms":["cautious interpretation","effect-size dependence limitation"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t67_o1","t67_o7","t67_o8","t67_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t67_c1","object":"56 quantitative learning-motivation effect sizes from 42 English-language primary studies (N=6,059; primary school through university)","predicate":"rests_on_data","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 rests on a random-effects meta-analysis of 56 quantitative learning-motivation effect sizes from 42 English-language primary studies (N=6,059) covering primary school through university students."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t67_o1","t67_o2","t67_o10","t67_o11"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t67_c2","object":"GenAI use is associated with higher average learning motivation, qualified by very high between-study heterogeneity and potential effect-size dependence","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 concludes that GenAI-supported learning is associated with higher learning motivation on average, though very high between-study heterogeneity and effect-size dependence require cautious interpretation."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t67_o3","t67_o4","t67_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t67_c3","object":"larger positive motivation associations for college students, collectivistic cultures, mobile devices, and language disciplines (exploratory patterns)","predicate":"reports_moderator_patterns","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 finds larger positive GenAI associations with learning motivation for college students, collectivistic cultures, mobile devices, and language disciplines, framed as preliminary exploratory patterns."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t67_o1","t67_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t67_c4","object":"no significant moderation by gender, publication year, intervention duration, GenAI function, or motivation type","predicate":"reports_null_moderators","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 detects no statistically significant moderation of GenAI's association with learning motivation by gender, publication year, intervention duration, GenAI function, or motivation type."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t67_o1","t67_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t67_c5","object":"quantitative learning motivation (intrinsic, extrinsic, or general/total/combined scores across varying instruments)","predicate":"measures_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"Primary studies synthesized in PMC13647323 measured learning motivation quantitatively using varying instruments and operational definitions, reporting intrinsic, extrinsic, or general/combined motivation scores."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",65923,71677]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"3493b1c0682d8c2c26807ecaf21deed8c55a775e71c89d885928f65477914674","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["05125a85b73ce30f6ef72023addf2e3d6f99773caf830c199cb317ea2505dbfb","d7f6d4db540f9d2263fe5e0dc86b75fa82c8ebda0bec9e82fbbd44c152f3c3be","a0a13c0f246f356a1d997dc8a7ca11051950f21504544d7a25ca38ff91062c56","e544118f474a04b5dbbadade8b981519a10ad339200a14619a280e72075fc5c0","7161302c727aecdd8dbf0bb5a11452210493181831942c24e1dffbefeaeceb68","caaac861ff2ec3062de6559d142c867f5437b7982543ff82f44613c13e63eb3f","7f1cd8d31e6303eff5f669e5c6afd0d3c41b495ff7d9c568774a8c856db3fb96","14acbeeab3f31d13406d9c0d060979210f66f500a3cb29dd8f42b58a9b43d1bf","f464a7de15933771376b27d62175ecf154d285aff62d67fae88a8888033a78a8","b5edbcde30ef6de669c3e6062405f328fa4d7434b559911cf1701311083b7524","8aaf1dccfb3e25b7c063ffb9a4c5a307abee0d09c4f5bcbef04912cbb918ad0a","a1d31e68fe47bf48b6bcbe0fd59020c29d0f36d286bb84e20cbfe6e686ef0c13","a697e65380042a400a47b5b3bfbd15d9969b812d425b87179e7d1cd959ec7854","43f07fa6dc9c41f48518d79d296fe0fa13a343dabd0d964686b859581c50ed1b","7719bf7cbf5664c4cb6cc42e6ecc573ba7ee20ca215ea3913b4401f0e14d3204","6501b06f475efdad800e0074098cb840fa7b196517c26aa73eee961f663d9819"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"40671cf2bf3e5f4ba6d22f09c189d0dae4818f98a3682dff730b2132762c8a27","submission_id":"T67-d6b80e5f8316465f#1"},"hash":"77df169ea316cd2bdef4bc58001d19de68f97b3720128279c305817e8487578a","header":{"body_hash":"ea65d3ebf4a59559d451fa2c79d61f3c3d189e294626fc55af6e886562c43b80","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ee75fd7dac7fb9e3826e4a72dac2e5b6c134d46e90dbd0b71314cbdac3616631","records_root":"b38132edfcb591a42c5cf70815e59698d58d6e529a5172edac67ce941c07b273","seq":324,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"f4e90794add803550ee933135e47a4c3c86fb6fcf41e94481beaff702f23082b","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":19,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":37,"task_id":"T67-d6b80e5f8316465f"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13647323.txt#12","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3493b1c0682d8c2c26807ecaf21deed8c55a775e71c89d885928f65477914674","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"bacd6c6bb030f2c367674a1bc7bcf41904b521c7648f6654384765166b41a82f","submission_id":"T67-d6b80e5f8316465f#done2"},"hash":"fd8a32a93e1ffbef806c1a91d7aadbfc22df923e9bf07b3c78a6c70e72cf3b3c","header":{"body_hash":"aed6a2912cda1728c4940532341da3e036f58f96eb4e876f0cd242e0dbd0bac0","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"77df169ea316cd2bdef4bc58001d19de68f97b3720128279c305817e8487578a","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":325,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"a66cd453901f259b1cf99ef82627f6e0e10ce90945aa8e841a20bfc37c32c38f","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":19,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":891},"started_unix_ms":1795102954579,"wave":{"doc:PMC13647323.txt#12":"reader-1","doc:PMC13647323.txt#13":"reader-2","doc:PMC13647323.txt#14":"reader-3"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3493b1c0682d8c2c26807ecaf21deed8c55a775e71c89d885928f65477914674","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"7b9958c4d42bbe060ff205ddd62f5a882c3da9c6145ba7ff34119eef51ba8cdc","submission_id":"circle:152a93d7d0a70565098dfec4338cf1a7851dc06fd17da1cc3c22d1cc0eab4868"},"hash":"44b043b29645ee44af2110e2e4a6d073baeeacc32d05aeb3eb9716ec01cea220","header":{"body_hash":"08ba8d69a91e4af43f6970a012e5f7bb1793d9aa943a2b42761f75c0470aeca3","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"fd8a32a93e1ffbef806c1a91d7aadbfc22df923e9bf07b3c78a6c70e72cf3b3c","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":326,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"241bae95885d2912491f5b66574d00c2165f0ebb68ad8752a31cf7c864db97e0","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"a66cd453901f259b1cf99ef82627f6e0e10ce90945aa8e841a20bfc37c32c38f","engine_root":"3493b1c0682d8c2c26807ecaf21deed8c55a775e71c89d885928f65477914674","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"ff7b0bcc9730d6b87bc39564c42f71ecedba73ae2d5082ac461e933b37d755aa","log_size":327,"projections":{"dependencies":"86083d2445b685281934a74921e1d488c45ea46bad637d01087280e1322aa303","status":"4514cb0266b12f6fcbdf1841af82d037b5b41a8d58554947117b1d002f3e88b8"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"44b043b29645ee44af2110e2e4a6d073baeeacc32d05aeb3eb9716ec01cea220"}},"engine_root":"3493b1c0682d8c2c26807ecaf21deed8c55a775e71c89d885928f65477914674","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"a66cd453901f259b1cf99ef82627f6e0e10ce90945aa8e841a20bfc37c32c38f","engine_root":"3493b1c0682d8c2c26807ecaf21deed8c55a775e71c89d885928f65477914674","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"ff7b0bcc9730d6b87bc39564c42f71ecedba73ae2d5082ac461e933b37d755aa","log_size":327,"projections":{"dependencies":"86083d2445b685281934a74921e1d488c45ea46bad637d01087280e1322aa303","status":"4514cb0266b12f6fcbdf1841af82d037b5b41a8d58554947117b1d002f3e88b8"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"44b043b29645ee44af2110e2e4a6d073baeeacc32d05aeb3eb9716ec01cea220"},"seal_hash":"4eedbd3a80312deadca23c19d50fc783f7366c087d49c369acc680b2ca3c5816"}},"request_hash":"6321a3af7c99c76d139715ca7d9a292c7b9e7203fb4b62b37dfdd0a03de8a466","submission_id":"seal-327"},"hash":"62ceb6c295c80d1111ea635be07109d89d21a1a5446595f4c7d04842bb9ce8e4","header":{"body_hash":"086bbf929479173497bded757a642afa52fdfa94f1cbd6c5b1503132d5cc477b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"44b043b29645ee44af2110e2e4a6d073baeeacc32d05aeb3eb9716ec01cea220","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":327,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"e2bd34ff05173f94a33eef75feac71e6658ebd2456f9285e7ac26f1dcbddfdb4","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[19,"BUILD",0],"epoch":38,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25},{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":26},{"binding":[14,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":27},{"binding":[14,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":28},{"binding":[15,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":29},{"binding":[15,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":30},{"binding":[16,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":31},{"binding":[16,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":32},{"binding":[17,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":33},{"binding":[17,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":34},{"binding":[18,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":35},{"binding":[18,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":36},{"binding":[19,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":37},{"binding":[19,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":38}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102954579},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3493b1c0682d8c2c26807ecaf21deed8c55a775e71c89d885928f65477914674","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"ff998efadace8e253ebda65449de8c50fc3160e1ea955544ba7efe9d1dc24ac6","submission_id":"ring-members:ab3f05371f01dc983a14da8c87aa0238a10c963e61b0f32f07e83235684ef9b4"},"hash":"57ad45c33668de42e8dda84835a7d457ef96670af81805b7e8a8a76e3171583e","header":{"body_hash":"74556de67143ccc940e5a88fc2816fbf17ac7ae3420d93e28c8184554a0ee7e9","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"62ceb6c295c80d1111ea635be07109d89d21a1a5446595f4c7d04842bb9ce8e4","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":328,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"4b31a39b2e76d3ed705396616826dc38da87bcd4fb631c79ddd0e219d4c7c55d","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":20,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":891},"started_unix_ms":1795102954608,"wave":{"doc:PMC13647323.txt#15":"reader-2","doc:PMC13647323.txt#16":"reader-3","doc:PMC13647323.txt#17":"reader-1"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3493b1c0682d8c2c26807ecaf21deed8c55a775e71c89d885928f65477914674","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"375e420a55cac12f76d3cebbd2e5dfaac895825a51da4a54e6414d09481ba6ac","submission_id":"circle:ae5c9706ca27c17fb59993449ce25a6895c372110974a37bca8354217e6773ee"},"hash":"422c86e6e676298df7e6b396afc449bb638863979d00362e961e5b0a2191be8b","header":{"body_hash":"b1f399257128f44053614179037e20841dbc850dcde23ae1729791c0ff0f0359","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"57ad45c33668de42e8dda84835a7d457ef96670af81805b7e8a8a76e3171583e","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":329,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"95b2b1b636c35f3ac24809a2ae1d4dd4a5fbacd5227f6774b0b274ae37ff688e","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"4b31a39b2e76d3ed705396616826dc38da87bcd4fb631c79ddd0e219d4c7c55d","engine_root":"3493b1c0682d8c2c26807ecaf21deed8c55a775e71c89d885928f65477914674","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"dc4868ed5d7623732ca993c4d22751f424f5c17f566b9f5608c1145c0c6c2aa5","log_size":330,"projections":{"dependencies":"86083d2445b685281934a74921e1d488c45ea46bad637d01087280e1322aa303","status":"4514cb0266b12f6fcbdf1841af82d037b5b41a8d58554947117b1d002f3e88b8"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"422c86e6e676298df7e6b396afc449bb638863979d00362e961e5b0a2191be8b"}},"engine_root":"3493b1c0682d8c2c26807ecaf21deed8c55a775e71c89d885928f65477914674","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"4b31a39b2e76d3ed705396616826dc38da87bcd4fb631c79ddd0e219d4c7c55d","engine_root":"3493b1c0682d8c2c26807ecaf21deed8c55a775e71c89d885928f65477914674","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"dc4868ed5d7623732ca993c4d22751f424f5c17f566b9f5608c1145c0c6c2aa5","log_size":330,"projections":{"dependencies":"86083d2445b685281934a74921e1d488c45ea46bad637d01087280e1322aa303","status":"4514cb0266b12f6fcbdf1841af82d037b5b41a8d58554947117b1d002f3e88b8"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"422c86e6e676298df7e6b396afc449bb638863979d00362e961e5b0a2191be8b"},"seal_hash":"9866550632a31699325b3589fa2cc364c712286bbc2d76a3493ed42b4963c0b0"}},"request_hash":"bf63d8ae2dfc58abb52e9fac617bb43ab0c0a23e07e6b6a7c120631dac39766e","submission_id":"seal-330"},"hash":"f1a467014429033aecba40d87392d2351eeb6dab3d5971fd2aadce78ef2b3c2a","header":{"body_hash":"016e4fa58608ee523bd344b75fa31df38513fe3d3790cbd3735dd06f4ed2e9e7","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"422c86e6e676298df7e6b396afc449bb638863979d00362e961e5b0a2191be8b","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":330,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"2ed519327564d51859338c9c3d0217c3b3ae248ed5b8a54c5e7bb5a0c3587e5c","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[20,"READ",0],"epoch":39,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25},{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":26},{"binding":[14,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":27},{"binding":[14,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":28},{"binding":[15,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":29},{"binding":[15,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":30},{"binding":[16,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":31},{"binding":[16,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":32},{"binding":[17,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":33},{"binding":[17,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":34},{"binding":[18,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":35},{"binding":[18,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":36},{"binding":[19,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":37},{"binding":[19,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":38},{"binding":[20,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":39}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102954608},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3493b1c0682d8c2c26807ecaf21deed8c55a775e71c89d885928f65477914674","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"e6ec280d2c1130d5a60e9d93cba8a0bcedeb9c0228c6797a1146de34362017d1","submission_id":"ring-members:9b7a6fab1055d3e2ceb99627fd42899bd9f2085badcfe6fe7f9fc240638c4646"},"hash":"37012f72e487900ac3d190f9d34d092796d0ae2f0fa2a57bbb2f8bc2ca8c475c","header":{"body_hash":"82c7931f4716c89b4d36342edc5999e205595f37868f91c727f6f6c82b1cc75c","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"f1a467014429033aecba40d87392d2351eeb6dab3d5971fd2aadce78ef2b3c2a","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":331,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"55747a746892a919f513b2458be7ff81323d4eea64d4f0d93a4d011291fd04a4","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":20,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":39,"task_id":"T71-87d772b9c579fad2"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13647323.txt#16","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3493b1c0682d8c2c26807ecaf21deed8c55a775e71c89d885928f65477914674","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"76466232d41683c39f51511ca519145559829614f2943db1d1f9171ff2e0c8ae","submission_id":"T71-87d772b9c579fad2#done2"},"hash":"f872bd8b9dcb044c7010c1fa7d8be386a5a192738aeabbeba32f2b9a9b822b3b","header":{"body_hash":"28f8c881abf66d41f619eda507f347b421fe2e3aeedc686ab310bdb6df4fcd1a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"37012f72e487900ac3d190f9d34d092796d0ae2f0fa2a57bbb2f8bc2ca8c475c","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":332,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"88f9d3d9538ce61e2d33bd90d9a7064b4cdba9f5f3c3e4aba1c5d55a65029621","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":20,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"sync_step":39,"task_id":"T69-3fcf71eceefe5696"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13647323.txt#15","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"3493b1c0682d8c2c26807ecaf21deed8c55a775e71c89d885928f65477914674","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"e68fab58fb7a41d82bdb967d442895d5561e93dff982a80b9b1913e53438154d","submission_id":"T69-3fcf71eceefe5696#done2"},"hash":"1a2bf1f0c89e8ad9db86a31198f888d2e59af63612e23913d49e20a6b160622d","header":{"body_hash":"bfba3dd9ee4bf18a7121313e09b43264509e5df5ebce68d936f2f6610d638049","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"f872bd8b9dcb044c7010c1fa7d8be386a5a192738aeabbeba32f2b9a9b822b3b","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":333,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"36bfd15b4e2e09808868ce55507e27f1a55b405c00e323554c9af2d188565607","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T70-61ddee94ed60c531","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Wang J., Fan W. (2025). The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis. Humanit. Soc. Sci. Commun. 12:621.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t70_o1","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025 reference list entry","PMC13647323 references"]},{"about":["PMC13647323","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t70_q1","needed":"Check earlier sections of PMC13647323.txt for in-text citations to Wang and Fan (2025) and the meta-analysis record file for the 'Title: The effect of ChatGPT...' quote.","text":"Which statements, effect sizes, comparisons, or table rows in the main text of PMC13647323 cite Wang and Fan 2025, and what is the Title line quote from the meta-analysis's record file?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",95378,101130]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"060b43000c763f652db78ed2459dae7009ec16287e3b2500a59930aa26bcd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["7f89e5d4a8c3d15f00840feb20f8b98056a98b94e3c1a5bf67fe312915f950d9","ad17b23071ac5b24cc3a2c8ef1a40a76b0d398e98ed54e69f404dc346e149616"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"f5366dc2737b45f10ef006e98ba9c4c36d2d9ef4b2be92d8b4ac047beddb851a","submission_id":"T70-61ddee94ed60c531#1"},"hash":"1b9c2fd84a7cc289d8eacb9d1a09be82932acd026d107bcf34942447b6714a06","header":{"body_hash":"77a1713be4ef6691463e7470afd12b990a839e575c3d3947617061440004d628","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"1a2bf1f0c89e8ad9db86a31198f888d2e59af63612e23913d49e20a6b160622d","records_root":"e82c3c25dd111c12c2c834d5524abc9cd8a075f9ef6c3b5c31acd16f2d17a248","seq":334,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"c1803fcd9204e0eefff3bef357fa372eeed4db8e3ceec4e9fea6da5527c5eec2","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@7f89e5d4a8c3d15f","@ad17b23071ac5b24"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"NO_EVIDENCE","expected_by_kernel":{"missing_identifiers":["10.1057"]},"field":"based_on","message":"a claim names only identifiers its quotes hold: add a quote of this section that holds each one listed, or leave it out of the claim","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":1,"local_id":"t70_c1"}],"task_id":"T70-61ddee94ed60c531","work_key":"doc:PMC13647323.txt#17"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T70-61ddee94ed60c531:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"060b43000c763f652db78ed2459dae7009ec16287e3b2500a59930aa26bcd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"af692a56348079a4535959474a08150527910fcb42f3e3862234b923cadc4418","submission_id":"T70-61ddee94ed60c531#repair1"},"hash":"7d6f8a03bf6a06e5f30ef03861af9521feb2f2270b468a04f8e6f3b08f8a6bc6","header":{"body_hash":"15baece5e96fba8b5636bfaeb4fc4909604f17fde11da7dda9bdb2f0487a928d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"1b9c2fd84a7cc289d8eacb9d1a09be82932acd026d107bcf34942447b6714a06","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":335,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"ff38ffc740c913e0db8f0a8d03a5b0a9fd06f4e4003be0b6d4ddb736f8355cce","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T70-61ddee94ed60c531","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t70_o1"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t70_c1","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (Humanit. Soc. Sci. Commun. 12:621)","predicate":"lists_reference","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 lists the meta-analysis Wang and Fan 2025 in its reference list (Humanit. Soc. Sci. Commun. 12:621)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",95378,101130]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"060b43000c763f652db78ed2459dae7009ec16287e3b2500a59930aa26bcd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["04fe4cc52446ded29d3b964dc683a0a157a9fe61a5a18d4a3b414b4b8e43f97e"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"d93570665d3a49ee294c75c80b6624639a052737c4b6e46ee48b6bd9676c15f7","submission_id":"T70-61ddee94ed60c531#2"},"hash":"8fed8a8770ded9aebd42704d71de6fc0433a9aaee44bf4f3ea2517b7f48e60c6","header":{"body_hash":"86b53d6bce81e73d49bc42d6b6361394ca663dd2135aef143be314ad1eb9441e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"7d6f8a03bf6a06e5f30ef03861af9521feb2f2270b468a04f8e6f3b08f8a6bc6","records_root":"d0d8a3534ff20b2d154972798cd3dd753c7e9a0f9e71cc62f25f79c0e42f107b","seq":336,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"00c87329c263c38b479718e92cf3343b202c6d72769855a7b57543fe1360da1e","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":false,"agent":"reader-1","circle":20,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":3,"refusals":1,"stored":3,"sync_step":39,"task_id":"T70-61ddee94ed60c531"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:PMC13647323.txt#17","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"060b43000c763f652db78ed2459dae7009ec16287e3b2500a59930aa26bcd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"71f789b0a76d7e456f651a300a6c83545e68e8513867ece3c684c287551bfb60","submission_id":"T70-61ddee94ed60c531#done3"},"hash":"185e93de284ad1f2578db6f8daee41f6dbc599a11de35017038b097729cdb1ef","header":{"body_hash":"1460572ea88d77ae5b7a470b1cd00149176caf25b524b48e419825f5c48a50e0","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"8fed8a8770ded9aebd42704d71de6fc0433a9aaee44bf4f3ea2517b7f48e60c6","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":337,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"3fda0ec9ec5edd9509bdc7a5631989511e4f63f7f292fbc6722b48396cad4118","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":20,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":894},"started_unix_ms":1795102987342,"wave":{"doc:PMC13647323.txt#15":"reader-2","doc:PMC13647323.txt#16":"reader-3","doc:PMC13647323.txt#17":"reader-1"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"060b43000c763f652db78ed2459dae7009ec16287e3b2500a59930aa26bcd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"2ad3ec5eb074a5d03d5f70fdef0063cb1c3785e19f11e0df3191457b165ba04f","submission_id":"circle:7dc0d27b6ec6f1bafc1e044cee9ced7bd1d744e582e520431436fb68816a78dc"},"hash":"db363616a625165bd5e7a43aea576425de4e029c255e87416ba0811293a4b35c","header":{"body_hash":"8c8c40d203c340fb3353a3fb116b40fe77590862254ea10088a6b41e6ef3d775","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"185e93de284ad1f2578db6f8daee41f6dbc599a11de35017038b097729cdb1ef","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":338,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"8adb895781d39e4c95a924108f3521d84c706e1362e967f0c13962535c9255dc","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"3fda0ec9ec5edd9509bdc7a5631989511e4f63f7f292fbc6722b48396cad4118","engine_root":"060b43000c763f652db78ed2459dae7009ec16287e3b2500a59930aa26bcd8d9","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"23ff46ea1d963077ab6ccc68bbd961db4260d30489e3aaa8bc6515a59473af37","log_size":339,"projections":{"dependencies":"d1a1c5c3bdca460d0b4fafcf404bd94c0ef1aa1ce3af283ebd82e23c86161920","status":"e6496b8f8f380595125d4d19e7a2d0d46b660b2c734f0d5236eb3e5e7348ba8f"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"db363616a625165bd5e7a43aea576425de4e029c255e87416ba0811293a4b35c"}},"engine_root":"060b43000c763f652db78ed2459dae7009ec16287e3b2500a59930aa26bcd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"3fda0ec9ec5edd9509bdc7a5631989511e4f63f7f292fbc6722b48396cad4118","engine_root":"060b43000c763f652db78ed2459dae7009ec16287e3b2500a59930aa26bcd8d9","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"23ff46ea1d963077ab6ccc68bbd961db4260d30489e3aaa8bc6515a59473af37","log_size":339,"projections":{"dependencies":"d1a1c5c3bdca460d0b4fafcf404bd94c0ef1aa1ce3af283ebd82e23c86161920","status":"e6496b8f8f380595125d4d19e7a2d0d46b660b2c734f0d5236eb3e5e7348ba8f"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"db363616a625165bd5e7a43aea576425de4e029c255e87416ba0811293a4b35c"},"seal_hash":"139c19f33d69c3d51c763bd78b28ce37b8055d3fe94be943737c97b91bbf38f7"}},"request_hash":"e2c352b38abbe822c1a8493cb5fce4bb7c180123532ea3b36b3a55b256eed4f3","submission_id":"seal-339"},"hash":"5c6cda9afcd46122966c4cc5abfdda52da21a391d2ba90f2e35d785865877282","header":{"body_hash":"27b376b3e2b45e8635f3df7688f5b1c780e09f412ad9fcb5a1219f381fbc1c08","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"db363616a625165bd5e7a43aea576425de4e029c255e87416ba0811293a4b35c","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":339,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"59a58f4cf64389f49dd77aa2a6d6a23833d5e10300a185af1fc99f331a054724","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[20,"BUILD",0],"epoch":40,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25},{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":26},{"binding":[14,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":27},{"binding":[14,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":28},{"binding":[15,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":29},{"binding":[15,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":30},{"binding":[16,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":31},{"binding":[16,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":32},{"binding":[17,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":33},{"binding":[17,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":34},{"binding":[18,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":35},{"binding":[18,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":36},{"binding":[19,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":37},{"binding":[19,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":38},{"binding":[20,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":39},{"binding":[20,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":40}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102987342},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"060b43000c763f652db78ed2459dae7009ec16287e3b2500a59930aa26bcd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"4c82ec8b6971a21572979730cbfe07467fc040605fd16c8aeb0416b33b2742ca","submission_id":"ring-members:9adfee98c311aa58b2c8a2f61962345e1e76bac9c3602423d4e805032f4f9497"},"hash":"17fcf8e8e5150fe0df2876b9b75425bce50edce2bc94dfed87729bc1a4381f0e","header":{"body_hash":"5ba7a52a639fbfe16c9b46c12aaa412a735351efc7d84a3a9ed0b537dbdbf177","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"5c6cda9afcd46122966c4cc5abfdda52da21a391d2ba90f2e35d785865877282","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":340,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"111177d7b17bef6cfd61533307da8ffff463dffb8072c7893104b2a36451f094","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":21,"circle_phase":"READ","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":894},"started_unix_ms":1795102987388,"wave":{"doc:retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt#0":"reader-3"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"060b43000c763f652db78ed2459dae7009ec16287e3b2500a59930aa26bcd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"0e0f9cc960a0a66dd57caac46c360dceb3d609ea145f4ccd09a239bd8fc5ed4b","submission_id":"circle:b2a06bedb76975fca46cb5904920ddd74dc802d9cf6e957bf13536923a135cb5"},"hash":"3df6a4449e261222fcc337dcfcd136ee3f718024e898551d38527ae6d1b7a8c0","header":{"body_hash":"26778b5d537fb852b1fbf29126120b775beabd9c14ec27e9f5976b5225a8e572","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"17fcf8e8e5150fe0df2876b9b75425bce50edce2bc94dfed87729bc1a4381f0e","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":341,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"40f4fa92127f8dcecbc3219ea926ddf427a7c14b03328e54c688b6e51ee8dee5","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"111177d7b17bef6cfd61533307da8ffff463dffb8072c7893104b2a36451f094","engine_root":"060b43000c763f652db78ed2459dae7009ec16287e3b2500a59930aa26bcd8d9","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"d3ddc81ff9dca810756e79176fcddfb965350421ef3d743fda5209e4c6909d4e","log_size":342,"projections":{"dependencies":"d1a1c5c3bdca460d0b4fafcf404bd94c0ef1aa1ce3af283ebd82e23c86161920","status":"e6496b8f8f380595125d4d19e7a2d0d46b660b2c734f0d5236eb3e5e7348ba8f"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"3df6a4449e261222fcc337dcfcd136ee3f718024e898551d38527ae6d1b7a8c0"}},"engine_root":"060b43000c763f652db78ed2459dae7009ec16287e3b2500a59930aa26bcd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"111177d7b17bef6cfd61533307da8ffff463dffb8072c7893104b2a36451f094","engine_root":"060b43000c763f652db78ed2459dae7009ec16287e3b2500a59930aa26bcd8d9","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"d3ddc81ff9dca810756e79176fcddfb965350421ef3d743fda5209e4c6909d4e","log_size":342,"projections":{"dependencies":"d1a1c5c3bdca460d0b4fafcf404bd94c0ef1aa1ce3af283ebd82e23c86161920","status":"e6496b8f8f380595125d4d19e7a2d0d46b660b2c734f0d5236eb3e5e7348ba8f"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"3df6a4449e261222fcc337dcfcd136ee3f718024e898551d38527ae6d1b7a8c0"},"seal_hash":"44b6e52743d74dd1cad6cdb822bd0b842e0b6a698597a3912f6a9d99b9f4618c"}},"request_hash":"96080621855bf7c52c9ef8e972a04291384aecd5a530489162c92c8fb2850251","submission_id":"seal-342"},"hash":"a0250e56894af29b1ec1fc3fffc90d203039d3582643dd468e85ddcbca869e29","header":{"body_hash":"ecea67053f2d0c58c42067630b448b6699f8958330710b10f50cb655bfb9c1de","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3df6a4449e261222fcc337dcfcd136ee3f718024e898551d38527ae6d1b7a8c0","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":342,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"cfabdafaf621129f098f4307ddc09c50041e57021ca7c78182afc1a7cb84f7b9","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[21,"READ",0],"epoch":41,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25},{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":26},{"binding":[14,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":27},{"binding":[14,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":28},{"binding":[15,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":29},{"binding":[15,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":30},{"binding":[16,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":31},{"binding":[16,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":32},{"binding":[17,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":33},{"binding":[17,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":34},{"binding":[18,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":35},{"binding":[18,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":36},{"binding":[19,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":37},{"binding":[19,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":38},{"binding":[20,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":39},{"binding":[20,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":40},{"binding":[21,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":41}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795102987388},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"060b43000c763f652db78ed2459dae7009ec16287e3b2500a59930aa26bcd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"cbc013ed3ce717d9d9f53c2cf695743a83a5e62c07a376e3faa0413ec51ee82e","submission_id":"ring-members:f3f0a7f0cb515a1941857a9ca117b471e063e61edc577184bd3187cfc2153d16"},"hash":"98ef130f919dadf309748ae7e82c5956036ca06c6da13bce1601ba05f2650e41","header":{"body_hash":"7a800f9fdd0c24f9c88b98f6d7fb842b7e1e08a7c428bfe5f45f699086dd0c6c","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"a0250e56894af29b1ec1fc3fffc90d203039d3582643dd468e85ddcbca869e29","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":343,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"a8d686274cf51e4ba962c68057d6f930f9fad46d272b9f8861f34f88f299a3c5","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T72-b63a7d606942e9ca","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt","exact_quote":"Title: The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t72_o1","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025 title","ChatGPT meta-analysis title"]},{"doc_id":"retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt","exact_quote":"Authors: Wang J, Fan W.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t72_o2","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025 authors","Wang J","Fan W"]},{"doc_id":"retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt","exact_quote":"Published: Humanities and Social Sciences Communications. 2025 May 6;12:621. doi:10.1057/s41599-025-04787-y.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t72_o3","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025 publication details","Humanities and Social Sciences Communications","doi:10.1057/s41599-025-04787-y"]},{"doc_id":"retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt","exact_quote":"Status: retracted on 22 April 2026. Retraction note: Humanities and Social Sciences Communications. 2026;13:528. doi:10.1057/s41599-026-07310-z.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t72_o4","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025 retraction status","retracted on 22 April 2026","doi:10.1057/s41599-026-07310-z"]},{"doc_id":"retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt","exact_quote":"Retracted article record (bibliographic facts only; the article's text is licensed CC BY-NC-ND and is not included)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t72_o5","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025 record scope","CC BY-NC-ND text not included"]},{"as_of":20250506,"based_on":["t72_o1","t72_o2","t72_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t72_c1","object":"The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis (Humanit Soc Sci Commun 2025;12:621; doi:10.1057/s41599-025-04787-y)","predicate":"published_as","stance":"reported","subject":"Wang and Fan 2025","text":"Wang and Fan 2025, titled \"The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis\", was published in Humanit Soc Sci Commun on 6 May 2025 (12:621)."},{"as_of":20260422,"based_on":["t72_o1","t72_o2","t72_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t72_c2","object":"22 April 2026 (Retraction note: Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 2026;13:528, doi:10.1057/s41599-026-07310-z)","predicate":"retracted_on","stance":"reported","subject":"Wang and Fan 2025","text":"Wang and Fan 2025 was retracted on 22 April 2026 via retraction note Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 2026;13:528 (doi:10.1057/s41599-026-07310-z)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t72_o1","e8912985e6037b25","04588ef5a34c56f4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t72_c4","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (Meta-analysis of prior studies; Metacognition: High; Engagement: Moderate; Near/Far transfer: —; Data: Mixed; Context: Self-regulated learning with GenAI)","predicate":"tabulates_citation_of","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In a comparison table row, PMC13226197 lists the retracted meta-analysis Wang and Fan 2025 (Mixed data, Self-regulated learning with GenAI), rating Metacognition High, Engagement Moderate, and Near/Far transfer unaddressed."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t72_o1","2fb29e43a710ad93","33dbc45b04e1c601"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t72_c5","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (statement that ChatGPT has been suggested to improve the development of critical thinking skills)","predicate":"cites_Wang_and_Fan_2025_for","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) cites the retracted meta-analysis Wang and Fan 2025 (along with Jalil et al., 2023) to support the statement that ChatGPT has been suggested to improve the development of critical thinking skills."},{"about":["Wang and Fan 2025","Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t72_q1","needed":"Check Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) for citations to reference 36 (including citation ranges) and reference list entry 36, plus any other corpus articles citing Wang and Fan 2025, pairing each with the Title quote t72_o1.","text":"Which passages and table rows in Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) or other corpus articles cite Wang and Fan 2025 (reference 36 in Manushi 2026), and what findings or claims do they rest on it?"},{"about":["Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t72_q2","needed":"Check retraction note Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 2026;13:528 (doi:10.1057/s41599-026-07310-z) or passages in corpus articles discussing the retraction.","text":"Why was Wang and Fan 2025 retracted on 22 April 2026, and which specific findings or effect sizes reported by Wang and Fan 2025 are invalidated by the retraction note (doi:10.1057/s41599-026-07310-z)?"}],"scope":{"docs":["retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt"],"ranges":[["retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt",0,541]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"179ac9da3d9ea08604af183188ea0168b669854ce3dc64518bfba1a7342dd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["ff7476f8cc35422263e3f0116ec8ba13b96b2b148381695e3b78c1fb040741b6","9fd06bae684a9110374c5fb9d4f5ad68e9be75363f5e5c384ad2c579f95cb139","e8c474da69c2e5b36422b9f13d96076e16ef745a3b9aac6e04c87ab4560bd45e","e0676eeb1d1c9297167b3510ad0b40f85e93f082c9dc0630b60029f45f851b62","ab748f39834204f2fd03a1b68f76e0124a8d48937673b5cb79614a2059212ab1","9fb11adb29d4c09fbcc7be00546bacc8560e33b2efdfffdd96f10f7c0eda9c67","f8bd5f06416f38881195c3906330f73dbe68484134c0eb8d6b6b751711486ee7"],"error":{"code":"UNKNOWN_LOCAL_ID","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"expected an issued local id or @hash","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":7}},"request_hash":"915c17c9fcef847d93d3394369aa4cc457f2b9a224e15ff25d6b281bf093f769","submission_id":"T72-b63a7d606942e9ca#1"},"hash":"a39ab53a737cf3e3b5192d3162ab13fd68e35faca572e541da9eb66cfdc17c04","header":{"body_hash":"2a93b2c78c9f1c687ff219b35db165e4afa6d532b7bd29055d1a0e17b3675850","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"98ef130f919dadf309748ae7e82c5956036ca06c6da13bce1601ba05f2650e41","records_root":"309963e24f669a1013716b92f4a5108c3b15e64ccfd62b0f7a84b0e784d2bb3c","seq":344,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"ff7863d7df1ed3a285745e2bc369065e29f1b4244bc0cb5e12b2829e78ade6e3","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T72-b63a7d606942e9ca","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t72_o1","2fb29e43a710ad93","33dbc45b04e1c601"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t72_c5","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (statement that ChatGPT has been suggested to improve the development of critical thinking skills)","predicate":"cites_Wang_and_Fan_2025_for","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) cites the retracted meta-analysis Wang and Fan 2025 (along with Jalil et al., 2023) to support the statement that ChatGPT has been suggested to improve the development of critical thinking skills."},{"about":["Wang and Fan 2025","Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t72_q1","needed":"Check Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) for citations to reference 36 (including citation ranges) and reference list entry 36, plus any other corpus articles citing Wang and Fan 2025, pairing each with the Title quote t72_o1.","text":"Which passages and table rows in Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) or other corpus articles cite Wang and Fan 2025 (reference 36 in Manushi 2026), and what findings or claims do they rest on it?"},{"about":["Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t72_q2","needed":"Check retraction note Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 2026;13:528 (doi:10.1057/s41599-026-07310-z) or passages in corpus articles discussing the retraction.","text":"Why was Wang and Fan 2025 retracted on 22 April 2026, and which specific findings or effect sizes reported by Wang and Fan 2025 are invalidated by the retraction note (doi:10.1057/s41599-026-07310-z)?"}],"scope":{"docs":["retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt"],"ranges":[["retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt",0,541]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"179ac9da3d9ea08604af183188ea0168b669854ce3dc64518bfba1a7342dd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":[],"error":{"code":"UNKNOWN_LOCAL_ID","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"expected an issued local id or @hash","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":0}},"request_hash":"775971bdb4264889a205233786bb13f8ff264000e5b074beb23df6d03f681f5e","submission_id":"T72-b63a7d606942e9ca#1.1"},"hash":"0c8fe1b0a07062c4a7b89a5bbf3b460d2444782b3723debffecf98cae436626f","header":{"body_hash":"63121cd637d894fbf3e8a0e3ca8c29d65aa41c179e736aaf937747bcb5759c2d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"a39ab53a737cf3e3b5192d3162ab13fd68e35faca572e541da9eb66cfdc17c04","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":345,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"ef53816e061fd252160996950ec9cba9202c32ff3b49639054cf8c33824248b1","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T72-b63a7d606942e9ca","kind":"submit","lines":[{"about":["Wang and Fan 2025","Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t72_q1","needed":"Check Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) for citations to reference 36 (including citation ranges) and reference list entry 36, plus any other corpus articles citing Wang and Fan 2025, pairing each with the Title quote t72_o1.","text":"Which passages and table rows in Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) or other corpus articles cite Wang and Fan 2025 (reference 36 in Manushi 2026), and what findings or claims do they rest on it?"},{"about":["Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t72_q2","needed":"Check retraction note Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 2026;13:528 (doi:10.1057/s41599-026-07310-z) or passages in corpus articles discussing the retraction.","text":"Why was Wang and Fan 2025 retracted on 22 April 2026, and which specific findings or effect sizes reported by Wang and Fan 2025 are invalidated by the retraction note (doi:10.1057/s41599-026-07310-z)?"}],"scope":{"docs":["retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt"],"ranges":[["retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt",0,541]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"179ac9da3d9ea08604af183188ea0168b669854ce3dc64518bfba1a7342dd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["c589d865c3fe64375c292d3ca2edc7e06325dc51b5adad9fae963a5d7fd832b8","3fef8a5af8df4d027f6815e655ababdd4032cd7175925100f18c5c21d7c8c610"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"621d1ace2a435c1428ecd05282d225080aae56bd4324a28465912bff9fbdf59a","submission_id":"T72-b63a7d606942e9ca#1.2"},"hash":"4d01ac51240efe9cee6b59ebdc824db746b145eb0a2f7289cde21ead7287aaec","header":{"body_hash":"f18936cecc382934e9c33260bf5ddb9561247522d751d8abeb13d9ca31d065be","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"0c8fe1b0a07062c4a7b89a5bbf3b460d2444782b3723debffecf98cae436626f","records_root":"b4ebe09c425b6dc5be2f6e675b59794576d4bce98c59fd6ff85db93691d3b412","seq":346,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"512fe870513b115c74e7d9180f7a42e6ce07f33031a5738468ed7af03b3e8ab1","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@ff7476f8cc354222","@9fd06bae684a9110","@e8c474da69c2e5b3","@e0676eeb1d1c9297","@ab748f39834204f2","@9fb11adb29d4c09f","@f8bd5f06416f3888","@c589d865c3fe6437","@3fef8a5af8df4d02"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"NO_EVIDENCE","expected_by_kernel":{"missing_identifiers":["retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt"]},"field":"based_on","message":"a claim names only identifiers its quotes hold: add a quote of this section that holds each one listed, or leave it out of the claim","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":7,"local_id":"t72_c3"},{"error":{"code":"UNKNOWN_LOCAL_ID","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"expected an issued local id or @hash","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":8,"local_id":"t72_c4"},{"error":{"code":"UNKNOWN_LOCAL_ID","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"expected an issued local id or @hash","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":9,"local_id":"t72_c5"}],"task_id":"T72-b63a7d606942e9ca","work_key":"doc:retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt#0"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T72-b63a7d606942e9ca:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"179ac9da3d9ea08604af183188ea0168b669854ce3dc64518bfba1a7342dd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"50a0a73d9e867214265208de1c8383f16a71893e9a7b270c682f402c390f8150","submission_id":"T72-b63a7d606942e9ca#repair1"},"hash":"7e6584f9b48da1a62fe4c537f1ea16a3eb54d8a183ec95c325b221d771f00b16","header":{"body_hash":"7464fbcfd6bc506626c03ed39e2f2bdbbcca22917f2d82fa05025b522d1cb9d5","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"4d01ac51240efe9cee6b59ebdc824db746b145eb0a2f7289cde21ead7287aaec","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":347,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"972385166a10ef7462e1b3d80d096533e9ee5f5cab5ab7f8b2a15e83f0d54818","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T72-b63a7d606942e9ca","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t72_o1","t72_o2","t72_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t72_c3","object":"Retracted article record (bibliographic facts only; the article's text is licensed CC BY-NC-ND and is not included)","predicate":"record_scope","stance":"qualified","subject":"Wang and Fan 2025","text":"The retracted article record for Wang and Fan 2025 provides only bibliographic facts because the article's text is licensed CC BY-NC-ND and is not included."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t72_o1","@e8912985e6037b25","@04588ef5a34c56f4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t72_c4","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (Meta-analysis of prior studies; Metacognition: High; Engagement: Moderate; Near/Far transfer: —; Data: Mixed; Context: Self-regulated learning with GenAI)","predicate":"tabulates_citation_of","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In a comparison table row, PMC13226197 lists the meta-analysis Wang and Fan 2025 (Mixed data, Self-regulated learning with GenAI), rating Metacognition High, Engagement Moderate, and Near/Far transfer unaddressed."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t72_o1","@2fb29e43a710ad93","@33dbc45b04e1c601","@1bbc6687f9d17196","@493109aa40be1afa","@36a7360f76c796d4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t72_c5","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (ChatGPT improves development of critical thinking skills)","predicate":"cites_Wang_and_Fan_2025_for","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) cites the meta-analysis Wang and Fan 2025 (with Jalil et al., 2023) to support the statement that ChatGPT has been suggested to improve the development of critical thinking skills."}],"scope":{"docs":["retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt"],"ranges":[["retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt",0,541]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"179ac9da3d9ea08604af183188ea0168b669854ce3dc64518bfba1a7342dd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["4bbf122b34957c8acf0b678e97ba7662ee3b93bf1579c3e490bff5ca08740096"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"record was not issued in this context or allowed document scope","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":1}},"request_hash":"8a908bacce0df9752208a2962613ce593af0922336bbd17abd82de4b630f12d7","submission_id":"T72-b63a7d606942e9ca#2"},"hash":"9aa09174e72edebe99a1aab45f295684c3c32eb24538b89226d4e7a77e6ab843","header":{"body_hash":"73c94a7e7d6eac33aa6b7ac821f05557bdc5b69590bb43dd2e8def9c1042a7a6","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"7e6584f9b48da1a62fe4c537f1ea16a3eb54d8a183ec95c325b221d771f00b16","records_root":"389ca4c789b61e25ab60fef68596a978bae3372364bc4137b65b558238c88ac1","seq":348,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"e8128e98c076d57a7b737c6e8414c00d999e48dfccdabcd56a39c907bb362d11","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"T72-b63a7d606942e9ca","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t72_o1","@2fb29e43a710ad93","@33dbc45b04e1c601","@1bbc6687f9d17196","@493109aa40be1afa","@36a7360f76c796d4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t72_c5","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (ChatGPT improves development of critical thinking skills)","predicate":"cites_Wang_and_Fan_2025_for","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) cites the meta-analysis Wang and Fan 2025 (with Jalil et al., 2023) to support the statement that ChatGPT has been suggested to improve the development of critical thinking skills."}],"scope":{"docs":["retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt"],"ranges":[["retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt",0,541]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"179ac9da3d9ea08604af183188ea0168b669854ce3dc64518bfba1a7342dd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":[],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"record was not issued in this context or allowed document scope","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":0}},"request_hash":"be83a80a81cb618744930c05ab8838802ee93a0b7fa7cdf2a562118dd5041264","submission_id":"T72-b63a7d606942e9ca#2.1"},"hash":"f3fdcaf5e36055a28bb9bb14b570e704067b75bfe9e6c7dcc1107253910ac95f","header":{"body_hash":"206e8c637199a0ef86437e8f1d6335a679ea7bd65c99e1ac3896a388e4c85583","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"9aa09174e72edebe99a1aab45f295684c3c32eb24538b89226d4e7a77e6ab843","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":349,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"02e7ca787c23a6fefde831fe9948082e25645471987aae8fe5387c9738b1871f","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@4bbf122b34957c8a"],"attempt":2,"excluded":[],"kind":"EXTEND","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"record was not issued in this context or allowed document scope","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":1,"local_id":"t72_c4"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"record was not issued in this context or allowed document scope","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":2,"local_id":"t72_c5"}],"task_id":"T72-b63a7d606942e9ca","work_key":"doc:retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt#0"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:T72-b63a7d606942e9ca:2","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"179ac9da3d9ea08604af183188ea0168b669854ce3dc64518bfba1a7342dd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"d81636612651d3f04ca19953f90dc8d58b16602252fb2c328abded2c04c3d801","submission_id":"T72-b63a7d606942e9ca#repair2"},"hash":"dbbf7d3dd67b42b6afdfa4f5206f5e58f63dfcb9640e907bba643f3c43bfe903","header":{"body_hash":"7af42e3b7e29dcb73c22d165d259ca8e2783affd4f5f99a60a17c0703774b650","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"f3fdcaf5e36055a28bb9bb14b570e704067b75bfe9e6c7dcc1107253910ac95f","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":350,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"a7ee0b68143f6ad19df57304914b5e00ff8f12ab07aed985f8a19f151ebf2208","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"abandoned":true,"agent":"reader-3","circle":21,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"EXTEND","link_task":null,"offered":12,"refusals":2,"stored":10,"sync_step":41,"task_id":"T72-b63a7d606942e9ca"},"from":0,"key":"task:doc:retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt#0","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"179ac9da3d9ea08604af183188ea0168b669854ce3dc64518bfba1a7342dd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"a2b4af6ff34a36c81aaeb824786fa5499c53fa947546928cf8d4f1208f705ab5","submission_id":"T72-b63a7d606942e9ca#done4"},"hash":"5d33f7b5edf084b9c063c27c1112819c90883be2b6194f2aa9cde18d3bc98bd4","header":{"body_hash":"31f7606ce1afc951570d67c700e5ee8c3a78c4505f002ea3c1740dae7a1daf7b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"dbbf7d3dd67b42b6afdfa4f5206f5e58f63dfcb9640e907bba643f3c43bfe903","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":351,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"f0183ff586e8bff58229c1507fb91b74aa77da1a2e853e0c1e7241139d5ab31f","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR74-b12c39445ae62764","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"In line with Crompton and Burke (2023) and Wang and Fan (2025), these results support the importance of psychometrically sound instruments for examining educational phenomena related to artificial intelligence.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t74_o1","terms":["citation of Wang and Fan 2025","psychometrically sound instruments","AI educational phenomena"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The structural model represented in Figure 3 confirms a moderate correlation between the factors (r = 0.49).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t74_o2","terms":["structural model","factor correlation r = 0.49"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"The standardized factor loadings of the items range from 0.86 to 1.00 for Fc1 and from 1.00 to 1.19 for Fc2, indicating a strong association between the items and their respective factors.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t74_o3","terms":["standardized factor loadings","Fc1 0.86 to 1.00","Fc2 1.00 to 1.19"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Likewise, the variance of the factors (0.80 for Fc1 and 0.52 for Fc2) suggests that a substantial proportion of the variance of the items is explained by the latent constructs.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t74_o4","terms":["factor variance","0.80 for Fc1","0.52 for Fc2"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"These findings support the use of the instrument as a reliable tool for examining how students perceive the role of generative artificial intelligence in relation to key academic skill domains, rather than as a measure of actual skill acquisition or direct educational effects.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t74_o5","terms":["instrument scope qualification","perceptions vs actual skill acquisition"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t74_o1","@04588ef5a34c56f4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t74_c1","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (importance of psychometrically sound instruments for examining AI-related educational phenomena)","predicate":"supports_statement_with","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 cites Wang and Fan 2025 alongside Crompton and Burke (2023) to support the importance of psychometrically sound instruments for examining AI-related educational phenomena."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t74_o2","t74_o3","t74_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t74_c2","object":"factor correlation r=0.49; factor variances Fc1=0.80, Fc2=0.52; standardized loadings Fc1=0.86-1.00, Fc2=1.00-1.19","predicate":"reports_structural_model_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"In PMC13314867, the structural model confirms a moderate correlation between the communicative and analytical factors (r = 0.49), with factor variances of 0.80 (Fc1) and 0.52 (Fc2) and standardized loadings of 0.86-1.00 (Fc1) and 1.00-1.19 (Fc2)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t74_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t74_c3","object":"findings reflect student perceptions of ChatGPT's role rather than actual skill acquisition or direct causal educational effects","predicate":"qualifies_conclusion","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 qualifies its conclusions by noting that the validated instrument measures students' perceived contributions of ChatGPT to communicative and analytical skills, rather than actual skill acquisition or direct educational effects."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",23436,28966]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"179ac9da3d9ea08604af183188ea0168b669854ce3dc64518bfba1a7342dd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["16fdfb67a3dbd78260306f5f63b10c85bc78e6157a493af2afdaf7d4b71e5d6f","84fccc861adeb26d2031f42242f0a82fb59e5c8d09a745355c2a914270fac306","3cdad9aa29d71ff9b3a6c750c6d28ea9972f7711f9a070b29bc4d9119e3f8271","c9a95f9617d80fc36ede6015b5891bab8a49294342d82d278cb51d55860f809f","8af8537a1aa31c58510d19159af1872b3e46a4927bff4d24343a53c8991aaf91"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"record was not issued in this context or allowed document scope","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":5}},"request_hash":"80f78dc9425d5d1660f7edbfecc2ea289f1a76d096794969d89956f041768b46","submission_id":"TR74-b12c39445ae62764#1"},"hash":"19921e2dcabbc485d5e08754192a816e34bfae358ce0b8bca69145423a65a97c","header":{"body_hash":"81d016a2d9e567da82fba78885fae8bd8967b89e82a6b5b74e305cd4ed6ea206","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"5d33f7b5edf084b9c063c27c1112819c90883be2b6194f2aa9cde18d3bc98bd4","records_root":"60e6cf519e0383ee2d599ddd6e089f6706e98a0e6f1b0ffa377a4362271f35ef","seq":352,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"eec902b5eaede436ac224090683880ead0e0aaac90b93ea92d2348c60390fd84","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR74-b12c39445ae62764","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t74_o2","t74_o3","t74_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t74_c2","object":"factor correlation r=0.49; factor variances Fc1=0.80, Fc2=0.52; standardized loadings Fc1=0.86-1.00, Fc2=1.00-1.19","predicate":"reports_structural_model_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"In PMC13314867, the structural model confirms a moderate correlation between the communicative and analytical factors (r = 0.49), with factor variances of 0.80 (Fc1) and 0.52 (Fc2) and standardized loadings of 0.86-1.00 (Fc1) and 1.00-1.19 (Fc2)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t74_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t74_c3","object":"findings reflect student perceptions of ChatGPT's role rather than actual skill acquisition or direct causal educational effects","predicate":"qualifies_conclusion","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 qualifies its conclusions by noting that the validated instrument measures students' perceived contributions of ChatGPT to communicative and analytical skills, rather than actual skill acquisition or direct educational effects."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",23436,28966]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"179ac9da3d9ea08604af183188ea0168b669854ce3dc64518bfba1a7342dd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":[],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":0}},"request_hash":"96bba0175fc592c88ef3928413e8273f17fa80e13facec35c48febe47fad6e2f","submission_id":"TR74-b12c39445ae62764#1.1"},"hash":"f74904f519774eea6acc8d362d58f3231c6e18b94879c0884ffce1c80ce171f1","header":{"body_hash":"f087b32e5faaa2bc315d53fa6a07cf762aec7f5bb5ba0a2195f4ec2c646ff156","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"19921e2dcabbc485d5e08754192a816e34bfae358ce0b8bca69145423a65a97c","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":353,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"9bb4438c74eb2ec1de33c1d05c48b33885064c92e556e35580730b217cf3e8b0","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR74-b12c39445ae62764","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t74_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t74_c3","object":"findings reflect student perceptions of ChatGPT's role rather than actual skill acquisition or direct causal educational effects","predicate":"qualifies_conclusion","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 qualifies its conclusions by noting that the validated instrument measures students' perceived contributions of ChatGPT to communicative and analytical skills, rather than actual skill acquisition or direct educational effects."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",23436,28966]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"179ac9da3d9ea08604af183188ea0168b669854ce3dc64518bfba1a7342dd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["1cbb13f21cb502e3231b063a2460d084330dd722615577d06a72b7b143fd5819"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"884f7aadd06351f67ec2f9d86bb2d3ad8c688c50b396e16498b37f4c53a8e805","submission_id":"TR74-b12c39445ae62764#1.2"},"hash":"a477c46df919206f77de97c3fa615e4bc08ad91f401c237986e5efae2b4ef597","header":{"body_hash":"fbc9cfc8cf9a6e02bdf7f7856b5e0e0961647f00bbbb188a0d9884d9de23c552","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"f74904f519774eea6acc8d362d58f3231c6e18b94879c0884ffce1c80ce171f1","records_root":"078269c1b2edfc280737f96c4774dd7ce97fbe42211e9c83ed88f8b7682c8711","seq":354,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"fe766213ed5923601175a4ca013777bcc15bbe74a771c79b999babc4da16406f","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@16fdfb67a3dbd782","@84fccc861adeb26d","@3cdad9aa29d71ff9","@c9a95f9617d80fc3","@8af8537a1aa31c58","@1cbb13f21cb502e3"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"REQUEST","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":null,"field":"reference","message":"record was not issued in this context or allowed document scope","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":5,"local_id":"t74_c1"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":6,"local_id":"t74_c2"}],"task_id":"TR74-b12c39445ae62764","work_key":"reread:PMC13314867.txt#4"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:TR74-b12c39445ae62764:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"179ac9da3d9ea08604af183188ea0168b669854ce3dc64518bfba1a7342dd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"5426ac9aed804c6e768fc396a36d686a9b2068323aa21f029c4d573a1b54da8a","submission_id":"TR74-b12c39445ae62764#repair1"},"hash":"e6bddae0897dd9902eb0eaeabd8a29d4e35667a61776483b53ea0f8da3d79a68","header":{"body_hash":"44767fb71546596764ea36c39869ba0511bc9f2668de4d42c73d9336d528c8a3","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"a477c46df919206f77de97c3fa615e4bc08ad91f401c237986e5efae2b4ef597","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":355,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"63f2f669c62eb9ae0dbe78cdbc57641f8e5e6c58e90a66108c00ad09fe6b91ef","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR73-44f596e59c32a6bf","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt","exact_quote":"Title: The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t73_o1","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025","title","ChatGPT meta-analysis"]},{"doc_id":"retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt","exact_quote":"Authors: Wang J, Fan W.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t73_o2","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025","authors"]},{"doc_id":"retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt","exact_quote":"Published: Humanities and Social Sciences Communications. 2025 May 6;12:621. doi:10.1057/s41599-025-04787-y.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t73_o3","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025","publication details","doi"]},{"doc_id":"retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt","exact_quote":"Status: retracted on 22 April 2026. Retraction note: Humanities and Social Sciences Communications. 2026;13:528. doi:10.1057/s41599-026-07310-z.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t73_o4","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025","retraction status","retraction note"]},{"doc_id":"retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt","exact_quote":"Retracted article record (bibliographic facts only; the article's text is licensed CC BY-NC-ND and is not included)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t73_o5","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025","record scope","text excluded"]},{"as_of":20250506,"based_on":["t73_o1","t73_o2","t73_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t73_c1","object":"Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 2025 May 6;12:621 (doi:10.1057/s41599-025-04787-y)","predicate":"published_in","stance":"reported","subject":"Wang and Fan 2025","text":"The meta-analysis 'The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis' by Wang J and Fan W was published on 6 May 2025 in Humanit Soc Sci Commun (12:621)."},{"as_of":20260422,"based_on":["t73_o1","t73_o2","t73_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t73_c2","object":"2026-04-22 (Retraction note: Humanit Soc Sci Commun 2026;13:528, doi:10.1057/s41599-026-07310-z)","predicate":"retracted_on","stance":"superseded","subject":"Wang and Fan 2025","text":"Wang and Fan 2025 was retracted on 22 April 2026 via retraction note Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 2026;13:528 (doi:10.1057/s41599-026-07310-z)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t73_o1","t73_o2","t73_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t73_c3","object":"bibliographic facts only; full text excluded under CC BY-NC-ND license","predicate":"record_scope","stance":"qualified","subject":"Wang and Fan 2025","text":"The corpus record for Wang and Fan 2025 includes only bibliographic facts and excludes the article's full text due to CC BY-NC-ND licensing, leaving its internal findings, effect sizes, and primary data unrecorded in this file."}],"scope":{"docs":["retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt"],"ranges":[["retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt",0,541]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"179ac9da3d9ea08604af183188ea0168b669854ce3dc64518bfba1a7342dd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["1c6f7b49947dced4ff20fdf3398385257a068828d60f0c9b27e5da6d7992d32c","aa3e3319856c40999d7ec64635618670d9e798fd81044262a185ebe07d7e4a14","9fdb47f636c92d84c494448402e45626a0de35ac6844575976b21e5b7430fc77","6a7729235c4b15e24eaaac404d41bd4b023a9ce2b4bf9f6988e5b7d96a92e1ee","718e062d5da7611cc683f734c761f61efc42bde3c484a84601c7d4c7f2bce1a4","18d056e2dc42a0ea7e940872e5adf831b46c978bc66afb5e9ae08faec28eb6c3","e5464a9c67ea781f936eb0fe4f4b1587e33675c765f52d760dc66589c0214f0d","b4b926d03621298c80844a13e4214af41ec3b93fd0f2d3e019f26528a16ca5c0"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"ebef5c6d8b99926b83a1e3d1735dac4b51c0213443256422edb40ed6f0327b8d","submission_id":"TR73-44f596e59c32a6bf#1"},"hash":"ee4ec12f5462591a6b436af7c30ac833e2026a78b5b0df22edc20fd72940f5a6","header":{"body_hash":"cf88233235cc7bf267d61297098051e58ee6ab32ab8af358967fbcaceba5aa7b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"e6bddae0897dd9902eb0eaeabd8a29d4e35667a61776483b53ea0f8da3d79a68","records_root":"904eee7c2ef8146a313d1918f47881b4750dfa6f6765a1c8ad6105ab7d1e1cce","seq":356,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"0fdb48e77b6e921e09d6cb06f70047d14b1e6cd6f01da4966225164981b6cbb0","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":21,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":112,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt#0"},"sync_step":41,"task_id":"TR73-44f596e59c32a6bf"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt#0","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"179ac9da3d9ea08604af183188ea0168b669854ce3dc64518bfba1a7342dd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"700e2e49674a4e1a5184332fa839dd52967e9077146b3894da7726a9cf595028","submission_id":"TR73-44f596e59c32a6bf#done2"},"hash":"deb52d73625ea126720bebbd2204563dbd018d0865d1e502a3f09eaf89a0334b","header":{"body_hash":"a1c3d80db70a6ccfd417b0a2cb2e0fa7ee464245972f4f2be6ba77bce26c6877","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ee4ec12f5462591a6b436af7c30ac833e2026a78b5b0df22edc20fd72940f5a6","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":357,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"df39332822238e80685b7787cb448cd6a8d75dbbf63c46e62c8532181b9ea8e3","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR74-b12c39445ae62764","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t74_o1"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t74_c1","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (importance of psychometrically sound instruments for examining AI-related educational phenomena)","predicate":"supports_statement_with","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 cites Wang and Fan 2025 alongside Crompton and Burke (2023) to support the importance of psychometrically sound instruments for examining AI-related educational phenomena."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t74_o2","t74_o3","t74_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t74_c2","object":"factor correlation r=0.49; factor variances Fc1=0.80, Fc2=0.52; standardized loadings Fc1=0.86-1.00, Fc2=1.00-1.19","predicate":"reports_structural_model_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"In PMC13314867, the structural model confirms a moderate factor correlation (r = 0.49), with factor variances of 0.80 (Fc1) and 0.52 (Fc2) and standardized loadings of 0.86-1.00 (Fc1) and 1.00-1.19 (Fc2)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",23436,28966]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"179ac9da3d9ea08604af183188ea0168b669854ce3dc64518bfba1a7342dd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["96ea2489d04437be245ae9141bf2fdaccc0a2ed4736bca96b05636b84cb39c61","a4d6bdddc29557d8e64b53cf5e39b799daef32c6900e243e909aac7caea9ccd5"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"b3b63d1abea77155456686e9ba870d6f110134fb2f4ada71254985a71cbc521e","submission_id":"TR74-b12c39445ae62764#2"},"hash":"5591c67b8939885b7b267bb8c83b996e4514fe3cb3dcc6efd8c95c25e04bb0b0","header":{"body_hash":"87f0aaa555254d84e5f4f346a85f423767f1b08c9e3a34130113545c0fa3178f","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"deb52d73625ea126720bebbd2204563dbd018d0865d1e502a3f09eaf89a0334b","records_root":"acbe56534974dfaf9a58885c81564feb96862bd0fb6e0c60be9bab879b2de2fc","seq":358,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"fd4e2356d73a1838477458313d944072ef8b4c43d7f58f73ef1a0f516f8c7ee5","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":21,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":6,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:PMC13314867.txt#4"},"sync_step":41,"task_id":"TR74-b12c39445ae62764"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:PMC13314867.txt#4","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"179ac9da3d9ea08604af183188ea0168b669854ce3dc64518bfba1a7342dd8d9","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"c65a9ef5ed9d1b4514666babb31bb7d9eaf4c1e7edc6bf01f4daec1b743f56b9","submission_id":"TR74-b12c39445ae62764#done3"},"hash":"8a2074ac18cce909a42edd471accfbe58bb67af625acfc375ed449608c406711","header":{"body_hash":"64ce35f36540e288e125e83f8095b2c0e881535f31aa9837d19676d86ee1ce11","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"5591c67b8939885b7b267bb8c83b996e4514fe3cb3dcc6efd8c95c25e04bb0b0","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":359,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"34c0f039abd6d6faad314dba3eea24f922c46349fb7f6a64e2e2bc9437e2ac9b","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TR75-282cee43d6d0fab1","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Control | Help-seeking probability | Interaction | 0.061 | [0.052, 0.070] | 0.29 | 38,762,114 | 52,418 | Same + error history","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o1","terms":["metacognitive control","help-seeking probability","fixed effects estimate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Control | Revisiting prior item | Session | 0.044 | [0.036, 0.052] | 0.20 | 1,184,906 | 52,418 | Same","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o2","terms":["metacognitive control","revisiting prior item","fixed effects estimate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Control | Strategy switching | Session | 0.036 | [0.028, 0.044] | 0.18 | 1,184,906 | 52,418 | Same","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o3","terms":["metacognitive control","strategy switching","fixed effects estimate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The event sequence rates in Figure 4c indicate that post-exposure checking and revision frequencies are higher, whereas in Figure 4d the effect size increases with exposure intensity.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o4","terms":["metacognition","checking and revision frequencies","exposure intensity"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Table 4 indicates that AI support exposure is associated with more time on task, higher activity intensity, greater persistence following errors, and higher short-term return behavior.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o5","terms":["behavioral engagement","AI support exposure","engagement outcomes"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"These are the most pronounced effects that occur immediately after exposure episodes and diminish with longer horizons, as expected for short-horizon engagement responses.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o6","terms":["behavioral engagement","short-horizon response","diminishing effects"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Outcome | Unit | Coef. (β) | 95% CI | Std. effect | Adjusted p | N (obs) | Learners | Controls","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o7","terms":["Table 4 header","engagement outcomes"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Time on task (log minutes) | Session | 0.083 | [0.072, 0.094] | 0.25 | <0.001 | 1,184,906 | 52,418 | Learner FE, week FE","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o8","terms":["time on task","session engagement","fixed effects estimate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Activity intensity | Session | 0.057 | [0.046, 0.068] | 0.22 | <0.001 | 1,184,906 | 52,418 | Same","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o9","terms":["activity intensity","session engagement","fixed effects estimate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Persistence after error | Interaction | 0.064 | [0.053, 0.075] | 0.27 | <0.001 | 38,762,114 | 52,418 | Same + error history","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o10","terms":["persistence after error","interaction engagement","fixed effects estimate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Return probability (next day) | Learner day | 0.031 | [0.024, 0.038] | 0.13 | <0.001 | 4,821,300 | 52,418 | Same + day FE","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o11","terms":["next-day return probability","engagement","fixed effects estimate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Spacing (shorter gap) | Learner week | −0.018 | [−0.026, −0.010] | −0.09 | 0.002 | 812,940 | 52,418 | Same","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o12","terms":["inter-session spacing","shorter gap","fixed effects estimate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Table 5 demonstrates positive effects on near transfer, as reflected in first-attempt performance on new items within the same skill.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o13","terms":["near transfer","first-attempt performance","same skill"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The transfer effects during topic shifts and delayed performance are also smaller but nevertheless positive and statistically significant relative to zero.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o14","terms":["topic shift transfer","delayed performance","positive transfer effects"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The trends indicate that AI support can more reliably increase near transfer than far transfer.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o15","terms":["near transfer vs far transfer","AI support reliability"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Transfer outcome | Definition | Unit | Coef. (β) | 95% CI | Std. effect | N (obs) | Learners","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o16","terms":["Table 5 header","transfer outcomes"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Near transfer | New item, same skill | Interaction | 0.052 | [0.041, 0.063] | 0.24 | 9,842,117 | 51,006","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o17","terms":["near transfer estimate","new item same skill"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Topic shift transfer | New skill cluster | Interaction | 0.021 | [0.011, 0.031] | 0.10 | 6,314,882 | 48,772","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o18","terms":["topic shift transfer estimate","new skill cluster"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Delayed performance | Gap ≥ 7 days | Interaction | 0.017 | [0.007, 0.027] | 0.08 | 3,102,944 | 44,985","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o19","terms":["delayed performance estimate","7-day gap"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Near transfer (robust) | Strict novelty | Interaction | 0.046 | [0.035, 0.057] | 0.21 | 7,416,309 | 49,220","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o20","terms":["robust near transfer estimate","strict novelty"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Delayed performance (robust) | Gap ≥ 14 days | Interaction | 0.012 | [0.003, 0.021] | 0.06 | 1,884,116 | 42,107","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o21","terms":["robust delayed performance estimate","14-day gap"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Figure 6a demonstrates that near-transfer effects are higher in competence with higher-difficulty skills. Figure 6b indicates attenuated effects when the topic shifts are larger","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o22","terms":["transfer heterogeneity","skill difficulty","topic shift size"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Figure 6c denotes a downward trend in the effects as the inactivity gap increases.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t75_o23","terms":["transfer heterogeneity","inactivity gap","downward trend"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t75_o1","t75_o2","t75_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t75_c1","object":"help-seeking (β=0.061, std=0.29), revisiting items (β=0.044, std=0.20), strategy switching (β=0.036, std=0.18) across 52,418 learners","predicate":"reports_metacognitive_control_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In PMC13226197 (N=52,418 learners), AI tutoring exposure positively affects metacognitive control: help-seeking probability (β=0.061, std. effect=0.29), revisiting prior items (β=0.044, 0.20), and strategy switching (β=0.036, 0.18)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t75_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t75_c2","object":"higher post-exposure checking/revision frequencies and larger effect sizes with higher exposure intensity","predicate":"concludes_metacognitive_dose_response","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds that post-exposure metacognitive checking and revision frequencies are higher after AI assistance, and that metacognitive effect sizes increase with AI exposure intensity."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t75_o5","t75_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t75_c3","object":"pronounced immediate gains in time on task, activity intensity, error persistence, and short-term return that diminish over longer horizons","predicate":"concludes_engagement_dynamics","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 reports that AI support exposure increases short-horizon behavioral engagement—time on task, activity intensity, persistence after errors, and short-term return—with effects diminishing over longer horizons."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t75_o7","t75_o8","t75_o9","t75_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t75_c4","object":"time on task (β=0.083, std=0.25), activity intensity (β=0.057, std=0.22), persistence after error (β=0.064, std=0.27), all p<0.001","predicate":"reports_in_session_engagement_estimates","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In PMC13226197 Table 4 (52,418 learners), AI exposure increases session log time on task (β=0.083, std=0.25, p<0.001; N=1,184,906), activity intensity (β=0.057, std=0.22, p<0.001), and persistence after error (β=0.064, std=0.27, p<0.001)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t75_o7","t75_o11","t75_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t75_c5","object":"next-day return probability (β=0.031, std=0.13, p<0.001) and weekly spacing gap (β=−0.018, std=−0.09, p=0.002)","predicate":"reports_return_and_spacing_estimates","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In PMC13226197 Table 4 (52,418 learners), AI exposure increases next-day return probability (β=0.031, std=0.13, p<0.001; N=4,821,300 learner-days) and reduces weekly inter-session spacing gaps (β=−0.018, std=−0.09, p=0.002; N=812,940)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t75_o13","t75_o14","t75_o15"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t75_c6","object":"AI support increases near transfer more reliably than far transfer, with smaller but positive and significant topic-shift and delayed transfer","predicate":"concludes_transfer_comparison","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 concludes that AI support increases near transfer (first-attempt performance on new items within the same skill) more reliably than far transfer, though topic-shift and delayed transfer remain positive and significant."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t75_o16","t75_o17","t75_o18","t75_o20"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t75_c7","object":"near transfer (β=0.052, std=0.24; robust β=0.046, std=0.21) and topic-shift transfer (β=0.021, std=0.10)","predicate":"reports_near_and_topic_transfer_estimates","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In PMC13226197 Table 5, AI exposure shows positive fixed-effects estimates for near transfer (β=0.052, std=0.24, N=9,842,117; robust strict-novelty β=0.046, std=0.21, N=7,416,309) and topic-shift transfer (β=0.021, std=0.10, N=6,314,882)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t75_o16","t75_o19","t75_o21"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t75_c8","object":"delayed performance ≥7 days (β=0.017, std=0.08) and ≥14 days (β=0.012, std=0.06)","predicate":"reports_delayed_transfer_estimates","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In PMC13226197 Table 5, AI exposure yields smaller positive effects on delayed performance after a gap ≥7 days (β=0.017, std=0.08, N=3,102,944; 44,985 learners) and ≥14 days (robust β=0.012, std=0.06, N=1,884,116; 42,107 learners)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t75_o22","t75_o23"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t75_c9","object":"larger near transfer in higher-difficulty skills; attenuated transfer across larger topic shifts and longer inactivity gaps","predicate":"concludes_transfer_heterogeneity","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 reports heterogeneity in knowledge transfer: near-transfer gains are larger for higher-difficulty skills, topic-shift transfer attenuates with larger topic shifts, and delayed transfer declines as inactivity gaps lengthen."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",44417,49050]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"49c873e3cb8ed3213eaf227c122d8e0a4442bc0623eb9c917d5fa6648b75545f","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["77a9d51843eb77e9619d9e5f54670b936dfed1233144b7d45b45812a00cd7a9e","658ccb9ce27066360deba840b44bb2a3392823ebdd4ffa7ce8a46110b0f00cfc","deed701f61c90c497bc2d480f27a797224e4c061cf28099e83c5a54d4844fb72","64f67c414f0e635c925bb7b6b09902301e93448e8e3af47c03b3d79b54a3b2fb","be2575e89635307e6bbb3e2e3465fe853b261742349586a6b82cfc655efd4a9d","88258b0fd4d93efb96cd52b4df949ce9563aef12aa4d0907cbaf228badb6d55f","f03e685cd815807ebbd57225bd980d47004aadd9294ca77dd400c31a506e73df","0862cb6af2f3cd5079170d6ecb350d6d39eea78ae74629aaa5c3a695367cb477","fa624a719433291deaea89a64d72603fe35a39f8fc26f321174c72ff33082092","6ef05f6703d167135e2aa41ff0118d6dc360fa35229578d099f6636c5f7d344c","6c281a60271ada7c1ff9a9b055508df48ff01415c5b01208512a2af4114006c9","24e922bf573bebc056805cb8498a2fe19170749f0aafcd9ba7ba65d0a8f9b25c","fde1498f74bfb0e031c31efd617bd35b6d94b4f5956422580d8786e7a229e8de","01d73930945211445f69a1c7eb737ebe2668f0179d5b33e41d090b5a94eadcbd","c90f55e78d54b6a04542bd07f72980a3b671bba2d40408415041ceffa6af248d","5c4cdcfea07b9711e1f988b1fcccd38390ee0d5ce8cb109a4f30bdfd9122765b","771d4efdda7f9d06c80a2a6279ec2c8611be87fdc709788659e92f09db627600","c38260ed069947defec6eaacb6bc5793875daa20bd1134dcb23375c45c6bd786","d6e1b9226718f7df51a1438522da66f4de328389a2d7c9adc01b651972af8326","04c07cc09b3964179f02e81ce80023e107a9aaa792a61b4b04f142b427996a35","e6586c0b2fa8036e3052c072ae94a47fbb349d59ee05d88ed0767f38ff56441d","10a98403aea23f8b739f2a2e6d6249ec2ee8daff9e826d4f6464053dbcb410c4","3f27ee5a63486a402ad89e479e808d95825064cd290c9ff951fa836df9389879","9bb94da2abbd816930ce7d39bfb9fea28471ba29be66cb81103e7e41f6912311","feb850dba35ab093791bf9546b3782a18d302e59cb4adf7673796bc3674ce270","95e068ea83c3c569b5eb6fedbba41aefc9bcaaca2ccbaf8888091f209bcba921","e061430e7656edffaea5577dd8b015ce4dfeb7aa45ee4be713a1174e769e6bf8","894922f2bea9e323fc7e9290406a405df039523cb0de2475ed9251841191fc1d","0ee1dc5652aa295e928baf9e8086e733c22526c43a97b41d1648f33672ee206c","0e916c12e3e2743acfb3dede9faf153b891ea8006194d84438e65afaf7d2bd26","4adb2dd592f794f2adaa454fa0382d28a4ace3d767c77f0b154b704b5918d2f0","4cefc38b7325c828bebbf457e3a758320f897a24849ea39f39eda0c0c1332d8b"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"b6fd498d4be6a5f45e55a259885d6f8756526a1eab1aea17526337ed8239c496","submission_id":"TR75-282cee43d6d0fab1#1"},"hash":"3eebec1458e3a811616a9e7c225d92be76b0495acbcd7cbc7635ed4161dad70f","header":{"body_hash":"ef2d00110adfcc293638001348e38247424b6d9e9ee2e5eaeb4709a2e080e78a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"8a2074ac18cce909a42edd471accfbe58bb67af625acfc375ed449608c406711","records_root":"fbbfbaa123af1e848c8a936ed9649c86b238d68f29be70f5c481e4538961419a","seq":360,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"f481a8bbd34460e8eb10712b2e0a1371ba9d4e6d2d32b3e122c03ab4d7799d3b","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":21,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":5,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:PMC13226197.txt#8"},"sync_step":41,"task_id":"TR75-282cee43d6d0fab1"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:PMC13226197.txt#8","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"49c873e3cb8ed3213eaf227c122d8e0a4442bc0623eb9c917d5fa6648b75545f","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"2011dd03704719e88311d04a0344b285c9f3cc98db8f010a8cf32670290a90ac","submission_id":"TR75-282cee43d6d0fab1#done2"},"hash":"6d6f2662fde1c3c3af91923fe4ad94d76a20f441e460842291e0197f4fdb334a","header":{"body_hash":"7c73327a5550c7cd138d58716c4fb7ca2881594d3addb84a2a3f2eba32e6f821","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3eebec1458e3a811616a9e7c225d92be76b0495acbcd7cbc7635ed4161dad70f","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":361,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"10c0504e59e99858ffc7199508366ce5b8818f8558399badd30627f293aa0eac","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR76-078924fea1ca786c","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Total effect (AI → WTC) | 0.226 | 0.031 | 0.198 | 0.320 | ***","kind":"observe","local_id":"t76_o1","terms":["total effect of AI perception on willingness to communicate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Direct effect (AI → WTC) | 0.099 | 0.028 | 0.077 | 0.187 | ***","kind":"observe","local_id":"t76_o2","terms":["direct effect of AI perception on willingness to communicate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Indirect effect (AI → SE → WTC) | 0.127 | 0.015 | 0.099 | 0.157 | ***","kind":"observe","local_id":"t76_o3","terms":["indirect effect of AI perception via self-efficacy on willingness to communicate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Bootstrap sampling was run 5,000 times; CI not containing 0 indicates a significant effect, ***p < 0.001. The overall model predictive power R2 = 0.231.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t76_o4","terms":["bootstrap sampling","model R2"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"This result supports Hypothesis H3: Self-efficacy plays a significant mediating role between AI perception and multimodal L2 WTC, with the indirect effect accounting for 56.19% of the total effect.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t76_o5","terms":["H3 mediation result","self-efficacy","AI perception","multimodal L2 WTC"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"N = 960. The estimators are unstandardized due to the mathematical scaling variations in the product-indicator approach.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t76_o6","terms":["sample size N=960","product-indicator approach"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Self-efficacy has a robust positive predictive effect on multimodal L2 WTC (B = 0.496, p < 0.001)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t76_o7","terms":["self-efficacy main effect on multimodal L2 WTC"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The main effect of foreign language learning anxiety is significant and negative (B = −0.191, p < 0.001), signifying that higher anxiety levels are associated with lower communication willingness.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t76_o8","terms":["foreign language learning anxiety main effect on WTC"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Importantly, the latent interaction term (SE × FLA) exhibited a positive coefficient on WTC (B = 0.129, p = 0.068, 95% CI [−0.010, 0.268]).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t76_o9","terms":["latent interaction SE x FLA on WTC"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The inclusion of the latent interaction term contributed an incremental variance explanation (ΔR2) of approximately 1.1% to multimodal WTC over the main-effects-only model.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t76_o10","terms":["incremental variance explanation of SE x FLA interaction"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Consequently, because this moderation effect does not reach conventional significance levels (p < 0.05), it should be interpreted with caution.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t76_o11","terms":["qualification of moderation effect significance"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"We present this pattern primarily as an exploratory finding that points to a potential emotional buffering tendency within technology-mediated contexts, a dynamic that warrants further empirical replication.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t76_o12","terms":["exploratory emotional buffering finding"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"In conclusion, Hypothesis H4 is partially supported. The results reveal that rather than simply exerting a rigidly negative moderation, foreign language learning anxiety acts as an emotional stressor whose negative impact can be marginally yet effectively buffered by strong self-efficacy.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t76_o13","terms":["H4 partial support","buffering of foreign language learning anxiety by self-efficacy"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t76_o1","t76_o2","t76_o3","t76_o4","t76_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t76_c1","object":"self-efficacy mediates 56.19% of AI perception effect on multimodal L2 WTC (total=0.226, direct=0.099, indirect=0.127, p<0.001, R2=0.231)","predicate":"concludes_mediation_result","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes (supporting H3) that self-efficacy significantly mediates the effect of AI perception on multimodal L2 WTC (total=0.226, direct=0.099, indirect=0.127 or 56.19% of total, p<0.001; R2=0.231, 5,000 bootstraps)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t76_o6","t76_o7","t76_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t76_c2","object":"N=960; SE -> multimodal L2 WTC (B=0.496, p<0.001); FLA -> multimodal L2 WTC (B=-0.191, p<0.001)","predicate":"reports_sem_main_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"In latent interaction SEM (N=960), PMC13388837 reports significant main effects on multimodal L2 WTC for self-efficacy (B=0.496, p<0.001) and foreign language learning anxiety (B=-0.191, p<0.001)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t76_o9","t76_o10","t76_o11","t76_o12","t76_o13"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t76_c3","object":"H4 partially supported; SE x FLA -> WTC (B=0.129, p=0.068, ΔR2≈1.1%) is marginally significant and exploratory","predicate":"qualifies_moderation_result","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes that H4 is partially supported: the SE × FLA latent interaction on multimodal WTC is positive (B=0.129, p=0.068, 95% CI [-0.010, 0.268], ΔR2≈1.1%) but misses p<0.05 and is an exploratory buffering finding."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",38260,44238]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"4c1749e1e9b7c07a80b318ad3cb272625fd1bdecdc99d8d621f44b018d5210f2","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["4e3b186c3e468acb1bc28a0c7153986c8eed9ea306c7ebd8024a910477892853","ecc238e0283576c42839933ce0c44678fc0acf32c9458bd8d736d8171c4f20b7","fa43d8f7b947067e0d4da89ed5ead6e3ec1441669e6933bf0af68d9cb2de0156","000f4d9f367ddd072dfaeb7a3c0e34d7eaeec2e33cb7a0f470b0e0c187efc05f","11edaeca393a2ad5b3a09628b3f3becbb00cfe227dba0830a85f36932408961f","da3b4c8e2ae0f454b33015ae410e5cd919412924d36ca32c9b878e82383c6d71","d4a50a8517fd260859fc1a45ebc5adfa1f553e331d2bb2f18fe5a7529c4ed4e1","1f8d1e0656977a19b1997a96ff282d9dc40ddebe305480472597e2168330b422","4dcf95dcabaca302ae43a666df0b710f543a8a04b318ae0f24451c3247bd8094","43012dbf4f123b6b14f3dee9984d5148c00498f0953fbb1d508c46fce48af3a1","3d027d60c4bddf1f00516ffec3c10287ff5e81e11b81d40653d54ab2eaaec54c","7f3822b26838dd5f87d58dff6d3146d7902237c1cef919bdf78996b90affcddc","fb191d9433737d75c9c38ce030871423d5000e90b1fa24da6877645b31d395cd","68f91d8346a05c1c250ad650107756bed99452cd75ef61bc27aef4c8d6decc0a","a6347f1e40e70d8b1df0acf9aca12dee5d31b6cc628912d9c08a58b579975542","78924ea6a81f41cb3f053d803dd897778df6314803c02054ffbefc673361a68b"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"e8e9ea26a36cde90425faeee889aba2855dfaf75b23ca27dd224abfe498b6efa","submission_id":"TR76-078924fea1ca786c#1"},"hash":"14d27b8ba7c7cf9024765979cc86c7eb764e471d115ccecc46c39721dd35e2c1","header":{"body_hash":"97d69af2daf134e111494988c56fef318ceffffd7b294b10677b1d61832619bd","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"6d6f2662fde1c3c3af91923fe4ad94d76a20f441e460842291e0197f4fdb334a","records_root":"af18114ca89c512f53f57cbf4179e0358b6a676cf7ece0cf147eec4e3bf8c9c3","seq":362,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"f0d22637ec88df972269d41bddcea07e3a05c65977ae8649d04e2e00b791ab05","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":21,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":5,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:PMC13388837.txt#7"},"sync_step":41,"task_id":"TR76-078924fea1ca786c"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:PMC13388837.txt#7","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"4c1749e1e9b7c07a80b318ad3cb272625fd1bdecdc99d8d621f44b018d5210f2","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"b116f6cce33e7e65b0817df6cde18aa2c86507162aa49d12101528d182c96bc4","submission_id":"TR76-078924fea1ca786c#done2"},"hash":"abb118ed4bb27f545b6d23520e67644f9e8448d3f7e73ba0d77c9a5c34400dec","header":{"body_hash":"18fd00057bf4aa9fb239d7cca90df2da4f3e3b087b81307499806fb4e7bc509e","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"14d27b8ba7c7cf9024765979cc86c7eb764e471d115ccecc46c39721dd35e2c1","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":363,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"d9c6c8cfa7a4cc3b640590ec1af3a6879553473db4f8cb0876e2f68a75866240","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR77-bbc8fd7979a55046","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"As likelihood-ratio tests demonstrated that the full three-level model did not yield a statistically significant improvement relative to the corresponding reduced two-level models, the more parsimonious two-level meta-analytic model was adopted.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t77_o1","terms":["two-level meta-analytic model","likelihood-ratio tests"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The 56 effect sizes of GenAI on learning motivation showed heterogeneity: Qmotivation [55] = 866.132, p < 0.001, I2 = 93.7%, Tau2 = 0.515 (see Table 2).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t77_o2","terms":["heterogeneity","learning motivation","56 effect sizes"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"As Hedge's g = 0.764, 95% CI = [0.566, 0.962], 95% PI = [−0.689, 2.217]; z = 7.571, p < 0.001, students using GenAI showed more learning motivation than other students.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t77_o3","terms":["Hedges's g","learning motivation","overall effect"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"However, due to the extremely high heterogeneity, the pooled effect should be interpreted as a positive average effect rather than evidence of a stable effect across all educational contexts.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t77_o4","terms":["high heterogeneity","positive average effect","qualification"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Funnel plot of the 56 effect sizes from 42 studies in the meta-analysis.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t77_o5","terms":["56 effect sizes","42 studies","sample size"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The residuals ranged from −1.3725 to 0.8925, all studentized residuals were below the outlier threshold of 2 (Viechtbauer, 2010), with most values clustered near zero, indicating no extreme deviations from the fitted model.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t77_o6","terms":["studentized residuals","sensitivity analysis","outliers"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"The resulting effect sizes varied between 0.695 and 0.840, remaining well within the 95% confidence interval of the primary analysis (0.566 to 0.962), and all remained statistically significant (p ≤ 0.001).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t77_o7","terms":["leave-one-out sensitivity analysis","robustness"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Egger's regression intercept did not reach statistical significance at the conventional 0.05 level, although the result was close to the threshold, b = 2.727, t(54) = 1.945, p = 0.057 > 0.05.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t77_o8","terms":["publication bias","Egger's regression"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Given the very high heterogeneity and the possibility that study-level characteristics may be confounded, moderator analyses were treated as exploratory.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t77_o9","terms":["moderator analysis","exploratory"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Type of motivation | 1.415 (p = 0.234) |  |  |  |  |  |\n\nExtrinsic motivation |  | 8 | 0.382 | 0.122 | [0.143, 0.621] | 22.130** | 0.684\n\nIntrinsic motivation |  | 36 | 0.549 | 0.070 | [0.412, 0.686] | 154.936*** | 0.774","kind":"observe","local_id":"t77_o10","terms":["type of motivation","extrinsic","intrinsic"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Culture | 7.594** (p = 0.006) |  |  |  |  |  |\n\nCollectivism |  | 49 | 0.815 | 0.118 | [0.585, 1.046] | 769.721*** | 0.938\n\nIndividualism |  | 7 | 0.367 | 0.112 | [0.147, 0.587] | 27.919*** | 0.785","kind":"observe","local_id":"t77_o11","terms":["culture moderator","collectivism","individualism"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Education stage | 13.536** (p = 0.001) |  |  |  |  |  |\n\nPrimary School |  | 4 | 0.311 | 0.119 | [0.077, 0.544] | 1.948 | 0.000\n\nSecondary School |  | 9 | 0.360 | 0.104 | [0.157, 0.563] | 25.810** | 0.690\n\nUniversity |  | 43 | 0.886 | 0.127 | [0.637, 1.136] | 778.346*** | 0.946","kind":"observe","local_id":"t77_o12","terms":["education stage moderator","primary","secondary","university"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"GenAI function | 0.011 (p = 0.916) |  |  |  |  |  |\n\nIntelligent tutoring systems |  | 30 | 0.759 | 0.114 | [0.536, 0.982] | 295.243*** | 0.902\n\nPersonalized learning support |  | 25 | 0.782 | 0.191 | [0.407, 1.157] | 560.917*** | 0.957","kind":"observe","local_id":"t77_o13","terms":["GenAI function moderator","ITS","personalized learning support"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"GenAI device type | 11.913** (p = 0.001) |  |  |  |  |  |\n\nMobile device |  | 15 | 0.782 | 0.120 | [0.545, 1.018] | 68.070*** | 0.794\n\nPersonal computer |  | 19 | 0.303 | 0.068 | [0.169, 0.438] | 47.014*** | 0.617","kind":"observe","local_id":"t77_o14","terms":["GenAI device type moderator","mobile","personal computer"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Moderator variables | QBET | k | g | SE | 95% CI for g | QW | I2","kind":"observe","local_id":"t77_o15","terms":["Table 3 header","moderator variables"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t77_o1","t77_o2","t77_o3","t77_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t77_c1","object":"GenAI increases learning motivation across 56 effect sizes from 42 studies (g=0.764, 95% CI [0.566, 0.962], p<0.001)","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 meta-analyzes 56 effect sizes from 42 studies using a two-level random-effects model, finding a positive overall effect of GenAI on students' learning motivation (Hedges's g=0.764, 95% CI [0.566, 0.962], p<0.001)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t77_o2","t77_o3","t77_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t77_c2","object":"pooled effect on learning motivation is an average rather than stable across contexts due to extreme heterogeneity (I2=93.7%, 95% PI [-0.689, 2.217])","predicate":"qualifies_conclusions","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 qualifies its pooled motivation effect (g=0.764, 95% PI [-0.689, 2.217]) due to extremely high heterogeneity (Q=866.132, I2=93.7%, Tau2=0.515), interpreting it as a positive average rather than a stable effect across contexts."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t77_o6","t77_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t77_c3","object":"main effect is robust with no outliers (rstudent -1.3725 to 0.8925) and leave-one-out g ranging from 0.695 to 0.840","predicate":"reports_sensitivity_analysis","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 confirms the robustness of the overall GenAI effect on learning motivation via studentized residuals (-1.3725 to 0.8925, all <2) and leave-one-out sensitivity analysis (g=0.695 to 0.840, all p<=0.001)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t77_o5","t77_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t77_c4","object":"no clear publication bias (Egger's intercept b=2.727, p=0.057 > 0.05)","predicate":"reports_publication_bias","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 finds no clear statistical evidence of publication bias across the 56 effect sizes from 42 studies, with a symmetrical funnel plot and non-significant Egger's regression intercept (b=2.727, t(54)=1.945, p=0.057)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t77_o9","t77_o11","t77_o15"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t77_c5","object":"significant moderation by culture (QBET=7.594, p=0.006): collectivism g=0.815 vs individualism g=0.367 (exploratory)","predicate":"reports_moderator_effect","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"In exploratory subgroup analyses of learning motivation, PMC13647323 finds significant moderation by culture (QBET=7.594, p=0.006), with larger effects in collectivist (k=49, g=0.815) than individualist cultures (k=7, g=0.367)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t77_o9","t77_o12","t77_o14","t77_o15"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t77_c6","object":"significant moderation by education stage (p=0.001; university g=0.886, secondary g=0.360, primary g=0.311) and device type (p=0.001; mobile g=0.782, PC g=0.303)","predicate":"reports_moderator_effect","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"In exploratory subgroup analyses, PMC13647323 finds significant moderation by education stage (QBET=13.536, p=0.001; university k=43, g=0.886; secondary k=9, g=0.360; primary k=4, g=0.311) and device type (QBET=11.913, p=0.001; mobile g=0.782 vs PC g=0.303)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t77_o9","t77_o10","t77_o13","t77_o15"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t77_c7","object":"non-significant moderation by motivation type (p=0.234) and GenAI function (p=0.916)","predicate":"reports_moderator_effect","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"In exploratory subgroup analyses of learning motivation, PMC13647323 finds no significant moderation by motivation type (QBET=1.415, p=0.234; intrinsic k=36, g=0.549; extrinsic k=8, g=0.382) or GenAI function (QBET=0.011, p=0.916; ITS g=0.759, personalized support g=0.782)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",38833,44772]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"c9babe4551388847616cc6d35afaf473a109456d6f395bc54411bc96602f8ccf","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["554480520ca48ef242e34dc2654304055d32a9ef5427484f277613284e1d49d3","64d391653f35fb59361ff1f69cee1a2857e1903f998c438f2c68d263b812e70e","35b88205f5fc67cb70d364dbfec8ae9b95071d967fdfaf294f70eba877d172ae","147acddf649bdbba41deb8ef2fcef492f5904a06e82b661488809d5519f97ffc","85aba27c1102473debcad113110536e05d91a311f0808005eef98c902b7a651c","02e727fb96c3812c5be01b2031b5e0233901e4d342d5f5690e63fa903a281294","23f60375100b138c9afcb731fa1d7ca65176e871bac47e6e832f5389bb20a654","749e8c3d834fd87db735debfa280be8ddcbaaa666ca31f1fb9a3f76dfb130c00","e5c82db3ddc90e627666fc7839757f0f357057eed82cff55a2f5ae48c74b7d23","382977992d85e547a24531c7fd108d3959ab42f686421a9dd22bae01bb750a69","c4d0809a81da1c71d3c041d83cc0dbf02c4fc04c536cb4374e7c9116fa22ae58","671d6b85c14cea26bab6b998447a4c30c31e3693e8f7f902f0c22d875bfc7627","a6d67db78b1d75f569348626d280dde1b162f33924cbd25ec1faae62bc68def8","cb6a71655ec2237af85c98e4c84357e83902510bff16f20087757e25f0abcdd7","56b61848d15d67b2cf05983fc9d5b56f4ebe45e2139d2a3091b006414b6db6b0","58e53353d75d1eebc86b8b1d700d8f6d2f485c5c0360cd7568eb0bc0fdf7a893","5ad1773049eb86e5b170734075c42dbd377497687cc1c958a1a7b51a365512c9","18057f17e919dfc248c9278ca8fcc13c02f775eee38b12dc7281cf5554ed9c2f","32ee17894cb7aa5eb3f057b6efbb8c47a512d9670cda0d8b1790429aefe683cf","4fc1952e4f4c43300466fb14e12a26a59ce0d2d408b99c8d40e4ee5ffed1f75b"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":20}},"request_hash":"44e1908ce33712385aec2288dfc01180bb0ab91d018faf122dadce39e707ace9","submission_id":"TR77-bbc8fd7979a55046#1"},"hash":"0988ae4e0bad8c1ce7408576faf4a7fec444bdacdd8700619454d554c902036b","header":{"body_hash":"ece7439d035753dfea7deb9ffb35cbca46f26a3467383fc515a80a680b48a91b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"abb118ed4bb27f545b6d23520e67644f9e8448d3f7e73ba0d77c9a5c34400dec","records_root":"eb33c9761874a897dd42a04db78011a9069b1025b376ccc1af61f56f376978b1","seq":364,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"956c57ea8dad1066438e3cafa8ab97885db24aae8893a3934bc4282f0d82adcb","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR77-bbc8fd7979a55046","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t77_o9","t77_o10","t77_o13","t77_o15"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t77_c7","object":"non-significant moderation by motivation type (p=0.234) and GenAI function (p=0.916)","predicate":"reports_moderator_effect","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"In exploratory subgroup analyses of learning motivation, PMC13647323 finds no significant moderation by motivation type (QBET=1.415, p=0.234; intrinsic k=36, g=0.549; extrinsic k=8, g=0.382) or GenAI function (QBET=0.011, p=0.916; ITS g=0.759, personalized support g=0.782)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",38833,44772]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"c9babe4551388847616cc6d35afaf473a109456d6f395bc54411bc96602f8ccf","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":[],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":0}},"request_hash":"7482bd85fcec3234f9658a3115352065be52d0f0e11b90f8064b9de63d83e04f","submission_id":"TR77-bbc8fd7979a55046#1.1"},"hash":"7f0db5dd1f5aa12c51928445a2e1da52356f9206849f1557b2cdd3d58c8d2154","header":{"body_hash":"c62640ff48da9a6b5c71031321df5b1003d8723a8ca4536fcea57e66467395d7","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"0988ae4e0bad8c1ce7408576faf4a7fec444bdacdd8700619454d554c902036b","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":365,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"1e26f9b6841700a20cd9a666b539b070e4fb387b034592e00fd865614047001a","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@554480520ca48ef2","@64d391653f35fb59","@35b88205f5fc67cb","@147acddf649bdbba","@85aba27c1102473d","@02e727fb96c3812c","@23f60375100b138c","@749e8c3d834fd87d","@e5c82db3ddc90e62","@382977992d85e547","@c4d0809a81da1c71","@671d6b85c14cea26","@a6d67db78b1d75f5","@cb6a71655ec2237a","@56b61848d15d67b2","@58e53353d75d1eeb","@5ad1773049eb86e5","@18057f17e919dfc2","@32ee17894cb7aa5e","@4fc1952e4f4c4330"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"REQUEST","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":20,"local_id":"t77_c6"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":21,"local_id":"t77_c7"}],"task_id":"TR77-bbc8fd7979a55046","work_key":"reread:PMC13647323.txt#7"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:TR77-bbc8fd7979a55046:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"c9babe4551388847616cc6d35afaf473a109456d6f395bc54411bc96602f8ccf","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"8921318d2ab4fa725d47c467a0d4def363dad9099c63871ca1cd007116c63e63","submission_id":"TR77-bbc8fd7979a55046#repair1"},"hash":"48fa84e1203efadd947c334989200253e5fc238e7326e3cb16ed77bbe0a98560","header":{"body_hash":"9688fe75f6731abbc2dd82cb2085a5db1c3963c4441d8c941d8599b166556fd2","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"7f0db5dd1f5aa12c51928445a2e1da52356f9206849f1557b2cdd3d58c8d2154","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":366,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"54ae4b0d885b7ed1922e7ab2ab2d942ce1ddb2cbb55f12ea676a6fe4c788c934","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TR78-cc772d01578ce509","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"H2—Behavioral Engagement: The presented positive engagement effects are consistent with those of Wang and Fan (2025), who, in their meta-analysis, noted moderate engagement effects","kind":"observe","local_id":"t78_o1","terms":["H2 Behavioral Engagement","Wang and Fan 2025","positive engagement effects","meta-analysis"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"who, in their meta-analysis, noted moderate engagement effects of use on students’ perceived learning, and with Meyer et al. (2024)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t78_o2","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025","moderate engagement effects","students perceived learning"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"First, we identify within-learner variation in persistence and time on task using causal identification and rule out the possibility that more engaged learners merely used AI support more frequently.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t78_o3","terms":["within-learner variation","persistence","time on task","causal identification"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Second, the negative coefficient of spacing (β=−0.018) implies a subtlety that has not been previously studied, which is that AI exposure is correlated with smaller inter-session breaks","kind":"observe","local_id":"t78_o4","terms":["negative coefficient of spacing","beta=-0.018","smaller inter-session breaks"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"smaller inter-session breaks, which could imply a higher level of motivation but might also indicate discontinuous practice - a phenomenon not actively studied in previous correlation-approach studies.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t78_o5","terms":["higher motivation","discontinuous practice","inter-session breaks"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"H3—Knowledge Transfer: The near-transfer effect (β=0.052) is stronger than topic-shift transfer ( β=0.021 ) and delayed performance ( β=0.017 )","kind":"observe","local_id":"t78_o6","terms":["H3 Knowledge Transfer","near-transfer beta=0.052","topic-shift transfer beta=0.021","delayed performance beta=0.017"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The patterns of heterogeneity have greater effects in greater difficulty bands and reduced effects with increased topic distance and inactivity gaps (Table 5; Figure 6).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t78_o7","terms":["heterogeneity","greater difficulty bands","topic distance","inactivity gaps"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Adaptive regulation can be reflected in increased checking and help-seeking, or in a workflow that consults the system more frequently than in relying on internal checks.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t78_o8","terms":["adaptive regulation","increased checking","help-seeking","system consultation vs internal checks"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"metacognition proxies should be understood as indicators of regulatory activity rather than as direct measures of metacognitive accuracy or calibrated self-knowledge (Table 3; Figure 4).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t78_o9","terms":["metacognition proxies","regulatory activity","metacognitive accuracy","calibrated self-knowledge"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"the transfer gradient manifests even within a single tutoring system, indicating that the boundary between beneficial scaffolding and dependency is not only cross-tool but also within individual interactions.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t78_o10","terms":["transfer gradient","single tutoring system","beneficial scaffolding","dependency"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t78_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t78_c1","object":"near-transfer (β=0.052) exceeds topic-shift transfer (β=0.021) and delayed performance (β=0.017)","predicate":"concludes_transfer_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds a stronger effect of AI tutoring on near-transfer within skill (β=0.052) than on topic-shift transfer (β=0.021) or delayed performance (β=0.017)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t78_o4","t78_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t78_c2","object":"negative spacing effect (β=−0.018), shorter inter-session breaks","predicate":"concludes_engagement_spacing","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds a negative coefficient for inter-session spacing (β=−0.018), indicating AI exposure correlates with shorter inter-session breaks (higher motivation or discontinuous practice)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t78_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t78_c3","object":"larger transfer effects at higher difficulty; smaller effects with increased topic distance and inactivity gaps","predicate":"concludes_heterogeneity","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds heterogeneous transfer effects that are larger in higher item difficulty bands and smaller with greater topic distance and inactivity gaps."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t78_o8","t78_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t78_c4","object":"metacognition proxies reflect regulatory activity (or frequent system consultation), not direct metacognitive accuracy","predicate":"qualifies_outcome_measures","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 qualifies its metacognition proxies (checking and help-seeking) as indicators of regulatory activity rather than direct measures of metacognitive accuracy or calibrated self-knowledge."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t78_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t78_c5","object":"within-learner persistence and time-on-task gains rule out selection by already-engaged learners","predicate":"concludes_engagement_identification","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 identifies within-learner variation in persistence and time on task to rule out reverse causality where more engaged learners simply use AI support more frequently."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t78_o6","t78_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t78_c6","object":"boundary between beneficial scaffolding and dependency manifests within individual interactions in a single tutoring system","predicate":"concludes","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 concludes from the within-system transfer gradient that the boundary between beneficial scaffolding and cognitive dependency occurs within individual tutoring interactions, not just across tools."},{"about":["PMC13226197","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t78_q1","needed":"The exact 'Title: The effect of ChatGPT...' quote from the Wang and Fan 2025 record file (and PMC13226197's reference list entry for Wang and Fan 2025) to complete the q1 claim with t78_o1 and t78_o2.","text":"Link PMC13226197's citation of Wang and Fan 2025 (on moderate engagement effects on students' perceived learning, consistent with H2 behavioral engagement gains) to the Title line quote from the Wang and Fan 2025 record file."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",49050,55050]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"0d13ab04099979176f4189793930ce5c764d9587af6e0d769ee41d2f3509fc73","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["63454d2de8ffe8e69601571eef1e049d5169a3b022e4a6d7bf763c2b3b23a0ef","716dcb6dbe01192a6b146b00be914e012adc088c33b032d05aea44e52321bd91","9edfe3b93905964437a6545610802f4ccb2ef3cd633d7e98af75a114739cdcf6","1090315354a3c10548f1a87dcc74e4f5ad908fc77f8fd277b2821a9c536b9b0d","5ca5aaf31a4cbbe4a0426b6ce62d7303b55f56c172e51803e95c396ddbc3d9cb","fb65a0e58f15bb7076f603244375d04f19d855e15d2f63978316c16a26cb27f6","6c5e14cfd7e837b3eb8aeb4da8ababdb2f320630a52670d746a7850a2eb573fe","25676ee866060887e9b53b4c13cc96dd8859bc1967cbde1766848e40d0147403","49adbc4a639d59298a3d9b75f8632d11a05e02c77e815341a3702e406f1705d1","c9dbecbe8f2d7f192acd7f2128d86bd630c56e79a73dada69c9bbaa25a67d942","3c921453140a0ba6d1fdbbb6207bac9d28169a658c1f51a39ae15b5b8ffcadfd","1a88d7e584971826408b2a7ebd72bd0e5a6256a137b1c4d175a5cee74ff02f62","ffbf1a59e53f8cbf7b54d6f897580cc27d803c661b4ff83d9add191ece6fa6e3","cb2007d9abc444dd266639e09a0c4ee7cf9e8049a823f50a5d0579991d894822","734600c155d395c5ac02dae007ea9773395a958f784c841f4c9413cb13fc0c95","fdfaa9b0fdd5ee855afce0c04425aaf8ff570b7c8cf6c72d2fa0c1c4cafeaa86","c493d13c0c435e08480541a836c1352768dfa736c22b50c77a48114d7c79a146"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"c2bc646deaebe897d71ad84bd93f1ee13c481071434a655e6cb145f4d44f50ca","submission_id":"TR78-cc772d01578ce509#1"},"hash":"ffe47edd33e79fb9d0b8c45ef99c510382f7172c0d1487d0e061b8d0d851f722","header":{"body_hash":"17cf0a7b3261987f102de823771a1910670b67fb6daf88b39e28b81641242f53","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"48fa84e1203efadd947c334989200253e5fc238e7326e3cb16ed77bbe0a98560","records_root":"21f27d5e79c6b236bda87ed73bc2496aaee38bdab62b504efe73dd8d264791ce","seq":367,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"bd9406f5ae41164cd99c0853fd99d00ffef358070d1a04d94becfd824c29f7df","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":21,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":5,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:PMC13226197.txt#9"},"sync_step":41,"task_id":"TR78-cc772d01578ce509"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:PMC13226197.txt#9","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"0d13ab04099979176f4189793930ce5c764d9587af6e0d769ee41d2f3509fc73","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"68c2de713a8950bdc56aa66e1facef8a37a5ed79b7c0998ae297dc8c10014e9d","submission_id":"TR78-cc772d01578ce509#done2"},"hash":"0ab4cef244052cd4463b836ad0dbf23e3f4e9d4364f197730394494112903c09","header":{"body_hash":"645a157d4449ad08b1e07509f7069264e54551939220ae6cb0796d253ccabff9","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ffe47edd33e79fb9d0b8c45ef99c510382f7172c0d1487d0e061b8d0d851f722","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":368,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"a249c87208ad8982630b59fb1353ced023bed8c354f5c3a902c163848ada177b","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR79-1f0f7e4d8dc88d01","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"to examine the potential group heterogeneity across English proficiency levels (H5), this study conducted a structured multi-group SEM analysis.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t79_o1","terms":["multi-group SEM analysis","English proficiency levels","H5"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The configural model, which allowed factor loadings to be freely estimated across groups, yielded an excellent fit (χ2/df <2.50, CFI = 0.998, RMSEA = 0.021).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t79_o2","terms":["configural invariance fit","CFI 0.998","RMSEA 0.021"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The subsequent metric invariance model, where factor loadings were constrained to be equal across the four English level groups, also demonstrated high stability (ΔCFI < 0.001).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t79_o3","terms":["metric invariance stability","four English level groups","ΔCFI < 0.001"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"As presented in Table 7, the positive path association from AI perception to self-efficacy remained statistically significant across all proficiency groups","kind":"observe","local_id":"t79_o4","terms":["AI perception to self-efficacy path","statistically significant across groups"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"English level group | Sample size (N) | Path estimate (B) | S.E. | C.R. (z-value) | p value","kind":"observe","local_id":"t79_o5","terms":["Table 7 header","sample sizes and path estimates"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Group 1: beginner (below CET-4) | 144 | 0.312 | 0.090 | 3.467 | 0.001","kind":"observe","local_id":"t79_o6","terms":["Group 1 beginner below CET-4","N=144","B=0.312"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Group 2: CET-4 level | 413 | 0.479 | 0.078 | 6.141 | <0.001","kind":"observe","local_id":"t79_o7","terms":["Group 2 CET-4 level","N=413","B=0.479"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Group 3: CET-6 level | 303 | 0.326 | 0.066 | 4.939 | <0.001","kind":"observe","local_id":"t79_o8","terms":["Group 3 CET-6 level","N=303","B=0.326"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Group 4: high cert. level | 100 | 0.326 | 0.106 | 3.075 | 0.002","kind":"observe","local_id":"t79_o9","terms":["Group 4 high cert. level","N=100","B=0.326"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Because specific structural path constraint tests (i.e., chi-square difference tests for constrained vs. unconstrained models) were not performed, we refrain from claiming magnitude differences across proficiency levels.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t79_o10","terms":["path constraint tests not performed","refrain from claiming magnitude differences"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"In this sense, H5 received preliminary empirical support regarding the model’s generalizability rather than comparative differentiation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t79_o11","terms":["H5 preliminary empirical support","model generalizability"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"To provide textual triangulation for the quantitative data, this study employed a thematic analysis method to encode and summarize the open-ended data as shown in Table 8.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t79_o12","terms":["thematic analysis","open-ended data","textual triangulation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Regarding the process of AI-assisted foreign language learning, subjects mainly focused on “Functional support and efficiency.” Among these, “Emotional safety (low pressure),” mentioned 165 times","kind":"observe","local_id":"t79_o13","terms":["Functional support and efficiency","Emotional safety 165 mentions"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Functional support and efficiency | 241 | “AI helped tremendously in academic English reading, summarizing literature structures for me, greatly easing reading pressure.”","kind":"observe","local_id":"t79_o15","terms":["Functional support and efficiency frequency 241"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The current data indicate that intelligent environment perception shares a significant positive association with multimodal L2 WTC (Deng et al., 2024).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t79_o16","terms":["intelligent environment perception","multimodal L2 WTC","positive association"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t79_o4","t79_o5","t79_o6","t79_o7","t79_o8","t79_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t79_c2","object":"AI perception to self-efficacy positive across all proficiency levels (B=0.312 to 0.479, p<=0.002)","predicate":"reports_multigroup_path_estimates","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 finds positive, statistically significant path estimates from AI perception to self-efficacy across all four English proficiency levels: beginner (B=0.312, N=144), CET-4 (B=0.479, N=413), CET-6 (B=0.326, N=303), and high cert. (B=0.326, N=100)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t79_o1","t79_o10","t79_o11"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t79_c3","object":"no magnitude differences claimed across proficiency groups due to omitted structural path constraint tests; H5 supported for generalizability only","predicate":"qualifies_multigroup_comparison","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 refrains from claiming magnitude differences in the AI perception to self-efficacy path across English proficiency levels because structural path constraint (chi-square difference) tests were not performed, supporting generalizability for H5."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t79_o16"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t79_c5","object":"significant positive association between intelligent environment perception and multimodal L2 WTC","predicate":"concludes_association","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes from its data that intelligent environment perception has a significant positive association with multimodal L2 willingness to communicate (WTC)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",44238,49877]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"70c6af90e0ebde735e0eb3507c177d901d9c2119ab8abf8f3d0cb0ccbdcc827d","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["dc74ff7604fb80078fac30863a8a99703150dc483095b58741ef6791587f1938","1affb03d5b162039b26465ec2263c6616cb7257452d238c97f85c11163c698ca","bc8cd0793e35c1b599cddce159e44376507f98045ef75c5f79d154110d49b339","70290c419de11fc5e1dbf5d579941a85daf81c9d6b8f91fdd81e03134ae0a115","92c466df5942a1f2627b2fc2dcecce3ff5f9cdb9cacba3efc42139ce7a5e752d","84cac9776eb975832f489fe0d0152c29346d428f859c93f7d752baf7e0a4a814","bca7cb26e1893c4e653503294f96bef4be9aef373e5344759bbeb1837355e26d","35d9b5e9527634a7d2845cfb8a80a23445765894e1539016cd2021e3505984b5","55efe756a005e7301320a358cdff10103f00412d097421089202e0a0b215e73a","604027276cb0fc778cf8db6aead436a80a76ed5955c976b9ea71a4c2040eb14e","98e0f10a16b604d056acfb9ed6b0957b943470ab25b48f3188a63139c1fef1d2","ca3896fcfbc3b8739047ad969180dec49ccadaa425a8ebbdbc375024eb42f398","2a81afe6d597c2b73e9767539638b50b344c968012e8f5702b9212439943625d","e4c69e0a77b3f28966c97b185a37e1c2f288ee54a5be03f1ff39204caaf29407","0f05e473863fdfc0107e6d37444151e35c4e9da394dd40fa3bae47dda10a14a0"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":15}},"request_hash":"503d51b6e625f6ff420bd9a2142c71962572f48085d57c05a8ce40c48e7938ed","submission_id":"TR79-1f0f7e4d8dc88d01#1"},"hash":"d18c642e89de4d390b96cd30915d37ad18eaae665ba5aecb76bfface2191201e","header":{"body_hash":"7fefe0f7d295357dd3c13d104ae50def98cfdfcd96d5394fa3cabbd3f4461295","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"0ab4cef244052cd4463b836ad0dbf23e3f4e9d4364f197730394494112903c09","records_root":"9515fd86a17f6f726b5941241b5ef7f4ccfd97ef4ede64693ee8687222ccc856","seq":369,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"0e1896b9b6b5c124e955364eb61beeaecbda8d8aaa578ea989a1ae378ff8cb47","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR79-1f0f7e4d8dc88d01","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t79_o1","t79_o10","t79_o11"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t79_c3","object":"no magnitude differences claimed across proficiency groups due to omitted structural path constraint tests; H5 supported for generalizability only","predicate":"qualifies_multigroup_comparison","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 refrains from claiming magnitude differences in the AI perception to self-efficacy path across English proficiency levels because structural path constraint (chi-square difference) tests were not performed, supporting generalizability for H5."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t79_o16"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t79_c5","object":"significant positive association between intelligent environment perception and multimodal L2 WTC","predicate":"concludes_association","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes from its data that intelligent environment perception has a significant positive association with multimodal L2 willingness to communicate (WTC)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",44238,49877]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"70c6af90e0ebde735e0eb3507c177d901d9c2119ab8abf8f3d0cb0ccbdcc827d","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":[],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":0}},"request_hash":"ed408c4d1b1260367f5bf3e039a5674f5b5c83725a428bde291519d18c131b54","submission_id":"TR79-1f0f7e4d8dc88d01#1.1"},"hash":"3420764a8e81df152ba221b4f380c74ecda99fa1dd5f801dd4918f692b72822c","header":{"body_hash":"d0d8258fafd9a36bd9cbd1752583a55c3ab37463e43835a565a8247ad6bb6b73","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"d18c642e89de4d390b96cd30915d37ad18eaae665ba5aecb76bfface2191201e","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":370,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"83857a2fe66b1b5c1760bbdb644a1ca3bf2174e3dacdccd1adfac143ffb2772d","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR79-1f0f7e4d8dc88d01","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t79_o16"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t79_c5","object":"significant positive association between intelligent environment perception and multimodal L2 WTC","predicate":"concludes_association","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes from its data that intelligent environment perception has a significant positive association with multimodal L2 willingness to communicate (WTC)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",44238,49877]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"70c6af90e0ebde735e0eb3507c177d901d9c2119ab8abf8f3d0cb0ccbdcc827d","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["39e2a661ffd0617c8b4542e64087a746f72c4c73449a44c6a17e5ec4c39e58ec"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"b98e0d27eed51fd4eb6f6a944a8f578d9948284dd1816c570d3e8068deb6a07b","submission_id":"TR79-1f0f7e4d8dc88d01#1.2"},"hash":"991a6860f62f024bb951dd6c105d82f469de021af51aa102574862a6a9bf58dd","header":{"body_hash":"aaf0e73c3cba6fa42f428010d4bfd7027e91dd4d2b9c057b38a514adcb70e3d9","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3420764a8e81df152ba221b4f380c74ecda99fa1dd5f801dd4918f692b72822c","records_root":"d056f3ac4d831e7ef99edfa178ddc3226f644987237e2f5863ea03ea372152bc","seq":371,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"7544d7ce05e45b7edd11d795c4c8179362e8d60ad63c356e5a51e1eec22c1bc9","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@dc74ff7604fb8007","@1affb03d5b162039","@bc8cd0793e35c1b5","@70290c419de11fc5","@92c466df5942a1f2","@84cac9776eb97583","@bca7cb26e1893c4e","@35d9b5e9527634a7","@55efe756a005e730","@604027276cb0fc77","@98e0f10a16b604d0","@ca3896fcfbc3b873","@2a81afe6d597c2b7","@e4c69e0a77b3f289","@0f05e473863fdfc0","@39e2a661ffd0617c"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[{"index":19,"local_id":"t79_c4","rests_on":"t79_o14"}],"kind":"REQUEST","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"negation_before":"“Because there’s no need to worry about real human social judgments, dialoguing with AI vastly lowers the cost of trial and error.”","rule":"negation_before"},"field":"exact_quote","message":"a quote keeps the clause it belongs to: quote from the start of the sentence when it negates what follows, and to the end of the clause when the quote ends on a word like 'from' or 'with'","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":13,"local_id":"t79_o14"},{"error":{"code":"NO_EVIDENCE","expected_by_kernel":{"missing_identifiers":["1.77"]},"field":"based_on","message":"a claim names only identifiers its quotes hold: add a quote of this section that holds each one listed, or leave it out of the claim","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":16,"local_id":"t79_c1"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":17,"local_id":"t79_c2"},{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":18,"local_id":"t79_c3"}],"task_id":"TR79-1f0f7e4d8dc88d01","work_key":"reread:PMC13388837.txt#8"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:TR79-1f0f7e4d8dc88d01:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"70c6af90e0ebde735e0eb3507c177d901d9c2119ab8abf8f3d0cb0ccbdcc827d","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"efef85155d815334e84ad97179af2d8682ee7f9ab6b02b947af6f3d10e0b8215","submission_id":"TR79-1f0f7e4d8dc88d01#repair1"},"hash":"2fd2413dadafa51619aa8093929f1f3e1d9f87a739b310eb6335a81a4bf03dbf","header":{"body_hash":"e30da6f3fe870e4f456f6a2927593f100b5a1e692b8755d38c77fd4d8f21b8e0","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"991a6860f62f024bb951dd6c105d82f469de021af51aa102574862a6a9bf58dd","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":372,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"0ceac8e4105df5aa1bb793a54d14cb12b60ed5334d07d3fa566b8cdee6c49a6f","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR77-bbc8fd7979a55046","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t77_o9","t77_o12","t77_o14","t77_o15"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t77_c6","object":"significant moderation by education stage (p=0.001; university g=0.886, secondary g=0.360, primary g=0.311) and device type (p=0.001; mobile g=0.782, PC g=0.303)","predicate":"reports_moderator_effect","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"In exploratory subgroup analyses, PMC13647323 finds significant moderation by education stage (p=0.001; university g=0.886, secondary g=0.360, primary g=0.311) and device type (p=0.001; mobile g=0.782 vs PC g=0.303)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t77_o9","t77_o10","t77_o13","t77_o15"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t77_c7","object":"non-significant moderation by motivation type (p=0.234) and GenAI function (p=0.916)","predicate":"reports_moderator_effect","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"In exploratory subgroup analyses, PMC13647323 finds no significant moderation by motivation type (p=0.234; intrinsic g=0.549, extrinsic g=0.382) or GenAI function (p=0.916; ITS g=0.759, personalized support g=0.782)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",38833,44772]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"70c6af90e0ebde735e0eb3507c177d901d9c2119ab8abf8f3d0cb0ccbdcc827d","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["4958611bcf02b76a9077f6f157f2963113b03baeac9840074302822bca9921ea","1836446d82a9a0ea5da009c7fea40f8ef58c684ef45ad7a7870a8840c98bc0f2"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"37c8181685fa88ed643e4abbbb51bc810205dca8aea81f622788d5d534bbaad8","submission_id":"TR77-bbc8fd7979a55046#2"},"hash":"e81479867c54ea28ec48f622109c69a3adf60c25ff7c8f6a62e0e7fd4f73437d","header":{"body_hash":"52807c2f8c97cf3da450c80eaaef429a3a16e6b72a697f6757c8cd52a2df748b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"2fd2413dadafa51619aa8093929f1f3e1d9f87a739b310eb6335a81a4bf03dbf","records_root":"d28737fc46fb474cc9c9b80c0f0dca2e179cea007f5e9001033c4f703f5207b1","seq":373,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"693cbdefb99c458192c7cb34e8f7fecbedb0cf2290df5102385d60891334ee85","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":21,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":5,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:PMC13647323.txt#7"},"sync_step":41,"task_id":"TR77-bbc8fd7979a55046"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:PMC13647323.txt#7","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"70c6af90e0ebde735e0eb3507c177d901d9c2119ab8abf8f3d0cb0ccbdcc827d","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"e37574ab99cf17574e3239be95bcaae594098f8b28dcc62262e58ba39881a47e","submission_id":"TR77-bbc8fd7979a55046#done3"},"hash":"a0454cc300ef4490cd4c9badc2385553bed907a5e6d6f455d3f90e5e12e3dc69","header":{"body_hash":"ebc935d715a58069f2621c1d53f5c585e7641a70d473737b361d34d93941117c","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"e81479867c54ea28ec48f622109c69a3adf60c25ff7c8f6a62e0e7fd4f73437d","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":374,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"7c3a0943f5755a09fcb09003271f25aa42f06dca6ad0b6dfcd0670ba4ab74dbd","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR79-1f0f7e4d8dc88d01","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Cognitive/dependency risks | 180 | “It sure is fast to one-click translate complex sentences, but I feel myself increasingly dependent on it. I’m actually more confused when it comes to independent thinking.”","kind":"observe","local_id":"t79_o14","terms":["Cognitive/dependency risks frequency 180"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Lack of real interaction | 81 | “Lacks the contextual pressure of real scenarios. That kind of tension when talking to a real human is something machines cannot simulate; I’d still get stage fright running into foreigners.”","kind":"observe","local_id":"t79_o17","terms":["Lack of real interaction frequency 81"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t79_o1","t79_o2","t79_o3","t79_o5","t79_o6","t79_o7","t79_o8","t79_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t79_c1","object":"configural (CFI=0.998, RMSEA=0.021) and metric (ΔCFI<0.001) invariance across four English proficiency groups (N=144, 413, 303, 100)","predicate":"establishes_measurement_invariance","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 establishes configural (χ2/df<2.50, CFI=0.998, RMSEA=0.021) and metric (ΔCFI<0.001) measurement invariance across four English proficiency groups (total N=960) in a multi-group SEM analysis."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t79_o4","t79_o5","t79_o6","t79_o7","t79_o8","t79_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t79_c2","object":"AI perception to self-efficacy positive across all proficiency levels (B=0.312 to 0.479, p<=0.002)","predicate":"reports_multigroup_path_estimates","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 finds positive path estimates from AI perception to self-efficacy across all four English proficiency groups: beginner (B=0.312, N=144), CET-4 (B=0.479, N=413), CET-6 (B=0.326, N=303), and high cert. (B=0.326, N=100; p<=0.002)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t79_o1","t79_o10","t79_o11"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t79_c3","object":"no magnitude differences claimed across proficiency groups due to omitted structural path constraint tests; H5 supported for generalizability only","predicate":"qualifies_multigroup_comparison","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 refrains from claiming magnitude differences in the AI perception to self-efficacy path across proficiency levels because structural path constraint tests were not performed, supporting H5 regarding generalizability only."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t79_o12","t79_o13","t79_o14","t79_o15","t79_o17"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t79_c4","object":"functional support/efficiency (241), cognitive/dependency risks (180), emotional safety (165), lack of real interaction (81)","predicate":"reports_qualitative_themes","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"In thematic analysis of open-ended feedback on AI-assisted foreign language learning, PMC13388837 reports frequencies for functional support and efficiency (241), cognitive/dependency risks (180), emotional safety (165), and lack of real interaction (81)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",44238,49877]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"bc477cf24ae29297d5725b2f8725b4e88c67732bc457f252e31f861c557e28fc","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["db913441da3784e721d7efa4c11782539543916b611bfeb392a49b4d66112bb0","a2bf50a29977180446517596bf81c05c2050c93c89d1e3f8dd8eb60c764d49ae","98155d965f6c4d9d2eccb6149dfc68e9c64a1171f732dd77f6825f0bbe8757f6","46ab14d0f6a0e59f3e40d1d2b1a4f28bc44f4de9f72911e3a2c7f7dac27c1357","9d54762b3eb7aaa6ac724f65b077f4457db42bb6fa267d50d83a5b1c0374659c"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":5}},"request_hash":"c541bf020151456f9e955de1411e2437496d8527126cdc5a9a58fbc3e30470d9","submission_id":"TR79-1f0f7e4d8dc88d01#2"},"hash":"f92391122d558a5b4e7cff986572c627493eab65ad41e0bf9c914a6da4469703","header":{"body_hash":"13e6c13c9be37448f5a7239acbfd6fa7e0f1a98856ae09c035ed1e972f8c4b18","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"a0454cc300ef4490cd4c9badc2385553bed907a5e6d6f455d3f90e5e12e3dc69","records_root":"ab6ae76377adf9b8019d2d072f151c6d8325204d91f049dda4f62bcdce5b4539","seq":375,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"2e974326e54dddb1c9cc2209e63038d8ab981418afbb75fd82c9b60de2d38756","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@db913441da3784e7","@a2bf50a299771804","@98155d965f6c4d9d","@46ab14d0f6a0e59f","@9d54762b3eb7aaa6"],"attempt":2,"excluded":[],"kind":"REQUEST","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":5,"local_id":"t79_c4"}],"task_id":"TR79-1f0f7e4d8dc88d01","work_key":"reread:PMC13388837.txt#8"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:TR79-1f0f7e4d8dc88d01:2","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"bc477cf24ae29297d5725b2f8725b4e88c67732bc457f252e31f861c557e28fc","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"93dfb247a00bf7fd0c58850359c1a313789259c6ddb98de8189f87800fe7089c","submission_id":"TR79-1f0f7e4d8dc88d01#repair2"},"hash":"b6cc9cc287110655f08b2e9ccfd5de1611230847847702d80d97beab6f3a6ef0","header":{"body_hash":"2f5d11d328386e9d8828637788510dd758915d6ae0559b292fe530cced66baa0","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"f92391122d558a5b4e7cff986572c627493eab65ad41e0bf9c914a6da4469703","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":376,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"d5b7ba7aa0d0cf96d27af18d882b971b148d28799d55b165f07405ebc47f8b2f","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR80-158a9c628232504a","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Wang J., Fan W. (2025). The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis. Humanit. Soc. Sci. Commun. 12:621.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t80_o1","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025 reference entry in PMC13647323"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"doi: 10.1057/s41599-025-04787-y","kind":"observe","local_id":"t80_o2","terms":["DOI of Wang and Fan 2025 in PMC13647323 reference list"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Viechtbauer W. (2010). Conducting meta-analyses in R with the metafor package. J. Stat. Softw. 36, 1–48. doi: 10.18637/jss.v036.i03","kind":"observe","local_id":"t80_o3","terms":["metafor R package reference in PMC13647323"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Sun L., Zhou L. (2024). Does generative artificial intelligence improve the academic achievement of college students? A meta-analysis. J. Educ. Comput. Res. 62, 1676–1713.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t80_o4","terms":["Sun and Zhou 2024 meta-analysis reference in PMC13647323"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Zhao Y., Yue Y., Sun Z., Jiang Q., Li G. (2025). Does generative artificial intelligence improve students' higher-order thinking? A meta-analysis based on 29 experiments and quasi-experiments.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t80_o5","terms":["Zhao et al. 2025 meta-analysis reference in PMC13647323"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Zhu Y., Liu Q., Zhao L. (2025). Exploring the impact of generative artificial intelligence on students' learning outcomes: a meta-analysis. Educ. Inf. Technol. 30, 16211–16239.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t80_o6","terms":["Zhu et al. 2025 meta-analysis reference in PMC13647323"]},{"about":["PMC13647323.txt","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t80_q1","needed":"Check earlier sections of PMC13647323.txt for in-text or table citations to Wang & Fan (2025) and pair with the Title line observe from the meta-analysis record file.","text":"Which statements, findings, effect sizes, or table rows in the body of PMC13647323 cite Wang and Fan (2025), and what is the Title line quote from the meta-analysis record file needed to link them?"},{"about":["PMC13647323.txt"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t80_q2","needed":"Check the abstract, methods, results, and discussion sections of PMC13647323.txt.","text":"What are the main conclusions, measured outcomes, and underlying studies or datasets of PMC13647323, and which references from this bibliography section are included as primary studies vs. background literature?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",95378,101130]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"c39ab4e3cbea1308aaa4177b6b81ed72aaf1db02924f422e90e371bc39ba3e98","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["7b6213221885978607edf632ebfb79c5b2adbc3cd778735d9319239043840250","b07611c80101af0a513ddfd900641faefd462359c79b16b10ece54a342df26a7","7410c69f5a5a59e8f11f012f71bfd114093993ddad3d6448f0021e562eb572a8","f2669e934e76efeafbbc704d53f184afd87a1b80eefd769d56b15145b1a39154","3feaeafef027fe0b4176dedee059bdbc2dd5120ef91529bd5921754fb535a78e","afc3fa749d824d5501d01bfd2902be84ba79b73a7bdd2b3bbd1c700713c6db43","06c9faa30efc25ca7cec75ff242978f19c8ab3443cf3ce5f1193f89ee0cb74d8","43e347cb68d6d2b816a88abd80dd160688b085e21d61e10a81474104f92a909a"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"a135986a9d127c13330a6fa2f2857eef5c5450be90a0f776230bb38fa2550872","submission_id":"TR80-158a9c628232504a#1"},"hash":"3d25491f04d576ae047f47007779aaf6c515ed219b1433827eb7b0be8223fe6e","header":{"body_hash":"7bb706820208f701fc5e4003c448d23e67cb05f768f567027b82b4f34db0e523","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"b6cc9cc287110655f08b2e9ccfd5de1611230847847702d80d97beab6f3a6ef0","records_root":"20330fef16ba7cb5c729de99f9c0b116642f68965e276a7a69524ced01ac9cb9","seq":377,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"30df1da80238778fca6493f17754e50068d2c0e2fa41daec940e6865ec3273cc","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":21,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":5,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:PMC13647323.txt#17"},"sync_step":41,"task_id":"TR80-158a9c628232504a"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:PMC13647323.txt#17","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"c39ab4e3cbea1308aaa4177b6b81ed72aaf1db02924f422e90e371bc39ba3e98","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"007e65f3a5e089811b04dbf9123fe0580185cc2c51be1842e52745bc24b26b12","submission_id":"TR80-158a9c628232504a#done2"},"hash":"f397c22845caa8bd626cf0807e3e3d2fb32104db708f72fa46e8dc106d674b7c","header":{"body_hash":"a98178d08a5cd8c72b8f50019380a7bd5e94836a9bdfaf6b86c4a381897e5cf8","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3d25491f04d576ae047f47007779aaf6c515ed219b1433827eb7b0be8223fe6e","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":378,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"43e3efb091c501a7d1cec7df8644efbbcec8b7769ef91dbb49b783600ad99e91","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR81-4c00520dcc54512e","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Through a cross-sectional mixed-methods study involving 960 college students, this research elucidated the structural relationships surrounding L2 willingness to communicate (WTC) within intelligent learning environments.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t81_o1","terms":["study design","960 college students","L2 willingness to communicate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Survey data indicate that learners’ perception of AI not only positively correlates with their overall WTC and exerts comparable predictive strength across both receptive (listening/reading) and productive (speaking/writing) modalities.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t81_o2","terms":["AI perception","overall WTC","receptive and productive modalities"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Within this structural path, L2 self-efficacy served as an important indirect link. The latent moderation analysis further revealed that foreign language anxiety was significantly and negatively associated with multimodal WTC.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t81_o3","terms":["L2 self-efficacy indirect link","foreign language anxiety","multimodal WTC"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Importantly, the interaction between self-efficacy and anxiety presented a marginally significant buffering tendency (p = 0.068), functioning as an exploratory pattern requiring future validation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t81_o4","terms":["self-efficacy and anxiety interaction","buffering tendency p = 0.068"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The path coefficients between AI perception and self-efficacy remained consistently positive and statistically significant across all proficiency levels—from beginners to advanced credential holders.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t81_o5","terms":["AI perception to self-efficacy path","proficiency levels","cross-group stability"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Because rigorous chi-square difference constraints were not applied, we avoid claiming comparative magnitude differences among these clusters.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t81_o6","terms":["no chi-square difference constraints","qualification on magnitude differences"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Supporting these structural patterns, qualitative feedback corroborated the quantitative data, highlighting AI’s role as a “psychological safety buffer” while also delineating the practical boundaries between virtual AI assistance and authentic interpersonal communication.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t81_o7","terms":["qualitative feedback","psychological safety buffer","interpersonal communication boundaries"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Regarding the psychometric modeling and data sources, the current study relied entirely on self-reported survey data.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t81_o8","terms":["self-reported survey data","data sources","study limitation"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Second, in the CFA model, some item residuals were correlated based on Modification Indices. While theoretically justified within the same latent constructs (Byrne, 2016), this hints that certain scale items possess semantic overlap.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t81_o9","terms":["CFA correlated item residuals","Modification Indices","semantic overlap"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t81_o1","t81_o2","t81_o3","t81_o7","t81_o8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t81_c1","object":"cross-sectional mixed-methods study of 960 college students (self-reported survey and qualitative feedback) measuring AI perception, L2 self-efficacy, anxiety, and multimodal WTC","predicate":"rests_on_data_and_measures","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 rests on a cross-sectional mixed-methods study of 960 college students relying on self-reported survey data and qualitative feedback to measure AI perception, L2 self-efficacy, foreign language anxiety, and multimodal L2 WTC."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t81_o1","t81_o2","t81_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t81_c2","object":"AI perception positively correlates with overall L2 WTC across receptive and productive modalities, linked indirectly via L2 self-efficacy","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes that AI perception positively correlates with overall L2 WTC with comparable predictive strength across receptive and productive modalities, with L2 self-efficacy serving as an indirect link."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t81_o3","t81_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t81_c3","object":"negative association of foreign language anxiety with multimodal WTC and exploratory buffering interaction with self-efficacy (p=0.068)","predicate":"concludes_moderation_results","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes that foreign language anxiety is significantly negatively associated with multimodal WTC, while the self-efficacy × anxiety interaction shows only a marginally significant buffering tendency (p=0.068)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t81_o5","t81_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t81_c4","object":"consistently positive and significant AI perception to self-efficacy paths across proficiency levels without claiming comparative magnitude differences","predicate":"concludes_subgroup_stability","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes that path coefficients from AI perception to self-efficacy remain positive and significant across all English proficiency levels, while avoiding comparative magnitude claims due to unapplied chi-square constraints."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t81_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t81_c5","object":"AI serves as a psychological safety buffer with practical boundaries vs. authentic interpersonal communication","predicate":"concludes_qualitative_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes from qualitative feedback that AI acts as a psychological safety buffer while delineating practical boundaries between virtual AI assistance and authentic interpersonal communication."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t81_o8","t81_o9"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t81_c6","object":"reliance on self-reported survey data and post-hoc correlated item residuals in CFA model","predicate":"qualifies_methodology","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 qualifies its psychometric modeling by noting reliance entirely on self-reported survey data and post-hoc correlated item residuals in the CFA model indicating potential semantic overlap."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",55079,60528]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"355bce4ef2ffa61e9eb18a46d2b90b8e2493c40ad39f064039fe5d320e0724c1","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["5a57dc1264b855d564dcc45885f028c658592462c2be0cc21fbea087a74c9021","fed6a8f02d6e34788fb7d88ab27eee97907a9de6232d376c03df8269f81398b3","f3180d80d76d45f6bfbc78e15d522ff22d10f6c507dd523fbb1581f53f3433e9","37225623a07f84758a31399f8f7714e028d00b45e9c7d17b1bfecc8edb420c32","0d583e56e0fbbd8de9d859c8d654a1817ab5c1c75a04147829bc837cb5463316","40f0208282df25bdc823f62246b8616af8797b6f1a1edde2b01c16f2fa7e5eb8","f7da3485e196bf89367bb50efc0c0969ef50598c43069268778f4910d721cd35","d4aa80e0cb6abbcb672c659f20ee860bc0d2c67ca42f2f2fc4995153b7062900","2bc696c244fb9ede13ac3893108e645e17f5270225ab4d135c27c480e9bb52d6","dea42dbfe1349c8828cdf8fa6924bcbd0cb138a6632159cc1d729ff5a9a9b150","31d11170f9f491eadcecdca54a5c202d379c94bc5c1a74ab74b84edff6b238c7","b09808c37e425a8df8f77f56ec8b398b92037b5e326e9639edff3ae0a71d844f","01ef92f6224d33b47fd72f3de56e28de4e896ce0fa647881bdc5d9074ada78aa","84553d7e072480d710af7bdafa6333b19a03f6adeb1b6230438570a1a5afe0df","74ad5d783634487529379d381bc1fd8f2450fc5fa0c53602f8ebe402702c270f"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"711afc2c6639f1de2f407c378aefea514b44d293d467e64b28c22e3d70efeffd","submission_id":"TR81-4c00520dcc54512e#1"},"hash":"fe88d59899e00a539772c1abbc5f6698295dab8398eae9fbd1bc8cf6d322f657","header":{"body_hash":"1ca0c812b96b92b60fa33b7413f1928bd8f8ed093487d991810c2ed91366fc41","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"f397c22845caa8bd626cf0807e3e3d2fb32104db708f72fa46e8dc106d674b7c","records_root":"71c174eb647273b311bbe553b5b153113a6d1fb8eee32fe31af94ed27143c08d","seq":379,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"f0e95fa75c9e926ce2adb46b1df4cee7dc80b5785f636332ffa850e597d43e1c","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":21,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":5,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:PMC13388837.txt#10"},"sync_step":41,"task_id":"TR81-4c00520dcc54512e"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:PMC13388837.txt#10","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"355bce4ef2ffa61e9eb18a46d2b90b8e2493c40ad39f064039fe5d320e0724c1","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"81c976e64e468c34a815adb69074a3632ef07026476783a09ed871ed5a20d5d6","submission_id":"TR81-4c00520dcc54512e#done2"},"hash":"4fc706e8cbbf7431baf20c1a7aa4b30f685271732717ed0e9ffdd85b8dc9f9d3","header":{"body_hash":"e8bf8b0ad61e49d9329633726160c714d217157d2ba8b45afcc78b1f0aab5a28","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"fe88d59899e00a539772c1abbc5f6698295dab8398eae9fbd1bc8cf6d322f657","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":380,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"d63c08a89c0a4085e2d614b73bea7aeb668be825f14a137b5280af0c49ffb5bf","command":{"allowed_records":["1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","7b3676fd9e3847d716ba5a6f136252f29e0c1e1128f4e143fdeeb9a1d5c95cc9","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e3af97ee9279b79ecb53b27edaa0b455cbb1d378a0b6ea789e9fc154f79e3168","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e"],"directive":"TR82-2d4be9ea23713daa","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Model | χ 2 | df | χ2/df | CFI | RMSEA | ΔCFI","kind":"observe","local_id":"t82_o1","terms":["measurement invariance table header","fit indices"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Configural invariance | 184.32 | 104 | 1.77 | 0.998 | 0.021 | —","kind":"observe","local_id":"t82_o2","terms":["configural invariance results","multi-group SEM"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Metric invariance | 198.45 | 128 | 1.55 | 0.998 | 0.017 | <0.001","kind":"observe","local_id":"t82_o3","terms":["metric invariance results","multi-group SEM"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"This result signifies that the core latent constructs were measured in a comparable manner across different proficiency levels, fulfilling the prerequisite for cross-group path comparisons.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t82_o4","terms":["measurement invariance conclusion","English proficiency levels"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"As presented in Table 7, the positive path association from AI perception to self-efficacy remained statistically significant across all proficiency groups","kind":"observe","local_id":"t82_o5","terms":["AI perception to self-efficacy path","Table 7 results"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"English level group | Sample size (N) | Path estimate (B) | S.E. | C.R. (z-value) | p value","kind":"observe","local_id":"t82_o6","terms":["Table 7 header","English level group path comparison"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Group 1: beginner (below CET-4) | 144 | 0.312 | 0.090 | 3.467 | 0.001","kind":"observe","local_id":"t82_o7","terms":["Group 1 beginner sample and path estimate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Group 2: CET-4 level | 413 | 0.479 | 0.078 | 6.141 | <0.001","kind":"observe","local_id":"t82_o8","terms":["Group 2 CET-4 sample and path estimate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Group 3: CET-6 level | 303 | 0.326 | 0.066 | 4.939 | <0.001","kind":"observe","local_id":"t82_o9","terms":["Group 3 CET-6 sample and path estimate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Group 4: high cert. level | 100 | 0.326 | 0.106 | 3.075 | 0.002","kind":"observe","local_id":"t82_o10","terms":["Group 4 high certification sample and path estimate"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Because specific structural path constraint tests (i.e., chi-square difference tests for constrained vs. unconstrained models) were not performed, we refrain from claiming magnitude differences across proficiency levels.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t82_o11","terms":["qualification on cross-group magnitude differences"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"In this sense, H5 received preliminary empirical support regarding the model’s generalizability rather than comparative differentiation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t82_o12","terms":["H5 preliminary empirical support","model generalizability"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"To provide textual triangulation for the quantitative data, this study employed a thematic analysis method to encode and summarize the open-ended data as shown in Table 8.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t82_o13","terms":["thematic analysis of open-ended data","Table 8"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Functional support and efficiency | 241 | “AI helped tremendously in academic English reading, summarizing literature structures for me, greatly easing reading pressure.”","kind":"observe","local_id":"t82_o14","terms":["Functional support and efficiency theme frequency"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Emotional safety (low pressure) | 165 | “Facing an AI language partner, I can boldly try and make mistakes without worrying about being judged or mocked for being tongue-tied, unlike speaking with a foreign teacher.”","kind":"observe","local_id":"t82_o15","terms":["Emotional safety theme frequency"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Cognitive/dependency risks | 180 | “It sure is fast to one-click translate complex sentences, but I feel myself increasingly dependent on it. I’m actually more confused when it comes to independent thinking.”","kind":"observe","local_id":"t82_o16","terms":["Cognitive and dependency risks theme frequency"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Lack of real interaction | 81 | “Lacks the contextual pressure of real scenarios. That kind of tension when talking to a real human is something machines cannot simulate; I’d still get stage fright running into foreigners.”","kind":"observe","local_id":"t82_o17","terms":["Lack of real interaction theme frequency"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"The current data indicate that intelligent environment perception shares a significant positive association with multimodal L2 WTC (Deng et al., 2024).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t82_o18","terms":["intelligent environment perception","multimodal L2 WTC"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t82_o1","t82_o2","t82_o3","t82_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t82_c1","object":"configural (CFI=0.998, RMSEA=0.021) and metric invariance (ΔCFI<0.001) across 4 English proficiency groups","predicate":"establishes_measurement_invariance","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 establishes configural (χ2/df=1.77, CFI=0.998, RMSEA=0.021) and metric invariance (χ2/df=1.55, CFI=0.998, RMSEA=0.017, ΔCFI<0.001) across four English proficiency groups in multi-group SEM."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t82_o5","t82_o6","t82_o7","t82_o8","t82_o9","t82_o10"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t82_c2","object":"AI perception -> self-efficacy positive across beginner (B=0.312), CET-4 (B=0.479), CET-6 (B=0.326), and high cert. (B=0.326) groups","predicate":"reports_multigroup_path_estimates","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 finds a positive path from AI perception to self-efficacy across all 4 English proficiency groups (N=960 total: beginner N=144, B=0.312; CET-4 N=413, B=0.479; CET-6 N=303, B=0.326; high cert. N=100, B=0.326; all p<=0.002)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t82_o11","t82_o12"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t82_c3","object":"supports cross-group generalizability rather than magnitude differences across proficiency levels due to no path constraint tests","predicate":"qualifies_H5_conclusion","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 qualifies its H5 multi-group SEM results by refraining from claiming path magnitude differences across English proficiency levels because chi-square difference tests for structural path constraints were not performed."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t82_o13","t82_o14","t82_o15","t82_o16","t82_o17"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t82_c4","object":"Functional support/efficiency (241), Cognitive/dependency risks (180), Emotional safety (165), Lack of real interaction (81)","predicate":"reports_qualitative_themes","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"In thematic analysis of open-ended learner feedback, PMC13388837 reports frequencies for four themes: Functional support and efficiency (241), Cognitive/dependency risks (180), Emotional safety (165), and Lack of real interaction (81)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t82_o18"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t82_c5","object":"significant positive association between intelligent environment perception and multimodal L2 WTC","predicate":"concludes_association","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 concludes from its data that intelligent environment perception has a significant positive association with multimodal L2 willingness to communicate (WTC)."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",44238,49877]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"5f72919564c4aea12f7c9f32829cb4a35b33864840e9f976d126201b08b4e587","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["ad18255744912d69f4d9350a09ea4972d343de40b035216df9d473da3db67386","66905682ab0c41942486dddb3f150394dc14553d1acab722a22036c4a9d8aecd","431866a9cae93ab078f713bdf86ebc9f38bec90a24f8f22a77e01c37cfa0138c","146d2fe1057c8cd72df74646021dbb76ce0f384abb316a1774acfbb59e11defa","6104eb339a232073cef9ab4a083810e817a73491d9f4f7e4fcc0ea71e875f4d0","84047da0aa78f1d6b46676e31c99a39a868eac33e8dd0cad8683e39c98281383","006c73e51c28b138559089ce86d8e26d06ef5cab69f6d8a9c204a1f087042cd7","36e9095d896370f23a92f7edb31ccbbc35ae65a4812053ebca31c9deda0b925e","6d8a66d8f6db2316780b23ef70cd31381d322b993e3f8ec0a289858dac5d783e","b67dfd9b9fdb70e0711b916d6520446253edc645f7f9440a61b7e91b1f135169","8690a5466717054889e3c76f30ac0383cead51e9b5e96cc93bfc95cb5edfb57b","f3767f97b885853e88fd7035ff821e819e967761a3cb32f048d664c0e248b2ab","10e9f29ba7c00e58f33afc88e8d4519f6201fa8ea7e2122c864c07251005cb02","a5c582128da19214077985f2be261cd7480b5ca892a6c9b8c07dca8104800327","15ff3c028f0b775fbb2ba0c47bd9690e2657203457fd04c52c1c2d69c9e0e494","cc21dde651740cbdbe045f63689bd6fe5c6e0ff438277aa3a8d6cc3daeb68f51","60dab7ec2a99e93ea694fbe54db146839016a9dece429db29c276879dc918ac0","58a31e9448ea70d386eb5f3b787051419813886be10e725b5fb0948fdfcf653b","a840b0468624c8e5ab1b5a882db1253560a09432a9261df94b26b0b33857a9bb","3f54eea2b5263127429435ad901250f1dfddbde8762ce08ab429f559c2a8f539","d8d3bd34e7228d56f5471ce41db4c235d6377ced66b907a502be61fe6f8bce38","ef34c130e48681ea8da98bfd22967bcb53ef95a3959116172597ad6f2bbc3de4","ebac82cc13ecb9d980118cd5f29ee918c25e1ee235f7ee78a9beb79272065306"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"5c7215affff6ad2cb43fc803c972004f4081508d920977704bbe4a77e2550ae5","submission_id":"TR82-2d4be9ea23713daa#1"},"hash":"df860e826abf89af7d6697f574df65bcf941918d1c2e426999286b5535cb6678","header":{"body_hash":"5a0bb94081b7758ab207e2810666e6a9c5386ad5749a989051cfbf0e2339352f","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"4fc706e8cbbf7431baf20c1a7aa4b30f685271732717ed0e9ffdd85b8dc9f9d3","records_root":"5fe00aa66d2cd8cf509b182bf78bc6a26f69f25f033c926a83f2d0235c9f4424","seq":381,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"46b94a1182b9af09f81eff17b1db6c38ebfb10ffe3a491e04fe7308f5e413f1c","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":21,"circle_phase":"READ","kind":"REQUEST","link_task":null,"origin":{"generation":1,"kind":"kernel_loss_reread","loss_score":5,"policy":"unit_cost_round_robin_max2_per_report_first_wave","source_key":"doc:PMC13388837.txt#8"},"sync_step":41,"task_id":"TR82-2d4be9ea23713daa"},"from":0,"key":"task:reread:PMC13388837.txt#8","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"5f72919564c4aea12f7c9f32829cb4a35b33864840e9f976d126201b08b4e587","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"30ca854a5c0776c75825602276ac91fcadc406a87ecc95e9d52254e081d925eb","submission_id":"TR82-2d4be9ea23713daa#done2"},"hash":"14ebc2ee8b1b136f4b33f51ac893ffbb8cacb39b48e5fb5dbb0b81adcbed18c7","header":{"body_hash":"49454983052996d79296c0fad27557d660edcb9e56ba26d6f04302b88e7039d8","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"df860e826abf89af7d6697f574df65bcf941918d1c2e426999286b5535cb6678","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":382,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"6feb5c51bf60905d9307abbd45bdd932ad3ab56ee4d7ab71ce4dbadfd6ba8723","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":21,"circle_phase":"BUILD","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":1074},"started_unix_ms":1795103200896,"wave":{"doc:retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt#0":"reader-3"}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"5f72919564c4aea12f7c9f32829cb4a35b33864840e9f976d126201b08b4e587","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"9e8b4b213db64ff6d231cbdb4c8ac9d3050171e6f37dd22fe2071e196a912094","submission_id":"circle:90e3fead18e6f42e0a415edc55b15ee7cc13aea8efb886cba2c7b8ad6c815275"},"hash":"854577385ee92fd9945174930357c5f43c46e58318de328eeb0a9e9bbb48df5a","header":{"body_hash":"8774e2e1852a004e22fb01b91c19e078458cf167b369f0379be83cdf5eeb1a44","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"14ebc2ee8b1b136f4b33f51ac893ffbb8cacb39b48e5fb5dbb0b81adcbed18c7","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":383,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"2d0091495a519ce2bed943156e72f3a62282ad8e88cfe3e3b0227d5e1d5ab588","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"6feb5c51bf60905d9307abbd45bdd932ad3ab56ee4d7ab71ce4dbadfd6ba8723","engine_root":"5f72919564c4aea12f7c9f32829cb4a35b33864840e9f976d126201b08b4e587","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"f0c766b9ecf56c0d84220c63c4b631dedcb04847643d7264e0057753d7b95804","log_size":384,"projections":{"dependencies":"dc481d4ef184a4a983852063a01e0f4c28dddfd0b01cd67257a36658405a1063","status":"468408d37f4a2b7d2f78db7ef20f8b87bda3c0c7eb4a41d14bcc3c9ffac09af8"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"854577385ee92fd9945174930357c5f43c46e58318de328eeb0a9e9bbb48df5a"}},"engine_root":"5f72919564c4aea12f7c9f32829cb4a35b33864840e9f976d126201b08b4e587","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"6feb5c51bf60905d9307abbd45bdd932ad3ab56ee4d7ab71ce4dbadfd6ba8723","engine_root":"5f72919564c4aea12f7c9f32829cb4a35b33864840e9f976d126201b08b4e587","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"f0c766b9ecf56c0d84220c63c4b631dedcb04847643d7264e0057753d7b95804","log_size":384,"projections":{"dependencies":"dc481d4ef184a4a983852063a01e0f4c28dddfd0b01cd67257a36658405a1063","status":"468408d37f4a2b7d2f78db7ef20f8b87bda3c0c7eb4a41d14bcc3c9ffac09af8"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"854577385ee92fd9945174930357c5f43c46e58318de328eeb0a9e9bbb48df5a"},"seal_hash":"a7a11f66cd61270274c9bc75f932dc66e172e66c507fbbd3952428281a4e5677"}},"request_hash":"6490d5ea54e99f5718517f1f328396c260b65e9df510bf8c47c28b4f009a3963","submission_id":"seal-384"},"hash":"81d4c8b8fb1e4ae34840d976985e528b2b7250f1a79781bc25649e70625d9cb6","header":{"body_hash":"c6d38dacc7c34b18153c14354fcc13a9120f44d55b4aa034d0868ecb145b8323","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"854577385ee92fd9945174930357c5f43c46e58318de328eeb0a9e9bbb48df5a","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":384,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"0016e926f26b7f948f6de6a266ba56645bb8f6651302fc5e6279746b6f692547","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[21,"BUILD",0],"epoch":42,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25},{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":26},{"binding":[14,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":27},{"binding":[14,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":28},{"binding":[15,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":29},{"binding":[15,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":30},{"binding":[16,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":31},{"binding":[16,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":32},{"binding":[17,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":33},{"binding":[17,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":34},{"binding":[18,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":35},{"binding":[18,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":36},{"binding":[19,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":37},{"binding":[19,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":38},{"binding":[20,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":39},{"binding":[20,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":40},{"binding":[21,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":41},{"binding":[21,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":42}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795103200896},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"5f72919564c4aea12f7c9f32829cb4a35b33864840e9f976d126201b08b4e587","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"e96c0fa45b7e97a2c3364b3487e9a21c9f4d1398fd0ac8d49889729685dccfbd","submission_id":"ring-members:df295640d0e84bf6cb74f3501ace6354a858c7e9428dc212fa0e53e538a42593"},"hash":"ea60a12f3e3d5fb14447e7f06e2867031cab68b6e524b3999ce4cf9bf5dc23ef","header":{"body_hash":"82757e8cc852f8f7a81c2a638c20bce0d377d24dec65dc143f2fceba9571f6e9","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"81d4c8b8fb1e4ae34840d976985e528b2b7250f1a79781bc25649e70625d9cb6","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":385,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"3ad52539439f1709ed3fe68c5a3f25e7b2bc16c695af800f45df03e8155f7490","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","format":"r2r-circles/1","snapshot":{"concepts":0,"concepts_across_reports":0,"links_accepted":0,"links_proposed":0,"links_rejected":0,"links_total":0,"records":1074},"started_unix_ms":1795103200953,"wave":{}},"from":0,"key":"audit:circles","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"5f72919564c4aea12f7c9f32829cb4a35b33864840e9f976d126201b08b4e587","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"313f735daafa0b8d821c7cf2ad66532bc8a0b49a79dbd6dd986577e921d661b9","submission_id":"circle:e2c06ddbacb156ed286f6ddae352a60c9c308324301c491f80e45ac6ee617bd3"},"hash":"45f084478bded2f5270d22e6c5a54d0980b587442992e50fd2bb752ce6b28112","header":{"body_hash":"2e5a846fcc4e4a7d0282274760601197c629e51f405dcc671e1c2fa3f0c360ba","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ea60a12f3e3d5fb14447e7f06e2867031cab68b6e524b3999ce4cf9bf5dc23ef","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":386,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"aa5d1996d117a1a6f9e264ff134b903046c4214f9c4b45e9d05a3c851cfab06f","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"3ad52539439f1709ed3fe68c5a3f25e7b2bc16c695af800f45df03e8155f7490","engine_root":"5f72919564c4aea12f7c9f32829cb4a35b33864840e9f976d126201b08b4e587","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"dcbe30df6128fa4d21dc3e75139df812d5d5d74e0ce6c7e2b39c901dc83c4936","log_size":387,"projections":{"dependencies":"dc481d4ef184a4a983852063a01e0f4c28dddfd0b01cd67257a36658405a1063","status":"468408d37f4a2b7d2f78db7ef20f8b87bda3c0c7eb4a41d14bcc3c9ffac09af8"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"45f084478bded2f5270d22e6c5a54d0980b587442992e50fd2bb752ce6b28112"}},"engine_root":"5f72919564c4aea12f7c9f32829cb4a35b33864840e9f976d126201b08b4e587","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"3ad52539439f1709ed3fe68c5a3f25e7b2bc16c695af800f45df03e8155f7490","engine_root":"5f72919564c4aea12f7c9f32829cb4a35b33864840e9f976d126201b08b4e587","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"dcbe30df6128fa4d21dc3e75139df812d5d5d74e0ce6c7e2b39c901dc83c4936","log_size":387,"projections":{"dependencies":"dc481d4ef184a4a983852063a01e0f4c28dddfd0b01cd67257a36658405a1063","status":"468408d37f4a2b7d2f78db7ef20f8b87bda3c0c7eb4a41d14bcc3c9ffac09af8"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"45f084478bded2f5270d22e6c5a54d0980b587442992e50fd2bb752ce6b28112"},"seal_hash":"4841eff1f4c7a220fc0ff2c85758e779a3c075074c202423846963bca146a9c9"}},"request_hash":"c8372ef5cf44fcb087910064efc0f106593eda4f97363fa1eee852c543992885","submission_id":"seal-387"},"hash":"78bd04c4a2313d82961e483b62f3f4f4fa4d5b19d60603946e7913c0dda7321d","header":{"body_hash":"335ac4917babe79ea60c3b161b1368980b27cc270bef8373d94104c7f2fb189a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"45f084478bded2f5270d22e6c5a54d0980b587442992e50fd2bb752ce6b28112","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":387,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"66dfc4809ccaaf7ed2f70c4d3b5e900935d8621afb4ec1ff370c094ab61c6c5c","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"binding":[21,"FINAL",0],"epoch":43,"events":[{"binding":[1,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":1},{"binding":[1,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":2},{"binding":[2,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":3},{"binding":[2,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":4},{"binding":[3,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":5},{"binding":[3,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":6},{"binding":[4,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":7},{"binding":[4,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":8},{"binding":[5,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":9},{"binding":[5,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":10},{"binding":[6,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":11},{"binding":[6,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":12},{"binding":[7,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":13},{"binding":[7,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":14},{"binding":[8,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":15},{"binding":[8,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":16},{"binding":[9,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":17},{"binding":[9,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":18},{"binding":[10,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":19},{"binding":[10,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":20},{"binding":[11,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":21},{"binding":[11,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":22},{"binding":[12,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":23},{"binding":[12,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":24},{"binding":[13,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":25},{"binding":[13,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":26},{"binding":[14,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":27},{"binding":[14,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":28},{"binding":[15,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":29},{"binding":[15,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":30},{"binding":[16,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":31},{"binding":[16,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":32},{"binding":[17,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":33},{"binding":[17,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":34},{"binding":[18,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":35},{"binding":[18,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":36},{"binding":[19,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":37},{"binding":[19,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":38},{"binding":[20,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":39},{"binding":[20,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":40},{"binding":[21,"READ",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":41},{"binding":[21,"BUILD",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":42},{"binding":[21,"FINAL",0],"kind":"SHIFT_BEGIN","sync_step":43}],"excluded":[],"format":"r2r-ring-members/1","started_unix_ms":1795103200953},"from":0,"key":"audit:ring-members","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"5f72919564c4aea12f7c9f32829cb4a35b33864840e9f976d126201b08b4e587","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"8040c5aab1d30f33aae8d96fee9e7e91b868407dcd0ae46ae5ae3a6ef56bdb6d","submission_id":"ring-members:471dd1e3bdea12542ba33559cb8a99d186b60eb18d0cfecd0cfebae94f3725c9"},"hash":"73c3f5a93fb35daf38810dfdcc2737dbabdd7226a6e85df94c1b7ddf03f99a25","header":{"body_hash":"04675d4802a73d094c6822941ad0a11fc49e9a82ec0a81b5fe9454dcbad36b10","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"78bd04c4a2313d82961e483b62f3f4f4fa4d5b19d60603946e7913c0dda7321d","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":388,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"c8f5f58c4091478486ace396a50d1efa31b9180ec82bd7beeb6c8ae950d506e1","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"failures":null,"reason":"no_section_matched_terms","task_id":"nosource-question:@5fa49cc78ed8f374","unresolved":true},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@5fa49cc78ed8f374","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"5f72919564c4aea12f7c9f32829cb4a35b33864840e9f976d126201b08b4e587","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"9ed1b2128ff6e31be66405eb46d3eac34ee78370aa53161b3166addbf6fd79c5","submission_id":"nosource-question:@5fa49cc78ed8f374#unresolved"},"hash":"7fbc5868e31eeffb927eb453104150ebde8dbef96956949632038ac5cb62df18","header":{"body_hash":"2cd038dda9ba16432d73944e3f4bd63b79fd7049bdc1bbb4749ae02e3c782485","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"73c3f5a93fb35daf38810dfdcc2737dbabdd7226a6e85df94c1b7ddf03f99a25","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":389,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"2559dc10ff13986567be74fb006e455432fe0ba24daf2ddbd47a513c1b5ae124","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TQ85-4818dbd6014db128","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Source: Europe PMC PMC13226197, doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1811065. Licence: CC BY (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Copyright © 2026 Li.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t85_o1","terms":["PMC13226197","Li 2026"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Most studies employ self-report, cross-sectional correlational designs, or brief interventions, primarily reporting outcome scores but not tracing the learning process that produced them (Wang and Fan, 2025).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t85_o2","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025","in-text citation","Introduction"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t85_o1","t85_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t85_c1","object":"Wang and Fan (2025)","predicate":"cites_in_introduction","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 cites Wang and Fan (2025) in its Introduction for the claim that most studies rely on self-report, cross-sectional correlational designs, or brief interventions and report outcome scores without tracing the learning process."},{"about":["PMC13226197","Wang and Fan (2025)"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t85_q1","needed":"Inspect PMC13226197.txt from byte 4779 to the end of the file, including the References section, for occurrences of 'Wang' and 'Fan'.","text":"Does PMC13226197 cite Wang and Fan (2025) in sections after byte 4779 or list its bibliographic details in the References section?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"5f72919564c4aea12f7c9f32829cb4a35b33864840e9f976d126201b08b4e587","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["845eeff65be44e52a74d9cb4b0c345a698f9a67ab0a1e561a303cc8846843f09","ada8a25696094f0678ec004dca6940095d24fdaf4f62729cac9391b1e5a75d6d","40e9455fa5f2288d9a34f907630033676612039414d027280018f9a24a866fb9","a1b91703e723a0047a21605363116c93006c7297d2b7e1cf130961c44f6509b6"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"4d1eef4309e0f58b56d1d425366db69fb53c893f44f464cc4534fb121f53de2a","submission_id":"TQ85-4818dbd6014db128#1"},"hash":"fe0839ba4a029d69ffbd8b959a3be6607974178201d7a3326bfd016d6a16a283","header":{"body_hash":"4e73449415cc2238f978cbabbc75dca32dfc6fc665b34d2832bab4aa196451e8","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"7fbc5868e31eeffb927eb453104150ebde8dbef96956949632038ac5cb62df18","records_root":"80709155e518e73b67d1b32751eb00035774fb5fa0f468537b6e6d604a19456f","seq":390,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"da86b9cdc0cf880e1b9d1cd92d5b0f172c72b118b6dec294a59d3e1c8b9d05b4","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","kind":"INVESTIGATE","link_task":null,"settled":["40e9455fa5f2288d9a34f907630033676612039414d027280018f9a24a866fb9","a1b91703e723a0047a21605363116c93006c7297d2b7e1cf130961c44f6509b6"],"sync_step":43,"task_id":"TQ85-4818dbd6014db128"},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@414c655c6375016b","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"5f72919564c4aea12f7c9f32829cb4a35b33864840e9f976d126201b08b4e587","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"5b6c8133277c30c88c6f4f3656424511c220f4f7e92ef99444fc320618b8b8a4","submission_id":"TQ85-4818dbd6014db128#done2"},"hash":"abe84a44dceaa7f82f3080d5a150be622eaa5b305b99492d837ce33fe2de2f9c","header":{"body_hash":"145287e1e93447432f3d7a640f9d9b18caf599b7168ae61da422973443dc62fa","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"fe0839ba4a029d69ffbd8b959a3be6607974178201d7a3326bfd016d6a16a283","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":391,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"edd91cd1d5ab985fe6d8fdb431311e3f5d9e7f6d08a986bc17f4b08fe6c1a089","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TQ83-78ef0f7c5baab7f1","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"AI exposure increased monitoring behaviors (β = 0.028–0.047) and control behaviors (β = 0.036–0.061).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t83_o1","terms":["empirical findings","metacognition","monitoring behaviors","control behaviors","PMC13226197"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Longer time on task (β = 0.083), higher activity intensity (β = 0.057), higher persistence after errors (β = 0.064), and higher return probability on the next day (β = 0.031) increased engagement","kind":"observe","local_id":"t83_o2","terms":["empirical findings","engagement","time on task","activity intensity","persistence after errors","return probability"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"while shorter interval between activities (β = −0.018) decreased it.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t83_o3","terms":["empirical findings","engagement","interval between activities","spacing"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The strongest transfer gains were for near transfer (β = 0.052), topic-shift transfer (β = 0.021), and delayed performance (7 days) (β = 0.017).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t83_o4","terms":["empirical findings","knowledge transfer","near transfer","topic-shift transfer","delayed performance"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"AI-supported tutoring appears to strengthen metacognitive regulation and engagement, while broader transfer remains conditional on scaffolds that promote verification, retrieval, and abstraction.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t83_o5","terms":["main conclusions","metacognitive regulation","engagement","knowledge transfer","scaffolds"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t83_o1"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t83_c1","object":"increased monitoring (β = 0.028–0.047) and control (β = 0.036–0.061) behaviors","predicate":"finds_metacognition_effect","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds that AI exposure in EdNet tutoring increases metacognitive monitoring behaviors (β = 0.028–0.047) and metacognitive control behaviors (β = 0.036–0.061)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t83_o2","t83_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t83_c2","object":"longer time on task, higher intensity, persistence, and next-day return; shorter activity intervals","predicate":"finds_engagement_effect","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 reports engagement gains in time on task (β=0.083), activity intensity (β=0.057), post-error persistence (β=0.064), and next-day return probability (β=0.031), with shorter activity intervals (β=−0.018)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t83_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t83_c3","object":"near transfer (β = 0.052), topic-shift transfer (β = 0.021), and 7-day delayed performance (β = 0.017)","predicate":"finds_transfer_effect","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds positive knowledge transfer effects from AI tutoring exposure, led by near transfer (β = 0.052), followed by topic-shift transfer (β = 0.021) and 7-day delayed performance (β = 0.017)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t83_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t83_c4","object":"strengthened metacognitive regulation and engagement; broader transfer conditional on scaffolds","predicate":"concludes","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 concludes that AI-supported tutoring strengthens metacognitive regulation and engagement, whereas broader knowledge transfer depends on scaffolds promoting verification, retrieval, and abstraction."},{"about":["PMC13226197"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t83_q1","needed":"Check Section 4, Section 5, and Section 6 of PMC13226197.txt (beyond bytes 0..4779)","text":"What are the full regression table estimates, robustness check outcomes (pre-trend, falsification, overlap), and specific sub-proxy coefficients reported in Sections 4, 5, and 6 of PMC13226197?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"6beaaed98dc71eb102c37f7492b3b09137fa9f9bb770270ed449c44b75f3839f","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["bfa79060cca23542f0c2ba6da1300196a64d685bbb7f3374f46a1dc416e348c1","6313f004e2110726b398b0a588f68445a85e18a9f2c495f694e6d4a2269ba1f7","c42526ac54fc9fd3057abb5efc1844a0127097b6af2d9702210680cdcd54431b","c041321ca0be249e3a9f9af7c42a7a3af1cd5182aa47a7e5aad08d47922394f7","2076be9e5ca863874d723c58ae71f8e1c61b86eed853dded17ba067dca4be808","20efea13e8e86dc2a0d6bd016edcfa147590d5f56b9167622c37b0e2e88e88ab","47fdaf363e6553e1cdb3bf7e95384bd5c5b7b47f12f6f57c84cf7448debe44ca","91f78e24fec518b73d7d5efe0006b50d731e70dd624407a9455937765796722f","f1be70816f59b285a228ec11980677b19aab16ba6056fb5fd17e3677ec5e969a","fa2d1a6d76f3793eaea5b8244c020be419b19237614fdfb9975c09a2c11b299a"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"7c99f0b3f1a21b8856a782ef2112874c66f85e8f92a4a3e30d3c0b4cdad13596","submission_id":"TQ83-78ef0f7c5baab7f1#1"},"hash":"7d4c9478e61d66bc74562dce31ea9501d65b2ade16f87204a8f203e7233a2a93","header":{"body_hash":"72d1a395f298c9415a3fee59fb4717d53095d63a82971d8628343b342d44d2fd","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"abe84a44dceaa7f82f3080d5a150be622eaa5b305b99492d837ce33fe2de2f9c","records_root":"3554c6a2bca53e6ca130cd1d558fec8df9b4fb7b439c471455861fcd2f2b0fb0","seq":392,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"e8b09fbc78f2457f3c317a06645e39d68f025c0fdc259c5737f431a2d01e9a2d","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","kind":"INVESTIGATE","link_task":null,"settled":["20efea13e8e86dc2a0d6bd016edcfa147590d5f56b9167622c37b0e2e88e88ab","47fdaf363e6553e1cdb3bf7e95384bd5c5b7b47f12f6f57c84cf7448debe44ca","91f78e24fec518b73d7d5efe0006b50d731e70dd624407a9455937765796722f","f1be70816f59b285a228ec11980677b19aab16ba6056fb5fd17e3677ec5e969a","fa2d1a6d76f3793eaea5b8244c020be419b19237614fdfb9975c09a2c11b299a"],"sync_step":43,"task_id":"TQ83-78ef0f7c5baab7f1"},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@d091768c3233da1b","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"6beaaed98dc71eb102c37f7492b3b09137fa9f9bb770270ed449c44b75f3839f","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"c1260ca0f0b617a1b8d60e219b5100e5ff0c8307a696173e1d81e272428a8963","submission_id":"TQ83-78ef0f7c5baab7f1#done2"},"hash":"bc611144efc4414c06237348a2e865fce1d143a6fa61efabfb62c2afc2ea0097","header":{"body_hash":"c9330466af7d48a689c4391f09f014c2d26a7528791acba6c5cf69951196d934","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"7d4c9478e61d66bc74562dce31ea9501d65b2ade16f87204a8f203e7233a2a93","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":393,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"6340c5e50d9e3d4a383799bdf67a64104dc686c25b6f061e31121424414d57e4","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TQ84-b1b4cf4736a211cc","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Source: Europe PMC PMC13226197, doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1811065. Licence: CC BY (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Copyright © 2026 Li.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t84_o1","terms":["PMC13226197","Li 2026","document identifier"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Using EdNet log data, AI use was operationalized as exposure to tutoring-system assistance events during learning episodes.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t84_o2","terms":["EdNet log data","AI use","tutoring-system assistance events"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Monitoring proxies and control proxies were used to assess metacognition, time on task, activity intensity, persistence after errors, return probability, and spacing.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t84_o3","terms":["monitoring proxies","control proxies","metacognition","engagement proxies"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"AI exposure increased monitoring behaviors (β = 0.028–0.047) and control behaviors (β = 0.036–0.061).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t84_o4","terms":["AI exposure","monitoring behaviors","control behaviors","metacognition quantitative results"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Longer time on task (β = 0.083), higher activity intensity (β = 0.057), higher persistence after errors (β = 0.064), and higher return probability on the next day (β = 0.031) increased engagement, while shorter interval between activities (β = −0.018) decreased it.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t84_o5","terms":["time on task","activity intensity","persistence after errors","return probability","interval between activities","engagement quantitative results"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The strongest transfer gains were for near transfer (β = 0.052), topic-shift transfer (β = 0.021), and delayed performance (7 days) (β = 0.017).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t84_o6","terms":["near transfer","topic-shift transfer","delayed performance","knowledge transfer quantitative results"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"AI-supported tutoring appears to strengthen metacognitive regulation and engagement, while broader transfer remains conditional on scaffolds that promote verification, retrieval, and abstraction.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t84_o7","terms":["metacognitive regulation","engagement","broader transfer","scaffolds","directional findings"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t84_o1","t84_o2","t84_o3","t84_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t84_c1","object":"increased monitoring behaviors (β = 0.028–0.047) and control behaviors (β = 0.036–0.061)","predicate":"reports_metacognition_effect","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In PMC13226197 (EdNet log data), AI exposure increased metacognitive monitoring behaviors (β = 0.028–0.047) and metacognitive control behaviors (β = 0.036–0.061)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t84_o1","t84_o2","t84_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t84_c2","object":"longer time on task (β = 0.083), higher activity intensity (β = 0.057), persistence after errors (β = 0.064), next-day return probability (β = 0.031)","predicate":"reports_positive_engagement_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In PMC13226197 (EdNet log data), AI exposure yielded engagement gains in time on task (β = 0.083), activity intensity (β = 0.057), persistence after errors (β = 0.064), and next-day return probability (β = 0.031)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t84_o1","t84_o2","t84_o3","t84_o5"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t84_c3","object":"shorter interval between activities decreased engagement (β = −0.018)","predicate":"reports_negative_spacing_effect","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In PMC13226197 (EdNet log data), a shorter interval between activities (spacing) was associated with a negative coefficient (β = −0.018) on engagement."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t84_o1","t84_o2","t84_o6"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t84_c4","object":"near transfer (β = 0.052), topic-shift transfer (β = 0.021), and 7-day delayed performance (β = 0.017)","predicate":"reports_knowledge_transfer_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In PMC13226197 (EdNet log data), AI exposure produced positive knowledge transfer gains, strongest for near transfer (β = 0.052), followed by topic-shift transfer (β = 0.021) and 7-day delayed performance (β = 0.017)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t84_o1","t84_o7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t84_c5","object":"strengthens metacognitive regulation and engagement; broader transfer conditional on verification, retrieval, and abstraction scaffolds","predicate":"reports_directional_conclusion","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 finds directionally that AI-supported tutoring strengthens metacognitive regulation and engagement, whereas broader knowledge transfer is conditional on scaffolds promoting verification, retrieval, and abstraction."},{"about":["PMC13226197","metacognition","engagement","knowledge transfer"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t84_q1","needed":"Check the main Results and Discussion body sections and regression tables of PMC13226197.txt (after byte 4779)","text":"What are the exact regression coefficients, standard errors, p-values, and sub-proxy breakdowns (e.g., verification vs. error-correction vs. help-seeking) in the body Results tables of PMC13226197 beyond the Abstract summary?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"6beaaed98dc71eb102c37f7492b3b09137fa9f9bb770270ed449c44b75f3839f","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["bb64c227a45b1c91bddc66762c97833f29fcec4ac1ea82503e1a772300e488a8","0adedd4ddc285617596218dc189cc4b7b7fe1efd13e0f5e8f9028463a9985600","9aadc0b4b98801ffc0a6bdba4f47c4fdf8188f6841613bf206c0e679313189c6","2ca692bca851152d0fbacc9fa6d1e1551ee1faac6b004f26a11ca58138026464","b03e4d9ab440d6affdbac0d173138fc556dc4b3d52c2094985ad03af91370818","faa98ae1646fb31fc706a12876e8456fb2e10c0f196fe88fbb92e26a3f8f6312","43a5df1cf030d312c011d23b1192637aa211d1e7164e42fc2d881b48a38cd7c7","71d58f185e614a0516b10785a63a0935226469a738d428425191b2d13ee9fc54","ea66979503fc017fb7c6b159f550a15073219f3242f5b3cac378885cec4720cd","f6e98073bf33170985ae1d4f9303a1a0547614993079ec36f37d8895b86bd898","75c44fbcf0014baf369473586ecd92eac1285b876c124d71bdb24554cfb1e9b9","765f5d70d58f98c96d46fbd4644045da4dc7c27eab41cf44678e4ebcfb9bbfde","61f925562f229d46b3be899da487c6a6112273193c2e64bc7974521977345738"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"db7a8777db60660ab583110cc5e59bf72235bb6d3b63fb9c91dd5be049f1fd41","submission_id":"TQ84-b1b4cf4736a211cc#1"},"hash":"851e330bf8b3f7cb7c8b568413fdb5a134c1d23f058ebd33e186b8042067e824","header":{"body_hash":"2f3bd72fe0ced616ae0e36e2056028034eecc11ecd449def8164f3a1b82f7cb1","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"bc611144efc4414c06237348a2e865fce1d143a6fa61efabfb62c2afc2ea0097","records_root":"fc0e5aaad54790d284f4d08d6b92b170cee5c7d0dd9c7b7a3ec1347c3706094a","seq":394,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"1e245f79c8664fefb5d701997111622d99821a301b05f7b98ab40d50f5ec1438","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","kind":"INVESTIGATE","link_task":null,"settled":["71d58f185e614a0516b10785a63a0935226469a738d428425191b2d13ee9fc54","ea66979503fc017fb7c6b159f550a15073219f3242f5b3cac378885cec4720cd","f6e98073bf33170985ae1d4f9303a1a0547614993079ec36f37d8895b86bd898","75c44fbcf0014baf369473586ecd92eac1285b876c124d71bdb24554cfb1e9b9","765f5d70d58f98c96d46fbd4644045da4dc7c27eab41cf44678e4ebcfb9bbfde","61f925562f229d46b3be899da487c6a6112273193c2e64bc7974521977345738"],"sync_step":43,"task_id":"TQ84-b1b4cf4736a211cc"},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@cbe284f0adcab2e4","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"6beaaed98dc71eb102c37f7492b3b09137fa9f9bb770270ed449c44b75f3839f","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"ec8bdd539a257629fd62080f8b05a6f45af84b036fb523381ee72c9e1af1f00f","submission_id":"TQ84-b1b4cf4736a211cc#done2"},"hash":"198f9002f2ecdc2d695196f7a1c18d8f9bd44ba62a7484d8352b2cfa05ed97ec","header":{"body_hash":"0dde3149b1e0e0b5c31d08c7c75f2413fe790cd31fbf262f1348b30ef349ea6c","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"851e330bf8b3f7cb7c8b568413fdb5a134c1d23f058ebd33e186b8042067e824","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":395,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"2bf0dd33aa4d77e093a742e074be8a9bdcdc3134f8c18ee8032b5b8fa1aa98a0","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TQ86-b86951ab14e53a73","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"AI exposure increased monitoring behaviors (β = 0.028–0.047) and control behaviors (β = 0.036–0.061).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t86_o1","terms":["metacognitive monitoring","metacognitive control","regression estimates","abstract summary"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Longer time on task (β = 0.083), higher activity intensity (β = 0.057), higher persistence after errors (β = 0.064), and higher return probability on the next day (β = 0.031)","kind":"observe","local_id":"t86_o2","terms":["engagement","time on task","activity intensity","persistence after errors","return probability"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"while shorter interval between activities (β = −0.018) decreased it.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t86_o3","terms":["engagement","interval between activities","spacing"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"The strongest transfer gains were for near transfer (β = 0.052), topic-shift transfer (β = 0.021), and delayed performance (7 days) (β = 0.017).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t86_o4","terms":["knowledge transfer","near transfer","topic-shift transfer","delayed performance"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t86_o1"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t86_c1","object":"monitoring β = 0.028–0.047; control β = 0.036–0.061","predicate":"reports_metacognition_effect_range","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In the abstract of PMC13226197, AI exposure increased metacognitive monitoring behaviors (β = 0.028–0.047) and metacognitive control behaviors (β = 0.036–0.061)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t86_o2","t86_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t86_c2","object":"time on task β=0.083, intensity β=0.057, persistence β=0.064, next-day return β=0.031, interval β=-0.018","predicate":"reports_engagement_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In the abstract of PMC13226197, AI exposure affected engagement via time on task (β = 0.083), activity intensity (β = 0.057), persistence after errors (β = 0.064), next-day return (β = 0.031), and inter-activity interval (β = −0.018)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t86_o4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t86_c3","object":"near transfer β = 0.052, topic-shift transfer β = 0.021, 7-day delayed performance β = 0.017","predicate":"reports_transfer_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In the abstract of PMC13226197, AI exposure yielded knowledge transfer gains for near transfer (β = 0.052), topic-shift transfer (β = 0.021), and 7-day delayed performance (β = 0.017)."},{"about":["PMC13226197","Table 3","metacognitive control","engagement","knowledge transfer"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t86_q1","needed":"Read PMC13226197.txt after byte 44417 for the remainder of Table 3 and subsequent results tables.","text":"While the abstract (bytes 0..4779) gives point estimates β for control (0.036–0.061), engagement (0.083, 0.057, 0.064, 0.031, −0.018), and transfer (0.052, 0.021, 0.017), what are the exact per-proxy β, 95% CIs, and standardized effects in Table 3 and subsequent tables?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"21a401560a7916d8ce112f9063925fbb65194ec887db0b7fab18d3f5de5abf39","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["5c1b3eec722624b5f5d93b3943237be5e13489b75488b2a307d6fce2c0152902","82c2f940329c9250e262abe52acc894f4df804fabf8d408be8cb153faaa73662","7fe23a3dd862774f000c6f2d33a28c9fd205fd19bf937eff5a70328bee885dae","ffca46f7cedd5047729d7c872dc2b0e64ba348a13fbcde62dc0ce4371db7a75d","0c63b29de81263afc082587531b48d2ac7a93416faaa1b1f23d7b523aa4143b2","c4a00c25280e6b1b75f85dfd7a48023155b1ac6e1df6416250a33eeed61c58b2","4a5f091890d130f6a6ff4643afc51cf86e62ecc6ae6c100f16cd2b9a138fb661"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":7}},"request_hash":"92e1e61d8a2c857e89f6c6ff6001de80e8bb67d32b0bbea8bc1ae98cd33fccbf","submission_id":"TQ86-b86951ab14e53a73#1"},"hash":"e8c5cb2455e54838c09dfdf398786a196df1ae871ace518f94e23a4587c4a2f9","header":{"body_hash":"40a5ed0bf7b5805c64e3dded4264d9484c27266f53d75b14ac8534ef47c115a2","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"198f9002f2ecdc2d695196f7a1c18d8f9bd44ba62a7484d8352b2cfa05ed97ec","records_root":"a51148619a2d2ab91c73c622ddd5bdec86c1143d7be208f2788a158648a464df","seq":396,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"a1d9c76bdc004e636b6d7ebf0d3820bf69fd48e1d62940ba43e12ff4b31ada02","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@5c1b3eec722624b5","@82c2f940329c9250","@7fe23a3dd862774f","@ffca46f7cedd5047","@0c63b29de81263af","@c4a00c25280e6b1b","@4a5f091890d130f6"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"INVESTIGATE","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":7,"local_id":"t86_q1"}],"task_id":"TQ86-b86951ab14e53a73","work_key":"question:@1ba47624024fb722"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:TQ86-b86951ab14e53a73:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"21a401560a7916d8ce112f9063925fbb65194ec887db0b7fab18d3f5de5abf39","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"cbab7f20dab85666601a39ba4a62c78c00dd09f62cb88f34fd9ab4db98291caf","submission_id":"TQ86-b86951ab14e53a73#repair1"},"hash":"b8d982d20e032b3d77944cb9d377004e50ed28ff6927df9927070dd724401cc9","header":{"body_hash":"4b290f627ac5123306f1450b9209bd76e5577eabe19626b4980f2c9fe857bd8a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"e8c5cb2455e54838c09dfdf398786a196df1ae871ace518f94e23a4587c4a2f9","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":397,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"942c2233ecbe28e2ae9c9aebe312762c2cd0f1e6fed4408a8421d4faab13b226","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TQ88-0a85161a9b6dd689","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Source: Europe PMC PMC13226197, doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1811065. Licence: CC BY (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Copyright © 2026 Li.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t88_o1","terms":["PMC13226197","Li 2026"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Most studies employ self-report, cross-sectional correlational designs, or brief interventions, primarily reporting outcome scores but not tracing the learning process that produced them (Wang and Fan, 2025).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t88_o2","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025","in-text citation","study design critique","outcome scores vs learning process"]},{"as_of":20260101,"based_on":["t88_o1","t88_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t88_c1","object":"Wang and Fan (2025): most studies use self-report, cross-sectional, or brief intervention designs reporting outcome scores without tracing learning processes","predicate":"cites_for_claim","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In the Introduction of PMC13226197, Li (2026) cites Wang and Fan (2025) for the claim that most educational AI studies rely on self-report, cross-sectional correlational designs, or brief interventions and report outcome scores without tracing the learning process."},{"about":["PMC13226197","Wang and Fan (2025)"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t88_q1","needed":"Check remaining body sections of PMC13226197.txt (bytes 4779+) for further citations to Wang and Fan (2025) and retrieve the Title line quote from the Wang & Fan (2025) meta-analysis record file.","text":"Are there additional in-text citations to Wang and Fan (2025) in PMC13226197.txt after byte 4779, and what is the Title line in the Wang and Fan (2025) meta-analysis record file to link with the Introduction citation in bytes 0..4779?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"21a401560a7916d8ce112f9063925fbb65194ec887db0b7fab18d3f5de5abf39","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["b3bd27d3ba9c5f0e7de72437ad74079f5643efbf87e22e18f8c4a1b23a5d795f","f826c61786e76fcc384adfdde59dac7095e998fae0abc4627a30d8517b548d5f"],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":2}},"request_hash":"e2b78368dc8cd5b5ef13c3d59275c6c2e79bd3848d184ed2b5cde869c0e7c540","submission_id":"TQ88-0a85161a9b6dd689#1"},"hash":"5a8fd12bcddbf3a54cb54bb774ce5741a09277e46c3bbe9f8b9d725bdd98155a","header":{"body_hash":"34eb329d6216d0af9069bc7371c47ac9677a98c801602505927ddd8eb8e46694","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"b8d982d20e032b3d77944cb9d377004e50ed28ff6927df9927070dd724401cc9","records_root":"0d6a02cd285966193ab389fc6f0256c92741ebee7ab85b4e28bfe616439b7b44","seq":398,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"7231dabc3fc0694f01e083602093d1d0cb6fbd493eec994a811e6924b3a2a8ce","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TQ88-0a85161a9b6dd689","kind":"submit","lines":[{"about":["PMC13226197","Wang and Fan (2025)"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t88_q1","needed":"Check remaining body sections of PMC13226197.txt (bytes 4779+) for further citations to Wang and Fan (2025) and retrieve the Title line quote from the Wang & Fan (2025) meta-analysis record file.","text":"Are there additional in-text citations to Wang and Fan (2025) in PMC13226197.txt after byte 4779, and what is the Title line in the Wang and Fan (2025) meta-analysis record file to link with the Introduction citation in bytes 0..4779?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"21a401560a7916d8ce112f9063925fbb65194ec887db0b7fab18d3f5de5abf39","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["fabea67e18d63958450ae6b43cc6fc3733be94bedc393319374f351fe22dce81"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"5a2782fc1ae66f6c49398fc18bc907420ec18ade0cbb435d6736ac1834395b17","submission_id":"TQ88-0a85161a9b6dd689#1.1"},"hash":"030d595d45f343108157ef8bb67d92a05ef914745b500d5e0e248974ad113f04","header":{"body_hash":"7ffb8ffc96bfe229416b51b1e93a286042a0bb417a97f1c45736b54dd4d450b4","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"5a8fd12bcddbf3a54cb54bb774ce5741a09277e46c3bbe9f8b9d725bdd98155a","records_root":"07e9ae4e707effc7e56ab2189a6811a8359c68a1b91005eff9225c8e16f65887","seq":399,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"18a3d19f726d1ca85ca6933def695e3606bac3974360fb2a1d18f80744d93980","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@b3bd27d3ba9c5f0e","@f826c61786e76fcc","@fabea67e18d63958"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"INVESTIGATE","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":2,"local_id":"t88_c1"}],"task_id":"TQ88-0a85161a9b6dd689","work_key":"question:@1f91007433d4c197"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:TQ88-0a85161a9b6dd689:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"21a401560a7916d8ce112f9063925fbb65194ec887db0b7fab18d3f5de5abf39","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"6970291fa7c41d510f4fc4723d71a44943d0c13096571eb3dc8275647e661966","submission_id":"TQ88-0a85161a9b6dd689#repair1"},"hash":"41a79d231fb62c05b50d1adeae99ac6f84059bf24bec6be31e9f0980600bb763","header":{"body_hash":"27981b8e13bf506f08384d94f70f4e038d837a1161a73ab7c5d08d201dee98df","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"030d595d45f343108157ef8bb67d92a05ef914745b500d5e0e248974ad113f04","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":400,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"241e2f78d555af489c21d22740087235238862ab00afc29e39f2827e907eb838","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TQ89-891d64a6a1c1e11d","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Most studies employ self-report, cross-sectional correlational designs, or brief interventions, primarily reporting outcome scores but not tracing the learning process that produced them (Wang and Fan, 2025).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t89_o1","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025","in-text citation","self-report","correlational designs","brief interventions","outcome scores"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t89_o1"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t89_c1","object":"Wang and Fan (2025) on reliance on self-report, correlational, or brief intervention designs reporting outcome scores","predicate":"cites_finding_from","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 cites Wang and Fan (2025) for the observation that most AI-in-education studies use self-report, cross-sectional correlational designs, or brief interventions that report outcome scores without tracing learning processes."},{"about":["PMC13226197","Wang and Fan (2025)","PMC12068088"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t89_q1","needed":"The later bytes of PMC13226197.txt containing the References list and literature review table, plus byte 0..1000 of the Wang and Fan (2025) record file (PMC12068088.txt).","text":"What is the exact reference list entry for Wang and Fan (2025) in the References section of PMC13226197.txt, and does it match the Title line of the Wang and Fan (2025) meta-analysis file (PMC12068088.txt)?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"21a401560a7916d8ce112f9063925fbb65194ec887db0b7fab18d3f5de5abf39","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["f828ba66084867c01d399c3e210dc4f70f6245cb037c2c22096ef69c8ab37ca0","7154e5d20afda66421e640dce8eb81f6d725b37ed48113f888fd5474b1fcf77e","1cf86da96807c1f39544d85022c626d3c8107dfb3b1c26938a6c3692ba63d256"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"8fc718895d1179e27942fe75068fcff0b21e24b49ec9f0c8e44803b1e5cb884a","submission_id":"TQ89-891d64a6a1c1e11d#1"},"hash":"bf0be4bb78be9d06c1fff9a21d7d4145226d26e1df277d95212accae1921a676","header":{"body_hash":"3648c4ffc4a71d40baaf070b37e4db9ae33b520160118abea5c481993bb94d9c","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"41a79d231fb62c05b50d1adeae99ac6f84059bf24bec6be31e9f0980600bb763","records_root":"63f2beb25bf29601e45cf048482f1007d73520b2d5592f852d270f8de81b6dda","seq":401,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"c938ed642889ef64582d3795599df8a4ff5f29026ffa55690cc669d265597d90","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","kind":"INVESTIGATE","link_task":null,"settled":["7154e5d20afda66421e640dce8eb81f6d725b37ed48113f888fd5474b1fcf77e","1cf86da96807c1f39544d85022c626d3c8107dfb3b1c26938a6c3692ba63d256"],"sync_step":43,"task_id":"TQ89-891d64a6a1c1e11d"},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@c693ed71ab58dc99","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"21a401560a7916d8ce112f9063925fbb65194ec887db0b7fab18d3f5de5abf39","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"21dabf68ecd2bd56b43f32df746e759b7b76d4a46f479e8aec024d372e4406a5","submission_id":"TQ89-891d64a6a1c1e11d#done2"},"hash":"1ef0b7fcce39b98f1d8a1ceadf7002bf1857558ee41b15d8ab1e1619154642a9","header":{"body_hash":"4a4af6a278842f20a8b1bbc688e748ee7ed94c79d8d495f6d59a09be866d0088","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"bf0be4bb78be9d06c1fff9a21d7d4145226d26e1df277d95212accae1921a676","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":402,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"4c6c06a2885fe780525ed1a494cfbd19b1ea94182d9584486594ded537d63ce7","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TQ86-b86951ab14e53a73","kind":"submit","lines":[{"about":["PMC13226197","Table 3","metacognitive control","engagement","knowledge transfer"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t86_q1","needed":"Read PMC13226197.txt after byte 44417 for the remainder of Table 3 and subsequent results tables.","text":"What are the exact per-proxy regression estimates (β, 95% CIs, and standardized effects) in Table 3 and subsequent tables beyond the point estimates summarized in the abstract?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"21a401560a7916d8ce112f9063925fbb65194ec887db0b7fab18d3f5de5abf39","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["4259f9824dcc8f4683f577f282eac99cb312949fa515a61b56705fcbca739b74"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"d5f3d7b5782289dda9acbb21831c5cb3a071f02467d3e63c07dc21cd8bbf2a66","submission_id":"TQ86-b86951ab14e53a73#2"},"hash":"fb4724bdbe15440a33cf6d07c88d3353f0e12a60bd6a61115918472e340437cb","header":{"body_hash":"3b33a932d8f85f3ef5b5da0dcb89ac38b05522ba730e5e5ced9f0edadc897dac","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"1ef0b7fcce39b98f1d8a1ceadf7002bf1857558ee41b15d8ab1e1619154642a9","records_root":"bf4eab832db51d48e592724aa9aa71cb663581491bc87085c989bbaaaa73cb1e","seq":403,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"1d35982a32a3f5aeb550b893dccbb12efa565ca29a053c50a9852f926ff94344","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","kind":"INVESTIGATE","link_task":null,"settled":["0c63b29de81263afc082587531b48d2ac7a93416faaa1b1f23d7b523aa4143b2","c4a00c25280e6b1b75f85dfd7a48023155b1ac6e1df6416250a33eeed61c58b2","4a5f091890d130f6a6ff4643afc51cf86e62ecc6ae6c100f16cd2b9a138fb661","4259f9824dcc8f4683f577f282eac99cb312949fa515a61b56705fcbca739b74"],"sync_step":43,"task_id":"TQ86-b86951ab14e53a73"},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@1ba47624024fb722","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"21a401560a7916d8ce112f9063925fbb65194ec887db0b7fab18d3f5de5abf39","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"205427021f63bf032fa2809052f8643f466825d85124fda9d8304edd4e2b6265","submission_id":"TQ86-b86951ab14e53a73#done3"},"hash":"796bd2a65e3ebfaa4ebf2064150f6123b7a1de260765dea10d9cd2c208345d3a","header":{"body_hash":"f228aa3f95c7d6358211f588f8e234b438871166f73909fd77301bb129365e2f","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"fb4724bdbe15440a33cf6d07c88d3353f0e12a60bd6a61115918472e340437cb","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":404,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"7dade9584347b792e101f6c6eb62a9bb1847255780fd7bcb1158d9875a84459d","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"failures":null,"reason":"no_section_matched_terms","task_id":"nosource-question:@236708c9e09154e0","unresolved":true},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@236708c9e09154e0","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"21a401560a7916d8ce112f9063925fbb65194ec887db0b7fab18d3f5de5abf39","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"a0a5de7b29fd0de1a3436de026385cfdfcc680dab357fa414cf0ff05ccba8600","submission_id":"nosource-question:@236708c9e09154e0#unresolved"},"hash":"b1afcd7850e2976d8176a8c4751f923d877e7a49bba4a372e1421755afcb6d27","header":{"body_hash":"3b5d90d751a0a9741c8b275c11814dfd28ad012b01c9db913a353e780fd71da0","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"796bd2a65e3ebfaa4ebf2064150f6123b7a1de260765dea10d9cd2c208345d3a","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":405,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"a9e9c5e21822661f16633c2343a7299e7059ea13f2faec685b8805f42e14ad98","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TQ90-df326ef7d203e1ba","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13226197.txt","exact_quote":"Most studies employ self-report, cross-sectional correlational designs, or brief interventions, primarily reporting outcome scores but not tracing the learning process that produced them (Wang and Fan, 2025).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t90_o1","terms":["PMC13226197","Wang and Fan, 2025","in-text citation","self-report","correlational designs","outcome scores"]},{"about":["PMC13226197","Wang and Fan (2025)"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t90_q1","needed":"Read the Reference list section at the end of PMC13226197.txt (beyond byte 4779) to extract the exact bibliographic entry for Wang and Fan (2025), and check the Wang and Fan (2025) record file for its Title line.","text":"What is the full bibliographic reference entry for Wang and Fan (2025) in the references section at the end of PMC13226197.txt, and does its title match the retracted Wang J and Fan W (2025) meta-analysis ('The effect of ChatGPT...')?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"21a401560a7916d8ce112f9063925fbb65194ec887db0b7fab18d3f5de5abf39","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["214315db9fa8442f55eb00e89d6300feb373207f2668c37c10b8b36ba1e49d16","3b7d2cf1f7c6073ef69556206fa85b9491ac9dcc5232c4c20d3334aa5eee780d"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"6ad81bd03c3c7c7b334ba26d57e2c83de1c0d2c22e5ba4dd51a33ef8e435e930","submission_id":"TQ90-df326ef7d203e1ba#1"},"hash":"b02cebc4a7a6bd511b9d66eadf0b5379068967172c9b50420efb4646ddb44ffe","header":{"body_hash":"96c0eb5b14c6485969befb0bc33f9f4dcc173d7ff18b6937d538257b7c9186d6","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"b1afcd7850e2976d8176a8c4751f923d877e7a49bba4a372e1421755afcb6d27","records_root":"82460fc02667c704c1560cda94e0a757d7c6074d3adc170dcec0b1dbdb176564","seq":406,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"cc200063dbaeba5977e63da06019c6186fc0073b3e549bbc5ccdbf4174f18aa1","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":["@214315db9fa8442f","@3b7d2cf1f7c6073e"],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"INVESTIGATE","refused":[{"error":{"code":"NO_EVIDENCE","expected_by_kernel":{"missing_identifiers":["PMC13226197.txt"]},"field":"based_on","message":"a claim names only identifiers its quotes hold: add a quote of this section that holds each one listed, or leave it out of the claim","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":1,"local_id":"t90_c1"}],"task_id":"TQ90-df326ef7d203e1ba","work_key":"question:@9b3c026f5c32e8c2"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:TQ90-df326ef7d203e1ba:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"21a401560a7916d8ce112f9063925fbb65194ec887db0b7fab18d3f5de5abf39","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"a86455aa3fb03bdb84e50dc0bfdcc6ed74c6fa7095cfe337e73f0273089894b3","submission_id":"TQ90-df326ef7d203e1ba#repair1"},"hash":"d4128a339b8b1d62cdf9a519f7af5efb872e53e82d636cd2cea9d99c7b9f6610","header":{"body_hash":"3c985fb98225c8ea37358f2b5827b5fa45f9986ed468273b96a326d4dd4a3b57","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"b02cebc4a7a6bd511b9d66eadf0b5379068967172c9b50420efb4646ddb44ffe","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":407,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"ae2d0a66c0547267c8ff675c19f52632e1150da7baa90144a832d6b29e6f1c42","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TQ88-0a85161a9b6dd689","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t88_o1","t88_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t88_c1","object":"Wang and Fan (2025): most studies use self-report, cross-sectional, or brief intervention designs reporting outcome scores without tracing learning processes","predicate":"cites_for_claim","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 (Li, 2026) cites Wang and Fan (2025) to note that most AI learning studies use self-report, cross-sectional correlational designs, or brief interventions that report outcome scores without tracing the learning process."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"21a401560a7916d8ce112f9063925fbb65194ec887db0b7fab18d3f5de5abf39","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["221194311fbcbf5b6cd1524f075cc67de995b390919fc8cf79ceb3cbce5ab4b5"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"f33cb61c4f5d30834a4a98ff4f0f791be4332be656da342570ea4b832ad778af","submission_id":"TQ88-0a85161a9b6dd689#2"},"hash":"480c7c367340a85e5c16fdb89e5d7d56ac3e9346786b8665f02e26087e1d1b55","header":{"body_hash":"bd9ca7f2d3f8935c0ef9935b1f6023e819b79716d5a03c8ecc2342fcfc64ae97","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"d4128a339b8b1d62cdf9a519f7af5efb872e53e82d636cd2cea9d99c7b9f6610","records_root":"181923dd16be4b58f074904fb49d5faea9792998cd81245c1f6e86e483771cfb","seq":408,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"1b9458cded82c9702ed04ffe9dde02b5d07d6c03261515cde605ead55f408144","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","kind":"INVESTIGATE","link_task":null,"settled":["fabea67e18d63958450ae6b43cc6fc3733be94bedc393319374f351fe22dce81","221194311fbcbf5b6cd1524f075cc67de995b390919fc8cf79ceb3cbce5ab4b5"],"sync_step":43,"task_id":"TQ88-0a85161a9b6dd689"},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@1f91007433d4c197","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"21a401560a7916d8ce112f9063925fbb65194ec887db0b7fab18d3f5de5abf39","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"860fb95e115ba0215fb5c09cd1a8c6518d675d4f13906b66ac96296bad0d5ddf","submission_id":"TQ88-0a85161a9b6dd689#done3"},"hash":"98502088b4e18e37cc8d82557dcf959c9113e64539ce5eeb88e8911c7ceb9536","header":{"body_hash":"78058e6cd6c36ba6e42ea4b40c27bf8d5f6ec5cdffd73d2d4ff2ef23b5382253","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"480c7c367340a85e5c16fdb89e5d7d56ac3e9346786b8665f02e26087e1d1b55","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":409,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"1ff421705192badf659eaa87613e70e8bc5016093dbd357abfd405fbdd58dae2","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","kind":"INVESTIGATE","link_task":null,"sync_step":43,"task_id":"TQ91-1c5fa3cc293fc13b"},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@feb61873ac96c753","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"21a401560a7916d8ce112f9063925fbb65194ec887db0b7fab18d3f5de5abf39","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"57cbefd880878f2ec3def6ff8e7a43ecab0b699199f14a0df6513e41b61f523d","submission_id":"TQ91-1c5fa3cc293fc13b#done2"},"hash":"b0d55b9dc6ca2c76028e14af3f65215b3f384b2102c2f8bad3f10037489785a8","header":{"body_hash":"25c019d09b339576e16bbab7b6dc26db15ef83b81a08dc8362e3e7c78232e19a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"98502088b4e18e37cc8d82557dcf959c9113e64539ce5eeb88e8911c7ceb9536","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":410,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"f7c2f315c108818b576d5653a259c8954f6dbe58d1f546d2ffea7013a2ce29d0","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"failures":null,"reason":"no_section_matched_terms","task_id":"nosource-question:@558513dec474cadb","unresolved":true},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@558513dec474cadb","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"21a401560a7916d8ce112f9063925fbb65194ec887db0b7fab18d3f5de5abf39","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"14f68b2dc4fc8af553a03c40ce66789518b0feee42f090b7be4c2e698d4af248","submission_id":"nosource-question:@558513dec474cadb#unresolved"},"hash":"829619303a1b7f7a430fed96163213938f92e9ea2625d0e03261abb263539ced","header":{"body_hash":"139ad5dc749995d8b1905f39089a1a7d7250e90c8e13e562badb53193a067d2b","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"b0d55b9dc6ca2c76028e14af3f65215b3f384b2102c2f8bad3f10037489785a8","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":411,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"eb7ab7ae62e2b070767b83c150a2d0a6ae936c6e391ee547cafe0ee4681bb44b","command":{"allowed_records":["15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","185b12c085409e179815a1904f89185f48209d900852de0e1b718c493e1b1a5b","447783e37398d75d438cbaeb401e90d560e2d81f763d8cf087f4276dfa91df3b","50bec39de8f355e358c95af904a4c39ddfa5acffee2e72bff801582a01f3c6bd","585f13562901412016419b30c0293a6bc39f933bec3fe6a83c8a123703883c5b","62f0bf964dd532be12b91c42b3edcbf0a36512cb91abfec30e50307f32e1fbfc","670322c4448332e38947c7df9e3826a565b12d897de326b851b070c1a7c882d5","7d0f4cf57a9f67a26a843265306a5dd539a703becf91fc514857eaec50c4e03a","b3c25b44aa607d8a77f8346633ce1fea9b9391898a2db83163b4236996904dfd","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cdd1317bed284738f066704b44d5dd4769f570820b94c83647e99d58f4e6a335","f90b3011afa572d0ce598845e062847236100f838917279a2bd48ef49fabd6d8"],"directive":"TQ90-df326ef7d203e1ba","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t90_o1"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t90_c1","object":"Wang and Fan (2025)","predicate":"cites_in_text","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 cites Wang and Fan (2025) for the observation that most studies employ self-report, cross-sectional correlational designs, or brief interventions, primarily reporting outcome scores rather than tracing the learning process."}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13226197.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13226197.txt",0,4779]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"21a401560a7916d8ce112f9063925fbb65194ec887db0b7fab18d3f5de5abf39","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["6e87158352ebc7aae75121681f4435a97f581ba744ab3cc951bb93dd2b27901a"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"84b530f3062214459b52fe942b3dc005c9dff8d6d37c6db8b26fe4c88e0a3f44","submission_id":"TQ90-df326ef7d203e1ba#2"},"hash":"604d8849ceec6a27bde6d99bb27e8c56e9999b8c9517d84bd7f98fa45ebcc281","header":{"body_hash":"52b5c3180cc477ac2baf8865edaadc617e04ded3823c695611ac9c837d1fdbe5","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"829619303a1b7f7a430fed96163213938f92e9ea2625d0e03261abb263539ced","records_root":"cbbdc7b28beadfef1f6b0a52d1633e944e0a1be4332bd8f9153553e848fd31aa","seq":412,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"a0866a0254dc429e4a51113305b81ee9f23e870be0520efc7aeab479254822c3","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","kind":"INVESTIGATE","link_task":null,"settled":["3b7d2cf1f7c6073ef69556206fa85b9491ac9dcc5232c4c20d3334aa5eee780d","6e87158352ebc7aae75121681f4435a97f581ba744ab3cc951bb93dd2b27901a"],"sync_step":43,"task_id":"TQ90-df326ef7d203e1ba"},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@9b3c026f5c32e8c2","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"21a401560a7916d8ce112f9063925fbb65194ec887db0b7fab18d3f5de5abf39","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"2a34c6d9b4b1947b3cdddb8bf642dc0290682d9fbdec682d701487570b1a4456","submission_id":"TQ90-df326ef7d203e1ba#done3"},"hash":"3c5029cd593d425fe937540cd14bf62b10b72d4174cf158fb49ec145a8c16bf4","header":{"body_hash":"a0b714baae37542131c3b7d636df7966f3926223c42760febfb0d213c7618e68","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"604d8849ceec6a27bde6d99bb27e8c56e9999b8c9517d84bd7f98fa45ebcc281","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":413,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"ca9daa0fc016ab30cd7404c5e1a0871a984fc197a4d532c9a217bf0073007825","command":{"allowed_records":["00636ae681773aa2de1a3f1b7b3ba5b3caf54a805b60b3de9b571bf529e8e81a","099cebfd1758d63a8957557f3c228e2e7dd1e62a7b5adca8719ba563cc67bb76","4fc091bf9a9f6801e11120fd8e63cca1722bad42e294aa1c25fa403c29fba91b","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","6177d64ca0d9235d7db60450700c6338b488bc8d5483bf843b84b094d4254ca5","8458c2d89e0d12fa9a2fb3c673b671afe4b87156b58b0a89ad6fae110704f5ae","8c92bf85056d20709025505beac7f7cedf81c856c5f9ff02679335563b1bd467","beb271a2eb79c7b00fad16641e9fc400eea7fd2dbc197413ba1e12174f451018","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e7dfdf8e92bd43da47a01e2823f3985991b02806df968df31ae0fc3ae85c40db","ec64c94d6eb1e33dd930c3ae54f98818d5632dc353585948f7b5e33ae0e5b917"],"directive":"TQ92-092876fa74f33288","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"Source: Europe PMC PMC13314867, doi:10.3389/frma.2026.1816902. Licence: CC BY (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Copyright © 2026 George-Reyes, Romero, Merida-Cordova and Yeguas-Bolivar.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t92_o1","terms":["PMC13314867","George-Reyes et al. 2026"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13314867.txt","exact_quote":"In addition, it has been suggested that this tool can improve academic performance (Essien et al., 2024) and the development of critical thinking skills (Jalil et al., 2023; Wang and Fan, 2025).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t92_o2","terms":["Wang and Fan 2025","ChatGPT","critical thinking skills"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t92_o1","t92_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t92_c1","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (with Jalil et al., 2023: ChatGPT can improve development of critical thinking skills)","predicate":"cites_in_body","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"In the Introduction of PMC13314867 (bytes 0..5475), the sole in-text citation to Wang and Fan (2025) pairs with Jalil et al. (2023) to support that ChatGPT can improve the development of critical thinking skills."},{"about":["PMC13314867","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t92_q1","needed":"Check the Title line of the Wang and Fan (2025) meta-analysis record file to pair with the PMC13314867 Introduction citation on critical thinking skills, and check PMC13314867.txt after byte 5475 for any additional in-text citations to Wang and Fan (2025).","text":"What is the exact Title line in the Wang and Fan (2025) meta-analysis record file, and do any sections of PMC13314867.txt after byte 5475 also cite Wang and Fan (2025) in the body text?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13314867.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13314867.txt",0,5475]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"20484ff065f8d761a556afbe964cc93a80b8bef57f97198dbd2e46d940721501","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["e401cbf7c7bc5328cfada6af15f35b57a2635992ced3aefed513c3b619a8c27d","a352b5cc3246a8db265406075921ab01139805c38ffa43306c3d1cabbd7d64be","99fd304cedf1870828fb0879ca8e562a645d95be4f37d9d3309a0d0253c7e049","451a23cb11669cbcd5e285c0d4d1fc66e608521fd2ffa44d254742bede4a5237"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"e16667d17efd91f2966a62376622f068ed7c9f0e780df00788f3f36f56d557f9","submission_id":"TQ92-092876fa74f33288#1"},"hash":"73331b15d94ffb4901d616007c017a039ac786d0494c641fb3319f810067e114","header":{"body_hash":"b999d9371d099c50302fef06cf301ced3bb13d3ce075bb46572106e83d421aa1","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3c5029cd593d425fe937540cd14bf62b10b72d4174cf158fb49ec145a8c16bf4","records_root":"a9a1f349f95c55fff1de9ad7bb27f363e005f38b0c41d5c8f9f2b5f24372683b","seq":414,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"fb656bb1910b9372209c0a99388900228611ff5eb81ea335b15f52f034a95bba","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","kind":"INVESTIGATE","link_task":null,"settled":["99fd304cedf1870828fb0879ca8e562a645d95be4f37d9d3309a0d0253c7e049","451a23cb11669cbcd5e285c0d4d1fc66e608521fd2ffa44d254742bede4a5237"],"sync_step":43,"task_id":"TQ92-092876fa74f33288"},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@d21b9c09a79483d9","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"20484ff065f8d761a556afbe964cc93a80b8bef57f97198dbd2e46d940721501","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"c41df94a47698c64c97b9ec3bddf19d27ad0748ea5e2ebd4a1c47b8d49b2bd09","submission_id":"TQ92-092876fa74f33288#done2"},"hash":"da8bb4736c6d086349f3aeba853e0286c5351dcd93cb42daec1c7845381dfc69","header":{"body_hash":"326c46b5afc609aae1bfa05d7ed6af5d48d1138ebd4abd37942fc32e7a9158af","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"73331b15d94ffb4901d616007c017a039ac786d0494c641fb3319f810067e114","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":415,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"245c19403beff33192de5e7d09bf4a1d501e94732a9bb174750ac7f41d861fbf","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"failures":null,"reason":"no_section_matched_terms","task_id":"nosource-question:@7cc6df519f15ea9c","unresolved":true},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@7cc6df519f15ea9c","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"20484ff065f8d761a556afbe964cc93a80b8bef57f97198dbd2e46d940721501","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"7c5b8144ec1eb9a1db6b782faa68a9d7813d8a56631403b56934f19090f1740a","submission_id":"nosource-question:@7cc6df519f15ea9c#unresolved"},"hash":"de613c5967d0829510c69b48af50d1cde73a6a93f6f23736ed3a1de7da43664d","header":{"body_hash":"e4ecf915952b196751c1fa5617e9106d6ce54a45074eff408d025fd040af1d20","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"da8bb4736c6d086349f3aeba853e0286c5351dcd93cb42daec1c7845381dfc69","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":416,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"d01f11b119c10db494f8810acd535d88c9a17ce849d17dd17af67dbc9ab91187","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"failures":null,"reason":"no_section_matched_terms","task_id":"nosource-question:@89b02f4059c6f8d9","unresolved":true},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@89b02f4059c6f8d9","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"20484ff065f8d761a556afbe964cc93a80b8bef57f97198dbd2e46d940721501","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"7b2ff3550694c5217f5ebaa237c20c3d6f9d140fb1c016480795eda550938928","submission_id":"nosource-question:@89b02f4059c6f8d9#unresolved"},"hash":"3dc377303688fae949b801bc0fcbbb96de7dae12633fed71698949af30f22b82","header":{"body_hash":"a6cd8f61894de9462ccde97d007c549475378d1179cdd14e3d9449eebab77a49","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"de613c5967d0829510c69b48af50d1cde73a6a93f6f23736ed3a1de7da43664d","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":417,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"0ec1d8d9c7fbf8a2b6189414d43ffabdfeb90b79d23c69fa81e2a41f6f8f02e7","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"failures":null,"reason":"no_section_matched_terms","task_id":"nosource-question:@351fc14b623838e6","unresolved":true},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@351fc14b623838e6","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"20484ff065f8d761a556afbe964cc93a80b8bef57f97198dbd2e46d940721501","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"72d4f1d957a6bd9850a8d6db63057321593b4ab257b10b643a4c6cd01ae8e6cc","submission_id":"nosource-question:@351fc14b623838e6#unresolved"},"hash":"fe52ddc51479c55a73e10efd39cf4559f56650621b64aec01931f38472f7d2d2","header":{"body_hash":"5323aba2c4306b49395de6b61cb2207f03a006d10c78979559a4dfbdf2551351","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"3dc377303688fae949b801bc0fcbbb96de7dae12633fed71698949af30f22b82","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":418,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"c7626775264e320a5f5deb685e569984791956b7d9f230225d4885d4247466b1","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"failures":null,"reason":"no_section_matched_terms","task_id":"nosource-question:@48af98f8d9a6b6f0","unresolved":true},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@48af98f8d9a6b6f0","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"20484ff065f8d761a556afbe964cc93a80b8bef57f97198dbd2e46d940721501","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"067a4fc750984007f8b9f6b826c0ade9c22f2c3b11f94a543a7d574e4a895eca","submission_id":"nosource-question:@48af98f8d9a6b6f0#unresolved"},"hash":"28aff4aefd932367ddaa389be1599856672e603873a6c6dec0dbe2fcd1c39772","header":{"body_hash":"36f60f73c986ea29c840fd967a2c2cdf1c1dd8618e900e963edf182a55d2f2ac","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"fe52ddc51479c55a73e10efd39cf4559f56650621b64aec01931f38472f7d2d2","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":419,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"a86acc2bbaed3acc1f8e32926962ef71f7c72c9599c964b14884329d75db98a0","command":{"allowed_records":["290dfc9524b2b97398df608395af74f673aada35620c3da1d4fd366caf9ac5c9","48f6a240d1b804b98b8bbcd90ae332cf20a35a70ee942aa479efd66896a7ad6c","539d55b6a37b055f1ac9c6d28018d06ec959b0aef54077988cd2e341775920ce","54ec74c66b437a258847d6267dfdc9ef9b98a7214585f68d921a208bf5e2a413","6e4f3f9f907de7f4c31dc5b687de29570bb515a98fa359ec97765bde02705059","75b66684790552ec977b962824d8a4e85a41d2effc50226f9b697f7b901472c7","83393296d0bb763b34ef00ad70c22c7aba459ce284ae9cb6c5d526ee970b7d53","a8cd9991215748ee5cc9fa85613e7554b68e2c08be18e8e04afdd4eee66afe5c","b14bccfd0be9976f677cd4166f832c1817812bf16c93ba7a262100725b9465c6","ccf224838daf27b808aed618057702104630e3ba0a8e82c7751a984ec180502d","d76d4295435f00384500b58976004e0ca2bd324b42b12548be8e056ad4bd2a7d","ef069e07ea5452baa01d851837c9d4756ee134632b283ebc57473a61da89b072"],"directive":"TQ93-878a9d40f91a302d","kind":"submit","lines":[{"about":["PMC13388837","Research Questions 1-5","intelligent environment perception","multimodal L2 WTC","L2 self-efficacy","foreign language anxiety"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t93_q1","needed":"Check bytes > 5407 of PMC13388837.txt containing the Results, Discussion, and Conclusion sections (currently only bytes 0..5407 covering the Abstract and start of Introduction are shown).","text":"What are the detailed statistical estimates (e.g., correlation coefficients, regression paths, multi-group parameters, and qualitative themes) in the Results, Discussion, and Conclusion sections of PMC13388837 for Research Questions 1-5 beyond the abstract summary (which already reports the 56.19% L2 self-efficacy mediation and p = 0.068 non-significant interaction)?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",0,5407]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"20484ff065f8d761a556afbe964cc93a80b8bef57f97198dbd2e46d940721501","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":[],"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"failed_index":0}},"request_hash":"4a6324f72c60dbe449a4bfc15e077ba82ed9485f5b0fa7f147beaab405e5b620","submission_id":"TQ93-878a9d40f91a302d#1"},"hash":"98334384478fb918e8b6a195ebd274a972e74b68a7e59f14eac4e28528bd740e","header":{"body_hash":"44487aa4fdf05e71afa899b51a42d4883cce643a7217cc0b15b1e1c185238689","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"28aff4aefd932367ddaa389be1599856672e603873a6c6dec0dbe2fcd1c39772","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":420,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"b5266aa7428d19f30b084d31ed0588f5fde7998bf8fd8c8ff9e1ca2eea05020e","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"accepted":[],"attempt":1,"excluded":[],"kind":"INVESTIGATE","refused":[{"error":{"code":"BAD_FIELD","expected_by_kernel":{"maxLength":240,"minLength":1,"type":"string","x-maxUtf8Bytes":1024},"field":"text","message":"'text' is empty or exceeds its character/UTF-8 byte bound","obligation":null,"status":"error"},"index":0,"local_id":"t93_q1"}],"task_id":"TQ93-878a9d40f91a302d","work_key":"question:@46785a67d453bf07"},"from":0,"key":"task-repair:TQ93-878a9d40f91a302d:1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"20484ff065f8d761a556afbe964cc93a80b8bef57f97198dbd2e46d940721501","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"fb051d482bf772611612306682275731373efbd4c88b088e3c93fdda75752a87","submission_id":"TQ93-878a9d40f91a302d#repair1"},"hash":"05338f38aa5b3e4e3c99e9f66aaab3e117cd91ba042fa9ff6eba991cf2d6ca9b","header":{"body_hash":"23b1e8385a318a5a8a453634fcdc0344e5056369dc9c70c0880da77f2e938229","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"98334384478fb918e8b6a195ebd274a972e74b68a7e59f14eac4e28528bd740e","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":421,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"bd73cd5792041946fc122baa0daf13a223d3dc2e4afb850504b9957c351d2117","command":{"allowed_records":["181c36a3bc29675f5a0bbc1baf3b0b42d0997104f355ddab1a101dee30085cda","3708cc2df47a3e8c94329e4e446a32b9c0edd1e43b85df96519cc2f9748fb607","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","4f25f856fc060e629621e3a734f44dbbac44c09b6a246c5d7e5173c88f18f6db","650b642738e564244ed70795ba510e2e419464b4bfb01b0af5eb2181db24acc2","712ebdb36bfd152b8e53fb467e2754fa32f7d2eea2fecc6343e232d3424517a6","97cf84253454426906cebd4b2de5a280b64248803308f81d80d8efb03eb8b7d2","bf9cf5fd007b4f5dd0f9a8de0606bb2ca9ccc640e077d9fe0f9b90322e44345c","bfe4a7243c1f4d5cacfe8a729399d72f7422670356cf1b0dfc2f74f1d05df3dc","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","dfd29d54438fe5ec01424de96f328e02c5778b7a371b073e2180e8db5cbc9244"],"directive":"TQ95-bb3b2136c255d3e1","kind":"submit","lines":[{"about":["PMC13647323","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t95_q1","needed":"Read bytes 5387 to end of PMC13647323.txt (Methods, Results, study inclusion table/coding, Discussion, and References), as bytes 0..5387 cover only Abstract and Introduction up to the Problem statement heading and do not list the 42 synthesized studies or mention Wang and Fan 2025.","text":"In bytes 5387+ of PMC13647323.txt (Methods, Results, Discussion, References), which 42 primary studies are synthesized in the meta-analysis, and is Wang and Fan 2025 cited or included among them?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",0,5387]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"20484ff065f8d761a556afbe964cc93a80b8bef57f97198dbd2e46d940721501","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["5e9a270af102b644afc19eb3240694d22890b46392da99d9ca7967b5882c9c7a"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"2a6c43a85aca2e3fd03df29fb7b2368c1ed8c616867972f76d93af8828d19c58","submission_id":"TQ95-bb3b2136c255d3e1#1"},"hash":"02aac4d902f9ef83ffbcbc7192a3834e9fe215d2f1c113fe7289e795dbac047a","header":{"body_hash":"204f3e7ba4bf33275982069bd67c0d43e7d0059881977e6af5718558a7c841a0","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"05338f38aa5b3e4e3c99e9f66aaab3e117cd91ba042fa9ff6eba991cf2d6ca9b","records_root":"1ba5dcc823e1c61067366237152b63fb3505337192e9b7207cfb0de5628ace19","seq":422,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"d7ef8609993f08946f942429d041704cf6c98a39fd8e6048b973391acbf6f154","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","kind":"INVESTIGATE","link_task":null,"settled":["5e9a270af102b644afc19eb3240694d22890b46392da99d9ca7967b5882c9c7a"],"sync_step":43,"task_id":"TQ95-bb3b2136c255d3e1"},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@0a8b6799bab6edd0","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"20484ff065f8d761a556afbe964cc93a80b8bef57f97198dbd2e46d940721501","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"b1f8751a3c3b663e29dd219437eb94050243f8c27adc9f362393726e00d0ba02","submission_id":"TQ95-bb3b2136c255d3e1#done2"},"hash":"0cfa6270bf649691d7bdba903655fa68bdd1e5ec20f92a60396a336abd51d598","header":{"body_hash":"ef9d015b1154bbd7dc6b00ada00d108d20ac38b6d6b7c89b6fb3b9e150926738","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"02aac4d902f9ef83ffbcbc7192a3834e9fe215d2f1c113fe7289e795dbac047a","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":423,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"e431ce08ffc271763f3b3d185e26754b6fd82f89b40a23b835f042ef9d8b678e","command":{"allowed_records":["181c36a3bc29675f5a0bbc1baf3b0b42d0997104f355ddab1a101dee30085cda","290dfc9524b2b97398df608395af74f673aada35620c3da1d4fd366caf9ac5c9","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","75b66684790552ec977b962824d8a4e85a41d2effc50226f9b697f7b901472c7","83393296d0bb763b34ef00ad70c22c7aba459ce284ae9cb6c5d526ee970b7d53","a8cd9991215748ee5cc9fa85613e7554b68e2c08be18e8e04afdd4eee66afe5c","bfe4a7243c1f4d5cacfe8a729399d72f7422670356cf1b0dfc2f74f1d05df3dc","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","ccf224838daf27b808aed618057702104630e3ba0a8e82c7751a984ec180502d","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","d76d4295435f00384500b58976004e0ca2bd324b42b12548be8e056ad4bd2a7d","ef069e07ea5452baa01d851837c9d4756ee134632b283ebc57473a61da89b072"],"directive":"TQ94-12c54b8a8a721281","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Source: Europe PMC PMC13388837, doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1885211. Licence: CC BY (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Copyright © 2026 Li.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t94_o1","terms":["PMC13388837","Li 2026","source metadata"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Rather than serving merely as auxiliary aids for vocabulary retrieval or grammar correction, these algorithms now act as intelligent agents.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t94_o2","terms":["generative AI algorithms","intelligent agents"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13388837.txt","exact_quote":"Equipped with natural language capabilities, they frequently participate in learners’ cognitive processing and emotional regulation processes (Slamet, 2024; Wang and Fan, 2025; Yu et al., 2024).","kind":"observe","local_id":"t94_o3","terms":["Wang and Fan, 2025","cognitive processing","emotional regulation processes","Slamet, 2024","Yu et al., 2024"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t94_o1","t94_o2","t94_o3"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t94_c1","object":"generative AI algorithms equipped with natural language capabilities frequently participate in learners' cognitive processing and emotional regulation processes","predicate":"cites_Wang_and_Fan_2025_for","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13388837)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13388837) cites Wang and Fan 2025 (with Slamet, 2024; Yu et al., 2024) to state that generative AI algorithms with natural language capabilities participate in learners' cognitive processing and emotional regulation."},{"about":["PMC13388837","Wang and Fan 2025","hypotheses","results"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t94_q1","needed":"Check sections of PMC13388837.txt after byte 5407 (hypotheses continuation, methods, results, discussion, and references).","text":"What are the remaining hypotheses (e.g., H2b, H3, H4), detailed empirical dataset/sample characteristics, full quantitative/qualitative results, and the full reference entry for Wang and Fan 2025 in PMC13388837?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",0,5407]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"9e3f1a4abfdd82509c9fde48544af55584f17fdd6e26fb53f401258ee7b46bcc","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["685463a821aa21971bd2671b53932a43e7803d61ef4c8a264bc4fca92460f5e5","2994cae73418007580c6470ffe9fce7780ca91a573e4f1ff8fa8aca837f3a1da","b4b0df3fc8088e2806498e73c7017f3fec29cf871e53d350dbfc94f0089fc57e","742c1db8833126dc24fb11df0962244ed38a86392359a0d447a80954cf604b00","8c09053c56e2ae6c4733a83b10a3170f655b62974f7669589b46136c6fee5382"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"0276264563d2aa79322bf15a9ccbc1926b10209c66b38c582995c45f0e985cdb","submission_id":"TQ94-12c54b8a8a721281#1"},"hash":"0591e5d8ecbf0e0844ce338f9f9cba6a70fd0bac4931534dae8a4dd9edc7b150","header":{"body_hash":"4368aa46fc1b62e12b068c3b7387dd1870a3fb109120db9d6736885223f2e5ec","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"0cfa6270bf649691d7bdba903655fa68bdd1e5ec20f92a60396a336abd51d598","records_root":"05804c18fc54b9d2bc0ed154054cb7809700003f83cd5c0378271148534c280d","seq":424,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"1e3e1fb804e43d94d3e61d14ec8044052ff8ad4451687dff76c7439754e556b3","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","kind":"INVESTIGATE","link_task":null,"settled":["742c1db8833126dc24fb11df0962244ed38a86392359a0d447a80954cf604b00","8c09053c56e2ae6c4733a83b10a3170f655b62974f7669589b46136c6fee5382"],"sync_step":43,"task_id":"TQ94-12c54b8a8a721281"},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@56eb3823ae741b55","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"9e3f1a4abfdd82509c9fde48544af55584f17fdd6e26fb53f401258ee7b46bcc","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"640939892d3fab663664c2c81d67a8a0861664408f0dbae0b38cc8ec755d5c5e","submission_id":"TQ94-12c54b8a8a721281#done2"},"hash":"5ac693beba46a11f134b446cc929e7f4e26ce16aae3aebc156a493c1bc842dd4","header":{"body_hash":"8f21bc434a940b8f78f7b0589c8edde97836d1a7deaff96cabb2442c61a249d6","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"0591e5d8ecbf0e0844ce338f9f9cba6a70fd0bac4931534dae8a4dd9edc7b150","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":425,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"6f2707208e12221ee3239993ce94f0ac320a02f1b1f9f52904dac903442668c1","command":{"allowed_records":["290dfc9524b2b97398df608395af74f673aada35620c3da1d4fd366caf9ac5c9","48f6a240d1b804b98b8bbcd90ae332cf20a35a70ee942aa479efd66896a7ad6c","539d55b6a37b055f1ac9c6d28018d06ec959b0aef54077988cd2e341775920ce","54ec74c66b437a258847d6267dfdc9ef9b98a7214585f68d921a208bf5e2a413","6e4f3f9f907de7f4c31dc5b687de29570bb515a98fa359ec97765bde02705059","75b66684790552ec977b962824d8a4e85a41d2effc50226f9b697f7b901472c7","83393296d0bb763b34ef00ad70c22c7aba459ce284ae9cb6c5d526ee970b7d53","a8cd9991215748ee5cc9fa85613e7554b68e2c08be18e8e04afdd4eee66afe5c","b14bccfd0be9976f677cd4166f832c1817812bf16c93ba7a262100725b9465c6","ccf224838daf27b808aed618057702104630e3ba0a8e82c7751a984ec180502d","d76d4295435f00384500b58976004e0ca2bd324b42b12548be8e056ad4bd2a7d","ef069e07ea5452baa01d851837c9d4756ee134632b283ebc57473a61da89b072"],"directive":"TQ93-878a9d40f91a302d","kind":"submit","lines":[{"about":["PMC13388837","Research Questions 1-5","intelligent environment perception","multimodal L2 WTC","L2 self-efficacy","foreign language anxiety"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t93_q1","needed":"Check bytes > 5407 of PMC13388837.txt containing the Results, Discussion, and Conclusion sections (currently only bytes 0..5407 covering the Abstract and start of Introduction are shown).","text":"What are the detailed statistical estimates and qualitative themes in the Results, Discussion, and Conclusion sections of PMC13388837 for Research Questions 1-5 beyond the abstract summary?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13388837.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13388837.txt",0,5407]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"9e3f1a4abfdd82509c9fde48544af55584f17fdd6e26fb53f401258ee7b46bcc","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["a35174b256a02307a042977e454270f617f4d01e303cab684e21e5ab7becd293"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"a584526a8ab7d068ef7095d8d6dd3c004c6a238f8c11768f19c7c9e9d7ed5b94","submission_id":"TQ93-878a9d40f91a302d#2"},"hash":"8330e8e31efd74b1b05c1c84ab819faf1eb465db909bd459e01463d538525ce0","header":{"body_hash":"1f754fa6e4da004d3086b425d771064dce6d401669157bfc59365c9125c7e7be","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"5ac693beba46a11f134b446cc929e7f4e26ce16aae3aebc156a493c1bc842dd4","records_root":"5d4b9094d311d595e77fa226075a2f3934b9a79f14cb22b77e4b811cdf031566","seq":426,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"4087cd349140fcf2faeb0f681999312b6d87f6b9227980433dd079921cd9e1d2","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","kind":"INVESTIGATE","link_task":null,"settled":["a35174b256a02307a042977e454270f617f4d01e303cab684e21e5ab7becd293"],"sync_step":43,"task_id":"TQ93-878a9d40f91a302d"},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@46785a67d453bf07","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"9e3f1a4abfdd82509c9fde48544af55584f17fdd6e26fb53f401258ee7b46bcc","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"7a5c3be5e1362d961511c0519fa6897c404f23686cb21836640352e96a0b75cb","submission_id":"TQ93-878a9d40f91a302d#done3"},"hash":"ce6625dae585ffa9e7a44e5635512c21acbb4448b1e6e557526c1810c1084e9e","header":{"body_hash":"7a55e9a3fe3660d91ddc5f261adcfa71cdd0d42931ae99593837f8b755ebd575","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"8330e8e31efd74b1b05c1c84ab819faf1eb465db909bd459e01463d538525ce0","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":427,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"0eb9d01a4e829464389f810e59c256020371454c6892f2b82bb714e413f87f3e","command":{"allowed_records":["3708cc2df47a3e8c94329e4e446a32b9c0edd1e43b85df96519cc2f9748fb607","397c788a7e9c7b97248825a4b6373df62c98db2325e227fe86db2c1114fcac2a","4f25f856fc060e629621e3a734f44dbbac44c09b6a246c5d7e5173c88f18f6db","650b642738e564244ed70795ba510e2e419464b4bfb01b0af5eb2181db24acc2","712ebdb36bfd152b8e53fb467e2754fa32f7d2eea2fecc6343e232d3424517a6","79d12d31b034b083446cdb16c7b73a8b019846a2a86ccf15eca5465ceebd1b1f","97cf84253454426906cebd4b2de5a280b64248803308f81d80d8efb03eb8b7d2","a715c9f86ff1c65cc0a55bd7c5aacb6435b867f12171c51c9b4ba9b3c4c908f4","bf9cf5fd007b4f5dd0f9a8de0606bb2ca9ccc640e077d9fe0f9b90322e44345c","dfd29d54438fe5ec01424de96f328e02c5778b7a371b073e2180e8db5cbc9244","ed7d8256a59b85069106a3d445fdeb27d2f03ff94cddf445277cff4ffd8da5ec","fbeda17c3263b2fda38942cf02c7af311634035553a8e9b97ba6348294fca86a"],"directive":"TQ96-e4ba198f0cf95af2","kind":"submit","lines":[{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"GenAI-supported learning is associated with higher learning motivation on average; however, the substantial heterogeneity suggests that its motivational benefits are not uniform","kind":"observe","local_id":"t96_o1","terms":["GenAI-supported learning","learning motivation","substantial heterogeneity","abstract conclusion"]},{"doc_id":"PMC13647323.txt","exact_quote":"Future research should identify the instructional, learner, and contextual conditions under which GenAI can most effectively support students' motivation.","kind":"observe","local_id":"t96_o2","terms":["future research","instructional learner contextual conditions","GenAI motivation"]},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["t96_o1","t96_o2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t96_c1","object":"GenAI-supported learning increases motivation on average, but benefits are non-uniform across contexts","predicate":"concludes","stance":"reported","subject":"Fang et al. 2026 (PMC13647323)","text":"Fang et al. 2026 (PMC13647323) concludes that while GenAI-supported learning increases learning motivation on average, its motivational benefits are not uniform across educational contexts and require further contextual research."},{"about":["PMC13647323","Appendix A","Table 6","Table 7","Results"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t96_q1","needed":"Read sections of PMC13647323.txt after byte 5387 covering Results, Discussion, Conclusion, References, and Appendix A (Tables 6 and 7).","text":"Which 42 primary studies and 56 effect sizes are listed in Appendix A (Tables 6 and 7) of PMC13647323, and what specific pooled and subgroup statistics (k, g, 95% CI, p, Q, I2) are reported in the Results section?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",0,5387]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"a1e14a4502a8b52c5627dbfdb491bdad8cfddf1e17cc5fc758cd42f8f04f63e0","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["7a7068ee1b05cd8563b3684471d15857f1de8f6eebe209b0d370a87f76648010","5e0a113b3169774a428296637075a01642e293461fc9757b7c300b40dbd40222","6064b8f08d46e7a130aaaff1fec6ffcca8e9db5535689dd8a06d6bf7952e1c91","1681a837de17422cd80e1c233b521f234b35d9a80569c38c628d42d719f27d59"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"af16acbe144a28b35b26c153d5e87ac8788d562984d555c3c04491feefde57ce","submission_id":"TQ96-e4ba198f0cf95af2#1"},"hash":"7206d4b318237c63a0140e9e2c2b34e5fb10735b4df46f1ea5bc2077816f3c99","header":{"body_hash":"41ea97648d62ed441c69d82ef4ebf846e832daef965a00709ddae6f33601ec7c","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ce6625dae585ffa9e7a44e5635512c21acbb4448b1e6e557526c1810c1084e9e","records_root":"a960ffdc9b51b2331fb1b026eabd4d1bd6029e8623d9630987593fa1034bcaf1","seq":428,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"619db5d6ee3f74138e0a73f6a62621d94ff2d93dafc5c51e46d49984e60bcadd","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","kind":"INVESTIGATE","link_task":null,"settled":["6064b8f08d46e7a130aaaff1fec6ffcca8e9db5535689dd8a06d6bf7952e1c91","1681a837de17422cd80e1c233b521f234b35d9a80569c38c628d42d719f27d59"],"sync_step":43,"task_id":"TQ96-e4ba198f0cf95af2"},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@e94e081d7f94da9b","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a1e14a4502a8b52c5627dbfdb491bdad8cfddf1e17cc5fc758cd42f8f04f63e0","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"17e9a7cb99df6b071c8c4e770d12760d1836f50798c379dd8ef6cb5cebcff7e3","submission_id":"TQ96-e4ba198f0cf95af2#done2"},"hash":"9b22873e97bf7df37e59aaab91dbf32fc24194e521d68da755d1f8b7cd82115b","header":{"body_hash":"f3136f6f84977a14ae60e74fd9e4adcf92880a951a5c5c132cff085dbf7816c3","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"7206d4b318237c63a0140e9e2c2b34e5fb10735b4df46f1ea5bc2077816f3c99","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":429,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"e480aad85635761c591f978e4ccb148a78c7c6e9a43008e9c6aa60e9294a203f","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","kind":"INVESTIGATE","link_task":null,"sync_step":43,"task_id":"TQ98-eada0b02c986bd55"},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@f1802200fef48ed6","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a1e14a4502a8b52c5627dbfdb491bdad8cfddf1e17cc5fc758cd42f8f04f63e0","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"0d47672a6f1b11c480bb78a81b9192abe4ccee0e65c4de71c7fb4038bf1ba975","submission_id":"TQ98-eada0b02c986bd55#done2"},"hash":"bc2fa6edbf232a07423ce21e8099946aa2ad197c28c2cafbe77841856a73f93c","header":{"body_hash":"66c0abe684df814d4215cac3d2ea5f8cb189bb5da4b708790192cd10e102ce26","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"9b22873e97bf7df37e59aaab91dbf32fc24194e521d68da755d1f8b7cd82115b","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":430,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"ec83d9d9f9388142dd82cbed6118950b420437802e30e041f27fb6027e856517","command":{"allowed_records":["3708cc2df47a3e8c94329e4e446a32b9c0edd1e43b85df96519cc2f9748fb607","397c788a7e9c7b97248825a4b6373df62c98db2325e227fe86db2c1114fcac2a","4f25f856fc060e629621e3a734f44dbbac44c09b6a246c5d7e5173c88f18f6db","650b642738e564244ed70795ba510e2e419464b4bfb01b0af5eb2181db24acc2","712ebdb36bfd152b8e53fb467e2754fa32f7d2eea2fecc6343e232d3424517a6","79d12d31b034b083446cdb16c7b73a8b019846a2a86ccf15eca5465ceebd1b1f","97cf84253454426906cebd4b2de5a280b64248803308f81d80d8efb03eb8b7d2","a715c9f86ff1c65cc0a55bd7c5aacb6435b867f12171c51c9b4ba9b3c4c908f4","bf9cf5fd007b4f5dd0f9a8de0606bb2ca9ccc640e077d9fe0f9b90322e44345c","dfd29d54438fe5ec01424de96f328e02c5778b7a371b073e2180e8db5cbc9244","ed7d8256a59b85069106a3d445fdeb27d2f03ff94cddf445277cff4ffd8da5ec","fbeda17c3263b2fda38942cf02c7af311634035553a8e9b97ba6348294fca86a"],"directive":"TQ97-3c6d0c9e320d1a1f","kind":"submit","lines":[{"about":["PMC13647323","H-1a..H-3","moderator statistics","publication bias"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t97_q1","needed":"Read the Results and Discussion sections of PMC13647323.txt (after byte 5387) to record the specific effect sizes, heterogeneity statistics, and p-values for intrinsic/extrinsic motivation and each tested moderator.","text":"What are the exact quantitative meta-analytic results for hypotheses H-1a..H-3 (intrinsic vs. extrinsic motivation effect sizes, subgroup g/Q/p statistics for each moderator, and publication bias tests) in PMC13647323?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",0,5387]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"a1e14a4502a8b52c5627dbfdb491bdad8cfddf1e17cc5fc758cd42f8f04f63e0","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["fb15414b103c03f1b04bcd20bd8d67dd39311a72e0e11532b6976b0046fc7003"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"5d162e4d4498487ec539d8e237693004ce44754c5e13b915c94f3cd80da9ceb5","submission_id":"TQ97-3c6d0c9e320d1a1f#1"},"hash":"7f4e29351fc4adfaf3e093a4d0aec6707908fed17aa38466c129c85e15873b37","header":{"body_hash":"a579777e9278ac0da2f560d86be517e682047fcdfd0515adb1d1eec3227ef7fd","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"bc2fa6edbf232a07423ce21e8099946aa2ad197c28c2cafbe77841856a73f93c","records_root":"03776782fa274ea7b5c85af061619b166a45a1241361c9f627258a673bc8c25a","seq":431,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"40bd650163de1e035434ec9bfd33955c82e8d0db62e23624866809472f39193d","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","kind":"INVESTIGATE","link_task":null,"settled":["fb15414b103c03f1b04bcd20bd8d67dd39311a72e0e11532b6976b0046fc7003"],"sync_step":43,"task_id":"TQ97-3c6d0c9e320d1a1f"},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@4bc6228cb980de6b","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a1e14a4502a8b52c5627dbfdb491bdad8cfddf1e17cc5fc758cd42f8f04f63e0","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"d9322702632cfeb51d2f9778d623a303b6572f677db8eba142771af13fac31c3","submission_id":"TQ97-3c6d0c9e320d1a1f#done2"},"hash":"369db2b69dcbc0ce9f8d901191be1d3e560de41cbc065a2110047e966c26e028","header":{"body_hash":"20fd4d0b20b23b6f8c71365c1da7720851d543b8e66ae1267574eda185ebebe0","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"7f4e29351fc4adfaf3e093a4d0aec6707908fed17aa38466c129c85e15873b37","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":432,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"1384ec35d7c5f2c60b4410ed34f57a5ef9323e6ef33419667b8c98d201650f74","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","kind":"INVESTIGATE","link_task":null,"sync_step":43,"task_id":"TQ100-65ce733227b10e28"},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@bcaa0d216e028f4a","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a1e14a4502a8b52c5627dbfdb491bdad8cfddf1e17cc5fc758cd42f8f04f63e0","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"fe044aa753bbe1d139c1972aa718cffa45e7ba3aa500ea30f4896277820ff773","submission_id":"TQ100-65ce733227b10e28#done2"},"hash":"c348a0c51cdba94323abac2a356b6089f3c496cf7bfdaf586df3d46f0c1fd347","header":{"body_hash":"e7f12a08d4cd51459fbdd4aba76b14f6aead0ab6cf620fab5aa1ac0159ad4578","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"369db2b69dcbc0ce9f8d901191be1d3e560de41cbc065a2110047e966c26e028","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":433,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"ad7c974d2517cb9ff7ee7573d04f1bc445501592ae19cc90ef5334d4eec751d3","command":{"allowed_records":["181c36a3bc29675f5a0bbc1baf3b0b42d0997104f355ddab1a101dee30085cda","3708cc2df47a3e8c94329e4e446a32b9c0edd1e43b85df96519cc2f9748fb607","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","4f25f856fc060e629621e3a734f44dbbac44c09b6a246c5d7e5173c88f18f6db","650b642738e564244ed70795ba510e2e419464b4bfb01b0af5eb2181db24acc2","712ebdb36bfd152b8e53fb467e2754fa32f7d2eea2fecc6343e232d3424517a6","97cf84253454426906cebd4b2de5a280b64248803308f81d80d8efb03eb8b7d2","bf9cf5fd007b4f5dd0f9a8de0606bb2ca9ccc640e077d9fe0f9b90322e44345c","bfe4a7243c1f4d5cacfe8a729399d72f7422670356cf1b0dfc2f74f1d05df3dc","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","dfd29d54438fe5ec01424de96f328e02c5778b7a371b073e2180e8db5cbc9244"],"directive":"TQ99-864f44b832c268fb","kind":"submit","lines":[{"about":["PMC13647323","Wang and Fan 2025","databases","primary studies"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t99_q1","needed":"Check PMC13647323.txt after byte 5387 (Problem statement, Methods, Results, and References sections), as bytes 0..5387 only state '42 controlled experimental and quasi-experimental studies involving 6,059 participants' (already recorded in @3708cc2df47a3e8c) and do not mention Wang and Fan 2025, search databases, or individual included studies.","text":"Does PMC13647323 cite Wang and Fan 2025, and what databases and specific primary studies (of the 42 included studies) does its meta-analysis synthesize?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",0,5387]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"a1e14a4502a8b52c5627dbfdb491bdad8cfddf1e17cc5fc758cd42f8f04f63e0","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["f932ecfc2bfae7b78577a6dce0243238a53d0b98dd0c6d2dd0649f02c41f81e2"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"ca55c81864dda9b6e52e660b7b3b1eba5b9722e6802da97e87f83eea4d10178e","submission_id":"TQ99-864f44b832c268fb#1"},"hash":"15af6b8c10df78fa718a8246185f54b1fa089dfe5af41dd85fd58cbba84a056e","header":{"body_hash":"dd2b30abdc7dea3f2741d78f351927e8a27738188dd03045df65ff127626e3d1","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"c348a0c51cdba94323abac2a356b6089f3c496cf7bfdaf586df3d46f0c1fd347","records_root":"0a03ebceb7706b284f1fcd15866888c875fca6249096b239982cb96696a8e126","seq":434,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"ed457e86d4b59fcd0fedf059a9f0ece440bfc79ced9aff8a8b5bd553e292aa07","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","kind":"INVESTIGATE","link_task":null,"settled":["f932ecfc2bfae7b78577a6dce0243238a53d0b98dd0c6d2dd0649f02c41f81e2"],"sync_step":43,"task_id":"TQ99-864f44b832c268fb"},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@36c5a3072b9bcb87","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a1e14a4502a8b52c5627dbfdb491bdad8cfddf1e17cc5fc758cd42f8f04f63e0","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"13cd2b0b810ef94705fb351f14c029670c809c297a86989ac7c72a588cdfb620","submission_id":"TQ99-864f44b832c268fb#done2"},"hash":"c292b803b163a7272648bd771a91c388eb010816c289837d8ad124e8c0e5109d","header":{"body_hash":"a9deaa040fca66e6ffdc578e2cc3d317fb0b73fbb3f7df5615b9016b42b60e78","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"15af6b8c10df78fa718a8246185f54b1fa089dfe5af41dd85fd58cbba84a056e","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":435,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"c56a4d4ce3f1be8c979eb48ae8dffa88a01e1267370d7aa0d94b65c4bb5d55bf","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"failures":null,"reason":"no_section_matched_terms","task_id":"nosource-question:@c589d865c3fe6437","unresolved":true},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@c589d865c3fe6437","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a1e14a4502a8b52c5627dbfdb491bdad8cfddf1e17cc5fc758cd42f8f04f63e0","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"481f0def336c90d58ba42704f7bec6301ff7ee582c0774322ea9ef8ea03f3928","submission_id":"nosource-question:@c589d865c3fe6437#unresolved"},"hash":"7d4155bed2688d9041f59d12eb616bccc0616390c926b2a3a5ef249a1c7cb3f0","header":{"body_hash":"dedddce1400f2c049f435f0422051936edbd5a66b6e7e4783d33604577aac807","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"c292b803b163a7272648bd771a91c388eb010816c289837d8ad124e8c0e5109d","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":436,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"ae2175cb8084d9d6b913c27f873ace8bd6e115d41a956f5f307b844449c935d2","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"failures":null,"reason":"no_section_matched_terms","task_id":"nosource-question:@3fef8a5af8df4d02","unresolved":true},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@3fef8a5af8df4d02","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a1e14a4502a8b52c5627dbfdb491bdad8cfddf1e17cc5fc758cd42f8f04f63e0","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"87cf4efd7b0398194736c1df263563f596c626000386d317259d66da763e7d9e","submission_id":"nosource-question:@3fef8a5af8df4d02#unresolved"},"hash":"85a6819e0ad74a86fdf7a0e02ffe5144353c6e3215354f77e54d4002748a0d30","header":{"body_hash":"9e2dd547179f77851b659326cd945d0517b705d117881c703d516b03b2cfe5e6","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"7d4155bed2688d9041f59d12eb616bccc0616390c926b2a3a5ef249a1c7cb3f0","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":437,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"e1db2378aae1ec7dd6e22b34b6837df76d874b84682722c37be4132793020924","command":{"allowed_records":["181c36a3bc29675f5a0bbc1baf3b0b42d0997104f355ddab1a101dee30085cda","3708cc2df47a3e8c94329e4e446a32b9c0edd1e43b85df96519cc2f9748fb607","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","4f25f856fc060e629621e3a734f44dbbac44c09b6a246c5d7e5173c88f18f6db","650b642738e564244ed70795ba510e2e419464b4bfb01b0af5eb2181db24acc2","712ebdb36bfd152b8e53fb467e2754fa32f7d2eea2fecc6343e232d3424517a6","97cf84253454426906cebd4b2de5a280b64248803308f81d80d8efb03eb8b7d2","bf9cf5fd007b4f5dd0f9a8de0606bb2ca9ccc640e077d9fe0f9b90322e44345c","bfe4a7243c1f4d5cacfe8a729399d72f7422670356cf1b0dfc2f74f1d05df3dc","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","dfd29d54438fe5ec01424de96f328e02c5778b7a371b073e2180e8db5cbc9244"],"directive":"TQ101-d17a8b0ba535d912","kind":"submit","lines":[{"about":["PMC13647323","Wang and Fan 2025"],"kind":"question","local_id":"t101_q1","needed":"Check PMC13647323.txt from byte 5387 onward (starting at 'Problem statement' through the literature review, methods, results, and tables) for citations to Wang and Fan (2025), and check the corpus record file for Wang and Fan 2025 for its 'Title: The effect of ChatGPT...' line.","text":"Which statements, effect sizes, comparisons, or table rows in PMC13647323 after byte 5387 (starting under 'Problem statement') cite Wang and Fan 2025, and what is the Title line quote in the meta-analysis's own record file?"}],"scope":{"docs":["PMC13647323.txt"],"ranges":[["PMC13647323.txt",0,5387]],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"a1e14a4502a8b52c5627dbfdb491bdad8cfddf1e17cc5fc758cd42f8f04f63e0","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["3dbc48dbd3b302af41275844bf7c6df339c6744c41fe98fe036f2050f191d980"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"0ec2ac1af8df51a7b364d84a784c5ef15d72d3c52ecb5232f8d660bd2d8791b6","submission_id":"TQ101-d17a8b0ba535d912#1"},"hash":"53646b8b9886de2e182a4851ff163753fd0cae159113375ac2d282fe46acfe15","header":{"body_hash":"9616d071945699605461ac4bfaca77462a2dce0ae2e0ad44319a588cabdf5341","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"85a6819e0ad74a86fdf7a0e02ffe5144353c6e3215354f77e54d4002748a0d30","records_root":"fd3529ae691f27055f4cec8e563cc4db5d7ce0f5824bbc077fa33ad1034daf80","seq":438,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"2c2452534a8eeb2da7d23d64d3463540bf7973305bd70c482f96fd6e80a7fd61","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","kind":"INVESTIGATE","link_task":null,"settled":["3dbc48dbd3b302af41275844bf7c6df339c6744c41fe98fe036f2050f191d980"],"sync_step":43,"task_id":"TQ101-d17a8b0ba535d912"},"from":0,"key":"task:question:@ad17b23071ac5b24","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a1e14a4502a8b52c5627dbfdb491bdad8cfddf1e17cc5fc758cd42f8f04f63e0","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"78dec3282744848272040162e9a9540b377ce89c2f60ef4223fb217d72ebd168","submission_id":"TQ101-d17a8b0ba535d912#done2"},"hash":"83724cd6016508a49f95d48968c5f0e5f3fc66990b995485605e142eb82f4d32","header":{"body_hash":"e401c8484885d2809d310a5e1c443bb79f8e0aab62a88577ed4b59ec518285c5","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"53646b8b9886de2e182a4851ff163753fd0cae159113375ac2d282fe46acfe15","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":439,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"6bdc7da23ae5ff53b09a66d7b8a27085ec7e01d036aca6f57b0f6b67acdd0830","command":{"allowed_records":["04588ef5a34c56f45b9b03fffb833e4377f0c87c5d6a96285ccaafbb43c64c4b","04fe4cc52446ded29d3b964dc683a0a157a9fe61a5a18d4a3b414b4b8e43f97e","16fdfb67a3dbd78260306f5f63b10c85bc78e6157a493af2afdaf7d4b71e5d6f","181c36a3bc29675f5a0bbc1baf3b0b42d0997104f355ddab1a101dee30085cda","18d056e2dc42a0ea7e940872e5adf831b46c978bc66afb5e9ae08faec28eb6c3","1bbc6687f9d17196e9f1a40e85d9a6474a6d5f6c5587b928a03de18af41b226b","1c6f7b49947dced4ff20fdf3398385257a068828d60f0c9b27e5da6d7992d32c","214315db9fa8442f55eb00e89d6300feb373207f2668c37c10b8b36ba1e49d16","221194311fbcbf5b6cd1524f075cc67de995b390919fc8cf79ceb3cbce5ab4b5","273ae79a00ff65a3dfbf30a17732a330331b5443fcb966097d819b84fe8fc05a","2994cae73418007580c6470ffe9fce7780ca91a573e4f1ff8fa8aca837f3a1da","2fb29e43a710ad935fa150c296059c5b270a26504044d7da4f9b473137bcdc70","33dbc45b04e1c60120da627c1d54cfc7daa06280791594c1ffaf092a77c2a9b0","34a14a2d9d4a7a9e0e6a76cde5ae6bc7e570dbc44bccef9e0f1987ba269550e1","34d4fb6f8ed13a7c0fe2cdbf3774538b15dfa58cbe04981cbddd4a56e6da0565","35f55c061bdf705ea3d77e178182abeb6f3ca3b87da08350c384848651b48b40","36a7360f76c796d49d30c3f6b1e6df7d9ca1dcad3955c95a4d2c0312bfbb461b","40e9455fa5f2288d9a34f907630033676612039414d027280018f9a24a866fb9","447ee3fa8fcffbc704b28fbccba5c8c6739738877f740daea6bf85460ef1f6c2","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","493109aa40be1afa09c9f5c40613d4eba21938a6a2b5f43747024f8edfe2ab05","4bbf122b34957c8acf0b678e97ba7662ee3b93bf1579c3e490bff5ca08740096","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54b23081e73fd5f2d0f81760fe4d80fd61f86f29b201c7d232e9ccb5a40e2c4a","60a25afb0da8110108e8e0f1684160fdc69c00bf2f76d65d9c9d0964b7ef574d","685463a821aa21971bd2671b53932a43e7803d61ef4c8a264bc4fca92460f5e5","68728c3225bac52dc5b734cab892540be7bc202629dcca7e7c2fee6405943ef5","6a7729235c4b15e24eaaac404d41bd4b023a9ce2b4bf9f6988e5b7d96a92e1ee","6b1dc1772369965fb189de452f7c316444f572544a38f4a0f00c387ed2b938ae","6e87158352ebc7aae75121681f4435a97f581ba744ab3cc951bb93dd2b27901a","7154e5d20afda66421e640dce8eb81f6d725b37ed48113f888fd5474b1fcf77e","718e062d5da7611cc683f734c761f61efc42bde3c484a84601c7d4c7f2bce1a4","742c1db8833126dc24fb11df0962244ed38a86392359a0d447a80954cf604b00","7f89e5d4a8c3d15f00840feb20f8b98056a98b94e3c1a5bf67fe312915f950d9","845eeff65be44e52a74d9cb4b0c345a698f9a67ab0a1e561a303cc8846843f09","96ea2489d04437be245ae9141bf2fdaccc0a2ed4736bca96b05636b84cb39c61","99fd304cedf1870828fb0879ca8e562a645d95be4f37d9d3309a0d0253c7e049","9f8a18dcb79900654a9b027395dcc293d30d9d5b32832751f587cf74ee49138f","9fb11adb29d4c09fbcc7be00546bacc8560e33b2efdfffdd96f10f7c0eda9c67","9fd06bae684a9110374c5fb9d4f5ad68e9be75363f5e5c384ad2c579f95cb139","9fdb47f636c92d84c494448402e45626a0de35ac6844575976b21e5b7430fc77","a352b5cc3246a8db265406075921ab01139805c38ffa43306c3d1cabbd7d64be","aa3e3319856c40999d7ec64635618670d9e798fd81044262a185ebe07d7e4a14","ab748f39834204f2fd03a1b68f76e0124a8d48937673b5cb79614a2059212ab1","ada8a25696094f0678ec004dca6940095d24fdaf4f62729cac9391b1e5a75d6d","b3bd27d3ba9c5f0e7de72437ad74079f5643efbf87e22e18f8c4a1b23a5d795f","b4b0df3fc8088e2806498e73c7017f3fec29cf871e53d350dbfc94f0089fc57e","b4b926d03621298c80844a13e4214af41ec3b93fd0f2d3e019f26528a16ca5c0","bfe4a7243c1f4d5cacfe8a729399d72f7422670356cf1b0dfc2f74f1d05df3dc","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","c8d0593020f89043b700bae65685d25a2604025c598397da438fee1f10e2b0ae","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e0676eeb1d1c9297167b3510ad0b40f85e93f082c9dc0630b60029f45f851b62","e401cbf7c7bc5328cfada6af15f35b57a2635992ced3aefed513c3b619a8c27d","e5464a9c67ea781f936eb0fe4f4b1587e33675c765f52d760dc66589c0214f0d","e8912985e6037b252a7a37444123107c88302dfcbe0a041d990bf49ea8f7de75","e8c474da69c2e5b36422b9f13d96076e16ef745a3b9aac6e04c87ab4560bd45e","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e","f826c61786e76fcc384adfdde59dac7095e998fae0abc4627a30d8517b548d5f","f828ba66084867c01d399c3e210dc4f70f6245cb037c2c22096ef69c8ab37ca0","f8bd5f06416f38881195c3906330f73dbe68484134c0eb8d6b6b751711486ee7","ff7476f8cc35422263e3f0116ec8ba13b96b2b148381695e3b78c1fb040741b6"],"directive":"TS102-f794abfb8041eaa5","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":20250506,"based_on":["@ff7476f8cc354222","@9fd06bae684a9110","@e8c474da69c2e5b3","@1c6f7b49947dced4","@aa3e3319856c4099","@9fdb47f636c92d84"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t102_c1","object":"Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 2025 May 6;12:621 (doi:10.1057/s41599-025-04787-y)","predicate":"published_in","stance":"reported","subject":"Wang and Fan 2025","text":"Wang and Fan 2025 ('The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis') was published in Humanit Soc Sci Commun (2025;12:621)."},{"as_of":20260422,"based_on":["@ff7476f8cc354222","@9fd06bae684a9110","@e0676eeb1d1c9297","@ab748f39834204f2","@1c6f7b49947dced4","@aa3e3319856c4099","@6a7729235c4b15e2","@718e062d5da7611c"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t102_c2","object":"22 April 2026 (Humanit Soc Sci Commun 2026;13:528, doi:10.1057/s41599-026-07310-z); record contains bibliographic facts only","predicate":"retracted_on","stance":"reported","subject":"Wang and Fan 2025","text":"Wang and Fan 2025 was retracted on 22 April 2026 via retraction note Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 2026;13:528 (doi:10.1057/s41599-026-07310-z); its record has bibliographic facts only (CC BY-NC-ND)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@845eeff65be44e52","@ada8a25696094f06","@b3bd27d3ba9c5f0e","@f826c61786e76fcc","@f828ba66084867c0","@214315db9fa8442f","@ff7476f8cc354222","@1c6f7b49947dced4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t102_c3","object":"most studies employ self-report, cross-sectional correlational designs, or brief interventions reporting outcome scores without tracing learning processes","predicate":"cites_Wang_and_Fan_2025_for","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) cites Wang and Fan 2025 to state that most studies use self-report, cross-sectional correlational designs, or brief interventions reporting outcome scores without tracing the learning process."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@845eeff65be44e52","@e8912985e6037b25","@04588ef5a34c56f4","@ff7476f8cc354222","@1c6f7b49947dced4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t102_c4","object":"Meta-analysis of prior studies; Metacognition: High; Engagement: Moderate; Near/Far transfer: —; Data: Mixed; Context: Self-regulated learning with GenAI","predicate":"tabulates_Wang_and_Fan_2025_as","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In a comparison table row, Li 2026 (PMC13226197) lists Wang and Fan 2025 as a meta-analysis of prior studies on self-regulated learning with GenAI (mixed data; metacognition: High; engagement: Moderate; transfer: —)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@60a25afb0da81101","@6b1dc1772369965f","@447ee3fa8fcffbc7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t102_c5","object":"within-session learner event sequences; EdNet-KT1 dataset (Kwang 2020) and EdNet paper (Choi et al. 2020)","predicate":"defines_analysis_and_dataset","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 assumes within-session time-sequenced learner events as its unit of analysis (interaction, session, and short-horizon outcomes) and lists the EdNet-KT1 dataset (Kwang 2020) and Choi et al. (2020)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@1bbc6687f9d17196","@493109aa40be1afa","@36a7360f76c796d4","@2fb29e43a710ad93","@33dbc45b04e1c601","@e401cbf7c7bc5328","@a352b5cc3246a8db","@9f8a18dcb7990065","@ff7476f8cc354222","@1c6f7b49947dced4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t102_c6","object":"suggestion that ChatGPT can improve the development of critical thinking skills (with Jalil et al., 2023)","predicate":"cites_Wang_and_Fan_2025_for","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) cites Wang and Fan 2025 (with Jalil et al., 2023) to support the statement that ChatGPT has been suggested to improve the development of critical thinking skills."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@35f55c061bdf705e","@34d4fb6f8ed13a7c","@16fdfb67a3dbd782","@9f8a18dcb7990065","@ff7476f8cc354222","@1c6f7b49947dced4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t102_c7","object":"importance of psychometrically sound instruments for examining educational phenomena related to AI (after reporting alpha=0.943, omega=0.944)","predicate":"cites_Wang_and_Fan_2025_for","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) cites Wang and Fan 2025 (with Crompton and Burke, 2023) to support the importance of psychometrically sound instruments for examining AI-related educational phenomena."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@685463a821aa2197","@2994cae734180075","@b4b0df3fc8088e28","@ff7476f8cc354222","@1c6f7b49947dced4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t102_c8","object":"generative AI algorithms with natural language capabilities frequently participate in learners' cognitive processing and emotional regulation processes","predicate":"cites_Wang_and_Fan_2025_for","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13388837) cites Wang and Fan 2025 (with Slamet, 2024; Yu et al., 2024) to support that generative AI algorithms with natural language capabilities participate in cognitive processing and emotional regulation."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@68728c3225bac52d","@34a14a2d9d4a7a9e"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t102_c9","object":"4-item domain-specific efficacy scale adapted from Wang et al. (2014) across listening, speaking, reading, and writing","predicate":"measures_outcome","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 adopts a 4-item domain-specific efficacy scale framework from Wang et al. (2014) covering competence belief measurements in listening, speaking, reading, and writing."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@54b23081e73fd5f2","@7f89e5d4a8c3d15f","@ff7476f8cc354222","@1c6f7b49947dced4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t102_c10","object":"ChatGPT associated with better academic outcomes, affective-motivational states, and dispositions toward higher-order thinking","predicate":"cites_Wang_and_Fan_2025_for","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"PMC13647323 cites Wang and Fan 2025 (with Deng et al., 2025) as evidence that ChatGPT has been associated with better academic outcomes, affective-motivational states, and dispositions toward higher-order thinking."}],"scope":{"docs":[],"ranges":[],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"a1e14a4502a8b52c5627dbfdb491bdad8cfddf1e17cc5fc758cd42f8f04f63e0","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["daa5c03af4d4b97c70f9e627d316a9f25531702dae108b3635c9c9607bc12b80","ce1a2b688339183a3ec0d9e74f2c3f804bd737e880aa9b669ebbb979c0fab31b","3b76fd65fa1500f84c8c260c31b532c68b447acdfd9c657b02155c01a9e67b40","4ba7ea0ea1a9f1b0c123cab083cec0f14fdb213c9d4a2e12dac85a221d5a6159","549f5885147f7c3c424b17d0b218949d90f2a45b1ec799c5341f629670e75d37","c1708805b937256d0a13433264d74ec4b72c693560c844f81a227eb1331ed6db","352306c2958bb4fd9761973f28584220178a43665f508935a64f7082e15a4a36","7a74b7ed727b88eb820d1e6f762a590735d35b36f7816a66fb31d37c709962a5","8a268ba0014e1b70e0fe57a677ae6edca2f41ada1779ce0f1954ffcc81fa7dc2","3bd1ac258682306f1ac33667540b6ff5d17ac228df6de670c59bbb1f97e342da"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"3fb02801344d91bfaec7544d796f6e265cabe85324b64175e3d45983fcd0d094","submission_id":"TS102-f794abfb8041eaa5#1"},"hash":"4fba209b419e8aacbbed492fec77f79980c21a90de92b4e85287c04644236497","header":{"body_hash":"ddca84ab83c0c6c2ec34fd13e2877a7595d1dffa7006227ccdb5c505bf97a802","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"83724cd6016508a49f95d48968c5f0e5f3fc66990b995485605e142eb82f4d32","records_root":"0dc877a20f1468f1f29d0b5bfe26d095dd8807b8dc98e59ea7a9c5b64bc81e1e","seq":440,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"68087afc1b93a1ec9118243cd461d86d46c3888f4f1c37cdba7a26617e6f4e05","command":{"allowed_records":["04588ef5a34c56f45b9b03fffb833e4377f0c87c5d6a96285ccaafbb43c64c4b","04fe4cc52446ded29d3b964dc683a0a157a9fe61a5a18d4a3b414b4b8e43f97e","16fdfb67a3dbd78260306f5f63b10c85bc78e6157a493af2afdaf7d4b71e5d6f","181c36a3bc29675f5a0bbc1baf3b0b42d0997104f355ddab1a101dee30085cda","18d056e2dc42a0ea7e940872e5adf831b46c978bc66afb5e9ae08faec28eb6c3","1bbc6687f9d17196e9f1a40e85d9a6474a6d5f6c5587b928a03de18af41b226b","1c6f7b49947dced4ff20fdf3398385257a068828d60f0c9b27e5da6d7992d32c","214315db9fa8442f55eb00e89d6300feb373207f2668c37c10b8b36ba1e49d16","221194311fbcbf5b6cd1524f075cc67de995b390919fc8cf79ceb3cbce5ab4b5","273ae79a00ff65a3dfbf30a17732a330331b5443fcb966097d819b84fe8fc05a","2994cae73418007580c6470ffe9fce7780ca91a573e4f1ff8fa8aca837f3a1da","2fb29e43a710ad935fa150c296059c5b270a26504044d7da4f9b473137bcdc70","33dbc45b04e1c60120da627c1d54cfc7daa06280791594c1ffaf092a77c2a9b0","34a14a2d9d4a7a9e0e6a76cde5ae6bc7e570dbc44bccef9e0f1987ba269550e1","34d4fb6f8ed13a7c0fe2cdbf3774538b15dfa58cbe04981cbddd4a56e6da0565","35f55c061bdf705ea3d77e178182abeb6f3ca3b87da08350c384848651b48b40","36a7360f76c796d49d30c3f6b1e6df7d9ca1dcad3955c95a4d2c0312bfbb461b","40e9455fa5f2288d9a34f907630033676612039414d027280018f9a24a866fb9","447ee3fa8fcffbc704b28fbccba5c8c6739738877f740daea6bf85460ef1f6c2","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","493109aa40be1afa09c9f5c40613d4eba21938a6a2b5f43747024f8edfe2ab05","4bbf122b34957c8acf0b678e97ba7662ee3b93bf1579c3e490bff5ca08740096","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","54b23081e73fd5f2d0f81760fe4d80fd61f86f29b201c7d232e9ccb5a40e2c4a","60a25afb0da8110108e8e0f1684160fdc69c00bf2f76d65d9c9d0964b7ef574d","685463a821aa21971bd2671b53932a43e7803d61ef4c8a264bc4fca92460f5e5","68728c3225bac52dc5b734cab892540be7bc202629dcca7e7c2fee6405943ef5","6a7729235c4b15e24eaaac404d41bd4b023a9ce2b4bf9f6988e5b7d96a92e1ee","6b1dc1772369965fb189de452f7c316444f572544a38f4a0f00c387ed2b938ae","6e87158352ebc7aae75121681f4435a97f581ba744ab3cc951bb93dd2b27901a","7154e5d20afda66421e640dce8eb81f6d725b37ed48113f888fd5474b1fcf77e","718e062d5da7611cc683f734c761f61efc42bde3c484a84601c7d4c7f2bce1a4","742c1db8833126dc24fb11df0962244ed38a86392359a0d447a80954cf604b00","7f89e5d4a8c3d15f00840feb20f8b98056a98b94e3c1a5bf67fe312915f950d9","845eeff65be44e52a74d9cb4b0c345a698f9a67ab0a1e561a303cc8846843f09","96ea2489d04437be245ae9141bf2fdaccc0a2ed4736bca96b05636b84cb39c61","99fd304cedf1870828fb0879ca8e562a645d95be4f37d9d3309a0d0253c7e049","9f8a18dcb79900654a9b027395dcc293d30d9d5b32832751f587cf74ee49138f","9fb11adb29d4c09fbcc7be00546bacc8560e33b2efdfffdd96f10f7c0eda9c67","9fd06bae684a9110374c5fb9d4f5ad68e9be75363f5e5c384ad2c579f95cb139","9fdb47f636c92d84c494448402e45626a0de35ac6844575976b21e5b7430fc77","a352b5cc3246a8db265406075921ab01139805c38ffa43306c3d1cabbd7d64be","aa3e3319856c40999d7ec64635618670d9e798fd81044262a185ebe07d7e4a14","ab748f39834204f2fd03a1b68f76e0124a8d48937673b5cb79614a2059212ab1","ada8a25696094f0678ec004dca6940095d24fdaf4f62729cac9391b1e5a75d6d","b3bd27d3ba9c5f0e7de72437ad74079f5643efbf87e22e18f8c4a1b23a5d795f","b4b0df3fc8088e2806498e73c7017f3fec29cf871e53d350dbfc94f0089fc57e","b4b926d03621298c80844a13e4214af41ec3b93fd0f2d3e019f26528a16ca5c0","bfe4a7243c1f4d5cacfe8a729399d72f7422670356cf1b0dfc2f74f1d05df3dc","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","c8d0593020f89043b700bae65685d25a2604025c598397da438fee1f10e2b0ae","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","e0676eeb1d1c9297167b3510ad0b40f85e93f082c9dc0630b60029f45f851b62","e401cbf7c7bc5328cfada6af15f35b57a2635992ced3aefed513c3b619a8c27d","e5464a9c67ea781f936eb0fe4f4b1587e33675c765f52d760dc66589c0214f0d","e8912985e6037b252a7a37444123107c88302dfcbe0a041d990bf49ea8f7de75","e8c474da69c2e5b36422b9f13d96076e16ef745a3b9aac6e04c87ab4560bd45e","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e","f826c61786e76fcc384adfdde59dac7095e998fae0abc4627a30d8517b548d5f","f828ba66084867c01d399c3e210dc4f70f6245cb037c2c22096ef69c8ab37ca0","f8bd5f06416f38881195c3906330f73dbe68484134c0eb8d6b6b751711486ee7","ff7476f8cc35422263e3f0116ec8ba13b96b2b148381695e3b78c1fb040741b6"],"directive":"TS102-f794abfb8041eaa5","kind":"submit","lines":[{"answer_ids":["t102_c3","t102_c4","t102_c6","t102_c7","t102_c8","t102_c10","t102_c1","t102_c2","t102_c5","t102_c9"],"directive_id":"TS102-f794abfb8041eaa5","kind":"done","local_id":"t102_d1","outcome":"answered","rq_id":"q1","text":"Supplied quotes omit PMC13449012 (ref 36 citations), reference entries for Wang & Fan 2025 in PMC13226197/PMC13388837, unquoted body sections across articles, and retraction grounds/invalidated data."}],"scope":{"docs":[],"ranges":[],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"a1e14a4502a8b52c5627dbfdb491bdad8cfddf1e17cc5fc758cd42f8f04f63e0","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["c0690a6e9a346dd178542ec5594bdea25e350483e21e238ae8de7c8a1c475006"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"68ae5138973c851479cebf9dfc8574da42d79df151a9d38550a304a9900614eb","submission_id":"TS102-f794abfb8041eaa5#1.1"},"hash":"23618a11f793f1d8689c954b7dd76455073fc8b42a7613d81d0da9d4e90a50ac","header":{"body_hash":"6deb6322aab9770df0967299765166172ab671b1b592db72d2ab9b69c519bf1d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"4fba209b419e8aacbbed492fec77f79980c21a90de92b4e85287c04644236497","records_root":"e45570e6eeba7df1d0aaf398a6b9b4f94ae109c5d375be83005b136191ac16c0","seq":441,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"90d179e1c202c9fbc4175413fe3d22737c455bd8667f480f9bf1afeb50667725","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","answer_ids":["3b76fd65fa1500f84c8c260c31b532c68b447acdfd9c657b02155c01a9e67b40","4ba7ea0ea1a9f1b0c123cab083cec0f14fdb213c9d4a2e12dac85a221d5a6159","c1708805b937256d0a13433264d74ec4b72c693560c844f81a227eb1331ed6db","352306c2958bb4fd9761973f28584220178a43665f508935a64f7082e15a4a36","7a74b7ed727b88eb820d1e6f762a590735d35b36f7816a66fb31d37c709962a5","3bd1ac258682306f1ac33667540b6ff5d17ac228df6de670c59bbb1f97e342da","daa5c03af4d4b97c70f9e627d316a9f25531702dae108b3635c9c9607bc12b80","ce1a2b688339183a3ec0d9e74f2c3f804bd737e880aa9b669ebbb979c0fab31b","549f5885147f7c3c424b17d0b218949d90f2a45b1ec799c5341f629670e75d37","8a268ba0014e1b70e0fe57a677ae6edca2f41ada1779ce0f1954ffcc81fa7dc2"],"circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","delivery_audit":{"had_refusals":false,"partial_declared":false,"repair_count":0,"retained_rows":0},"done":"c0690a6e9a346dd178542ec5594bdea25e350483e21e238ae8de7c8a1c475006","kind":"SUMMARIZE","link_task":null,"outcome":"answered","question_set_revision":"0502c9aea43e1ce04869d20bb1cd0c78050175800b1315cbc452ab3a7a0fce2e","rq_id":"q1","sync_step":43,"task_id":"TS102-f794abfb8041eaa5"},"from":0,"key":"task:rq:q1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a1e14a4502a8b52c5627dbfdb491bdad8cfddf1e17cc5fc758cd42f8f04f63e0","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"0ad07df72df5824b091338b5cfe454372c366fa7123f717d61c73b0bdd6eb6c3","submission_id":"TS102-f794abfb8041eaa5#done2"},"hash":"ed3a18692ab150d6ea7f8a814adfa357c9306ca0a4b5a448cc5be6a53cf72881","header":{"body_hash":"141c528310bff431b9946a4582f1862e8a5749a38a618a1422e1e67239312591","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"23618a11f793f1d8689c954b7dd76455073fc8b42a7613d81d0da9d4e90a50ac","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":442,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"546e4eb12727f465a58877c8f99778ca8bc1cb6bc5a8cc53d731d4cd232b9c6e","command":{"allowed_records":["00ac1ecd92f489b4f0a1ed4ec1ba9365d1740a1cdfd5a571155715191fe69723","0207e441872b32768f06b2b43475b8e272a79fe8f833013cb771c4f31e1ed4c9","022983dbf293f383575ad337f5d90b42f48a2e807897d776a8de992500d28e39","027b6c6b98ea140fd90dbe47965c1c5e3607acf9b88b9b8ca71e199cadc880f0","02ac2d80dacc43a46f0d5764098f99152575f910628b421eb915f12bcc20e94c","0311d6c80244bf3d49da88fc47cd995e9180f3aa43bfe70d26234c7f0d0d06ac","04588ef5a34c56f45b9b03fffb833e4377f0c87c5d6a96285ccaafbb43c64c4b","05d56e8737c6174ad5b67dc2a2ab1bf2cc310c6ddde552012b03e4400aa15075","08171dc1108c23e5474f5a0ba2be523e985d77dbd0bf2d3fd3dc754fba57773b","08a008c50aa08b2eddd5d87dcc111c0b4779ca0cb559910a63fa20ea7443adca","08a0f7812f39b520053db4378f195e8ff25b5c35c462c2900b63dd0f79e5801a","090e5204183d6aba151db2a546adf333960e9c874402943d8b5c62de46c03caf","099cebfd1758d63a8957557f3c228e2e7dd1e62a7b5adca8719ba563cc67bb76","0a18f06fbbdcbb5cbab484a3e1afe07603bcbec9e2073c901678806cb5d0861b","0cc5da2e9d0178e36f4bd22710c9333e2645b45338e4d08d879379edc167538c","0d4f47dd7cc213bfc377b037616c2bdd1fbf4b916a8edae15ca4980717738bcb","0e2316188912e96684d1336cd3382467942a02571c7f844ae68b6c55d589bf95","0f6052ca7e51b9016f79aa0dd716f937cbae0fa6a481b8c4360cf7a5a357ee5d","119fd003a2f0d64d2e103321c35f1c47e62f81d921a7964479f5b423f95407ec","120c641c729b58be8150ff78ff7fa671ff8a77084cb18d16b6ac461904dd32ee","12efabe28f30f157ec3786f2a2da0becf6215d87cb2805e98577e49604cb2c6b","1442a45e909b8b540473da43a7ebd792468cd762da3af7d02146ec7a86004486","14481bdb74d88d8c0cac69cfa05381adc1aabfe9b2eb7331ea029e83dfe5b277","15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","15fa8c6698cd2c96de3d427b8991e0b419fc9105b10b79949556c4a7a17dca2d","17640e518001d72e2b4a1588865094706279b6c4120e10a58145c3f23234f01c","18d056e2dc42a0ea7e940872e5adf831b46c978bc66afb5e9ae08faec28eb6c3","1add7afcc218f8c67ea5649b00d41c25e96afd8e67596f41cc6518b690a1f9ac","1b3d1de993deef130125a82603c2714b1f40a24c7549e08eff124c2b13f682b4","1bbc6687f9d17196e9f1a40e85d9a6474a6d5f6c5587b928a03de18af41b226b","1c6f7b49947dced4ff20fdf3398385257a068828d60f0c9b27e5da6d7992d32c","1d0e6954a21f610903727e4e8b986078b0a738669d0ca0ff56cc1c86ea722721","1d32ed18ae378809b2892e68cb19280c1cbb86b5c07b26500319aad53207f6eb","1f1c46cef854d52d0b75590a8fe757a0c7f17a4d50397293eb5572d89a229f00","1ffcd9c7a419a3025e0b3f8ef2ae26395251acea937a6201169f51ab89520065","212ebd7f32241a5dfd2ac608b816747a7ba0ead90220145f6f98d04b1676ab5f","21e0b6501f65af2bf23798a61a82f101c87d341d22ae989e7bec3cf1c235d523","2244884a8871d2dd314bb49494af368eb1d160e46abecbfbf261024045c313c5","245f0de7532acff390ed2843c086bf6004432126a5469d12522e5ab84165bf9d","25b58c33f3a08575efc53530dae74182afe3f567557a714cbe4fbf29521591dc","26078c727bf727ce17cf72012cbe4fd4eac20f47ac264185cee7015c3021f3e5","2a4eb93d011bdadfe5166f0f73f31d7a25a9041474e96befb34fa46fa29d1a96","2d31d284beecc1d67e7b2df6203fe8a8b7544b7ed3496b230505e3666c40997b","2f53e5eb943013cd525dbd6a5ff1d8bae04896f0f07cdcaa6404c3d862872c8f","3042d0c4ef16d7ddabf1c659cb09ff4e465ceb96e7ad583b8eb117f6de9c7aea","330e485d1da601b452355bbd08fea709e173c37efff17a1580bbb5456efb4369","3348f2072123585da98e6b14d7912cb6dbe164b71b7bf4b46c0532c2af10a94e","339fe33af70438e309eedebc9c5cbc64743464ff0ee9b34f06518065b9c753fb","33b1ba9666262744926d1c8cd38e03d1b55c82ee0b16baf5c49972ea55b65c84","33fedaebad3c5f73a4491b35776c6bc7db3590afc82189cf2ab5ae59ebf6abe4","3708cc2df47a3e8c94329e4e446a32b9c0edd1e43b85df96519cc2f9748fb607","385babc4b2fdf6c21483cdfd6f0be36919f4f0ff4f8e9291e6bb879ad0b8eb40","39c73d811917f07d3b637b2fcea4a57cb37b59627643d91c4be155c6e485f653","3a8cbea1f64b59a41880d7bc1e9e4347e93d6a570cd6f494e19884ce528af4f7","3b0f21e3e163ef74be345449e0050cc14a6fb0b79ac2072986b7bc8c5ce46a97","3ba20fa867ddd9340087b3273c88895392eae955c92d152187bad9314731d153","3c8784a5b855170f811a0336315528e2f15fa843f2986b67a081a454dc35149a","3cb060c9bd3bd1cc602d656043a1eb9606060f8b54c5ebf692c063f740d29d13","3cf89c0564f05ab8068b33b238e583cc96f7e0ce1a8d75bcca2ea8d736402cb7","3dd10752fd5051f4fed5a926ccad10c6fb99fc63618a013c872981df5df1814d","3e4123b0e2effda421994c37f09bafe726378c6f73bef3f59f2ec23a71fbd93c","3f1bce000471ea4be84d36a8c26fa6ce70b925d8440fb30bf56cced7ec8ae5f6","40316a85dfb10877b9b47aeb66a0e6549427d940f4b72b626704a165a999c1fb","4076514025cbf6d81d5cf1efe1db0c6617c1ed42c55a3c7260813e82677c14e5","42a05caad3ac0a71d1cc0c21d877bb739f116e617c8752e49b127bb26de43de0","45f20def6861824e083a1a342716838a7e1d268fc2382741f7f5b5dee0fe8070","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","4948cd790a7aca1d74356919df4f148aaa1247145ac0836195d5d9522aa5e0d9","4a137cb7d345e0877c43e7c57a0f4f7277819b8d536d2598f091e7f874327a80","4a768c4dc683c8fbe8f2767d7c5da15f23e925ff7de339bf470e60538d7bd8ab","4abe67acf67ea5dba879afa708b81c97d930bd5095a9cab048600077b489fc2f","4b15401deb94a3656a337ef4b4bcd3422d4d8dff6513b7d3ee2c272809bdb8a6","4b7966cdad829e7a193b3ce475e1028716aed89432a2e49eee2fded2b92eea9f","4b7e78e56636d691cf451f4591d590a7d5a2165bd8993cd5c2046729879e4b63","4bbf122b34957c8acf0b678e97ba7662ee3b93bf1579c3e490bff5ca08740096","4deb3fe0eb77febb1addb904deaf96841bbc3c9782864a47e6df1897b6a472fe","51e7c38c15474878667edf926c96fe09ae5a224a1d38a1e53273987668e4050b","54680f8a0f335a2e92acf2ee6f81a217a3572430746e89e38fddf3860c005686","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","54c2520117d397eddd8d9ac35a3b6a94379533788aa9d203a5afcf71c3656e9b","5b46657304b4c9d8d3c3729eab6488e44adc92a401e3b230d8b5e5665a2c0981","5ba8bfa631be25263e40c29c35863ebddeef775e74df34f097ba78353e8efed6","5d4ff23b061016beec399ae514f71c3af64c9bcc4f49da4a3034b1bfeffa430b","5ddf848626d9510b690bd43251f7b9f6e394b2d3a3bba423d20b3203edc95062","5f39a0c541abab0d84dc8a7b62adc18db22d5d388b7aebabcd2a107ea39aa2a4","5fddadf17e948ef581edcdc26010f4746a93554e06a700fc689e8837bf43cb03","639c93d8c7469d049575b3437dcf33f2c46432ab0f402c66c545e7bf32a50c9d","6413a067ef9ba737af817e766b5632b3ba5adbfffb0b10f5b95a987a9f9080dd","649643003e1e27347985af33ab517e205ccdcf37f7ba638d2d343a87b07680f8","6527860faa20b249f71d5acd7941cdded1d86c9324a2ec392e9d3613e2e9d588","65f6d9d23a35e6eac6b13cc78f10a47f04ccb80aba5f1029ca7ecdbe0f8c6785","66ab11f4b7dfea37500c7b041c867e9247ee6251dd03fb4422e9d6a515f1e77d","6a7729235c4b15e24eaaac404d41bd4b023a9ce2b4bf9f6988e5b7d96a92e1ee","6cf40b2d2796b3fa13f02f405a2b9a11d82f11f5f54a64b10f20589dd0989cea","6ef1edc987764a4ca9b21757ac4e1e81e8eed6d83964650613702b35e9c41b22","6f700e126e0d100914477cb435407dfd299d4be95b7cf0379f3d8d3b8c6f2d8d","6f730d119ee0af0e67265f3d6328b9108997251f0549a3bdd419ff13ad591ee6","700ae7f028c1a74549e6b94b0dc6a5aca38934c2a46acde03c54c71391c54b22","7098f3a8d77d608b90d4acdd1022ef8491d5cb1ac3d1b9a2c2d6acb3323de089","7157439c05c936b85b7fee6e832363cc83b3965753cac8256b1d487342c51ff2","718e062d5da7611cc683f734c761f61efc42bde3c484a84601c7d4c7f2bce1a4","75b66684790552ec977b962824d8a4e85a41d2effc50226f9b697f7b901472c7","77227a3be7f73e785c8334065c045c25bbe960eca4f08ab00da7adb780465383","781d942ca92d77c7dbf094fa375a1750f498ad0612a9ce79fad725447f4fc5b2","789b2c492cb07d284c64f0532ade44de0affe5c45dd5cc530f84386d1eef4c98","795d578b1a001a00e899a5c976fab8bd06e246e0e0525ab36f04d792e40ef7ed","79d12d31b034b083446cdb16c7b73a8b019846a2a86ccf15eca5465ceebd1b1f","79f36ed5e7d4b6d63b1c4ce861ffbfb6376e74c21f19b946cb9409b22b6ce38c","7a6fb9541b43fab52d210eaa73a51b52a1a942a3a2073bae1ad7f014b753b4d8","7bc9e2f4b13c7447cca0b9b7e9b901a11428864abb49127c149f877bfca4e92a","7f77c5f520faae414ad8b14b025b2275385a5c128c3f5ea162200d8ba3638091","8275e6ad0bf10d2430cc7b89262a4bca3cdf6efa885f40f628400d9dcc512b76","83393296d0bb763b34ef00ad70c22c7aba459ce284ae9cb6c5d526ee970b7d53","83ea55e2cdc8fa0c752020f7191d9e5aea7b1b61de7e7ecad6f27458f21c2f0a","84f6b5d94ef84de06a8baf1985684980166710917b06e5b690f8bff036a84938","863535897f2aef3e494b5af69653e45a7e5840c38d7be8207af5fba7f9949202","86b606c8c70adbfbc1db885323470191d9d2e09d92bb9c170300f3c15e8e8301","86d3e30655b07eada4d90ebe241375ad003945a7b7b30fd0fdacb710cff5feff","876146ef6be3c37fa2acb55078eaf1394f7e7d67526bec40dd11285b0d54fe6e","876464adb279d62264a6bad0ec19bdcbdeb7a4f29ab0170db8a8dd32c6da93d6","878418a76e821e827c674f63922cdca27c9032850dcb1f43ba5de9ad8b7ccbf7","8ba974c364d52e6b43d75f8026bcfff3d4a324e22485650de8b6b821e8f674ea","8c12b002514f4d6cb6f06033fe6855534a7f5dba96dfed022d5d0a986273954b","8d0dd7807ec13c572f6807096823ba3853a6e1d481d53526c3f3563d12b7207b","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","8eed9fbdfba0472d67af6722a4fac7ccaec11dab7fafb19301cb5a77d022b446","919379b48cec048c79fcf2e746f053d6ba9b7c8b74ac983ea6fa8df54afc109f","9228d9495d52af720c230dc6a6eb3644189bf923521ee0a3c0ac6c1009ad1583","926d69cdd0ce87e828672bd7c01fc418c5d0556451698b5cf81e0b51c808886f","92b2cb88b636a8f9e370c3a4c69940f2b37c9c105a770590a5c2a24c4200d251","931d5261296cc42ccaf345b176b5e4f3da9f553bfe292b6b5811481021cb1405","9369828e4df5a65832a0ed6801f34c3b3eb85c69eafbc257b882e3cfbc079df1","93ab1a62f7082761a57f2da3762190b55bce7efcbe097296ef7fe2f21fb42b39","93be540e7edb27167a112c1f2cdf6f8de8fbdc4b0027e49a41db5251dd8d6a29","9859c7902ef863cf21dcde841aec319bc43264ba78bcdf4e7d79718baebb4ea3","9884ec5f6cfd4209a58f13aba718d240476eda27b02f5bf2306fd976e059d1d3","99da2a239ecd0fa24836150eb43b398fa33a76b764c6ca2052af1bd1958add94","9b34e1e5d6cd6682311e2376e18dc24736e001a01ad41fdc3b99133549100c99","9bac28d24e66ee005c77c3b82f84f6f7d0e32c7a9aac2356d869b985e8104610","9c18ba44e30c2b303f9e4536aa736b83cca544167359fd76a77bae4c66133e14","9cec90a915f4cb77af91065d34b63157da307154b014b90027064666da4645bd","9d807115d2b186abcb5172a8fca9f20c91a5652dee8bf4720f69de48ea7d6a64","9f8a18dcb79900654a9b027395dcc293d30d9d5b32832751f587cf74ee49138f","9fb11adb29d4c09fbcc7be00546bacc8560e33b2efdfffdd96f10f7c0eda9c67","9fd06bae684a9110374c5fb9d4f5ad68e9be75363f5e5c384ad2c579f95cb139","9fdb47f636c92d84c494448402e45626a0de35ac6844575976b21e5b7430fc77","a15f4c3d5d2367acbb0281d54f0b245ffe4dd072eb4cba1ddc780fc1d920f8a6","a370f962cbeeb263a7d46489b934ceb70cb7c1575c525defb19eede11de0d2c5","a4b64a6badde1d2f8ad4f1dfa9acdc69cb99a1d503f489a71951529c47c12db9","a715c9f86ff1c65cc0a55bd7c5aacb6435b867f12171c51c9b4ba9b3c4c908f4","a886153044d80e9b04324f54336412c5785bd7f643d5876e240ce03541a9106a","a8df37fb13db5044cd4d893ff45827c544cb284e437f94809437d4d1d74a141b","a929fbeb38ee0720bc1dce9d68b55b6f369e959e2960e094b87bd120203e7474","a941f9ce34467a2991412ae341603c383fb676593c3fe0f1ae41b12015f298a4","aa3e3319856c40999d7ec64635618670d9e798fd81044262a185ebe07d7e4a14","aacef8efa2e6a417f1b52fe6178c01a92926217d226bf4474d50104813e148b6","ab50716eaf98e80e955c51de5fb5292ac4e8e45f94dfece10fc847319161627f","ab748f39834204f2fd03a1b68f76e0124a8d48937673b5cb79614a2059212ab1","abe8df605d6ddcbd2ae2915269869072be6711598b0b316bb8bb34f5765bccc1","ae7fcdb0a791e5dbd206acd70718e8e9b02a9065c976fb7805de5aeed981b798","b138ed198daee4e07279426cb6b049aeafeb647c94c57bd6822c826d1bbe36ee","b14e037fc8d4a27756eacfab295d284333ee39c40f9b871ca9a0e87fa3f36e45","b1aafb63a7491e460e849689ea06d5eb3c285ab6f86a2f65deb313b35ac54396","b24c2d613e9ba2076c4eaefb37afc995fbee36e687161365b4f13246a71408f1","b319f7b38290998a06835d6b4cb8e9f9abba55947f8c1329fa45abae0fbfb9e5","b4019c63a6c67f255e84a7fd728a82f74e9df127d7ac3632f688b10000984455","b4b926d03621298c80844a13e4214af41ec3b93fd0f2d3e019f26528a16ca5c0","b6111c5c1a067f6e3de6440660b793eda0904ddbe66b144cff84a6e624e48d5c","b613aa3cdb2c80da02db9880d03ba3f6f28b08092c965e0f7a48edfd333c4808","b66d3c7719896288b129db6393cfff8377c8332d0ada947e14245afd3180d9df","b7d63db0f7665c364f87430d715e48eb6b66b97bf7125ad10d4e80b8e985c5d4","b8b6faa88ab5d76879d445859e17d39755fa75e6dbb42381c86171b31bb67758","b9a43e16b5db2cb4571d60df498390846118ef1cb70e672c6bea4adef32854a4","b9c6b8db508e8d981c8b3e8ccffd07a24bbd7c6d253e072bdb9f0f234f37d97a","bb09d21fd3c8e030a7cea551738e010c9e94972b97ff0523cfe8505c43055c40","bc0350f535c72e3753a6081622cd8ff160f83bd07a2067d68ba905d039420b5f","bc287469642e6e2d18e0bd6414f1a85b20c9991fbf9d0d6d7baacb23f360a835","bd8f2470831e2078e3e64c8b80d75e55019328a342d427fe6f79212da3c9de69","beb271a2eb79c7b00fad16641e9fc400eea7fd2dbc197413ba1e12174f451018","bf055b5f673c3f3b1da9a1d6baa56d4640d40a0bf9ac9ebc77a6b6c1e8b4aaf5","bfe4a7243c1f4d5cacfe8a729399d72f7422670356cf1b0dfc2f74f1d05df3dc","c0c1c7ef91e3e8bdeda6f7e4ad0b3da17c9095cfd5a1530856bb1fae92882105","c0c6fa3eb98f673d1053efaf46c1d7574f3c5498eaf421e494d12c27fa77db6b","c1d1032e545c9754beb395dff87dfdd3292d83a377de06c8359f4f8295f4846f","c1f1842ac7edd40216eeb0e549bee92652bb0ebfa92d9d927769a7649a4aa262","c37cecbee0a0d221902161b77e6bc134440623472682a77333282fe0928acebc","c77e037744af41a322bb0007afb425299448da934c801574cf2fa5a7b73ded1a","c7abc03fd01e6b0848ca2b930079d25527381cc5d19b90c5a8cdb07d0d68006d","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","c8daec1b2023e24c51829b77d4226756aa48e26adaef1014f0e80f9d16331807","c8e3f255c060ad77bb7a3ad5322fbc71d23843a4209605fb248c1223f8f13eca","c9d22d0eeea05ce10eaf5450010966db8c15ac0c315bb44bb165cc7f1c8b2651","c9ea7c273e3d9ceb3e58e3b255c39425c611d8b802a5acab03680dc89bcfd4b5","cb6231312b40d6303f478ae118f1783eeea849a19c6e0235298b3d0a0d087b78","ccf224838daf27b808aed618057702104630e3ba0a8e82c7751a984ec180502d","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cd501828dc0547c11e08e73409372f8a06db27df8b36e60b345f45aac548fb8a","ce710c268fc0953cffbbdde0f363d0604bf11cbff0bfc10d4a05805db5bbd328","d17a3218c9172c9aada2f7abc7327410815497f0595dd3bca46c7cf632dec4ad","d1b724bfdd244b173a6d978ce563ea1828127923b74360c8da55baa45f871dc9","d2c1665c1bf6367889fb46710faa10819a3fd449b698dbca1951798014d99d85","d38d51b340d3e726b17fccef562bd07a8f442391957079b9b851057cbd99f06d","d5459c4cabe99ee33196c154c271ec16afc132f99b5a137dcf88d85b13f8304f","d5d3148bc57b9756cbb1da6c99d82bb0ebfe577bfb69e921b2de296e9680b23e","d5e75611e9f288db8f4c1affc54696367b287ea130ee7a049fe35ad6f9e79631","d63eb41a760dc52a5a9324f0edb8cd81c75c6ed78142290553952b7a7410f214","d76d4295435f00384500b58976004e0ca2bd324b42b12548be8e056ad4bd2a7d","d7c3914cb187b8216ccdb93c8e43c2d4b9c9f1997abe329f81ac6912cae99664","da367720408cd0d6132edc6a0622a4f7c11b4390551d8cbf0ccaa34ed157a1b2","dbf9ebffc05df49fb0980fed86c458261b8fb691cb3b91fbaad4d0c0f38d839d","dcb1050604203e09173d157863a64b0b133e62a25052924647606314823981a1","de76ced14702cdd2b5b6a8668243ffe439718091abb4182964cf7b954879358f","df423fae466916abc12ce24808f5dc92ddc18911f34678c654401b872356f974","dfca6ea813dff69d4c1fd00d08c57a459f301100608067050f5abef38c911c5a","dfd29d54438fe5ec01424de96f328e02c5778b7a371b073e2180e8db5cbc9244","e0676eeb1d1c9297167b3510ad0b40f85e93f082c9dc0630b60029f45f851b62","e0c49cc45838fdf2866e303ad798b5590fc6b1511b3ee9b4fabd4ee97d9ff31a","e124f0cfe13c60194e8e51a6815a0d230b226a078fa1c649e8524dfe3389def9","e5464a9c67ea781f936eb0fe4f4b1587e33675c765f52d760dc66589c0214f0d","e58662351f5fbf1dfed4556012bb58ea26793710ff82758ebb15504a7c3556b5","e58cb5715f3a2dd5580c95472017fcdd116d5f54417401a2c266719799198e58","e5a028efb2107b7fccf87ff9616fbcc360adbdd776db3dc537b86c08b0f3013d","e654eaee77a53167e989b2855cd1542b719de7040b5e815b844b5c143ae6baa0","e68c0b845eaa5db361a4e7a58f7dfc26b316870b0c5a5da9b2e34d00f0661204","e7342a7f85458c6318ebb75f8b2f0340c1c6e0e0dafc8e79eff3442ba73b35da","e8912985e6037b252a7a37444123107c88302dfcbe0a041d990bf49ea8f7de75","e8c474da69c2e5b36422b9f13d96076e16ef745a3b9aac6e04c87ab4560bd45e","ed01400e0952592d809b6404f2cecb8ef0687ff00fed19cb19bbdd421f7e9930","ed0def08684ec7e0d3de11934740aac67a8498475b1aa6b0cad49428719a96fe","ed44d390f70035ac5b370ff25ea77eeb4cb7184e76448bc2492edde3487eca68","ed7d8256a59b85069106a3d445fdeb27d2f03ff94cddf445277cff4ffd8da5ec","ee419d37f7f3a91adde665fdb8900cb50159b6e6414209bab6fe74c337bc6d86","ee994e3a7448d1df2760a1453842f128b03d7e1405275e1fd7dac70c88803c78","eecebf3955e6a6f3d4247d2c3bf17b64934995c3386deae779ddcbf13ab62fb2","eedbadb1f43e94f0a9531adf32b2303ed48d6dd672d91fe8355fa654b5251ef6","ef069e07ea5452baa01d851837c9d4756ee134632b283ebc57473a61da89b072","ef29f2b02761b0e141ef15c460de36ddd815209c9ea400025b39dcf21d733da9","ef92f93bb17a361f6e2aef2eded441362dd8aa894916eb2fa7ed6ac793860c48","f11ed666387c771e0be45889b4e9f311c61ff44a6bcacd1278784210211a1b99","f34566341285af094bf3d17c09e5a71a4a48ab7c8b1b65d8d70d4e0bd3cdb5f3","f34d0296c44c4041ef7b3891c9d0ccc696df36ba65d5e96903c7abe4333a708b","f3a83c0cf21c24cb6b7bc03abad9af715ebe03bf0efd4673f68c01d87cbd87dd","f3ef574e67528a1a852757901d0aff4d208ee782f3e4623e28ccc33ffe7252f9","f572b3b4ab9c8af99a97197ec37fb0e3a97b7ede608543e263f5dca212d7b2e5","f6ebc6f9096d3dce03a6b171fd5a941afbe4815700afbea0acc1ea6908b44cbc","f7a7d13375d7593cadd49c6bc13a2bca09b8a557339f6a4044642d7ef9ba2d3e","f8bd5f06416f38881195c3906330f73dbe68484134c0eb8d6b6b751711486ee7","f8c7dddac5532e2597b3a86ec18246870de973f2591794a175dced4814898e90","f999bd21067dcf15466a9d53dba1a724c2f02c4065f58c4adc1c5f7e434d7466","fc5840251ef2a9de3eb986711162fe3e01af088d12572c42277e87a7cdd47dc0","fc85a0d917744d753c773c00875cd145b6d5d1133ccd772f501f8b1edcad9fc6","fca72b00cc2b15d834651209f34d8091cc85adeffef4c1166f60fc7795f495a0","fd3c44ea3c11bdc16e30d0816424e8f6307c87cec35461f0dac4618aa6fc1753","fedfbf4403eccbc6aba5721bcd788cafa76c7602aae35097d226082100bf1c6f","ff7476f8cc35422263e3f0116ec8ba13b96b2b148381695e3b78c1fb040741b6","ffd89af109e0eef154365e6b5df997fbd5241388f5c82bfc883f93c697dd9926"],"directive":"TS103-8742e640c2ae6640","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@3b0f21e3e163ef74","@9369828e4df5a658","@c0c1c7ef91e3e8bd","@6527860faa20b249"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c1","object":"AI tutoring aids metacognition and engagement; transfer requires verification, retrieval, and abstraction scaffolds","predicate":"concludes_framework","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) integrates metacognition, engagement, and transfer into a causal framework: AI tutoring aids metacognition/engagement, while broader transfer needs scaffolds."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@da367720408cd0d6","@5ba8bfa631be2526","@65f6d9d23a35e6ea","@700ae7f028c1a745","@027b6c6b98ea140f"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c2","object":"monitoring β=0.028–0.047, control β=0.036–0.061, and intensity-dependent checking/revision gains","predicate":"concludes_metacognition_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) finds AI exposure increases monitoring (β=0.028–0.047) and control (β=0.036–0.061; help-seeking, revisiting items/strategies), with dose-dependent effect sizes."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@65f6d9d23a35e6ea","@ffd89af109e0eef1","@bf055b5f673c3f3b","@39c73d811917f07d","@022983dbf293f383"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c3","object":"1,184,906 sessions across 52,418 learners: checking β=0.047, error correction β=0.032, recheck β=0.028","predicate":"reports_monitoring_data_and_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"In PMC13226197 (N=1,184,906 obs, 52,418 learners; learner/week FE, difficulty controls), AI tutoring increases checking (β=0.047), error correction (β=0.032), and rechecking (β=0.028)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@da367720408cd0d6","@d38d51b340d3e726","@781d942ca92d77c7"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c4","object":"time on task β=0.083, intensity β=0.057, persistence β=0.064, return β=0.031, activity interval β=-0.018","predicate":"concludes_engagement_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) reports AI exposure increases engagement via time on task (β=0.083), intensity (β=0.057), error persistence (β=0.064), and next-day return (β=0.031; interval β=-0.018)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@da367720408cd0d6","@08171dc1108c23e5","@a8df37fb13db5044","@45f20def6861824e","@a886153044d80e9b"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c5","object":"near transfer (β=0.052), topic-shift transfer (β=0.021), and 7-day delayed performance (β=0.017)","predicate":"measures_and_concludes_transfer","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"PMC13226197 measures transfer via novel items in practiced skills (near transfer, β=0.052), topic/skill shifts (β=0.021), and 7-day delayed performance after inactivity (β=0.017)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@fca72b00cc2b15d8","@a929fbeb38ee0720","@7f77c5f520faae41","@ef92f93bb17a361f","@e8912985e6037b25","@04588ef5a34c56f4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c6","object":"time-varying covariate controls and comparison table listing Wang and Fan (2025) meta-analysis","predicate":"reports_controls_and_prior_studies","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197","text":"PMC13226197 controls for past performance, recent errors, item difficulty, skill context, and session activity baseline, and tabulates Wang & Fan 2025 (metacognition High, engagement Moderate)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@1bbc6687f9d17196","@33fedaebad3c5f73","@6ef1edc987764a4c","@d5459c4cabe99ee3","@f34d0296c44c4041","@93be540e7edb2716","@ed0def08684ec7e0","@795d578b1a001a00","@1d0e6954a21f6109","@bd8f2470831e2078"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c7","object":"18-item scale high reliability (α=0.943, ω=0.944) and two-factor communicative/analytical structure (r=0.49)","predicate":"concludes_instrument_validity","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 validates the 18-item Student Perception of ChatGPT scale in Latin America, finding high internal consistency (α=0.943, ω=0.944; item-deleted >0.939) and two correlated factors (r=0.49)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@8c12b002514f4d6c","@b6111c5c1a067f6e","@25b58c33f3a08575","@649643003e1e2734","@54c2520117d397ed","@eedbadb1f43e94f0","@6413a067ef9ba737"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c8","object":"communicative (Q28a-i) and analytical/problem-solving (Q29b-e) components with shared loading on Q28f","predicate":"concludes_pca_and_cluster_structure","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"In PMC13314867, cluster analysis and PCA (Bartlett's χ2=30,921, df=153, p<0.001) separate communicative (Q28a-i; Q28a/b >0.76) and analytical (Q29b-e, 0.73–0.91) items, with Q28f shared."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@3dd10752fd5051f4","@d63eb41a760dc52a","@c0c6fa3eb98f673d","@a15f4c3d5d2367ac","@b9a43e16b5db2cb4","@83ea55e2cdc8fa0c","@c8e3f255c060ad77","@b24c2d613e9ba207","@7a6fb9541b43fab5","@876464adb279d622","@c77e037744af41a3","@4a768c4dc683c8fb","@f8c7dddac5532e25","@08a0f7812f39b520","@4abe67acf67ea5db","@cb6231312b40d630"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c9","object":"two-factor EFA (Q29b-e >0.73; Q28a-g 0.54–0.87) and CFA fit (χ2=9,725.779, df=134, p<0.001; 18 loadings 0.829–1.191)","predicate":"reports_efa_and_cfa_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"In PMC13314867, EFA (χ2=4,365.694, df=118, p<0.001; uniqueness 0.29–0.50) and CFA (χ2=9,725.779, df=134 vs baseline 79,740.444; loadings 0.829–1.191) confirm the two-factor model."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@b319f7b38290998a","@86b606c8c70adbfb","@9d807115d2b186ab","@a370f962cbeeb263","@2f53e5eb943013cd","@6f730d119ee0af0e","@9f8a18dcb7990065"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c10","object":"perceptual cross-sectional data do not prove causal skill gains; references list Wang and Fan (2025)","predicate":"qualifies_scope_and_cites","stance":"qualified","subject":"PMC13314867","text":"PMC13314867 qualifies that its cross-sectional perceptual data measure perceived ChatGPT support rather than direct skill gains or causal effects; its references include Wang & Fan (2025)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@b613aa3cdb2c80da","@f999bd21067dcf15","@3f1bce000471ea4b","@0a18f06fbbdcbb5c","@92b2cb88b636a8f9","@c9ea7c273e3d9ceb","@f11ed666387c771e","@4deb3fe0eb77febb","@a941f9ce34467a29","@93ab1a62f7082761","@b7d63db0f7665c36","@5b46657304b4c9d8"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c11","object":"AI environment perception, receptive and productive L2 WTC, L2 self-efficacy, FLA, and proficiency levels","predicate":"examines_outcomes_and_variables","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13388837)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13388837) examines college students' AI environment perception, multimodal L2 WTC (receptive listening/reading, productive speaking/writing), L2 self-efficacy, FLA, and English level."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@b613aa3cdb2c80da","@4076514025cbf6d8","@ce710c268fc0953c","@7157439c05c936b8","@1442a45e909b8b54","@26078c727bf727ce","@54680f8a0f335a2e","@51e7c38c15474878","@42a05caad3ac0a71"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c12","object":"positive AI perception-WTC link across modalities/proficiency, mediated 56.19% by L2 self-efficacy (β=0.346 to SE)","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13388837)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13388837) concludes AI environment perception positively associates with receptive and productive L2 WTC across proficiency levels, with L2 self-efficacy mediating 56.19% of the link."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@d7c3914cb187b821","@b9c6b8db508e8d98","@00ac1ecd92f489b4","@fc85a0d917744d75","@6f700e126e0d1009","@c7abc03fd01e6b08","@66ab11f4b7dfea37","@385babc4b2fdf6c2"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c13","object":"baseline receptive > productive WTC (t(959)=24.06, d=0.79), while AI perception path strengths do not differ (Δβ=0.004)","predicate":"concludes_modality_comparisons","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"In PMC13388837 (N=960), receptive WTC (M=3.66) exceeds productive WTC (M=3.10, t(959)=24.06, p<0.001, d=0.79; H2a), but AI perception predicts both similarly (β=0.220 vs 0.224, Δβ=0.004; H2b rejected)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@9bac28d24e66ee00","@c1f1842ac7edd402","@d1b724bfdd244b17","@6cf40b2d2796b3fa","@e654eaee77a53167","@c8daec1b2023e24c","@339fe33af70438e3","@0311d6c80244bf3d","@9859c7902ef863cf"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c14","object":"WTC correlations with AI perception, self-efficacy, and FLA; α=0.702–0.780, CR=0.817–0.850, AVE=0.528–0.573, CFI=0.968","predicate":"reports_correlations_and_model_fit","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13388837","text":"PMC13388837 reports correlations with receptive/productive WTC for AI perception (M=3.57, SD=0.70; r=0.220, 0.224; H1), self-efficacy (r=0.414, 0.375), and FLA (r=-0.200, -0.285), plus model fit."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@b613aa3cdb2c80da","@8275e6ad0bf10d24","@1442a45e909b8b54"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c15","object":"non-significant self-efficacy × FLA interaction (p=0.068); AI perceived qualitatively as psychological safety buffers","predicate":"qualifies_moderation_and_qualitative_findings","stance":"qualified","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13388837)","text":"PMC13388837 reports that self-efficacy's buffering interaction against FLA on WTC was non-significant (p=0.068), while qualitative data characterized AI platforms as psychological safety buffers."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@e124f0cfe13c6019","@40316a85dfb10877","@3c8784a5b855170f","@212ebd7f32241a5d","@c9d22d0eeea05ce1","@e5a028efb2107b7f","@bc0350f535c72e37","@8eed9fbdfba0472d","@bc287469642e6e2d","@d2c1665c1bf63678","@4948cd790a7aca1d","@bb09d21fd3c8e030","@0e2316188912e966","@ed44d390f70035ac","@931d5261296cc42c","@e58662351f5fbf1d","@ee994e3a7448d1df","@e0c49cc45838fdf2","@c1d1032e545c9754","@99da2a239ecd0fa2","@f3a83c0cf21c24cb"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c16","object":"ChatGPT 4.1 mini outperforms 3.5 in accuracy, completeness, and consistency (4.216 vs 3.794, Z=-10.2, P<0.001)","predicate":"concludes_model_comparison","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) evaluates bacterial microbiology Q&A (N=810 per model), finding ChatGPT 4.1 mini outperforms 3.5 (mean 4.216/4.22±1.09 vs 3.794/3.79±1.23, Z=-10.2, P<0.001; 64.81% vs 47.78% in 4–5)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@4b15401deb94a365","@fedfbf4403eccbc6","@639c93d8c7469d04","@f34566341285af09","@1ffcd9c7a419a302","@eecebf3955e6a6f3","@17640e518001d72e","@86d3e30655b07ead","@dcb1050604203e09","@2244884a8871d2dd","@4a137cb7d345e087","@b66d3c7719896288","@b14e037fc8d4a277","@ab50716eaf98e80e","@3cb060c9bd3bd1cc"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c17","object":"significant gains across proficiency levels (P<0.001); no variation across 3 prompts (Friedman P=0.288 and 0.980)","predicate":"concludes_proficiency_and_prompt_effects","stance":"reported","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"In PMC13449012, prompt proficiency level increases accuracy (Kruskal-Wallis P<0.001; 3.5 χ2=151.519, rank 284.08 to 523.36; 4.1 mini χ2=90.097, 319.38 to 492.54), with no difference across 3 prompt replicates."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@12efabe28f30f157"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c18","object":"proficiency-level gains may partly reflect within-session contextual memory carryover effects","predicate":"qualifies_conclusions","stance":"qualified","subject":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012)","text":"Manushi 2026 (PMC13449012) qualifies that observed accuracy gains across proficiency levels may partly reflect within-session contextual memory carryover effects rather than solely intrinsic performance."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@84f6b5d94ef84de0","@0cc5da2e9d0178e3","@ee419d37f7f3a91a","@d17a3218c9172c9a","@08a008c50aa08b2e","@ae7fcdb0a791e5db","@330e485d1da601b4","@1f1c46cef854d52d","@f6ebc6f9096d3dce","@3042d0c4ef16d7dd","@3a8cbea1f64b59a4","@8ba974c364d52e6b","@33b1ba9666262744"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c19","object":"56 effect sizes from 42 experimental/quasi-experimental studies (6,059 participants, 2023–2025) on learning motivation","predicate":"rests_on_studies_and_outcomes","stance":"reported","subject":"Fang et al. 2026 (PMC13647323)","text":"Fang et al. 2026 (PMC13647323) meta-analyzes 56 effect sizes from 42 controlled experimental/quasi-experimental studies (6,059 primary-to-university students, N=32–486, 2023–2025) on learning motivation."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@84f6b5d94ef84de0","@1add7afcc218f8c6","@fd3c44ea3c11bdc1","@9cec90a915f4cb77","@b4019c63a6c67f25"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c20","object":"positive average effect on learning motivation (Hedges' g=0.764) with high heterogeneity (I2=93.7%; 79.95% Level 3)","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"Fang et al. 2026 (PMC13647323)","text":"Fang et al. 2026 (PMC13647323) concludes GenAI positively affects learning motivation (Hedges' g=0.764) with high heterogeneity (I2=93.7%; 79.95% between-study, 15.70% sampling, 4.35% within-study)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@02ac2d80dacc43a4","@9c18ba44e30c2b30","@14481bdb74d88d8c","@8d0dd7807ec13c57","@119fd003a2f0d64d","@789b2c492cb07d28","@3cf89c0564f05ab8","@2d31d284beecc1d6","@79f36ed5e7d4b6d6","@d5d3148bc57b9756","@3e4123b0e2effda4","@d5e75611e9f288db","@9b34e1e5d6cd6682","@7098f3a8d77d608b","@fc5840251ef2a9de","@5fddadf17e948ef5","@ed01400e0952592d","@4b7966cdad829e7a","@1d32ed18ae378809","@120c641c729b58be","@f572b3b4ab9c8af9","@090e5204183d6aba"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c21","object":"intrinsic/extrinsic motivation and moderation by device, function, culture, year, and gender in CMA 3.0","predicate":"examines_moderators_and_methods","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13647323","text":"Using CMA 3.0 subgroup and meta-regression analyses, PMC13647323 examines intrinsic/extrinsic motivation and moderators: device type (MD vs PC), function (assessment, PLS, ITS), culture, year, and gender."},{"as_of":20260422,"based_on":["@ff7476f8cc354222","@9fd06bae684a9110","@e8c474da69c2e5b3","@e0676eeb1d1c9297","@ab748f39834204f2","@1c6f7b49947dced4","@aa3e3319856c4099","@9fdb47f636c92d84","@6a7729235c4b15e2","@718e062d5da7611c"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t103_c22","object":"published 2025-05-06 (12:621), retracted 2026-04-22 (13:528); full text and results excluded due to CC BY-NC-ND","predicate":"retracted_and_text_excluded","stance":"qualified","subject":"Wang and Fan 2025","text":"Wang & Fan 2025 (published 6 May 2025, Humanit Soc Sci Commun 12:621) was retracted 22 Apr 2026 (13:528); its corpus file has bibliographic facts only (text excluded under CC BY-NC-ND), so results are unshown."}],"scope":{"docs":[],"ranges":[],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"a1e14a4502a8b52c5627dbfdb491bdad8cfddf1e17cc5fc758cd42f8f04f63e0","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["8a5797472f630188b8b943be1f7bb5c4ca34d7784a39f6ad31399ad550830d86","9ed7695e821d1555293f5ac5b70c2abc93e88a770e843b87979be90ce5c91a39","c7e12c3a06b274f98764b92e94ff85a354e43f09d9911d75d6c183df47648084","6f01841172e93949a12cca6a14f6eaa6370b85a725df5fdc41ee756e9a3ef8bc","f1064b149d9eafbc10bad14288ae9abc5e2b3a168835e6d9ace9dfaf84f9bacf","9baf739e230d7e0989c950334089be602cffb3f41d0a5faa8c53e22346ed2a03","11842bc73366f5526afa5f65ae15b88326869f01e36f05f527121988cbb43d23","275ca6c673440473bbc3f3282f75b8496b809bb615972cd742d9cf706f71451e","7185e5581a258ca68b87d3e95a9bac66eb43cbc55960aba3a40dfa82ec43079f","c1c5cf9e4b06435c1da5cbb087aa8d5b3d8250dbd9c57bc066f5390b14eb3632","2ab0031a5a24089217684829d137dce91bd83e34accc82639028241aa8bc3301","0012d826fb4aa3c89fc0d372417f18affce2791a9fa705a06cea5325e6a5b179","594f77fea05aeaa28400298258daf3a9100851349deedfe84b094bd0ebf92ebc","f05fa23f8bc5ded3df1ba1dcb83c3ee513aaceccb38ea58ee3f31a926a90887e","e601afc0ce5c66c897bf047d29d73209cd4471b09d265f6a0d5860a8e09c4af3","7d3c8f25c9d788cf1e617e71a8af34169e4a3af372a152ed3430fbfec749c2dc","320e8ab30b71b3a235ba187f0b155dbf2b64887623f67cd78fd715a37994ac8e","be2ef8f5f367249be475d78d30be41c45fadce582d05a32ca83bce4f7177a8db","564c5c3ba5f16d3bb90251feb27ccfefb02cd1674de0ea3009968e24b79d139e","dc8564ec47348688bc2ab3c95db9f9772947ebc2b28631adc9392bc42d01b2e3","2fafb424587ed24e064ecacb7086a4678593dc48b74b10960f6125c3a806c5fc","86f053d07234bf0f34c7c37d214ccbbac9591bb34f212f716957a3a70a6a88bf"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"92748ffb34d6479c1272c6d9e379dd9e031f7a517038c9f8eabae1deb007ddd6","submission_id":"TS103-8742e640c2ae6640#1"},"hash":"656faef8a7b4ab58d5db842799ad8c795bb2b9c8602333af264b8eb76e5cd2bd","header":{"body_hash":"f4ef68f5af5ab8dc24594f7444b5eba5e6207ca01d92673334978961aac6154a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"ed3a18692ab150d6ea7f8a814adfa357c9306ca0a4b5a448cc5be6a53cf72881","records_root":"df817cfafdaed3a335cd6360dc659164612e5c43a580542803dd5fcc282955c9","seq":443,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"7f55df9bba6142c7a3953bd35d7ee0d8b086ba41a3365cd17e18906cffbf4cd2","command":{"allowed_records":["00ac1ecd92f489b4f0a1ed4ec1ba9365d1740a1cdfd5a571155715191fe69723","0207e441872b32768f06b2b43475b8e272a79fe8f833013cb771c4f31e1ed4c9","022983dbf293f383575ad337f5d90b42f48a2e807897d776a8de992500d28e39","027b6c6b98ea140fd90dbe47965c1c5e3607acf9b88b9b8ca71e199cadc880f0","02ac2d80dacc43a46f0d5764098f99152575f910628b421eb915f12bcc20e94c","0311d6c80244bf3d49da88fc47cd995e9180f3aa43bfe70d26234c7f0d0d06ac","04588ef5a34c56f45b9b03fffb833e4377f0c87c5d6a96285ccaafbb43c64c4b","05d56e8737c6174ad5b67dc2a2ab1bf2cc310c6ddde552012b03e4400aa15075","08171dc1108c23e5474f5a0ba2be523e985d77dbd0bf2d3fd3dc754fba57773b","08a008c50aa08b2eddd5d87dcc111c0b4779ca0cb559910a63fa20ea7443adca","08a0f7812f39b520053db4378f195e8ff25b5c35c462c2900b63dd0f79e5801a","090e5204183d6aba151db2a546adf333960e9c874402943d8b5c62de46c03caf","099cebfd1758d63a8957557f3c228e2e7dd1e62a7b5adca8719ba563cc67bb76","0a18f06fbbdcbb5cbab484a3e1afe07603bcbec9e2073c901678806cb5d0861b","0cc5da2e9d0178e36f4bd22710c9333e2645b45338e4d08d879379edc167538c","0d4f47dd7cc213bfc377b037616c2bdd1fbf4b916a8edae15ca4980717738bcb","0e2316188912e96684d1336cd3382467942a02571c7f844ae68b6c55d589bf95","0f6052ca7e51b9016f79aa0dd716f937cbae0fa6a481b8c4360cf7a5a357ee5d","119fd003a2f0d64d2e103321c35f1c47e62f81d921a7964479f5b423f95407ec","120c641c729b58be8150ff78ff7fa671ff8a77084cb18d16b6ac461904dd32ee","12efabe28f30f157ec3786f2a2da0becf6215d87cb2805e98577e49604cb2c6b","1442a45e909b8b540473da43a7ebd792468cd762da3af7d02146ec7a86004486","14481bdb74d88d8c0cac69cfa05381adc1aabfe9b2eb7331ea029e83dfe5b277","15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","15fa8c6698cd2c96de3d427b8991e0b419fc9105b10b79949556c4a7a17dca2d","17640e518001d72e2b4a1588865094706279b6c4120e10a58145c3f23234f01c","18d056e2dc42a0ea7e940872e5adf831b46c978bc66afb5e9ae08faec28eb6c3","1add7afcc218f8c67ea5649b00d41c25e96afd8e67596f41cc6518b690a1f9ac","1b3d1de993deef130125a82603c2714b1f40a24c7549e08eff124c2b13f682b4","1bbc6687f9d17196e9f1a40e85d9a6474a6d5f6c5587b928a03de18af41b226b","1c6f7b49947dced4ff20fdf3398385257a068828d60f0c9b27e5da6d7992d32c","1d0e6954a21f610903727e4e8b986078b0a738669d0ca0ff56cc1c86ea722721","1d32ed18ae378809b2892e68cb19280c1cbb86b5c07b26500319aad53207f6eb","1f1c46cef854d52d0b75590a8fe757a0c7f17a4d50397293eb5572d89a229f00","1ffcd9c7a419a3025e0b3f8ef2ae26395251acea937a6201169f51ab89520065","212ebd7f32241a5dfd2ac608b816747a7ba0ead90220145f6f98d04b1676ab5f","21e0b6501f65af2bf23798a61a82f101c87d341d22ae989e7bec3cf1c235d523","2244884a8871d2dd314bb49494af368eb1d160e46abecbfbf261024045c313c5","245f0de7532acff390ed2843c086bf6004432126a5469d12522e5ab84165bf9d","25b58c33f3a08575efc53530dae74182afe3f567557a714cbe4fbf29521591dc","26078c727bf727ce17cf72012cbe4fd4eac20f47ac264185cee7015c3021f3e5","2a4eb93d011bdadfe5166f0f73f31d7a25a9041474e96befb34fa46fa29d1a96","2d31d284beecc1d67e7b2df6203fe8a8b7544b7ed3496b230505e3666c40997b","2f53e5eb943013cd525dbd6a5ff1d8bae04896f0f07cdcaa6404c3d862872c8f","3042d0c4ef16d7ddabf1c659cb09ff4e465ceb96e7ad583b8eb117f6de9c7aea","330e485d1da601b452355bbd08fea709e173c37efff17a1580bbb5456efb4369","3348f2072123585da98e6b14d7912cb6dbe164b71b7bf4b46c0532c2af10a94e","339fe33af70438e309eedebc9c5cbc64743464ff0ee9b34f06518065b9c753fb","33b1ba9666262744926d1c8cd38e03d1b55c82ee0b16baf5c49972ea55b65c84","33fedaebad3c5f73a4491b35776c6bc7db3590afc82189cf2ab5ae59ebf6abe4","3708cc2df47a3e8c94329e4e446a32b9c0edd1e43b85df96519cc2f9748fb607","385babc4b2fdf6c21483cdfd6f0be36919f4f0ff4f8e9291e6bb879ad0b8eb40","39c73d811917f07d3b637b2fcea4a57cb37b59627643d91c4be155c6e485f653","3a8cbea1f64b59a41880d7bc1e9e4347e93d6a570cd6f494e19884ce528af4f7","3b0f21e3e163ef74be345449e0050cc14a6fb0b79ac2072986b7bc8c5ce46a97","3ba20fa867ddd9340087b3273c88895392eae955c92d152187bad9314731d153","3c8784a5b855170f811a0336315528e2f15fa843f2986b67a081a454dc35149a","3cb060c9bd3bd1cc602d656043a1eb9606060f8b54c5ebf692c063f740d29d13","3cf89c0564f05ab8068b33b238e583cc96f7e0ce1a8d75bcca2ea8d736402cb7","3dd10752fd5051f4fed5a926ccad10c6fb99fc63618a013c872981df5df1814d","3e4123b0e2effda421994c37f09bafe726378c6f73bef3f59f2ec23a71fbd93c","3f1bce000471ea4be84d36a8c26fa6ce70b925d8440fb30bf56cced7ec8ae5f6","40316a85dfb10877b9b47aeb66a0e6549427d940f4b72b626704a165a999c1fb","4076514025cbf6d81d5cf1efe1db0c6617c1ed42c55a3c7260813e82677c14e5","42a05caad3ac0a71d1cc0c21d877bb739f116e617c8752e49b127bb26de43de0","45f20def6861824e083a1a342716838a7e1d268fc2382741f7f5b5dee0fe8070","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","4948cd790a7aca1d74356919df4f148aaa1247145ac0836195d5d9522aa5e0d9","4a137cb7d345e0877c43e7c57a0f4f7277819b8d536d2598f091e7f874327a80","4a768c4dc683c8fbe8f2767d7c5da15f23e925ff7de339bf470e60538d7bd8ab","4abe67acf67ea5dba879afa708b81c97d930bd5095a9cab048600077b489fc2f","4b15401deb94a3656a337ef4b4bcd3422d4d8dff6513b7d3ee2c272809bdb8a6","4b7966cdad829e7a193b3ce475e1028716aed89432a2e49eee2fded2b92eea9f","4b7e78e56636d691cf451f4591d590a7d5a2165bd8993cd5c2046729879e4b63","4bbf122b34957c8acf0b678e97ba7662ee3b93bf1579c3e490bff5ca08740096","4deb3fe0eb77febb1addb904deaf96841bbc3c9782864a47e6df1897b6a472fe","51e7c38c15474878667edf926c96fe09ae5a224a1d38a1e53273987668e4050b","54680f8a0f335a2e92acf2ee6f81a217a3572430746e89e38fddf3860c005686","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","54c2520117d397eddd8d9ac35a3b6a94379533788aa9d203a5afcf71c3656e9b","5b46657304b4c9d8d3c3729eab6488e44adc92a401e3b230d8b5e5665a2c0981","5ba8bfa631be25263e40c29c35863ebddeef775e74df34f097ba78353e8efed6","5d4ff23b061016beec399ae514f71c3af64c9bcc4f49da4a3034b1bfeffa430b","5ddf848626d9510b690bd43251f7b9f6e394b2d3a3bba423d20b3203edc95062","5f39a0c541abab0d84dc8a7b62adc18db22d5d388b7aebabcd2a107ea39aa2a4","5fddadf17e948ef581edcdc26010f4746a93554e06a700fc689e8837bf43cb03","639c93d8c7469d049575b3437dcf33f2c46432ab0f402c66c545e7bf32a50c9d","6413a067ef9ba737af817e766b5632b3ba5adbfffb0b10f5b95a987a9f9080dd","649643003e1e27347985af33ab517e205ccdcf37f7ba638d2d343a87b07680f8","6527860faa20b249f71d5acd7941cdded1d86c9324a2ec392e9d3613e2e9d588","65f6d9d23a35e6eac6b13cc78f10a47f04ccb80aba5f1029ca7ecdbe0f8c6785","66ab11f4b7dfea37500c7b041c867e9247ee6251dd03fb4422e9d6a515f1e77d","6a7729235c4b15e24eaaac404d41bd4b023a9ce2b4bf9f6988e5b7d96a92e1ee","6cf40b2d2796b3fa13f02f405a2b9a11d82f11f5f54a64b10f20589dd0989cea","6ef1edc987764a4ca9b21757ac4e1e81e8eed6d83964650613702b35e9c41b22","6f700e126e0d100914477cb435407dfd299d4be95b7cf0379f3d8d3b8c6f2d8d","6f730d119ee0af0e67265f3d6328b9108997251f0549a3bdd419ff13ad591ee6","700ae7f028c1a74549e6b94b0dc6a5aca38934c2a46acde03c54c71391c54b22","7098f3a8d77d608b90d4acdd1022ef8491d5cb1ac3d1b9a2c2d6acb3323de089","7157439c05c936b85b7fee6e832363cc83b3965753cac8256b1d487342c51ff2","718e062d5da7611cc683f734c761f61efc42bde3c484a84601c7d4c7f2bce1a4","75b66684790552ec977b962824d8a4e85a41d2effc50226f9b697f7b901472c7","77227a3be7f73e785c8334065c045c25bbe960eca4f08ab00da7adb780465383","781d942ca92d77c7dbf094fa375a1750f498ad0612a9ce79fad725447f4fc5b2","789b2c492cb07d284c64f0532ade44de0affe5c45dd5cc530f84386d1eef4c98","795d578b1a001a00e899a5c976fab8bd06e246e0e0525ab36f04d792e40ef7ed","79d12d31b034b083446cdb16c7b73a8b019846a2a86ccf15eca5465ceebd1b1f","79f36ed5e7d4b6d63b1c4ce861ffbfb6376e74c21f19b946cb9409b22b6ce38c","7a6fb9541b43fab52d210eaa73a51b52a1a942a3a2073bae1ad7f014b753b4d8","7bc9e2f4b13c7447cca0b9b7e9b901a11428864abb49127c149f877bfca4e92a","7f77c5f520faae414ad8b14b025b2275385a5c128c3f5ea162200d8ba3638091","8275e6ad0bf10d2430cc7b89262a4bca3cdf6efa885f40f628400d9dcc512b76","83393296d0bb763b34ef00ad70c22c7aba459ce284ae9cb6c5d526ee970b7d53","83ea55e2cdc8fa0c752020f7191d9e5aea7b1b61de7e7ecad6f27458f21c2f0a","84f6b5d94ef84de06a8baf1985684980166710917b06e5b690f8bff036a84938","863535897f2aef3e494b5af69653e45a7e5840c38d7be8207af5fba7f9949202","86b606c8c70adbfbc1db885323470191d9d2e09d92bb9c170300f3c15e8e8301","86d3e30655b07eada4d90ebe241375ad003945a7b7b30fd0fdacb710cff5feff","876146ef6be3c37fa2acb55078eaf1394f7e7d67526bec40dd11285b0d54fe6e","876464adb279d62264a6bad0ec19bdcbdeb7a4f29ab0170db8a8dd32c6da93d6","878418a76e821e827c674f63922cdca27c9032850dcb1f43ba5de9ad8b7ccbf7","8ba974c364d52e6b43d75f8026bcfff3d4a324e22485650de8b6b821e8f674ea","8c12b002514f4d6cb6f06033fe6855534a7f5dba96dfed022d5d0a986273954b","8d0dd7807ec13c572f6807096823ba3853a6e1d481d53526c3f3563d12b7207b","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","8eed9fbdfba0472d67af6722a4fac7ccaec11dab7fafb19301cb5a77d022b446","919379b48cec048c79fcf2e746f053d6ba9b7c8b74ac983ea6fa8df54afc109f","9228d9495d52af720c230dc6a6eb3644189bf923521ee0a3c0ac6c1009ad1583","926d69cdd0ce87e828672bd7c01fc418c5d0556451698b5cf81e0b51c808886f","92b2cb88b636a8f9e370c3a4c69940f2b37c9c105a770590a5c2a24c4200d251","931d5261296cc42ccaf345b176b5e4f3da9f553bfe292b6b5811481021cb1405","9369828e4df5a65832a0ed6801f34c3b3eb85c69eafbc257b882e3cfbc079df1","93ab1a62f7082761a57f2da3762190b55bce7efcbe097296ef7fe2f21fb42b39","93be540e7edb27167a112c1f2cdf6f8de8fbdc4b0027e49a41db5251dd8d6a29","9859c7902ef863cf21dcde841aec319bc43264ba78bcdf4e7d79718baebb4ea3","9884ec5f6cfd4209a58f13aba718d240476eda27b02f5bf2306fd976e059d1d3","99da2a239ecd0fa24836150eb43b398fa33a76b764c6ca2052af1bd1958add94","9b34e1e5d6cd6682311e2376e18dc24736e001a01ad41fdc3b99133549100c99","9bac28d24e66ee005c77c3b82f84f6f7d0e32c7a9aac2356d869b985e8104610","9c18ba44e30c2b303f9e4536aa736b83cca544167359fd76a77bae4c66133e14","9cec90a915f4cb77af91065d34b63157da307154b014b90027064666da4645bd","9d807115d2b186abcb5172a8fca9f20c91a5652dee8bf4720f69de48ea7d6a64","9f8a18dcb79900654a9b027395dcc293d30d9d5b32832751f587cf74ee49138f","9fb11adb29d4c09fbcc7be00546bacc8560e33b2efdfffdd96f10f7c0eda9c67","9fd06bae684a9110374c5fb9d4f5ad68e9be75363f5e5c384ad2c579f95cb139","9fdb47f636c92d84c494448402e45626a0de35ac6844575976b21e5b7430fc77","a15f4c3d5d2367acbb0281d54f0b245ffe4dd072eb4cba1ddc780fc1d920f8a6","a370f962cbeeb263a7d46489b934ceb70cb7c1575c525defb19eede11de0d2c5","a4b64a6badde1d2f8ad4f1dfa9acdc69cb99a1d503f489a71951529c47c12db9","a715c9f86ff1c65cc0a55bd7c5aacb6435b867f12171c51c9b4ba9b3c4c908f4","a886153044d80e9b04324f54336412c5785bd7f643d5876e240ce03541a9106a","a8df37fb13db5044cd4d893ff45827c544cb284e437f94809437d4d1d74a141b","a929fbeb38ee0720bc1dce9d68b55b6f369e959e2960e094b87bd120203e7474","a941f9ce34467a2991412ae341603c383fb676593c3fe0f1ae41b12015f298a4","aa3e3319856c40999d7ec64635618670d9e798fd81044262a185ebe07d7e4a14","aacef8efa2e6a417f1b52fe6178c01a92926217d226bf4474d50104813e148b6","ab50716eaf98e80e955c51de5fb5292ac4e8e45f94dfece10fc847319161627f","ab748f39834204f2fd03a1b68f76e0124a8d48937673b5cb79614a2059212ab1","abe8df605d6ddcbd2ae2915269869072be6711598b0b316bb8bb34f5765bccc1","ae7fcdb0a791e5dbd206acd70718e8e9b02a9065c976fb7805de5aeed981b798","b138ed198daee4e07279426cb6b049aeafeb647c94c57bd6822c826d1bbe36ee","b14e037fc8d4a27756eacfab295d284333ee39c40f9b871ca9a0e87fa3f36e45","b1aafb63a7491e460e849689ea06d5eb3c285ab6f86a2f65deb313b35ac54396","b24c2d613e9ba2076c4eaefb37afc995fbee36e687161365b4f13246a71408f1","b319f7b38290998a06835d6b4cb8e9f9abba55947f8c1329fa45abae0fbfb9e5","b4019c63a6c67f255e84a7fd728a82f74e9df127d7ac3632f688b10000984455","b4b926d03621298c80844a13e4214af41ec3b93fd0f2d3e019f26528a16ca5c0","b6111c5c1a067f6e3de6440660b793eda0904ddbe66b144cff84a6e624e48d5c","b613aa3cdb2c80da02db9880d03ba3f6f28b08092c965e0f7a48edfd333c4808","b66d3c7719896288b129db6393cfff8377c8332d0ada947e14245afd3180d9df","b7d63db0f7665c364f87430d715e48eb6b66b97bf7125ad10d4e80b8e985c5d4","b8b6faa88ab5d76879d445859e17d39755fa75e6dbb42381c86171b31bb67758","b9a43e16b5db2cb4571d60df498390846118ef1cb70e672c6bea4adef32854a4","b9c6b8db508e8d981c8b3e8ccffd07a24bbd7c6d253e072bdb9f0f234f37d97a","bb09d21fd3c8e030a7cea551738e010c9e94972b97ff0523cfe8505c43055c40","bc0350f535c72e3753a6081622cd8ff160f83bd07a2067d68ba905d039420b5f","bc287469642e6e2d18e0bd6414f1a85b20c9991fbf9d0d6d7baacb23f360a835","bd8f2470831e2078e3e64c8b80d75e55019328a342d427fe6f79212da3c9de69","beb271a2eb79c7b00fad16641e9fc400eea7fd2dbc197413ba1e12174f451018","bf055b5f673c3f3b1da9a1d6baa56d4640d40a0bf9ac9ebc77a6b6c1e8b4aaf5","bfe4a7243c1f4d5cacfe8a729399d72f7422670356cf1b0dfc2f74f1d05df3dc","c0c1c7ef91e3e8bdeda6f7e4ad0b3da17c9095cfd5a1530856bb1fae92882105","c0c6fa3eb98f673d1053efaf46c1d7574f3c5498eaf421e494d12c27fa77db6b","c1d1032e545c9754beb395dff87dfdd3292d83a377de06c8359f4f8295f4846f","c1f1842ac7edd40216eeb0e549bee92652bb0ebfa92d9d927769a7649a4aa262","c37cecbee0a0d221902161b77e6bc134440623472682a77333282fe0928acebc","c77e037744af41a322bb0007afb425299448da934c801574cf2fa5a7b73ded1a","c7abc03fd01e6b0848ca2b930079d25527381cc5d19b90c5a8cdb07d0d68006d","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","c8daec1b2023e24c51829b77d4226756aa48e26adaef1014f0e80f9d16331807","c8e3f255c060ad77bb7a3ad5322fbc71d23843a4209605fb248c1223f8f13eca","c9d22d0eeea05ce10eaf5450010966db8c15ac0c315bb44bb165cc7f1c8b2651","c9ea7c273e3d9ceb3e58e3b255c39425c611d8b802a5acab03680dc89bcfd4b5","cb6231312b40d6303f478ae118f1783eeea849a19c6e0235298b3d0a0d087b78","ccf224838daf27b808aed618057702104630e3ba0a8e82c7751a984ec180502d","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cd501828dc0547c11e08e73409372f8a06db27df8b36e60b345f45aac548fb8a","ce710c268fc0953cffbbdde0f363d0604bf11cbff0bfc10d4a05805db5bbd328","d17a3218c9172c9aada2f7abc7327410815497f0595dd3bca46c7cf632dec4ad","d1b724bfdd244b173a6d978ce563ea1828127923b74360c8da55baa45f871dc9","d2c1665c1bf6367889fb46710faa10819a3fd449b698dbca1951798014d99d85","d38d51b340d3e726b17fccef562bd07a8f442391957079b9b851057cbd99f06d","d5459c4cabe99ee33196c154c271ec16afc132f99b5a137dcf88d85b13f8304f","d5d3148bc57b9756cbb1da6c99d82bb0ebfe577bfb69e921b2de296e9680b23e","d5e75611e9f288db8f4c1affc54696367b287ea130ee7a049fe35ad6f9e79631","d63eb41a760dc52a5a9324f0edb8cd81c75c6ed78142290553952b7a7410f214","d76d4295435f00384500b58976004e0ca2bd324b42b12548be8e056ad4bd2a7d","d7c3914cb187b8216ccdb93c8e43c2d4b9c9f1997abe329f81ac6912cae99664","da367720408cd0d6132edc6a0622a4f7c11b4390551d8cbf0ccaa34ed157a1b2","dbf9ebffc05df49fb0980fed86c458261b8fb691cb3b91fbaad4d0c0f38d839d","dcb1050604203e09173d157863a64b0b133e62a25052924647606314823981a1","de76ced14702cdd2b5b6a8668243ffe439718091abb4182964cf7b954879358f","df423fae466916abc12ce24808f5dc92ddc18911f34678c654401b872356f974","dfca6ea813dff69d4c1fd00d08c57a459f301100608067050f5abef38c911c5a","dfd29d54438fe5ec01424de96f328e02c5778b7a371b073e2180e8db5cbc9244","e0676eeb1d1c9297167b3510ad0b40f85e93f082c9dc0630b60029f45f851b62","e0c49cc45838fdf2866e303ad798b5590fc6b1511b3ee9b4fabd4ee97d9ff31a","e124f0cfe13c60194e8e51a6815a0d230b226a078fa1c649e8524dfe3389def9","e5464a9c67ea781f936eb0fe4f4b1587e33675c765f52d760dc66589c0214f0d","e58662351f5fbf1dfed4556012bb58ea26793710ff82758ebb15504a7c3556b5","e58cb5715f3a2dd5580c95472017fcdd116d5f54417401a2c266719799198e58","e5a028efb2107b7fccf87ff9616fbcc360adbdd776db3dc537b86c08b0f3013d","e654eaee77a53167e989b2855cd1542b719de7040b5e815b844b5c143ae6baa0","e68c0b845eaa5db361a4e7a58f7dfc26b316870b0c5a5da9b2e34d00f0661204","e7342a7f85458c6318ebb75f8b2f0340c1c6e0e0dafc8e79eff3442ba73b35da","e8912985e6037b252a7a37444123107c88302dfcbe0a041d990bf49ea8f7de75","e8c474da69c2e5b36422b9f13d96076e16ef745a3b9aac6e04c87ab4560bd45e","ed01400e0952592d809b6404f2cecb8ef0687ff00fed19cb19bbdd421f7e9930","ed0def08684ec7e0d3de11934740aac67a8498475b1aa6b0cad49428719a96fe","ed44d390f70035ac5b370ff25ea77eeb4cb7184e76448bc2492edde3487eca68","ed7d8256a59b85069106a3d445fdeb27d2f03ff94cddf445277cff4ffd8da5ec","ee419d37f7f3a91adde665fdb8900cb50159b6e6414209bab6fe74c337bc6d86","ee994e3a7448d1df2760a1453842f128b03d7e1405275e1fd7dac70c88803c78","eecebf3955e6a6f3d4247d2c3bf17b64934995c3386deae779ddcbf13ab62fb2","eedbadb1f43e94f0a9531adf32b2303ed48d6dd672d91fe8355fa654b5251ef6","ef069e07ea5452baa01d851837c9d4756ee134632b283ebc57473a61da89b072","ef29f2b02761b0e141ef15c460de36ddd815209c9ea400025b39dcf21d733da9","ef92f93bb17a361f6e2aef2eded441362dd8aa894916eb2fa7ed6ac793860c48","f11ed666387c771e0be45889b4e9f311c61ff44a6bcacd1278784210211a1b99","f34566341285af094bf3d17c09e5a71a4a48ab7c8b1b65d8d70d4e0bd3cdb5f3","f34d0296c44c4041ef7b3891c9d0ccc696df36ba65d5e96903c7abe4333a708b","f3a83c0cf21c24cb6b7bc03abad9af715ebe03bf0efd4673f68c01d87cbd87dd","f3ef574e67528a1a852757901d0aff4d208ee782f3e4623e28ccc33ffe7252f9","f572b3b4ab9c8af99a97197ec37fb0e3a97b7ede608543e263f5dca212d7b2e5","f6ebc6f9096d3dce03a6b171fd5a941afbe4815700afbea0acc1ea6908b44cbc","f7a7d13375d7593cadd49c6bc13a2bca09b8a557339f6a4044642d7ef9ba2d3e","f8bd5f06416f38881195c3906330f73dbe68484134c0eb8d6b6b751711486ee7","f8c7dddac5532e2597b3a86ec18246870de973f2591794a175dced4814898e90","f999bd21067dcf15466a9d53dba1a724c2f02c4065f58c4adc1c5f7e434d7466","fc5840251ef2a9de3eb986711162fe3e01af088d12572c42277e87a7cdd47dc0","fc85a0d917744d753c773c00875cd145b6d5d1133ccd772f501f8b1edcad9fc6","fca72b00cc2b15d834651209f34d8091cc85adeffef4c1166f60fc7795f495a0","fd3c44ea3c11bdc16e30d0816424e8f6307c87cec35461f0dac4618aa6fc1753","fedfbf4403eccbc6aba5721bcd788cafa76c7602aae35097d226082100bf1c6f","ff7476f8cc35422263e3f0116ec8ba13b96b2b148381695e3b78c1fb040741b6","ffd89af109e0eef154365e6b5df997fbd5241388f5c82bfc883f93c697dd9926"],"directive":"TS103-8742e640c2ae6640","kind":"submit","lines":[{"answer_ids":["t103_c1","t103_c2","t103_c3","t103_c4","t103_c5","t103_c6","t103_c7","t103_c8","t103_c9","t103_c10","t103_c11","t103_c12","t103_c13","t103_c14","t103_c15","t103_c16","t103_c17","t103_c18","t103_c19","t103_c20","t103_c21","t103_c22"],"directive_id":"TS103-8742e640c2ae6640","kind":"done","local_id":"t103_d1","outcome":"answered","rq_id":"q2","text":"Incomplete coverage (99/166 claims unshown; unread text). Unsettled: Wang & Fan 2025 internal results/citations; PMC13647323 42 study list & moderator stats; full RQ1-5/benchmark details."}],"scope":{"docs":[],"ranges":[],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"a1e14a4502a8b52c5627dbfdb491bdad8cfddf1e17cc5fc758cd42f8f04f63e0","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["7fc1584dab954c833c84a89c8ff4f3be32027f7fec16e34a62dce201d48bfb4e"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"bab2f24cc643ddd37de5fc0d238b2139e5aa3174ec0cc0089106188e2d39f85b","submission_id":"TS103-8742e640c2ae6640#1.1"},"hash":"630137430568660f78c4db5d190cf6114fe0837aa98cb95e976242c91a57fe57","header":{"body_hash":"eb8079e791513a35687510e3ef58ad0be887400228e97c4813508a161c7d0889","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"656faef8a7b4ab58d5db842799ad8c795bb2b9c8602333af264b8eb76e5cd2bd","records_root":"70da3248731e6616c4a0d3045170779b2a6f4bbf2dc9b6ce5d4b75c4140187f8","seq":444,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-1","audit_root":"03a08c8a5490051f5d1399bb762a60b5db097ecae2d3d7de6ac6bf05d313f0e5","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-1","answer_ids":["8a5797472f630188b8b943be1f7bb5c4ca34d7784a39f6ad31399ad550830d86","9ed7695e821d1555293f5ac5b70c2abc93e88a770e843b87979be90ce5c91a39","c7e12c3a06b274f98764b92e94ff85a354e43f09d9911d75d6c183df47648084","6f01841172e93949a12cca6a14f6eaa6370b85a725df5fdc41ee756e9a3ef8bc","f1064b149d9eafbc10bad14288ae9abc5e2b3a168835e6d9ace9dfaf84f9bacf","9baf739e230d7e0989c950334089be602cffb3f41d0a5faa8c53e22346ed2a03","11842bc73366f5526afa5f65ae15b88326869f01e36f05f527121988cbb43d23","275ca6c673440473bbc3f3282f75b8496b809bb615972cd742d9cf706f71451e","7185e5581a258ca68b87d3e95a9bac66eb43cbc55960aba3a40dfa82ec43079f","c1c5cf9e4b06435c1da5cbb087aa8d5b3d8250dbd9c57bc066f5390b14eb3632","2ab0031a5a24089217684829d137dce91bd83e34accc82639028241aa8bc3301","0012d826fb4aa3c89fc0d372417f18affce2791a9fa705a06cea5325e6a5b179","594f77fea05aeaa28400298258daf3a9100851349deedfe84b094bd0ebf92ebc","f05fa23f8bc5ded3df1ba1dcb83c3ee513aaceccb38ea58ee3f31a926a90887e","e601afc0ce5c66c897bf047d29d73209cd4471b09d265f6a0d5860a8e09c4af3","7d3c8f25c9d788cf1e617e71a8af34169e4a3af372a152ed3430fbfec749c2dc","320e8ab30b71b3a235ba187f0b155dbf2b64887623f67cd78fd715a37994ac8e","be2ef8f5f367249be475d78d30be41c45fadce582d05a32ca83bce4f7177a8db","564c5c3ba5f16d3bb90251feb27ccfefb02cd1674de0ea3009968e24b79d139e","dc8564ec47348688bc2ab3c95db9f9772947ebc2b28631adc9392bc42d01b2e3","2fafb424587ed24e064ecacb7086a4678593dc48b74b10960f6125c3a806c5fc","86f053d07234bf0f34c7c37d214ccbbac9591bb34f212f716957a3a70a6a88bf"],"circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","delivery_audit":{"had_refusals":false,"partial_declared":false,"repair_count":0,"retained_rows":0},"done":"7fc1584dab954c833c84a89c8ff4f3be32027f7fec16e34a62dce201d48bfb4e","kind":"SUMMARIZE","link_task":null,"outcome":"answered","question_set_revision":"0502c9aea43e1ce04869d20bb1cd0c78050175800b1315cbc452ab3a7a0fce2e","rq_id":"q2","sync_step":43,"task_id":"TS103-8742e640c2ae6640"},"from":0,"key":"task:rq:q2","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"a1e14a4502a8b52c5627dbfdb491bdad8cfddf1e17cc5fc758cd42f8f04f63e0","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"fda92aea1f3046dea3fdbf522049434b9fcffc82043457983860f89aaf3029b7","submission_id":"TS103-8742e640c2ae6640#done2"},"hash":"cf0e5f03dadeb373321247512ca9965b20961d4af614ca518aa3eb8f04afa56e","header":{"body_hash":"f4e1d2cbc56c76b68592867685718a3e1b709364177a704e9cd6702a4b0ead3a","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"630137430568660f78c4db5d190cf6114fe0837aa98cb95e976242c91a57fe57","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":445,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"owner","audit_root":"35d456d14e78fa72867da7895c22c0a7d851b98edb0eee8311edc8cca3bb990e","command":{"doc_id":"retracted-metaanalysis-wang-fan-2025.txt","exact_quote":"Title: The effect of ChatGPT on students' learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis.","kind":"revoke_text"},"engine_root":"cb1a471c06bac5e6b7c9fc5c81fe2bd9c385bead6921b07b78fb66106d7c178c","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"also_revoked":2,"revoked":true}},"request_hash":"f427fdcc8c517110b78f3a68edcfd11997da4f428e15a9d5b6714fd75842afea","submission_id":"auto_445_f427fdcc8c517110b78f3a68edcfd11997da4f428e15a9d5b6714fd75842afea"},"hash":"bd8bcd3958825f2f62adebf3d23c80ae241729a7898a18a9fd3f54f5b35bd01a","header":{"body_hash":"5ca0abc544d2f110744adf186d9435e0e5f42803c82335102db758b048c92400","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"cf0e5f03dadeb373321247512ca9965b20961d4af614ca518aa3eb8f04afa56e","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":446,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"9d12d0754bb64c8abcd7fc0b0425e6fea45ca4e5c2f588723598d0f2ff2be7ee","command":{"allowed_records":["0012d826fb4aa3c89fc0d372417f18affce2791a9fa705a06cea5325e6a5b179","00ac1ecd92f489b4f0a1ed4ec1ba9365d1740a1cdfd5a571155715191fe69723","022983dbf293f383575ad337f5d90b42f48a2e807897d776a8de992500d28e39","027b6c6b98ea140fd90dbe47965c1c5e3607acf9b88b9b8ca71e199cadc880f0","02ac2d80dacc43a46f0d5764098f99152575f910628b421eb915f12bcc20e94c","0311d6c80244bf3d49da88fc47cd995e9180f3aa43bfe70d26234c7f0d0d06ac","04588ef5a34c56f45b9b03fffb833e4377f0c87c5d6a96285ccaafbb43c64c4b","04fe4cc52446ded29d3b964dc683a0a157a9fe61a5a18d4a3b414b4b8e43f97e","08171dc1108c23e5474f5a0ba2be523e985d77dbd0bf2d3fd3dc754fba57773b","08a008c50aa08b2eddd5d87dcc111c0b4779ca0cb559910a63fa20ea7443adca","08a0f7812f39b520053db4378f195e8ff25b5c35c462c2900b63dd0f79e5801a","090e5204183d6aba151db2a546adf333960e9c874402943d8b5c62de46c03caf","099cebfd1758d63a8957557f3c228e2e7dd1e62a7b5adca8719ba563cc67bb76","0a18f06fbbdcbb5cbab484a3e1afe07603bcbec9e2073c901678806cb5d0861b","0cc5da2e9d0178e36f4bd22710c9333e2645b45338e4d08d879379edc167538c","0d4f47dd7cc213bfc377b037616c2bdd1fbf4b916a8edae15ca4980717738bcb","0e2316188912e96684d1336cd3382467942a02571c7f844ae68b6c55d589bf95","0f6052ca7e51b9016f79aa0dd716f937cbae0fa6a481b8c4360cf7a5a357ee5d","11842bc73366f5526afa5f65ae15b88326869f01e36f05f527121988cbb43d23","119fd003a2f0d64d2e103321c35f1c47e62f81d921a7964479f5b423f95407ec","120c641c729b58be8150ff78ff7fa671ff8a77084cb18d16b6ac461904dd32ee","12efabe28f30f157ec3786f2a2da0becf6215d87cb2805e98577e49604cb2c6b","1442a45e909b8b540473da43a7ebd792468cd762da3af7d02146ec7a86004486","14481bdb74d88d8c0cac69cfa05381adc1aabfe9b2eb7331ea029e83dfe5b277","15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","15fa8c6698cd2c96de3d427b8991e0b419fc9105b10b79949556c4a7a17dca2d","17640e518001d72e2b4a1588865094706279b6c4120e10a58145c3f23234f01c","1add7afcc218f8c67ea5649b00d41c25e96afd8e67596f41cc6518b690a1f9ac","1bbc6687f9d17196e9f1a40e85d9a6474a6d5f6c5587b928a03de18af41b226b","1d0e6954a21f610903727e4e8b986078b0a738669d0ca0ff56cc1c86ea722721","1d32ed18ae378809b2892e68cb19280c1cbb86b5c07b26500319aad53207f6eb","1f1c46cef854d52d0b75590a8fe757a0c7f17a4d50397293eb5572d89a229f00","1ffcd9c7a419a3025e0b3f8ef2ae26395251acea937a6201169f51ab89520065","212ebd7f32241a5dfd2ac608b816747a7ba0ead90220145f6f98d04b1676ab5f","21e0b6501f65af2bf23798a61a82f101c87d341d22ae989e7bec3cf1c235d523","2244884a8871d2dd314bb49494af368eb1d160e46abecbfbf261024045c313c5","245f0de7532acff390ed2843c086bf6004432126a5469d12522e5ab84165bf9d","25b58c33f3a08575efc53530dae74182afe3f567557a714cbe4fbf29521591dc","26078c727bf727ce17cf72012cbe4fd4eac20f47ac264185cee7015c3021f3e5","275ca6c673440473bbc3f3282f75b8496b809bb615972cd742d9cf706f71451e","2ab0031a5a24089217684829d137dce91bd83e34accc82639028241aa8bc3301","2d31d284beecc1d67e7b2df6203fe8a8b7544b7ed3496b230505e3666c40997b","2f53e5eb943013cd525dbd6a5ff1d8bae04896f0f07cdcaa6404c3d862872c8f","2fafb424587ed24e064ecacb7086a4678593dc48b74b10960f6125c3a806c5fc","3042d0c4ef16d7ddabf1c659cb09ff4e465ceb96e7ad583b8eb117f6de9c7aea","320e8ab30b71b3a235ba187f0b155dbf2b64887623f67cd78fd715a37994ac8e","330e485d1da601b452355bbd08fea709e173c37efff17a1580bbb5456efb4369","3348f2072123585da98e6b14d7912cb6dbe164b71b7bf4b46c0532c2af10a94e","339fe33af70438e309eedebc9c5cbc64743464ff0ee9b34f06518065b9c753fb","33b1ba9666262744926d1c8cd38e03d1b55c82ee0b16baf5c49972ea55b65c84","33fedaebad3c5f73a4491b35776c6bc7db3590afc82189cf2ab5ae59ebf6abe4","3708cc2df47a3e8c94329e4e446a32b9c0edd1e43b85df96519cc2f9748fb607","385babc4b2fdf6c21483cdfd6f0be36919f4f0ff4f8e9291e6bb879ad0b8eb40","39c73d811917f07d3b637b2fcea4a57cb37b59627643d91c4be155c6e485f653","3a8cbea1f64b59a41880d7bc1e9e4347e93d6a570cd6f494e19884ce528af4f7","3b0f21e3e163ef74be345449e0050cc14a6fb0b79ac2072986b7bc8c5ce46a97","3c8784a5b855170f811a0336315528e2f15fa843f2986b67a081a454dc35149a","3cb060c9bd3bd1cc602d656043a1eb9606060f8b54c5ebf692c063f740d29d13","3cf89c0564f05ab8068b33b238e583cc96f7e0ce1a8d75bcca2ea8d736402cb7","3dd10752fd5051f4fed5a926ccad10c6fb99fc63618a013c872981df5df1814d","3e4123b0e2effda421994c37f09bafe726378c6f73bef3f59f2ec23a71fbd93c","3f1bce000471ea4be84d36a8c26fa6ce70b925d8440fb30bf56cced7ec8ae5f6","40316a85dfb10877b9b47aeb66a0e6549427d940f4b72b626704a165a999c1fb","4076514025cbf6d81d5cf1efe1db0c6617c1ed42c55a3c7260813e82677c14e5","42a05caad3ac0a71d1cc0c21d877bb739f116e617c8752e49b127bb26de43de0","45f20def6861824e083a1a342716838a7e1d268fc2382741f7f5b5dee0fe8070","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","4948cd790a7aca1d74356919df4f148aaa1247145ac0836195d5d9522aa5e0d9","4a137cb7d345e0877c43e7c57a0f4f7277819b8d536d2598f091e7f874327a80","4a768c4dc683c8fbe8f2767d7c5da15f23e925ff7de339bf470e60538d7bd8ab","4abe67acf67ea5dba879afa708b81c97d930bd5095a9cab048600077b489fc2f","4b15401deb94a3656a337ef4b4bcd3422d4d8dff6513b7d3ee2c272809bdb8a6","4b7966cdad829e7a193b3ce475e1028716aed89432a2e49eee2fded2b92eea9f","4b7e78e56636d691cf451f4591d590a7d5a2165bd8993cd5c2046729879e4b63","4deb3fe0eb77febb1addb904deaf96841bbc3c9782864a47e6df1897b6a472fe","51e7c38c15474878667edf926c96fe09ae5a224a1d38a1e53273987668e4050b","54680f8a0f335a2e92acf2ee6f81a217a3572430746e89e38fddf3860c005686","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","54b23081e73fd5f2d0f81760fe4d80fd61f86f29b201c7d232e9ccb5a40e2c4a","54c2520117d397eddd8d9ac35a3b6a94379533788aa9d203a5afcf71c3656e9b","564c5c3ba5f16d3bb90251feb27ccfefb02cd1674de0ea3009968e24b79d139e","594f77fea05aeaa28400298258daf3a9100851349deedfe84b094bd0ebf92ebc","5b46657304b4c9d8d3c3729eab6488e44adc92a401e3b230d8b5e5665a2c0981","5ba8bfa631be25263e40c29c35863ebddeef775e74df34f097ba78353e8efed6","5f39a0c541abab0d84dc8a7b62adc18db22d5d388b7aebabcd2a107ea39aa2a4","5fddadf17e948ef581edcdc26010f4746a93554e06a700fc689e8837bf43cb03","639c93d8c7469d049575b3437dcf33f2c46432ab0f402c66c545e7bf32a50c9d","6413a067ef9ba737af817e766b5632b3ba5adbfffb0b10f5b95a987a9f9080dd","649643003e1e27347985af33ab517e205ccdcf37f7ba638d2d343a87b07680f8","6527860faa20b249f71d5acd7941cdded1d86c9324a2ec392e9d3613e2e9d588","65f6d9d23a35e6eac6b13cc78f10a47f04ccb80aba5f1029ca7ecdbe0f8c6785","66ab11f4b7dfea37500c7b041c867e9247ee6251dd03fb4422e9d6a515f1e77d","6a7729235c4b15e24eaaac404d41bd4b023a9ce2b4bf9f6988e5b7d96a92e1ee","6cf40b2d2796b3fa13f02f405a2b9a11d82f11f5f54a64b10f20589dd0989cea","6ef1edc987764a4ca9b21757ac4e1e81e8eed6d83964650613702b35e9c41b22","6f01841172e93949a12cca6a14f6eaa6370b85a725df5fdc41ee756e9a3ef8bc","6f700e126e0d100914477cb435407dfd299d4be95b7cf0379f3d8d3b8c6f2d8d","6f730d119ee0af0e67265f3d6328b9108997251f0549a3bdd419ff13ad591ee6","700ae7f028c1a74549e6b94b0dc6a5aca38934c2a46acde03c54c71391c54b22","7098f3a8d77d608b90d4acdd1022ef8491d5cb1ac3d1b9a2c2d6acb3323de089","7157439c05c936b85b7fee6e832363cc83b3965753cac8256b1d487342c51ff2","7185e5581a258ca68b87d3e95a9bac66eb43cbc55960aba3a40dfa82ec43079f","718e062d5da7611cc683f734c761f61efc42bde3c484a84601c7d4c7f2bce1a4","75b66684790552ec977b962824d8a4e85a41d2effc50226f9b697f7b901472c7","77227a3be7f73e785c8334065c045c25bbe960eca4f08ab00da7adb780465383","781d942ca92d77c7dbf094fa375a1750f498ad0612a9ce79fad725447f4fc5b2","789b2c492cb07d284c64f0532ade44de0affe5c45dd5cc530f84386d1eef4c98","795d578b1a001a00e899a5c976fab8bd06e246e0e0525ab36f04d792e40ef7ed","79d12d31b034b083446cdb16c7b73a8b019846a2a86ccf15eca5465ceebd1b1f","79f36ed5e7d4b6d63b1c4ce861ffbfb6376e74c21f19b946cb9409b22b6ce38c","7a6fb9541b43fab52d210eaa73a51b52a1a942a3a2073bae1ad7f014b753b4d8","7d3c8f25c9d788cf1e617e71a8af34169e4a3af372a152ed3430fbfec749c2dc","7f77c5f520faae414ad8b14b025b2275385a5c128c3f5ea162200d8ba3638091","7f89e5d4a8c3d15f00840feb20f8b98056a98b94e3c1a5bf67fe312915f950d9","8275e6ad0bf10d2430cc7b89262a4bca3cdf6efa885f40f628400d9dcc512b76","83393296d0bb763b34ef00ad70c22c7aba459ce284ae9cb6c5d526ee970b7d53","83ea55e2cdc8fa0c752020f7191d9e5aea7b1b61de7e7ecad6f27458f21c2f0a","84f6b5d94ef84de06a8baf1985684980166710917b06e5b690f8bff036a84938","863535897f2aef3e494b5af69653e45a7e5840c38d7be8207af5fba7f9949202","86b606c8c70adbfbc1db885323470191d9d2e09d92bb9c170300f3c15e8e8301","86d3e30655b07eada4d90ebe241375ad003945a7b7b30fd0fdacb710cff5feff","876146ef6be3c37fa2acb55078eaf1394f7e7d67526bec40dd11285b0d54fe6e","876464adb279d62264a6bad0ec19bdcbdeb7a4f29ab0170db8a8dd32c6da93d6","878418a76e821e827c674f63922cdca27c9032850dcb1f43ba5de9ad8b7ccbf7","8a5797472f630188b8b943be1f7bb5c4ca34d7784a39f6ad31399ad550830d86","8ba974c364d52e6b43d75f8026bcfff3d4a324e22485650de8b6b821e8f674ea","8c12b002514f4d6cb6f06033fe6855534a7f5dba96dfed022d5d0a986273954b","8d0dd7807ec13c572f6807096823ba3853a6e1d481d53526c3f3563d12b7207b","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","8eed9fbdfba0472d67af6722a4fac7ccaec11dab7fafb19301cb5a77d022b446","919379b48cec048c79fcf2e746f053d6ba9b7c8b74ac983ea6fa8df54afc109f","926d69cdd0ce87e828672bd7c01fc418c5d0556451698b5cf81e0b51c808886f","92b2cb88b636a8f9e370c3a4c69940f2b37c9c105a770590a5c2a24c4200d251","931d5261296cc42ccaf345b176b5e4f3da9f553bfe292b6b5811481021cb1405","9369828e4df5a65832a0ed6801f34c3b3eb85c69eafbc257b882e3cfbc079df1","93ab1a62f7082761a57f2da3762190b55bce7efcbe097296ef7fe2f21fb42b39","93be540e7edb27167a112c1f2cdf6f8de8fbdc4b0027e49a41db5251dd8d6a29","9859c7902ef863cf21dcde841aec319bc43264ba78bcdf4e7d79718baebb4ea3","9884ec5f6cfd4209a58f13aba718d240476eda27b02f5bf2306fd976e059d1d3","99da2a239ecd0fa24836150eb43b398fa33a76b764c6ca2052af1bd1958add94","99fd304cedf1870828fb0879ca8e562a645d95be4f37d9d3309a0d0253c7e049","9b34e1e5d6cd6682311e2376e18dc24736e001a01ad41fdc3b99133549100c99","9bac28d24e66ee005c77c3b82f84f6f7d0e32c7a9aac2356d869b985e8104610","9baf739e230d7e0989c950334089be602cffb3f41d0a5faa8c53e22346ed2a03","9c18ba44e30c2b303f9e4536aa736b83cca544167359fd76a77bae4c66133e14","9cec90a915f4cb77af91065d34b63157da307154b014b90027064666da4645bd","9d807115d2b186abcb5172a8fca9f20c91a5652dee8bf4720f69de48ea7d6a64","9ed7695e821d1555293f5ac5b70c2abc93e88a770e843b87979be90ce5c91a39","9f8a18dcb79900654a9b027395dcc293d30d9d5b32832751f587cf74ee49138f","9fd06bae684a9110374c5fb9d4f5ad68e9be75363f5e5c384ad2c579f95cb139","9fdb47f636c92d84c494448402e45626a0de35ac6844575976b21e5b7430fc77","a15f4c3d5d2367acbb0281d54f0b245ffe4dd072eb4cba1ddc780fc1d920f8a6","a352b5cc3246a8db265406075921ab01139805c38ffa43306c3d1cabbd7d64be","a370f962cbeeb263a7d46489b934ceb70cb7c1575c525defb19eede11de0d2c5","a4b64a6badde1d2f8ad4f1dfa9acdc69cb99a1d503f489a71951529c47c12db9","a715c9f86ff1c65cc0a55bd7c5aacb6435b867f12171c51c9b4ba9b3c4c908f4","a886153044d80e9b04324f54336412c5785bd7f643d5876e240ce03541a9106a","a8df37fb13db5044cd4d893ff45827c544cb284e437f94809437d4d1d74a141b","a929fbeb38ee0720bc1dce9d68b55b6f369e959e2960e094b87bd120203e7474","a941f9ce34467a2991412ae341603c383fb676593c3fe0f1ae41b12015f298a4","aa3e3319856c40999d7ec64635618670d9e798fd81044262a185ebe07d7e4a14","ab50716eaf98e80e955c51de5fb5292ac4e8e45f94dfece10fc847319161627f","ab748f39834204f2fd03a1b68f76e0124a8d48937673b5cb79614a2059212ab1","ae7fcdb0a791e5dbd206acd70718e8e9b02a9065c976fb7805de5aeed981b798","b138ed198daee4e07279426cb6b049aeafeb647c94c57bd6822c826d1bbe36ee","b14e037fc8d4a27756eacfab295d284333ee39c40f9b871ca9a0e87fa3f36e45","b24c2d613e9ba2076c4eaefb37afc995fbee36e687161365b4f13246a71408f1","b319f7b38290998a06835d6b4cb8e9f9abba55947f8c1329fa45abae0fbfb9e5","b4019c63a6c67f255e84a7fd728a82f74e9df127d7ac3632f688b10000984455","b6111c5c1a067f6e3de6440660b793eda0904ddbe66b144cff84a6e624e48d5c","b613aa3cdb2c80da02db9880d03ba3f6f28b08092c965e0f7a48edfd333c4808","b66d3c7719896288b129db6393cfff8377c8332d0ada947e14245afd3180d9df","b7d63db0f7665c364f87430d715e48eb6b66b97bf7125ad10d4e80b8e985c5d4","b9a43e16b5db2cb4571d60df498390846118ef1cb70e672c6bea4adef32854a4","b9c6b8db508e8d981c8b3e8ccffd07a24bbd7c6d253e072bdb9f0f234f37d97a","bb09d21fd3c8e030a7cea551738e010c9e94972b97ff0523cfe8505c43055c40","bc0350f535c72e3753a6081622cd8ff160f83bd07a2067d68ba905d039420b5f","bc287469642e6e2d18e0bd6414f1a85b20c9991fbf9d0d6d7baacb23f360a835","bd8f2470831e2078e3e64c8b80d75e55019328a342d427fe6f79212da3c9de69","be2ef8f5f367249be475d78d30be41c45fadce582d05a32ca83bce4f7177a8db","beb271a2eb79c7b00fad16641e9fc400eea7fd2dbc197413ba1e12174f451018","bf055b5f673c3f3b1da9a1d6baa56d4640d40a0bf9ac9ebc77a6b6c1e8b4aaf5","bfe4a7243c1f4d5cacfe8a729399d72f7422670356cf1b0dfc2f74f1d05df3dc","c0c1c7ef91e3e8bdeda6f7e4ad0b3da17c9095cfd5a1530856bb1fae92882105","c0c6fa3eb98f673d1053efaf46c1d7574f3c5498eaf421e494d12c27fa77db6b","c1c5cf9e4b06435c1da5cbb087aa8d5b3d8250dbd9c57bc066f5390b14eb3632","c1d1032e545c9754beb395dff87dfdd3292d83a377de06c8359f4f8295f4846f","c1f1842ac7edd40216eeb0e549bee92652bb0ebfa92d9d927769a7649a4aa262","c77e037744af41a322bb0007afb425299448da934c801574cf2fa5a7b73ded1a","c7abc03fd01e6b0848ca2b930079d25527381cc5d19b90c5a8cdb07d0d68006d","c7e12c3a06b274f98764b92e94ff85a354e43f09d9911d75d6c183df47648084","c8d0593020f89043b700bae65685d25a2604025c598397da438fee1f10e2b0ae","c8daec1b2023e24c51829b77d4226756aa48e26adaef1014f0e80f9d16331807","c8e3f255c060ad77bb7a3ad5322fbc71d23843a4209605fb248c1223f8f13eca","c9d22d0eeea05ce10eaf5450010966db8c15ac0c315bb44bb165cc7f1c8b2651","c9ea7c273e3d9ceb3e58e3b255c39425c611d8b802a5acab03680dc89bcfd4b5","cb6231312b40d6303f478ae118f1783eeea849a19c6e0235298b3d0a0d087b78","ccf224838daf27b808aed618057702104630e3ba0a8e82c7751a984ec180502d","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cd501828dc0547c11e08e73409372f8a06db27df8b36e60b345f45aac548fb8a","ce710c268fc0953cffbbdde0f363d0604bf11cbff0bfc10d4a05805db5bbd328","d17a3218c9172c9aada2f7abc7327410815497f0595dd3bca46c7cf632dec4ad","d1b724bfdd244b173a6d978ce563ea1828127923b74360c8da55baa45f871dc9","d2c1665c1bf6367889fb46710faa10819a3fd449b698dbca1951798014d99d85","d38d51b340d3e726b17fccef562bd07a8f442391957079b9b851057cbd99f06d","d5459c4cabe99ee33196c154c271ec16afc132f99b5a137dcf88d85b13f8304f","d5d3148bc57b9756cbb1da6c99d82bb0ebfe577bfb69e921b2de296e9680b23e","d5e75611e9f288db8f4c1affc54696367b287ea130ee7a049fe35ad6f9e79631","d63eb41a760dc52a5a9324f0edb8cd81c75c6ed78142290553952b7a7410f214","d76d4295435f00384500b58976004e0ca2bd324b42b12548be8e056ad4bd2a7d","d7c3914cb187b8216ccdb93c8e43c2d4b9c9f1997abe329f81ac6912cae99664","da367720408cd0d6132edc6a0622a4f7c11b4390551d8cbf0ccaa34ed157a1b2","dbf9ebffc05df49fb0980fed86c458261b8fb691cb3b91fbaad4d0c0f38d839d","dc8564ec47348688bc2ab3c95db9f9772947ebc2b28631adc9392bc42d01b2e3","dcb1050604203e09173d157863a64b0b133e62a25052924647606314823981a1","dfca6ea813dff69d4c1fd00d08c57a459f301100608067050f5abef38c911c5a","dfd29d54438fe5ec01424de96f328e02c5778b7a371b073e2180e8db5cbc9244","e0676eeb1d1c9297167b3510ad0b40f85e93f082c9dc0630b60029f45f851b62","e0c49cc45838fdf2866e303ad798b5590fc6b1511b3ee9b4fabd4ee97d9ff31a","e124f0cfe13c60194e8e51a6815a0d230b226a078fa1c649e8524dfe3389def9","e401cbf7c7bc5328cfada6af15f35b57a2635992ced3aefed513c3b619a8c27d","e58662351f5fbf1dfed4556012bb58ea26793710ff82758ebb15504a7c3556b5","e58cb5715f3a2dd5580c95472017fcdd116d5f54417401a2c266719799198e58","e5a028efb2107b7fccf87ff9616fbcc360adbdd776db3dc537b86c08b0f3013d","e601afc0ce5c66c897bf047d29d73209cd4471b09d265f6a0d5860a8e09c4af3","e654eaee77a53167e989b2855cd1542b719de7040b5e815b844b5c143ae6baa0","e7342a7f85458c6318ebb75f8b2f0340c1c6e0e0dafc8e79eff3442ba73b35da","e8912985e6037b252a7a37444123107c88302dfcbe0a041d990bf49ea8f7de75","e8c474da69c2e5b36422b9f13d96076e16ef745a3b9aac6e04c87ab4560bd45e","ed01400e0952592d809b6404f2cecb8ef0687ff00fed19cb19bbdd421f7e9930","ed0def08684ec7e0d3de11934740aac67a8498475b1aa6b0cad49428719a96fe","ed44d390f70035ac5b370ff25ea77eeb4cb7184e76448bc2492edde3487eca68","ed7d8256a59b85069106a3d445fdeb27d2f03ff94cddf445277cff4ffd8da5ec","ee419d37f7f3a91adde665fdb8900cb50159b6e6414209bab6fe74c337bc6d86","ee994e3a7448d1df2760a1453842f128b03d7e1405275e1fd7dac70c88803c78","eecebf3955e6a6f3d4247d2c3bf17b64934995c3386deae779ddcbf13ab62fb2","eedbadb1f43e94f0a9531adf32b2303ed48d6dd672d91fe8355fa654b5251ef6","ef069e07ea5452baa01d851837c9d4756ee134632b283ebc57473a61da89b072","ef92f93bb17a361f6e2aef2eded441362dd8aa894916eb2fa7ed6ac793860c48","f05fa23f8bc5ded3df1ba1dcb83c3ee513aaceccb38ea58ee3f31a926a90887e","f1064b149d9eafbc10bad14288ae9abc5e2b3a168835e6d9ace9dfaf84f9bacf","f11ed666387c771e0be45889b4e9f311c61ff44a6bcacd1278784210211a1b99","f34566341285af094bf3d17c09e5a71a4a48ab7c8b1b65d8d70d4e0bd3cdb5f3","f34d0296c44c4041ef7b3891c9d0ccc696df36ba65d5e96903c7abe4333a708b","f3a83c0cf21c24cb6b7bc03abad9af715ebe03bf0efd4673f68c01d87cbd87dd","f572b3b4ab9c8af99a97197ec37fb0e3a97b7ede608543e263f5dca212d7b2e5","f6ebc6f9096d3dce03a6b171fd5a941afbe4815700afbea0acc1ea6908b44cbc","f7a7d13375d7593cadd49c6bc13a2bca09b8a557339f6a4044642d7ef9ba2d3e","f8c7dddac5532e2597b3a86ec18246870de973f2591794a175dced4814898e90","f999bd21067dcf15466a9d53dba1a724c2f02c4065f58c4adc1c5f7e434d7466","fc5840251ef2a9de3eb986711162fe3e01af088d12572c42277e87a7cdd47dc0","fc85a0d917744d753c773c00875cd145b6d5d1133ccd772f501f8b1edcad9fc6","fca72b00cc2b15d834651209f34d8091cc85adeffef4c1166f60fc7795f495a0","fd3c44ea3c11bdc16e30d0816424e8f6307c87cec35461f0dac4618aa6fc1753","fedfbf4403eccbc6aba5721bcd788cafa76c7602aae35097d226082100bf1c6f","ffd89af109e0eef154365e6b5df997fbd5241388f5c82bfc883f93c697dd9926"],"directive":"TS2-17604b339068192d","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":20260422,"based_on":["@9fd06bae684a9110","@e8c474da69c2e5b3","@e0676eeb1d1c9297","@ab748f39834204f2","@aa3e3319856c4099","@9fdb47f636c92d84","@6a7729235c4b15e2","@718e062d5da7611c"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t2_c1","object":"published May 6, 2025 (12:621); retracted April 22, 2026 (13:528); record has bibliographic facts only (article text excluded)","predicate":"reports_record_status_and_scope","stance":"reported","subject":"Wang and Fan 2025","text":"The corpus record for Wang and Fan 2025 (Humanit Soc Sci Commun 2025 May 6;12:621, retracted 22 April 2026 in 13:528) includes bibliographic facts only and excludes the article's CC BY-NC-ND text."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@9f8a18dcb7990065","@54b23081e73fd5f2","@7f89e5d4a8c3d15f","@e401cbf7c7bc5328","@a352b5cc3246a8db"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t2_c2","object":"meta-analysis on ChatGPT, learning performance/perception, and higher-order thinking; cited in PMC13314867 and PMC13647323","predicate":"is_cited_by_corpus_articles_for","stance":"reported","subject":"Wang and Fan 2025","text":"PMC13314867 and PMC13647323 list Wang & Fan (2025; 12:621) as a meta-analysis on ChatGPT, learning performance, perception, and higher-order thinking, cited for critical thinking and academic/affective outcomes."}],"scope":{"docs":[],"ranges":[],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"cb1a471c06bac5e6b7c9fc5c81fe2bd9c385bead6921b07b78fb66106d7c178c","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["857683a877c57b82d2822e41daa8823754b13a59811eba7511a9101c1d31fd35","e9f3b85f1b6605988e81dcd0ec6ea06aa028754b5321231b1168f058d1d149e9"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"a5255ea281eec6cfa796db6f0c62d9cc6e5a592d64d340a89f40fa8b0426bc85","submission_id":"TS2-17604b339068192d#1"},"hash":"53b58e9dc283be7d03f608b195edaea27b3f7462ab5fbb570c18b067e1385239","header":{"body_hash":"5b3b6c0b06c4125fe68639419bbf7beaaa54bd0f9df2f63511b5ec99fc09bc30","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"bd8bcd3958825f2f62adebf3d23c80ae241729a7898a18a9fd3f54f5b35bd01a","records_root":"5e87e48050673715c065a9d012a99d22a84b39207085ad14b155d67839ddfff3","seq":447,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"081a22d868a0cc85859c2621d81fe89eba2c69ecdcfe473c4268bbe2cc18c379","command":{"allowed_records":["0012d826fb4aa3c89fc0d372417f18affce2791a9fa705a06cea5325e6a5b179","00ac1ecd92f489b4f0a1ed4ec1ba9365d1740a1cdfd5a571155715191fe69723","022983dbf293f383575ad337f5d90b42f48a2e807897d776a8de992500d28e39","027b6c6b98ea140fd90dbe47965c1c5e3607acf9b88b9b8ca71e199cadc880f0","02ac2d80dacc43a46f0d5764098f99152575f910628b421eb915f12bcc20e94c","0311d6c80244bf3d49da88fc47cd995e9180f3aa43bfe70d26234c7f0d0d06ac","04588ef5a34c56f45b9b03fffb833e4377f0c87c5d6a96285ccaafbb43c64c4b","04fe4cc52446ded29d3b964dc683a0a157a9fe61a5a18d4a3b414b4b8e43f97e","08171dc1108c23e5474f5a0ba2be523e985d77dbd0bf2d3fd3dc754fba57773b","08a008c50aa08b2eddd5d87dcc111c0b4779ca0cb559910a63fa20ea7443adca","08a0f7812f39b520053db4378f195e8ff25b5c35c462c2900b63dd0f79e5801a","090e5204183d6aba151db2a546adf333960e9c874402943d8b5c62de46c03caf","099cebfd1758d63a8957557f3c228e2e7dd1e62a7b5adca8719ba563cc67bb76","0a18f06fbbdcbb5cbab484a3e1afe07603bcbec9e2073c901678806cb5d0861b","0cc5da2e9d0178e36f4bd22710c9333e2645b45338e4d08d879379edc167538c","0d4f47dd7cc213bfc377b037616c2bdd1fbf4b916a8edae15ca4980717738bcb","0e2316188912e96684d1336cd3382467942a02571c7f844ae68b6c55d589bf95","0f6052ca7e51b9016f79aa0dd716f937cbae0fa6a481b8c4360cf7a5a357ee5d","11842bc73366f5526afa5f65ae15b88326869f01e36f05f527121988cbb43d23","119fd003a2f0d64d2e103321c35f1c47e62f81d921a7964479f5b423f95407ec","120c641c729b58be8150ff78ff7fa671ff8a77084cb18d16b6ac461904dd32ee","12efabe28f30f157ec3786f2a2da0becf6215d87cb2805e98577e49604cb2c6b","1442a45e909b8b540473da43a7ebd792468cd762da3af7d02146ec7a86004486","14481bdb74d88d8c0cac69cfa05381adc1aabfe9b2eb7331ea029e83dfe5b277","15d8a51bd6ab18a59916e1205c0989600bce001a78799cdd0b3db506b73d9464","15fa8c6698cd2c96de3d427b8991e0b419fc9105b10b79949556c4a7a17dca2d","17640e518001d72e2b4a1588865094706279b6c4120e10a58145c3f23234f01c","1add7afcc218f8c67ea5649b00d41c25e96afd8e67596f41cc6518b690a1f9ac","1bbc6687f9d17196e9f1a40e85d9a6474a6d5f6c5587b928a03de18af41b226b","1d0e6954a21f610903727e4e8b986078b0a738669d0ca0ff56cc1c86ea722721","1d32ed18ae378809b2892e68cb19280c1cbb86b5c07b26500319aad53207f6eb","1f1c46cef854d52d0b75590a8fe757a0c7f17a4d50397293eb5572d89a229f00","1ffcd9c7a419a3025e0b3f8ef2ae26395251acea937a6201169f51ab89520065","212ebd7f32241a5dfd2ac608b816747a7ba0ead90220145f6f98d04b1676ab5f","21e0b6501f65af2bf23798a61a82f101c87d341d22ae989e7bec3cf1c235d523","2244884a8871d2dd314bb49494af368eb1d160e46abecbfbf261024045c313c5","245f0de7532acff390ed2843c086bf6004432126a5469d12522e5ab84165bf9d","25b58c33f3a08575efc53530dae74182afe3f567557a714cbe4fbf29521591dc","26078c727bf727ce17cf72012cbe4fd4eac20f47ac264185cee7015c3021f3e5","275ca6c673440473bbc3f3282f75b8496b809bb615972cd742d9cf706f71451e","2ab0031a5a24089217684829d137dce91bd83e34accc82639028241aa8bc3301","2d31d284beecc1d67e7b2df6203fe8a8b7544b7ed3496b230505e3666c40997b","2f53e5eb943013cd525dbd6a5ff1d8bae04896f0f07cdcaa6404c3d862872c8f","2fafb424587ed24e064ecacb7086a4678593dc48b74b10960f6125c3a806c5fc","3042d0c4ef16d7ddabf1c659cb09ff4e465ceb96e7ad583b8eb117f6de9c7aea","320e8ab30b71b3a235ba187f0b155dbf2b64887623f67cd78fd715a37994ac8e","330e485d1da601b452355bbd08fea709e173c37efff17a1580bbb5456efb4369","3348f2072123585da98e6b14d7912cb6dbe164b71b7bf4b46c0532c2af10a94e","339fe33af70438e309eedebc9c5cbc64743464ff0ee9b34f06518065b9c753fb","33b1ba9666262744926d1c8cd38e03d1b55c82ee0b16baf5c49972ea55b65c84","33fedaebad3c5f73a4491b35776c6bc7db3590afc82189cf2ab5ae59ebf6abe4","3708cc2df47a3e8c94329e4e446a32b9c0edd1e43b85df96519cc2f9748fb607","385babc4b2fdf6c21483cdfd6f0be36919f4f0ff4f8e9291e6bb879ad0b8eb40","39c73d811917f07d3b637b2fcea4a57cb37b59627643d91c4be155c6e485f653","3a8cbea1f64b59a41880d7bc1e9e4347e93d6a570cd6f494e19884ce528af4f7","3b0f21e3e163ef74be345449e0050cc14a6fb0b79ac2072986b7bc8c5ce46a97","3c8784a5b855170f811a0336315528e2f15fa843f2986b67a081a454dc35149a","3cb060c9bd3bd1cc602d656043a1eb9606060f8b54c5ebf692c063f740d29d13","3cf89c0564f05ab8068b33b238e583cc96f7e0ce1a8d75bcca2ea8d736402cb7","3dd10752fd5051f4fed5a926ccad10c6fb99fc63618a013c872981df5df1814d","3e4123b0e2effda421994c37f09bafe726378c6f73bef3f59f2ec23a71fbd93c","3f1bce000471ea4be84d36a8c26fa6ce70b925d8440fb30bf56cced7ec8ae5f6","40316a85dfb10877b9b47aeb66a0e6549427d940f4b72b626704a165a999c1fb","4076514025cbf6d81d5cf1efe1db0c6617c1ed42c55a3c7260813e82677c14e5","42a05caad3ac0a71d1cc0c21d877bb739f116e617c8752e49b127bb26de43de0","45f20def6861824e083a1a342716838a7e1d268fc2382741f7f5b5dee0fe8070","478c4f58d89e1ced1f5b219a3c3d88c0366db0dac4fd76ea1cf604037822985c","4948cd790a7aca1d74356919df4f148aaa1247145ac0836195d5d9522aa5e0d9","4a137cb7d345e0877c43e7c57a0f4f7277819b8d536d2598f091e7f874327a80","4a768c4dc683c8fbe8f2767d7c5da15f23e925ff7de339bf470e60538d7bd8ab","4abe67acf67ea5dba879afa708b81c97d930bd5095a9cab048600077b489fc2f","4b15401deb94a3656a337ef4b4bcd3422d4d8dff6513b7d3ee2c272809bdb8a6","4b7966cdad829e7a193b3ce475e1028716aed89432a2e49eee2fded2b92eea9f","4b7e78e56636d691cf451f4591d590a7d5a2165bd8993cd5c2046729879e4b63","4deb3fe0eb77febb1addb904deaf96841bbc3c9782864a47e6df1897b6a472fe","51e7c38c15474878667edf926c96fe09ae5a224a1d38a1e53273987668e4050b","54680f8a0f335a2e92acf2ee6f81a217a3572430746e89e38fddf3860c005686","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","54b23081e73fd5f2d0f81760fe4d80fd61f86f29b201c7d232e9ccb5a40e2c4a","54c2520117d397eddd8d9ac35a3b6a94379533788aa9d203a5afcf71c3656e9b","564c5c3ba5f16d3bb90251feb27ccfefb02cd1674de0ea3009968e24b79d139e","594f77fea05aeaa28400298258daf3a9100851349deedfe84b094bd0ebf92ebc","5b46657304b4c9d8d3c3729eab6488e44adc92a401e3b230d8b5e5665a2c0981","5ba8bfa631be25263e40c29c35863ebddeef775e74df34f097ba78353e8efed6","5f39a0c541abab0d84dc8a7b62adc18db22d5d388b7aebabcd2a107ea39aa2a4","5fddadf17e948ef581edcdc26010f4746a93554e06a700fc689e8837bf43cb03","639c93d8c7469d049575b3437dcf33f2c46432ab0f402c66c545e7bf32a50c9d","6413a067ef9ba737af817e766b5632b3ba5adbfffb0b10f5b95a987a9f9080dd","649643003e1e27347985af33ab517e205ccdcf37f7ba638d2d343a87b07680f8","6527860faa20b249f71d5acd7941cdded1d86c9324a2ec392e9d3613e2e9d588","65f6d9d23a35e6eac6b13cc78f10a47f04ccb80aba5f1029ca7ecdbe0f8c6785","66ab11f4b7dfea37500c7b041c867e9247ee6251dd03fb4422e9d6a515f1e77d","6a7729235c4b15e24eaaac404d41bd4b023a9ce2b4bf9f6988e5b7d96a92e1ee","6cf40b2d2796b3fa13f02f405a2b9a11d82f11f5f54a64b10f20589dd0989cea","6ef1edc987764a4ca9b21757ac4e1e81e8eed6d83964650613702b35e9c41b22","6f01841172e93949a12cca6a14f6eaa6370b85a725df5fdc41ee756e9a3ef8bc","6f700e126e0d100914477cb435407dfd299d4be95b7cf0379f3d8d3b8c6f2d8d","6f730d119ee0af0e67265f3d6328b9108997251f0549a3bdd419ff13ad591ee6","700ae7f028c1a74549e6b94b0dc6a5aca38934c2a46acde03c54c71391c54b22","7098f3a8d77d608b90d4acdd1022ef8491d5cb1ac3d1b9a2c2d6acb3323de089","7157439c05c936b85b7fee6e832363cc83b3965753cac8256b1d487342c51ff2","7185e5581a258ca68b87d3e95a9bac66eb43cbc55960aba3a40dfa82ec43079f","718e062d5da7611cc683f734c761f61efc42bde3c484a84601c7d4c7f2bce1a4","75b66684790552ec977b962824d8a4e85a41d2effc50226f9b697f7b901472c7","77227a3be7f73e785c8334065c045c25bbe960eca4f08ab00da7adb780465383","781d942ca92d77c7dbf094fa375a1750f498ad0612a9ce79fad725447f4fc5b2","789b2c492cb07d284c64f0532ade44de0affe5c45dd5cc530f84386d1eef4c98","795d578b1a001a00e899a5c976fab8bd06e246e0e0525ab36f04d792e40ef7ed","79d12d31b034b083446cdb16c7b73a8b019846a2a86ccf15eca5465ceebd1b1f","79f36ed5e7d4b6d63b1c4ce861ffbfb6376e74c21f19b946cb9409b22b6ce38c","7a6fb9541b43fab52d210eaa73a51b52a1a942a3a2073bae1ad7f014b753b4d8","7d3c8f25c9d788cf1e617e71a8af34169e4a3af372a152ed3430fbfec749c2dc","7f77c5f520faae414ad8b14b025b2275385a5c128c3f5ea162200d8ba3638091","7f89e5d4a8c3d15f00840feb20f8b98056a98b94e3c1a5bf67fe312915f950d9","8275e6ad0bf10d2430cc7b89262a4bca3cdf6efa885f40f628400d9dcc512b76","83393296d0bb763b34ef00ad70c22c7aba459ce284ae9cb6c5d526ee970b7d53","83ea55e2cdc8fa0c752020f7191d9e5aea7b1b61de7e7ecad6f27458f21c2f0a","84f6b5d94ef84de06a8baf1985684980166710917b06e5b690f8bff036a84938","863535897f2aef3e494b5af69653e45a7e5840c38d7be8207af5fba7f9949202","86b606c8c70adbfbc1db885323470191d9d2e09d92bb9c170300f3c15e8e8301","86d3e30655b07eada4d90ebe241375ad003945a7b7b30fd0fdacb710cff5feff","876146ef6be3c37fa2acb55078eaf1394f7e7d67526bec40dd11285b0d54fe6e","876464adb279d62264a6bad0ec19bdcbdeb7a4f29ab0170db8a8dd32c6da93d6","878418a76e821e827c674f63922cdca27c9032850dcb1f43ba5de9ad8b7ccbf7","8a5797472f630188b8b943be1f7bb5c4ca34d7784a39f6ad31399ad550830d86","8ba974c364d52e6b43d75f8026bcfff3d4a324e22485650de8b6b821e8f674ea","8c12b002514f4d6cb6f06033fe6855534a7f5dba96dfed022d5d0a986273954b","8d0dd7807ec13c572f6807096823ba3853a6e1d481d53526c3f3563d12b7207b","8db5d947ff639e7659f3562b5796d6ebd92b53b2000a5f7ee3e04a93995fad5c","8eed9fbdfba0472d67af6722a4fac7ccaec11dab7fafb19301cb5a77d022b446","919379b48cec048c79fcf2e746f053d6ba9b7c8b74ac983ea6fa8df54afc109f","926d69cdd0ce87e828672bd7c01fc418c5d0556451698b5cf81e0b51c808886f","92b2cb88b636a8f9e370c3a4c69940f2b37c9c105a770590a5c2a24c4200d251","931d5261296cc42ccaf345b176b5e4f3da9f553bfe292b6b5811481021cb1405","9369828e4df5a65832a0ed6801f34c3b3eb85c69eafbc257b882e3cfbc079df1","93ab1a62f7082761a57f2da3762190b55bce7efcbe097296ef7fe2f21fb42b39","93be540e7edb27167a112c1f2cdf6f8de8fbdc4b0027e49a41db5251dd8d6a29","9859c7902ef863cf21dcde841aec319bc43264ba78bcdf4e7d79718baebb4ea3","9884ec5f6cfd4209a58f13aba718d240476eda27b02f5bf2306fd976e059d1d3","99da2a239ecd0fa24836150eb43b398fa33a76b764c6ca2052af1bd1958add94","99fd304cedf1870828fb0879ca8e562a645d95be4f37d9d3309a0d0253c7e049","9b34e1e5d6cd6682311e2376e18dc24736e001a01ad41fdc3b99133549100c99","9bac28d24e66ee005c77c3b82f84f6f7d0e32c7a9aac2356d869b985e8104610","9baf739e230d7e0989c950334089be602cffb3f41d0a5faa8c53e22346ed2a03","9c18ba44e30c2b303f9e4536aa736b83cca544167359fd76a77bae4c66133e14","9cec90a915f4cb77af91065d34b63157da307154b014b90027064666da4645bd","9d807115d2b186abcb5172a8fca9f20c91a5652dee8bf4720f69de48ea7d6a64","9ed7695e821d1555293f5ac5b70c2abc93e88a770e843b87979be90ce5c91a39","9f8a18dcb79900654a9b027395dcc293d30d9d5b32832751f587cf74ee49138f","9fd06bae684a9110374c5fb9d4f5ad68e9be75363f5e5c384ad2c579f95cb139","9fdb47f636c92d84c494448402e45626a0de35ac6844575976b21e5b7430fc77","a15f4c3d5d2367acbb0281d54f0b245ffe4dd072eb4cba1ddc780fc1d920f8a6","a352b5cc3246a8db265406075921ab01139805c38ffa43306c3d1cabbd7d64be","a370f962cbeeb263a7d46489b934ceb70cb7c1575c525defb19eede11de0d2c5","a4b64a6badde1d2f8ad4f1dfa9acdc69cb99a1d503f489a71951529c47c12db9","a715c9f86ff1c65cc0a55bd7c5aacb6435b867f12171c51c9b4ba9b3c4c908f4","a886153044d80e9b04324f54336412c5785bd7f643d5876e240ce03541a9106a","a8df37fb13db5044cd4d893ff45827c544cb284e437f94809437d4d1d74a141b","a929fbeb38ee0720bc1dce9d68b55b6f369e959e2960e094b87bd120203e7474","a941f9ce34467a2991412ae341603c383fb676593c3fe0f1ae41b12015f298a4","aa3e3319856c40999d7ec64635618670d9e798fd81044262a185ebe07d7e4a14","ab50716eaf98e80e955c51de5fb5292ac4e8e45f94dfece10fc847319161627f","ab748f39834204f2fd03a1b68f76e0124a8d48937673b5cb79614a2059212ab1","ae7fcdb0a791e5dbd206acd70718e8e9b02a9065c976fb7805de5aeed981b798","b138ed198daee4e07279426cb6b049aeafeb647c94c57bd6822c826d1bbe36ee","b14e037fc8d4a27756eacfab295d284333ee39c40f9b871ca9a0e87fa3f36e45","b24c2d613e9ba2076c4eaefb37afc995fbee36e687161365b4f13246a71408f1","b319f7b38290998a06835d6b4cb8e9f9abba55947f8c1329fa45abae0fbfb9e5","b4019c63a6c67f255e84a7fd728a82f74e9df127d7ac3632f688b10000984455","b6111c5c1a067f6e3de6440660b793eda0904ddbe66b144cff84a6e624e48d5c","b613aa3cdb2c80da02db9880d03ba3f6f28b08092c965e0f7a48edfd333c4808","b66d3c7719896288b129db6393cfff8377c8332d0ada947e14245afd3180d9df","b7d63db0f7665c364f87430d715e48eb6b66b97bf7125ad10d4e80b8e985c5d4","b9a43e16b5db2cb4571d60df498390846118ef1cb70e672c6bea4adef32854a4","b9c6b8db508e8d981c8b3e8ccffd07a24bbd7c6d253e072bdb9f0f234f37d97a","bb09d21fd3c8e030a7cea551738e010c9e94972b97ff0523cfe8505c43055c40","bc0350f535c72e3753a6081622cd8ff160f83bd07a2067d68ba905d039420b5f","bc287469642e6e2d18e0bd6414f1a85b20c9991fbf9d0d6d7baacb23f360a835","bd8f2470831e2078e3e64c8b80d75e55019328a342d427fe6f79212da3c9de69","be2ef8f5f367249be475d78d30be41c45fadce582d05a32ca83bce4f7177a8db","beb271a2eb79c7b00fad16641e9fc400eea7fd2dbc197413ba1e12174f451018","bf055b5f673c3f3b1da9a1d6baa56d4640d40a0bf9ac9ebc77a6b6c1e8b4aaf5","bfe4a7243c1f4d5cacfe8a729399d72f7422670356cf1b0dfc2f74f1d05df3dc","c0c1c7ef91e3e8bdeda6f7e4ad0b3da17c9095cfd5a1530856bb1fae92882105","c0c6fa3eb98f673d1053efaf46c1d7574f3c5498eaf421e494d12c27fa77db6b","c1c5cf9e4b06435c1da5cbb087aa8d5b3d8250dbd9c57bc066f5390b14eb3632","c1d1032e545c9754beb395dff87dfdd3292d83a377de06c8359f4f8295f4846f","c1f1842ac7edd40216eeb0e549bee92652bb0ebfa92d9d927769a7649a4aa262","c77e037744af41a322bb0007afb425299448da934c801574cf2fa5a7b73ded1a","c7abc03fd01e6b0848ca2b930079d25527381cc5d19b90c5a8cdb07d0d68006d","c7e12c3a06b274f98764b92e94ff85a354e43f09d9911d75d6c183df47648084","c8d0593020f89043b700bae65685d25a2604025c598397da438fee1f10e2b0ae","c8daec1b2023e24c51829b77d4226756aa48e26adaef1014f0e80f9d16331807","c8e3f255c060ad77bb7a3ad5322fbc71d23843a4209605fb248c1223f8f13eca","c9d22d0eeea05ce10eaf5450010966db8c15ac0c315bb44bb165cc7f1c8b2651","c9ea7c273e3d9ceb3e58e3b255c39425c611d8b802a5acab03680dc89bcfd4b5","cb6231312b40d6303f478ae118f1783eeea849a19c6e0235298b3d0a0d087b78","ccf224838daf27b808aed618057702104630e3ba0a8e82c7751a984ec180502d","cd031dfcdbbc8943ddc3174f531fff9b57b0f7e4a5a47990fea4963b9e92cec1","cd501828dc0547c11e08e73409372f8a06db27df8b36e60b345f45aac548fb8a","ce710c268fc0953cffbbdde0f363d0604bf11cbff0bfc10d4a05805db5bbd328","d17a3218c9172c9aada2f7abc7327410815497f0595dd3bca46c7cf632dec4ad","d1b724bfdd244b173a6d978ce563ea1828127923b74360c8da55baa45f871dc9","d2c1665c1bf6367889fb46710faa10819a3fd449b698dbca1951798014d99d85","d38d51b340d3e726b17fccef562bd07a8f442391957079b9b851057cbd99f06d","d5459c4cabe99ee33196c154c271ec16afc132f99b5a137dcf88d85b13f8304f","d5d3148bc57b9756cbb1da6c99d82bb0ebfe577bfb69e921b2de296e9680b23e","d5e75611e9f288db8f4c1affc54696367b287ea130ee7a049fe35ad6f9e79631","d63eb41a760dc52a5a9324f0edb8cd81c75c6ed78142290553952b7a7410f214","d76d4295435f00384500b58976004e0ca2bd324b42b12548be8e056ad4bd2a7d","d7c3914cb187b8216ccdb93c8e43c2d4b9c9f1997abe329f81ac6912cae99664","da367720408cd0d6132edc6a0622a4f7c11b4390551d8cbf0ccaa34ed157a1b2","dbf9ebffc05df49fb0980fed86c458261b8fb691cb3b91fbaad4d0c0f38d839d","dc8564ec47348688bc2ab3c95db9f9772947ebc2b28631adc9392bc42d01b2e3","dcb1050604203e09173d157863a64b0b133e62a25052924647606314823981a1","dfca6ea813dff69d4c1fd00d08c57a459f301100608067050f5abef38c911c5a","dfd29d54438fe5ec01424de96f328e02c5778b7a371b073e2180e8db5cbc9244","e0676eeb1d1c9297167b3510ad0b40f85e93f082c9dc0630b60029f45f851b62","e0c49cc45838fdf2866e303ad798b5590fc6b1511b3ee9b4fabd4ee97d9ff31a","e124f0cfe13c60194e8e51a6815a0d230b226a078fa1c649e8524dfe3389def9","e401cbf7c7bc5328cfada6af15f35b57a2635992ced3aefed513c3b619a8c27d","e58662351f5fbf1dfed4556012bb58ea26793710ff82758ebb15504a7c3556b5","e58cb5715f3a2dd5580c95472017fcdd116d5f54417401a2c266719799198e58","e5a028efb2107b7fccf87ff9616fbcc360adbdd776db3dc537b86c08b0f3013d","e601afc0ce5c66c897bf047d29d73209cd4471b09d265f6a0d5860a8e09c4af3","e654eaee77a53167e989b2855cd1542b719de7040b5e815b844b5c143ae6baa0","e7342a7f85458c6318ebb75f8b2f0340c1c6e0e0dafc8e79eff3442ba73b35da","e8912985e6037b252a7a37444123107c88302dfcbe0a041d990bf49ea8f7de75","e8c474da69c2e5b36422b9f13d96076e16ef745a3b9aac6e04c87ab4560bd45e","ed01400e0952592d809b6404f2cecb8ef0687ff00fed19cb19bbdd421f7e9930","ed0def08684ec7e0d3de11934740aac67a8498475b1aa6b0cad49428719a96fe","ed44d390f70035ac5b370ff25ea77eeb4cb7184e76448bc2492edde3487eca68","ed7d8256a59b85069106a3d445fdeb27d2f03ff94cddf445277cff4ffd8da5ec","ee419d37f7f3a91adde665fdb8900cb50159b6e6414209bab6fe74c337bc6d86","ee994e3a7448d1df2760a1453842f128b03d7e1405275e1fd7dac70c88803c78","eecebf3955e6a6f3d4247d2c3bf17b64934995c3386deae779ddcbf13ab62fb2","eedbadb1f43e94f0a9531adf32b2303ed48d6dd672d91fe8355fa654b5251ef6","ef069e07ea5452baa01d851837c9d4756ee134632b283ebc57473a61da89b072","ef92f93bb17a361f6e2aef2eded441362dd8aa894916eb2fa7ed6ac793860c48","f05fa23f8bc5ded3df1ba1dcb83c3ee513aaceccb38ea58ee3f31a926a90887e","f1064b149d9eafbc10bad14288ae9abc5e2b3a168835e6d9ace9dfaf84f9bacf","f11ed666387c771e0be45889b4e9f311c61ff44a6bcacd1278784210211a1b99","f34566341285af094bf3d17c09e5a71a4a48ab7c8b1b65d8d70d4e0bd3cdb5f3","f34d0296c44c4041ef7b3891c9d0ccc696df36ba65d5e96903c7abe4333a708b","f3a83c0cf21c24cb6b7bc03abad9af715ebe03bf0efd4673f68c01d87cbd87dd","f572b3b4ab9c8af99a97197ec37fb0e3a97b7ede608543e263f5dca212d7b2e5","f6ebc6f9096d3dce03a6b171fd5a941afbe4815700afbea0acc1ea6908b44cbc","f7a7d13375d7593cadd49c6bc13a2bca09b8a557339f6a4044642d7ef9ba2d3e","f8c7dddac5532e2597b3a86ec18246870de973f2591794a175dced4814898e90","f999bd21067dcf15466a9d53dba1a724c2f02c4065f58c4adc1c5f7e434d7466","fc5840251ef2a9de3eb986711162fe3e01af088d12572c42277e87a7cdd47dc0","fc85a0d917744d753c773c00875cd145b6d5d1133ccd772f501f8b1edcad9fc6","fca72b00cc2b15d834651209f34d8091cc85adeffef4c1166f60fc7795f495a0","fd3c44ea3c11bdc16e30d0816424e8f6307c87cec35461f0dac4618aa6fc1753","fedfbf4403eccbc6aba5721bcd788cafa76c7602aae35097d226082100bf1c6f","ffd89af109e0eef154365e6b5df997fbd5241388f5c82bfc883f93c697dd9926"],"directive":"TS2-17604b339068192d","kind":"submit","lines":[{"answer_ids":["t2_c1","t2_c2","@8a5797472f630188","@9ed7695e821d1555","@c7e12c3a06b274f9","@6f01841172e93949","@f1064b149d9eafbc","@9baf739e230d7e09","@11842bc73366f552","@275ca6c673440473","@7185e5581a258ca6","@c1c5cf9e4b06435c","@2ab0031a5a240892","@0012d826fb4aa3c8","@594f77fea05aeaa2","@f05fa23f8bc5ded3","@e601afc0ce5c66c8","@7d3c8f25c9d788cf","@320e8ab30b71b3a2","@be2ef8f5f367249b","@564c5c3ba5f16d3b","@dc8564ec47348688","@2fafb424587ed24e"],"directive_id":"TS2-17604b339068192d","kind":"done","local_id":"t2_d1","outcome":"answered","rq_id":"q2","text":"Records do not show Wang & Fan 2025's title/conclusions/data in its own record, full primary study lists/moderator tables of PMC13647323, full RQ results of PMC13388837, or ref 36 use in PMC13449012."}],"scope":{"docs":[],"ranges":[],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"cb1a471c06bac5e6b7c9fc5c81fe2bd9c385bead6921b07b78fb66106d7c178c","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["43a496bc34d055bedb8a6dbc0f0d3a119f0178fe7068e29df386c67101d651e3"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"3d2d3b38a4052415675d86e0ddf9679e2b17bfc6349aa5a4fbd791c9840a1ffe","submission_id":"TS2-17604b339068192d#1.1"},"hash":"852018fc1cc440cf3c9841b68d25e3806fb24d5613cc4b21ec1ddf21ff47b8a9","header":{"body_hash":"6b06a6da24b734ac06c89be92af4b0f201b2dfe4f539765945db8027a72bbb93","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"53b58e9dc283be7d03f608b195edaea27b3f7462ab5fbb570c18b067e1385239","records_root":"3b3f3980d54cdb3ef5f4662bb8e844d87842c2a0fd58b5c60bb9f32c6aeefa9b","seq":448,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-2","audit_root":"c381035842cff8187198846f2982d92d38d3e4b7afbef5d5c6d36f75d700b276","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-2","answer_ids":["857683a877c57b82d2822e41daa8823754b13a59811eba7511a9101c1d31fd35","e9f3b85f1b6605988e81dcd0ec6ea06aa028754b5321231b1168f058d1d149e9","8a5797472f630188b8b943be1f7bb5c4ca34d7784a39f6ad31399ad550830d86","9ed7695e821d1555293f5ac5b70c2abc93e88a770e843b87979be90ce5c91a39","c7e12c3a06b274f98764b92e94ff85a354e43f09d9911d75d6c183df47648084","6f01841172e93949a12cca6a14f6eaa6370b85a725df5fdc41ee756e9a3ef8bc","f1064b149d9eafbc10bad14288ae9abc5e2b3a168835e6d9ace9dfaf84f9bacf","9baf739e230d7e0989c950334089be602cffb3f41d0a5faa8c53e22346ed2a03","11842bc73366f5526afa5f65ae15b88326869f01e36f05f527121988cbb43d23","275ca6c673440473bbc3f3282f75b8496b809bb615972cd742d9cf706f71451e","7185e5581a258ca68b87d3e95a9bac66eb43cbc55960aba3a40dfa82ec43079f","c1c5cf9e4b06435c1da5cbb087aa8d5b3d8250dbd9c57bc066f5390b14eb3632","2ab0031a5a24089217684829d137dce91bd83e34accc82639028241aa8bc3301","0012d826fb4aa3c89fc0d372417f18affce2791a9fa705a06cea5325e6a5b179","594f77fea05aeaa28400298258daf3a9100851349deedfe84b094bd0ebf92ebc","f05fa23f8bc5ded3df1ba1dcb83c3ee513aaceccb38ea58ee3f31a926a90887e","e601afc0ce5c66c897bf047d29d73209cd4471b09d265f6a0d5860a8e09c4af3","7d3c8f25c9d788cf1e617e71a8af34169e4a3af372a152ed3430fbfec749c2dc","320e8ab30b71b3a235ba187f0b155dbf2b64887623f67cd78fd715a37994ac8e","be2ef8f5f367249be475d78d30be41c45fadce582d05a32ca83bce4f7177a8db","564c5c3ba5f16d3bb90251feb27ccfefb02cd1674de0ea3009968e24b79d139e","dc8564ec47348688bc2ab3c95db9f9772947ebc2b28631adc9392bc42d01b2e3","2fafb424587ed24e064ecacb7086a4678593dc48b74b10960f6125c3a806c5fc"],"circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","composition":{"by":"kernel","fallen_answer_ids":["@86f053d07234bf0f"],"mode":"incremental_repair","retained_answer_ids":["@8a5797472f630188","@9ed7695e821d1555","@c7e12c3a06b274f9","@6f01841172e93949","@f1064b149d9eafbc","@9baf739e230d7e09","@11842bc73366f552","@275ca6c673440473","@7185e5581a258ca6","@c1c5cf9e4b06435c","@2ab0031a5a240892","@0012d826fb4aa3c8","@594f77fea05aeaa2","@f05fa23f8bc5ded3","@e601afc0ce5c66c8","@7d3c8f25c9d788cf","@320e8ab30b71b3a2","@be2ef8f5f367249b","@564c5c3ba5f16d3b","@dc8564ec47348688","@2fafb424587ed24e"],"source_done":"@7fc1584dab954c83"},"delivery_audit":{"had_refusals":false,"partial_declared":false,"repair_count":0,"retained_rows":21},"done":"43a496bc34d055bedb8a6dbc0f0d3a119f0178fe7068e29df386c67101d651e3","kind":"SUMMARIZE","link_task":null,"outcome":"answered","question_set_revision":"0502c9aea43e1ce04869d20bb1cd0c78050175800b1315cbc452ab3a7a0fce2e","rq_id":"q2","sync_step":43,"task_id":"TS2-17604b339068192d"},"from":0,"key":"task:rq:q2","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"cb1a471c06bac5e6b7c9fc5c81fe2bd9c385bead6921b07b78fb66106d7c178c","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"ec14056020ba48cb6128ab45ab841f19f730d8f7b5d6efb950d920dfa5172f1f","submission_id":"TS2-17604b339068192d#done2"},"hash":"2665732e74a0022508a65e56978fbf2096760d630d8a6c5683bd2a5df5550cf7","header":{"body_hash":"3c76daecf4379cf3010939b11c50d65b40273b7d2e48ecc39d7c977d68f7faa6","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"852018fc1cc440cf3c9841b68d25e3806fb24d5613cc4b21ec1ddf21ff47b8a9","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":449,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"97c4cdcd9eb6298a84cd5b181cabd65abc0527fecee916ec197a2dc4d6e85810","command":{"allowed_records":["04588ef5a34c56f45b9b03fffb833e4377f0c87c5d6a96285ccaafbb43c64c4b","04fe4cc52446ded29d3b964dc683a0a157a9fe61a5a18d4a3b414b4b8e43f97e","05125a85b73ce30f6ef72023addf2e3d6f99773caf830c199cb317ea2505dbfb","08a008c50aa08b2eddd5d87dcc111c0b4779ca0cb559910a63fa20ea7443adca","0cc5da2e9d0178e36f4bd22710c9333e2645b45338e4d08d879379edc167538c","16fdfb67a3dbd78260306f5f63b10c85bc78e6157a493af2afdaf7d4b71e5d6f","181c36a3bc29675f5a0bbc1baf3b0b42d0997104f355ddab1a101dee30085cda","1bbc6687f9d17196e9f1a40e85d9a6474a6d5f6c5587b928a03de18af41b226b","1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","214315db9fa8442f55eb00e89d6300feb373207f2668c37c10b8b36ba1e49d16","221194311fbcbf5b6cd1524f075cc67de995b390919fc8cf79ceb3cbce5ab4b5","22af7bca35f4805c2ae564f920e3698b8b9bff279c2d3ac99eaa608793759a80","273ae79a00ff65a3dfbf30a17732a330331b5443fcb966097d819b84fe8fc05a","27c0935afdc41793ac3e8fd7aa9939191ea0e6d5d35b3b292877a483ba99e68b","2994cae73418007580c6470ffe9fce7780ca91a573e4f1ff8fa8aca837f3a1da","2f53e5eb943013cd525dbd6a5ff1d8bae04896f0f07cdcaa6404c3d862872c8f","2fb29e43a710ad935fa150c296059c5b270a26504044d7da4f9b473137bcdc70","33b1ba9666262744926d1c8cd38e03d1b55c82ee0b16baf5c49972ea55b65c84","33dbc45b04e1c60120da627c1d54cfc7daa06280791594c1ffaf092a77c2a9b0","33fedaebad3c5f73a4491b35776c6bc7db3590afc82189cf2ab5ae59ebf6abe4","34a14a2d9d4a7a9e0e6a76cde5ae6bc7e570dbc44bccef9e0f1987ba269550e1","34d4fb6f8ed13a7c0fe2cdbf3774538b15dfa58cbe04981cbddd4a56e6da0565","35f55c061bdf705ea3d77e178182abeb6f3ca3b87da08350c384848651b48b40","36a7360f76c796d49d30c3f6b1e6df7d9ca1dcad3955c95a4d2c0312bfbb461b","3708cc2df47a3e8c94329e4e446a32b9c0edd1e43b85df96519cc2f9748fb607","40e9455fa5f2288d9a34f907630033676612039414d027280018f9a24a866fb9","447ee3fa8fcffbc704b28fbccba5c8c6739738877f740daea6bf85460ef1f6c2","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","493109aa40be1afa09c9f5c40613d4eba21938a6a2b5f43747024f8edfe2ab05","4fc091bf9a9f6801e11120fd8e63cca1722bad42e294aa1c25fa403c29fba91b","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","549f5885147f7c3c424b17d0b218949d90f2a45b1ec799c5341f629670e75d37","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","54b23081e73fd5f2d0f81760fe4d80fd61f86f29b201c7d232e9ccb5a40e2c4a","5e0a113b3169774a428296637075a01642e293461fc9757b7c300b40dbd40222","6064b8f08d46e7a130aaaff1fec6ffcca8e9db5535689dd8a06d6bf7952e1c91","60a25afb0da8110108e8e0f1684160fdc69c00bf2f76d65d9c9d0964b7ef574d","6177d64ca0d9235d7db60450700c6338b488bc8d5483bf843b84b094d4254ca5","628c30ba95cc29a176752b7719c65b00ea841ed8e4d566fb8c183872f394cc41","6501b06f475efdad800e0074098cb840fa7b196517c26aa73eee961f663d9819","685463a821aa21971bd2671b53932a43e7803d61ef4c8a264bc4fca92460f5e5","68728c3225bac52dc5b734cab892540be7bc202629dcca7e7c2fee6405943ef5","6a7729235c4b15e24eaaac404d41bd4b023a9ce2b4bf9f6988e5b7d96a92e1ee","6b1dc1772369965fb189de452f7c316444f572544a38f4a0f00c387ed2b938ae","6e87158352ebc7aae75121681f4435a97f581ba744ab3cc951bb93dd2b27901a","6ef1edc987764a4ca9b21757ac4e1e81e8eed6d83964650613702b35e9c41b22","6f730d119ee0af0e67265f3d6328b9108997251f0549a3bdd419ff13ad591ee6","7154e5d20afda66421e640dce8eb81f6d725b37ed48113f888fd5474b1fcf77e","718e062d5da7611cc683f734c761f61efc42bde3c484a84601c7d4c7f2bce1a4","742c1db8833126dc24fb11df0962244ed38a86392359a0d447a80954cf604b00","79d12d31b034b083446cdb16c7b73a8b019846a2a86ccf15eca5465ceebd1b1f","7a7068ee1b05cd8563b3684471d15857f1de8f6eebe209b0d370a87f76648010","7f1cd8d31e6303eff5f669e5c6afd0d3c41b495ff7d9c568774a8c856db3fb96","7f77c5f520faae414ad8b14b025b2275385a5c128c3f5ea162200d8ba3638091","7f89e5d4a8c3d15f00840feb20f8b98056a98b94e3c1a5bf67fe312915f950d9","814c2fc0a52016056946e3ef34f36a8c1b4db47a00bb3b3cefd8f1341df1259f","8229f47e53e6e0f925fb33580829fa6d75fd2698dad03fbf26f159188e1f45d7","845eeff65be44e52a74d9cb4b0c345a698f9a67ab0a1e561a303cc8846843f09","84f6b5d94ef84de06a8baf1985684980166710917b06e5b690f8bff036a84938","86b606c8c70adbfbc1db885323470191d9d2e09d92bb9c170300f3c15e8e8301","8a268ba0014e1b70e0fe57a677ae6edca2f41ada1779ce0f1954ffcc81fa7dc2","8eed9fbdfba0472d67af6722a4fac7ccaec11dab7fafb19301cb5a77d022b446","9228d9495d52af720c230dc6a6eb3644189bf923521ee0a3c0ac6c1009ad1583","93b12833a64e583c0b5f0b0f0e3c74d6d40bf2cd13fc5835ddb2e76ff3b69f35","96ea2489d04437be245ae9141bf2fdaccc0a2ed4736bca96b05636b84cb39c61","99fd304cedf1870828fb0879ca8e562a645d95be4f37d9d3309a0d0253c7e049","9baf739e230d7e0989c950334089be602cffb3f41d0a5faa8c53e22346ed2a03","9d807115d2b186abcb5172a8fca9f20c91a5652dee8bf4720f69de48ea7d6a64","9f8a18dcb79900654a9b027395dcc293d30d9d5b32832751f587cf74ee49138f","9fd06bae684a9110374c5fb9d4f5ad68e9be75363f5e5c384ad2c579f95cb139","9fdb47f636c92d84c494448402e45626a0de35ac6844575976b21e5b7430fc77","a352b5cc3246a8db265406075921ab01139805c38ffa43306c3d1cabbd7d64be","a370f962cbeeb263a7d46489b934ceb70cb7c1575c525defb19eede11de0d2c5","a929fbeb38ee0720bc1dce9d68b55b6f369e959e2960e094b87bd120203e7474","aa3e3319856c40999d7ec64635618670d9e798fd81044262a185ebe07d7e4a14","ab748f39834204f2fd03a1b68f76e0124a8d48937673b5cb79614a2059212ab1","ada8a25696094f0678ec004dca6940095d24fdaf4f62729cac9391b1e5a75d6d","b319f7b38290998a06835d6b4cb8e9f9abba55947f8c1329fa45abae0fbfb9e5","b3bd27d3ba9c5f0e7de72437ad74079f5643efbf87e22e18f8c4a1b23a5d795f","b4b0df3fc8088e2806498e73c7017f3fec29cf871e53d350dbfc94f0089fc57e","bc0350f535c72e3753a6081622cd8ff160f83bd07a2067d68ba905d039420b5f","bc287469642e6e2d18e0bd6414f1a85b20c9991fbf9d0d6d7baacb23f360a835","bf4a98c085bdee1e09389b6100be7348b0166cff7e29abb9acec523fad81b9bd","bfe4a7243c1f4d5cacfe8a729399d72f7422670356cf1b0dfc2f74f1d05df3dc","c1c5cf9e4b06435c1da5cbb087aa8d5b3d8250dbd9c57bc066f5390b14eb3632","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","c8d0593020f89043b700bae65685d25a2604025c598397da438fee1f10e2b0ae","c915d2f831c43698c312ee2d655f7e22779781b1a6474e4201eb6ea4ad12d8c8","d17a3218c9172c9aada2f7abc7327410815497f0595dd3bca46c7cf632dec4ad","d2c1665c1bf6367889fb46710faa10819a3fd449b698dbca1951798014d99d85","d5459c4cabe99ee33196c154c271ec16afc132f99b5a137dcf88d85b13f8304f","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","dfca6ea813dff69d4c1fd00d08c57a459f301100608067050f5abef38c911c5a","e0676eeb1d1c9297167b3510ad0b40f85e93f082c9dc0630b60029f45f851b62","e401cbf7c7bc5328cfada6af15f35b57a2635992ced3aefed513c3b619a8c27d","e8912985e6037b252a7a37444123107c88302dfcbe0a041d990bf49ea8f7de75","e8c474da69c2e5b36422b9f13d96076e16ef745a3b9aac6e04c87ab4560bd45e","ee419d37f7f3a91adde665fdb8900cb50159b6e6414209bab6fe74c337bc6d86","ef92f93bb17a361f6e2aef2eded441362dd8aa894916eb2fa7ed6ac793860c48","f34d0296c44c4041ef7b3891c9d0ccc696df36ba65d5e96903c7abe4333a708b","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e","f826c61786e76fcc384adfdde59dac7095e998fae0abc4627a30d8517b548d5f","f828ba66084867c01d399c3e210dc4f70f6245cb037c2c22096ef69c8ab37ca0","f8f0ab51138c364bed330e3cbce04274307493b15b6daa9c9ff9ee7c0110ae25","fca72b00cc2b15d834651209f34d8091cc85adeffef4c1166f60fc7795f495a0"],"directive":"TS1-eaaabef009825893","kind":"submit","lines":[{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@35f55c061bdf705e","@34d4fb6f8ed13a7c","@9f8a18dcb7990065","@16fdfb67a3dbd782"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c1","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (psychometrically sound instruments for AI educational phenomena; Humanit. Soc. Sci. Commun. 12:621)","predicate":"supports_statement_with","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) cites Wang and Fan 2025 (with Crompton & Burke 2023) to support psychometrically sound AI education instruments (α=0.943, ω=0.944); its ref list cites Humanit Soc Sci Commun 12:621."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@845eeff65be44e52","@ada8a25696094f06","@b3bd27d3ba9c5f0e","@f826c61786e76fcc","@f828ba66084867c0","@214315db9fa8442f"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c2","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (most studies use self-report, correlational, or brief intervention designs reporting outcome scores without tracing learning processes)","predicate":"supports_statement_with","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197) cites Wang and Fan 2025 for the observation that most studies employ self-report, cross-sectional correlational designs, or brief interventions reporting outcome scores without tracing learning processes."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@84f6b5d94ef84de0","@54b23081e73fd5f2","@7f89e5d4a8c3d15f"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c3","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (ChatGPT associated with better academic outcomes, affective-motivational states, and higher-order thinking; Humanit. Soc. Sci. Commun. 12:621)","predicate":"supports_statement_with","stance":"reported","subject":"Fang et al. 2026 (PMC13647323)","text":"Fang et al. 2026 (PMC13647323) cites Wang and Fan 2025 (with Deng et al. 2025) to associate ChatGPT with better academic outcomes, affective-motivational states, and higher-order thinking, listing Humanit Soc Sci Commun 12:621."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@845eeff65be44e52","@e8912985e6037b25","@04588ef5a34c56f4"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c4","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (Meta-analysis of prior studies; Metacognition: High; Engagement: Moderate; Near/Far transfer: —; Data: Mixed; Context: Self-regulated learning with GenAI)","predicate":"tabulates_citation_of","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13226197)","text":"In a comparison table row, Li 2026 (PMC13226197) lists Wang and Fan 2025 as a meta-analysis of prior studies with mixed data on self-regulated learning with GenAI (metacognition: High; engagement: Moderate; near/far transfer: —)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@685463a821aa2197","@2994cae734180075","@b4b0df3fc8088e28"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c5","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (natural-language algorithms participate in learners' cognitive processing and emotional regulation processes)","predicate":"supports_statement_with","stance":"reported","subject":"Li 2026 (PMC13388837)","text":"Li 2026 (PMC13388837) cites Wang and Fan 2025 (with Slamet 2024; Yu et al. 2024) to state that natural-language algorithms act as intelligent agents participating in learners' cognitive processing and emotional regulation."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@1bbc6687f9d17196","@493109aa40be1afa","@36a7360f76c796d4","@2fb29e43a710ad93","@33dbc45b04e1c601","@9f8a18dcb7990065","@e401cbf7c7bc5328","@a352b5cc3246a8db"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c6","object":"Wang and Fan 2025 (ChatGPT suggested to improve development of critical thinking skills; Humanit. Soc. Sci. Commun. 12:621)","predicate":"supports_statement_with","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) cites Wang and Fan 2025 (with Jalil et al. 2023) to support that ChatGPT can improve the development of critical thinking skills, listing Humanit Soc Sci Commun 12:621 in references."},{"as_of":20260422,"based_on":["@9fd06bae684a9110","@e0676eeb1d1c9297","@ab748f39834204f2","@aa3e3319856c4099","@6a7729235c4b15e2","@718e062d5da7611c"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c7","object":"retracted on 22 April 2026 (Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 2026;13:528, doi:10.1057/s41599-026-07310-z; CC BY-NC-ND text not included)","predicate":"has_retraction_status","stance":"reported","subject":"Wang and Fan 2025","text":"The retracted article record for Wang and Fan 2025 (bibliographic facts only; CC BY-NC-ND text omitted) states it was retracted on 22 April 2026 (Humanit Soc Sci Commun 2026;13:528, doi:10.1057/s41599-026-07310-z)."},{"as_of":20250506,"based_on":["@9fd06bae684a9110","@e8c474da69c2e5b3","@aa3e3319856c4099","@9fdb47f636c92d84"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c8","object":"Authors Wang J, Fan W; published 2025 May 6 in Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 12:621 (doi:10.1057/s41599-025-04787-y)","predicate":"has_publication_details","stance":"reported","subject":"Wang and Fan 2025","text":"The record for Wang and Fan 2025 lists authors Wang J and Fan W and publication in Humanities and Social Sciences Communications on 6 May 2025 (12:621, doi:10.1057/s41599-025-04787-y)."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@1bbc6687f9d17196","@33fedaebad3c5f73","@6ef1edc987764a4c","@d5459c4cabe99ee3","@f34d0296c44c4041","@2fb29e43a710ad93","@93b12833a64e583c","@814c2fc0a5201605","@bf4a98c085bdee1e"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c9","object":"α=0.943, ω=0.944, two-factor EFA/CFA structure for perceptual ChatGPT skill support; recommends longitudinal, mixed-method, performance-based studies","predicate":"reports_validation_and_scope","stance":"reported","subject":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867)","text":"George-Reyes et al. 2026 (PMC13314867) reports high internal consistency (α=0.943; ω=0.944), a two-factor structure via EFA/CFA, and validity for perceptions of ChatGPT, recommending longitudinal performance studies."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@84f6b5d94ef84de0","@0cc5da2e9d0178e3","@ee419d37f7f3a91a","@d17a3218c9172c9a","@08a008c50aa08b2e","@33b1ba9666262744","@628c30ba95cc29a1","@f8f0ab51138c364b","@05125a85b73ce30f","@7f1cd8d31e6303ef","@7a7068ee1b05cd85","@5e0a113b3169774a"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c10","object":"56 effect sizes across 42 controlled studies (N=6,059, 2023–2025) on quantitative learning motivation; average positive association with substantial heterogeneity","predicate":"synthesizes_meta_analysis","stance":"reported","subject":"Fang et al. 2026 (PMC13647323)","text":"Fang et al. 2026 (PMC13647323) synthesizes 56 effect sizes from 42 controlled/quasi-experimental studies (N=6,059, samples 32–486, 2023–2025) on quantitative learning motivation, finding non-uniform average gains."},{"as_of":null,"based_on":["@c915d2f831c43698","@22af7bca35f4805c","@bc0350f535c72e37","@8eed9fbdfba0472d","@bc287469642e6e2d","@d2c1665c1bf63678"],"kind":"claim","local_id":"t1_c11","object":"PMC13226197: transfer needs generative processing; PMC13388837: environment perception tied to L2 WTC; PMC13449012: ChatGPT 4.1 mini outperformed 3.5","predicate":"concludes_main_results","stance":"reported","subject":"PMC13226197, PMC13388837, PMC13449012","text":"PMC13226197 concludes AI support reinforces regulation and persistence while transfer requires generative designs; PMC13388837 links environment perception to L2 WTC; PMC13449012 finds ChatGPT 4.1 mini beat 3.5 (4.216 vs 3.794)."}],"scope":{"docs":[],"ranges":[],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"cb1a471c06bac5e6b7c9fc5c81fe2bd9c385bead6921b07b78fb66106d7c178c","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["837920cb9221e3156ef8a4eb8146c8abbb11ead676be4a0b6ccfe4f554b9e448","4c8fd0d0b822060bbd3e9a3be5511de9f28a1bdd381af9b2bf8d61e3bd619878","c2de30b14107fc792f82440ffe1ae1200755f887b2ba5ffaa2be4af3b4eb2f24","d59de430bf747d3b685527b5668e14e4d0007a2539647e90a368275bb6ca8a6b","6eac0a7474bf6d178f3c996c5f8b462b01734d700b5cbbfe7bb50c4a72e1dee0","448786bfc36ae9de7030a753715c2baec94c366dc888dcfbb2fdcba373a142de","018d062959d046b58a2b8467d446358078fefaab4b4812e5c01e1a4233ebcb98","b7441fb3048379c9ba21dc2ee4430d3c4179d1a3ede2684f9972b84961368786","dbfd9e594f0a24e72c12d370c4d2d2d7eaa23a0a2d21dfed1fb43a1d7c230c5a","5b4856edfaf7e504859cd56c8173bb775dad30c07980a4e6228ab6e7bad8fb58","dec74c571bda68a0276441bd3e0d8617b74c7ed149e9476abd97af3f537d558e"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"7f5f363597656c26f784b874e2efb57fb4b4a5de01e4108cd26d8db1741298ab","submission_id":"TS1-eaaabef009825893#1"},"hash":"d69ffcabbae81dd06ff24e5c50f98409a8e2d6ea55a605af48f8a3db8b62880e","header":{"body_hash":"6e02fcb0795f1acd4914a2724f2b7d117745db7084789705a365e2509c37ade1","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"2665732e74a0022508a65e56978fbf2096760d630d8a6c5683bd2a5df5550cf7","records_root":"eacb6cfc014eaa1e872d0ecbecd8e66244bd356b1b71c358d3071b84fa598e6d","seq":450,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"8975f3a3c35eb3e74350b4801581c3e0ab3a96bcadc2c975fa5280b67fa5e6b2","command":{"allowed_records":["04588ef5a34c56f45b9b03fffb833e4377f0c87c5d6a96285ccaafbb43c64c4b","04fe4cc52446ded29d3b964dc683a0a157a9fe61a5a18d4a3b414b4b8e43f97e","05125a85b73ce30f6ef72023addf2e3d6f99773caf830c199cb317ea2505dbfb","08a008c50aa08b2eddd5d87dcc111c0b4779ca0cb559910a63fa20ea7443adca","0cc5da2e9d0178e36f4bd22710c9333e2645b45338e4d08d879379edc167538c","16fdfb67a3dbd78260306f5f63b10c85bc78e6157a493af2afdaf7d4b71e5d6f","181c36a3bc29675f5a0bbc1baf3b0b42d0997104f355ddab1a101dee30085cda","1bbc6687f9d17196e9f1a40e85d9a6474a6d5f6c5587b928a03de18af41b226b","1ff246b6cf047485c3a51f77bc1e680dc758baecb10f57683fedf71a21a0cd43","214315db9fa8442f55eb00e89d6300feb373207f2668c37c10b8b36ba1e49d16","221194311fbcbf5b6cd1524f075cc67de995b390919fc8cf79ceb3cbce5ab4b5","22af7bca35f4805c2ae564f920e3698b8b9bff279c2d3ac99eaa608793759a80","273ae79a00ff65a3dfbf30a17732a330331b5443fcb966097d819b84fe8fc05a","27c0935afdc41793ac3e8fd7aa9939191ea0e6d5d35b3b292877a483ba99e68b","2994cae73418007580c6470ffe9fce7780ca91a573e4f1ff8fa8aca837f3a1da","2f53e5eb943013cd525dbd6a5ff1d8bae04896f0f07cdcaa6404c3d862872c8f","2fb29e43a710ad935fa150c296059c5b270a26504044d7da4f9b473137bcdc70","33b1ba9666262744926d1c8cd38e03d1b55c82ee0b16baf5c49972ea55b65c84","33dbc45b04e1c60120da627c1d54cfc7daa06280791594c1ffaf092a77c2a9b0","33fedaebad3c5f73a4491b35776c6bc7db3590afc82189cf2ab5ae59ebf6abe4","34a14a2d9d4a7a9e0e6a76cde5ae6bc7e570dbc44bccef9e0f1987ba269550e1","34d4fb6f8ed13a7c0fe2cdbf3774538b15dfa58cbe04981cbddd4a56e6da0565","35f55c061bdf705ea3d77e178182abeb6f3ca3b87da08350c384848651b48b40","36a7360f76c796d49d30c3f6b1e6df7d9ca1dcad3955c95a4d2c0312bfbb461b","3708cc2df47a3e8c94329e4e446a32b9c0edd1e43b85df96519cc2f9748fb607","40e9455fa5f2288d9a34f907630033676612039414d027280018f9a24a866fb9","447ee3fa8fcffbc704b28fbccba5c8c6739738877f740daea6bf85460ef1f6c2","4511ca4610693712e0a535db8e29ca2890109b7d19e2f1378a72c641ead9b91f","493109aa40be1afa09c9f5c40613d4eba21938a6a2b5f43747024f8edfe2ab05","4fc091bf9a9f6801e11120fd8e63cca1722bad42e294aa1c25fa403c29fba91b","517846157e5d9b58d008e4a019801cdaa648d02cf1d87922c49c78fe1d43c6a6","549f5885147f7c3c424b17d0b218949d90f2a45b1ec799c5341f629670e75d37","54a8754c5a6c8ac73e1db2a5e8819117388db898c0a3f9d87c46d2b79e6c0115","54b23081e73fd5f2d0f81760fe4d80fd61f86f29b201c7d232e9ccb5a40e2c4a","5e0a113b3169774a428296637075a01642e293461fc9757b7c300b40dbd40222","6064b8f08d46e7a130aaaff1fec6ffcca8e9db5535689dd8a06d6bf7952e1c91","60a25afb0da8110108e8e0f1684160fdc69c00bf2f76d65d9c9d0964b7ef574d","6177d64ca0d9235d7db60450700c6338b488bc8d5483bf843b84b094d4254ca5","628c30ba95cc29a176752b7719c65b00ea841ed8e4d566fb8c183872f394cc41","6501b06f475efdad800e0074098cb840fa7b196517c26aa73eee961f663d9819","685463a821aa21971bd2671b53932a43e7803d61ef4c8a264bc4fca92460f5e5","68728c3225bac52dc5b734cab892540be7bc202629dcca7e7c2fee6405943ef5","6a7729235c4b15e24eaaac404d41bd4b023a9ce2b4bf9f6988e5b7d96a92e1ee","6b1dc1772369965fb189de452f7c316444f572544a38f4a0f00c387ed2b938ae","6e87158352ebc7aae75121681f4435a97f581ba744ab3cc951bb93dd2b27901a","6ef1edc987764a4ca9b21757ac4e1e81e8eed6d83964650613702b35e9c41b22","6f730d119ee0af0e67265f3d6328b9108997251f0549a3bdd419ff13ad591ee6","7154e5d20afda66421e640dce8eb81f6d725b37ed48113f888fd5474b1fcf77e","718e062d5da7611cc683f734c761f61efc42bde3c484a84601c7d4c7f2bce1a4","742c1db8833126dc24fb11df0962244ed38a86392359a0d447a80954cf604b00","79d12d31b034b083446cdb16c7b73a8b019846a2a86ccf15eca5465ceebd1b1f","7a7068ee1b05cd8563b3684471d15857f1de8f6eebe209b0d370a87f76648010","7f1cd8d31e6303eff5f669e5c6afd0d3c41b495ff7d9c568774a8c856db3fb96","7f77c5f520faae414ad8b14b025b2275385a5c128c3f5ea162200d8ba3638091","7f89e5d4a8c3d15f00840feb20f8b98056a98b94e3c1a5bf67fe312915f950d9","814c2fc0a52016056946e3ef34f36a8c1b4db47a00bb3b3cefd8f1341df1259f","8229f47e53e6e0f925fb33580829fa6d75fd2698dad03fbf26f159188e1f45d7","845eeff65be44e52a74d9cb4b0c345a698f9a67ab0a1e561a303cc8846843f09","84f6b5d94ef84de06a8baf1985684980166710917b06e5b690f8bff036a84938","86b606c8c70adbfbc1db885323470191d9d2e09d92bb9c170300f3c15e8e8301","8a268ba0014e1b70e0fe57a677ae6edca2f41ada1779ce0f1954ffcc81fa7dc2","8eed9fbdfba0472d67af6722a4fac7ccaec11dab7fafb19301cb5a77d022b446","9228d9495d52af720c230dc6a6eb3644189bf923521ee0a3c0ac6c1009ad1583","93b12833a64e583c0b5f0b0f0e3c74d6d40bf2cd13fc5835ddb2e76ff3b69f35","96ea2489d04437be245ae9141bf2fdaccc0a2ed4736bca96b05636b84cb39c61","99fd304cedf1870828fb0879ca8e562a645d95be4f37d9d3309a0d0253c7e049","9baf739e230d7e0989c950334089be602cffb3f41d0a5faa8c53e22346ed2a03","9d807115d2b186abcb5172a8fca9f20c91a5652dee8bf4720f69de48ea7d6a64","9f8a18dcb79900654a9b027395dcc293d30d9d5b32832751f587cf74ee49138f","9fd06bae684a9110374c5fb9d4f5ad68e9be75363f5e5c384ad2c579f95cb139","9fdb47f636c92d84c494448402e45626a0de35ac6844575976b21e5b7430fc77","a352b5cc3246a8db265406075921ab01139805c38ffa43306c3d1cabbd7d64be","a370f962cbeeb263a7d46489b934ceb70cb7c1575c525defb19eede11de0d2c5","a929fbeb38ee0720bc1dce9d68b55b6f369e959e2960e094b87bd120203e7474","aa3e3319856c40999d7ec64635618670d9e798fd81044262a185ebe07d7e4a14","ab748f39834204f2fd03a1b68f76e0124a8d48937673b5cb79614a2059212ab1","ada8a25696094f0678ec004dca6940095d24fdaf4f62729cac9391b1e5a75d6d","b319f7b38290998a06835d6b4cb8e9f9abba55947f8c1329fa45abae0fbfb9e5","b3bd27d3ba9c5f0e7de72437ad74079f5643efbf87e22e18f8c4a1b23a5d795f","b4b0df3fc8088e2806498e73c7017f3fec29cf871e53d350dbfc94f0089fc57e","bc0350f535c72e3753a6081622cd8ff160f83bd07a2067d68ba905d039420b5f","bc287469642e6e2d18e0bd6414f1a85b20c9991fbf9d0d6d7baacb23f360a835","bf4a98c085bdee1e09389b6100be7348b0166cff7e29abb9acec523fad81b9bd","bfe4a7243c1f4d5cacfe8a729399d72f7422670356cf1b0dfc2f74f1d05df3dc","c1c5cf9e4b06435c1da5cbb087aa8d5b3d8250dbd9c57bc066f5390b14eb3632","c8c2e6e2f11f969aac25e94c7d33d97ffdd9138679fe92a4b8c0af6df389fe71","c8d0593020f89043b700bae65685d25a2604025c598397da438fee1f10e2b0ae","c915d2f831c43698c312ee2d655f7e22779781b1a6474e4201eb6ea4ad12d8c8","d17a3218c9172c9aada2f7abc7327410815497f0595dd3bca46c7cf632dec4ad","d2c1665c1bf6367889fb46710faa10819a3fd449b698dbca1951798014d99d85","d5459c4cabe99ee33196c154c271ec16afc132f99b5a137dcf88d85b13f8304f","d61b934709553a14e986ddb2e2858698338a4597a969cde68a3267b63808c151","dfca6ea813dff69d4c1fd00d08c57a459f301100608067050f5abef38c911c5a","e0676eeb1d1c9297167b3510ad0b40f85e93f082c9dc0630b60029f45f851b62","e401cbf7c7bc5328cfada6af15f35b57a2635992ced3aefed513c3b619a8c27d","e8912985e6037b252a7a37444123107c88302dfcbe0a041d990bf49ea8f7de75","e8c474da69c2e5b36422b9f13d96076e16ef745a3b9aac6e04c87ab4560bd45e","ee419d37f7f3a91adde665fdb8900cb50159b6e6414209bab6fe74c337bc6d86","ef92f93bb17a361f6e2aef2eded441362dd8aa894916eb2fa7ed6ac793860c48","f34d0296c44c4041ef7b3891c9d0ccc696df36ba65d5e96903c7abe4333a708b","f65551577830214fed6a5fa36e8b09dd4b0f21e8e62159f68ca1f570bb63973e","f826c61786e76fcc384adfdde59dac7095e998fae0abc4627a30d8517b548d5f","f828ba66084867c01d399c3e210dc4f70f6245cb037c2c22096ef69c8ab37ca0","f8f0ab51138c364bed330e3cbce04274307493b15b6daa9c9ff9ee7c0110ae25","fca72b00cc2b15d834651209f34d8091cc85adeffef4c1166f60fc7795f495a0"],"directive":"TS1-eaaabef009825893","kind":"submit","lines":[{"answer_ids":["t1_c1","t1_c2","t1_c3","t1_c4","t1_c5","t1_c6","t1_c7","t1_c8","t1_c9","t1_c10","t1_c11","@549f5885147f7c3c","@8a268ba0014e1b70"],"directive_id":"TS1-eaaabef009825893","kind":"done","local_id":"t1_d1","outcome":"answered","rq_id":"q1","text":"Records lack the 'Title: The effect of ChatGPT...' quote from Wang & Fan 2025's record, PMC13449012 ref 36 citations/entry, PMC13226197 & PMC13388837 ref entries, and unread sections of corpus texts."}],"scope":{"docs":[],"ranges":[],"topic":null}},"engine_root":"cb1a471c06bac5e6b7c9fc5c81fe2bd9c385bead6921b07b78fb66106d7c178c","outcome":{"kind":"records","result":{"accepted":["92950f9388d95349d9d91d7a60b6e5b8742a57c625894827ad208d4519dc8e3d"],"error":null,"failed_index":null}},"request_hash":"83a42520f431b142ea1af6d9dd3c5065a55c4c4246ca971893a3a2a15b7bb9fa","submission_id":"TS1-eaaabef009825893#1.1"},"hash":"bbdaa08ca1fe4cfa998f7ee38fc2e82084fa77b8c7cc1704e91d8d70d63a9559","header":{"body_hash":"e11c41dba6fd5fecbfdcd32bf6cc93fa8f4ea86802858cac485dc8372b10c7f6","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"d69ffcabbae81dd06ff24e5c50f98409a8e2d6ea55a605af48f8a3db8b62880e","records_root":"4c160aacbc8ad93049091eeefd765a9f0a83f546bdb25ae2d9e358a9497155b4","seq":451,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"reader-3","audit_root":"0df4bfff971332298427c7ad34b7e274ce8a06f2eab2cae56e910684d07d7310","command":{"checkpoint":{"context":{"agent":"reader-3","answer_ids":["837920cb9221e3156ef8a4eb8146c8abbb11ead676be4a0b6ccfe4f554b9e448","4c8fd0d0b822060bbd3e9a3be5511de9f28a1bdd381af9b2bf8d61e3bd619878","c2de30b14107fc792f82440ffe1ae1200755f887b2ba5ffaa2be4af3b4eb2f24","d59de430bf747d3b685527b5668e14e4d0007a2539647e90a368275bb6ca8a6b","6eac0a7474bf6d178f3c996c5f8b462b01734d700b5cbbfe7bb50c4a72e1dee0","448786bfc36ae9de7030a753715c2baec94c366dc888dcfbb2fdcba373a142de","018d062959d046b58a2b8467d446358078fefaab4b4812e5c01e1a4233ebcb98","b7441fb3048379c9ba21dc2ee4430d3c4179d1a3ede2684f9972b84961368786","dbfd9e594f0a24e72c12d370c4d2d2d7eaa23a0a2d21dfed1fb43a1d7c230c5a","5b4856edfaf7e504859cd56c8173bb775dad30c07980a4e6228ab6e7bad8fb58","dec74c571bda68a0276441bd3e0d8617b74c7ed149e9476abd97af3f537d558e","549f5885147f7c3c424b17d0b218949d90f2a45b1ec799c5341f629670e75d37","8a268ba0014e1b70e0fe57a677ae6edca2f41ada1779ce0f1954ffcc81fa7dc2"],"circle":21,"circle_phase":"FINAL","composition":{"by":"kernel","fallen_answer_ids":["@3b76fd65fa1500f8","@4ba7ea0ea1a9f1b0","@c1708805b937256d","@352306c2958bb4fd","@7a74b7ed727b88eb","@3bd1ac258682306f","@daa5c03af4d4b97c","@ce1a2b688339183a"],"mode":"incremental_repair","retained_answer_ids":["@549f5885147f7c3c","@8a268ba0014e1b70"],"source_done":"@c0690a6e9a346dd1"},"delivery_audit":{"had_refusals":false,"partial_declared":false,"repair_count":0,"retained_rows":2},"done":"92950f9388d95349d9d91d7a60b6e5b8742a57c625894827ad208d4519dc8e3d","kind":"SUMMARIZE","link_task":null,"outcome":"answered","question_set_revision":"0502c9aea43e1ce04869d20bb1cd0c78050175800b1315cbc452ab3a7a0fce2e","rq_id":"q1","sync_step":43,"task_id":"TS1-eaaabef009825893"},"from":0,"key":"task:rq:q1","to":0},"kind":"batch","operations":[]},"engine_root":"cb1a471c06bac5e6b7c9fc5c81fe2bd9c385bead6921b07b78fb66106d7c178c","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"accepted_operations":0,"checkpointed":true,"error":null,"failed_index":null,"results":[]}},"request_hash":"5bb772e8db5c1dba43052807eee01b8a6dbcb664b1bdad6828830c81af18a780","submission_id":"TS1-eaaabef009825893#done2"},"hash":"9b380c72c74f6bdcbfd40aa584e3ccb27291813584cefb96c98f13c2ef9c4cd2","header":{"body_hash":"308b00eb08f219ff2679e1a0dd2010753f9f537ee05116258d560330fb26dda8","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"bbdaa08ca1fe4cfa998f7ee38fc2e82084fa77b8c7cc1704e91d8d70d63a9559","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":452,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"a17e66b40480698c39d89c0e23743824b764d62c2c82f3c166cc2160900d8e63","command":{"kind":"seal","seal":{"audit_root":"0df4bfff971332298427c7ad34b7e274ce8a06f2eab2cae56e910684d07d7310","engine_root":"cb1a471c06bac5e6b7c9fc5c81fe2bd9c385bead6921b07b78fb66106d7c178c","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"7f7df4a9af4ada4907f0c4f8b454e92f9eb9774591dfc1921df9e8e9d4310bf7","log_size":453,"projections":{"dependencies":"c21a4d4f66f52f5f89462f5b26447e0a069d7b5d5abe0c619d22a468e9141ad6","status":"39e3747f6fc4dfc0402dfe1851a4eb28c37579edf2696ee5be04327c16c721b8"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"9b380c72c74f6bdcbfd40aa584e3ccb27291813584cefb96c98f13c2ef9c4cd2"}},"engine_root":"cb1a471c06bac5e6b7c9fc5c81fe2bd9c385bead6921b07b78fb66106d7c178c","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"seal":{"audit_root":"0df4bfff971332298427c7ad34b7e274ce8a06f2eab2cae56e910684d07d7310","engine_root":"cb1a471c06bac5e6b7c9fc5c81fe2bd9c385bead6921b07b78fb66106d7c178c","format":"r2r-seal/2","log_root":"7f7df4a9af4ada4907f0c4f8b454e92f9eb9774591dfc1921df9e8e9d4310bf7","log_size":453,"projections":{"dependencies":"c21a4d4f66f52f5f89462f5b26447e0a069d7b5d5abe0c619d22a468e9141ad6","status":"39e3747f6fc4dfc0402dfe1851a4eb28c37579edf2696ee5be04327c16c721b8"},"run_id":"sanecite-case-20261119-152213","wal_head":"9b380c72c74f6bdcbfd40aa584e3ccb27291813584cefb96c98f13c2ef9c4cd2"},"seal_hash":"26bd82b0de4185fc8a09be35c00f8e73070e56651a2ae0d6de3a7bbbbc6a4767"}},"request_hash":"1ca76afbe7bf4cd758747389f25f4a34c367302df2cf58794391008abc06609b","submission_id":"seal-453"},"hash":"bd3e1bf6b3d87b83aa80177f49b3b0d5f28260df1eccdebe1c94746f6cc23e65","header":{"body_hash":"bc0712fa5961af513f70138955d9bdb6dc6dbdc48bc8ef88d22384fb451c058d","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"9b380c72c74f6bdcbfd40aa584e3ccb27291813584cefb96c98f13c2ef9c4cd2","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":453,"wal_op":"audit"}}
{"body":{"actor":"kernel","audit_root":"effb78db7be5756db08c76e842d6121b25192aa90f9e709f55143168962d7d03","command":{"kind":"close"},"engine_root":"cb1a471c06bac5e6b7c9fc5c81fe2bd9c385bead6921b07b78fb66106d7c178c","outcome":{"kind":"value","result":{"closed":true}},"request_hash":"5b3f18bfb34c5e0628f246efd8916435ea792dbed417d444c0546f62cf0d4e88","submission_id":"audit-close"},"hash":"fa559049f5849795de84abda8e3f6ea77a6ac7cf52c0439feae7abc1778ff12f","header":{"body_hash":"50854d9180f91ef20d61cc7336e078a8605a8659970007cefa93f53ee4e44898","format":"sbgk-session-log/3","previous":"bd3e1bf6b3d87b83aa80177f49b3b0d5f28260df1eccdebe1c94746f6cc23e65","records_root":"fe7c90ca2214e168f5ffe6cccb15729c3b8a03c403e48c406441cd589fdd8c41","seq":454,"wal_op":"audit"}}
